Maybe not the most realistic battle scenes but I think it conveys the desperate fighting during the Battle of Stalingrad. I cant imagine the sacrifice on both sides for this piece of real estate. Glad I wasn't a Russian or German born day around 1921-1922. I WOULD have never made it !
The Poles could not understand how Moscow drove them out and made Poland a province.The French-could not understand how Moscow drove them away and made a bistro in Paris. The Germans could not understand how they were driven out of Moscow, and in Berlin-a Red Flag. Americans can't understand how Moscow got out of poverty and became strong again. Could it be God's fault?OR ARE THE RUSSIANS WORTHY?
@@erikdekter2384 You're probably more informed. I was born in the USSR, and now I live in Russia, but you probably know better. And what does THAT have to do with it? After all, we are talking about the Film and the Truth of that War
@@жекащаз I've been to Russia many times so i know something:). About the film though. I don't deny the fact that Russians won the war all i'm saying is that Germans usually are portrayed as brainless and cowardly idiots while Russian soldiers winning literally every battle.
@@erikdekter2384 You were, and I live. You judge the War by the Film, and I fought. NOT in that war. But I know what Death really smells like. And I think, Eric, that you are fluent in writing and speaking Russian.Let me guess - are you from Ukraine?
By the time the snow was this deep in Stalingrad, the Germans had not much fighting capability left. They were very low on ammunition and food, and were surrounded by a massive Russian force.
Yup, while busting through a hot spot I myself usually keep my chamber empty for safety reasons, just so when the shit hits the fan I gotta hunker down and load my k98.
Против Германии Дания продержалась 6 часов, Люксембург 1 день, Голландия 5 дней, Югославия 11 дней, Бельгия 18 дней, Греция 24 дня, Польша 27 дней, Франция 1 месяц и 12 дней, Дом Павлова стоял 58 дней.
И защищало этот дом всего-то 32 бойца. Были среди этих героев узбек, калмык, таджик и еврей. Остальные бойцы - славяне. А Павлов был родом с Новгородчины.
@@Aden_III If my comment offended you then I apologize but I really don’t see how it has anything to do with race. I worked in the city of Detroit for over three years and have lived in Michigan for 20. Yes, my comment plays on a stereotype that Detroit is a rough city. Detroit has made great progress over the past years.
Yea you know i cant have a match without at least 2 teamkills in every match , my expectation is blow enemy but my whole team always rushing without brain and most of them are killed by my grenade ,but it seems normal day for red ORCHESTRA 2 player
The film is weak. My grandfather, sergeant of the Red Army, Asofiev Alexander Vasilievich, a participant in the Battle of Stalingrad, said: "The Germans were good warriors, but still we beat them." When he spoke of war, he always cried.
@@hellome4219 no, I'm Russian, I know that. I know that regular army was scattered and that a few years before Stalin canceled training programs for Partisans because he thought that war wouldn't be in our territory. But our people were brave enough to stay and fight, to die, to kill. I just tried to explain that they are just recruits.
Btw, where are the German LMGs? You know, the German tactic was based on firepower and the LGMs were the staple of the German tactics. The Germans should have the PPSH here too, as the Germans used many Russian weapons such as the PPSH. I don't know why the Germans only got kar98 rifles here, and every Soviet got the PPSH. It's the same as "Why every Soviet got a grenade, and Germans only a few." Each German rifleman got 2 grenades. In each German straight line-up there were two people with the MP40, one LMG squad with 3-4 people and five people with kar98 rifles. Each shooter got 2 grenades, NCOs got 6 magazines in the MP40, which gives him firepower for his units, LGM got one magazine for 50 rounds, but also got one or two people carrying ammunition, usually several magazines with 50 rounds but also boxes with 300 rounds. It's probably Stalingrad and i know the Germans were very poorly equipped, but they used a lot of captured weapons left from their commanders, so I have no idea where the amount of MP40 or PPSH in the hands of the Germans is. You can also talk a lot about the tactics, because the Germans crawl hardly and attack, as I said, without any fire protection. The Germans don't use grenades, only once, twice and that's it. Most of them are killed by the Soviets holding the PPSH, who had, by the way, two rounds, because for each PPSH there were two individual rounds, due to the poor quality of production of these weapons. The magazines only entered the weapon for which they were produced, so I do not know how much these Soviets could fire. They could reload the magazines but those jammed and broke easily, and I think these are assault troops (maybe) and they've been using these weapons for a while.
Danke PanzerWaffel, perfekt....you've right about germans organisations, in some movies they don't adapt reality of the ground battle, the SVT russian automatic rifle was also very appreciaited by germans.......Gott mit Uns Kamerade ; )
I personally think that Model 1897 Winchester ("Trench gun") have bigger power in rounds but you have only few in tube. But for close-quarter fight i would prefer some kind of shotgun. But that's just my opinion.
As here, many videos show some Germans using captured Soviet submachine guns and some Soviets using captured German submachine guns. Both the PPSH-41 and the MP-38/40 were excellent weapons. The German MP-44/Sturmgeweher 44 might well be preferable to both. (Although the Winchester 1897 is another excellent weapon, for home defense I prefer a Remington 870 with an extended tube, cross-loaded with slugs and #4 buckshot.)
@@kritischertrinker9971 das mag sein aber diese Berichte werden von den Historikern nicht beachtet und werden so in ihrer Aufarbeitung nicht berücksichtigt. Deshalb wird diese Epoche nicht Objektiv bewertet, weil man nicht alle Faktoren ahndet..
*Yeah,that was a maskcoat.Germans didnt have it.They even didnt have winter shoes and winter clothes.That is strange,but fact.Maybe cause they were using heroin and pervitin*
@@hellome4219 The Germans did have winter clothes... just not enough of them for the entire army. And Mr. Shephard is correct that the sniper's camouflage smock is _way_ too pristine white and clean for someone who has been crawling through an urban battlefield. They don't exactly scrub those city streets every day, and definitely not whilst a major battle is going on.
Its funny to see how people call it bad direction. You are free to watch RAMBO.. and no bullet will touch the american.. now thats direction and so absolutely realistic enactment.. mesmerizing, award winning.. I love it.
Nobody didn't attack this shitty house. Stalingrad was captured, the German offensive has stopped because they reached their goal, defense positions on the Volga for Heeresgruppe B.
As vital as it was for Western Europe, D-Day was a side show compared to the losses on the Eastern Front. After Stalingrad it was a long walk home for the Wehrmact
It's not just failure of the war but it's clear that no one can not fulfilled his dream because human know every thing but not know which day is a last day for his own and his family.
@@МудрыйЛис-е8с Почему до середины 1942 года? Союзники высадились в Нормандии летом 1944, а полностью территория Франции не в январе ли 1945 была очищена.
@@васях-ъ1о у нацистов людские ресурсы были меньше, чем у союзников - США, Великобритании и СССР. Иначе бы был ты абажуром, или баварское пил - в зависимости от нюансов.
The vicious, primordial, and savage violence, combined with conditions and numbers make it almost impossible to comprehend. But happen it did, and worse...
The Wehrmacht may not have lost the war in Stalingrad, but they lost their morale. Any soldier who returned never wished to go back... any solder who stayed, never returned.
Such great memories. It was 17 years ago that kids like me was already at the frontline fighting and charging alongside Sgt Moody and Captain Foley for the US side. The era of early pc gaming and playstation 2.
The soldier's life is shot both for winners and loosers. This lesson should be learned from that war. Unfortunately not all modern Russians understand that.
That was a fun bit of fiction. It looked like a similar number of German and Russian soldiers fighting, which would have been a crushing defeat for the Reds, seven days a week. But I did enjoy seeing all the gear. Could the Germans with the MP38/40s extend their stocks in the next production, please?
What's fiction? The Germans lost more men attacking Pavlovs House more than they did attacking France. Pavlovs House was defended by 25 soldiers and 10 civilians. Even the Germans admit these numbers. The Russians took heavy casualties in the beginning of Stalingrad but it's not like they were idiots who didn't know how to fight, especially when the Siberians came.
Buenas tardes muchachos !!!!! Primera vez qe veo este video y me dejó impresionado ¿ Es un film ruso ?? Es serie o alguna película ? Espero sus respuestas, muchas gracias.
There's quite a lot differences between the public narrative about Pavlov's house, and the truth about it. It was manned by lot more soldiers, they are never been cut from supplies, they even have in the house a room for rest with SF literature and board games, the house was not in the much battle intense part of the city, Pavlov didn't capture the house, he came later, the House hold out a lot more than it is commonly known, she's abandoned and wehrmacht captured it in January.
Вместо того, чтобы ругатся подумайте ....Сколько жизней молодых извели в самом цвете! Сколько уничтоженно труда человеческого. Пол страны стерли в пепел! Что потом горем и тем же самым в Германию вернулось.....От такая примерно диспозиция.
*Those who doubt the casualties,remember,that in assault on Koenigsberg in 1945 died 42000 of wermacht soldiers and only 3600 of soviet soldiers.That is a historical fact.*
Dude. Come on! The great majority of that 42,000 were POWs that were out of ammo, had not eaten for two weeks, and surrounded by about 200,000 soviets. Get real and stop lying before your nose starts growing. I mean, damnit.
There are three films mixed. "The Battle for Stalingrad" and "Enemy at the gate" (the same events). But I also recommend you to watch "The Battle for Sevastopol"
Удивляет внешний вид бойцов. Все чистенькие,гладко выбритые,на форме ни пятна, ни рванины...прямо как с ателье.. И не скажешь что на фронте,где не то что- бы помыться, зад подтереть нечем... Наше кино,такое правдивое.
@@MichaelDelvalle-nt4gp Indeed, there is a good chance it might have, since 7.62x25mm is a very hot-loaded round with excellent penetration even when fired from pistol-length barrels. Coming from a submachine gun-length barrel, it likely would have gone straight through that skinny German (the Germans were a bit low on food by the winter of 1942) and still had enough energy to likely wound or kill the Russian under him.
You should learn Russian language. The whole world will be using it soon. We are eager to establish new empire and new order. Commies are coming ... face it
Consider german infantry doctrine is based on universal machine gun such as mg-34, seeing a bunch of german soldiers assaulting a position without mg covering fire is just wrong.
It's clear that the very limited budget of this film went mostly to special effects and not hiring decent actors. The funny thing is that the Russian film crew could have probably saved _a lot_ of money and got some local veterans to fill most of the roles--at least they'd know how to move and handle their weapons in a somewhat convincing manner as opposed to looking like rank amateurs. I bet that quite a few of those vets would probably volunteer for that role--it gives them something to do, and who wouldn't want to have their name in the credits of a patriotic feature film?
@Harrison: were you saying it should be "berlingrad" instead of "stalingrad? very innovative, but unfortunately, in history, your mirage of "berlingrad" were disappeared in less than 20-day.
@@brexitmeansbrexit4129 actually the germans were a very skilled and highly trained army, they showed discipline at the front. The grand were led greatly, experienced commanders, and overall better field weapons. Russians however were mostly untrained men, most of their uniforms in the summer were peasant clothing, most of the time they were poorly led, they had good field weapons but they were unreliable, exception to the beautiful mosin rifle, Russians won stalingrad because they had the entire Russian backing them up, militias and partisians had their side, it was their turf, losing any big Russian city would break morale, Russians hated Germans, they had the US backing them up, and they outnumbered the Germans and had supplies for winter...
It is not. It were the Germans who were attacking pavlov house. And it were the germans, who lacked automatic weapons, and were armed mostly with carbines
twombonu Are you upset that he is correct it is nothing more than propaganda? It seems so! The Russian soldiers were truly untrained and not good in the case of combat they gave farmers a gun if he was lucky and pointed him at an MG and expected him to win!
That is pretty funny that is all you can come up with how many more petty insults do you have for me since in all reality Germans should have won that fight if not for this being propaganda?
That's so exaggerated it's not even funny. The conscripts were the least trained but they still were. The russians had divisions of fully trained units as well. The germans were trained better on average yes and had better equipment but it clearly wasn't enough.
''fight to control one house''
Yep, sounds like another day with the siblings.
😂😂😂
Wait until you're married fella
LOL
Maybe not the most realistic battle scenes but I think it conveys the desperate fighting during the Battle of Stalingrad. I cant imagine the sacrifice on both sides for this piece of real estate. Glad I wasn't a Russian or German born day around 1921-1922. I WOULD have never made it !
Это не кусок недвижимости это наш город и наша родина,недвижимость у вас так и нелезтм кнам
@@literatyra- complain russian kid
Despite what leaders may say, no glory in fighting in wars and battles.
Me neither can't run 🙄💙🏴💙🏴
@@Pau_Pau9there is glory in dying for your country
After watching Russian WW2 movies, I can't figure out how the Germans didn't lose in first week of the war.
The Poles could not understand how Moscow drove them out and made Poland a province.The French-could not understand how Moscow drove them away and made a bistro in Paris. The Germans could not understand how they were driven out of Moscow, and in Berlin-a Red Flag. Americans can't understand how Moscow got out of poverty and became strong again. Could it be God's fault?OR ARE THE RUSSIANS WORTHY?
@@жекащаз Only Putin and his gang are rich. Russians still are living in poverty.
@@erikdekter2384
You're probably more informed. I was born in the USSR, and now I live in Russia, but you probably know better. And what does THAT have to do with it? After all, we are talking about the Film and the Truth of that War
@@жекащаз I've been to Russia many times so i know something:).
About the film though. I don't deny the fact that Russians won the war all i'm saying is that Germans usually are portrayed as brainless and cowardly idiots while Russian soldiers winning literally every battle.
@@erikdekter2384
You were, and I live. You judge the War by the Film, and I fought. NOT in that war. But I know what Death really smells like.
And I think, Eric, that you are fluent in writing and speaking Russian.Let me guess - are you from Ukraine?
By the time the snow was this deep in Stalingrad, the Germans had not much fighting capability left. They were very low on ammunition and food, and were surrounded by a massive Russian force.
По сути лагерь вооруженных военнопленных.
Вопрос в другом, зачем немцы туда пришли ? Их никто не звал. Силы немецкой армии не такие уж и маленькие были.
A..
Yup, while busting through a hot spot I myself usually keep my chamber empty for safety reasons, just so when the shit hits the fan I gotta hunker down and load my k98.
haha
Yep
Против Германии Дания продержалась 6 часов, Люксембург 1 день, Голландия 5 дней, Югославия 11 дней, Бельгия 18 дней, Греция 24 дня, Польша 27 дней, Франция 1 месяц и 12 дней, Дом Павлова стоял 58 дней.
И защищало этот дом всего-то 32 бойца. Были среди этих героев узбек, калмык, таджик и еврей. Остальные бойцы - славяне. А Павлов был родом с Новгородчины.
от географии плыть надо...а потом все остальное.
@@alext1351 Так у Германии тоже география не ахти)))
А до Сталинграда за сколько дней дошли?
@@Марат-ь6л а почитать сложно? В июле 1942-го.
Pavlov's House....best level in COD without doubt!
L
Multiplayer was great as well
Basically Detroit
No
You’ve obviously never been to Detroit. This is Detroit on a boring Monday morning.
@@sgoconnor1 why Is it that white men think they can claim how Detroit is?
@@Aden_III If my comment offended you then I apologize but I really don’t see how it has anything to do with race. I worked in the city of Detroit for over three years and have lived in Michigan for 20. Yes, my comment plays on a stereotype that Detroit is a rough city. Detroit has made great progress over the past years.
@@sgoconnor1 You have NEVER been to Stalingrad at the height of the battle.
Expectations when you play Red Orchestra 2^
Reality *Throws grenade, bounces off the wall. *Kills whole team
Yea you know i cant have a match without at least 2 teamkills in every match , my expectation is blow enemy but my whole team always rushing without brain and most of them are killed by my grenade ,but it seems normal day for red ORCHESTRA 2 player
Looks like he’s just come out of a catalog 😂
Definitely not a neighborhood that I would walk my dog in.
The film is weak. My grandfather, sergeant of the Red Army, Asofiev Alexander Vasilievich, a participant in the Battle of Stalingrad, said: "The Germans were good warriors, but still we beat them." When he spoke of war, he always cried.
The Russians didn't beat the Germans , the winter did .
@@kengurovich4416 Yes Yes. This damn Russian winter. ) Do you think that next time, if you dress warmer, it will be different? )))
And this is why history is better than any fiction someone can make up, because history actually happened
This has the lighting quality of a low budget history channel special
I can’t stand to watch movies in which the hero does not even know how to hold or shoulder a weapon.
😎and you do?😁
@@hellome4219 Believe it or not most Americans do.
In the years of war, USSR army was just citizens with weapons. Kids, elder people, everyone who can fight.
@@daimyogames3245 How can you know that ?watched some hollywood blockbusters?😎
@@hellome4219 no, I'm Russian, I know that. I know that regular army was scattered and that a few years before Stalin canceled training programs for Partisans because he thought that war wouldn't be in our territory. But our people were brave enough to stay and fight, to die, to kill.
I just tried to explain that they are just recruits.
The Soviets learned to make good snipers after being schooled by Simo Haya in the Finnish Winter war.
Finns have always been good from a distance.....up close not so much
@@shadedbear6414 kv1-e laught in finnish
Wtf no
@@shadedbear6414 armies usually fight the way they are strong at... genius
Häyhä saatana!
Must've been a cat house to fight over it like that...
Building to building fighting so intense..most exciting and realistic war drama.... 😗
Looks like any British city the next morning after a night on the town.
Btw, where are the German LMGs? You know, the German tactic was based on firepower and the LGMs were the staple of the German tactics. The Germans should have the PPSH here too, as the Germans used many Russian weapons such as the PPSH. I don't know why the Germans only got kar98 rifles here, and every Soviet got the PPSH. It's the same as "Why every Soviet got a grenade, and Germans only a few." Each German rifleman got 2 grenades.
In each German straight line-up there were two people with the MP40, one LMG squad with 3-4 people and five people with kar98 rifles. Each shooter got 2 grenades, NCOs got 6 magazines in the MP40, which gives him firepower for his units, LGM got one magazine for 50 rounds, but also got one or two people carrying ammunition, usually several magazines with 50 rounds but also boxes with 300 rounds. It's probably Stalingrad and i know the Germans were very poorly equipped, but they used a lot of captured weapons left from their commanders, so I have no idea where the amount of MP40 or PPSH in the hands of the Germans is.
You can also talk a lot about the tactics, because the Germans crawl hardly and attack, as I said, without any fire protection. The Germans don't use grenades, only once, twice and that's it. Most of them are killed by the Soviets holding the PPSH, who had, by the way, two rounds, because for each PPSH there were two individual rounds, due to the poor quality of production of these weapons. The magazines only entered the weapon for which they were produced, so I do not know how much these Soviets could fire. They could reload the magazines but those jammed and broke easily, and I think these are assault troops (maybe) and they've been using these weapons for a while.
Danke PanzerWaffel, perfekt....you've right about germans organisations, in some movies they don't adapt reality of the ground battle, the SVT russian automatic rifle was also very appreciaited by germans.......Gott mit Uns Kamerade ; )
PPSH-41 with 71 round magazine was an excellent "house cleaner" no matter what you say.
sergeontheloose
What if it jammed
@@josephstalin7817 every weapon jams, that's why you keep it clean.
I personally think that Model 1897 Winchester ("Trench gun") have bigger power in rounds but you have only few in tube.
But for close-quarter fight i would prefer some kind of shotgun.
But that's just my opinion.
As here, many videos show some Germans using captured Soviet submachine guns and some Soviets using captured German submachine guns. Both the PPSH-41 and the MP-38/40 were excellent weapons. The German MP-44/Sturmgeweher 44 might well be preferable to both. (Although the Winchester 1897 is another excellent weapon, for home defense I prefer a Remington 870 with an extended tube, cross-loaded with slugs and #4 buckshot.)
This is battle for Pavlov house ?
Cloud Clown No, your house. (Jk)
Да.
IDK, But most likely
@bhauger1 propaganda against nazi like u))
@Free Lance Russian Shill There were many strongpoints in Stalingrad, but most people seem to only know one.
Zu viele Menschen sind auf beiden Seiten gefallen.
Lasst uns aus der Geschichte lernen.
Friede für Russland, Deutschland und der ganzen Welt.
Es gab auch Russen die auf Deutscher Seite kämpften.
@@kritischertrinker9971 das ist war.
Aber das Schicksal das ihnen dann ereilte, steht in keinen Geschichtsbuch nicht eine Silbe...
@@elwoodblues8140 Doch, in Büchern und im Internet.
@@kritischertrinker9971 das mag sein aber diese Berichte werden von den Historikern nicht beachtet und werden so in ihrer Aufarbeitung nicht berücksichtigt.
Deshalb wird diese Epoche nicht Objektiv bewertet, weil man nicht alle Faktoren ahndet..
@@elwoodblues8140 Dann sind es ganz schön bekloppte Historiker, wenn selbst ich die kenne.
Stalingrad was where WWII was won. More time spent on taking one house than was spent taking the whole of France!
Damn, that composer is the next Hans Zimmer. Almost made it to elevator music quality.
A handful of Americans from any Hollywood-movie would have smashed those Germans in two minutes
I could most defiantly enjoy this flick..the horrors of war seem easier when sittin on the couch with a samidge
Think you mean definitely
@@rrh2918 uh definitely
I love how every poorly directed Russian movie is immediately assumed to be propaganda lol
Because half of the time it is.
Only half?
Fashist
No, at all...
@@ГеоргийСветлов-ю6с communist
That snipers mum definitely uses Persil, he’s whiter than white!!
*Yeah,that was a maskcoat.Germans didnt have it.They even didnt have winter shoes and winter clothes.That is strange,but fact.Maybe cause they were using heroin and pervitin*
@@hellome4219 The Germans did have winter clothes... just not enough of them for the entire army. And Mr. Shephard is correct that the sniper's camouflage smock is _way_ too pristine white and clean for someone who has been crawling through an urban battlefield. They don't exactly scrub those city streets every day, and definitely not whilst a major battle is going on.
Its funny to see how people call it bad direction. You are free to watch RAMBO.. and no bullet will touch the american.. now thats direction and so absolutely realistic enactment.. mesmerizing, award winning.. I love it.
58 days of defense of one house, and how long did France resist?
Tobruk - 7 months
Nobody didn't attack this shitty house. Stalingrad was captured, the German offensive has stopped because they reached their goal, defense positions on the Volga for Heeresgruppe B.
@@_redprince_ 🤣🤣🤣
😂
@@АлексейВиноградов-н6ц
I was talking about the house, not the whole city.
As vital as it was for Western Europe, D-Day was a side show compared to the losses on the Eastern Front. After Stalingrad it was a long walk home for the Wehrmact
German soldiers sent to the Western front found it was a picnic compared to the Eastern front.
It's not just failure of the war but it's clear that no one can not fulfilled his dream because human know every thing but not know which day is a last day for his own and his family.
Rat cam on ,nhan dan nuoc Nga xo viet vi dai.
Дом Павлова!!! Держал оборону дольше чем вся Франция!!!
Владимир Соколов - Франция пала к ногам победителя, и отсасывала вплоть до середине 1942 года.
И на стороне нацистов воевало больше, чем против
@@МудрыйЛис-е8с Почему до середины 1942 года? Союзники высадились в Нормандии летом 1944, а полностью территория Франции не в январе ли 1945 была очищена.
@@васях-ъ1о у нацистов людские ресурсы были меньше, чем у союзников - США, Великобритании и СССР. Иначе бы был ты абажуром, или баварское пил - в зависимости от нюансов.
The vicious, primordial, and savage violence, combined with conditions and numbers make it almost impossible to comprehend. But happen it did, and worse...
If anything, this shows the futility of war.
Young men and old dying because of the stupidity of a few.
The Wehrmacht may not have lost the war in Stalingrad, but they lost their morale. Any soldier who returned never wished to go back... any solder who stayed, never returned.
Such great memories. It was 17 years ago that kids like me was already at the frontline fighting and charging alongside Sgt Moody and Captain Foley for the US side. The era of early pc gaming and playstation 2.
MARTIN! OVER HERE, GET IN THE CAR!
Still my favourite game
Early pC gaming? Bro, I played wolfenstein 3d early 90s, killing Nazis already back then ;P
That's my house every Friday night when the beer runs out and we have to decide who goes to get more....
frag explosions look pretty good
Whoever decided this scene needed a music bed should have been fired.
The soldier's life is shot both for winners and loosers. This lesson should be learned from that war. Unfortunately not all modern Russians understand that.
لي شهور ادور الفلم اخيرا لقيته
That was a fun bit of fiction. It looked like a similar number of German and Russian soldiers fighting, which would have been a crushing defeat for the Reds, seven days a week. But I did enjoy seeing all the gear. Could the Germans with the MP38/40s extend their stocks in the next production, please?
What's fiction? The Germans lost more men attacking Pavlovs House more than they did attacking France. Pavlovs House was defended by 25 soldiers and 10 civilians. Even the Germans admit these numbers. The Russians took heavy casualties in the beginning of Stalingrad but it's not like they were idiots who didn't know how to fight, especially when the Siberians came.
@@saucejohnson9862 more than attacking only paris actually, where they actually didn't even fight
@@iono5556The Germans fought agaisnt the french partisans in Paris.
Buenas tardes muchachos !!!!! Primera vez qe veo este video y me dejó impresionado ¿ Es un film ruso ?? Es serie o alguna película ? Espero sus respuestas, muchas gracias.
Фильм - Сын отца народов
This scene would be totally different with out the shitty music. It’s like it removes tension rather then building it.
Agreed.
That soundtrack is so melodramatic, old fashioned and unnecessary.
Yea the soviets had the most soldier deaths of the war but not a single one fell to the Germans
excellent!!!STALINGRAD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
6:25 remington 870 sound for kar98k. Interesting.
No cover MGS??? Unrealistic....
I like how the German chambered a round after his partner went down….just like an American western cycling the Model 74
There's quite a lot differences between the public narrative about Pavlov's house, and the truth about it. It was manned by lot more soldiers, they are never been cut from supplies, they even have in the house a room for rest with SF literature and board games, the house was not in the much battle intense part of the city, Pavlov didn't capture the house, he came later, the House hold out a lot more than it is commonly known, she's abandoned and wehrmacht captured it in January.
and lost it in february.
That looks like hell. God do we have it easy
Excellent action once again, thank you for sharing this one. What movie/TV series is this?
Son of 'The Father of Nations' (Сын отца народов) 2013
sitamfricus Thanks, it looks a good one. Your videos are always fantastic and thank you once again for this fine edit.
Hola tendrás alguna link de la película??
เยอรมันต้องรุกเข้าหาศัตรูในอาคาร เสียเปรียบเสี่ยงมาก แต่เยอรมัน คือชาตินักรบ นักสู้
Война это плохо! Люди я всем желаю СЧАСТЬЯ 🙏
Вместо того, чтобы ругатся подумайте ....Сколько жизней молодых извели в самом цвете! Сколько уничтоженно труда человеческого. Пол страны стерли в пепел! Что потом горем и тем же самым в Германию вернулось.....От такая примерно диспозиция.
*Those who doubt the casualties,remember,that in assault on Koenigsberg in 1945 died 42000 of wermacht soldiers and only 3600 of soviet soldiers.That is a historical fact.*
Dude. Come on! The great majority of that 42,000 were POWs that were out of ammo, had not eaten for two weeks, and surrounded by about 200,000 soviets. Get real and stop lying before your nose starts growing. I mean, damnit.
@@mustlovedogs272 Нацист, хочешь повторить
@@СергейКолосов-е2й KCXYNT WXZAOP BVRPIK CEPDRT URFSJK.
Hats off for all soldiers who faught for freedom.
They were tougher than you and me. Not the actors. The real soldiers.
Ppsh..., absolutely powerful...
Хотите показать правду ,не надо преувеличивать
It seems impossible to survive this for more than a few days at most.
I am from Iraq. Best regards, what is the name of the film and thank you
pearl harbor
There are three films mixed. "The Battle for Stalingrad" and "Enemy at the gate" (the same events). But I also recommend you to watch "The Battle for Sevastopol"
War in Iraq 😭
Looks like a great movie , are these for sale anywhere ?
На мой взгляд, очень правдиво показан один из многочисленных боёв за Дом Павлова в Сталинграде...
Too many films and shows focus too much on visual spectacle. Sound is equally as important to create visceral action scenes.
Agreed. Lack of music also helps with immersion.
Russian Bias?
Yes
Reminds me of south Chicago on a weekend
Удивляет внешний вид бойцов. Все чистенькие,гладко выбритые,на форме ни пятна, ни рванины...прямо как с ателье.. И не скажешь что на фронте,где не то что- бы помыться, зад подтереть нечем... Наше кино,такое правдивое.
3:08 the Russian and German would both be dead in real life, you hit the enemy, you don't shoot, if you are up close.
ideally you shoot. but not if you have a friendly in the line of fire because that would have probably penetrated through the german
This is an essay on a given topic and each nation interprets in its own way . Hello from Murmansk
I would shoot from the side so my comrade wasn't in the line of fire.
Karen Houser who are you referring to?
@@MichaelDelvalle-nt4gp Indeed, there is a good chance it might have, since 7.62x25mm is a very hot-loaded round with excellent penetration even when fired from pistol-length barrels. Coming from a submachine gun-length barrel, it likely would have gone straight through that skinny German (the Germans were a bit low on food by the winter of 1942) and still had enough energy to likely wound or kill the Russian under him.
Да здравствует Советский союз!
Pavlov's house in Call of Duty 1
Girls in dodgeball: chatting
boys:
please add English subtitles
You should learn Russian language. The whole world will be using it soon. We are eager to establish new empire and new order. Commies are coming ... face it
@@steelbunyea LMAO dude, you sound like a flat earther who spends his days ranting on reddit XD
Stalingrad (2013 film) directed by Fedor Bondarchuk with english subs
ruclips.net/video/fMVW0CsG1-0/видео.html
REPLY
The Germans lost on cold and lack of food supply and not on Soviet combat efficiency.
And John Wayne wasn't propaganda?What American movie is not a distortion of fact.Head up yours m8
That house must have a really nice view
it might have a picasso hanging on the wall.
Not even a particularly nice house to b arguing about
The advance technology of PPSh, it didn't cause recoil back then. Long lost technology
Why shoot the enemy when you can fist fight him!!!
Consider german infantry doctrine is based on universal machine gun such as mg-34, seeing a bunch of german soldiers assaulting a position without mg covering fire is just wrong.
Good comment.
Is a russian film, what did you expect?
There was an area of Stalingrad Center which the Germans never did take. In Stalingrad North, too.
It's clear that the very limited budget of this film went mostly to special effects and not hiring decent actors. The funny thing is that the Russian film crew could have probably saved _a lot_ of money and got some local veterans to fill most of the roles--at least they'd know how to move and handle their weapons in a somewhat convincing manner as opposed to looking like rank amateurs.
I bet that quite a few of those vets would probably volunteer for that role--it gives them something to do, and who wouldn't want to have their name in the credits of a patriotic feature film?
The Uniforms and weapons detail were good.
The Germans should be in the russian position and the russians should in the germans position. That is more accurate.
what a fuckin shit comment
Lol yeah Harrison can go and fuck himself
@Harrison: were you saying it should be "berlingrad" instead of "stalingrad? very innovative, but unfortunately, in history, your mirage of "berlingrad" were disappeared in less than 20-day.
@@brexitmeansbrexit4129 actually the germans were a very skilled and highly trained army, they showed discipline at the front. The grand were led greatly, experienced commanders, and overall better field weapons. Russians however were mostly untrained men, most of their uniforms in the summer were peasant clothing, most of the time they were poorly led, they had good field weapons but they were unreliable, exception to the beautiful mosin rifle, Russians won stalingrad because they had the entire Russian backing them up, militias and partisians had their side, it was their turf, losing any big Russian city would break morale, Russians hated Germans, they had the US backing them up, and they outnumbered the Germans and had supplies for winter...
It is not. It were the Germans who were attacking pavlov house. And it were the germans, who lacked automatic weapons, and were armed mostly with carbines
Is this on Stalingrad? What is the name of this film? Thanks.
Is there really a need for Soviet propaganda movies 70 years after the war?
twombonu Are you upset that he is correct it is nothing more than propaganda? It seems so! The Russian soldiers were truly untrained and not good in the case of combat they gave farmers a gun if he was lucky and pointed him at an MG and expected him to win!
That is pretty funny that is all you can come up with how many more petty insults do you have for me since in all reality Germans should have won that fight if not for this being propaganda?
That's so exaggerated it's not even funny. The conscripts were the least trained but they still were. The russians had divisions of fully trained units as well. The germans were trained better on average yes and had better equipment but it clearly wasn't enough.
yes, because there's another one coming...
Q11
pretty clean sniper....
7:11 Разве так кучно наступают?
Жора Интересующийся Фантазия русский националистов 🤦🏻♂️ и лжепатриотов лежащих на диване с пивом
The mp40 sounds fucking great though not gonna lie
*Кім қазақ!*
Мен Кыргыз
Propaganda rusa , la realidad no fue tan elegante ni tan limpia.... yo no estaba... pero me acuerdo😂😂 JAJAJAJAAJ
Так все и било !
Must be a Russian movie! Last time, the Russians fought this smartly occurred only in movies and textbooks.
What bunch of crap!
когда идёт живая сила ,ЭТО САМОЕ СТРАШНОЕ) нА САМОМ ДЕЛЕ ТЫ УЖЕ СМЕРТНИК ,ПОПДИСАВ ДОГОВОР.сАМОЕ СТРАШНОЕ ЭТО ОДИНОЧЕСТВО И УМИРАТЬ В НЁМ.
Soviet rats...
You, nazi pig!