This us such a wonderful song frim their SPIRITS HAVING FLOWN album, and I don't know why some people don't like it. Whenever I play and hear "Until" once, I've gotta listen to it at LEAST five or ten more times at the same time in a row !!! I always put my player on repeat1 ... and just let it loop over and over !!! I LOVE this song - it's so "dreamy" to me. Wish there was an actual video of them singing it, live. Does anyone know of one out there ? Love these guys bunches !!! BEE GEES AND ANDY FOREVER !!! ❣️❤️❣️
Thank you Chad, loved your reaction. This song makes me feel as if I’m floating in a cloud of love and emotions, but it’s definitely way too short. When I listen to it I have to hear it at least a half dozen times. Barry’s voice is so full of emotion, it touches the soul. ❤❤❤
Hi Chad! So nice to spend some time with you on a Sunday morning.😊🌞 Barry is "the man". Never was or ever will be anyone like him. His incredible voice in this song is so hauntingly beautiful. When he hits that last note I get chills. He never ceases to amaze me. So MANY DIFFERENT songs in the Brothers Gibb catalog. Just remarkable. Thanks Chad for your wonderful reaction to this "Barry gem". Til next time take care my friend.♥️
Beautiful, sensitive and sad song! I'm glad to see this reaction, which I've been waiting for since January 2022, when I proposed it to you! Thanks Chad!
Is there anything Barry Gibb can’t do? That last note was something out of this world. It’s easy to see why they were so frustrated to be pigeon holed as a “disco group.” They have touched so many different genres through the years from pop, to country, to ballads, dance and more. I’m in my late 50s and am just in the last year understanding the depth of their talents. Thank you for this react and “Jivetalkin’” RUclips channel.
I imagine Barry Gibb singing this song in the dark studio. Listen to the lyrics. “ we held our love… Until “. Until what is the question? And that is left to the imagination of the listener.
Olá Chad! Eu não encontrei a música "Lost in Your Love" na sua playlist dos Bee Gees, gostaria de vê-lo reagindo a ela. Eu também gostaria muito de vê-lo reagindo ao Andy Gibb cantando "Love só Right", é incrível! Amei essa música na voz do Barry, eu não conhecia. Maravilhoso!
Never heard this song before and I think I had the same facial expression like you at the end! Seems Barry could have sung opera with education and training!😆
Someone once asked Robin if he wanted operatic training and apparently he replied that it would take away the part of his voice that was him. And once in an interview when asked about not reading music I think it was Mo who said if they did the knowledge and rules would have limited their spontinaety.
@@HeatherMyfanwyTylerGreey Hm, Freddy Mercury had operatic training, but his voice was always the same. Opera singers clearly don't sound like pop singers. They use their voices differently, setting up the "mechanism" to sound authentic for the type of music they sing. The question is: can the same singer sing both opera and pop? The answer is yes - if you know how!
I love this song. Barry's fervent, impassioned delivery is perfect. I always found it sad. The lyrics don't reflect that as much as the effect of the emotional vocal. Because it is the last track on the album, and because it has this somber intensity, I related it to saying goodbye. It still triggers me, that the magnificent music on "Spirits" is coming to an end.
"to whom it may concern" has another songs that You have not listen... "Sea of smiling faces", "when do I " and another where MAURICE is the vocal lead... Thanks Chad, for your dedication!!❤❤ "Give the Best" is another songs of the film "MELODY"... WITH LOVE FROM ARGENTINA ... WATCH THIS FILM PLEASE, "MELODY "..... 😘😘😘😘❤️❤️❤️❤️
There were a lot of sad breakup, lonely songs at the end of the 70’s and early 80’s when Robin’s first marriage was breaking up. To quote Bernie Taupin (through Elton John) ‘sad songs say so much’.
If I heard rightly though there were two vibrato to the falsetto at the end. One shadowed the other. Barry's wide and slower one and Robin's faster shorter one, or maybe I was hearing things?
I've never been a fan of this song so I've only heard it a few times before. I mean, I like it a little bit more than I used to now that I just heard it again because I just realized how beautiful Barry's voice is in it, but I still think the song, otherwise, sounds really weird. That's so awesome that you, now, have this album on vinyl!😍 I'd love to have it on vinyl!
I think you mean it sounds different - not weird. It's a different sound bcuz it doesn't have all the usual instruments in it - just a synthesizer keyboard that I can determine. It's a very soothing song to me, though - not weird. 🥰 BEE GEES FOREVER ❣️❤️❣️
This song is definitely different than others on the album. Almost new wave with the outer space music along with the unusual lyrics and rhythm. Not one of my favorites. Now you can say you have reacted to the whole Spirits album. :)
this is the only song in spirits album that wasnt sung in falsetto....next album (living eyes)was the opposite, all songs were sung in normal voice except the last one (soldiers)
This us such a wonderful song frim their SPIRITS HAVING FLOWN album, and I don't know why some people don't like it. Whenever I play and hear "Until" once, I've gotta listen to it at LEAST five or ten more times at the same time in a row !!! I always put my player on repeat1 ... and just let it loop over and over !!! I LOVE this song - it's so "dreamy" to me. Wish there was an actual video of them singing it, live. Does anyone know of one out there ? Love these guys bunches !!! BEE GEES AND ANDY FOREVER !!! ❣️❤️❣️
Wow! Barry's voice got me! This song had a mixture of old-time spiritual and opera. Only Barry could accomplish that. Thanks, Chad!
Barry was one of a kind!❤❤❤❤❤. This was a “luv-a-bye”
Awesome! Thank you Chad!BEEGEES forever! They are the best!
Short and sweet. Go Bee Gees.
Thank you Chad, loved your reaction. This song makes me feel as if I’m floating in a cloud of love and emotions, but it’s definitely way too short. When I listen to it I have to hear it at least a half dozen times. Barry’s voice is so full of emotion, it touches the soul. ❤❤❤
Hi Chad! So nice to spend some time with you on a Sunday morning.😊🌞 Barry is "the man". Never was or ever will be anyone like him. His incredible voice in this song is so hauntingly beautiful. When he hits that last note I get chills. He never ceases to amaze me. So MANY DIFFERENT songs in the Brothers Gibb catalog. Just remarkable. Thanks Chad for your wonderful reaction to this "Barry gem". Til next time take care my friend.♥️
A beautifully crafted song with heartfelt lyrics and a uniqueness that could only have been produced by the Bee Gees. Thank you for sharing.
Beautiful, sensitive and sad song! I'm glad to see this reaction, which I've been waiting for since January 2022, when I proposed it to you! Thanks Chad!
Beautiful song. Thank you Chad and Jivetalkin RUclips channel. ❤❤❤
Is there anything Barry Gibb can’t do? That last note was something out of this world. It’s easy to see why they were so frustrated to be pigeon holed as a “disco group.” They have touched so many different genres through the years from pop, to country, to ballads, dance and more. I’m in my late 50s and am just in the last year understanding the depth of their talents. Thank you for this react and “Jivetalkin’” RUclips channel.
ROBIN TOO. AND MO
Barry is a lovely talent that I am glad we are still blessed with. Thanks Chad
Loved it ❤awesome !!!
Love Bee Gees ❤❤❤
Thanks Chad
Love that you reacted to this! I love listening to this song on vinyl!☺ Also the "jivetalkin" youtube channel is amazing!!😆
Wow! Amazing vocal ability. So much talent Mr Gibb. Thanks for putting this one up Chad, I love watching your Bee Gee Reactions.
This reminds me of the sing that Celine did way back in the 70s.... Calling.
Thank you for tis Chad, love this Song!!👌❤🎶❤. Barry's Voice is so Sanft and Beautiful!!👍💜🎶💜🌻🐝😍.! Barry Is the Man.❤ and best Bee Gees forever!!💞
Thanks for this reaction, Chad! It's a special song, took me some getting used to. But I think it's beautiful.
Barry’s voice is so versatile, it’s beautiful, thankyou Chad ❤
I feel like I've been transported to another realm.BARRY IS THE MAN❤
Whanderful Berry Gidd ❤❤❤❤
I imagine Barry Gibb singing this song in the dark studio. Listen to the lyrics. “ we held our love… Until “. Until what is the question? And that is left to the imagination of the listener.
Check out Be Who You Are, it is along the line of this one, but much longer
Charadealso very similar.
Great news! Chad has reacted to this, here's the link. Enjoy ruclips.net/video/hbyEiVy5MpA/видео.htmlsi=crvsWQAHb_82lDwW
@rebeccamcvey8600 Chad has reacted to this, here's the link. Enjoy ruclips.net/video/BirCk0qNh5I/видео.htmlsi=XlUoxSRhBRXdp2Cr
That haunting wailing on the second part I had played as my mother’s coffin was lowered.
Really beautiful Chad, thanks for sharing ❤
Olá Chad! Eu não encontrei a música "Lost in Your Love" na sua playlist dos Bee Gees, gostaria de vê-lo reagindo a ela. Eu também gostaria muito de vê-lo reagindo ao Andy Gibb cantando "Love só Right", é incrível! Amei essa música na voz do Barry, eu não conhecia. Maravilhoso!
Never heard this song before and I think I had the same facial expression like you at the end! Seems Barry could have sung opera with education and training!😆
Someone once asked Robin if he wanted operatic training and apparently he replied that it would take away the part of his voice that was him. And once in an interview when asked about not reading music I think it was Mo who said if they did the knowledge and rules would have limited their spontinaety.
@@HeatherMyfanwyTylerGreey Hm, Freddy Mercury had operatic training, but his voice was always the same. Opera singers clearly don't sound like pop singers. They use their voices differently, setting up the "mechanism" to sound authentic for the type of music they sing. The question is: can the same singer sing both opera and pop? The answer is yes - if you know how!
Amazing ❤❤❤
love this song
I love this song. Barry's fervent, impassioned delivery is perfect. I always found it sad. The lyrics don't reflect that as much as the effect of the emotional vocal. Because it is the last track on the album, and because it has this somber intensity, I related it to saying goodbye. It still triggers me, that the magnificent music on "Spirits" is coming to an end.
"to whom it may concern" has another songs that You have not listen... "Sea of smiling faces", "when do I " and another where MAURICE is the vocal lead... Thanks Chad, for your dedication!!❤❤ "Give the Best" is another songs of the film "MELODY"... WITH LOVE FROM ARGENTINA ... WATCH THIS FILM PLEASE, "MELODY "..... 😘😘😘😘❤️❤️❤️❤️
Along the lines of Be Who You Are
There were a lot of sad breakup, lonely songs at the end of the 70’s and early 80’s when Robin’s first marriage was breaking up. To quote Bernie Taupin (through Elton John) ‘sad songs say so much’.
If I heard rightly though there were two vibrato to the falsetto at the end. One shadowed the other. Barry's wide and slower one and Robin's faster shorter one, or maybe I was hearing things?
Bee Gees mode experimental
Well, they can't all be favorites. :)
I've never been a fan of this song so I've only heard it a few times before. I mean, I like it a little bit more than I used to now that I just heard it again because I just realized how beautiful Barry's voice is in it, but I still think the song, otherwise, sounds really weird. That's so awesome that you, now, have this album on vinyl!😍 I'd love to have it on vinyl!
I think you mean it sounds different - not weird. It's a different sound bcuz it doesn't have all the usual instruments in it - just a synthesizer keyboard that I can determine. It's a very soothing song to me, though - not weird. 🥰 BEE GEES FOREVER ❣️❤️❣️
Questa canzone è spettacolare non è per tutti bisogna conoscere veramente la musica.
This is along the same lines as Be Who You Are, Barry likes to go into the classical genre.
This song is definitely different than others on the album. Almost new wave with the outer space music along with the unusual lyrics and rhythm. Not one of my favorites. Now you can say you have reacted to the whole Spirits album. :)
I think I just heard the only song from The Bee Gees that I will never listen to again! I love The Bee Gees but don’t care for this song.
this is the only song in spirits album that wasnt sung in falsetto....next album (living eyes)was the opposite, all songs were sung in normal voice except the last one (soldiers)
the end was in falsetto, and that last note...wow
I never thought I would hear a Bee Gees song that I didn't like but I was wrong. Barry's voice as usual is beautiful but the song just wasn't.
This would even sound better without the music, IMO. 🥰🥰
Not my favorite song. I guess you can't like them all
🇮🇱🤛🤛👊
Why use words to the song over the wrong video? A lip reader cannot enjoy it!