From debut stage to now, I think Giselle is the most improved member. Drastic improvement on her dancing. Underrated vocalist, and her rap is top tier. Also her personality is a whole mood.
even in the interview who droped today the member said that she work very hard to improved her self and her she said that work harder since she trained just 11month before debut she want to improve her self faster . to not be different from the girls im so proud of here tbh i really encourage her
Giselle's natural eyes are so pretty. You can clearly see it as she stares into the camera while singing her lines in Forever. I hope their stylists will stop making the girls wear colored contact lenses. And yeah I can't stop looking at Giselle in Forever. I really love that outfit on her and her close up shots are so pretty. Her eyes 😍
OMG I love karina's personality, it's always this pure and real innocence about her that draws my literal attention. She is so relatable and down to earth and as the leader,lover her members so much. She truly deserves the title "4th generation IT girl"💣💘✨
I'm so proud of maknae ningning her voice is so angelic as expected uri main vocal ningning🥰 She's so beautiful and her charisma, stage presence, dance moves and vocal are on top!!!
@@bangh.sutoyo3748 I’m honestly so mad at SM for this. The girls can clearly sing so why don’t SM let them sing live? And ik it’s not because is aespa because other SM groups are lipsyncing now.
Ningning's vocals are so stable and clear while she is dancing and she have so much stage presence too! I mean, all the girls do, but Ning have the voice and singing/dance style/charisma I like the most, and she is still so young.
i can't believe people are still doubting aespa's vocals 😂 whoever watched dreams come true's bts knows how clear their voices are and how they manage to hit these high notes effortlessly and without make ugly faces
Those haters will just find anything to doubt them. Like its just studio recorded of cuz its clear.. they want live vocal fmwhen they dance on stage. Like lol. Not even most idols dance n performed full live. Most go only half live or singing some parts live when they can. They jist seeing their faves goods n unsee the bad but for those they dislike they unsee the goods n enlarge the bad. Double standard always
Exaclty. Although they do lipsync they sing live as well. Just like every other singer... even ariana grande lipsyncs sometimes. This live was really good though! Even better than the other lives that they did.
Oh my i really can relate to this, everytime there will always comments about lipsync. As if they're the only idol group in Korea who's lipsyncing. Most are really delusional, trying hard to hypnotize themselves like ' they do lypsinc, their perfect vocals aren't real'. 😂😂😂 pathetic human being..
LMAO, their dreams come true behind the scenes is full of pitch-correction and vocal effects. unlike red velvet and nct, most of what you heard there was messed with. STOP SETTING TOXIC STANDARDS THAT NO ONE, INCLUDING AESPA, CANT LIVE UP TO!
Yes, gurlss! Give us those vocals! The talent and power that they hold is insane. And excuse me, Ms. Karina Yoo, I should sue you for being too perfect 👀 Damn, whatever she’s wearing really draws my attention. Everything looks good on her!
Only SM artists can make netizen confuse and argue whether they singing live or lip sync because their live vocal as same, sometime much better than recording. That's the power of SM Water!!!
No matter how much hate this girls receive every day I'm so happy to see them smiling and performing. I really hope that they will keep being each other strengths. Plus can we talk about the vocals?? I bet Black Mamba, Savage , Forever was live, you can hear the vocals AMAZING!!!
Ningning got me feel “wow,,,so swag and beautiful”. I literally don’t know what i should say. She’s so charming charismatic gorgeous. She performed wonderful dancing, singing. She should be born an idol. It’s a bomb performance. I love Ningning~~~~ (also Karining kkkkk
에스파를 볼때마다 기분이 좋고 마음이 편해져요 누가 에스파를 힘들게 해도 항상 마이들이 있다는걸 잊지말고 행복하게 활동했으면 좋겠어요 오래오래 우리 짱스파를 보고싶다구요!! 그러니까 건강 잘 챙기구요 우리 짱스파 넘 열일하느라 수고 많은 한 해였네용 에스파도 메리 크리스마스~~~💗💗
Karina's voice is so stable...i am really glad that she had the chance to show her vocal more in Dreams Come True .And I hope she gets her own vocal song soon~♡.
Well, this is a group which has 4 main vocalists, 4 main rappers, 4 main dancers and 4 Visuals. Only SM can bring this on. All their groups are made of multi talented, amazingly talented members. I guess their casting + training = one of a kind.
@@chrissyalapo-calg9748 that's what I'm saying in some parts the background music was louder than their voices and not only the high notes are hard to sing while dancing but also they have smtown concert where they have to sing live they need to give their voices a rest
에스파는 4명중 2명이 외국인이지만 의사소통이 진짜 다 잘하는 것 같아서 보는 내가 안심되는 그룹이다 멤버수가 많지 않아서 서로 잘 챙겨주는것 같고 일본 팬으로서 보기 좋은 그룹💕 내년에도 화이팅 💕✨ エスパちゃんたちは4人中2人が外国人だけど、メンバー間の意思疎通がよく出来てそうで見てて安心できるグループ☺️💜 一年間お疲れ様☺️来年もファイティン✨ 日本から応援してます💕💕
This is a sweet Christmas gift from aespa! Actually I don't care about Forever tbh, but in this Christmas season Forever hits hard; seriously. Such a feel, and the live vocals & highnotes *chefs kiss
@@rockyrockelle642 most of the time they are using MR meaning Instrumentals and Live Vocals and sometimes LMR.. Intrumentals with recorded live vocals but not strong to overpower live vocals.
when I watched dream come true recording behind the scenes, ningning and winter really have a poker face while doing the highnote 😂 that's why the obsessed aespa hater and even naevis confused whether it is live or pre-recorded because they can sing effortlessly and professionally ~~
Karinaaaaaaaa ❤️💙❤️💙 Our visual leader, main dancer, lead rapper, vocalist, center, face of the group!!! She is everything!!!! I love her stage presence and her voice colors!!! 😍😍😍
The enough amount of talent,vocals,visuals and charisma is what we all love about AESPA. Always gives us the best performances that y'all always give us,thank youuu for this. STAN AESPA!🤝❤
@@chenlesmom789 an idol can't lip-sync the whole song (it's a rule) they have a percentage to sing live and lip-sync (I'm sorry, my English is not good)
I can hear their live vocal OMG 😱 when karina speak “beat drop” and giselle rap part on next level it’s prove that they’re sing live (pardon my english)
i’m pretty sure black mamba was the only part live one though….. it sounds like they didn’t edit their pre recorded vocals tho? so still vocal queens yk- but it doesn’t rlly sound live (black mamba sort of?)
They totally can sing their songs live, their vocal strength (especially ningning and winter) may be the best of 4th gen girl-groups. It's a loss that SM don't allow them to appeal their strength.
The funny thing is, the haters will not be Mamamoo or Red Velvet fans. Fans of the girl group who cannot sing LIVE properly will be the one hating on them 😂.
this proves that they really had many live performances in music shows even in their SM stages but cause they’re so good it’s hard to believe that it’s live
![[4K] 에스파(aespa)💥데뷔부터 지금까지💥무대 말아드림 | Black Mamba부터 Spicy까지](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/aQ2ZfTFW6Qk/mqdefault.jpg)
![[4K] 에스파(aespa)💥데뷔부터 지금까지💥무대 말아드림 | Black Mamba부터 Spicy까지](/img/tr.png)
![[Eng Sub] Asking Giselle and Ningning from Aespa on Gukbap](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/TezpPRaYq74/mqdefault.jpg)
English subtitle will be updated soon! stay tuned💙🌙⭐🦋
Are they singing live? Please answer😭
Yes
Yes
Thank you!
Spanish please!!
Tracklist:
00:00 Black Mamba
04:36 Next Level
13:13 Savage
24:24 Forever
I really hope they will perform "Dream Come True" on stage 💖
Waiting for SMTOWN concert
Thanks 💪💪
I made a remix of black mamba on my channel. Pls watch it. Thks a lot!
THANKYOU
Thx
From debut stage to now, I think Giselle is the most improved member. Drastic improvement on her dancing. Underrated vocalist, and her rap is top tier. Also her personality is a whole mood.
その通り
I actually think her facial expressions are the most improved.
even in the interview who droped today the member said that she work very hard to improved her self and her she said that work harder since she trained just 11month before debut she want to improve her self faster .
to not be different from the girls im so proud of here tbh i really encourage her
@@零-d8i س
@@malou1563 bruh its was a mistake that could happen to anyone and she already apologise…
we cant judge person abt his whole life bc one mistake
Giselle looks powerful here. She was already good but her stage presence and dancing has gotten even better. You're doing well Giselle!
Giselle's natural eyes are so pretty. You can clearly see it as she stares into the camera while singing her lines in Forever. I hope their stylists will stop making the girls wear colored contact lenses.
And yeah I can't stop looking at Giselle in Forever. I really love that outfit on her and her close up shots are so pretty. Her eyes 😍
OMG I love karina's personality, it's always this pure and real innocence about her that draws my literal attention. She is so relatable and down to earth and as the leader,lover her members so much. She truly deserves the title "4th generation IT girl"💣💘✨
this is what you call equally pretty fits IT'S MY FIRST TIME SEEING ALL OF THEM WITH GOOD FITS
I made a remix of black mamba on my channel. Pls check it out. thk you
aespa has the songs like Lucid dream, ICONIC, aenergy, YEPPI YEPPI and I’ll make you cry too. 😭🤟🏻💖
hoping to see them performing their b-sides on smtown
I made a remix of black mamba on my channel. Pls watch it. Thks a lot!
With Aenergy we assemble
Kwangya’s national anthem
At first, I love Ningning because of her natural cuteness and vocal ability. Now, I love them all. They are so talented😆
I'm so proud of maknae ningning her voice is so angelic as expected uri main vocal ningning🥰 She's so beautiful and her charisma, stage presence, dance moves and vocal are on top!!!
Yesssss
Their live vocals are so fvcking heavenly😭❣️
I made a remix of black mamba on my channel. Pls watch it. Thks a lot!
@@bangh.sutoyo3748 U CAN LITERALLY HEAR THEIR REAL SINGING IN FOREVER ARE YOU DEAF LOL 😂
@@bangh.sutoyo3748 stop trolling
you can clearly hear it's live vocals.
@@bangh.sutoyo3748 I’m honestly so mad at SM for this. The girls can clearly sing so why don’t SM let them sing live? And ik it’s not because is aespa because other SM groups are lipsyncing now.
Their live vocals are just *chefs kiss*
I made a remix of black mamba on my channel. Pls watch it. ty!!
KARINA LOOKS SO UNREALISTICALLY BEAUTIFUL, GORGEOUS DOLL
Ningning's vocals are so stable and clear while she is dancing and she have so much stage presence too!
I mean, all the girls do, but Ning have the voice and singing/dance style/charisma I like the most, and she is still so young.
Yuri
Yadav
@Johan Setiadi it’s not lip sync lol
@Johan Setiadi But this is dingo
KARINA LOOKS STUNNING!!! I CAN'T GET OVER HOW BEAUTIFUL HER VOICE AND HER VISUALS ARE!! 😍❤️💙❤️💙
did you see the improvement on their performance? keep working hard aespa we see your hardwork paying off! ❤️❤️❤️❤️
I made a remix of black mamba on my channel. Pls watch it. ty!!
@@pinkziesofficial stop spamming
@@케이시-q4o let them do tho
ALL OF THEM DID WELL AND WINTER NEVER FAILS TO CAUGHT MY ATTENTIONS ALL THE TIMES, SHE'S BORN TO BE AN ACE 🔥
Vocal queens
I made a remix of black mamba on my channel. Pls watch it. ty!!
Ning and Giselle are so precious. Ugh love them so much, Ning Ning stole the show for me this time though. She’s so beautiful 🤩
GISELLE IS A VISUAL RAPPER AND DANCER AND ALSO VOCAL SHE'S EVERYTHING 🥰
In aespa's beautiful sound, we trust.
I made a remix of black mamba on my channel. Pls watch it. Thks a lot!
winter 笑起來最美麗超迷人的! 😍😍😘😘👍👍🎄🎄🎄❤❤❤❤🎂🎂🎄🎄
Their raw vocal is really something. aespa DOMINATION
I made a remix of black mamba on my channel. Pls watch it. Thks a lot!
this is literally not live ya'll are so gullible its funny 😭
Rijan
These are most definitely not raw vocals.
@@zitoma3244 live or not they still have clean vocals so yuh
i can't believe people are still doubting aespa's vocals 😂 whoever watched dreams come true's bts knows how clear their voices are and how they manage to hit these high notes effortlessly and without make ugly faces
Those haters will just find anything to doubt them. Like its just studio recorded of cuz its clear.. they want live vocal fmwhen they dance on stage. Like lol. Not even most idols dance n performed full live. Most go only half live or singing some parts live when they can.
They jist seeing their faves goods n unsee the bad but for those they dislike they unsee the goods n enlarge the bad. Double standard always
Exaclty. Although they do lipsync they sing live as well. Just like every other singer... even ariana grande lipsyncs sometimes.
This live was really good though! Even better than the other lives that they did.
ഒന്ന്അമവ്വ
Oh my i really can relate to this, everytime there will always comments about lipsync. As if they're the only idol group in Korea who's lipsyncing. Most are really delusional, trying hard to hypnotize themselves like ' they do lypsinc, their perfect vocals aren't real'. 😂😂😂 pathetic human being..
LMAO, their dreams come true behind the scenes is full of pitch-correction and vocal effects. unlike red velvet and nct, most of what you heard there was messed with.
STOP SETTING TOXIC STANDARDS THAT NO ONE, INCLUDING AESPA, CANT LIVE UP TO!
라이브 쩐다…라이브 티난다는게 못해서가 아니라
음질이나 스킬이 조금 달라서 라이브인걸 알아볼수있네요 넘 잘해…👍
Winter getting more prettier and prettier, all of them are pretty
I made a remix of black mamba on my channel. Pls watch it. ty!!
EVERYONE IS A VOCAL EVEN THE MAIN RAPPER WHAT THIS IS INSANE
Yes, gurlss! Give us those vocals! The talent and power that they hold is insane.
And excuse me, Ms. Karina Yoo, I should sue you for being too perfect 👀
Damn, whatever she’s wearing really draws my attention. Everything looks good on her!
I made a remix of black mamba on my channel. Pls watch it. ty!!
Only SM artists can make netizen confuse and argue whether they singing live or lip sync because their live vocal as same, sometime much better than recording. That's the power of SM Water!!!
haha the fact that before i became an exol i was brainwashed that they can’t sing live
Hahaha i was laughing while reading some comment replies.. No matter how we say they are live, they keep insisting that they're not.
LOL STUPID AESPA FAN CANT ACCEPT THAT AESPA IS STILL NOT ALLOWED BY SM TO SING LIVE LOL
@@johnmeule5586 the effort to make yourself look dumb omg😭
@@johnmeule5586 you're just embarrassing yourself at this point..... they're singing live here
No matter how much hate this girls receive every day I'm so happy to see them smiling and performing. I really hope that they will keep being each other strengths. Plus can we talk about the vocals?? I bet Black Mamba, Savage , Forever was live, you can hear the vocals AMAZING!!!
Karina’s deep, warm voice in Forever I am obsessed!
This is one of my fave performances of them now. They really look good, and performed so good. I'm happy to stan them
I made a remix of black mamba on my channel. Pls watch it. ty!!
MY QUEENS WILL FLEX THEIR LIVE VOCALS!!! GO SLAAAAYYYY
I made a remix of black mamba on my channel. Pls watch it. ty!!
Oh my gosh! It's live. I can hear their bare voices... Wow, aespa is not just group of visuals but also vocal
can`t take my eyes off from giselle. she`s so stunning. her facial expressions became much better. i also love the outfits here so muchh
OML Karina is literally most gorgeous well versed talented idol out there and I am not even surprised 😌🙊💝💨
aespa vocals will slayyyy again
Live 100% ?🥺
I made a remix of black mamba on my channel. Pls watch it. Thks a lot!
Hey! I made a Aespa Savage remix, Can you guys give me a honest review about the video. please, 🥺, ruclips.net/video/4hKh9OTOqqk/видео.html
Finally aespa FULL LIVE VOCAL 😍
Stan talent, stan aespa
..finally a live vocal performance...this is what SM is hiding from everyone of us....their diffenetly slaying live vocals....
Finally?? You must be have hearing problem
@@im_notslim i dont have hearing problem..do you?
@@shayne9309 go to the hospital or clinic and check your ears
@@im_notslim ..i dont have too..my ears works perfectly fine...maybe you do need to go see some help...insecurities is an illness just so you know...
This!! They always lip sync (excluding encore stages) so it’s amazing they’re singing live for once. Their live vocals are amazing!
Aespa shows their pure vocals
it's LIVE! aespa best vocal group of 4th gen
I LOVE Winter's styling
I love their stages and vocals
I made a remix of black mamba on my channel. Pls watch it. ty!!
와 엣깅이들 라이브하는게 느껴진다..
진짜 1년이 지났다는것도 너무 안 믿겨지고
에스파와 함께하는 크리스마스가 2번째라는것도 안 믿겨 진다 .. 올해도 너무 수고했고 내년에도 지금처럼 건강하고 행복하면 좋겠어 사랑해 에스파 ❤️🌙⭐️🦋
마이 에스파 포에버~🤙
cant take mg eyes off Giselle
she's so addictive and talented
ㅇㅈ
Aespa never fails to give us, MYs, a jaw dropping performance. Kudos, Aespa! We're so proud of you!
Go Karina, Go Giselle, Go Winter, Go Ningning ❤️🌙🌟🦋
sm should really let them showcase their beautiful vocals, aespa keep growing while haters keep barking😝😝😍
Ningning got me feel “wow,,,so swag and beautiful”. I literally don’t know what i should say. She’s so charming charismatic gorgeous. She performed wonderful dancing, singing. She should be born an idol. It’s a bomb performance. I love Ningning~~~~ (also Karining kkkkk
Karining is the best ning!
Everyone did so great! and I can see Giselle’s improvements, aespa fighting!!
와....다들 점점 더 예뻐지는거아니냐구…♥
마지막 Forever보면서 소름이 돋았어…쵝오…💛
이와중에 닝깅이 귀여워..💕
다들 이뻐 죽겄어 ㅜㅜ 진짜 짱스파 영원했으면 좋겠구 메리 크리스마스!😘
THE VOCALS ARE SO BEAUTIFUL, THEY LOOK SO BEAUTIFUL TOO! Crying omg 😭😭
I made a remix of black mamba on my channel. Pls watch it. ty!!
@@pinkziesofficial stfu cloutchase weirfo stupid no one will watch ur trash edit
에스파를 볼때마다 기분이 좋고 마음이 편해져요 누가 에스파를 힘들게 해도 항상 마이들이 있다는걸 잊지말고 행복하게 활동했으면 좋겠어요 오래오래 우리 짱스파를 보고싶다구요!! 그러니까 건강 잘 챙기구요 우리 짱스파 넘 열일하느라 수고 많은 한 해였네용 에스파도 메리 크리스마스~~~💗💗
크 에스파 라이브며 춤이며 미모며 완벽해ㅠ,, 와중에 딩고 카메라무빙 지려요🤩
Karina's voice is so stable...i am really glad that she had the chance to show her vocal more in Dreams Come True .And I hope she gets her own vocal song soon~♡.
OMG THEIR VOCAL SO STABLEEEEE
Aespa's charisma is otherworldly 😳 and this was shot so beautifully 🥰 Thank you dingo for inviting Aespa 🤗
I made a remix of black mamba on my channel. Pls watch it. Tysm!
우리애기들 너무 바쁘게 사는거아냐ㅠㅠ 피곤할텐데ㅠㅠ 물론 우리 마이들은 너무좋지ㅠㅠ 이렇게 새로운거 하나하나 발견할때마다 말로표현할수 없을만큼좋지ㅠㅠ 사랑해💗
나 평생 my할께 우리 오래가자ㅠㅠ
Well, this is a group which has 4 main vocalists, 4 main rappers, 4 main dancers and 4 Visuals. Only SM can bring this on. All their groups are made of multi talented, amazingly talented members. I guess their casting + training = one of a kind.
애들 미모도 미쳤고, 라이브도 미쳤고, 카메라 무빙도 진짜 미쳤네..왤케 잘짹음? 춤볼땐 춤 잘보이게 찍고 얼굴 보고싶을땐 얼굴 딱 보여주고ㅋㅋㅋ
so excited to see them singing live !! aaa this will surely go down the historyyy
When?
They are singing live on this one
I made a remix of black mamba on my channel. Pls watch it. ty!!
@@chrissyalapo-calg9748 that's what I'm saying in some parts the background music was louder than their voices and not only the high notes are hard to sing while dancing but also they have smtown concert where they have to sing live they need to give their voices a rest
It's prerecorded, but still live before the actual performance.
에스파 세계관 살펴보다 세비지로 입덕하게 됬는데 넘 행복하다 진짜♥ 에스파도 메리크리스마스♥
윈터님 항상 예쁜 모습으로 활동하시는 모습을 보는 것이 학생인 제겐 큰 힘이 되고 있습니다.
앞으로도 쭉 건강하게 활동하셔서 에스파 10주년
콘서트를 보는 것이 제 꿈입니다^^
에스파는 4명중 2명이 외국인이지만 의사소통이 진짜 다 잘하는 것 같아서 보는 내가 안심되는 그룹이다
멤버수가 많지 않아서 서로 잘 챙겨주는것 같고 일본 팬으로서 보기 좋은 그룹💕
내년에도 화이팅 💕✨
エスパちゃんたちは4人中2人が外国人だけど、メンバー間の意思疎通がよく出来てそうで見てて安心できるグループ☺️💜
一年間お疲れ様☺️来年もファイティン✨
日本から応援してます💕💕
OK but can we talking about Ningning's vocals, she was born to slay
My bias🛐❣🥵
미쳤어 라이브실력찢었다 코디님들 애들 따뜻하고 간지나게 입혀주셔서 감사해요 짱스파 사랑해💙🌙⭐️🦋
This is a sweet Christmas gift from aespa! Actually I don't care about Forever tbh, but in this Christmas season Forever hits hard; seriously. Such a feel, and the live vocals & highnotes *chefs kiss
I made a remix of black mamba on my channel. Pls watch it. Thks a lot!
Aww giselle as your pf ^^
poor forever 😂
it's not live.
Winter's voice is so angelic just like her name Winter ❄️🥰 She's so beautiful and her charisma, dance moves and vocal are on top notch 😍😍
I made a remix of black mamba on my channel. Pls watch it. Thks a lot!
@@pinkziesofficial It's better not to comment
True .. winter's voice is so stable and flawless even on high note
aespa’s live vocal never disappoint and slay every time. Love them so much. Good job aespa.
vocals, rappers, visuals, dance
AESPA QUEENS
누나들 이번년도 고생 많았고 내년에도 좋은 모습 많이 보여줘 응원할게 에스파이팅🔥🔥🔥 연말 잘 보내❄️❄️❄️
Aespa is the only kpop gg I stream in Spotify rn as I found their music is really refreshing plus their vocal is on NEXT LEVEL
OMFG. GET READY FOR THESE GIRLIES VOCALS!!! Prove all those haters wrong!!
They already proved the haters wrong but uk haters gotta hate. they'll always find something😪
@@kae8385 agreed. aespa served raw vocal live in encore but haters keep throwing hate.
They were singing live for all this time?? Just asking no hate
@@rockyrockelle642 nope
@@rockyrockelle642 most of the time they are using MR meaning Instrumentals and Live Vocals and sometimes LMR.. Intrumentals with recorded live vocals but not strong to overpower live vocals.
서로에게 편지 써주는거 맴이 따숩다 따수워 ㅠㅠ 지젤사투리도 너무 귀엽네 진짴ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
when I watched dream come true recording behind the scenes, ningning and winter really have a poker face while doing the highnote 😂 that's why the obsessed aespa hater and even naevis confused whether it is live or pre-recorded because they can sing effortlessly and professionally ~~
yeah no one’s doing it like aespa this girlies will always slayyy
I made a remix of black mamba on my channel. Pls watch it. ty!!
I'm new fans and Winter caught my attention the most, she is so charming and captivating omg 💗
I made a remix of black mamba on my channel. Pls watch it. ty!!
Same. Winter is my bias, Karina my bias wrecker.
@@pinkziesofficial it's nice
짱스파 2022년도 지금처럼 쭉 사랑할게!!
카메라 무빙 뭐야.. 딩고 ㅠㅠㅠ 에스파도 사랑하지만 이걸 담아준 딩고도 너무 사랑해요!❤️🧡💛💚💙💜🖤🤍🤎❤️🔥❤️🩹❣️💕💞💓💗💖💘💝
Karinaaaaaaaa ❤️💙❤️💙
Our visual leader, main dancer, lead rapper, vocalist, center, face of the group!!! She is everything!!!! I love her stage presence and her voice colors!!! 😍😍😍
2:34 I got goosebumps when I heard Ning hit a high note
I made a remix of black mamba on my channel. Pls watch it. Tysm!
Winter can be cute and badass at the same time, It's rare to see idol like this, She's unique 😍
Ningning too!
They are all too
@@zahrotulmusyayadah9379 Lol akgae
Actually Ningning is better at duality then the rest lol
Rosè vibes
The enough amount of talent,vocals,visuals and charisma is what we all love about AESPA. Always gives us the best performances that y'all always give us,thank youuu for this. STAN AESPA!🤝❤
Giselle killed that rap in savage wow 🔥🔥
딩고뮤직에서 한번 더 에스파 크리스마스 콘서트가 보고싶다...😂
팬들 아끼구 사랑하는 에스파 영원히 같이 롱런하자!!! 에스파에게 부끄럽지 않은 팬일수 있게 노력할게!😎
WTF THEIR VOCALS ARE SO STABLE HOLYSHIT
I made a remix of black mamba on my channel. Pls watch it. Thks a lot!
@@chenlesmom789 i think its live with some playback in the back, which is quite understandable and what most idols do
@@chenlesmom789 an idol can't lip-sync the whole song (it's a rule) they have a percentage to sing live and lip-sync (I'm sorry, my English is not good)
@@oaishu there is literally no backtrack. its prerecorded.
@@chenlesmom789 it is live
4 MAIN VISUALS
4 MAIN VOCALS
4 MAIN DANCERS
4 MAIN RAPPERS
💯
I made a remix of black mamba on my channel. Pls watch it. Thks a lot!
4 Maknae
4 FOTG
4 Leader
YASHHH
Hey! I made a Aespa Savage remix, Can you guys give me a honest review about the video. please, 🥺, ruclips.net/video/4hKh9OTOqqk/видео.html
24:38 젤깅이 눈뜨는거 너무 이쁘다 ㅠㅠㅠ
25:08 미모 레전드 진짜진짜,,,
그들의 비주얼, 그들의 보컬은 정말 아름답습니다.
I can hear their live vocal OMG 😱 when karina speak “beat drop” and giselle rap part on next level it’s prove that they’re sing live (pardon my english)
I made a remix of black mamba on my channel. Pls watch it. Tysm!
@@pinkziesofficial Ui IPO jk kññññ
Lmao bye
I just know these girlies will slay this 😭😭
I made a remix of black mamba on my channel. Pls watch it. ty!!
Hey! I made a Aespa Savage remix, Can you guys give me a honest review about the video. please, 🥺, ruclips.net/video/4hKh9OTOqqk/видео.html
I know black mamba such a great debut song. Knowing this 1-year old song appeared in survival show, great job aespa
Ningning is so pretty oh my god and those vocals wow
Ningning’s facial expressions are improving every videos… ❤️❤️❤️
Wow their vocals!!
이 소녀들은 어떻게 그렇게 재능이 있습니까? 너무 예쁘고 멋진 보컬 💕💕
I'm so glad that SM finally let them sing live. I hate to see people judging them because of it
i’m pretty sure black mamba was the only part live one though….. it sounds like they didn’t edit their pre recorded vocals tho? so still vocal queens yk- but it doesn’t rlly sound live (black mamba sort of?)
They totally can sing their songs live, their vocal strength (especially ningning and winter) may be the best of 4th gen girl-groups. It's a loss that SM don't allow them to appeal their strength.
The funny thing is, the haters will not be Mamamoo or Red Velvet fans.
Fans of the girl group who cannot sing LIVE properly will be the one hating on them 😂.
@@vatansagu frrr
@@vatansagu what grp are you talking about?
Forever is so live u can hear winter and ning nings deep voice because they have colds
this proves that they really had many live performances in music shows even in their SM stages but cause they’re so good it’s hard to believe that it’s live