Sean Carroll Explains The Biggest Ideas in the Universe (2022)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 19 дек 2024

Комментарии • 132

  • @ryanjude1290
    @ryanjude1290 6 месяцев назад +36

    I'm a simple man. I see Sean Carroll in the headline... I click.

    • @keithmetcalf5548
      @keithmetcalf5548 6 месяцев назад +3

      Simple indeed...

    • @jmfp21jp
      @jmfp21jp 6 месяцев назад +5

      Brian is so cringe sometimes too lol

  • @johnwillis8223
    @johnwillis8223 6 месяцев назад +15

    Sean Carroll is covering up for Michio Kaku being out of control

    • @jessemontano762
      @jessemontano762 6 месяцев назад

      out of control?

    • @johnwillis8223
      @johnwillis8223 6 месяцев назад +4

      @@jessemontano762 Michio Kaku is out of control.

    • @jamesmatson5205
      @jamesmatson5205 6 месяцев назад +1

      @@johnwillis8223 You didn't actually answer the question. Someone asked 'out of control?' obviously wanting you to expand on the topic. Instead, you just parroted the same claim. How about backing up the claim with some information or evidence?

    • @donaldmcronald8989
      @donaldmcronald8989 6 месяцев назад +1

      @@jamesmatson5205 Bro is wildin'

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 4 месяца назад +1

    Conversations came about through HUMILITY! The Capital "I" became a little Child "i" AM. Now sincere conversations can take place!

  • @MoshkitaTheCat
    @MoshkitaTheCat 6 месяцев назад +2

    Love your channel, Dr. Keating. Thank you for hosting Dr. Carroll on your show… a big fan here.

  • @drprofessorsoso208
    @drprofessorsoso208 6 месяцев назад +2

    Dr. Sean's observation highlights how physicists often focus on their specific area of research through a reductionist lens, examining intricate details without considering the broader, interconnected picture. This narrow perspective can lead to a belief that their field is the most crucial, while others are deemed less important. However, this approach overlooks the interconnectedness of knowledge and the potential insights that emerge from a more not necessarily holistic but broader perspective.

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 4 месяца назад +1

    Clarity, coherence, adequacy, evidence, and witnesses!

  • @spencemallder7358
    @spencemallder7358 6 месяцев назад +4

    I earned an MS in Applied Physics decades ago. Sean's description of a Physics/Math degree as impractical is incorrect. I've found the Physics and Mathematics I learned prepared me to attack and learn many other disciplines including OR, Aerospace Engieering, Machine Learning (Bayesian Classifiers, SVMs, and much more). So young people out there, go get Physics and Mathematics degrees! You will be able to apply your knowledge in many, many disciplines.

    • @karagi101
      @karagi101 6 месяцев назад

      Lawrence Krauss too had a physics/math education.

    • @dohpam1ne
      @dohpam1ne 6 месяцев назад +1

      It depends on what you mean by practical. I have a BS in physics, and it has helped me to give me a very solid foundation in technical/scientific knowledge, but it has given me absolutely no help in the job market. It was a little more highly valued decades ago, but now, a plain physics degree isn't going to get you any jobs.

    • @karagi101
      @karagi101 6 месяцев назад

      OR was cool! Optimization…
      Was a key part of my Industrial Engineering degree.

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 4 месяца назад +1

    My Hosts Brian and Sean remember thy lives was DESIRED 1ST.

  • @kmktruthserum9328
    @kmktruthserum9328 6 месяцев назад

    45:30 We may be thinking too small... Instead of asking can they feel human emotions, can they feel emotions at all? How do we know they have a emotion of happiness? They may have an emotion that we don't even know exists and that's why we can't tell what a dog feels when it barks uncontrollably. Or would a computer feels when it is taking its sweet old time to open a program...

  • @BikianaBiswas
    @BikianaBiswas 6 месяцев назад

    Ooh! Such a fantastic discussion! An excellent interview between two physicists. Thanks to Dr. Brian for this. And such a good teacher and explainer Sean is as well as a top level physicist. From 34 to 38 (approx) his explanation of equvalance principle, and at the end answers to the questions. Shows such deep insights into his subjects. Enlightening indeed! And such good interview by Dr. Brian; insightgul! Thank you both for this! ❤ Loved it! ❤

  • @Bill..N
    @Bill..N 6 месяцев назад +2

    Very engaging as usual.. I am with Sean on the MWs theory for two reasons.. First, the Copenhagen interpretation feels FORCED with the additional added equations that were necessary to achieve a certain predetermined and biased outcome. Second, it provides a construct for salvaging MY biased outcome, which is the existence of free will, peace..

  • @helicalactual
    @helicalactual 6 месяцев назад +2

    Ok so, the issue is Einstein is only considering the curvature without the things causing the curvature.
    If you were to combine or commute not just the curvature but the thing is causing the curvature I'm willing to wager you will get the transit of mercury.

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 4 месяца назад +1

    Students shared "i" AM will say, can easily determine Fake nor KEPT! In front of HIM!

  • @RWin-fp5jn
    @RWin-fp5jn 6 месяцев назад

    A lot of issues covered. The discussion about Einstein and relativity is a nice summary of how the thoughts and mathematical descriptions concerning gravity developed 100 years ago and remained that way ever since. Problem is we never understood what caused gravity. We only described it. Sure, all formulas in SR and GR work. No need to touch them. But correlation isn’t causation. You can combine space and time and treat them like a 4D space like Minkowski did. Doesnt mean space and time themselves are equivalent though! Any change in space might instead be causally linked to an inverse change in energy and any change in time causally linked to a inverse change in mass. In that case any speeding object (as per special relativity) would gain in relativistic energy, thus decreasing frontal space of its grid. Likewise any speeding object would also gain in relativistic mass, thus decreasing frontal time of its grid. You would still have the APPARENT equivalence between space and time but we now see the CAUSUAL the link is actually somewhere else. That is the danger Sean Caroll and Brian overlook when just superficially discuss apparent equivalence and trusting on descriptive formulas that appear to work. By the way; I just explained where realivistic mass and energy come from, something Einstein did not feel comfortable to discuss for reasons I we now understand. By the way I also explained now where gravity comes from. Whis we could now correct this so called 100 year riddle of gravity which is the EASIEST of all phyisical phenomena to grasp.

  • @dosesandmimoses
    @dosesandmimoses 6 месяцев назад

    Tarp was similar “loan” that I helped pay for.. in fact, I think we all contributed to that issue. Is the same courtesy being extended to us? Systems… and the conclusion some have drawn is: let’s create more systems at a faster pace. I don’t know about everyone else, but I usually “dip” my foot in the pool before jumping head first .. or I watch the wave patterns to try to understand undertow.. but that’s just me. Thank you gentlemen

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 4 месяца назад

    Together with thy shared "i" AM came with sincere conversations given just for thee!

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 4 месяца назад +1

    Thank you Sean and Brian

  • @gravityalchemist6599
    @gravityalchemist6599 6 месяцев назад +1

    loved your explanation ofEinsteins equivalence principle.

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 4 месяца назад +1

    Same have made my HOUSE a REBELLIOUS HOUSE resting upon my Footstool!

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 4 месяца назад +1

    What is accurate nor precise?

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 4 месяца назад +1

    Removing dizziness! What is fainting?

  • @DwynAgGaire
    @DwynAgGaire 6 месяцев назад +1

    Great stuff, thanks!

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 6 месяцев назад

    My Heir Host Sean thank you! For thy visitation to comfort the COMFORTER! And to attend unto our OWN! Fulfillment come here in front! Loving you without shame but with boldness! Love you too Sean

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 4 месяца назад +1

    Overwhelming made simple!

  • @spaceinyourface
    @spaceinyourface 6 месяцев назад

    Heyyy,,you asked my wife, Joye's question.!! Thanks Brian 😊

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 4 месяца назад +1

    Many professors with their CLIPBOARDS. Beloved remember Who searches the Hearts and Minds?

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 6 месяцев назад

    Captives giants! Yes, can be unlooseed thy chains in front! Angels who persevere and heard the WORD will say! Recognize!

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 4 месяца назад +1

    Who controls the Sea of glass? Containing who consumed? Students shared "i" AM will say, before there's no #'s at the end of HIS NAME?

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 4 месяца назад +1

    Remember as HE able to hold. Likewise Brian and Sean remember ye ABLE to hold.

  • @paketisa4330
    @paketisa4330 6 месяцев назад +3

    why publish a 2 year old interview? why

    • @brendawilliams8062
      @brendawilliams8062 4 месяца назад

      Books for the young who are interested in Learning is coming every spring just like the grass

  • @JungleJargon
    @JungleJargon 6 месяцев назад

    Redshift is due to gravity. Whether the universe is expanding into oblivion for no reason is questionable. Invisible matter is questionable too. We are better served by making an effort to understand things by way of what is observed and verified.

    • @HarryNicNicholas
      @HarryNicNicholas 6 месяцев назад

      you again. lol. how is the thesis coming along?

  • @darwinlaluna3677
    @darwinlaluna3677 6 месяцев назад

    Both of u have a nice day, my respect to you both

  • @TonyMountjoy
    @TonyMountjoy 6 месяцев назад +4

    Sir Roger Penrose is on the right track. Ignore his approach at your own risk.

    • @karagi101
      @karagi101 6 месяцев назад +1

      What qualifies you to judge if Penrose is on the right track? Are you a top theoretical physicist?

    • @TonyMountjoy
      @TonyMountjoy 6 месяцев назад

      @@karagi101 If being a top theoretical physicist is the deciding factor than I am still correct backing Penrose because he self-qualifies by your own standard. You know... him being a Nobel prize winning genius who everyone agrees is in the very tippy top of theoretical physicists.

    • @karagi101
      @karagi101 6 месяцев назад

      @@TonyMountjoy LMAO That’s not how science works. Independent verification is required. The easiest person to deceive is yourself.

    • @jamesmatson5205
      @jamesmatson5205 6 месяцев назад

      @@TonyMountjoy Winning a Nobel prize for one thing does not automatically qualify the winners other ideas as correct. It just doesn't work that way. Sorry.

  • @gregoryhead382
    @gregoryhead382 6 месяцев назад +1

    1 mass-energy equivalent of the galaxy's visible mass = (((0.5 α light second^2 c^3)/(light meter))/G) My book title is: The Quantum Theory of Galactic Relatives. G_max & G_force are an AI generated computational Wolfram|Alpha result for 🐄 99% hard work, and 1% GRR-AH! 🐻

  • @Life_42
    @Life_42 6 месяцев назад +1

    My two favorites!!!

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 4 месяца назад +1

    Resting upon the NEW Permanent Foundation.

  • @darwinlaluna3677
    @darwinlaluna3677 6 месяцев назад

    Fields reacted much stronger maybe at summer like a wave and calmly when colder

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 4 месяца назад +1

    Beyond can contain. Contain

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 4 месяца назад

    Beloved bring the cosmos, universe, creation itself, nor ALL! In front!

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 4 месяца назад +1

    Where all names exist!

  • @meadowfreshhmilk
    @meadowfreshhmilk 6 месяцев назад

    What is a pilot

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 4 месяца назад +1

    Students shared "i" AM will say, HIS documents sent forth throughout the Clouds resting upon the NEW Permanent Foundation?

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 4 месяца назад

    Brian Saul to Paul have spoken of the little child born "i" AM from Phillipi!

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 4 месяца назад

    Who is the creator?

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 6 месяцев назад

    Time come remind and comes with comfort WHAT is WRONG? 1ST. Have accused Noone can accused! Death come here in front! Remind! What is thy sting?

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 6 месяцев назад

    Why say students with confidence? Even thy students can't exist in front of thee! Why? For thy students shared "i" AM. Time given a true reason.

  • @paulanderson3772
    @paulanderson3772 6 месяцев назад

    Thank you.

  • @rajeevgangal542
    @rajeevgangal542 6 месяцев назад

    I and others have said this often. All interviewers should learn brevity from Sean. Average of Ratio of length your own voice to that of the guest

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 4 месяца назад

    Brian and Sean remember thy own Names can't exist in front!

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 6 месяцев назад

    Singularity the I AM. Beloved who among can bring sincere conversations? The will say from the True Owner! When is foolish conversations? Time. As ye all see can learn from the past! Time given will say, remember for Who is not in the past? Beloved aren't ye all IN FRONT? All thy shared Feet resting upon the very tip of time in FRONT? ANGELS who persevere and heard the WORD will say, even HUMILITY stood up from HIS SEAT!

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 4 месяца назад +1

    Better yet, should the NEW Permanent Foundation visit all the Foundations of men according unto their own understanding?

  • @nunomaroco583
    @nunomaroco583 6 месяцев назад

    Just an brilliant mind, really like it....

  • @thesupremeginge
    @thesupremeginge 6 месяцев назад

    On the other hand, without people who understand basketball, there would be no NBA.

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 6 месяцев назад

    Will say, how else can thy Own show off in front of thee? But thy Neighbors GIVEN to attend as THY Keepers MEEKS! To prepare thy FEET to walked upon. UNFAMILIAR UNTO MANY! For the pleasures of life and exalting themselves above made blind from Who? Murderer and who deceiveth since in the beginning! He will removed the scales from their EYES. As He cleaned the PEEK HOLES with HIS SALIVA! SO MAY SEE CLEARLY! NEW EYES! GIVEN! Thank you for attending!

  • @JungleJargon
    @JungleJargon 6 месяцев назад

    The best way to learn is to learn from someone who knows. You have to learn that human history is limited to the sixteen original ancient civilizations that are from the sixteen grandsons of Noah.

    • @HarryNicNicholas
      @HarryNicNicholas 6 месяцев назад

      is that noah the drunk? noah who had to build a boat cos god can't create boats? that noah?

    • @JungleJargon
      @JungleJargon 6 месяцев назад

      @@HarryNicNicholas It’s Noah your ancestor have some respect.

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 6 месяцев назад

    What is utterance programming? Yes, language! Without no programmers in front of WHO?

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 4 месяца назад +1

    Bring all these principalities in front! Come and try to remove the little Child born "i" AM Feet resting upon the NEW Permanent Foundation!

  • @claras1fan
    @claras1fan 6 месяцев назад +1

    1088*

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 6 месяцев назад

    My Heir Host Brian many will questions why HIS OWN DOING WHY HIS SHARED "i" AM doing in front?

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 4 месяца назад

    Why say from Phillipi?

  • @rhcpmorley
    @rhcpmorley 6 месяцев назад

    Sean...the words Space and Time are both homonyms. You need to differentiate both their multiple meanings, else you literally don't know what are talking about.
    In the context of dimensions, Space is the dimension of spatial position (ergo the xyz-axis). And Time is the dimension of change.
    Merge the dimension of change with the dimension of spatial position....bingo, the dimension of changing spatial position aka (relative) Motion.
    Simples.

  • @AppleVsGravity
    @AppleVsGravity 6 месяцев назад +1

    Rich white people?? Sean is very anti-white. He's never donated to a white individual who isn't rich. Skin color matters to him. Not intellect.

    • @jamesmatson5205
      @jamesmatson5205 6 месяцев назад

      Huh? How is Sean.. 'anti-white'? And how exactly are you privy to every person that he has or hasn't donated to? What kind of inside knowledge must you have to know that? Are you his wife? If not, how?

    • @AppleVsGravity
      @AppleVsGravity 6 месяцев назад

      Because I know who he's donated to. It's not secret information. If you actually listened to him, you might have gotten that information. He says it VERY clearly. On his website, he has it listed who those donations went to. Not a single white person. Maybe you should have looked into it before commenting.

    • @jamesmatson5205
      @jamesmatson5205 6 месяцев назад

      @@AppleVsGravity Perhaps you could tell me which part of his website lists every person he has donated to? I did check his site and I can't see a "donations" tab. Maybe you could point it out? But irrespective, if we assume you have seen a list AND we assume that every person on that list is "not white" can you help explain to me how you draw from that the conclusion he is "anti white"? Because I don't think that's an objective conclusion to reach. I have donated almost exclusively to causes related to Alzheimers because my Dad suffered from it. But does that make me anti Cancer? Or anti Heart Disease? Or does it just make me passionate about a particular cause?

  • @theomnisthour6400
    @theomnisthour6400 6 месяцев назад

    Have you found the center of the new physical universe space-time yet? Kind of fish slaps Galileo, doesn't it?

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 4 месяца назад +1

    Unto all the Capital I exalted themselves above! Who ye talking too?

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 6 месяцев назад

    Beloved asked all my shared "i" AM programmers without?

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 6 месяцев назад +1

    Time can be understood! Beloved remind unto all shared "i" AM in front "WHO AM I"? Time will say to become as HE and all His shared "i" AM. Singular the I AM WILL SAY SHARED "i" AM come forth! Now sincere conversations can take place. Who else Singularity can talk to WHOM? Don't mind these Wannabes! Already set UNDERFOOT! Time to bring to remembrance and comes with comfort. Principalities who deceiveth sitting in high places? What is possible? Yes, including Ye principalities who deceiveth can be made NEW!

  • @HarryNicNicholas
    @HarryNicNicholas 6 месяцев назад

    have you gotten over not getting a nobel yet?

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 6 месяцев назад

    As ye all see! HIS Angels who persevere and heard the WORD have a CHAIN! TO BOUND ALL HANDS AND FEET IN FRONT OF WHO? Who love with patience, mercy, and grace! Judgment and Justice so love the Little Child born "i" born 1 out of many! Seems 1 yet 2. The Comforter will say!

  • @CPHSDC
    @CPHSDC 6 месяцев назад

    Probability of life? Intelligent life? Sounds like a calculation, a probability with us as 1. What happened to Darwinism? I don't think it works "there" either.

  • @Ken-vl4wk
    @Ken-vl4wk 6 месяцев назад

    What’s going on with this back and forth, focusing when the guest is talking then zooming in to Brian’s face?
    It is distracting and annoying. Is it automatic?

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 4 месяца назад

    Yes, even my pop King David knows WHO?

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 6 месяцев назад

    NEW has a NAME! Name nor names come here in front and remind! Without Thy shared "i" AM? Students will say from here!

  • @JungleJargon
    @JungleJargon 6 месяцев назад

    Every physical thing is from a greater power.

    • @hogfishmaximussailing5208
      @hogfishmaximussailing5208 6 месяцев назад

      But it sure as shit is not from some lame human created dogma!

    • @HarryNicNicholas
      @HarryNicNicholas 6 месяцев назад

      yeah, whatever. every physical thing is from a lesser power too. 🤪

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 4 месяца назад

    Philosophy come here in front and remind! LORD a little Child born "i" from afar EAST from Phillipi!

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 6 месяцев назад

    Students will say, even ye LOVE many shared clay FEET MIXED WITH IRON resting upon all fhy dry grounds. GROUNDED! In front of Thee! "WHO AM I"? As far to even have murdered Thee! In front of Thee! Wise of this world and scribes murmuring among themselves! Who is this little Child born "i"? Angels who persevere and heard the WORD will say not made by men's hands but of God of the Living! Some will say who is this battery? Better yet....who is this ENERGY?

    • @oliverjamito9902
      @oliverjamito9902 6 месяцев назад

      Beautiful will say remember WHO IS SITTING IN THE MIDST? Soothe HIm! Why? Can ye all shared eyes to see? Beautiful will say LET THEM SEE! Who's FEET resting upon "DO NO MORE"! NEVERTHELESS....as HE tilted the world before! Yes, these giants knows? Heirs Hosts shared "i" AM knows to keep? Yes instead to bound thy hands and feet in front! Unlooseed!

  • @JungleJargon
    @JungleJargon 6 месяцев назад

    Complexity is a joke when compared to living organisms. Living organisms require specific written programming.

    • @HarryNicNicholas
      @HarryNicNicholas 6 месяцев назад

      yeah, whatever.

    • @oliverjamito9902
      @oliverjamito9902 6 месяцев назад

      Programing come here in front! Liken unto unfamiliar ways of speaking unto many but yet is clear as water unto Whom BELONGS? Language

    • @JungleJargon
      @JungleJargon 6 месяцев назад

      @@HarryNicNicholas Yeah you admitted that you have nothing.

    • @JungleJargon
      @JungleJargon 6 месяцев назад

      @@oliverjamito9902 Word salad.

    • @oliverjamito9902
      @oliverjamito9902 6 месяцев назад

      @JungleJargon who among ye ALL shared "i" AM can find tune the OLIVER J= "i" ='Isa from the I AM! Yeshua

  • @FighterFred
    @FighterFred 6 месяцев назад +1

    Typical academics; silver spoons with tenure talking down to the peasants.

    • @jamesmatson5205
      @jamesmatson5205 6 месяцев назад +1

      How do you class Sean Carroll as having a 'silver spoon' in his mouth? Or talking 'down' to people?

  • @buca512boxer
    @buca512boxer 4 месяца назад

    I like Sean, but he's in a way a science denier by being a string, inflation and holography supporter. I agree with Nobel laureate Dr. Sir Roger Penrose when he says that all of that is faith, fashion and fantasy.

  • @thesupremeginge
    @thesupremeginge 6 месяцев назад

    He wasn't allowed to go outside? Was this in North Korea?

    • @bytefu
      @bytefu 4 месяца назад

      No, it obviously was the land of the free.

    • @thesupremeginge
      @thesupremeginge 4 месяца назад

      @@bytefu California is not land of the free.

  • @bobcabot
    @bobcabot 6 месяцев назад

    ...im a scam-physicist! ( dont tell anybody

  • @Uzay_Zaman
    @Uzay_Zaman 6 месяцев назад

    Today is Galatasaray

  • @MasoudJohnAzizi
    @MasoudJohnAzizi 6 месяцев назад

    One man's truth is another man's delusion.

  • @michael-4k4000
    @michael-4k4000 3 месяца назад

    Is Sean single?

  • @hakiza-technologyltd.8198
    @hakiza-technologyltd.8198 6 месяцев назад

    That guy just keep parroting same old ideas

    • @jamesmatson5205
      @jamesmatson5205 6 месяцев назад +1

      Are ideas not worth discussing because they are not new? Conversely are ideas only worth discussing because they are new? If you believe the latter, you must be right into Terrance Howard's treatise on how black holes don't exist and stars defecate baby planets.

    • @SeanAnthony-j7f
      @SeanAnthony-j7f 5 месяцев назад

      Ideas are immanent as long as their very abstract

  • @kurt2612
    @kurt2612 6 месяцев назад

    "The biggest ideas in the universe"... with all due respect for your perceived intellectual capacity... that title is literally the largest exaggeration in human history. These ideas aren't even the biggest in North America... I am actually disappointed that you... Dr. Keating, would stoop to clickbait titles to get views. I am a super-nerd who chooses to listen to content produced by inferior minds.... I never included you in that group until I read this title. Do better. ... because YOU ARE!

  • @johnnytass2111
    @johnnytass2111 6 месяцев назад

    Can an episode explore Chronon Field Theory?