Singing this song live that good (even better than on the album) truly shows what a great singer Kay is. Unlike those so-called singers like Stephy, Twins, Boy'z. They give you the shivers when they sing live...brrr.
i love every version of this song, whenever she sings it. on the surface, this song seems simple. but in kay's hands, even simple songs sound extraordinary. however, i disagree with the statement that this rendition is better than her 903 one, which was perfect. listen to the 903 version again, and you can hear that she was FLAWLESS in it. she gave 120% into that performance. she hit every note perfectly and she was extremely emotional.
re: 'false' vs 'real' voice. to me, her 'false' sounds much, much nicer than say Janice's or Kelly's 'real' voice, which scare me every time i listen to them sing high notes. secondly, it also depends on what the song demands. falsetto lets you reach higher notes, and for this song, she can definitely reach quite high. furthermore, search for the video where Kay sings "If I ain't got you" (with khalil fong) with her 'real' high voice. it sounds better than others (like janice and kelly.)
is it just me or the key in this one is actually lower than the one @ 903 live? i think the same thing happened to faye wong where she couldn't go back to her usual level right after her pregnancy. she's still really good right now but i agree she doesn't sound as good now as in this video.
holy crap she "ran voice" like hell, and this song ain't that good really it's just a vehicle to attract attention and see you hongers jump on her bandwagon.
前無古人, 後無來者，呢個時期ge佢，完美。
奇蹟出現
呢個時候既佢，係最自然、最靚、最直情流露，最富感染力既謝安琪!
x2...起雞皮.最富感染力既謝安琪😅
呢次新世紀 Live 真係經典囉，高音話上就上，新人黎講仲要勁淡定，玩Ad Lib本身其實已經加晒分，但最最最癲既係竟然好聽過CD Version，Kay 你真係好神....
x2...起雞皮.最富感染力既謝安琪
she is the hope in HK music!!! good luck and thx for this song!!
yay~~~ go KAy~~~ i just lovee her voice~~ its unique!!!!
I love Kay!
那時我在場呀........... 好多年前..佢果時真係好正
x2...起雞皮.最富感染力既謝安琪
Kay still got it. the 903 version is the best, it was perfect.
damn, she's good. She's brave to sing one her hardest songs live.
Singing this song live that good (even better than on the album) truly shows what a great singer Kay is.
Unlike those so-called singers like Stephy, Twins, Boy'z. They give you the shivers when they sing live...brrr.
great talent, great personality
係！佢真係有實力玩LIVE!
好勁@.@ ❤️
1
真係好好聽.........已經無法形容lu......
very good! Really want to go to her concert when she has one!
Kay唱得好辛苦！ 黃博輕鬆自如！ 好似雀仔飛天唱歌咁😊
she's awsome~ i relly love her voice~
i like how she moves around as she sings. makes me wants to swing about too. :)
黃博唱得好輕鬆
呢個時期kay..一定k.o黃博.....係呢個時期
@@nbachungI don’t think so
中英版crossover真係好正XD
i love every version of this song, whenever she sings it. on the surface, this song seems simple. but in kay's hands, even simple songs sound extraordinary.
however, i disagree with the statement that this rendition is better than her 903 one, which was perfect.
listen to the 903 version again, and you can hear that she was FLAWLESS in it. she gave 120% into that performance. she hit every note perfectly and she was extremely emotional.
Thanks Arluen.
This video is great!
點解要畀個爆ge肺佢~~唔公平~~
睇返以前ge Kay,好唏噓-_-
不過佢而家已經進步佐超多!!Kay加油!!
仲有好索，當時仲有啲少女feel^_^
人生不就是不斷會轉變嗎?
人要面對尤此而來的問題時, 通常你喜歡落井下石嗎?
問題必須要自己承擔, 但若果你知道他的困難, 你所作出的反應都可展現你的為人!
真係唱得好好
希望佢把聲會好番啦~~
原来佢係唱到呢首歌嘅..,但都無黃博嗰種輕盈感覺
看她以前的live,心總不自覺的酸了...
其實EVEN宜家既謝安琪唱呢首歌都係咁PERFECT架@@
大家可以睇下RUclips@@
佢唱D高難度D既歌先冇問題@@
唱D普普通通既先差D= =
佢低音同中音較弱，其實呢首既前部份都聽得出﹛反而上高音位就完全無問題
@@完來..係我唔識野....
但係呢首真係好好聽..講真的!!
高得黎好正!!!
佢仲可以唱高d!!!!就算時勢逼到呀kay變偶像派佢都係實力偶像派!!!!!!
個高度係女聲入面好普通 但要控制得好一連串假音轉音係好難
Kay is perfect at that time. So Joey envy her and attack her
這是不能在本地其他女歌手看到的....玩live~
ahluen ..thx the post.....!
呢個時候既啊Kay去左邊啊!?
I am wondering what awful situation will happen if other Hong Kong's Female singer perform this song ._.
GJ Kay.
Kay sing English better than Cantonese in my mind.
re: 'false' vs 'real' voice. to me, her 'false' sounds much, much nicer than say Janice's or Kelly's 'real' voice, which scare me every time i listen to them sing high notes.
secondly, it also depends on what the song demands. falsetto lets you reach higher notes, and for this song, she can definitely reach quite high.
furthermore, search for the video where Kay sings "If I ain't got you" (with khalil fong) with her 'real' high voice. it sounds better than others (like janice and kelly.)
Kelly Chan？
黃博完勝
說真的…少了當年的收放自如…
黃博唱得好過原唱...
Except it's real high.
點會有人覺得黃博唱得好過kay, 呢首歌後半part勁難唱, kay唱到遊刅有餘，個groove又係kay 捉得好好多
全盛謝安琪邊有咁易打敗
一到英文就無敵
唔係呀！一到英文就走哂音！😂😂
好眼光，咁而家呢？！
最好就係歌迷唔會跟住唱，安靜咁欣賞唔會干妖歌手
I agree. it's really not.
it's really high sure, but it's still a lot easier than 'real voice' high. Which she lacks.
黃博好唱好多，天使甘声😂
is it just me or the key in this one is actually lower than the one @ 903 live?
i think the same thing happened to faye wong where she couldn't go back to her usual level right after her pregnancy. she's still really good right now but i agree she doesn't sound as good now as in this video.
Other HK singers singing this song will be like suiciding for them! KAY ROCKS!
Lol.. I would like to see that happen. :)
@eggfung 果個live..好似比人放左上討論區傾,點知傾唔夠三日就比人檢舉,d anti..唉
@rrrr744 人地要作新聞交差呀!
假音既高音唔系高音?
@hei2005
咁都叫衰?!
你將高音&假音 聽成走音??
呢斷片唔可以作準吧
現場回音咁勁,仲要再入返cam支咪,效果好差係正常
佢果陣個樣同宜家都冇分別 點解會比人話整容?
而家成熟咗
因為佢地系聽歌唔系玩大合唱
本來已經難唱..仲要咁玩發..- -~
she needs to improve her 咬字
@peppepeppe5678 佢都係人姐:)
唉...天意弄人.
係幾好聽, 呢個係事實,
但係有幾個音都係走左, 呢個都係事實~
1:46 第二個高音
3:00 第一個高音
4:11
但係我覺得整體黎講, 真係幾ok呀,
咁難唱...走少少音在所難免姐~
LOL some crap like Yxmiko?
twiXs? xD
holy crap she "ran voice" like hell,
and this song ain't that good really it's just a vehicle to attract attention and see you hongers jump on her bandwagon.