Battlefied S2/E3 - The Battle for Russia

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 3 дек 2024

Комментарии • 3,2 тыс.

  • @edydon
    @edydon 7 лет назад +954

    A few moments of respect for the narrator - Tim Pigot-Smith. A fine Shakespearean and voice artist. RIP

    • @VincitOmniaVeritas.
      @VincitOmniaVeritas. 5 лет назад +16

      edydon RIP 💐

    • @gingerli5820
      @gingerli5820 5 лет назад +10

      There has been at least one other narrator in this series - Bob Sessions who I thought was better.

    • @2serveand2protect
      @2serveand2protect 5 лет назад +16

      A fine point. It's a VERY well done & narated series.

    • @stephenmacdonald76
      @stephenmacdonald76 5 лет назад +29

      Tim Piggot Smith done a fantastic job on this and really got me into ww2 history

    • @MB-fo2sk
      @MB-fo2sk 5 лет назад +12

      @@gingerli5820 The only other narrator for the WW2 series was Jonathan Booth, who was all right but not nearly as good as Tim Piggot-Smith in my opinion. The narrator for the Vietnam war series was Gavin MacFadyen (an American) who was excellent as well.

  • @TheDeJureTour
    @TheDeJureTour 6 лет назад +303

    Now this is a REAL documentary. 1994, wow. They don't make them like this anymore.

    • @milanstojadinovic7916
      @milanstojadinovic7916 6 лет назад

      ruclips.net/video/JhXKlYnSWjA/видео.html

    • @hellaacapella
      @hellaacapella 5 лет назад +3

      Agreed!

    • @ludaheracles7201
      @ludaheracles7201 4 года назад +3

      Congrats to Luga for making such a fantastic series 👏

    • @impaugjuldivmax
      @impaugjuldivmax 3 года назад

      visit epic history channel

    • @sam8404
      @sam8404 2 года назад +7

      @@ludaheracles7201 he didn't make it, he only uploaded it.

  • @Crazeyfor67
    @Crazeyfor67 7 лет назад +306

    The narrator is one of the best ever. Thank you sir.

    • @martintapia9374
      @martintapia9374 4 года назад +5

      I fully agree, a Superb narrator with a gifted voice

    • @CocoTaveras8975
      @CocoTaveras8975 4 года назад +1

      marTin Tapia I concur as well! Makes this documentary all the more captivating and interesting.

    • @Jimmybarth
      @Jimmybarth 4 года назад +2

      Yeah apparently his name is vasily, probably a ruski

    • @Dan-ih3dm
      @Dan-ih3dm 4 года назад

      Blame the weather always underestimating the the Russian tenacity.

    • @ludaheracles7201
      @ludaheracles7201 3 года назад +1

      @@Jimmybarth Bet you wish you was a Russian boy..

  • @SuperCragster
    @SuperCragster 11 лет назад +329

    I could watch this series of documentaries all day

  • @dfsengineer
    @dfsengineer 2 года назад +207

    What I really love about BATTLEFIELD is that they usually start with the clock wound back a year or so from the real topic of the episode so they can explain in depth all the background to the events for better understanding of them. Don't find many other history series that do that.

    • @juanfervalencia
      @juanfervalencia 2 года назад +7

      it is unique

    • @klown839
      @klown839 2 года назад +6

      I take notes on Battlefield. It’s brilliant.

    • @aliasunknown7476
      @aliasunknown7476 Год назад +1

      your mom goes to college

    • @NatoHoro
      @NatoHoro Год назад

      ​@@aliasunknown7476The f? Hsushsushssh

    • @jankutac9753
      @jankutac9753 Год назад +4

      I always used to wonder: why was Hitler so stupid to attack Stalin, who actually wanted to be friends and even join the axis.
      But now I understand.
      1. The dependence on Soviet resources
      2. Their proximity to the Baltic and the Ploiesti oil fields.
      3. The fear they would ally with Britain
      4. The realization that whenever Germany made a move, the Ussr Would always exploit it and also take some territory - but WITHOUT repercussions from the west.
      I think Hitler saw Stalin as the treacherous, smiling, bearded guy who could never be trusted, and he was afraid to let this guy exist behind his back

  • @RichardSaurus
    @RichardSaurus 6 лет назад +194

    I remember getting goosebumps when the opening theme music would start. Best-ever WW2 series. PBS was da shizznit back in the 90s

    • @georgedoolittle7574
      @georgedoolittle7574 5 лет назад +1

      This hints at the weakness in the plan actually...that some "time line" exists in War. Yes time would matter. "Time and again the Germans would close their pincers before the Russians could prevent from being encircled..

    • @georgewing5514
      @georgewing5514 4 года назад +2

      I like you. ⚡⚡

    • @pauliegualtieri4314
      @pauliegualtieri4314 4 года назад +7

      "Best ever WW2 series"
      The World At War: "Hold my stein"

    • @theinformationbomber7102
      @theinformationbomber7102 3 года назад +1

      I still get it now

    • @craigbeatty8565
      @craigbeatty8565 3 года назад +3

      Watch “Soviet Storm,” THAT defines a documentary series.

  • @UltraGaivalas
    @UltraGaivalas 5 лет назад +109

    that's what all documentaries should be - a continuous stream of relevant footage and a single narrator. I despise all documentaries that have their footage and narration constantly interrupted by a bunch of pretentious self-important professors and experts

    • @davidweston9115
      @davidweston9115 3 года назад +6

      YES! Instead of a camera following someone walking in the forest where a soldier might have dropped a bullet 80 years ago. With the camera focusing on the back of the guys head following like a dog. Brilliant. I don't watch that modern crap, won't pay for it, and won't watch it for free in hotels.

    • @rolandacevans
      @rolandacevans 3 года назад +1

      Hear hear

    • @Mr.Bassman
      @Mr.Bassman 2 года назад +1

      100% agreed, well put sir

    • @c.w.miller3024
      @c.w.miller3024 2 года назад +1

      Amen.

    • @realitymatters8720
      @realitymatters8720 Год назад

      So, you think their selfimportance is more important then the knowledge they can give you...
      Are you sure its not because you dont understand what they are saying ?
      Making a statement like you just did, indicate a complete dumbass !

  • @evellish184
    @evellish184 6 лет назад +77

    this show is timeless, been watching since I was a young boy.

    • @maxhalsted5381
      @maxhalsted5381 Год назад +1

      Myself included

    • @jakobquick6875
      @jakobquick6875 10 месяцев назад +1

      As a kid, I was forced to watch these with dad and used to hate it. Than I got older😅now black and white footage is my staple breakfast and dessert😂 dad used to say same thing to his pops when he was a kid I’m told…funny, brutal times back then, but nothing makes up for the better greater kid times of anything is possible with a snap or wave of your imagination, before work/job/grind made them possible but u have to buckle up, it’s gonna be a bumpy ride😂that’s life😊

    • @OwneyMadden430
      @OwneyMadden430 5 месяцев назад

      Yes sir, I agree this documentary series of a better time in my life . The early 1990s

    • @OwneyMadden430
      @OwneyMadden430 5 месяцев назад

      Yes sir, I agree this documentary series of a better time in my life . The early 1990s

    • @debar1944
      @debar1944 4 месяца назад

      Unreal doc, these were on discovery channel whe we were young😊

  • @stevebarber8501
    @stevebarber8501 Год назад +6

    I have watched many documentaries on WWII and this one is far superior in its clear delivery of information. The visuals and clarity of narration and showing of troop movements and maps etc... Give a strong overall sense of the reality of what went down .

  • @lloydliveryservices
    @lloydliveryservices 4 года назад +50

    His English speaking is so clearly make people feel in love with his documentary, myself I don't remember how many times I had watch it ,sometimes I just listened to it to help me fall in sleep.

    • @crazylee83wrestling
      @crazylee83wrestling 3 года назад +1

      That sir is known as King's/Queen's English. Much better sounding than the cockney's in London.

    • @annehersey9895
      @annehersey9895 2 года назад +5

      Flame, so nice to know I'm not the only one who often uses this series as a sleep aid! The melliferous timbre of his voice is very soothing-even when talking war!

    • @jimyoung9262
      @jimyoung9262 2 года назад +1

      Same here.

    • @TruthNTime
      @TruthNTime 2 года назад +1

      I often wondered if I was the only one who used this series to fall asleep to.

  • @neal.karn-jones
    @neal.karn-jones 2 года назад +14

    I've seen every episode in this series many times. It's the best series on WWII, imo.

  • @User-gn6qz
    @User-gn6qz 6 лет назад +31

    Anyone else watch this series more than once or twice and also anytime in 2018?

    • @onionmilk5855
      @onionmilk5855 3 года назад

      Yes I’m in 2018

    • @obsidiandwarf
      @obsidiandwarf 3 года назад

      I'm watching in2021, if its any use to you. ( As an aside, I was just thinking how this reminds me of my childhood. No, Not the actual war, but watching a programme called 'All Our Yesterdays' on the tv. I'd have been about seven then. Sunday afternoon dinner and All our Yesterdays. I wonder if thats on you tube... hang on... nope. Can't find it. Shame.)

    • @OwneyMadden430
      @OwneyMadden430 5 месяцев назад

      Yes many times over the years it’s the best !! Yes sir, I agree this documentary series of a better time in my life . The early 1990s

    • @CameronJones-n5h
      @CameronJones-n5h 5 дней назад

      Daily for years now. Seen every one of the European and Russian campaign ones over 100 times

  • @danielh3179
    @danielh3179 5 лет назад +109

    The narration at 1:51:23 is very well written and delivered by Tim Pigot-Smith: "On Dec. 1st in the center, the German 4th army had launched a final massive effort to smash what defenses remained in front of Moscow. Everything depended on the Russians having no reserves. However, for weeks Zhukov had been denied reinforcements as Stalin had held back increasingly powerful reserve formations, including the bulk of the Siberian divisions and their armor. The strength of the defenders was now up to over half a million. On Dec. 5th, Zhukov launched the reserves in a massive counter-attack. The Russian offensive was launched along a front 600 miles long. To the Germans, whose own offensive was being carried on with the last ounce of their strength, it came as a hideous shock. Along the entire length of the line, German armies were shattered into thousands of isolated units, fighting desperately for survival. The Battle of Moscow was lost and with it the Wehrmacht had lost the Battle for Russia."

    • @kpss6711
      @kpss6711 4 года назад

      @xellossaxon AHAHAHAHAHAHAHA YOU ARE SO FUNNY

    • @Mentol_
      @Mentol_ 4 года назад +5

      "The Red Army was the worst army in history" - so you want to say that the worst army for no reason defeated the army that was the best? I do not see much logic here.
      "Literally every single defensive and offensive tactics of the Red Army was based on mindlessly killing its own soldiers' - can you quote any soviet order that ignores the value of life of a soviet soldier?

    • @HowardHalifax
      @HowardHalifax 3 года назад +2

      @@Mentol_ Order No.227
      Over to you 🤣

    • @Mentol_
      @Mentol_ 3 года назад

      @@HowardHalifax Can you quote a passage from Order 227 that ignores the value of soldiers' lives?

    • @HowardHalifax
      @HowardHalifax 3 года назад

      @@Mentol_ Figured you wouldn't concede defeat there lol. As it's written in Russian I shall have to have it translated, but it does direct that each army must create "blocking detachments" at the rear that would shoot "panic-mongers and cowards". It also decreed that soldiers in penal battalions were to be sent to the most dangerous sections of the front lines.
      Wanna concede? Or are you going to keep asking for quotes? 🤣

  • @obergruppenfuhrersang-froi8203
    @obergruppenfuhrersang-froi8203 4 года назад +30

    Absolutely love these documentaries. I play them every night to go to sleep, for four years now.

    • @Woodman1a-f5i
      @Woodman1a-f5i 4 года назад +3

      Thought I was the only one that did that .

    • @annehersey9895
      @annehersey9895 2 года назад +3

      Great voice to lull one to sleep for sure!

    • @josephnavin4451
      @josephnavin4451 7 месяцев назад +1

      I do too. Then I have dreams about maps and shapes.

    • @jacobjorgenson9285
      @jacobjorgenson9285 5 месяцев назад

      War on your brain 🤷‍♂️

    • @dagalfheim7056
      @dagalfheim7056 5 месяцев назад

      It’s the music, the voice, the stories…season 1 & 2 just magical

  • @josephbertrand5558
    @josephbertrand5558 4 года назад +69

    I've watched this a hundred times or more

  • @joshuacarrasquillo9785
    @joshuacarrasquillo9785 8 лет назад +59

    As a WW2 enthusiast and an Army Infantry Veteran I truly appreciate what you have put together here. Great work!!!

  • @joshgoldbullion
    @joshgoldbullion 11 лет назад +10

    thank you so much to the uploader vasile luga these videos have kept me entertained for a while i used to watch this series many years ago on tv and thought it was one of the best ww2 docs im happy to find them here on youtube great job :) !

  • @Psychonautslog
    @Psychonautslog 8 лет назад +149

    'In Russia I encountered the fifth element - mud.' Napoleon Bonaparte

  • @caesar4857
    @caesar4857 6 лет назад +139

    WHy can't more documentaries be like this? Not one sided (as far as i could tell) and just giving information on what happened.

    • @TheHelghast1138
      @TheHelghast1138 5 лет назад +26

      Ah yes, the golden age of documentaries... before swamp people and ancient aliens. Those were good days indeed.

    • @crazylee83wrestling
      @crazylee83wrestling 3 года назад +7

      Now everyone just wants to make $$$$ off of overly-sensationalized crap.

    • @stevensteelforce2701
      @stevensteelforce2701 3 года назад

      it really doesn't matter any more....Russia lost many people but at the end they got a hold of a piece Real Estate used to be called Germany.

    • @rascallyrabbit8548
      @rascallyrabbit8548 2 года назад

      @@TheHelghast1138 v8

    • @ronalddesiderio7625
      @ronalddesiderio7625 Год назад

      Amen 👍🏾

  • @legionofthedamned157
    @legionofthedamned157 6 лет назад +50

    "Only the dead have truly seen the end of war "

  • @whynot-tomorrow_1945
    @whynot-tomorrow_1945 9 лет назад +238

    reading through these comments, try and spot the people who blatantly did not watch the documentary and just want to argue on the internet...

  • @RealPerson1000
    @RealPerson1000 7 лет назад +217

    The eastern front is on a lvl of its own. No other war comes close to the scale of the ost front.

    • @steveniavarone3683
      @steveniavarone3683 6 лет назад +43

      Very true. Sadly most Americans are ignorant of the Ost Front.

    • @Yora21
      @Yora21 6 лет назад +25

      Second Sino-Japanese War of 1935 to 1945.
      Recapture of France helped, but was a minor part in a much bigger picture. The real contribution the Americans made to defeating Germany was supplying the British and the Russians with ridiculous amounts of material. The Soviets provided the soldiers, the Americans the resources.

    • @steveniavarone3683
      @steveniavarone3683 6 лет назад +10

      Yora you are right. Not enough info about the 2nd Sino-Japanese War is shown thru the regular media. Many people don't know about this.

    • @emmanuelzepernick7209
      @emmanuelzepernick7209 6 лет назад +1

      Real person: I agree.

    • @calripson
      @calripson 6 лет назад +12

      Actually, over 90% of Soviet war production was domestically produced. There were a few key imports such as toluene.

  • @whynot-tomorrow_1945
    @whynot-tomorrow_1945 9 лет назад +505

    god I love this documentary series!
    it's so comprehensive : )

    • @whynot-tomorrow_1945
      @whynot-tomorrow_1945 9 лет назад +14

      and omg thank you for not talking about Stalingrad!
      If I had a dollar, man...

    • @Mokimanify
      @Mokimanify 9 лет назад +6

      +whynot-tomorrow? But very old and lacks much of the history learned in the past 20 years since the Soviets opened their archives.

    • @ΜΙΧΑΛΗΣΣΚΕΥΗΣ
      @ΜΙΧΑΛΗΣΣΚΕΥΗΣ 8 лет назад +10

      +whynot-tomorrow? STALINGRAD was another episode from the 1st season ,1st season has 6 ep and there are the most important battles according to the producer's point of view, i have to admit that he made a good choice for top-6 ( 1-battle of france ,2- battle of britain ,3- midway, 4-stalingrad, 5- normandy, 6- battle of berlin ....a rather good choice ,each episode from a very important phase of the ww2)

    • @thetomshowpt3vs.whatdumbst436
      @thetomshowpt3vs.whatdumbst436 8 лет назад +8

      I watch this over and over myself as i used to watch it as a kid.
      I know it's a bit dated and don't care. They paint a very detail picture with the info they had at production. So saying its dated and missing things isn't exactly correct.

    • @Mokimanify
      @Mokimanify 8 лет назад +3

      It is good, but since it was released much of the factual info has changed due to research..

  • @jefferytodd7017
    @jefferytodd7017 6 лет назад +5

    One of the best documentary series on WWII that I have ever seen !!!

  • @martinavaslovik3433
    @martinavaslovik3433 7 лет назад +6

    A really excellent and most educational documentary providing rich detail of the times, the conflict, leaders and forces involved.

  • @jrizzuti
    @jrizzuti 7 лет назад +51

    in my opinion best ww2 documentary series

    • @Bklyn988
      @Bklyn988 5 лет назад +3

      Its debatable, this and a documentary series called ww2 the complete history which is a 13 part series that came out in 2000 are the best in my opinion.

    • @generalposlijebitke6688
      @generalposlijebitke6688 4 года назад

      ruclips.net/channel/UCP1AejCL4DA7jYkZAELRhHQ

    • @ludaheracles7201
      @ludaheracles7201 3 года назад +2

      Yeh Vasile is a genius for sure, boy. 🇺🇸

  • @bxs0099
    @bxs0099 11 лет назад +15

    I love that this series isn't an Industrial Light & Magic CGI wet-dream.

  • @pb9548
    @pb9548 4 года назад +3

    This is such a great explanation of the battle! Thank you for posting.

  • @abouttocum
    @abouttocum 6 лет назад +15

    god I love this documentary series!
    it's so comprehensibleive

  • @cataphract8508
    @cataphract8508 3 года назад +5

    All of these wwll documentaries heavily remind me of my Grandad and my GreatGrandad , they were both full-time professional Army officers in the Greek Royal Army. Miss you guys❗

  • @berge7f91
    @berge7f91 Год назад +4

    Phase 1 1:07:47
    Phase 2 1:22:52
    Phase 3 1:29:25
    Phase 4 1:35:04
    Phase 5 1:43:00
    The Battle Won 1:49:39
    After the Battle 1:53:02

  • @Bluesit32
    @Bluesit32 6 лет назад +27

    Quite interesting! I never realized how screw Germany really was. Everything really did hinge on the Eastern Front. They needed fuel and oil and the Soviet Union was the best source.

    • @herptek
      @herptek 2 года назад +2

      Germany was from the get-go in between a rock and a hard place, just as it had been in the first world war. Then, however, Russia collapsed. It could conceivably have happened again.

  • @CameronJones-n5h
    @CameronJones-n5h 5 дней назад

    Never seen so many comments on how they love this series and praise it in every way. My personal favorite... The Narrator for sure. I've seen no less then 500 WWII documentaries and certain ones of those multiple times. None come close to this one. By far. I love how much others feel the same as i do about these MASTERPIECES. It brings comfort to me now more than anything. Never have i felt this was about any show, movie or documentary. Thank you to the ones responsible for bringing it to us all.

  • @meegz149
    @meegz149 6 лет назад +12

    I love this documentary! I became enamored with the Eastern Front since watching this back in the mid 90s on PBS

  • @robertkrause4861
    @robertkrause4861 6 лет назад +81

    By the time the allies landed on the Normandy beaches the Red Army had already torn the guts out of the Wehrmacht.

    • @markharrison2544
      @markharrison2544 6 лет назад +10

      The Allies had already defeated the Axis in North Africa.

    • @ИванИванов-х3е2ж
      @ИванИванов-х3е2ж 5 лет назад +4

      @@memento5113 this all looks like an 10-20% component of success. We all see what allies do without USSR. 6-week-France showed us a patetic show.
      Japan remembered what was in 1935-1939 on a border (lake Хасан and Халкин-Гол) and did not risk again.
      Allies saved 2-3 mln of soviet people, but they didn't win war.

    • @cska2001
      @cska2001 5 лет назад +16

      @@markharrison2544 You compare apples and berries! Just in one battle - the bloody Stalingrad battle - the Soviet Army lost more of it's soldiers and officers than the US and the Britain lost in the WHOLE WWII -COMBINED!

    • @cska2001
      @cska2001 5 лет назад +11

      @@memento5113 You are damn wrong: an ignorant and dumb MTF is you! 99% of americans truthfully believe that it was Tom Hanks who saved Private Ryan and together they beat Hitler! You are one of those idiots! Who never heard about Stalingrad and Kursk, Leningrad blockade and operation "Bagration", Mamayev kurgan and Sapun Gora, Zeelov's Hightes and Berlin operation. I can easily beat every you stupid and primitive thesis about "The only reason Soviet survived are the reasons listed below:", but don't want to waste my time. It was all too well known among the serious Western historians that it was the Soviet Army that crashed Hitler's Nazi Europe.

    • @lewistaylor2858
      @lewistaylor2858 4 года назад +16

      @@markharrison2544 yep there were 3 German divisions in North Africa for most of the fighting their, the max was 7, meanwhile 190 divisions were fighting in the Soviet Union. The African theatre had pretty much no bearing on the outcome of the war.

  • @loft-elevatinggolf4170
    @loft-elevatinggolf4170 6 лет назад +12

    very well done. the entire series is timeless. I actually prefer the old production value. Thank u Vasile - i wished you lived to see Montana~~!

  • @alphabeast8700
    @alphabeast8700 5 лет назад +29

    God Bless and Rest in Peace, Tim Pigot-Smith, a Great Narrator, and Man.

    • @TheHelghast1138
      @TheHelghast1138 5 лет назад +1

      A month moment of silence for a great man

  • @ryancase8858
    @ryancase8858 7 лет назад +9

    This is the most comprehensive and unbiased WW2 documentary series ever made...

  • @MrFight6666
    @MrFight6666 8 лет назад +44

    75 years since operation babarossa! Wow, the years go by so fast...

    • @benenemy
      @benenemy 8 лет назад +12

      man that was a hot summer.

    • @lianhector9546
      @lianhector9546 8 лет назад +2

      🙃
      WAAAAAIIT YOU JUST COMMENTED 20 minutes ago.............
      What a coincidence I mean REALLY

    • @TheArkan6
      @TheArkan6 4 года назад +2

      how did u write this 3 years ago and said 75 years its only going to be 75 years since its end this year in 2020 in may u some kinda future past comment? this is too next level I AM OUT BREH

    • @4FYTfa8EjYHNXjChe8xs7xmC5pNEtz
      @4FYTfa8EjYHNXjChe8xs7xmC5pNEtz 3 года назад

      It seems like only yesterday!

    • @MrFight6666
      @MrFight6666 3 года назад

      @@4FYTfa8EjYHNXjChe8xs7xmC5pNEtz For some I guess it did

  • @Syria120
    @Syria120 Год назад +4

    Man it’s so sad to see that we don’t get to see these type of documentaries anymore

  • @nicholasjohnable
    @nicholasjohnable 6 лет назад +14

    This series of Operation Barbarossa is the most comprehensive and captivating account of the invasion. Presented in great detail and with expert narration. Very informative and entertaining.

    • @craigdylan3953
      @craigdylan3953 Год назад

      Entertaining? What planet were you raised on?

    • @anonaki-mt6xb
      @anonaki-mt6xb Год назад

      Earth, planet of the Apes.@@craigdylan3953

  • @robertjelinski5113
    @robertjelinski5113 11 месяцев назад +2

    Outstanding, bravo!! excellent documentary by an outstanding narrator…Thank you so much.

  • @whatsgood8426
    @whatsgood8426 10 лет назад +55

    At 17:50
    Hitler: "you have only to kick in the door and the whole rotten structure will come crashing down"
    That's right Hitler, you kicked in Russia's door and your whole rotten structure came crashing down.

    • @ThePhantomStarfish
      @ThePhantomStarfish 5 лет назад +3

      @@mehdibouzid4392 Bitch who won the war?

    • @hissyhonker220
      @hissyhonker220 5 лет назад +3

      @@ThePhantomStarfish the banks and the government.... Helloooo patriot act!!! Yay!!!

    • @busTedOaS
      @busTedOaS 5 лет назад +3

      you could argue that Moscow is that "door", and they never managed to kick that in, so...

    • @azazelzel6954
      @azazelzel6954 5 лет назад +9

      @@ThePhantomStarfish USA Production won the war.

    • @Ickie71
      @Ickie71 5 лет назад +2

      @@azazelzel6954 Your ALL WRONG!,Allied Cohesion and working together on a Broad Front actually won this War.You cant just say US producion did it by itself,thats just nonsense and you know it really.

  • @andrewdoolittle5336
    @andrewdoolittle5336 8 лет назад +11

    the scope and scale of the Barbarossa Campaign was a complete shock to everybody. All of Europe including Russia expected an invasion of Southern Russia but no one anticipated an outright total invasion of the entire land mass...including the Russians.

    • @Bradgilliswhammyman
      @Bradgilliswhammyman 7 лет назад +1

      Only way to fully invade a nation and win today would be to use tactical nuclear weapons first to destroy the military completely and the industrial production of city targets.

  • @nwolinsP
    @nwolinsP 6 лет назад +35

    Wow, Costco being out of coffee filter does not seem like the big of a deal after watching this.

    • @TheHelghast1138
      @TheHelghast1138 5 лет назад +7

      No shit. I wish my fucking brother in law understood that. You'd think a wall of stukas was coming ahead of 4th panzer!
      Love your comment. It is eloquent in its brevity about the problems with modern society.

    • @teddmented
      @teddmented 5 лет назад

      👌

    • @trevorplows7494
      @trevorplows7494 4 года назад +1

      Everything trump touches, hey shite for brains , we are watching a documentary of an event that happened 79 years ago . Somewhat before Trump was born . Sooo take your political commie / democrat message and shove both that and your head up your backside. In your case the world would be a better place.

    • @ebannaw
      @ebannaw 4 года назад +1

      @@trevorplows7494 Conman in chief is ded.

    • @josephayers7395
      @josephayers7395 3 года назад +1

      @@ebannaw Yeah and now we have dimentia moron in chief

  • @jdsol1938
    @jdsol1938 9 лет назад +28

    it doesn't matter if you win battles , if you lose the war

    • @andreasfoerster772
      @andreasfoerster772 9 лет назад +6

      +jdsol1938 Thank you! Finally somebody says it! You sir, or ma'am, understand military strategy: battles are one aspects amongst dozens in a grand strategy for victory in a war or campaign. Morale, economics, logistics, politics, psychology, etc. are all important factors that decide the fate of conflict besides simply the outcome of particular engagements.

    • @paullindley9
      @paullindley9 8 лет назад +1

      like Hannibal himself

    • @CocoTaveras8975
      @CocoTaveras8975 4 года назад +1

      @@paullindley9 Yup or Napoleon.

  • @boy18inva
    @boy18inva 10 лет назад +162

    My grandfather told me that he remembered when he was a boy how the Catholic priest in his church was ecstatic at the news of Hitler's invasion of the Soviet Union. All during the summer and fall of 1941 this priest openly cheered on the Nazis against the Russians as if he was supporting his favorite team in the Super Bowl. He says the other clergy and even the bishop had this same attitude. They welcomed Hitler's crusade to wipe out the Communist atheists.
    What I am curious to know is how prevalent this attitude was in the Church, prior to America's entry in the war December 1941. Did the Catholic Church strongly support the war on the Soviet Union? If it is true, than it's certainly something you don't read in the history books.

    • @DrJones20
      @DrJones20 10 лет назад +10

      Very interesting.

    • @subscriber77
      @subscriber77 9 лет назад +20

      Virginia, you've raised a very interesting issue indeed, and sadly, one that is hardly ever addressed. As most of us, including agnostics like myself, would acknowledge, Christian religion has played a positive role up to a certain point in history. But like most well-meaning institutions, it lost its way and was gradually usurped by individuals who had little regard for its (alleged) founder's basic teachings. Consequently, over time, the Church was degraded to the point where it simply became a tool used to promote personal objectives. The Catholic Church, in particular, played an infamus role in enabling Nazi war criminals to escape justice. The reason given by this Church was the principle of Christian forgiveness. But I'm convinced that the reason for allowing all those mass murderers to escape justice and continue to pollute the world with their toxic ideology of hate was far less noble.

    • @TheWoodstock2009
      @TheWoodstock2009 9 лет назад +1

      Doy Virginia The catholic church after the war also excommunicated all who partecipate in communist organizations

    • @christopherbarnett7265
      @christopherbarnett7265 9 лет назад +13

      Doy Virginia the vatican hsd its own plan east which it conceived with the ustasé in croatia. they held 137 meetings in which the mass murder of serbs, jews, gypsies were fully known & demanded from pope pius, pius also wanted to spread catholicism in the east against the orthodox, heydrich refused the vatican that possibility - the hitory is not widely known but is discussed in detail in cornwell's, 'hitler's pope'

    • @zenoist2
      @zenoist2 9 лет назад +7

      Doy Virginia Stalin was a total enemy of ANY religion.
      There could only be one religion and it was what Stalin ordered.
      In early years in Russia he had preists bishops etc rounded up and shot or sent to Gulag , church goods confiscated for the state, taken by force, etc.
      Basically he wanted to rob every single organisation of any possibly critical voice and the Russian church was a very obvious target.
      I'm glad Russia has shaken off the awful "communism" they have endured for so long.

  • @kirbycraft9325
    @kirbycraft9325 2 года назад +3

    Great series. VERY THOROUGH, AND INFORMATIVE.

  • @damienmensinger1439
    @damienmensinger1439 3 года назад +5

    Battle of Midway is my favorite outta all of these classic episodes.

  • @enkisonofanu2301
    @enkisonofanu2301 6 лет назад +9

    I do not normally watch a 2 hrs video on youtube, but this was too interesting to forgo.

    • @CameronJones-n5h
      @CameronJones-n5h 5 дней назад

      Because of these i look for 2hr documentaries on wars

  • @aegontargaryen9322
    @aegontargaryen9322 10 месяцев назад +1

    This battlefield series is one of the best I’ve ever come across

  • @amb-yz9ee
    @amb-yz9ee Год назад +3

    I never get tired of learning about this. Just so fascinating.

  • @minderoded2383
    @minderoded2383 11 лет назад +3

    this is a great series. Solid narration over archival footage, the way it should always be done.

  • @kingkandy
    @kingkandy 11 месяцев назад +1

    This series is great in that it gives a detailed breakdown of key battles and offensives of World War II. The political context we know well, but the military aspects are rarely covered so thoroughly, which makes this series special.

  • @memento5113
    @memento5113 3 года назад +4

    My grandmas father and brother faught in the Finnish war. Thats how my grandmother came to Sweden as a refugee at 1 years old and lived here since. I never met the rest of my grandmas finish family but i'm proud of them.

  • @kolense
    @kolense 10 лет назад +54

    is it me or does the english make the best documentaries? I used to watch this on pbs when I was in grammer school.

    • @anadryantontine
      @anadryantontine 10 лет назад +9

      do the* grammar*
      Apparently you weren't paying all that much attention in class..

    • @63Baggies
      @63Baggies 7 лет назад +4

      Yes, we do make the best television programs all-round let alone documentaries:-)

    • @joshuaburton154
      @joshuaburton154 7 лет назад +1

      who says grammer school anymore? are you 70 lol

    • @dickiesdocos
      @dickiesdocos 7 лет назад +2

      What do you call it? automatic spell check?

    • @user_____M
      @user_____M 7 лет назад

      Not perfect. The maps are weirdly drawn, showing Transcarpathia as part of the USSR before Barbarossa on every occasion.

  • @peteyspaletas2023
    @peteyspaletas2023 Год назад +2

    Very good presentation. I really enjoyed this. Well done!👍

  • @KamalShariff
    @KamalShariff 11 лет назад +11

    @SuperGragster Thought is was just me. These are truly the best documentaries. Military history and science from a geo-political view. The best!

    • @SuperCragster
      @SuperCragster 11 лет назад +4

      They are so informative and tell you the straight facts, which is what you want if you want to educate yourself on the military history of ww2.

  • @antistalinist4552
    @antistalinist4552 2 года назад +12

    As far as battles go, it doesn't or won't get any larger than this, with the exception of Armageddon.

  • @Namsomnia
    @Namsomnia 6 лет назад +2

    They dont come any better than this docu, thankyou..

  • @qwidium
    @qwidium 4 месяца назад +3

    1:35 "After Kiev the red army no longer outnumberred the germans" I presume is a false affirmation.

  • @mrichar9
    @mrichar9 6 лет назад +4

    Great series. Very thorough and well executed. Amazing footage.
    War is hell. Let's never repeat it.

  • @nwk-wt3ty
    @nwk-wt3ty Год назад +1

    These are the kind of documentaries that made me fall in love with history.

  • @johneamer
    @johneamer 8 лет назад +305

    I think it took a dictator like Stalin to defeat a dictator like Hitler. The west would have never tolerated the loses that the Soviets endured. Remember 80 percent of German soldiers killed in WW2 were killed by the Soviets but at a very heavy cost to themselves.

    • @daehelttaR
      @daehelttaR 8 лет назад +15

      that is true

    • @romeomatei5692
      @romeomatei5692 8 лет назад +23

      It was more like 90%, acording to Max Hastings in Inferno: The World At War.

    • @allahburpscum100
      @allahburpscum100 8 лет назад +58

      It was in spite of Stalin and not because of him the Soviets won.
      Stalin's stupid moves in the first years of the war allowed the surprise attack and lead to many massive defeats that brought the Germans deep into the USSR.
      Stalin stupidly trusted Hitler not to attack and his stupid orders to hold fast in different times, when it would have made much more sense to pull back, led to the most massive encirclements in military history, with losses of millions of men and massive quantities of equipment.

    • @geromino97
      @geromino97 8 лет назад +25

      Invisible Deity i think Georgy zhukov deserves most of the credit

    • @allahburpscum100
      @allahburpscum100 8 лет назад +41

      geromino97
      Perhaps. The one thing you can say in Stalin's credit is that he eventually learned to mostly shut is big, dumb, paranoid mouth and leave it to the generals.

  • @penduloustesticularis1202
    @penduloustesticularis1202 2 года назад +3

    Perfect narration.

  • @paulwilcock3787
    @paulwilcock3787 Год назад +3

    Great stuff, lots of factual detail, no pathetic moralising

  • @ronalddesiderio7625
    @ronalddesiderio7625 Год назад +4

    Just the facts .
    In a clear and concise manner ❤this series No hidden agendas. No wasted words. Education the way it was meant to be. Watch listen 👂 Learn👍🏾

  • @user-bs5qr5ie4s
    @user-bs5qr5ie4s 9 месяцев назад +3

    I love these documentaries

  • @BlackJackTU160
    @BlackJackTU160 10 лет назад +6

    My favorite among all documentaries. Superb quality in every aspect.

  • @gullybull5568
    @gullybull5568 4 года назад +5

    excellent footage.
    unbiased and lots to see.

  • @hdckdsadd
    @hdckdsadd 11 лет назад +6

    one of the best series ever

  • @indydude3367
    @indydude3367 5 лет назад +2

    Cheers to the research and writing staff.

  • @craigseamus4335
    @craigseamus4335 7 лет назад +4

    god I comprehend this documentary series!
    it's so loving :)

    • @georgewing5514
      @georgewing5514 4 года назад

      Yes you do! Yes you do, you wee Irish shrimp. Blessings from Nepal 🇳🇵 🙏

  • @rameezahmed3231
    @rameezahmed3231 3 года назад +3

    Never get bored watching this 👌

  • @scottbeals6000
    @scottbeals6000 3 года назад +2

    World at War and Battlefield WW2 Documentaries are the best ever made.

  • @antonienewman9379
    @antonienewman9379 5 лет назад +4

    The most extensive, comprehensive invasion attempt ever

  • @SNP-1999
    @SNP-1999 3 года назад +4

    It is a little known fact that, while about 80% of Germany's army fought on the Eastern Front, in July 1943 only 26% of the Luftwaffe"s total fighter strength was in the east supporting the troops. A further 19% were stationed in the south, in Italy, southern France, Sardinia etc., but a stunning total of 55% were in the west, facing the RAF and the increasing threat of the USAAF. And this was even before D-Day. In July 1943, the western Allies had just invaded Sicily, and in the east the major battle of Kursk was being fought by the Germans with insufficient air support, one of the main reasons for the German defeat during that battle. The growing threat of around the clock bombing by the RAF and USAAF was a major contribution to the defeat of the Wehrmacht on the Eastern Front, depriving the army of the air cover by the Luftwaffe that it desperately needed. Three quarters of all Luftwaffe aircraft lost in July 1943 were stationed on the Western Front, in the defence of the Reich, and in the South, fighting the British and Americans. Out of 491 operational night fighters in the Luftwaffe, only 30 were stationed on the Eastern Front. Practically all of the most modern weapons, from V1 and V2 rockets, the Me 262 and Me 163 jet and rocket planes, plus others such as gliding bombs, were exclusively used in the west, only ever in small number at the end of the war in the east. These statistics and facts show the great importance that the aiir forces of the western allies played in the defeat of Nazi Germany.

    • @Luka23567
      @Luka23567 3 года назад +1

      Spot on, and something nobody ever mentions.

  • @brcarter1111
    @brcarter1111 5 лет назад +4

    Damnit I can't stop watching these... WW2 was one of the most terrible times in human existence where life was cheap. It hurts me to realize that for the same human and financial cost of WW2, every human need could have been met on the planet for the next 200 years. At the same time, the desperation and the drama of the conflict make it incredible.

    • @indy_go_blue6048
      @indy_go_blue6048 3 года назад +1

      I just finished Stephen Ambrose's "D-Day." He makes a point in the last chapter that on average 27,000 people died each day for 6 years.

  • @yanlumotungoe2361
    @yanlumotungoe2361 Год назад +4

    The irony of it all is that Hitler studied Napoleon's Russian invasion, yet he made the same mistake of not equipping his troops with winter gear.

  • @gr8db8ter28
    @gr8db8ter28 8 лет назад +90

    Okay, So Hitler fears a war on 2 Fronts and knows Germany could NEVER beat an alliance of The UK, US and USSR. His answer....Invade USSR while UK fights on AND THEN (for shits and giggles) declare war on US (without plans) simply because Japan bombed Pearl Harbor (without telling him).
    Gotcha
    P.S....never blame my video games for violence again

    • @doolittlegeorge
      @doolittlegeorge 8 лет назад +2

      So once Japan bombs Pearl Harbor AND all the British Possessions in the East then the USA and Britain are "fighting on 2 fronts."
      The 3rd Reich was under no obligation to support Japan...but it did though not immediately.
      December 7th 1941 is when "World War 2" began in my view but certainly there was already a lot of War going on by then as this remarkable documentary shows.

    • @gr8db8ter28
      @gr8db8ter28 8 лет назад +3

      chris storrier Hitler wasn't bound to declare war on the U.S. If thats the case then why didn't Japan declare war on the whole of Europe AND THEN refuse to open a second front in the East, allowing Stalin to use his many Siberian Divisions to throw the Nazis back from Moscow??

    • @gr8db8ter28
      @gr8db8ter28 8 лет назад +3

      Its called the Tripartie Pact. It was signed Sept. 27,1940. NOT LATE IN THE WAR! It meant nothing because they had different strategic interests, thus Japan refusing to help when it "mattered".
      Try again.

    • @doolittlegeorge
      @doolittlegeorge 8 лет назад +1

      +Adolf Hitler not true. the Japanese attack did not obligate Germany in any way against the USA. it's not like Japan had declared on Russia with Germany under the gun.

    • @iroscoe
      @iroscoe 8 лет назад +3

      Really how would the RN have been sunk opposing an invasion force mainly comprising converted river barges escorted by a Kriegsmarine destroyer force it outnumbered by more than 10 to 1?.

  • @thetomshowpt3vs.whatdumbst436
    @thetomshowpt3vs.whatdumbst436 8 лет назад +2

    Awesome upload. Thank you!

  • @rohansharma3941
    @rohansharma3941 6 лет назад +7

    The best documentary I came across why Hitler actually invaded Russia. It explains really well the need and circumstances under which such a decision must have been taken.

    • @AlbertIsraeli
      @AlbertIsraeli 2 года назад

      Dharma, you understand the “need” of Nazis? Would be nice to see you and your entire family and friends among those, who had what hitler “needed”.

  • @florintimis258
    @florintimis258 6 лет назад +7

    Best documentary an objective
    A lesson of history

  • @mikepthekangaroo7596
    @mikepthekangaroo7596 9 месяцев назад +1

    I remember when I was growing up watching World at War and Victory at Sea. My weekly ritual was making sure I didn’t miss either one.

  • @romanza_28
    @romanza_28 7 лет назад +52

    Hitler believed that he attacked the Soviet Union, but actually he attacked a huge tank factory. 25 000 tanks per year...

    • @barryboxinggym
      @barryboxinggym 6 лет назад +4

      very well said. tank factory

    • @jiminylummox9352
      @jiminylummox9352 6 лет назад +5

      Yep that is true. Stalin was a paranoid bastard but he won that war by skillfully turning the Soviet Union into a tank factory.

    • @felipewerner6670
      @felipewerner6670 6 лет назад +2

      spamming tanks, that is why in civilization order will get all production bonus.

    • @Tramseskumbanan
      @Tramseskumbanan 6 лет назад +2

      Black Wood Yes, they had a huge capacity in tank and weapon factories.
      The problem was that they didn’t know how to use the tanks.

    • @jiminylummox9352
      @jiminylummox9352 6 лет назад +8

      Not at first, but they learnt. The 1945 Red Army were tank warfare experts.

  • @stanbrekston
    @stanbrekston 11 лет назад +8

    barbarossa was so massive, so violent, so intense, that it is no wonder that it inevitably devolved into the most gigantic battle of all time. it was a colossal war of annihilation. @ 1:16:20, pay particular attention to this very little known battle; most people know that the largest tank battle in history was at kursk. but very few know of the 2nd largest tank battle in history, & that is the battle of dubno & brody. it was a fascinating clash.

    • @bombarderoazul
      @bombarderoazul 11 лет назад +2

      The eastern front is not known very well in the west, yet that is where Germany was defeated.

    • @June28July
      @June28July 11 лет назад

      bombarderoazul
      That goes for world war 2 in general, actually.

    • @stanbrekston
      @stanbrekston 11 лет назад +3

      bombarderoazul well actually germany was defeated on several fronts. stalin kept begging & pleading for the Americans & british to open a 'second front', to take the pressure off of the eastern front, but what stalin didn't realize, was that the Americans had already opened up a second front; & that was the war in the pacific from early 1942 onwards. had the US not cleaned up the japanese in the pacific, who knows where that 'kwantung' army, over a million strong, would have ended up. they could have attacked cccp from the east, & the bombers that was used at pearl harbor, could have just as easily been used on those soviet factories hiding behind the urals that were churning out t-34's & ppsh machine guns. in addition, the US 'lend lease' program sent cccp over 4000 sherman tanks alone, 4000! that's more tanks than the germans went into, 'barbarossa'. in addition, the US sent cccp over 4 million tons of food & opened a daylight bombing campaign on german industry that reduced their number of tanks & machine guns. all in all, while the eastern front was vital to the final victory, it was by no means the only factor.

    • @ralphbernhard1757
      @ralphbernhard1757 11 лет назад

      stanbrekston In view of the massive aid to the USSR, I find it strange that the USSR did not allow US bombers to operate from Wladivostok and Kamchatka to bomb Japan in return. Some "partnership". If I had been the USA, I would have secured this as a prerequisite before the delivery of Lend Lease equipment and food.

    • @stanbrekston
      @stanbrekston 11 лет назад

      Ralph Bernhard excellent point, sir. even in the midst of a world war when the very existance of the ussr was in question, they displayed conduct that was a prerequisite of their behavior in the 'cold war', like detaining some of our pilots that had to crash land. also i read somewhere, (i think it was either in WW2 or WW2 history magazine), that a russian supply ship, just having left san francisco loaded with 'lend lease' goods from the US, was heading for vladivostock on december 6th 1941. this supply ship actually spotted the japanese task force in the northern pacific, that was about to attack pearl harbor, & they remained silent. maybe they feared that had they sent the US a warning of this force of japanese aircraft carriers arrayed to our northwest, that the japanese would have sunk them. maybe they were correct because that task force let them pass without incident.

  • @VinodVerma-ik7vg
    @VinodVerma-ik7vg Год назад +1

    Very good video Thankyou

  • @robt3078
    @robt3078 10 лет назад +3

    Battlefield = Best ww2 documentaries ever!

  • @sayermuhib1541
    @sayermuhib1541 6 лет назад +3

    best documentary ever!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @quebecforce111
    @quebecforce111 5 месяцев назад +1

    That was the best series of ww2 documentary. I never see better than that. I like Apocalipse to but Battlefield are the best of the best

  • @EvocatusX
    @EvocatusX 9 лет назад +137

    It came down to resources. The USSR simply outproduced and out mobilized The Reich.

    • @07lubo
      @07lubo 9 лет назад +23

      +SODMGx Not really. The thing that saved the Russians was the weather and the massive help from the United States.

    • @EvocatusX
      @EvocatusX 9 лет назад +60

      07lubo Lol not even close.

    • @thereptilianarmysoldier389
      @thereptilianarmysoldier389 9 лет назад +42

      +07lubo Logic? No. The USSR forces were producing far more weapons and had far more men, along with the mental aspect of defending their country and being used to the harsh climate.

    • @07lubo
      @07lubo 9 лет назад +10

      +Charles Bruh The USSR were producing more weapons and materials, but the point is that the weather stopped the Germans from advancing to Moscow and by the time they could have resumed their attack the Americans already gave massive aid to the Russians. I'm not saying that the Russians couldn't deal with the Germans, but the main things is that they couldn't have done it alone.

    • @thereptilianarmysoldier389
      @thereptilianarmysoldier389 9 лет назад +8

      +07lubo The thing is is that they could have. Germany invaded Russia without warning or a declaration of war. Russia outnumbered them 10 to one. The weather sucked, yes, but at the same time the russians were able to deal with it because they were used to it. The U.S Didnt aid Russia in the defense of Russia with troops.

  • @TylerWest1776
    @TylerWest1776 2 года назад +5

    Best WW2 Documentary I've Ever Seen.

  • @SnipingMachines
    @SnipingMachines 4 года назад +2

    Content was pretty good 👌 Keep it up

  • @thevettegetsitwett
    @thevettegetsitwett Год назад +4

    He had a point if you just rush to Moscow you risk your Panzers themselves getting cut off and encircled. They likely could of worked out a compromise allowing some panzers & mechanized units to follow. You can’t leave all those millions of encircled Russians behind your lines or you risk them breaking out and joining the fight again.

  • @Shaymuhs
    @Shaymuhs 8 лет назад +9

    16:12 "And he was convinced: that soviet communism was a Jewish conspiracy" lost it

    • @frjoethesecond
      @frjoethesecond 8 лет назад +9

      To add to your excellent reply, Soviet communism was heavily inspired by the writings of Karl Marx who was a Jew.

    • @TopForkZombi
      @TopForkZombi 8 лет назад +4

      +frjoethesecond so what if he had jewish ancestry, marx was never a practicing jew. You are just being a vile anti Semite.

    • @sajenin3659
      @sajenin3659 7 лет назад +4

      Jews are a race not just a religion. You can't deny this there are Ashkenazi jews its a fact,but the truth is 85% of today's jews belong to a race

    • @schmittyvonbaun8418
      @schmittyvonbaun8418 7 лет назад +4

      Seamus Tobin the soviet leadership was overwhelmingly jewish as were almost all of the original Bolshevik leaders

    • @alexfloate2420
      @alexfloate2420 7 лет назад

      JJ and ignorance has found a voice....

  • @terryroe4852
    @terryroe4852 6 лет назад +1

    God love you Vasile......History buff here.....Love rhis site!

  • @angusyates828
    @angusyates828 2 года назад +3

    Stalin, who was paranoid was the only man to ever trust Hitler.

    • @mynamedoesntmatter8652
      @mynamedoesntmatter8652 Год назад

      And he killed every one of his commanders so he could install his own WWI group of commanders because they were under his thumb, but by a miracle the Russians finally beat Hitler’s armies. Staggering losses, insane losses, plus the minimum ten million-plus of his people he’d already starved to death in a genocidally motivated way. Of course he’d seen that happen once before. Then he tossed the Russian POWs in gulags merely because they’d been POWs. They didn’t choose to die instead.

  • @ragingbull6890
    @ragingbull6890 2 года назад +3

    Imagine being there in person 45:35 and hearing that crowd scream "Heil", goosebumps!!

    • @AlbertIsraeli
      @AlbertIsraeli 2 года назад

      Goosebumps from admiration or disgust?

  • @Ealdorman_of_Mercia
    @Ealdorman_of_Mercia 11 месяцев назад +2

    Best ww2 documentary ever made.

  • @kaynebartholomew2994
    @kaynebartholomew2994 6 лет назад +23

    I miss this show. Back when the military channel wasn't full of conspiracy theory shows and Nazi shows.

    • @uio890138
      @uio890138 6 лет назад +2

      I wonder if 'Ancient Aliens' had world wars on their home planets?......hehehehe. The History Channel is trash now days.

    • @hissyhonker220
      @hissyhonker220 5 лет назад

      Nazi shows?