They deserved to hear the criticism. Being the top trainees means higher expectations and at this point in the show, you gotta start fighting harder but not memorizing the lyrics is really critical.
But the people who are scolded here still have better live vocals than Moka and Iroha who can't even sing 2 words It's a shame they're being called idols
Fans need to realize that criticisms like this is every important for their idols to grow. They don't need to be "babied" at all times, because when they debut, they will hear more cruel words esp. these days that the internet is literally everywhere. If they don't have strong foundation or mentality to handle such things, they won't be able to survive the real world. Jo-Kwon, out of all the judges, is my favorite. He gives great feedback when he sees improvement but at the same time, uses his sharp tongue to advise trainees.
Exactly, without constructive critism, they won't be able to get better and better. Learning never stops and hearing only good things won't let you see your full potential. If you think the way the judges judged were unfair then that means you only want to hear what you want to hear. These judges actually take their time to focus on every detail and mentor these trainees, they didn't hate on them just for fun. They wouldn't want those trainees to debut just to get bashed by netizens, they want the trainees to be able to show their fans that they do deserved their spots.
Yes! It's just very ridicilous that some fans cannot accept that their favs. are being scolded like they're already perfect idols. These mentors know best the performance especially what needs to be improved.
But in this show, it seems as if the judges are criticizing for dramatic effect. like take lee hyun smth guy for example he will just completely shit on older trainees if they make small mistakes but for younger trainees with good visuals he will be biased and say they at least improved no matter what! and when they criticize, they don't really give good feedback, they just scold. that's why some trainees are losing confidence and some completely crashed (like Iris). and I feel like judges can be judges w/o actually scold and making a face the whole time, take Soyeon, Seungyoon, Woozi as a guest judge and JYP for eg
@@iris7879 idk how nice mentors have to be for you guys to be satisfied bc i sure do think trainees need to be humbled and made aware of room for improvement no matter how "good" you as an audience think they are. as a fan of kpop since 2008, i can assure you that the judges are nowhere as bad as yall make them out to be (not that i think the idol treatment in the past generations are perfect). ofc guest judges like woozi will come off abit nicer because they literally dont know the girls and are only appearing for 1 episode, it shouldn't be compared to judges who know the weakness and strengths of the girls. i am not defending the judges bc i also dont agree with everything they've said (jiwoo's my pick and they nitpick on her skills too) but fans need to realise that they don't see or hear everything the judges do so we cannot assume that we know any better than them. p.s. iris really did need the feedback to have a reality check, her attitude and skills were really not it. i'm sure with more time and training she'll be more ready to debut in the future :)
Jo Kwon trained for 8 to 10 years before he debuted, so he knows how intense the training is, and he gives the right criticism so the trainees won't make the same mistakes again.
if the fans are angry at these judges when they give constructive criticisms to the trainees then they have never met SM idols as Mentors/judges because when SM Idols appears as mentors/judges they give brutal criticisms and scolds the trainees, whenever they saw the trainees make any mistakes that can be avoided with proper practices and concenterations
Jokwon debuted under jyp and one thing that he learnt from jyp is that jyp hates trainees/singers who didn't memorized lyrics the most. That's why jokwon scolded the girls in here. It's to show how passionate you are as a singer. It's an attitude problem an individual has to fix. You have to discipline yourself.
@@mewsaomomo and Izty can sing they just have songs that don't match their vocal range. Its too high for them. Every singer has a vocal range Jyp knows it but doesn't seem to care.
the problem I feel is that the top trainees do badly in training because they think they are the cream of the crop (hence they slacked till scolded by the judges) and then they picked up the pace again; which is alarming for potential idols...
Wow, the judge actually did great job at correction the girls... They told them their mistake and how to be better... Thats how survival show should be.... And Goddess Gyuri is just beautiful as ever....
I cant sing a single note but even still I watch some of these audition shows scratching my head wondering if we are both listening to the same thing. This was brutal but honest, if they sound like crap now when the public and media get to them it will be worse and the stress of more songs will get to them. They had really brutal honest comments from the judges and whilst I dont know the others I do know Lee Hyun and Jo Kwon and they have outstanding vocals and know there stuff......
The thing is, this song is a staple for the heart of Kpop. And it's not like they're doing a hard choreo and they're all Korean so memorising lyrics should be easier for then. So it's bit disappointing to have trainees , supposed to be at the top to be slacking. Because if you're one of the bests, you should always be wary and practice hard.
Literally what happened now to Illit 💀 They should have practiced in the pre-debut. Vocally speaking, expert Minjae Jung was very disappointed. They have a long way to go until they are vocally pleasant. The most basics is to sing your recorded parts and if you can't do that you're not a professional rookie. That's an area Illit needs to improve according to him. No member really stands out to him in the debut. He wants to praise Minju for her unique voice but she is not a good vocalist, she has potential to become a good vocalist if she practices. Wonhee stands out to him when it came to expressive ability. She had the shortest time of training which impressed him. Overall the grade is quite low for him because they lacked basics in this debut. He hopes to see improvements for the comeback and show him their professional side by taking their job serious. I can't agree with him more. If they had the basics they wouldn't get bashed by netizens in the first place. We can blame this on Bang PD and Belift who didn't take vocal lessons to their hearts. Hybe has been controversial when it comes to provide heavy vocal training for their girl groups. MHJ put effort into that with NewJeans so they never got the same shitty treatment as Lesserafim and Illit. So their vocals turned out decent, not great or good, just average decent. Fromis_9 was signed to Off The Record so they were provided vocal training before they joined Pledis. GFriend was trained by Source Music when they were small and not a label to Hybe. So this is probably a management problem at Hybe.
The problem is the fans are always being angry at everything. Criticisms are needed for someone's growth. If you keep pampering and babying someone, he/she would never grow to their max potentials. No pain no gain
This is way too tame vs the criticisms they give to trainees off cam. "DO YOU WANT TO DO THIS OR NOT?" "DO YOU WANT TO QUIT?" "WE CAN REPLACE YOU WITH ANOTHER TRAINEE, THERE ARE HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF YOU" and my personal fave "DID YOUR PARENTS NOT TEACH YOU WELL?"
I hear some yg blood in minju's vocal deym that yg swag and vocal technique is really her weapon to fame, I hope hybe wont remove that from her cause that technique really suits her. I heard a mix of CL, Rosé and lee hi in her perf
Criticism should flow normally as it motivates them to do their work properly. However, being dependent on criticism, orders, and slacking off just because you've reached a certain stage where your talents have been recognized.. immediatley puts you at the bottom.
2:40 mark, Bang Jeemin from the upcoming Wake One first ever permanent girl group Izna (formed thru I-LAND 2024: N/a) got called as least impressive in Team I Don't Care (Green Team) on this mission when she competed on R U NEXT? last year.
While even though I am a jeemin Stan I do agree if you watched the show, jeemin at rehearsals missed the beat and her dictation was poor. Though she improved on stage
And not to mention it's a classic kpop song. The standard is already so high. They were way to lax in their rehearsal and definitely needed a reality check.
This comment is late but I had to say this, you have to remember the stages have heavily edited vocals to make all of the girls look better. Like very edited, in some stages they sound really robotic. The only non edited parts we get are the mid-term evaluations and some little clips through the episode. Jihyun sounded stable to you due to the editing, but the judges hear it live and also have an earpiece to hear it clearly so they know if they sang well or not. So most likely she was unstable, similar to the mid-term
idk what they were expecting like theyre going to debut in a top company and popularity is basically ensured so ofc they will be judged harshly plus there was basically no dancing how can they sound like that.
Watching this REMIND ME OF YANG HYUN SUK IN YG ,A PRODUCER WITH A EYE OF A GEM,,HE CRITIZED TRAINEE BUT TO MAKE THEM GOOD IT'S UP TO THE TRAINEE TO TAKE GIS WORD IN A GOOD WAY OR NOT AND LOOK EVERY YG ARTIST IS SO TALENTED WHEN THEY ARE FACING THE CRUEL WORLD,,,
They should scold them. Vocally speaking, expert Minjae Jung was very disappointed. Sing your parts like the recorded version are basics you need to craft. Because of Hybe's mismanagement of their girl groups they have a long way to go until they are vocally pleasant. No member didn't really stand out to him in the debut. Minju was not a good vocalist, but has a high potential to become a good vocalist if she practices. Wonhee stand out to him when it came to expressive ability. She had the shortest time of training. Overall the debut is a very low score to him because they lack basics. Especially in the vocal department he wants to see improvements. Even rookies need to be professional by taking their job serious. It doesn't make excuse for lack of basics. Illit are amateurs to him after this debut so if they want to change they better get practice.
Take note here, any trainee in Korea Have to go through hash trainee season . Rmb the only time when they can make mistake is when they are a trainee . I believe many of u saw ur favourite kpop idols get criticise by almost everyone for doing a minimum mistake . And most of these criticisms from their trainers ar important. Since is also builds them . Many of you were aware no matter how good the idols are there will always be hates . All these trainee are there to be judge from them professional . Is like if u cannot take this blow you can’t be an idols tbh
Hate the judges all you want but don't forget that this is a survival show, in order to debut they need to learn the hard way and survive so they can be the best idols. Besides the judges are professionals and experienced they know what they are doing. It's just that the editing really sucks.
You and ppl who likes your comment are the reason that idol didn’t improve their singing and dancing.bcoz they know that fans like you can protect them in whatever cost.they all are top trainees and judges expectations are higher compared to other groups.this performance are bad.really bad.if they continue like this,knetizen will eat them alive.
Fans need to realised the kpop industry is gotta be tough and the reason why he was so strict to them cause he want them to improved and do better if they want make it to debut and kpop industry is tough he been in the industry snice 2008 for 15 years he was struggling with 2am cause jyp and hybe formerly used bighit was struggling of bankruptcy if u guys don't know they have coed manged by bighit and jyp.
Constructive criticism is needed for every idol. Even if they decided to lipsync for every live performance they'll have in the future, they'll still look bad if their lips aren't sync to the lyrics.
I think hyewon was in the most critical and difficult position tbh. Imagine getting 2-3 lines and they all are high notes but your charm is not in “high note”, it must be so burden that ppl can’t see you much bc you are always behind and barely get to be in the middle and you don’t have lines to shine.. poor hyewon, if they gave her the part she wished for, she would deffo would do better bc she had the potential for it.
2:50 You’ve never been this criticized in her life? She never had an Asian parent yelling at her to do better at math? Never had her parent yell at her? Never had a teacher being strict? Makes sense why she’s a baby.
Look honestly after seeing some controversy about these shows idk what to believe. Some of the PD’S make contestants act a sort of way for views. Its always for views.
Entendí algunos puntos,por ejemplo cuando veo a New Jeans en especial Hanni ella siempre está con la misma energía en el baile, expresión facial y canto aunque no esté en el centro,es decir debes de disfrutar de todo el baile y no solo actuar de esa manera cuando la cámara te enfoca.Tal como lo hace Ji Min,creo que hay mucho potencial en todas ellas pero si o si deben disfrutar de su presentación,es como si tú trabajo fuera alegrar y llamar la atención del público con tu actuación,es tu trabajo y debes saber realizarlo a la perfección.Parece cruel pero algunos profesores también me lo mencionaban en mis clases,uno puede esforzarse mucho pero sino logras cumplir tu objetivo ese tiempo invertido desaparece,más que todo es enfocarte en tu meta y ser constante,eso es muy importante.
This here is exactly why there's the saying, ' Only YG artists can sing YG songs. ' I cringed all throughout watching this even when I didn't want or expect to then again, ROOM TO GROW and GET BETTER. OMG...never thought I'd see the day when 2nd Generation Kpop Artists grow up so fast and evolve into judges. They were just kids when I met them. Saranghae, 2nd Gen!
They're on a television show, i doubt they aren't all trying their hardest so maybe there is another reason besides "laziness". Were they not given enough time to practice
@@cansnbkey I know but wonhee haters are really too much they so toxic to just a 16 years old girl. And there no prove judge bias over wonhee. In every photos or videos about ru next The topic is whatever wonhee hater always put wonhee in. If someone made videos about chanelle, minju, himena, iroha etc haters always compared and say about bad things to wonhee wonhee is not others wonhee is wonhee don't always compared with others
@@andredaniel6658 A bit before the pandemic is when the preference of visuals and dance over live vocals began taking over and was officially cemented into practice with 4th gen. The only artists I know to be very reliable with singing live vocals at every show are all 2nd gen, early 3rd gen or bands. The few 4th gen artists I can think of to atleast make an actual effort to sing with live vocals are all soloists, with most of them being ex-group members. These days fans don't care about actual music or artistry. All you need is a pretty face and some dance. True, visuals have been important through all of the generations, but the emphasis on good looks has only peaked. Been an active listener and participant in the Korean music industry since like 2011 or so, which is 2nd gen. Everything has only gone downhill.
Seems like they forgot to take criticism to their hearts and get better. Now they got bashed from their first encore by netizens and now it's a witch hunt on Illit 😢
nah I still think knowing/memorising someone else's verses of a song you learnt two days ago is CRAZYDHD like idc sure in the long run but two days???????? when ur trying to memorise ur own lines and new choreo is crazy
Tbh I think that’s what idols have to do incase a member falls I’ll or can’t perform you will have to re learn a new choreo and learn the lines of the person missing within a day sometimes
But is it really? This is essentially their job/major. Students memorize 200 pages of pdfs in two days or write 5 essays in two days. This is the same thing, just a different kind of memorising in terms of dancing. But memorising one song is really nothing if you think about it.
@butterfliesonmymind705 Totally agree with you there. It's what is expected of them. If they can't do that simple task, then I don't know what else can they do when they debut.
Memorising song lyrics is incredibly easy. A normal person should be able to do it at the same level as these trainees. If you are having that much difficulty with that to think of it as crazy, then I recommend you should get checked out, cause there are illnesses that can cause that. - Have performed in singing, coming from a "musical" family with a professional violinist parent taught in the traditional way. Lyrics, music, classical and traditional performances are very familiar to me.
I’m new to Kpop and trainees and all that but after watching Korean tv shows and dramas I just wanted to ask if it’s common for everyone to have Botox? Or as a culture are they relatively expressionless facial wise compared to Western and African countries when people speak. Especially the forehead / eyes areas. I know it’s not all of them of course but I definitely notice. (I’m South African btw)
Listen let me tell you Gen Z don’t care 😂😂 I can see the judges are trying soo hard to scare them because that’s how their training days were, but the generation of today they aren’t phased 😂😂
![[C.C.] Soyeon Teacher Gets Extremely Angry😡 at the Chaotic Stage 🔥 #GIDLE #SOYEON](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5ivIdPw1ox8/mqdefault.jpg)
![[I-LAND2/3회 하이라이트] 미친 고음🎤과 비주얼✨이 만들어낸 파노라마📷 l 매주 목요일 저녁 8시 50분](/img/1.gif)
They deserved to hear the criticism. Being the top trainees means higher expectations and at this point in the show, you gotta start fighting harder but not memorizing the lyrics is really critical.
Gurl I did not like the judges
@@Imnotarcoyea☠️😊
But the people who are scolded here still have better live vocals than Moka and Iroha who can't even sing 2 words
It's a shame they're being called idols
@@vanlock9the songs are not in their range it’s not their fault hybe can’t pick good songs for then
@@vanlock9just watch their performance with jyp
Fans need to realize that criticisms like this is every important for their idols to grow. They don't need to be "babied" at all times, because when they debut, they will hear more cruel words esp. these days that the internet is literally everywhere. If they don't have strong foundation or mentality to handle such things, they won't be able to survive the real world. Jo-Kwon, out of all the judges, is my favorite. He gives great feedback when he sees improvement but at the same time, uses his sharp tongue to advise trainees.
Exactly, without constructive critism, they won't be able to get better and better. Learning never stops and hearing only good things won't let you see your full potential. If you think the way the judges judged were unfair then that means you only want to hear what you want to hear. These judges actually take their time to focus on every detail and mentor these trainees, they didn't hate on them just for fun. They wouldn't want those trainees to debut just to get bashed by netizens, they want the trainees to be able to show their fans that they do deserved their spots.
Yes! It's just very ridicilous that some fans cannot accept that their favs. are being scolded like they're already perfect idols. These mentors know best the performance especially what needs to be improved.
@@sun00305 this is how you know so many commenters are still children, they think constructive criticisms = hate
But in this show, it seems as if the judges are criticizing for dramatic effect. like take lee hyun smth guy for example he will just completely shit on older trainees if they make small mistakes but for younger trainees with good visuals he will be biased and say they at least improved no matter what! and when they criticize, they don't really give good feedback, they just scold. that's why some trainees are losing confidence and some completely crashed (like Iris). and I feel like judges can be judges w/o actually scold and making a face the whole time, take Soyeon, Seungyoon, Woozi as a guest judge and JYP for eg
@@iris7879 idk how nice mentors have to be for you guys to be satisfied bc i sure do think trainees need to be humbled and made aware of room for improvement no matter how "good" you as an audience think they are. as a fan of kpop since 2008, i can assure you that the judges are nowhere as bad as yall make them out to be (not that i think the idol treatment in the past generations are perfect).
ofc guest judges like woozi will come off abit nicer because they literally dont know the girls and are only appearing for 1 episode, it shouldn't be compared to judges who know the weakness and strengths of the girls.
i am not defending the judges bc i also dont agree with everything they've said (jiwoo's my pick and they nitpick on her skills too) but fans need to realise that they don't see or hear everything the judges do so we cannot assume that we know any better than them.
p.s. iris really did need the feedback to have a reality check, her attitude and skills were really not it. i'm sure with more time and training she'll be more ready to debut in the future :)
Jo Kwon trained for 8 to 10 years before he debuted, so he knows how intense the training is, and he gives the right criticism so the trainees won't make the same mistakes again.
LOL they took the lyrics of the song to heart. They all didn't care 🤣😂
I understand your comment after a few seconds😂😂
@@tehhoaiss hahaha ❤❤❤
if the fans are angry at these judges when they give constructive criticisms to the trainees then they have never met SM idols as Mentors/judges because when SM Idols appears as mentors/judges they give brutal criticisms and scolds the trainees, whenever they saw the trainees make any mistakes that can be avoided with proper practices and concenterations
Jokwon debuted under jyp and one thing that he learnt from jyp is that jyp hates trainees/singers who didn't memorized lyrics the most. That's why jokwon scolded the girls in here. It's to show how passionate you are as a singer. It's an attitude problem an individual has to fix. You have to discipline yourself.
Not just only because of jyp but it's professionalism
jyp should hate singers who cant sing too but he dubuted momo and itzy so...
@@mewsaooh please shut up!
@@mewsaowe talking about lyrics not singing ability? 🤨
@@mewsaomomo and Izty can sing they just have songs that don't match their vocal range. Its too high for them. Every singer has a vocal range Jyp knows it but doesn't seem to care.
the problem I feel is that the top trainees do badly in training because they think they are the cream of the crop (hence they slacked till scolded by the judges) and then they picked up the pace again; which is alarming for potential idols...
(i want to start by saying this is my opinion ;-;) but what u said made blackpink pop up in my head (｡ŏ﹏ŏ)
Wow, the judge actually did great job at correction the girls... They told them their mistake and how to be better... Thats how survival show should be....
And Goddess Gyuri is just beautiful as ever....
those criticisms were valid and trust me they were not as harsh as those you will get in the actual industry
Minju was a YG trainee, so it makes sense how she performed 2NE1's song so well!
I cant sing a single note but even still I watch some of these audition shows scratching my head wondering if we are both listening to the same thing. This was brutal but honest, if they sound like crap now when the public and media get to them it will be worse and the stress of more songs will get to them. They had really brutal honest comments from the judges and whilst I dont know the others I do know Lee Hyun and Jo Kwon and they have outstanding vocals and know there stuff......
i love minju's voice. She has such character in her voice.
It is funny how in this kind of show, 'fans' upset how judge being harsh when later once they debut, the 'fans' would be harsher
The thing is, this song is a staple for the heart of Kpop. And it's not like they're doing a hard choreo and they're all Korean so memorising lyrics should be easier for then. So it's bit disappointing to have trainees , supposed to be at the top to be slacking. Because if you're one of the bests, you should always be wary and practice hard.
Literally what happened now to Illit 💀
They should have practiced in the pre-debut. Vocally speaking, expert Minjae Jung was very disappointed. They have a long way to go until they are vocally pleasant.
The most basics is to sing your recorded parts and if you can't do that you're not a professional rookie. That's an area Illit needs to improve according to him.
No member really stands out to him in the debut. He wants to praise Minju for her unique voice but she is not a good vocalist, she has potential to become a good vocalist if she practices.
Wonhee stands out to him when it came to expressive ability. She had the shortest time of training which impressed him.
Overall the grade is quite low for him because they lacked basics in this debut. He hopes to see improvements for the comeback and show him their professional side by taking their job serious.
I can't agree with him more. If they had the basics they wouldn't get bashed by netizens in the first place. We can blame this on Bang PD and Belift who didn't take vocal lessons to their hearts. Hybe has been controversial when it comes to provide heavy vocal training for their girl groups. MHJ put effort into that with NewJeans so they never got the same shitty treatment as Lesserafim and Illit. So their vocals turned out decent, not great or good, just average decent.
Fromis_9 was signed to Off The Record so they were provided vocal training before they joined Pledis.
GFriend was trained by Source Music when they were small and not a label to Hybe. So this is probably a management problem at Hybe.
The problem is the fans are always being angry at everything. Criticisms are needed for someone's growth. If you keep pampering and babying someone, he/she would never grow to their max potentials. No pain no gain
This is way too tame vs the criticisms they give to trainees off cam.
"DO YOU WANT TO DO THIS OR NOT?" "DO YOU WANT TO QUIT?" "WE CAN REPLACE YOU WITH ANOTHER TRAINEE, THERE ARE HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF YOU" and my personal fave "DID YOUR PARENTS NOT TEACH YOU WELL?"
Wow these judges and the video itself is BRUTALLY HONEST
I hear some yg blood in minju's vocal deym that yg swag and vocal technique is really her weapon to fame, I hope hybe wont remove that from her cause that technique really suits her. I heard a mix of CL, Rosé and lee hi in her perf
This was recommended to me and after watching this, i just hope minjoo girl debuts. She sounded so good and she like actually shines. lol
She did!!
@@Leila-dw3gy thank you for the update. Soooo glad she did!!!
Criticism should flow normally as it motivates them to do their work properly. However, being dependent on criticism, orders, and slacking off just because you've reached a certain stage where your talents have been recognized.. immediatley puts you at the bottom.
Jihyun face doesn't look akward though i feel the sincerity of her smile she looks like she's having fun.
I liked how the judges were super harsh on them, they can at least put in effort
2:40 mark, Bang Jeemin from the upcoming Wake One first ever permanent girl group Izna (formed thru I-LAND 2024: N/a) got called as least impressive in Team I Don't Care (Green Team) on this mission when she competed on R U NEXT? last year.
While even though I am a jeemin Stan I do agree if you watched the show, jeemin at rehearsals missed the beat and her dictation was poor. Though she improved on stage
And not to mention it's a classic kpop song. The standard is already so high. They were way to lax in their rehearsal and definitely needed a reality check.
Jihyun ate the rest of them up in stability and presence, I don't really get how they're being judged
Finally jihyun support too
fr the whole voting thing and levels is so silly
This comment is late but I had to say this, you have to remember the stages have heavily edited vocals to make all of the girls look better. Like very edited, in some stages they sound really robotic. The only non edited parts we get are the mid-term evaluations and some little clips through the episode. Jihyun sounded stable to you due to the editing, but the judges hear it live and also have an earpiece to hear it clearly so they know if they sang well or not. So most likely she was unstable, similar to the mid-term
Believe me the performance you see here is the edited version mentors rare the real voice that's why they criticised
even if they only had a couple hours practice they should forsure have all the lyrics memorized, its the easiest part
minjoo voice wooww
The criticism made them work harder and show their grate talent
I can’t believe how stable Ji-hyun’s voice sounds while doing chest pumps 😮
Confused Jeemin is so cute 0:28
Im waiting for R U Next debut❤
I haven't watched the show, but at least for me the ones who i noticed more in their performance was Min Joo and Ji Hyun
min joo ate this UPPPPPPPPP
idk what they were expecting like theyre going to debut in a top company and popularity is basically ensured so ofc they will be judged harshly plus there was basically no dancing how can they sound like that.
Watching this REMIND ME OF YANG HYUN SUK IN YG ,A PRODUCER WITH A EYE OF A GEM,,HE CRITIZED TRAINEE BUT TO MAKE THEM GOOD IT'S UP TO THE TRAINEE TO TAKE GIS WORD IN A GOOD WAY OR NOT AND LOOK EVERY YG ARTIST IS SO TALENTED WHEN THEY ARE FACING THE CRUEL WORLD,,,
Now I wanna hear the judges comment about their final lineup (I'llit) encore performance.
They should scold them. Vocally speaking, expert Minjae Jung was very disappointed. Sing your parts like the recorded version are basics you need to craft.
Because of Hybe's mismanagement of their girl groups they have a long way to go until they are vocally pleasant.
No member didn't really stand out to him in the debut. Minju was not a good vocalist, but has a high potential to become a good vocalist if she practices.
Wonhee stand out to him when it came to expressive ability. She had the shortest time of training.
Overall the debut is a very low score to him because they lack basics. Especially in the vocal department he wants to see improvements. Even rookies need to be professional by taking their job serious. It doesn't make excuse for lack of basics. Illit are amateurs to him after this debut so if they want to change they better get practice.
I am pretty sure it's hybe who chose the lineup not judges cuz as per I know the judges would never select idols who can't sing
Wow it's hard. Keep going forward, girls. You got it!
Minjoo give me YG vibes
she was former yg trainee lol
I love the judges
Literally the standards when Jo kwon was a trainee were so strict and these days the trainees are all… a mess
Honestly beat cover ive seen of 2ne1
Take note here, any trainee in Korea Have to go through hash trainee season . Rmb the only time when they can make mistake is when they are a trainee . I believe many of u saw ur favourite kpop idols get criticise by almost everyone for doing a minimum mistake . And most of these criticisms from their trainers ar important. Since is also builds them . Many of you were aware no matter how good the idols are there will always be hates . All these trainee are there to be judge from them professional . Is like if u cannot take this blow you can’t be an idols tbh
Minjoo voices really had character same like rei from ive ...
I feel like the criticism helped them alot and they ended up improving!
i can undersand the judge here... Has Jihyun always been that attractive?? WOW
I can’t take jo Kwon serious with those eye brows 🌝
The performance was actually nice tbh
no it wasnt
Hate the judges all you want but don't forget that this is a survival show, in order to debut they need to learn the hard way and survive so they can be the best idols. Besides the judges are professionals and experienced they know what they are doing. It's just that the editing really sucks.
Finally, almost every show i seen judges had been delusional. I can tell you kniw forgetting the lyrics wasn't the only issue.
I think the people in the comment section sitting at home should leave it to the professionals to judge 😂😂
You and ppl who likes your comment are the reason that idol didn’t improve their singing and dancing.bcoz they know that fans like you can protect them in whatever cost.they all are top trainees and judges expectations are higher compared to other groups.this performance are bad.really bad.if they continue like this,knetizen will eat them alive.
Fans need to realised the kpop industry is gotta be tough and the reason why he was so strict to them cause he want them to improved and do better if they want make it to debut and kpop industry is tough he been in the industry snice 2008 for 15 years he was struggling with 2am cause jyp and hybe formerly used bighit was struggling of bankruptcy if u guys don't know they have coed manged by bighit and jyp.
How can korean forget about famous lyrics like" 2ne1's I don't care"
2:34 MINJUS SIDE EYE LOLLLL
these are the most creative ways of criticism i have ever heard 😂oml, i hope they take the advice and work harder! fighting~
If minjoo doesnt debut im gonna rant
2ne1 songs are hard to perform.
This is what happens when you place visuals over dance and singing.
Honestly if i was in r u next and if i was still there after some episodes like 7,8,9 i wouldnt even try i wouod just give up ❤
Constructive criticism is needed for every idol. Even if they decided to lipsync for every live performance they'll have in the future, they'll still look bad if their lips aren't sync to the lyrics.
I think hyewon was in the most critical and difficult position tbh. Imagine getting 2-3 lines and they all are high notes but your charm is not in “high note”, it must be so burden that ppl can’t see you much bc you are always behind and barely get to be in the middle and you don’t have lines to shine.. poor hyewon, if they gave her the part she wished for, she would deffo would do better bc she had the potential for it.
2:50
You’ve never been this criticized in her life? She never had an Asian parent yelling at her to do better at math? Never had her parent yell at her? Never had a teacher being strict? Makes sense why she’s a baby.
youngseo visual is insane
Look honestly after seeing some controversy about these shows idk what to believe. Some of the PD’S make contestants act a sort of way for views. Its always for views.
Entendí algunos puntos,por ejemplo cuando veo a New Jeans en especial Hanni ella siempre está con la misma energía en el baile, expresión facial y canto aunque no esté en el centro,es decir debes de disfrutar de todo el baile y no solo actuar de esa manera cuando la cámara te enfoca.Tal como lo hace Ji Min,creo que hay mucho potencial en todas ellas pero si o si deben disfrutar de su presentación,es como si tú trabajo fuera alegrar y llamar la atención del público con tu actuación,es tu trabajo y debes saber realizarlo a la perfección.Parece cruel pero algunos profesores también me lo mencionaban en mis clases,uno puede esforzarse mucho pero sino logras cumplir tu objetivo ese tiempo invertido desaparece,más que todo es enfocarte en tu meta y ser constante,eso es muy importante.
Yassss jokwon mothering
They are a mess. 😂
Guri jo kwon ❤
im glad they prove after those criticism. The before performance was so bad.
I was a Hyewon bias and this stage was what made me the most upset. Hope she gets the chance to debut in the future
These are more likely staged for “screen time,” though.
They need yg criticism for them to be good 😂
I know it's late but Minju was a yg trainee.
In he is really strict
ugh my blackjack heart. How dare you butcher that song 🤣
Edit: I was commenting as I watched. They definitely redeemed themselves at the end there!
This here is exactly why there's the saying, ' Only YG artists can sing YG songs. ' I cringed all throughout watching this even when I didn't want or expect to then again, ROOM TO GROW and GET BETTER. OMG...never thought I'd see the day when 2nd Generation Kpop Artists grow up so fast and evolve into judges. They were just kids when I met them. Saranghae, 2nd Gen!
one girl there is literally an ex-yg, but ok.
@@JeanYouLuckyBoishe didnt debut in yg for a reason
please grow up 🙏🏽
They're on a television show, i doubt they aren't all trying their hardest so maybe there is another reason besides "laziness". Were they not given enough time to practice
None of them (except Minju) debuted in ILLIT tho they were top trainees...
Evil edit made its business?
well youngseo was going to debut with them but left
I though u said “why jo-kwon ugly” hahahah
their face expressions are good judges dont see wonhee...
If you can't support don't try to take them down
@@BlackpinkJenniekim-tw6zc its just a fact they are judges they have to be equal to everyone they shouldnt have a bias
@@cansnbkey I know but wonhee haters are really too much they so toxic to just a 16 years old girl.
And there no prove judge bias over wonhee.
In every photos or videos about ru next
The topic is whatever wonhee hater always put wonhee in.
If someone made videos about chanelle, minju, himena, iroha etc haters always compared and say about bad things to wonhee
wonhee is not others wonhee is wonhee don't always compared with others
judges r more worried about singing quite literally bc theyre SINGERS ofc stage prescence is important but like they can improve over time (ex: aespa)
Toxic af get help
It sounds prerecorded.
Min -joo sound like rośe ❤
nah that one moustache judge needs to know how to give critics properly.. he's laughing like that makes people pumped up i swear
Hindi pa nila nakikilala si Papa YG 😅
Hye-won part omg why so sort 😂
🇩🇿🇰🇷👀👌🏼Their voices are wonderful frankly and they tire a lot with the dance
Most active idols have pre-recorded their vocals (there is only a few idols currently sing and dance at the same time) -
@@RoyLimisAw3s0meSince when did they started doing that?? During pandemic??
Kara jo kwon ❤
@@andredaniel6658 most of the idols; depending on how hard the chorography of the dance
@@andredaniel6658 A bit before the pandemic is when the preference of visuals and dance over live vocals began taking over and was officially cemented into practice with 4th gen.
The only artists I know to be very reliable with singing live vocals at every show are all 2nd gen, early 3rd gen or bands. The few 4th gen artists I can think of to atleast make an actual effort to sing with live vocals are all soloists, with most of them being ex-group members.
These days fans don't care about actual music or artistry. All you need is a pretty face and some dance. True, visuals have been important through all of the generations, but the emphasis on good looks has only peaked.
Been an active listener and participant in the Korean music industry since like 2011 or so, which is 2nd gen. Everything has only gone downhill.
gurl already practiced to using MR 😅
Jo Kwon is mother to me
in the end, the green team perform beautifully, but the judge still thinks that the performance is not that good. lol
I think hybe don't focus on their trainees. They only focus on debut 4 to 5 groups in one years that's why their trainers lack skill
Bukan suara asli full, ini pakai suara yg uda direkam sebelumnya juga..
Wah...baru tahu acara audisi pakai suara rekaman..😅😅
Minjoo gives me hanni vibes
If SHE became mentor...Maybe its make this show more interesting...she not just giving advice and critism but giving the example how to do it properly
Ik this would be deserved to realise ur mistakes, but if I was one of them I would burst out crying and tear up in like 3 seconds damn that was harsh-
Seems like they forgot to take criticism to their hearts and get better. Now they got bashed from their first encore by netizens and now it's a witch hunt on Illit 😢
้เพลงนี้ผมฟัง สมัยวัยรุ่น ตอนนี้แก่แล้ว34ปี🐱😸😻
nah I still think knowing/memorising someone else's verses of a song you learnt two days ago is CRAZYDHD like idc sure in the long run but two days???????? when ur trying to memorise ur own lines and new choreo is crazy
Tbh I think that’s what idols have to do incase a member falls I’ll or can’t perform you will have to re learn a new choreo and learn the lines of the person missing within a day sometimes
But is it really? This is essentially their job/major. Students memorize 200 pages of pdfs in two days or write 5 essays in two days. This is the same thing, just a different kind of memorising in terms of dancing. But memorising one song is really nothing if you think about it.
@butterfliesonmymind705 Totally agree with you there. It's what is expected of them. If they can't do that simple task, then I don't know what else can they do when they debut.
Memorising song lyrics is incredibly easy. A normal person should be able to do it at the same level as these trainees. If you are having that much difficulty with that to think of it as crazy, then I recommend you should get checked out, cause there are illnesses that can cause that.
- Have performed in singing, coming from a "musical" family with a professional violinist parent taught in the traditional way. Lyrics, music, classical and traditional performances are very familiar to me.
But you need to understand it's a part of their job
علاوي حبيب قلبي ابو حسين 🙂
dont they autotune the performances ?
I’m new to Kpop and trainees and all that but after watching Korean tv shows and dramas I just wanted to ask if it’s common for everyone to have Botox? Or as a culture are they relatively expressionless facial wise compared to Western and African countries when people speak. Especially the forehead / eyes areas.
I know it’s not all of them of course but I definitely notice. (I’m South African btw)
It's maybe not botox but some people talk without expression in general
Listen let me tell you Gen Z don’t care 😂😂 I can see the judges are trying soo hard to scare them because that’s how their training days were, but the generation of today they aren’t phased 😂😂
Wonhee giving side eye being the worst there 😧
well no
She’s actually one of the better singers like I was shocked. Stage presence is another story but she isn’t untalented.
She was a better singer than all of the IDC team except Minju, def not "the worst there"
Jo kwon is the only good judge on this show tbh
Nope. They all are good in their own. They just cut out some comment they made
pls help where can i watch ep 8