liz's voice is really beautiful and angelic. However, I was surprised by Gaeul's voice. In this video, you can enjoy the emotional atmosphere and their wonderful voices :D
Liz's vocal is beautiful as usual, but I really want to praise Gaeul... Not only the lyrics she wrote but also her underrated vocal talent😢 Gaeul has always been a quiet but hard-working child. Now she has the opportunity to show it. I am happy for her. Thanks to Starship give her a chance to show this❤
The fact that Liz's vocals and visuals are just insane 🔥✨ and gaeul has self written that whole part or rap she sang 💪❤️😭 SHOWS THEIR TALENT AND LOVE 🫂❤️
누가 하자고 했는지 알것 같은ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 근데 진짜 너무 잘했네요😮😮😮 리즈 음색이 노래에 정말 잘 어울리고 가을도 평소 차분한 분위기랑 잘 어울려서 가사가 마치 가을 님이 하는 말 같아요.. 태연 님도 좋아하실 거라는 생각이 드네요👍 앞으로도 이런 커버곡들 많이 올려주면 좋겠어요!💜💜
There’s something so magical about Liz’s voice, her vocals sound like they belong in fairytales. Truly a siren, so enchanting! And Gaeullll, to be able to write a rap for a song that wasn’t hers originally, and make it blend sooo seamlessly! She’s so talented, always leaves me in awe ❤
Everytime gaeul receive undeserved treatment from sse, i would comfort myself saying sse just keeping her talent for the future 😂 lets wait until next year and see if she will get what she deserved 😢😢
투엑스 넘 좋아해서 기대하면서 들었는데 기대한것보다 훨씬 좋아서 깜짝 놀랐어요! 특히 1:00 이후 추가된 새로운 파트 듣고 소름돋았어요. 편곡이나 변주된 멜로디도 좋지만 가사내용이 예술이네요. 주인공이 묵묵히 본인 심정을 토로하면서 자신을 까다롭고 힘든 아이라고 했던 x의 말을 비웃기라도 하듯이 이제서야 나인것 같다는 마지막 가사에서 전율이ㄷㄷㄷ 게다가 이렇게 겨울이 고스란히 느껴지는 영상까지 촬영해주셔서 그 고민과 노력, 재능에 박수를 보냅니다👏👏👏 그리고 썸머필름에서도 느꼈지만...가을님 분위기 장난 아니네요~연기해도 되겠어요👍
We waited so long for a Gaeul feature and when it is her time to shine, she stepped up to the plate and delivered spectacularly. That voice and writing her own rap, my god, she can do it all❤😊
@@mini1297 I've never listened to the original song before listening to this cover, but according to the comments: she wrote her own rap lyrics for this.
Liz has to be the best vocalist of this generation her voice is just so out of this world in every way and to see Gaeul actually singing and rapping finally get to see her potential and talent 😍
gaeul is an all rounder and none of you can tell me otherwise. shes so pretty perfect and talented. she can dance, sing, rap and even part takes in song writing. i absolutely love how liz and gaeul sound together >
Same. Their voices are so vastly different. Gaeul’s voice has attitude and style while Liz’s is soothing and gentle. They really need to make more together. Would love hearing one where Gaeul raps for her parts (Liz singing of course).
listening to this at least one times a day, still obsessed with gaeul's rap part, i hope rapper gaeul will be back in the next era. her rap part in ive songs are all iconic
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
Gaeul said that she's loves seeing Liz when she's singing, and now they're both has a chance to cover a song, nice job!
It's true, I'm excited to hear them both. ❤
0:21 초에서 진짜 고막 녹을뻔... 리즈가 존경하는 태연선배님 노래를 리메이크 하다니 미춋다.... 이런거 너무 좋다구여....아니 사랑한다구여...🥺💗
LIZ's voice is the definition of *PERFECTION* ✨
GAEUL's voice is the definition of *SATISFACTION* ✨
@JwisiejejeI know that 😊
they have very unique voices, which I find refreshing.
リズの純粋な歌声と、ガウルの何かを諦めたような歌声が対照的で凄く惹きつけられる
Gaeul looks so actress here. And Liz shine like a soloist. I hope both could have chance to hone their talents
透き通って溶けるようなリズちゃんの天然水みたいな声と、エッジが効いていて気だるげなガウルちゃんの炭酸水みたいな声の、二人の歌声の相性が良すぎる...
炭酸水という表現がとても素敵です✨
리즈는 진짜 잠잘때 들으면 반할 목소리고 가을은 모닝에 들으면 진짜 행복할것같아 ㅠㅠ❤️🔥
가을 Hello to my x 음색 치인다.. 그리고 자작랩..
貴重なガウルのボーカル
幸せすぎる❤
Liz voice really calm and gaeul voice at the end really sweet
liz's voice is really beautiful and angelic.
However, I was surprised by Gaeul's voice.
In this video, you can enjoy the emotional atmosphere and their wonderful voices :D
OMG!! MY BIAS LINE GAEULIZ 🥺😍🤩🥰
I LOVE BOTH OF THEM SO MUCHHH
아니ㅠㅠㅠ리즈음색좋은건 알고있었는데,😢😢가을음색미춌다!!!❤❤❤❤❤❤
深夜これ聞きながら歩くの気持ちよすぎて自分の全てがエモくなった気分になれる
めっちゃ分かる
リズの声は天然記念物並みに唯一無二で美しくて透き通っている。、
Liz's vocal is beautiful as usual, but I really want to praise Gaeul... Not only the lyrics she wrote but also her underrated vocal talent😢
Gaeul has always been a quiet but hard-working child. Now she has the opportunity to show it. I am happy for her. Thanks to Starship give her a chance to show this❤
I hope people stop judging gaeuls voice
@@mini1297 fr
@@mini1297 they will if they hear marigold covered by her
오ㅏ 가을이 음색 찰떡이다 여리면서 악센트 있는목소리 가리비즈는 사랑입니다❤
リズの綺麗な高音にガウルの少し低い歌声最高❤
ahhh i never expected a cover from both Gaeul and Liz. this is too good
2人にこの雰囲気の相性抜群では…
超大好き。
how is this not popular??? i cant get enough of liz's vocal, no matter how much ive listened to it😭 gaeul's highnote as well?? pls sm take them
I love this cover too, Liz's voice and Gaeul's rap, but which Gaeul's highnote did you talk about?
@@SoshiKyo at 1:30 ! i think it would kind of count as a highnote
@@berryhae7079aint no high note lmao but she still did great
OHHH i thought liz did the adlibs
Because no one cares about these two. Ppl only care about Wonyoung LOL
The fact that Liz's vocals and visuals are just insane 🔥✨ and gaeul has self written that whole part or rap she sang 💪❤️😭 SHOWS THEIR TALENT AND LOVE 🫂❤️
누가 하자고 했는지 알것 같은ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
근데 진짜 너무 잘했네요😮😮😮
리즈 음색이 노래에 정말 잘 어울리고
가을도 평소 차분한 분위기랑 잘 어울려서 가사가 마치 가을 님이 하는 말 같아요..
태연 님도 좋아하실 거라는 생각이 드네요👍
앞으로도 이런 커버곡들 많이 올려주면 좋겠어요!💜💜
진짜 잘했어 최고
Did Gaeul write her own rap? Whoa this is so good 😮
Liz&Gaeul unexpected duo
Is To.X song by Taeyeon unnie.....Cover by Liz and Gaeul
@@LalalalisaPark_myeah but Gaeul wrote some of her parts
I never would’ve expected the Gaeul/Liz combo either
@@LalalalisaPark_mthe rap part on this cover was self written by Gaeul
@@kyleoliver637same i was expecting liz x rei since liz is main vocalist and rei is main rapper
Gaeul wrote her rap verse herself?!! So impressive, and Liz's angelic voice too!!
大好き…
ガウルの感情鬼乗せTo.x天才過ぎる
liz's voice is angelic as always, but gaeul's is so calming. the most soothing voice of the group
@Jwisiejeje이서영상 가세요
I can see Liz pursuit as a solo while Gaeul pursuit as an actress
It matches them❤
Gaeul looks like an actress❤
리즈가 솔로로 활동하는것도 좋을거 같네요ㅎ
Liz is so alternative artist coded
근데, 왠지 리즈랑 가을이
서로 씬 찍은 거 같아.
왜냐하면 리즈 때는 조금 차분하다가,
가을씬이 되자 웃참 하려다가
흔들린 장면들이 있고, 어떤 씬들은 리즈밖에
못 찍을거 같아서.
아닐 수도 있고😂😂
와 진짜 목소리 미친다..와 녹는다 녹아
There’s something so magical about Liz’s voice, her vocals sound like they belong in fairytales. Truly a siren, so enchanting! And Gaeullll, to be able to write a rap for a song that wasn’t hers originally, and make it blend sooo seamlessly! She’s so talented, always leaves me in awe ❤
ガウルの声良すぎる…❤
深みがある?ような唯一無二の声ほんとにずっと聴ける
うわ…あまりに合いすぎて鳥肌が立った。ちょっと短すぎない？もっと必要です！！ガリビーズの時代❤❤
THEY SOUND SO WELL TOGETHER! Angelic Voices of Liz and Gaeul
Liz and Gaeul’s Vocals are so beautiful✨Could literally go on my bike riding along the city river at night to this song💜
@Jwisiejeje이서영상 가세요
やっぱガウルの声はこういう中低音のしっとりゆったりした切ない曲が合うよなあ、、
めちゃくちゃ綺麗で最高
다음 앨범에는 이렇게 유닛단위 곡도 몇 곡 담아주면 좋겠네요! 리즈 보컬은 정말 안정적이고 감미롭고~ 가을은 완전히 독보적인 음색과 분위기로 자작랩을 멋지게 써냈네요~ 매우 만족~!!!
진짜 유닛곡 담아주면 좋겠어요
liz voice is so beautiful💗💗💗💗
Gaeul all rounder ,she not just good as rapper ,dancer also vocal too , i need more Gaeul being vocalist please starship
Everytime gaeul receive undeserved treatment from sse, i would comfort myself saying sse just keeping her talent for the future 😂 lets wait until next year and see if she will get what she deserved 😢😢
가을아ㅜㅜ❤❤ 고마워 연습많이 했구나
2人の声がめっちゃ染みる
2人の魅力が凝縮された3分間だった。
AS USUAL THEIR VOICES ARE SO SOOTHING 😭🤍🫂
투엑스 넘 좋아해서 기대하면서 들었는데 기대한것보다 훨씬 좋아서 깜짝 놀랐어요!
특히 1:00 이후 추가된 새로운 파트 듣고 소름돋았어요. 편곡이나 변주된 멜로디도 좋지만 가사내용이 예술이네요. 주인공이 묵묵히 본인 심정을 토로하면서 자신을 까다롭고 힘든 아이라고 했던 x의 말을 비웃기라도 하듯이 이제서야 나인것 같다는 마지막 가사에서 전율이ㄷㄷㄷ
게다가 이렇게 겨울이 고스란히 느껴지는 영상까지 촬영해주셔서 그 고민과 노력, 재능에 박수를 보냅니다👏👏👏
그리고 썸머필름에서도 느꼈지만...가을님 분위기 장난 아니네요~연기해도 되겠어요👍
リズの透き通る儚い声とガウルのちょっと喉にかかるような耳に残る声が最高だよ💗
We all have to admit how underrated yet precious Gaeul’s vocals are
Also this matches Liz’s calm vibe so much
They really never disappoint
I hope starship will give her a chance to show us her vocal in the next comeback
We waited so long for a Gaeul feature and when it is her time to shine, she stepped up to the plate and delivered spectacularly. That voice and writing her own rap, my god, she can do it all❤😊
I hope she got more and more popular she is my bais
MY GIRL GAEUL IS SO TALENTED AND PASSIONATE ABOUT MUSIC
@Jwisiejeje좋은 정보 감사해요
@JwisiejejeI will watch it for sure
너무 예쁘고 잘한다... 가을이 가사도 좋아 요즘 엄청 바쁜데 다이브들이 커버 원하는 거 눈치채고 영상까지 찍어온 게 감동
I don't understand Korean but did she sing the same words of the song or she changed
@@mini1297 I've never listened to the original song before listening to this cover, but according to the comments: she wrote her own rap lyrics for this.
@@The_Real_Yang_Injang
Yeah I checked the original song gaeul wrote a part of the cover she is so talented
Amazing vocals
Amazing visual
Amazing clip
Jast perfection
ビジュが最高に良いだけではなく、最高に歌もうまいからほんと沼にはまるしかない
ガウルの魅力をもっとたくさんの人に届きますように
Can I ask you something is gaeul popular in Japan?😢
@@mini1297 In Japan, Gaeul seems to be more popular than in Korea. Gaeul has a beautiful face that Japanese like.
@@animo_animo so glad to hear that ❤️
미쳣다 리즈,가을선배!!!! 이 노래 조아하는지 어케알구 일케 딱 커버를 하ㅜㅜㅜ🥹🥹 ㄹㅇ 갓기들이다 음색봐바요ㅜㅜㅜ 우주체강조합 ㄷㄷ
Liz has to be the best vocalist of this generation her voice is just so out of this world in every way and to see Gaeul actually singing and rapping finally get to see her potential and talent 😍
Liz is the best 4th gen female singer.
@@NRam-ke6csLiz is a good singer but not as Hum Yunjin.., Lily,Ningning..
@@quazikabir546she’s better than yunjin
@@smth1203of course Liz is better than ive's Yujin . But she's not better than lesserafim's Yunjin..
Bffr@@smth1203
OH they brought back dive into ive covers!!! We are so here for it!!!
この曲マジ好き…！
リズの透明感とガウルの中毒性ある声でリピート止まらん
1:00 "Hello to my x" 이부분 넘 좋고 1:24 허 이부분 너무 지림 0:19 "하지만 내 일기가 재미 없어진 이유" 이부분 너무 좋다 스타쉽 일 잘했다 가을이랑 리즈 잘 뽑았다 가리비즈 사랑해
リズの声が透明感あって女神すぎる、、無限にきけるわ落ち着く
最近、原曲と一緒に毎日聴いてる。頭からずっ〜っと離れない😂
2人とも声が素敵だなあ🫶
Liz's singing really attracts me. I deeply fall in love with her voice❤❤❤
ガウルちゃんの歌声もっと聞きたいよ
この歌声に癒される
ガウルとリズにしかだせない ムードがあってこの曲めっちゃ好き♥
gaeul is an all rounder and none of you can tell me otherwise. shes so pretty perfect and talented. she can dance, sing, rap and even part takes in song writing. i absolutely love how liz and gaeul sound together >
Same. Their voices are so vastly different. Gaeul’s voice has attitude and style while Liz’s is soothing and gentle. They really need to make more together. Would love hearing one where Gaeul raps for her parts (Liz singing of course).
Geaul is so underrated especially from starship
@@mini1297 Don't worry 😊
We all love her..
serious? did you ever listen her singing without computer????????????????
you should see her singing live
@@quazikabir546 yeah that's what matters
TO.Xをカバーしてくれるのは嬉しい！
しかもリズとガウル歌声もう最高すぎる！
OMG!!! Didn't expect a cover song video by Gaeul & Liz!!!
1:04 가을이 최고의 장면. 진짜 미치게 이쁨
리즈 음색 미쳤다 .. 가을은 특유의 느낌 덕분에 노래에 찰떡이네 🫢🌸
마자요❤내 최애 사랑행🐿
Can I ask you something
Is gaeul popular in Korea?😢
I hat the fact that she is so underrated
@@mini1297여섯명중에 제일 인기가 없긴 한데 외국에서는 인기 많은것같아요 미국쪽이나 일본에서
@@하은-p5d
Sad to hear that
But thanks so much for answering me💜
징짜요..☺️☺️
ガウル…最強🎉
OMGGG Gaeul ❤️🔥
어머 가을이랑 리즈 음색 어쩔거야.. 진짜 너무 감미로운 목소리다... 투엑스 노래랑 너무 잘어울리는 음색인 것 같음!
아이브는 멤버별로 음색이 다 개성있고 대중적인 면도 강함. 데뷔 초에 3년정도 활동하면 그룹의 틀이 잡힐거라고 말했듯 이제 많은 부분이 보완되었음. 연차 쌓이면 더 많은걸 기대할 수 있을 거임. 다만 스쉽이 일을 잘해야...
스타쉽은 지금까지 아이브 키워낸걸 보면 하이브 다음으로 잘한다고 봄 중소치고는 기적같은 성과... 다만 카카오가 문제...
요즘 스쉽 정신차린거 같던데
잘 하고 있긴 한데
애들 적당히 좀 굴렸으면 좋겠음
스케줄이 말이 안 됨
스타쉽의 프로듀서들은 모든 사운드를 좋게 만드는 데 능숙하며 그들 중 누구도 보컬을 필요로 하지 않습니다.😂
@@R.P957ok but have u EVER seen their live vocal?🤣🤣
リズの透き通った声とガウル姉さんの力強くも切ない声が好きすぎて最近ずっと聴いてる
우리는 더 많은 커버가 필요해요. 🥹 너무 듣기 좋아요. 우리의 가을과 리즈 ❤
와 리즈언니 음색 짱 좋다💓💓
왤케 목소리가 이쁘죠 전 렝프여도 맂프가 될려라고도 합니다
아니 근데 가을언니 목소리도 무엇인가요 너무 이뻐요!!
스타쉽 사랑하니까 아이브 건강 잘 챙겨요 그리고 원영 유진 말고도 다른 멤버들도 센터 스게 해줘영
맂프 ㄱㅂㅈㄱ❤ 저도 레이가 차애고 리즈가 최애에요
@@대장토끼_08 오 좋았어요 리즈와레이를 공동 쵀애를 할려구요 좋은 조언 감사합니당💗
テヨンちゃんとガウルちゃんのファンなんですけど最高すぎやしませんか？
本当にガウルちゃん初恋顔すぎて、モテてる先輩ガウルちゃんのことを遠くから見てるっていう無い記憶が蘇ってきます…😢
Liz voice is angelic and gaeul voice is sweet
gaeul's voice is so unique i actually love it
Gaeul's self-written rap so impressive!!
@Jwisiejejei will i will i will ❤❤❤❤❤
곧 컴백이고 연말무대 준비하느라 바빴을텐데 팬들 위해서 커버 영상도 자주 올려주고 너무 효녀다 진짜 다이브는 유진이 너무 자랑스러워 고마워❤️
맞아요❤❤
透き通った声と少し鼻にかかった声どっちも心地良すぎて無限リピ
I'm re-watching IVE's covers in late night. Their voice is so good. They desever more famous than this
뭐야 영상보다 깜짝 놀랐네 둘 다 왜 이렇게 이뻐요?!! 노래도 넘 잘 부르고.. 분위기 쩔어,, 실물 보면 이런 느낌일 것 같음
Liz is the princess of vocals and visuals, Ga Eul is the thief of the hearts of all girls, she is so cool
@Jwisiejeje я знаю, слушала это прекрасно❤
DO YOU KNOW HOW MUCH WE MISSED THOSE VIDEOS, STARSHIP????
What videos😭
اغنية.جميلة
@@yqtyc Covers (?)
ガウルとリズ…この2人の質感が良すぎる…2人とも綺麗すぎてエモい雰囲気が刺さりますт т
After LIKEのパートと言い、どことなくガウルのパートは中毒性を引き起こすね✨
liz's part started the song with sad ballad and then gaeul's part turned it into rnb
Gaeul is an all rounder your voice so beautiful
Gaeul’s her own lyrics 🙀
Gaeul part is the new good thing!! Proud of you Gaeul!! And Liz's vocal, too!!
リズの横顔が本当に美しい。
リズの歌声が素晴らしい。
2人の歌声もビジュアルもMVの質感も全部好みすぎる🥲🥲
리즈 가을 각각의 매력이 돋보여서 더 홀렸던 노래 특히 가을선배님의 새로운 매력이 느껴졌어요! 리즈는 항상 너무 잘하고❤
リズは言うまでもなく天使の歌声ですが、ガウルのラッパーではなく、歌手としての歌声が良すぎて驚きました。「フッ」と笑う仕草が好きすぎる😇
listening to this at least one times a day, still obsessed with gaeul's rap part, i hope rapper gaeul will be back in the next era. her rap part in ive songs are all iconic
1:00 여기 진짜 완전 구간 반복 중 개조아 ㅠㅠㅠ
서로 반대인 그 음색이 잘어우러 지는게 너무 듣기가 좋아요
목소리 넘 매력적이양~
Thank you, Gaeul and Liz
Liz sounds so good. I love her voice. Hope she can have OST soon.
liz' voice has such a warm and pleasant tone
i don't know how to explain it in english but yeah her voice is underrated
Its SO underrated. People overlook her voice because she’s in IVE and for some reason people love to hate on IVE lol.
Her tone is the prettiest in their gen imo. Like warm sparkly honey 💛
리즈,가을 음색 넘 좋아요‼️ 원래는 원영 팬이었는데 가을은 음색 좋고,리즈도 춤 잘추고등등 다들 넘 매력있는 멤버들이예요🙀평생 팬할거예요,아이브 너무 사랑해요💤
まじガウル姉さん最高すぎ大好き