Poor Mr. Herring must've been so confused at the end... years ago my husband was driving behind an elderly man whose car was swerving a little and my hisband followed him and got him to stop and asked if he was alright, called his family and learned he was diabetic and got him some orange juice. That's the human reaction. "You okay, Pops?" Hannah been watching too many police shows.
Similar situation, A car the that was driving on the side of my papa noticed something was off about him, she continued to watch his keeping the speed until she noticed his face started to change, she called highway patrol to have them send help, she noticed my papa was out of it. Luckily there was a guard rail on his right side she used her car as a shield to slowly push my papa over to the car she put her car in front of his and parked when the car came to a stop she rushed to turn the car off took the keys, she saved my papa that day and potentially other pedestrians, he was having a stroke.
@emiilyjaane7377 we witnessed an accident or, rather, was hit by someone in a similar situation. Poor man died behind the wheel while driving. The car bounced and swerved for about two blocks. I know they had to be scared. My nephew who was driving, saw it in time so we missed getting hit head on. The driver hit the driver's door.
My grandfather at 38 had an diabetic issue in 1947. He was 38. Police arrested him. Thought he was drunk. He died of diabetes shock. My dad was 8 years old. The family never sued. Said at that time you did not sue the police. Times have changed. I hear he never drank and was a nice man.
😮 since when does a citizens arrest include mounting a car chase and pulling a gun on and shooting them? This woman is batshit crazy ! She is not a Cop and wasn’t even the person involved but a spectator/witness and an extremely dangerous one it seems!
This girl is a danger to herself and society! She caused the death of a man for absolutely no good reason. May he Rest In Peace. The defense attorney is as rude and pathetic as they come. A man is dead and the defense attorney appears to be bored. Swirling in his chair and making faces like a child.
@@nelsonmandela343if he as having a medical emergency or at least a problem, that doesn't mean he deserves to be hunted down and shot dead. She was talking on the duties of law enforcement.
@@nelsonmandela343is it wrong to run from a accident scene if you’re having a medical emergency? Police have been called and still have not shown up. But you think he needed to be “held accountable” for trying to seek medical attention?
@@nelsonmandela343if he broke the law I’m sure he would’ve been ticketed, had his day in court etc however the defendant appointed herself the judge jury & executioner that day.
she's a psycho by the looks of it. She recently got that gun permit days before she basically trapped that dude and tried to "justify" her killing. Its like she went out hunting.
I find it interesting that Ms.Hannah didn’t even have a conversation with the state officer , and she only talked to the truck driver who probably was the same complexion as her. I don’t understand why was the state officer able to identify that something was wrong with Mr. Herring and Ms. Hannah did not, which is why I believe her actions were intentional
Defense lawyer does not know that an EPI pen is for allergic reactions and not diabetes. Also Judge needs to stop lawyers from making faces, rolling eyes or shaking head
@@melissalouis4750lol that’s laughable. Tourette’s syndrome does not only activate facial ticks when and only when the person hears a something they perceive as unfavourable to them. Also ticks do vary widely but I’ve never seen in my practice (or heard of) only consistently expressions of sarcasm/eye rolling 😂
Totally agree re Epipen for Allergies and Glucojet for someone with dangerously low blood sugar levels. Defence lawyer needs an Advanced First Aid course
i agree....some ppl may not realize Atty Tucker had a stoke....it really took a toll on his health and apperance...but hes still a very handsome man..... im sick of the states atty.. shes such a nerd, objects to EVERYTHING, but what gets me, is the judge allows her objections... @@melissalouis4750
Did that defense attorney REALLY just imply that the victim was trying to cop a feel of her breasts when she put herself leaning in thru his window??? Ridiculous!
This defense "attorney" is a complete nutter, just like his client. He needs to be disbarred and never be able to practice in a court of law ever again. Hannah was indefensible but he made it so much worse for her in the eyes of the jury and the court.
@mizznyght205 I wonder why the judge let him carry on in such a disturbing disrespectful way? There should be rules and regulations for these so-called attorneys
@Lynds77 Thank you so much for the time stamps. I have great respect for the people who do all that work for complete strangers to benefit from. Well done!!!
I just want to commend the correctional officer for being so awesome! He got out to truly help, he cared enough to assist rather then doing what Hannah did ( hunt him down like an animal.) He noticed that he was having a medical emergency and had mercy. May Justice be served!!
Next time do not claim you are police if you are not law enforcement He knew what he was doing when he claimed he was a “state officer” during the car accident.
@@melissalouis4750 What is the meaning of post certificate? P.O.S.T. certified means any person possessing a valid, numbered certificate issued by the Board authorizing such person to serve as a peace officer or reserve peace officer. In GA., evidently they do have similar rights to LEO when they are on duty. It’s different State to State, but in States like GA. and N.Y. they do have similar rights, in CA., as an example, they don’t. Perhaps Google and read before making untrue statements. 🙄
The defendants lawyer stressing she only 21 years old well that tuff if our juridical system think it’s ok to allow a 21 year old to carry a weapon then she’s old enough to suffer consequences she created!😡
this is the first time I have given my verdict before the whole case was presented. Even if everything the defense said was true, she is still guilty. Are they honestly saying that he assaulted her which she was reaching in the car to pull him out? I will go even one further...lets say he had the gun and shot her, I would say that was justified. The only way he could touch her was if she put herself into his space which makes me think maybe he left the scene because he felt threatened by her in some way. Makes you wonder what she would have done has she gotten him out of the car.
He absolutely did not leave the scene cuz Hannah was making him feel uncomfortable or threatened, that’s reaching. Yes, she was totally wrong in what she did but that one statement you made sounds asinine.
I’m just watching the prosecutor’s opening statements and I’m annoyed with Hannah’s lawyer’s nodding his head, making faces, smirking. The judge needs to put a stop to it.
He thinks he will get away with a lot because he has a different judge but just wait. She'll catch on to him eventually. He doesn't seem to have much respect.
That defense attorney is so unprofessional he chuckles and smiles and acts so smug as the prosecution asks questions and swivels his chair back and forth facing the jury while making comments to the defendant about the witnesses answers. He should be admonished for this.
Hannah cares about Hannah imagine her screaming get the F outta the car , meanwhile she’s armed . The man had a medical emergency and this is how she treated him so crazy she belongs in a cell . His lawyer looks very smug childish swirling in his chair during cross how disturbing!
It doesn't even matter if the man had a medical emergency or not. It doesn't matter what he said or she said. Nothing changes the fact that she shot an unarmed man sitting in his car. This is a really poor example of arguing self defense. He's just blaming the victim, because he knows he's got no case.
She rejected a plea of life with parole, if found guilty she will get life without parole, her lawyer is terrible if he didn't advise her to take the deal instead went trial
She doesn't have to take a plea deal. Whether advised or not, by her lawyer. She knows she's not going to be found guilty. Come on, people. A cute little southern bell? All she did was kill an old Negro. In the south? She'll get a medal of honor from all Southerners. She'll more than likely get a talk show on Fox News making millions of dollars. You all know it's true.😮 WHAT?🤫🫣
She's probably realizing that now hearing him speak in front of a jury for the first time that she made the wrong choice. He's kind of a joke. How many years would she have to serve before a chance of parole?
Imagine having a diabetic emergency and you cause an accident with no injuries to the other driver and get chased and the shot by a woman that thought she was in the right. This is insane.
Yes it seems the prosecution lawyers are the only ones in the courtroom that are behaving professionally. The defense lawyer should teach the class on how NOT to have the jury respect you or like you.
I remember this case well. It was been postponed atleast 3 times. Mostly because is her attorney. Defense requested a different judge for the trial after the first one tried to get her lawyer dis barred. Apparently they thought he had faked a stroke to Hanna more time free. Plus he was always late to every court appearance. I’m not sure why she decided to stick with this smuck
That defense attorney is insufferable. I love both attorney's for the state. Nobody had to encourage the defendent to do what she did. She was he77 bent on playing cop, using her weapon to intimidate someone, anyone, and lost her mind when Mr Herring wouldn't comply and ended up hitting her precious truck. She is not a good person. A good person would have helped Mr Herring not take his life. She has absolutely no remourse sitting there all smug. She is a danger to society. Lock her up.
Only 10,000$ if she’s not a flight risk, probly just used house as collateral..her lawyer pretty arrogant, with the facial, expressions, and constant shaking his head..I’m sure he’s gona rub people wrong, which may bode not so well for her unfortunately..but maybe if their personalities are similar, she’s comfortable with him…time will tell..they both check jury alot
Anyone who has worked in the judicial system knows the difference between a public defender, appointed counsel, and retained counsel is the size of their caseloads, access to expensive experts, and trial experience. Public defenders are not somehow lesser than. In fact, public defenders are some of the most zealous and skilled advocates because they have extensive knowledge and the most trial experience from the amount of time spent in the courtroom. People love to use it as a way to insult a bad lawyer but it comes across as ignorant if you have ever worked with all 3.
50:55 That “audacity” came from the fact she was carrying a firearm! Purely, & simple, from her knowledge, that she’s carrying! That’s it! That’s the whole story…she’d have NEVER, acted in that manner, had she not! 🤷🏻♀️
Yes!! Wow sick of defendants wearing the cross, I’m watching from 🇬🇧 here it doesn’t seem to matter! But I see it way too much, most are just sad doing that. I bet if they looked into and was allowed to bring up their religious beliefs they would. But they won’t be questioned etc. Also why do these criminals, killers never wear glasses until trial???? I call bs, but makes me 😂 x
Right. More so, she wasn’t a kid. She was 21 and licensed to carry. That makes her an adult. Maybe her defense attorney missed that portion of law school 🙄. She’s not going to juvenile detention, buddy 😂
Epi-pen; "epi" as in short for epinephrine.🤦♀️ The man was diabetic not suffering from potentially lethal allergy. Can't believe prosecutor let that line of non-sensical questioning slide.
This unfortunate and tragic case and another such case are sufficient reasons for the Georgia legislature's decision to abolish citizen's arrest privileges of ordinary citizens except for shopkeepers or store owners who control and stop shoplifting. The pursuit of criminals is the responsibility and job of law enforcement and not the responsibility and job of ordinary citizens.
First off there was no reason for her to have a gun out to begin with! But on top of that, why in this world did she have a bullet in the chamber unless she was ready to kill!
My condolences goes to this man family this is sad all the way round this girl got some real messed up issues chasing people down and demanding them to do what she wants and then take their life how crazy that is
Diabetics don't have epipen. A diabetic has a low, it's called a glucicon injection. And its a resuce one. A type 1 diabetic needs to take insulin everytime they eat or drink. That cross was misleading. Hopefully the prosecution fixes that later1
I was around a guy once who was climbing on a rail on a small set of steps much like a little kid would. You could tell he was out of it. Medic responded and basically said watch this. He administered whatever diabetic medication that was needed and the guy came around within seconds. It was remarkable!
Yeah, I think that's what he meant. He just didn't think to look it up somewhere to get his facts straight. Not a good lawyer. Blaming the victim. smh.
@@marionnewsom8687epipens have epinephrine in them. They won’t help with blood sugar. There are similar pens for diabetics called hypopens that have glucagon in it. So either your son is not actually carrying an epipen and it’s called something else, or he is carrying it for a reason other than diabetes.
The correction officer never said "Go" he said "Get it get it get it get the picture of the tag". The defense is infuriating....they attempt to blame every single witness on the stand. Wtf was that story about an archer? I bet he's used that story in more than half of his cases 😂
This case is new to me. Watching this opening by defense is not helping. 😂 He is all over the place. He just needs to tell the story about what happened
That defense attorney is the worst i have ever seen. Telling the jury to consider evidence that is not there whats next is he going to tell them about jury nullification? As for him referring to the defendant as young well it shows he has a sense of humor.
Exactly! WTF does her being "young" have to do with anything? If you're old enough to own a gun, you're old enough to use it responsibly! You can't use it to intimidate and ultimately murder a confused man who left the scene of an accident!
Listening to her attorney, makes me think of the episode of Andy Griffith, where Gomer tries to arrest Barney. He's yelling, with that southern drawl, Citizens arrest citizens arrest! Google it, it's funny
I’ve met Hannah Payne a few times in the past. Didn’t even know she was ever arrested, so I did a MASSIVE double take when I saw her face and name in this trial. This was really surprising to me because she always seemed very reserved, but I didn’t know her that well. All things considered, seems like she’s probably guilty.
Did you meet her after or before the murder? I'm just curious. I always wonder what the people around these kinds of people know and think. This is just so crazy.
I may be able to understand citizens arrest if you witness a violent crime and have ability to hold Perp there until LE arrives. This was not that. She got this enraged over a traffic accident with no injuries? She chased him down and was angry so she shot him. This is not justified its lunacy.
I just mentioned this in a different trial - I watched a trial where attys argued about recollection. The witness, a friend of the defendant, said something different to a question asked previously. (Real answer was not good for the defense) She gave the witness the transcript of that hearing to “refresh his recollection”. He read it & said the transcript shows he said it, but he doesn’t remember saying it. Defense then argued that statement/question/info was NOT ALLOWED to be said in front of the jury because, despite having the transcript, his MEMORY was NOT refresh… it was simply reading off a paper. 🤷♀️Very interesting move from the defense..🤓
Defense is literally a worse lawyer than my cousin Vinny lol. That bow and arrow story made little to 0 sense. Neighbor still hit the tree sir. Aim was still good. Your client is guilty clown
Whats her defense?? Stand your ground? Wait chasing a car which was none of her business...! If a man didnt die this would be laughable. Lock her up for life without parole!! Entitled little B
Wow, usually judges stop the speaking objections. At 1:35:40the prosecutor makes an objection with a very long statement and the defense responds with another long response.
17:45 Court Begins
20:25 Jury enters
43:43 Prosecutions opening statements
1:15:05 Defense Opening Statements
1:38:10 Prosecution's Witness takes Stand Vickie Lynn Herring (Victims Sister)
1:41:15 Defense Cross Examination
1:45:01 Prosecution Calls Terry Robinson Correction Officer
2:19:27 Court Breaks
2:39:58 Court Resumes
2:41:29 Cross Examination by Defense
3:29:15 Court Concludes
Thanks @Lynds77 for the info
Thank you !
Thank you!
Thank you.
Absolutely ❤❤❤❤ finished the timestamps this morning for you all ❤❤ enjoy fellow law nerds and grizzlies
Poor Mr. Herring must've been so confused at the end... years ago my husband was driving behind an elderly man whose car was swerving a little and my hisband followed him and got him to stop and asked if he was alright, called his family and learned he was diabetic and got him some orange juice. That's the human reaction. "You okay, Pops?"
Hannah been watching too many police shows.
Absolutely
Similar situation, A car the that was driving on the side of my papa noticed something was off about him, she continued to watch his keeping the speed until she noticed his face started to change, she called highway patrol to have them send help, she noticed my papa was out of it. Luckily there was a guard rail on his right side she used her car as a shield to slowly push my papa over to the car she put her car in front of his and parked when the car came to a stop she rushed to turn the car off took the keys, she saved my papa that day and potentially other pedestrians, he was having a stroke.
@emiilyjaane7377 we witnessed an accident or, rather, was hit by someone in a similar situation. Poor man died behind the wheel while driving. The car bounced and swerved for about two blocks. I know they had to be scared. My nephew who was driving, saw it in time so we missed getting hit head on. The driver hit the driver's door.
@@emiilyjaane7did you get her name, are you guys still in contact
My grandfather at 38 had an diabetic issue in 1947. He was 38. Police arrested him. Thought he was drunk. He died of diabetes shock. My dad was 8 years old. The family never sued. Said at that time you did not sue the police. Times have changed. I hear he never drank and was a nice man.
😮 since when does a citizens arrest include mounting a car chase and pulling a gun on and shooting them? This woman is batshit crazy ! She is not a Cop and wasn’t even the person involved but a spectator/witness and an extremely dangerous one it seems!
Georgia repealed the citizens arrest in 2021 anyway.
Who does she think she is?! Let’s get this straight. She had road rage.
I think she was watching too many police chases on RUclips
A female George Zimmerman smh
@@ShalishaWhiteyes. Another name that has come to mind in this case.
This girl is a danger to herself and society! She caused the death of a man for absolutely no good reason. May he Rest In Peace. The defense attorney is as rude and pathetic as they come. A man is dead and the defense attorney appears to be bored. Swirling in his chair and making faces like a child.
He ran from a crash scene. Though it may not deserve a shooting, people need to take accountability for their actions.
@@nelsonmandela343if he as having a medical emergency or at least a problem, that doesn't mean he deserves to be hunted down and shot dead. She was talking on the duties of law enforcement.
Why the name Nelson Mandela
@@nelsonmandela343is it wrong to run from a accident scene if you’re having a medical emergency? Police have been called and still have not shown up. But you think he needed to be “held accountable” for trying to seek medical attention?
@@nelsonmandela343if he broke the law I’m sure he would’ve been ticketed, had his day in court etc however the defendant appointed herself the judge jury & executioner that day.
It wasn't a citizen's arrest. It was murder.
If Hannah had of mind her own business she wouldn't have got herself into the mess she's in. She caused it. She deserves to pay.
she's a psycho by the looks of it. She recently got that gun permit days before she basically trapped that dude and tried to "justify" her killing. Its like she went out hunting.
Yup
She was probably itching to shoot a blk man. @@rickjames5998
"Janies got a gun"
I find it interesting that Ms.Hannah didn’t even have a conversation with the state officer , and she only talked to the truck driver who probably was the same complexion as her. I don’t understand why was the state officer able to identify that something was wrong with Mr. Herring and Ms. Hannah did not, which is why I believe her actions were intentional
I literally can't stand looking at her face she has no remorse.
LOVE that the bailiffs swiftly eject any person with a ringing cellphone without any repeated announcements from the judge!
Citizens arrest???? He was killed by a cop-wanna-be. She had absolutely no business getting in the middle of all that. She needs therapy ... In jail.
Amen lol
Send her over here. I'll give her some therapy.
Yes. Citizen’s Arrest is a thing.
she yelled at him to return to the scene of a felony he committed, and he killed her for it. she isn't the bad guy in this
@@gawainethefirstshe should have minded her own business and called 911 not go and Chase somebody down and kill them she's crazy
Defense lawyer does not know that an EPI pen is for allergic reactions and not diabetes.
Also Judge needs to stop lawyers from making faces, rolling eyes or shaking head
What if the attorney has Tourette’s?
Making faces would be out of their control
@@melissalouis4750lol that’s laughable. Tourette’s syndrome does not only activate facial ticks when and only when the person hears a something they perceive as unfavourable to them. Also ticks do vary widely but I’ve never seen in my practice (or heard of) only consistently expressions of sarcasm/eye rolling 😂
Totally agree re Epipen for Allergies and Glucojet for someone with dangerously low blood sugar levels. Defence lawyer needs an Advanced First Aid course
i agree....some ppl may not realize Atty Tucker had a stoke....it really took a toll on his health and apperance...but hes still a very handsome man..... im sick of the states atty.. shes such a nerd, objects to EVERYTHING, but what gets me, is the judge allows her objections...
@@melissalouis4750
Making faces, rolling eyes, shaking their heads when they hear something they don’t like are things that the judge cannot control
Amazing opening statement by the prosecution! RIP to that man :(
Did that defense attorney REALLY just imply that the victim was trying to cop a feel of her breasts when she put herself leaning in thru his window??? Ridiculous!
What? Naw.
This defense "attorney" is a complete nutter, just like his client. He needs to be disbarred and never be able to practice in a court of law ever again. Hannah was indefensible but he made it so much worse for her in the eyes of the jury and the court.
He had nothing else to go on. Just listening to his opening statement is dreadful 😂
@mizznyght205
I wonder why the judge let him carry on in such a disturbing disrespectful way? There should be rules and regulations for these so-called attorneys
@Lynds77 Thank you so much for the time stamps. I have great respect for the people who do all that work for complete strangers to benefit from. Well done!!!
Agreed 😊
If Hannah is hoping this man is going to save her life, she's dead wrong.
Plaid three-piece suit. What box of 1980s mothballs did they pull this lawyer out of?
@@lauraweiss7875LA Law
He is horrible! A simpleton like her.
This attorney is going to get his client convicted. He's an absolute arse.
Even the 911 dispatch told her to not chase him down but her ego was too big to do so ! I’m glad justice was served ! May he rest in peace 🙏
She takes Karen to a new level
Callate maria , la versión latina de Karen
X 100
She’s the final boss Karen 😂
Yup
She got herself a gun and suddenly became Bertha Badass. Lock her up and let the general population in prison take care of her.
I just want to commend the correctional officer for being so awesome! He got out to truly help, he cared enough to assist rather then doing what Hannah did ( hunt him down like an animal.) He noticed that he was having a medical emergency and had mercy. May Justice be served!!
😂
Next time do not claim you are police if you are not law enforcement
He knew what he was doing when he claimed he was a “state officer” during the car accident.
@@melissalouis4750
What is the meaning of post certificate?
P.O.S.T. certified means any person possessing a valid, numbered certificate issued by the Board authorizing such person to serve as a peace officer or reserve peace officer.
In GA., evidently they do have similar rights to LEO when they are on duty. It’s different State to State, but in States like GA. and N.Y. they do have similar rights, in CA., as an example, they don’t.
Perhaps Google and read before making untrue statements. 🙄
@@Ms2unique4u was he on duty when the accident and shooting happened? I appreciate you looking up the answer too!
@@novascotiaskater1868Well, he said he wasn't on duty that day, that's why he did not go after the driver when he took off.
she didn't reach for the tissues until the jury were right about to walk in. Shes got the acting part well & truly at its finest
That was the weakest defense opening argument I’ve ever heard. He made her a martyr and a hero 🙄
The defendants lawyer stressing she only 21 years old well that tuff if our juridical system think it’s ok to allow a 21 year old to carry a weapon then she’s old enough to suffer consequences she created!😡
this is the first time I have given my verdict before the whole case was presented. Even if everything the defense said was true, she is still guilty. Are they honestly saying that he assaulted her which she was reaching in the car to pull him out? I will go even one further...lets say he had the gun and shot her, I would say that was justified. The only way he could touch her was if she put herself into his space which makes me think maybe he left the scene because he felt threatened by her in some way. Makes you wonder what she would have done has she gotten him out of the car.
He would not have been justified to use deadly force against non lethal force acted upon him
@@ChoppedSteakif she was reaching into his car trying to pull him out. He would have ALL rights to defend himself. Lethal or not!
He absolutely did not leave the scene cuz Hannah was making him feel uncomfortable or threatened, that’s reaching. Yes, she was totally wrong in what she did but that one statement you made sounds asinine.
The defense attorney is making inappropriate faces. After the judge just said to the public not to make faces.
Wen ? Minute?!!!!
I’m just watching the prosecutor’s opening statements and I’m annoyed with Hannah’s lawyer’s nodding his head, making faces, smirking. The judge needs to put a stop to it.
He thinks he will get away with a lot because he has a different judge but just wait. She'll catch on to him eventually. He doesn't seem to have much respect.
I agree with your comment, that would be considered swaying the jury and the judge made clear before this started
That defense attorney is so unprofessional he chuckles and smiles and acts so smug as the prosecution asks questions and swivels his chair back and forth facing the jury while making comments to the defendant about the witnesses answers. He should be admonished for this.
Ok she had no right to show up with a gun then just took someone life wow. She’s going to prison I’m sure.
I don't think I have ever ever watched a trial where there wasn't somebody coughing their brains out throughout the whole trial
Yeah. It's like they're sending signals to whoever is testifying
Hannah cares about Hannah imagine her screaming get the F outta the car , meanwhile she’s armed . The man had a medical emergency and this is how she treated him so crazy she belongs in a cell . His lawyer looks very smug childish swirling in his chair during cross how disturbing!
Look 👀 at this privileged little wannabe cop I hope she get life without parole
It doesn't even matter if the man had a medical emergency or not. It doesn't matter what he said or she said. Nothing changes the fact that she shot an unarmed man sitting in his car. This is a really poor example of arguing self defense. He's just blaming the victim, because he knows he's got no case.
how do you know he wasn't attacking her?@@LDiamondz
he shouldn't be driving if he has issues that make him run red lights, and then leave the scene afterwards @@LDiamondz
Right. Because nobody's ever had an unknown medical issue before.
Sounds like Hannah always wanted to be a cop & actually thought she was that day !
She would have made a bad cop
Who in the heck did she think she was, God??? This was murder and Mr. Herring had to be wondering why she was HUNTING him down. Jail for life!
She rejected a plea of life with parole, if found guilty she will get life without parole, her lawyer is terrible if he didn't advise her to take the deal instead went trial
She doesn't have to take a plea deal. Whether advised or not, by her lawyer. She knows she's not going to be found guilty. Come on, people. A cute little southern bell? All she did was kill an old Negro. In the south? She'll get a medal of honor from all Southerners. She'll more than likely get a talk show on Fox News making millions of dollars. You all know it's true.😮 WHAT?🤫🫣
I have a feelings he doesn't listen to anybody much.
She's probably realizing that now hearing him speak in front of a jury for the first time that she made the wrong choice. He's kind of a joke.
How many years would she have to serve before a chance of parole?
@@shonabeggs4640you called it lol!
Georgia 35 years would have to be served!
Imagine having a diabetic emergency and you cause an accident with no injuries to the other driver and get chased and the shot by a woman that thought she was in the right. This is insane.
As I type this Hannah thinks she’s right.
Hannah was VERY wrong here. But you really shouldn't run from an accident either. Regardless it's a terrible tragedy what happened to Mr. Herring.
Imagine not seeing another comment that begins with “Imagine”
prosecution doing a great job, so clear and concise with everything, jury will appreciate that
Yes it seems the prosecution lawyers are the only ones in the courtroom that are behaving professionally. The defense lawyer should teach the class on how NOT to have the jury respect you or like you.
I remember this case well. It was been postponed atleast 3 times. Mostly because is her attorney. Defense requested a different judge for the trial after the first one tried to get her lawyer dis barred. Apparently they thought he had faked a stroke to Hanna more time free. Plus he was always late to every court appearance. I’m not sure why she decided to stick with this smuck
Cost, probably.
She deserved him as a lawyer 😊😊
He was even late for her sentencing hearing. Then, made an excuse that he’s sick.
The defence lawyer snickering isn’t helping his client very much regardless to her innocence or not. Perhaps shows the attitudes of both of them.
He seems more worried about how he looks fixing his socks and shirt cuffs.
@@jarcher6586
😅😅😅
That defense attorney is insufferable. I love both attorney's for the state. Nobody had to encourage the defendent to do what she did. She was he77 bent on playing cop, using her weapon to intimidate someone, anyone, and lost her mind when Mr Herring wouldn't comply and ended up hitting her precious truck. She is not a good person. A good person would have helped Mr Herring not take his life. She has absolutely no remourse sitting there all smug. She is a danger to society. Lock her up.
Their facial expressions are fantastic, watching this guy, who probably smells like cheap cologne and baloney. Defense attorney is smarmy
@rez3501 - EXCELLENT COMMENT!!!!
@@shindlesthat’s the funny part about laws people like her will exploit them.
@@shindlesno she was not justified. He did not commit a felony so citizen's arrest is out the window
@@shindlesAre you from Mars?! No one conducting a citizens arrest has the right to kill an unarmed man. No one.
This defense attorney reminds me of a slimy used car salesman.
I agree!!
Totally agree
I'm gonna go out on a limb here and say her attorney is a public defender.
I very much doubt he is. She made 100,000 bail surely mom & pop had money for a lawyer
@@melissa74066and lots of community support. Many called in when she was arrested demanding her release.
Only 10,000$ if she’s not a flight risk, probly just used house as collateral..her lawyer pretty arrogant, with the facial, expressions, and constant shaking his head..I’m sure he’s gona rub people wrong, which may bode not so well for her unfortunately..but maybe if their personalities are similar, she’s comfortable with him…time will tell..they both check jury alot
Doubt it just a lazy one
Anyone who has worked in the judicial system knows the difference between a public defender, appointed counsel, and retained counsel is the size of their caseloads, access to expensive experts, and trial experience. Public defenders are not somehow lesser than. In fact, public defenders are some of the most zealous and skilled advocates because they have extensive knowledge and the most trial experience from the amount of time spent in the courtroom.
People love to use it as a way to insult a bad lawyer but it comes across as ignorant if you have ever worked with all 3.
50:55 That “audacity” came from the fact she was carrying a firearm! Purely, & simple, from her knowledge, that she’s carrying! That’s it! That’s the whole story…she’d have NEVER, acted in that manner, had she not! 🤷🏻♀️
Hannah deserves to rot in prison for the rest of her natural born life.
She made sure to wear that big ol’ Jesus on the cross necklace. Guess she’s asking for forgiveness for murdering someone.
The eye drops case that just ended, that lady did the same thing
@@emilyj9034I've noticed a lot of the women tend to do that
Yes!! Wow sick of defendants wearing the cross, I’m watching from 🇬🇧 here it doesn’t seem to matter! But I see it way too much, most are just sad doing that.
I bet if they looked into and was
allowed to bring up their religious beliefs they would. But they won’t be questioned etc.
Also why do these criminals, killers never wear glasses until trial????
I call bs, but makes me 😂 x
That cross didn't help her case...
@@LindaMoon-xq1qm yeah the power doesn't come from the cross
I never imagined seeing an actual Bob's Burgers character in reality.
lol 🤣😂😅
@@bbruce1978 she literally has no chin
The defence saying shes just a kid...yeah an armed kid!
Right. More so, she wasn’t a kid. She was 21 and licensed to carry. That makes her an adult. Maybe her defense attorney missed that portion of law school 🙄. She’s not going to juvenile detention, buddy 😂
That defense attorney is awful. Too bad for her.
I wouldn’t even want him defending me for a traffic infraction. She’s definitely getting the max 😊
too bad for her? she belongs in jail
Murder he should be ashamed of trying to get her out of it
@@danielbennett9847
She got him out of a cracker box
This lady judge is so soft spoken
Epi-pen; "epi" as in short for epinephrine.🤦♀️ The man was diabetic not suffering from potentially lethal allergy. Can't believe prosecutor let that line of non-sensical questioning slide.
I don't have much faith in this prosecutor unfortunately.
@SoulAlchemy why?
Cannot wait to see the interrogation video for this case.
This unfortunate and tragic case and another such case are sufficient reasons for the Georgia legislature's decision to abolish citizen's arrest privileges of ordinary citizens except for shopkeepers or store owners who control and stop shoplifting. The pursuit of criminals is the responsibility and job of law enforcement and not the responsibility and job of ordinary citizens.
The police won't do their job. It would be easier to just admit who is commiting these crimes
I agree. Yet, I feel rules should also apply to ordinary citizens in case of possible attempts of severe crimes, such as abduction.
@@grandmaida7819 only cause you support criminals
This was citizens murder. No arrest.
@MissSassy019 so true. Good point!
I do not like the term, 'Karen'. But this defendant sounds like the definition of 'Karen'.
First off there was no reason for her to have a gun out to begin with! But on top of that, why in this world did she have a bullet in the chamber unless she was ready to kill!
Good point!
If she had the job for ten years. Why all of a sudden go out and buy a gun.
She wanted to be like Kyle Rittenhouse and I’m so happy she’s guilty. Rouge citizens
That lady felt entitled
Defense counsel doesn't make sense. He sounds like a drunk.
My condolences goes to this man family this is sad all the way round this girl got some real messed up issues chasing people down and demanding them to do what she wants and then take their life how crazy that is
Epipen......... wtf. Her lawyer is a joke. He had diabetes not a peanut allergy.
And injecting oneself is NOT an issue - millions of people stick themselves with a needle multiple times a day… it’s not that big of deal.🙄
To eliminate all possibilities that he supposedly tried to stab her with a needle, instead he had them for Medical reasons not to harm
Diabetics don't have epipen. A diabetic has a low, it's called a glucicon injection. And its a resuce one. A type 1 diabetic needs to take insulin everytime they eat or drink. That cross was misleading. Hopefully the prosecution fixes that later1
Right Epi-pens are for severe allergic reaction AKA Anaphylaxis
I was around a guy once who was climbing on a rail on a small set of steps much like a little kid would. You could tell he was out of it. Medic responded and basically said watch this. He administered whatever diabetic medication that was needed and the guy came around within seconds. It was remarkable!
Yeah, I think that's what he meant. He just didn't think to look it up somewhere to get his facts straight. Not a good lawyer. Blaming the victim. smh.
My son is diabetic type 1 and he takes his epi pen everywhere with him
@@marionnewsom8687epipens have epinephrine in them. They won’t help with blood sugar. There are similar pens for diabetics called hypopens that have glucagon in it. So either your son is not actually carrying an epipen and it’s called something else, or he is carrying it for a reason other than diabetes.
This defense attorney is so badly behaved swiveling in his chair and making immature faces. Disgraceful!
The correction officer never said "Go" he said "Get it get it get it get the picture of the tag". The defense is infuriating....they attempt to blame every single witness on the stand. Wtf was that story about an archer? I bet he's used that story in more than half of his cases 😂
Worst defense attorney EVER!!🤦🏽♀️🤡🤣
Was she wearing her Jesus cross when she shot Mr Herring? She could have taken a picture of his tag and let the police track him down.
That defense attorney is a total SMOCK..
This is to hard to watch with a friggen ad every 60 seconds.
I never, ever see ads on RUclips. Your browser will have a FREE adblocker for you use - use it and you'll be bothered no more.
How are the defense questions to the first male witness at all helpful to defendant??
She’s wearing Jesus on her. All for show. She’s going to be found guilty.
There's plenty of Christians on prison. "prison ministries" is an actual thing.. for her, faith is not a shield. It's a sword.
This case is new to me. Watching this opening by defense is not helping. 😂 He is all over the place. He just needs to tell the story about what happened
The argument from the defense, around 3:18, completely throws out her defense that she thought he was drunk. 🙄
Lock her up and throw away the keys
That defense attorney is the worst i have ever seen. Telling the jury to consider evidence that is not there whats next is he going to tell them about jury nullification? As for him referring to the defendant as young well it shows he has a sense of humor.
GROUNDS!!😂😂
Exactly! WTF does her being "young" have to do with anything? If you're old enough to own a gun, you're old enough to use it responsibly! You can't use it to intimidate and ultimately murder a confused man who left the scene of an accident!
@@QueenOfEverything69do you know who the plaintiff is in this matter? 😂😂😂
@@QueenOfEverything69😅😅😅NOOOOOO!!! I have been trying to get that out of my mind! 😂😂😂
All judges should be required to have that accent
If she just minded her own business...
21 years old no way i thought she was in her 30's
Listening to her attorney, makes me think of the episode of Andy Griffith, where Gomer tries to arrest Barney. He's yelling, with that southern drawl, Citizens arrest citizens arrest! Google it, it's funny
The only thing the defence attorney has going for him is that he still has a full head of hair.
This defense attorney is from the bottom of the barrel…telling the jury to consider evidence that’s not there 🤦🏾♀️
She picked the right attorney 0:02
lol Hannah looks like a thumb
Lol😂
Excellent opening by prosecutor.
Yes!!! She’s excellent! She made me want to watch it.
It’s like a case study of opposites compared to the defense. What was that archery story??
I really really like Judge Scott. One of the reasons isn't really relevant but her voice is so pleasant to listen to.
This judge is so elegant and eloquent. I love her.
this is what happens when a Karen has a gun.
I’ve met Hannah Payne a few times in the past. Didn’t even know she was ever arrested, so I did a MASSIVE double take when I saw her face and name in this trial. This was really surprising to me because she always seemed very reserved, but I didn’t know her that well. All things considered, seems like she’s probably guilty.
She obviously has an alter ego.
Did you meet her after or before the murder? I'm just curious. I always wonder what the people around these kinds of people know and think. This is just so crazy.
@@candiig8371 Before. Probably 2017ish.
I may be able to understand citizens arrest if you witness a violent crime and have ability to hold Perp there until LE arrives. This was not that. She got this enraged over a traffic accident with no injuries? She chased him down and was angry so she shot him. This is not justified its lunacy.
He lost the case the minute he told that lame illustration. Good grief!
EPI pens are for allergic reactions not insulin adminstration
An Epipen is for correcting an allergic reaction not anything for Insulin
The judge is so soft spoken and sweet.
This defense attorney sounds like a cross between Kevin Spacey in Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil and Saul Goodman with a head cold.
That dude is a lawyer? I bought a car from him in 1977…
I just mentioned this in a different trial - I watched a trial where attys argued about recollection. The witness, a friend of the defendant, said something different to a question asked previously. (Real answer was not good for the defense) She gave the witness the transcript of that hearing to “refresh his recollection”. He read it & said the transcript shows he said it, but he doesn’t remember saying it. Defense then argued that statement/question/info was NOT ALLOWED to be said in front of the jury because, despite having the transcript, his MEMORY was NOT refresh… it was simply reading off a paper. 🤷♀️Very interesting move from the defense..🤓
Defense is literally a worse lawyer than my cousin Vinny lol. That bow and arrow story made little to 0 sense. Neighbor still hit the tree sir. Aim was still good. Your client is guilty clown
I was so lost! Waiting for some revelation that never came
I love Judge Scott, she’s so classy 🥰
Very effective cross examination. Not sure if the people commenting here sre actually watching the trial.
Whats her defense?? Stand your ground? Wait chasing a car which was none of her business...! If a man didnt die this would be laughable. Lock her up for life without parole!! Entitled little B
True. If all she did was chase him down and get the plate number, it would have been an ok-ish day for everyone. She shoots him? Wth?
Manipulation from the defensive side is just plain sad
Prosecutor and defendant look like their Sisters
Hannah look like she could care less
Hannah’s attorney isn’t doing her any favors. It’s like he’s grasping at wild straws right from the start and it’s making him come off as a bit slimy.
I seriously hope she didn't pay for this lawyer. 😂
Wow hes really saying his work tools are dangerous weapons....smh!
Wow, usually judges stop the speaking objections. At 1:35:40the prosecutor makes an objection with a very long statement and the defense responds with another long response.
Lol is that the only relevant metric determining whether an objection was done properly or not in your mind? "Wow you hear all them words?"