Manipur is Burning! Will AFSPA Save the State? Explained by Dr. Sidharth Arora | UPSC

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 21 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 55

  • @upscunstoppables
    @upscunstoppables  2 дня назад

    🚨 Unacademy Civil Services Championship Scholarship Test 🚨 👉 Register Now: unacademy.onelink.me/nWi1/j7qstrb5
    Ready to achieve your UPSC dream? 🌟 Take the Scholarship Test and win exciting rewards, scholarships, and more! 🏆
    Test Date & Time: 24th November, 11AM & 5PM.

    • @RinkuDubey-k4l
      @RinkuDubey-k4l День назад

      What’s the issue with unacademy app on ios or chrome in ios, sir.?I registered for upsc 2025 course but not able to watch any of your video. Contacted your help desk team, they are not supportive either, just help us till registration then minimal help not possible. I am a working person, time is already very less for me, and it’s really frustrating. Please help in this regard.

  • @gipsonluwang
    @gipsonluwang 2 дня назад +13

    AFSPA was already in Manipur for the last many decades including Imphal valley except some constituency. Just by including 6 police station won't solve the crisis. Jiribam district where recent killing happens is also under AFSPA.Does it work? It's the poverty of imagination of the Babu sitting in Delhi thinking that imposing AFSPA will solve the problem.

  • @Bharat-uz7qh
    @Bharat-uz7qh 2 дня назад +2

    It's amazing and outstanding session thank you very much Guru ji Jai hind sir 🇮🇳🙏🙏💚❤

  • @kavithavenkat3814
    @kavithavenkat3814 День назад +2

    God of polity Charan sparsh pranaam gurudeveji 🙏🙏❤️❤️🌹🌹❤️❤️

  • @Mohd.Shoil.
    @Mohd.Shoil. День назад +3

    FAVOUR :-
    *Maintain law and order
    *Internal security maintain
    *Legal protection of armed forces
    *Power-> maral / fear
    *Security challenges maintain
    AGAINST:-
    *Violation of state authority
    *Excessive power
    *Vioilation of human rights
    *No immunity-->HR
    *No accountability

  • @rakeshsinghrajput1015
    @rakeshsinghrajput1015 День назад +1

    Thanku so much sir 😊❤

  • @SimlaKar-qr2rs
    @SimlaKar-qr2rs 2 дня назад +2

    GREAT session sir

  • @naojoy4192
    @naojoy4192 День назад +2

    Great explanation 👍
    But the case in Manipur is slightly different. AFSPA is already there except 19 police stations and no positive actions has been seen so far. So, I don't think imposing AFSPA will do anything better.

  • @raksofficialmomin5429
    @raksofficialmomin5429 2 часа назад +3

    afspa will create more problems

  • @VISHALKUMAR-nd7wm
    @VISHALKUMAR-nd7wm 2 дня назад +2

    Hope so sir, because Manipur issue is continuously worse, maybe AFSPA can help to peace.

  • @vatsaljaiswal521
    @vatsaljaiswal521 2 дня назад +1

    Thank you sir for your outstanding sessions ......

  • @riteshgupta3323
    @riteshgupta3323 День назад +2

    Yes AFSPA will Definitely help in Controlling this Internal Disturbance in Manipur as some Disturbing elements are trying to disrupts the Peace and breaking down the constitutional machinery which in terms may cause terror among the Civilians and If AFSPA will not be imposed on that Area which will result in loss of Control and may find it very difficult to maintain the previous peaceful condition.

  • @nidhirani1234
    @nidhirani1234 2 дня назад +1

    yes sir it is necessary for enforcing AFSPA in manipur because situation is getting worse day by day

  • @vatsaljaiswal521
    @vatsaljaiswal521 2 дня назад +2

    yes Sir it is a need of an hour sometimes harsh step should be made to protect our nation's integrity and unity . "nothing beyond a nation "

    • @jeeselee
      @jeeselee 14 часов назад

      Why not control the Kuki immigrants? Why is India allowing a free hand to foreign militants a free hand in AFSPA imposed areas for the last 1 & half years? Why SOO with Myanmar militants?

  • @rajputharshdevsing3278
    @rajputharshdevsing3278 День назад +1

    AFSPA should be imposed in Manipur because the situation has not improved since last year and is becoming more tense daily. Thus, to control the conflicts and stop external factors from spraying oil into the fire, the imposition of AFSPA is necessary, according to my knowledge.

  • @DharmendraKumar-wp1be
    @DharmendraKumar-wp1be День назад +1

    Yes sir ❤ in my opinion AFSPA should be in manipur.

    • @jeeselee
      @jeeselee 14 часов назад

      Yes AFSPA should be imposed in the North East & not in Naxal affected area because NE people are not Aryans.

    • @chaiwala6458
      @chaiwala6458 3 часа назад

      @@jeeselee you are racist person and I think you hate North East Indian people because of their looks and lifestyles.

  • @ankurbarman6522
    @ankurbarman6522 15 часов назад +1

    Yess...it would definitely help to bring back law and order but with certain precautions...it must be align with the civilian population, where transparency, accountability and cooperation must be kept at the top priority . Thank you

  • @bishorjitnongthombam2655
    @bishorjitnongthombam2655 День назад +3

    AFSPA as it may sound good as it is explained, doesn't necessarily be the same in the ground field. It has been implemented in several parts except for some places.
    The need of the hour is to make sure H'ble PM Modi jee to break his SILENCE and pay a visit to Manipur like he would have visited during the election to collect votes. Isn't it a wonderful situation for a Leader to not visit the place which has been burning for the past 18+ months.

  • @moniabhijit
    @moniabhijit 2 дня назад +2

    AFSPA is essential for sach type of disturbed area.
    But there needs some transparency till a certain limit where there is no compromisation on internal security, sovereignty and the moral of the security forces.

  • @siddhantsharma1059
    @siddhantsharma1059 День назад +1

    Great explanation.

  • @akashshivhare8499
    @akashshivhare8499 День назад +1

    हाँ बिलकुल मदद करेगा लेकिन पुरे मणिपुर मे न लगाकर कुछ ऐसे क्षेत्र जहाँ विवाद ज्यादा है और यह तात्कालिक समाधान है साथ ही एक राजनितिक दृढ़ता दिखाने की जरुरत हैं..

  • @kt-pc6hj
    @kt-pc6hj 15 часов назад +1

    AFSPA is not the solution. It was already imposed in CHURACHANDPUR n MOREH yet ethnic violence broke out and led to mass displacement of people. The violence still continues due to politicisation of the conflict.

  • @YajpalRawat
    @YajpalRawat 2 дня назад +1

    Yes it will enforce in manipur as we can see the situation is out of control know for which afspa is only solution

  • @unbeatable421
    @unbeatable421 2 дня назад +2

    Flame 🔥🔥

  • @DonneO24
    @DonneO24 14 часов назад +1

    churchandpur and moreh are under afspa where violence got maximum and could not help a bit how will it make any difference now

  • @kamlaurikhinbam4804
    @kamlaurikhinbam4804 4 часа назад

    Sir there is AFSPA in hill district but the forces can't even arrest a single illegal kuki militants who fire from hill, security person help them.

  • @j.r.b9362
    @j.r.b9362 День назад +1

    Yes

  • @mayanklucknow
    @mayanklucknow 2 дня назад +3

    Art 356=MANIPUR

  • @MangboiHaokip-m1w
    @MangboiHaokip-m1w 13 часов назад

    Only Separate Administration will save Manipura

  • @nkNong
    @nkNong День назад

    What makes PM or Home minister unable to go and visit MANIPUR????

  • @shaikhgunjan6952
    @shaikhgunjan6952 54 минуты назад

    1.5 years se jaal raha ab yaad aya government ko, hilarious 😂 . Human life is nothing infront of politics, money and power.

  • @sagarbarik6966
    @sagarbarik6966 День назад

    Sir please continue polity class series

  • @cck_123.
    @cck_123. 4 часа назад

    Nagaland is rule by AFSPA, not by Democratic form of Government.. no one came to help the Naga struggle for self government /sovereignty.

  • @230amankumarmanjhi5
    @230amankumarmanjhi5 2 дня назад

    yes

  • @actually4660
    @actually4660 3 часа назад

    Jo log Apspa ko support karte hain unke gharo me apspa lagado. Easy to comment on something Far away as a bystander.

  • @nehakumari4422
    @nehakumari4422 2 дня назад

    Sir please again star episode of laxmikant

  • @Rah_vii
    @Rah_vii День назад +1

    Yes sir as it is the need of the hour to enforce AFSPA and I think, by keeping the possible transparency and accountability in this process will help to avoid the controversies regarding AFSPA.
    Thank you for the great explanation
    Jai Hind Sir 🇮🇳

    • @meireek9937
      @meireek9937 Час назад

      Tumharr maa baap par bhi AFSPA lagana chaiye. Agar tum ishke khilaf woh then why such treatment against northeast indian they are not your family.

  • @shaikhgunjan6952
    @shaikhgunjan6952 41 минуту назад

    Humlog Santi se ek sath kyun nahin reh sakte. Mere hisabse koi insaan marna nahin chahta apne family ko Akeley chodke. This is human tendency , kya ye top leadership ka plan hay both government and terrorists leader main.

  • @rishuthakur7047
    @rishuthakur7047 2 дня назад +6

    Kbi apne baap modi se question push liye kro

    • @shahildas1956
      @shahildas1956 2 дня назад

      behave yourself buddy is that the way of talking to your teachers ?

    • @Shuभm
      @Shuभm 2 дня назад

      Aapke baap Modi ne hi ye decision diya hai..

    • @vatsaljaiswal521
      @vatsaljaiswal521 2 дня назад +1

      behave bro only fool talk like this .........

    • @georgiameloni0123
      @georgiameloni0123 2 дня назад

      Kyu Ravish hai tumhara real mentor ya Dhruv Rathee hai.....
      Ya dono ne tumko pagal kar diya extremists psycho jihadi ideology wala

    • @georgiameloni0123
      @georgiameloni0123 2 дня назад

      Kyu Ravish hai tumhara real mentor ya Dhruv Rathee hai.....
      Ya dono ne tumko pagal kar diya extremists psycho jihadi ideology wala

  • @nandusharma9837
    @nandusharma9837 9 часов назад +1

    Afspa se itna pyari hai lagao na aap ke state yahan roj Hindu muslim ka dangai hota hai

  • @Shadid-k8m
    @Shadid-k8m День назад

    Khudke desh mein 2 sal se yudh ho raha hain aur aiye bare Chittagong ko todne😂...stand with christians🤟

  • @kalyanchatnalli6332
    @kalyanchatnalli6332 7 часов назад

    yes