Is David Benatar ableist, promortalist, racist, eugenicist ...? | 1st Sept 2024

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 15 сен 2024

Комментарии • 30

  • @michaeldillon3113
    @michaeldillon3113 14 дней назад +4

    I always remember the English actor ( ?actress ) Eleanor Bronn at the height of her fame back in the early 1970's saying ' I love my children so much that I can't bear to bring them into the world ' . As a very young person who had anti natalist sentiment ( without knowing that anti natalism was ' a thing ' ) I found her comment very reassuring. ✌️🕊️

  • @LawrenceAnton
    @LawrenceAnton 14 дней назад +3

    Excellent episode!

  • @Brunoburningbright
    @Brunoburningbright 6 дней назад

    As a non-philosopher, I was not aware of there being such a vociferous debate on this matter, but as a devotee of the works of Samuel Beckett I find myself intrigued by David Benetar. Thanks for enlarging my awareness.

    • @Eric-ej3oy
      @Eric-ej3oy 5 дней назад

      Eveyone is a philosher more or less.

  • @mattihayry5060
    @mattihayry5060 14 дней назад +2

    Another brilliant episode. congratulations! 🎯

  • @TommyLikeTom
    @TommyLikeTom 10 дней назад

    As a South African philosophy graduate I regret that Benatar's work has become the poster-child for South African philosophy. His work dominates every conversatin I've had with people about my degree, which is why I don't mention it anymore

  • @FactsCountdown
    @FactsCountdown 15 дней назад +5

    Humans have optimism baised because optimism helps in survival and reproduction.

  • @reinatakagawa
    @reinatakagawa 4 дня назад

    I saw that Leftist Cooks video in my recommendation, and from the title, I assumed the content thereof and did not click it, and judging by your rehash, my assumptions as to the content was correct. That's basically how every argument I've had with pro-natalists have gone. They love to misrepresent what you say to justify their own emotional conviction.

  • @Antcraft15
    @Antcraft15 15 дней назад +3

    Your cake analogy is great. I have to steal it!

  • @TempehLiberation
    @TempehLiberation 14 дней назад +2

    Simply fantastic, I appreciate the response to Leftist Cooks (I did suffer through the full length of the video, although I did it at 1.5 speed).

  • @NiaEsto
    @NiaEsto 15 дней назад +1

    I am shocked the festival will not even release an audio of the benatar talk

    • @thecosmicantinatalist
      @thecosmicantinatalist  14 дней назад +2

      Looks like they didn't even record it, and it might be because Dr. Benatar might have requested to not record is my guess.

  • @xenocrates2559
    @xenocrates2559 15 дней назад +1

    As always, thanks for your meticulous analyses.

  • @Rich-xq8df
    @Rich-xq8df 14 дней назад

    You're the best, man.
    You can't fathom the good/great you are doing with your honesty/logic/reason/decency.
    Thank you so much....

  • @Liveanimalsalone
    @Liveanimalsalone 14 дней назад

    We would be glad to see you Collab with voice of vegans ..he seems to be receptive...and also he is going to read better never to have been

  • @LouisGedo
    @LouisGedo 14 дней назад

    👋 hi

  • @0Nick0
    @0Nick0 14 дней назад

    I did think Peterson won the debate with Benatar

    • @Eric-ej3oy
      @Eric-ej3oy 5 дней назад

      You think. Dont know.

  • @WackyConundrum
    @WackyConundrum 14 дней назад +1

    Wrong pronoun 😅

    • @thecosmicantinatalist
      @thecosmicantinatalist  12 дней назад +1

      Yeah I am not very educated on this subject of genders and pronouns(as if I am on others btw) so I keep on making mistakes

    • @LifeStrike2030
      @LifeStrike2030 11 дней назад +1

      @@thecosmicantinatalistthank you for making the correction!

  • @antinatalizm
    @antinatalizm 15 дней назад +1

    Great content as always!🎉🫶