@@LearnwithSukantaSaha A good teaching always depends on time though. Who said we dont want lengthy discussion on that topic! A single poem doesn't require whole study on Eliot. The poem is deep and the explanation must be deep for the best teaching learning experience on this piece.
Oboshyoi hote pare. Analysis is upto you. Ami sob jagatei eta boli. You have to just back it up. Evabei to notun notun ideas and themes beriye ase. Keep it on. Khub valo.
First of all thanks for the question. But to be true I really don't know the right answer. But I have read many articles and also thought much and they are: 1. In my opinion, in broader aspects "This broken jaw" is just an image of deformity or physical damage. 2. If we study closely, this stanza starts with "The eyes are not here", this means they lack the sight(help) of God and also they are blind. Now added to that the broken jaw (for which we cannot even talk) also shows them to be voiceless too. That means they are at the same time visionless and voiceless. 3. Another thing came before my eyes but I can't establish any relation between. You know our Hanumaan ji was a 'broken-jaw'. His jaw was broken by Indra Dev's Vajra. And T.S. Eliot was much influenced by Indian traditional culture. But I don't think it's a good one. Now it's upto you. First two are much more relatable. Thanks.❤
Sir , You have said that the last line of the poem i.e. "...not with a bang but a whimper " has it's reference from Kipling's one of the poems , please write the name of the poem , as it seems I have not found the name of the poem in his list of poems . Have you said "Benny River" or like that ? Please clear .
Khub vlo laglo.....poem ta clearly bujhte parlam.....Thank you sir
Tomra bujhte parlei amar effort successful hobe.
It's really difficult to understand
Your style of explanation is just awesome,, thank you so much Sir 💞
Thank you so much.
Khub sundor reference diye bujhiyechen sir.....
Khub sundor sir
Khb sundar laglo..thnq sir..Good Morrow ta jdi explain krten help hoto
Amazing explanation
Kon sem? 😂
Thank you so much Sir.
hello dada tmr paranota khub sundor..truly informative...
Thanks.
Thank you so much sir for this explanation 🙏🏻❤️
Very nice explanation.
Very Helpful video thanks for making video thank you so much
Thank you so much 😊
Nice Explanation ❤️❤️
Thank you sir...❤️
Nice explanation
Preface to Shakespeare by samual jhonson jodi explanation ta detan khub upokar hotho..plz sir
I left my low humble home poem tar line by line analysis kore din .tnx
Thanks a lot
Jodi ektu figure of speech guloo ektu mention kore diten sir khub vlo hoto
Fantastic
Thanks
Hollow explanation. Ideas are presented in a superficial way
Yes. Of course. 😇 what more you want from so short a video especially on T. S. Eliot' poem! This is just a charging up.
@@LearnwithSukantaSaha A good teaching always depends on time though. Who said we dont want lengthy discussion on that topic! A single poem doesn't require whole study on Eliot. The poem is deep and the explanation must be deep for the best teaching learning experience on this piece.
Agreed and asking for your pardon ma'am.
Sir Preludes er upor kono video dile khub upokrito hotam
Just awesome
Khub kothin ei kobitata dada...kmn jeno
Thik bolecho. Asole Eliot er sob poem e kothin. Wasteland aaro kothin. Tobe dhire dhire bujhe bujhe poro dekhbe kichuta holeo sohoj hobe.
Sir. Hollow Men theke kichu question dile valo hoto..
Thanks
Nice exclamation🙏
Thanks.
Dada, can you please explain the "Danny Deever" poem's reference more clearly?
Preludes line by line upload plz
Soon.😊
Thank you sir.
I was looking for best analysis of 'The Hollow Men' then I found ur video...thanks
happy to help you.
The eyes are not here
There are no eyes here.... ei line duto r moddhy oi direct eyes e jara river cross koreche tader kotha bola hocche na ??
Oboshyoi hote pare. Analysis is upto you. Ami sob jagatei eta boli. You have to just back it up. Evabei to notun notun ideas and themes beriye ase. Keep it on. Khub valo.
Significance of "star" and the significance of "eyes"...aktu bole din 2 maks size er
What is the allusion "the broken jaw " ----pl comment
First of all thanks for the question. But to be true I really don't know the right answer. But I have read many articles and also thought much and they are:
1. In my opinion, in broader aspects "This broken jaw" is just an image of deformity or physical damage.
2. If we study closely, this stanza starts with "The eyes are not here", this means they lack the sight(help) of God and also they are blind. Now added to that the broken jaw (for which we cannot even talk) also shows them to be voiceless too. That means they are at the same time visionless and voiceless.
3. Another thing came before my eyes but I can't establish any relation between. You know our Hanumaan ji was a 'broken-jaw'. His jaw was broken by Indra Dev's Vajra. And T.S. Eliot was much influenced by Indian traditional culture. But I don't think it's a good one.
Now it's upto you. First two are much more relatable. Thanks.❤
@@LearnwithSukantaSaha thanks for your reply I follow your video
Sir , You have said that the last line of the poem i.e. "...not with a bang but a whimper " has it's reference from Kipling's one of the poems , please write the name of the poem , as it seems I have not found the name of the poem in his list of poems . Have you said "Benny River" or like that ? Please clear .
এটা ভালো লাগল। প্রথম পার্টে কিছু আইডিয়া ক্লিয়ার হয়নি
Thank you samanytomo upokare lagte pere.😊
First part e kon jaygay problem chilo, seta bolle ami aro clear korar chesta kortam.
Thank you sir 🙏
Thank you 😊 sir
Thanks
Thanks