Great channel. I'm a Boer from Natal, South Africa. It pains me to let you know that since 1994 not a single monument, battlefield or grave site has been maintained by the state, but guys like me take care of them as well as we can (Boer and Brit). I helped fence off the capture sight of Churchill near Frere. It was disappearing into the veld by the road side. Thanks again for this channel!
Yes, I add my thanks too. My great-grandfather, then Captain William Bolitho, commanded 27th Company, 7th Battalion, Imperial Yeomanry, at the British defeat at Nooitgedacht in December 1900, where he was awarded the Distinuished Service Cross, which he later received personally from King Edward VII. With another company of yeomanry, he was ordered by Brigadier Clements to take his men up a steep 900 foot kloof, and engage the Boers on top of the cliffs of the Magaliesberg range. / Assaulting uphill after a 900 foot climb is likely to be to be something of a forlorn hope, and so it proved, for as Wikipedia puts it "Reinforcements climbing the mountain lost heavily when Beyers' men suddenly poured fire into them". William was wounded, and lay there for 2 days and 2 nights with his men, before being briefly taken prisoner. / I would love to see the story of that battle told in detail! And photographs of the battlefield taken from an infantryman's eyes. I would like to see the battlefield as my great-grandfather saw it that day, in as far as a camera's lens can do it justice. / Boer generals De La Rey and Beyers were there, as well as Jan Smuts, so some great leaders. Their plan was brilliant, as the British dispositions were fatally flawed. The British numbered 1,500, and thought there were insufficient Boers locally to risk an attack, but more Boers arrived. The Wily Boer knew both his ground and his enemy, and struck while the iron was hot, for which the Boers deserve rspect. / The story of this battle needs properly telling! / It always amazes me that within 8 years, Britain handed power back to Boers, and that Botha and Jan Smuts played such a great part in sunsequent events. /
@@zen4men Interesting. I'm a member of a group called OMRS which collects and researches the history of medals. I'm from South Africa originally though living in the USA. I gave a presentation on exactly that battle and the Boer awards for service in the Anglo Boer war last year and was able to metion the exact events you speak of. I'm not sure the exact battlefield is visible now as it was then. Much has chaned and while I'm not there and so had to rely on what pictures I could find online I suspect some of the area might now be covered by the Hendrik Vervoerd Dam.
@@petercollingwood522 Hello Peter! Surely the HV / Gariep dam and Nooitgedacht are 350 or so miles apart? www.google.com/maps/@-25.8716095,27.5345544,7037m/data=!3m1!1e3?hl=en&entry=ttu I know there was a Nooitgedacht POW camp at another ( third ) location, but I do not know of a second battle by the same name. Your mention of this dam suggests we are talking of 2 separate battles? Please advise! /
You forgot to add to your story that when Churchill was captured by the Boers, Churchill strongly protested that he should be treated as a POW and set free because he was a civilian War Correspondent. The Boer General Jan Smuts, who was also the Attorny General of the Transvaal at the time and a friend of Churchill’s father, Lord Randolph Churchill, stepped in and told Churchill that he had better change his tune and accept that he was a POW because if he did not accept that, he would be shot by the Boers as a spy. In later years Churchill confessed that was the best legal advice he had ever received.
I grew up in Pretoria in the '60s and was familiar with the Staatsmodelskool. One story we were told about Churchill's escape was that he had to swim across the Apies river. This was always met with some hilarity as the Apies river is only about 6 inches deep.
That's correct. I'm from Durban but had maternal aunts living in Pretoria in Brecher street just walking distance from the Apies. I remember walking by it as a kid where ran in a concrete canal and never saw more than a trickle. And I recall one of my aunts who had read Churchills book where he apparently says "I crossed the mighty Apies" which caused her much amusement.
Two points of note. Firstly, it's true the British abandoned expanding rifle projectiles (exposed lead tip or hollow point) following the adoption of the Hague Convention. However, that was hardly an end to the matter. The reality is that expanding projectiles are simply much more effective at stopping enemy combatants than conventional full metal jacket projectiles. So, to correct this deficit in stopping power, (and skirt the provisions of the Hague Convention) the British Army introduced the Mk VII .303 cartridge in 1910. This cartridge incorporated a lightweight tip (aluminum, compressed paper or cellulose) beneath the projectile's (phosphor bronze) metal jacket which transferred the projectile's center of gravity further aft. This change in weight distribution caused the projectile to 'tumble' under rapid deceleration resulting in a much-increased wound canal, not greatly dissimilar to that caused by an expanding bullet!! lol. And secondly, I think we should take a moment to reflect on the sheer majesty of Herbert Kitchener's Omdurman mustache. It is, without doubt, one of the great military mustaches of all time.
The Boers also used expanding bullets. The Boers were expert hunters and expanding bullets were useful in bringing down game. The nature of Boer commando units lent itself to ad hoc armament. It was much less feesible for a modern army like the British to deliberately supply non standard ammunition. If the British did use dum dum rounds, the likelihood is they were locally sourced and privately purchased. Therefore there is no evidence of a state sanctioned war crime. Also, the law around the Hague convention is hazy as the Boer Republics never signed it, though they were technically under the 'protection' of the British empire at the time. It could also be argued that many Boer units were not recognised military units, but civilian terrorist or insurgency groups, so it is unclear if the convention applied to them as traditional 'combatants'. Either way, it never went to court.
The expanding bullets were useful in colonial wars, when British soldiers shot directly in the bodies of the adversaries. Same with hunting. It was a bad idea, when your enemy hides on the ground, in foliage or in the cities. It is better to use ammo with more punch-through power. Also, wounded soldiers were more a problem for logistics than dead ones - see 1WW. And all pointy bullets for Mausers or Enfields were supersonic - and these make temporary cavities in the body - much bigger than hollow-point rifle bullets. And then thumbling... Yeah. These honorable rules of war...
“Hero of the Empire” by Candice Millard is a brilliant detailed account of Churchill’s capture and escape from Pretoria which aided in securing his seat for Oldham on his second attempt. His books covering the Boer War: “London to Ladysmith via Pretoria”, “Ian Hamilton’s March” and “My Early Life” are priceless pieces of literature. Simon Ward should have received a film award for his performance in Richard Attenborough’s Young Winston.
Yep. Churchill was a war hero several times over. Participated in the last cavalry charge in British history. Predicted the "Gestapo" these "Socialists" would become. The River War by Winston Churchill. (Read both single and two-volume books) The Malakand Field Force by Winston Churchill. Churchill's Trial: Winston Churchill and the Salvation of Free Government by Larry P. Arnn. Thoughts and Adventures by Winston Churchill. The Man-Eaters of Tsavo by Lt. Colonel J.H. Patterson, D.S.O. The Seven Lives of Colonel Patterson: How an Irish Lion Hunter Led the Jewish Legion to Victory.
@@larrysingleton2864 Read the bulk of Churchill’s works I happen to have first editions of his Great Contemporaries, the Second World War (6 vols) and A History of the English Speaking Peoples (4 vols). I also have an abridged edition of The World Crisis, 1911-1918. One of my favourite biographies of Churchill has got to be Andrew Roberts’ one which is up there with those of Martin Gilbert and William Manchester.
@@augustvonmackensen1101 Damn you. Damn you to HELL! Just kidding. I'm kinda jealous. I've got Manchester's trilogy "The Last Lion" up on my bookshelf. "First editions...." You mutha.....
Great story! My great-great-grandfather Louis Baumann was a friend of Camillo Ricchiardi. They founded a Boer Colony in Argentine Patagonia in 1902. My great-grandfather Luis de Wet told me about them. Greetings from Argentina.
Chris that was bloody Brilliant ! You are one of the most natural story tellers ever to have been on RUclips. I was hanging on every word of it. Thank you.
Fascinating historical narrative full of gems of details and questions for history to ponder of “who did it?” and “what if’s..?” But in the end, as fate would have it, Churchill would not be denied to fulfill his destiny for Britain in WW2.
I simply cannot imagine our collective history without Winston Churchill. He played such a crucial role in World War 2, especially in keeping Britain in the fight against Germany. I do not believe there was ANY other British politician who could have accomplished what he did. With his intractable will, he was able to unite the country in a common belief that they could indeed resist the Nazi menace, and that it was worth the sacrifice. Again, I don't think any other politician would have been able to hold out against the fierce political opposition (even amongst those in his own party) who were ready to concede and make peace with Hitler. It also doesn't hurt that he gave some of the most inspiring, rousing speeches that even today still stir up emotions ("[...] We will never surrender!").
Enjoyed your presentation a great deal! Refreshes my memory of the history of that time period. Please do a presentation on John Churchill with his use of the broad sword and archery against the Germans in World War 2. I think he was captured as well (twice as I remember). What an interesting story presented today. I appreciate your presentations and keep them coming!
Wow. You know, I’ve heard and read a hundred times that Churchill was captured in the Boer War, and never once before heard the actual story of what happened. What a nice video.
Fascinating.War is never black and white.Thankfully with a great analysis to show us the intrcacies it is transformed from something dull into something absolutely essential to study.Thank you for grabbing my attention and keeping me rivetted to the story.
Now that is true tale of valor, mental fitness, and old fashion gritty determination. Churchill was and is epitome of manly virtue. Thank you Sir for producing another brilliant video on the great man. Kudos!
Just found your channel which I'm enjoying very much. Do you intend to cover the Jacobites, battle of Culloden etc. That would be a great addition in my view. Thankyou for the great content.
Dear Chris, another terrific video, thankyou so much. This s probably dating me ( and i have not read the entire comments list, so a viewer may have already mentioned it) but the film 'Young Winston', starring the (? late) Simon Ward told the story of Churchill's capture well. I think it dates from the late 70's. The scene is set in the film of the cutting and Churchill's bravery-and then his capture. They have re-created the scene well, as per your description. I beleive the Mauser pistol carired by Ward in the movie was Churchill's actual C9 (?) Mauser pistol.
@@TheHistoryChap Dear Chris, well I'm not 100% certain- funny the things a teenager remembers however, I recall that from the publicity for this movie, at that time! I'll do a search now. Best
Another excellent & very enjoyable account of stirring wartime escapades, Chris. 👏😊 And what **a fascinating coincidence** we have, with respect to Winston Churchill & Boris Johnson - who, we know, is a huge fan of Churchill, aspired to emulate him & PARTLY SUCCEEDED in doing so, by also becoming Prime Minister. But, IN ADDITION: WINSTON got himself fired at….. And BORIS also, um… got himself fired! 😉
Breaking News: Churchill was recaptured in Ottawa in late 2021; captors and whereabouts of the captive, unknown. (One of Yousuf Karsh's original prints of his "British Bulldog" photo was stolen). Thanks for a great recounting of events and the context of the story, Chris. I didn't quite appreciate the nuances of the combatants. The fog of war. As always, you give balance and accuracy, context, bias free and with the enthusiasm that keeps me coming back for more stories. My childhood godmother's father was the Mr. Howard who helped WSC escape. In my teens during the 1970's as a summer student, I worked on the Durban-Johannesburg oil pipeline that passed through Colenso. One of the storage depots was near Chievely. My dad told me to find the marker where WSC was captured. Glad he told me and glad I found it (with the help of the local station master), "Here marks the spot where..." etc, etc on a white obelisk (If memory serves).
Crikey what another great high quality documentary. I would recommend subscribers to watch the movie "Young Winston" which gives an excellent account of Churchills South African adventure. Also just a little correction. Major John McBride did not command the Irish Brigade. It is known in Ireland as "McBrides Brigade" but it was actually commanded by Irish-American Colonel John Blake who was a former US Calvaryman and veteran of the Indian Wars including the campaign against Geronimo. When Major John McBride was executed by firing squad in 1916 for taking part in the Easter Rising he refused a blindfold stating "This is not the first time I have faced British guns". He was married to Maud Gonne who the Irish poet W B.Yeats was infatuated with and was an inspiration for a lot of his poetry. McBrides son would be a future president of the Republic of Ireland. I would recommend the book "McBrides Brigade-Irish Commandos in the Anglo-Boer War" by Donal P McCraken. Both McBride and John Blake would write about their experiences in the Boer War. Also it was not exclusively soldiers from the Royal Dublin Fusiliers that were on the armoured train as there was soldiers from the Durham Light Infantry and a contingent from the Royal Navy operated the mounted cannon. I personally think Churchill was captured by a rank and file Boer Burgher. For example it made a better story for both Churchill and Botha to give it some embellishment after what they both achieved in their respective careers. The bravery of the Irish regiments in the British Army was immortalized in R.C.Woodvilles painting "My Brave Irish" which is a quote from Queen Victoria. Due to the bravery of Irish regiments in the Boer War a new Irish regiment would be formed which was the Irish Guards in April 1900. There is a monument to the Irish fallen from the Royal Dublin Fusiliers at the entrance to St. Stephens Green in Dublin known as the "Fusiliers Arch". During the Treaty negotiations(October-December 1921) in London between the Irish Delegation led by Michael Collins and the British government there was a heated exchange and Collins stated that the British had put a £10,000 bounty on his head during the Irish War of Independence 1919-1921. Churchill said "One moment Mr Collins" and returned with the wanted poster issued by the Boers for his capture dead or alive. David Lloyd George gave a poignant moving speech in Manchester 1900 condemning the British policy of farm burning etc but just 20 years later in 1920 as Pime Minister his government deployed the notorious "Black &Tan" and Auxiliaries to Ireland who burned down houses as official reprisals and killed innocent civilians. Christain De Wet was the childhood hero of Michael Collins. Christain De Wet wtote to Collins to congratulate him in his fight against the British! I think I gave you a lot of the aforementioned information previously in a post months ago on one of your other excellent Boer War documentaries. As always wishing you continued success in all your future endeavours.
Really enjoyed that - thanks Chris. I was hoping to "assist" the story as I have both volumes of "After Pretoria" which are additional to "With the flag to Pretoria". Unfortunately Vol 1 starts June/July 1900. 😞
Quite intriguing! Sir Winston Churchill was a man of deep wisdom. The then Donald Trump! I read how he escaped when I was a student in class five. But you know the art of how history should be presented to its audience. Great job, Chris!
Very good video. Have you seen any RUclips videos by the late actor Kenneth Griffiths? They were made in the early 1970's and include interviews with veterans of the Boer War.
Very interesting. I like how you treat history; that it’s not black and white. So true. I have been up to Spion Kop. An eerie place with the Afrikaans and British graves up there.
Great video Chris, seeing Winston sat in a rickshaw reminded me of my visit to Durban in 1956 on the way to Hong Kong (troopship Empire Fowey) with the Lady in White singing on the dockside, onshore we had a few rickshaw races pulled by Zulus! Happy days
Fabulous thank you! Would love a video on the story of the jeep in British service. Her Majesty the Queen was the last head of state to work on Jeeps. I wish she was still around to service my Jeep. I Love My Jeep!
You have done it again Old Chap. I love your channel. Churchill was indeed a controversial figure. You love him or hate him. I believe he was a man who used the times to his advantage.
Dolf De la Rey is a distant relative of mine. I still have a newspaper clipping inherited from my grandfather titled "Churchill's captor dies " reporting on Uncle Dolf's passing.
Discovered you channel recently and have been enjoying going through many of your videos! A quick, hopefully interesting bit re: foreign officers fighting on Boer side: there was one Niko Bagrationi, subject of Russian Empire, descendent of Georgian royal family. One of the first foreigners to arrive to fight. He made it to colonel in the Boer army but was captured and exiled to St Helena. He met with Lord Kitchener during his captivity (Apparently Kitchener wanted to know what on earth was a Georgian Prince doing fighting Great Britain in South Africa!), during this meeting he confronted Kitchener about the atrocities being committed by British troops… He even wrote a book about his experience in this war. Not sure that book is available in English through.
A lot of British football team's formed around the Boer war time have part's of stadium's are called the Kop( liverpool fc) or Spion kop (Sheffield Wednesday)as these terraces were so steep reminding veteran's of the slopes they fought on and saw so many men killed on.
“The most powerful person in the world is the story teller. The storyteller sets the vision, values and agenda of an entire generation that is to come”. Steve Jobs
Thank you very much for covering this episode in Winston Churchill 's life. Did he recover his missing Mauser and use it during the rest of the Boer war?
@@TheHistoryChap thank you very much - did he keep until the end of his life.i wonder. I recall reading that he visited Greece during the war and had a pistol with him during the Communist insurrection.
Here's a what if..... When Winston first arrived in India to join the Malakand Field Force, he ripped his right shoulder climbing out of the boat below the Gateway to India monument in Bombay. He had his hand on the ladder when the boat dipped in the swell. He knew he was now unable, as a cavalry officer, to use his sword. At Omdurman you could argue his life was saved because during the charge of the Lancers he sheathed his sword and used the new Mauser pistol. It saved his life. So, no torn shoulder, no Winston, no WW2 leader.... PS thanks for your content. Fantastic. How about the desert column saving Gordon? Brits on camels and two extraordinary battles. Come on!
Very interesting . My mother guided The Duke of Marlboro at The Nathaniel Chew House, Clivdon. It was the site of the Battle of Germantown. The next year we visited Blenheim Palace. It was one of my high points of our Oddesy.
Someone once asked me to name three people, dead or alive that I would like to have at a dinner party. The first person I selected was Churchill. His life story could entertain for weeks, let alone the few hours of an evening!
Would be very interesting and I doubt you would have to contribute anything to the discussion. Like all great people, Churchill was probably inspiring and annoying in equal measures. But what a life!
He certainly did do “something in this world” whatever people may think about him the world would be a different place if he hadn’t been our PM during WW2 Thank you again for another great video
Another interesting and informative video. I think I was surprised by two things The British use of rum dune after they were banned and the different nationalities fighting on each side.
I am still looking for my great grandfather Charles Byrne. You mentioned the soldiers on the train with Churchill were the Dublin Irish Fusilers. Assume it was a company strength.
I visited the place where he was held in Pretoria, it was a school but is now a library. I also visited the sight of the train wreck where he was captured . There is an upturned carriage to mark the spot I'm not sure if it's original or not
In the early 1960s as a young child my family visited a friend in Cape Town, they cared for a very old man called Mr Elder who claimed to have been Churchill's batman.
Just wanted to give an opinion on a throwaway comment made during this excellent presentation. I should add that I am a history graduate (now a journalist). The script referenced the tearing down of statues in the context of people mistakenly believing history is clearcut, black and white, etc. Having interviewed people involved in some of these events, I think I can say with some authority that no one tears down a statue because they think history is clearcut. On the contrary, they would argue that they're tearing down statues precisely because history is more complex. To them, such a protest is saying, for example, 'yes this guy might have had a swashbuckling career, taken part in great battles and/or enriched British society in some way during their lifetime but they were also an important cog in the enslavement and/or murder of black people so I'd prefer there's not a statue celebrating them down the road from me.' I have to say, this seems pretty reasonable, to say the least. Tearing down statues certainly doesn't change history, as is often claimed. It's a silly thing to say. Only a time machine could do that. What we can do, however, is speak more honestly about events of the past. Refusing to ignore certain inconvenient aspects of history does not 'change history' but enriches our understanding of it and frees us up to write more accurately about our past and complete the record. All historians should embrace this, not fear it. Sure, one might have to dispense with some childhood heroes along the way and perhaps acknowledge that their father or favourite teacher misled them somewhat, but that's all part of being a grown-up. Facing reality is how our societies progress. We survive losing Santa Claus and Spiderman. I wager we'll get over the odd slave-trader or two also.
@The History Chap No worries. I love your channel. I'm currently in the process of booking a trip to Durban in April to finally realise a lifelong ambition of visiting Isandlwana and Rorke's Drift. Any tips will be most welcome!
Churchill's stories were nothing but hot air. He also wrote how he swam the mighty Apies river, which is a river about ankle deep at best when flowing, and maybe waist deep when flooding.
James Haldane of the Gordon Highlanders would later escape from Boer captivity and rise to be a corps commander in the Great War; he died in 1950 I believe.
I'm no lover of Churchill, but his reaction on the armoured train incident is classic. "When I escaped from the relative safety of a railway accident.......
He was also a journalist in Cuba during the SpanAm war. Surprisingly on the Spanish side. His mum was a yank after all. He reported that "incoming rounds were exhilirating".
Keith, it is a while since I have seen the film. It was very much based upon his book "My Early Life". As for my Churchill books they are down on the bottom left hand side, just out of shot.
Your mention of Irish soldiers fighting on both sides of this war remembered me the last Spanish Civil War. Because, according to Hugh Tomas, there were Irish volunteers also on both sides of that war. At 1936 some members of the IRA were pro fascists and others were pro communists. So, the first group fought in the army of the far right Spanish side, lead by general Franco. I suppose that they were part of the Spanish Legion. And the other IRA members enlisted as part of the International Brigades that Stalin recruited at Paris. I know that there were also Italians on both sides and that during the battle of Guadalajara, mainly fought by the Italian Army sent by Mussolini to support Franco, the Italian Batallion Garibaldi, part of one of the International Brigades, was also involved. It would be very interesting to know if the Irish men of the IRA, communists and fascists, fought each other directly also on that war.
Was Churchill a member of a Highland regiment in that picture as he's wearing Glengarry headwear and was he an officer in a Highland regiment in his early year's.
My great-grandfather served in the 46th company of the Ulster Imperial Yeomanry (aka Belfast Yeomanry) in the 2nd Boer War. Trooper Richard Maze was captured along with 7 others of his company at the battle of Lindley on May 30, 1900. Fortunately (for me!) he was only grazed by a bullet but 4 others, including the trooper next to him, were killed!
The River War by Winston Churchill. (Read both single and two-volume books) The Malakand Field Force by Winston Churchill. Churchill's Trial: Winston Churchill and the Salvation of Free Government by Larry P. Arnn. Thoughts and Adventures by Winston Churchill. The Man-Eaters of Tsavo by Lt. Colonel J.H. Patterson, D.S.O. The Seven Lives of Colonel Patterson: How an Irish Lion Hunter Led the Jewish Legion to Victory.
Could you do a video on Percy Fawcett sometime? He claimed to have seen Winston Churchill in disguise in the Western Front theatre after his Dardanelles disgrace. Percy Fawcett - very fascinating British explorer, worthy of a good vid.
@@TheHistoryChap The book about him is called, "The Lost City of Z." I think Brad Pitt was in a recent movie based on this book. Percy Fawcett was an artillery man in WW I and then he became the great Amazon explorer whose mysterious disappearance in the deep jungle has fascinated people for generations, a little like Amelia Earhardt. Viewers would love his story!
Great channel. I'm a Boer from Natal, South Africa. It pains me to let you know that since 1994 not a single monument, battlefield or grave site has been maintained by the state, but guys like me take care of them as well as we can (Boer and Brit). I helped fence off the capture sight of Churchill near Frere. It was disappearing into the veld by the road side. Thanks again for this channel!
Sad to hear but doesn't surprise me. Thanks for all your hard work.
Yes, I add my thanks too.
My great-grandfather,
then Captain William Bolitho,
commanded 27th Company, 7th Battalion, Imperial Yeomanry,
at the British defeat at Nooitgedacht
in December 1900,
where he was awarded the Distinuished Service Cross,
which he later received personally from King Edward VII.
With another company of yeomanry,
he was ordered by Brigadier Clements
to take his men up a steep 900 foot kloof,
and engage the Boers
on top of the cliffs of the Magaliesberg range.
/
Assaulting uphill after a 900 foot climb
is likely to be to be something of a forlorn hope,
and so it proved,
for as Wikipedia puts it
"Reinforcements climbing the mountain lost heavily
when Beyers' men suddenly poured fire into them".
William was wounded,
and lay there for 2 days and 2 nights
with his men,
before being briefly taken prisoner.
/
I would love to see the story of that battle
told in detail!
And photographs of the battlefield
taken from an infantryman's eyes.
I would like to see the battlefield
as my great-grandfather saw it that day,
in as far as a camera's lens can do it justice.
/
Boer generals De La Rey and Beyers were there,
as well as Jan Smuts,
so some great leaders.
Their plan was brilliant,
as the British dispositions were fatally flawed.
The British numbered 1,500,
and thought there were insufficient Boers locally
to risk an attack,
but more Boers arrived.
The Wily Boer knew both his ground and his enemy,
and struck while the iron was hot,
for which the Boers deserve rspect.
/
The story of this battle needs properly telling!
/
It always amazes me
that within 8 years,
Britain handed power back to Boers,
and that Botha and Jan Smuts
played such a great part in sunsequent events.
/
@@zen4men Interesting. I'm a member of a group called OMRS which collects and researches the history of medals. I'm from South Africa originally though living in the USA. I gave a presentation on exactly that battle and the Boer awards for service in the Anglo Boer war last year and was able to metion the exact events you speak of. I'm not sure the exact battlefield is visible now as it was then. Much has chaned and while I'm not there and so had to rely on what pictures I could find online I suspect some of the area might now be covered by the Hendrik Vervoerd Dam.
@@petercollingwood522
Hello Peter!
Surely the HV / Gariep dam and Nooitgedacht
are 350 or so miles apart?
www.google.com/maps/@-25.8716095,27.5345544,7037m/data=!3m1!1e3?hl=en&entry=ttu
I know there was a Nooitgedacht POW camp
at another ( third ) location,
but I do not know of a second battle by the same name.
Your mention of this dam
suggests we are talking of 2 separate battles?
Please advise!
/
Good on you mnheer
You forgot to add to your story that when Churchill was captured by the Boers, Churchill strongly protested that he should be treated as a POW and set free because he was a civilian War Correspondent. The Boer General Jan Smuts, who was also the Attorny General of the Transvaal at the time and a friend of Churchill’s father, Lord Randolph Churchill, stepped in and told Churchill that he had better change his tune and accept that he was a POW because if he did not accept that, he would be shot by the Boers as a spy. In later years Churchill confessed that was the best legal advice he had ever received.
Thank you for adding that story. Interesting that they were to work together in later years.
Didn't his escape break a parole pledge?
I grew up in Pretoria in the '60s and was familiar with the Staatsmodelskool. One story we were told about Churchill's escape was that he had to swim across the Apies river. This was always met with some hilarity as the Apies river is only about 6 inches deep.
Sounds like Churchill! Thanks for sharing
Douglas Clerk. What else would you expect from a self promoting liar? The truth??
That's correct. I'm from Durban but had maternal aunts living in Pretoria in Brecher street just walking distance from the Apies. I remember walking by it as a kid where ran in a concrete canal and never saw more than a trickle. And I recall one of my aunts who had read Churchills book where he apparently says "I crossed the mighty Apies" which caused her much amusement.
Two points of note. Firstly, it's true the British abandoned expanding rifle projectiles (exposed lead tip or hollow point) following the adoption of the Hague Convention. However, that was hardly an end to the matter. The reality is that expanding projectiles are simply much more effective at stopping enemy combatants than conventional full metal jacket projectiles. So, to correct this deficit in stopping power, (and skirt the provisions of the Hague Convention) the British Army introduced the Mk VII .303 cartridge in 1910. This cartridge incorporated a lightweight tip (aluminum, compressed paper or cellulose) beneath the projectile's (phosphor bronze) metal jacket which transferred the projectile's center of gravity further aft. This change in weight distribution caused the projectile to 'tumble' under rapid deceleration resulting in a much-increased wound canal, not greatly dissimilar to that caused by an expanding bullet!! lol. And secondly, I think we should take a moment to reflect on the sheer majesty of Herbert Kitchener's Omdurman mustache. It is, without doubt, one of the great military mustaches of all time.
*Aluminium.
We're not yanks 😉
Thanks for that in-depth comment and I am pleased to see that others have contributed to it.
The Boers also used expanding bullets. The Boers were expert hunters and expanding bullets were useful in bringing down game. The nature of Boer commando units lent itself to ad hoc armament. It was much less feesible for a modern army like the British to deliberately supply non standard ammunition. If the British did use dum dum rounds, the likelihood is they were locally sourced and privately purchased. Therefore there is no evidence of a state sanctioned war crime. Also, the law around the Hague convention is hazy as the Boer Republics never signed it, though they were technically under the 'protection' of the British empire at the time. It could also be argued that many Boer units were not recognised military units, but civilian terrorist or insurgency groups, so it is unclear if the convention applied to them as traditional 'combatants'. Either way, it never went to court.
The cellulose was autoclaved, interestingly
The expanding bullets were useful in colonial wars, when British soldiers shot directly in the bodies of the adversaries. Same with hunting.
It was a bad idea, when your enemy hides on the ground, in foliage or in the cities. It is better to use ammo with more punch-through power.
Also, wounded soldiers were more a problem for logistics than dead ones - see 1WW.
And all pointy bullets for Mausers or Enfields were supersonic - and these make temporary cavities in the body - much bigger than hollow-point rifle bullets.
And then thumbling...
Yeah. These honorable rules of war...
Thank you for this video Chris. An excellent story, told by an excellent teller, your good self! Keep 'em coming!
That's very kind of you, Rob. Glad you enjoyed it.
Except that it's nonsense.
“Hero of the Empire” by Candice Millard is a brilliant detailed account of Churchill’s capture and escape from Pretoria which aided in securing his seat for Oldham on his second attempt.
His books covering the Boer War: “London to Ladysmith via Pretoria”, “Ian Hamilton’s March” and “My Early Life” are priceless pieces of literature.
Simon Ward should have received a film award for his performance in Richard Attenborough’s Young Winston.
Thank you for sharing.
Absolutely! Love Simon Ward in "Young Winston." Great movie!
Yep. Churchill was a war hero several times over. Participated in the last cavalry charge in British history. Predicted the "Gestapo" these "Socialists" would become.
The River War by Winston Churchill. (Read both single and two-volume books)
The Malakand Field Force by Winston Churchill.
Churchill's Trial: Winston Churchill and the Salvation of Free Government by Larry P. Arnn.
Thoughts and Adventures by Winston Churchill.
The Man-Eaters of Tsavo by Lt. Colonel J.H. Patterson, D.S.O.
The Seven Lives of Colonel Patterson: How an Irish Lion Hunter Led the Jewish Legion to Victory.
@@larrysingleton2864 Read the bulk of Churchill’s works I happen to have first editions of his Great Contemporaries, the Second World War (6 vols) and A History of the English Speaking Peoples (4 vols). I also have an abridged edition of The World Crisis, 1911-1918. One of my favourite biographies of Churchill has got to be Andrew Roberts’ one which is up there with those of Martin Gilbert and William Manchester.
@@augustvonmackensen1101 Damn you. Damn you to HELL! Just kidding. I'm kinda jealous. I've got Manchester's trilogy "The Last Lion" up on my bookshelf. "First editions...." You mutha.....
Great story! My great-great-grandfather Louis Baumann was a friend of Camillo Ricchiardi. They founded a Boer Colony in Argentine Patagonia in 1902. My great-grandfather Luis de Wet told me about them. Greetings from Argentina.
Wow, I never knew that there was a Boer colony in Patagonia. I had heard of the Welsh one.
@@TheHistoryChap Exactly, the Welsh colonization was before the Boer. In any case, the two communities mixed with the passing of the years.
Why did the boers sleep with their boots on ?
To keep De Wet from de feet .
Chris that was bloody Brilliant ! You are one of the most natural story tellers ever to have been on RUclips. I was hanging on every word of it. Thank you.
Very kind of you, thanks.
Very good account of South African history. Thank you.
Thanks for watching my video & your comment.
@@TheHistoryChap person name who claimed crossed Swords with Churchill at the Boer War
Fascinating historical narrative full of gems of details and questions for history to ponder of “who did it?” and “what if’s..?” But in the end, as fate would have it, Churchill would not be denied to fulfill his destiny for Britain in WW2.
Glad you enjoyed. Maybe some people do walk with destiny.
I simply cannot imagine our collective history without Winston Churchill. He played such a crucial role in World War 2, especially in keeping Britain in the fight against Germany. I do not believe there was ANY other British politician who could have accomplished what he did. With his intractable will, he was able to unite the country in a common belief that they could indeed resist the Nazi menace, and that it was worth the sacrifice. Again, I don't think any other politician would have been able to hold out against the fierce political opposition (even amongst those in his own party) who were ready to concede and make peace with Hitler. It also doesn't hurt that he gave some of the most inspiring, rousing speeches that even today still stir up emotions ("[...] We will never surrender!").
Enjoyed your presentation a great deal! Refreshes my memory of the history of that time period. Please do a presentation on John Churchill with his use of the broad sword and archery against the Germans in World War 2. I think he was captured as well (twice as I remember). What an interesting story presented today. I appreciate your presentations and keep them coming!
Strangely enough, someone suggested him last week. I think it would make for a great story.
I think this is my favorite video you've produced thus far. Simply brilliant story telling!
Many thanks.
Wow. You know, I’ve heard and read a hundred times that Churchill was captured in the Boer War, and never once before heard the actual story of what happened. What a nice video.
Thank you for watching and for commenting too.
Fascinating.War is never black and white.Thankfully with a great analysis to show us the intrcacies it is transformed from something dull into something absolutely essential to study.Thank you for grabbing my attention and keeping me rivetted to the story.
Thanks for watching. I'm glad you enjoyed it.
Very good !!
So important.
Details are brilliant.
Thank you for watching.
Excellent doco and thank you for introducing me to Arthur Lynch. I looked him up and what an absolutely fascinating Australian character.
Yes Lynch was.
An excellent video and as always presented with such excitement and enthusiasm. Great stuff
Thank you for your kind words.
Now that is true tale of valor, mental fitness, and old fashion gritty determination. Churchill was and is epitome of manly virtue. Thank you Sir for producing another brilliant video on the great man. Kudos!
Glad you enjoyed it. Thanks.
Pffffft!
@@davidwhite4874 would that be the matting call of a puff. Since it is and I am not . I wish you well and may be you will find your Prince Charming.
Extremely entertaining, interesting and above all fascinating!
Many thanks.
What a fascinating piece of history. Thanks for an excellent channel
Glad you enjoyed it.
You tell a great story. Thank you!
My pleasure! Thanks for watching.
History is full of different shades of grey
Indeed. That's what makes it so fascinating.
@@TheHistoryChap me too history is never clear cut
Fascinating history. Great video. I thoroughly enjoyed this. Thank you.
My pleasure. Thanks for watching.
Outstanding, what a story. Thank you Sir!
Glad you enjoyed it! Thanks for watching.
You tell these stories so well. Thank you
Thank you for watching.
Just found your channel which I'm enjoying very much. Do you intend to cover the Jacobites, battle of Culloden etc. That would be a great addition in my view. Thankyou for the great content.
Glad you are enjoying channel and yes, I do intend to cover the Jacobites. Make sure you subscribe so you don't miss it.
I do so look forward to each new video you post ☺ you are a grand historian and a story teller extraordinaire...thank you
David, you are very kind. Thanks for your support.
already knew, most of it, but, this version with photos, was well presented. you gave it life, so well done
Thank you.
Very interesting Chris keep up the good work
Thank you, Michael.
Dear Chris, another terrific video, thankyou so much. This s probably dating me ( and i have not read the entire comments list, so a viewer may have already mentioned it) but the film 'Young Winston', starring the (? late) Simon Ward told the story of Churchill's capture well. I think it dates from the late 70's. The scene is set in the film of the cutting and Churchill's bravery-and then his capture. They have re-created the scene well, as per your description. I beleive the Mauser pistol carired by Ward in the movie was Churchill's actual C9 (?) Mauser pistol.
Good film. I wasn't aware about the ~Mauser that Simon Ward carried being Churchill's very own weapon. Thanks for sharing.
@@TheHistoryChap Dear Chris, well I'm not 100% certain- funny the things a teenager remembers however, I recall that from the publicity for this movie, at that time! I'll do a search now. Best
@@TheHistoryChap Yes, Ward unfortunatley passed away in 2012 at the age of 70. The film is dated 1972!
Very enjoyable, thank you.
Thanks for watching. Glad you enjoyed.
Great stuff, I am really enjoying this as always.
Thank you for taking the time to watch and to comment.
As usual, well researched and entertaining. Yours is one of the few channels that I ring the bell for..
Thank you for your kind support.
What an awesome series of events in regards to a hero against darkness and totalitarianism
Thank you for taking the time to comment
Excellent! Thank you!
Many thanks.
Good man, like it! Interesting snippets.
Glad you enjoyed my video
always a joy to watch this channel
That's very kind of you. Thanks.
Thank you, this was a fascinating video
Thanks for watching.
That was a great story and analysis of history.
Thank you. Although I do feel for Kitchener and Buller. It must have been a nightmare having him buzzing around!
Another excellent & very enjoyable account of stirring wartime escapades, Chris. 👏😊
And what **a fascinating coincidence** we have, with respect to Winston Churchill & Boris Johnson - who, we know, is a huge fan of Churchill, aspired to emulate him & PARTLY SUCCEEDED in doing so, by also becoming Prime Minister. But, IN ADDITION:
WINSTON got himself fired at….. And BORIS also, um… got himself fired! 😉
Chuckling away. Yes the similarities are uncanny and I thinkBoris has tried to emulate his hero.
Totally true, both Churchill and Johnson are self promoting liars.
Breaking News: Churchill was recaptured in Ottawa in late 2021; captors and whereabouts of the captive, unknown. (One of Yousuf Karsh's original prints of his "British Bulldog" photo was stolen).
Thanks for a great recounting of events and the context of the story, Chris. I didn't quite appreciate the nuances of the combatants. The fog of war. As always, you give balance and accuracy, context, bias free and with the enthusiasm that keeps me coming back for more stories. My childhood godmother's father was the Mr. Howard who helped WSC escape. In my teens during the 1970's as a summer student, I worked on the Durban-Johannesburg oil pipeline that passed through Colenso. One of the storage depots was near Chievely. My dad told me to find the marker where WSC was captured. Glad he told me and glad I found it (with the help of the local station master), "Here marks the spot where..." etc, etc on a white obelisk (If memory serves).
James, thanks for sharing your personal story. Appreciated.
Crikey what another great high quality documentary. I would recommend subscribers to watch the movie "Young Winston" which gives an excellent account of Churchills South African adventure. Also just a little correction. Major John McBride did not command the Irish Brigade. It is known in Ireland as "McBrides Brigade" but it was actually commanded by Irish-American Colonel John Blake who was a former US Calvaryman and veteran of the Indian Wars including the campaign against Geronimo. When Major John McBride was executed by firing squad in 1916 for taking part in the Easter Rising he refused a blindfold stating "This is not the first time I have faced British guns". He was married to Maud Gonne who the Irish poet W B.Yeats was infatuated with and was an inspiration for a lot of his poetry. McBrides son would be a future president of the Republic of Ireland. I would recommend the book "McBrides Brigade-Irish Commandos in the Anglo-Boer War" by Donal P McCraken. Both McBride and John Blake would write about their experiences in the Boer War. Also it was not exclusively soldiers from the Royal Dublin Fusiliers that were on the armoured train as there was soldiers from the Durham Light Infantry and a contingent from the Royal Navy operated the mounted cannon. I personally think Churchill was captured by a rank and file Boer Burgher. For example it made a better story for both Churchill and Botha to give it some embellishment after what they both achieved in their respective careers. The bravery of the Irish regiments in the British Army was immortalized in R.C.Woodvilles painting "My Brave Irish" which is a quote from Queen Victoria. Due to the bravery of Irish regiments in the Boer War a new Irish regiment would be formed which was the Irish Guards in April 1900. There is a monument to the Irish fallen from the Royal Dublin Fusiliers at the entrance to St. Stephens Green in Dublin known as the "Fusiliers Arch". During the Treaty negotiations(October-December 1921) in London between the Irish Delegation led by Michael Collins and the British government there was a heated exchange and Collins stated that the British had put a £10,000 bounty on his head during the Irish War of Independence 1919-1921. Churchill said "One moment Mr Collins" and returned with the wanted poster issued by the Boers for his capture dead or alive. David Lloyd George gave a poignant moving speech in Manchester 1900 condemning the British policy of farm burning etc but just 20 years later in 1920 as Pime Minister his government deployed the notorious "Black &Tan" and Auxiliaries to Ireland who burned down houses as official reprisals and killed innocent civilians. Christain De Wet was the childhood hero of Michael Collins. Christain De Wet wtote to Collins to congratulate him in his fight against the British! I think I gave you a lot of the aforementioned information previously in a post months ago on one of your other excellent Boer War documentaries. As always wishing you continued success in all your future endeavours.
John, thanks for those illuminating insights. Very much appreciated.
Excellent, thanks
My pleasure. Thanks for watching.
Really enjoyed that - thanks Chris. I was hoping to "assist" the story as I have both volumes of "After Pretoria" which are additional to "With the flag to Pretoria". Unfortunately Vol 1 starts June/July 1900. 😞
Glad you enjoyed.
Loved hearing bits and pieces on Murdoch mystery’s and wanted the full story
Hope this helped fill in some gaps.
Quite intriguing! Sir Winston Churchill was a man of deep wisdom. The then Donald Trump!
I read how he escaped when I was a student in class five. But you know the art of how history should be presented to its audience.
Great job, Chris!
Thanks for watching and for taking the time to comment.
Thank you sir and thank you for what you do.
And thank you for your support.
This was very informative and entertaining thank you. I am reading his Nobel prize winning work which is prefaced by his account of the escape.
Thanks for taking the time to watch and to comment.
Very good video. Have you seen any RUclips videos by the late actor Kenneth Griffiths? They were made in the early 1970's and include interviews with veterans of the Boer War.
I'm glad you enjoyed. No I haven't seen those videos. Thanks for sharing.
Very interesting. I like how you treat history; that it’s not black and white. So true. I have been up to Spion Kop. An eerie place with the Afrikaans and British graves up there.
Thanks for sharing. I always find Culloden to be eerie too.
Great video Chris, seeing Winston sat in a rickshaw reminded me of my visit to Durban in 1956 on the way to Hong Kong (troopship Empire Fowey) with the Lady in White singing on the dockside, onshore we had a few rickshaw races pulled by Zulus! Happy days
Gosh, the Rickshaw boys of Durban. I remember them when I was a child, growing up in the city.
@@TheHistoryChap So you're another Durbanite too eh?
Fabulous thank you! Would love a video on the story of the jeep in British service. Her Majesty the Queen was the last head of state to work on Jeeps. I wish she was still around to service my Jeep. I Love My Jeep!
That's an interesting suggestion. Will add to my (never-ending) list.
That was brilliant! Thank you!
My pleasure. Thanks for watching.
Brilliant.Thanks for sharing your research.
My pleasure. Thanks for watching.
Another fantastic videos
Many thanks.
You have done it again Old Chap. I love your channel. Churchill was indeed a controversial figure. You love him or hate him. I believe he was a man who used the times to his advantage.
I reckon you are right...a man who was always willing to ride his luck.
You deserve a lot more subscribers! ❤
Thank you. Getting closer and closer to 100k.
Dolf De la Rey is a distant relative of mine. I still have a newspaper clipping inherited from my grandfather titled "Churchill's captor dies " reporting on Uncle Dolf's passing.
What a great relative to have in the family.
Really good, interesting and balanced video. Thank you.
My pleasure. Thanks for watching.
Great presentation
Glad you liked it.Thank you for taking the time to comment.
great narration
Thanks & thanks for watching my video
Discovered you channel recently and have been enjoying going through many of your videos! A quick, hopefully interesting bit re: foreign officers fighting on Boer side: there was one Niko Bagrationi, subject of Russian Empire, descendent of Georgian royal family. One of the first foreigners to arrive to fight. He made it to colonel in the Boer army but was captured and exiled to St Helena. He met with Lord Kitchener during his captivity (Apparently Kitchener wanted to know what on earth was a Georgian Prince doing fighting Great Britain in South Africa!), during this meeting he confronted Kitchener about the atrocities being committed by British troops… He even wrote a book about his experience in this war. Not sure that book is available in English through.
Thanks for sharing. Very interesting.
Fantastic episode 👏 👌 👍
many thanks. Glad you enjoyed it.
A lot of British football team's formed around the Boer war time have part's of stadium's are called the Kop( liverpool fc) or Spion kop (Sheffield Wednesday)as these terraces were so steep reminding veteran's of the slopes they fought on and saw so many men killed on.
Correct. In fact I refer to some of those stories in my video about Spion Kop. ruclips.net/video/CUlHyOHvYgU/видео.html
Dear Chris thanks wonderful story my favourite subject I have in my cullection a mouser rifle from the bore war if only it cube speak
Glad you enjoyed the story.
“The most powerful person in the world is the story teller.
The storyteller sets the vision, values and agenda
of an entire generation that is to come”. Steve Jobs
Thanks for sharing.
多謝！
Thank you very much for your support. Much appreciated.
Thank you very much for covering this episode in Winston Churchill 's life.
Did he recover his missing Mauser and use it during the rest of the Boer war?
Yes. It was left on the escaping train and when he arrived back in Natal after his escape, it was in storage.
@@TheHistoryChap thank you very much - did he keep until the end of his life.i wonder. I recall reading that he visited Greece during the war and had a pistol with him during the Communist insurrection.
Here's a what if..... When Winston first arrived in India to join the Malakand Field Force, he ripped his right shoulder climbing out of the boat below the Gateway to India monument in Bombay. He had his hand on the ladder when the boat dipped in the swell. He knew he was now unable, as a cavalry officer, to use his sword. At Omdurman you could argue his life was saved because during the charge of the Lancers he sheathed his sword and used the new Mauser pistol. It saved his life. So, no torn shoulder, no Winston, no WW2 leader.... PS thanks for your content. Fantastic. How about the desert column saving Gordon? Brits on camels and two extraordinary battles. Come on!
Desert column...? You are on! Just give me a little time.
Very interesting . My mother guided The Duke of Marlboro at The Nathaniel Chew House, Clivdon. It was the site of the Battle of Germantown. The next year we visited Blenheim Palace. It was one of my high points of our Oddesy.
Thank you for watching my video and for taking the time to share your family story.
Brilliant. Great man.
Thank you for watching
Someone once asked me to name three people, dead or alive that I would like to have at a dinner party. The first person I selected was Churchill. His life story could entertain for weeks, let alone the few hours of an evening!
Would be very interesting and I doubt you would have to contribute anything to the discussion. Like all great people, Churchill was probably inspiring and annoying in equal measures. But what a life!
He certainly did do “something in this world” whatever people may think about him the world would be a different place if he hadn’t been our PM during WW2
Thank you again for another great video
thanks for watching the video & taking the time to comment.
Another interesting and informative video. I think I was surprised by two things The British use of rum dune after they were banned and the different nationalities fighting on each side.
Glad you found it interesting.
No doubt some squaddies chopped the tips of the rifle rounds off with their bayonets, probably unofficially lol I know I would have done the same.
I am still looking for my great grandfather Charles Byrne. You mentioned the soldiers on the train with Churchill were the Dublin Irish Fusilers. Assume it was a company strength.
Without looking back through my notes I can';t confirm numbers.
Great story thanks. I personally don't like Churchill but have an avid interest in military history.
Bet he was a nightmare to work for and an even bigger nightmare to have under your command!
I visited the place where he was held in Pretoria, it was a school but is now a library. I also visited the sight of the train wreck where he was captured . There is an upturned carriage to mark the spot I'm not sure if it's original or not
Interesting. Thank you for sharing.
Oldham my home town his seat is now in our new Odeon cinema based in the old magnificent town hall !
Thank you very much for sharing. I wasn’t aware of that.
Great video, are their any books you would recommend on the Boer war please
The Boer War by Thomas Packham.
Well done.
Many thanks.
In the early 1960s as a young child my family visited a friend in Cape Town, they cared for a very old man called Mr Elder who claimed to have been Churchill's batman.
Thanks for sharing that interesting little snippet
Great videos. Conventional wisdom has it that it was Witbank, rather than Middelburg, where he hid in a mine shaft. (OK, only 20 miles apart).
Thanks for adding
This country has produced some great Britain's, & in my opinion he is the greatest.
He topped the BBC public poll of greatest Britons a few years ago.
@@TheHistoryChap Quite right too. Great videos keep them coming.
@@TheHistoryChap that's probably why the bbc slanders his name so often.
they know he is loved among his people
@@craigmason9893 I'm sure he is still loved among HIS people, Thatcher idolised him for instance. The rest of us, not so much.
Just wanted to give an opinion on a throwaway comment made during this excellent presentation. I should add that I am a history graduate (now a journalist).
The script referenced the tearing down of statues in the context of people mistakenly believing history is clearcut, black and white, etc.
Having interviewed people involved in some of these events, I think I can say with some authority that no one tears down a statue because they think history is clearcut. On the contrary, they would argue that they're tearing down statues precisely because history is more complex.
To them, such a protest is saying, for example, 'yes this guy might have had a swashbuckling career, taken part in great battles and/or enriched British society in some way during their lifetime but they were also an important cog in the enslavement and/or murder of black people so I'd prefer there's not a statue celebrating them down the road from me.' I have to say, this seems pretty reasonable, to say the least.
Tearing down statues certainly doesn't change history, as is often claimed. It's a silly thing to say. Only a time machine could do that. What we can do, however, is speak more honestly about events of the past. Refusing to ignore certain inconvenient aspects of history does not 'change history' but enriches our understanding of it and frees us up to write more accurately about our past and complete the record. All historians should embrace this, not fear it.
Sure, one might have to dispense with some childhood heroes along the way and perhaps acknowledge that their father or favourite teacher misled them somewhat, but that's all part of being a grown-up. Facing reality is how our societies progress. We survive losing Santa Claus and Spiderman. I wager we'll get over the odd slave-trader or two also.
Thank you for taking the time to contribute your in-depth comment.
@The History Chap No worries. I love your channel. I'm currently in the process of booking a trip to Durban in April to finally realise a lifelong ambition of visiting Isandlwana and Rorke's Drift. Any tips will be most welcome!
He sounds like he would have made a great archaeologists. 🤠
Honestly though, it seems as if everything you learn about Churchill is another surprise.
He has an mazing ability to pop up in stories.
Churchill's stories were nothing but hot air. He also wrote how he swam the mighty Apies river, which is a river about ankle deep at best when flowing, and maybe waist deep when flooding.
Thanks for taking the time to comment.
James Haldane of the Gordon Highlanders would later escape from Boer captivity and rise to be a corps commander in the Great War; he died in 1950 I believe.
Thanks for sharing. I knew that he managed to escape but didn't know what happened to him afterwards.
I'm no lover of Churchill, but his reaction on the armoured train incident is classic. "When I escaped from the relative safety of a railway accident.......
Stephen, I am sure that he could be extremely hard work, but he had an incredible knack of popping up in various stories.
@@TheHistoryChap That's probably because he wrote most of them.
When I see that photo with the soldier bent over looking at the ground, I think of Douglas Fairbanks Jr. and the film, Gunga Din...
Good point!
He was also a journalist in Cuba during the SpanAm war. Surprisingly on the Spanish side. His mum was a yank after all. He reported that "incoming rounds were exhilirating".
He was certainly an action seeker
I know he was a civilian but it wows me Churchill wasn't awarded some kind of award for his bravery on the train or daring escape.
Thanks for sharing that thought
Churchill had a charmed life, what luck knocking on the right door
Good observation
Read 'Young Winston' bio and the C96 he's carrying in the biopic became my favorite pistol.
Thank you for commenting.
Chris what did you think of the movie "Young Winston"? Also where is the book about Winston Churchill in the bookcase???
Keith, it is a while since I have seen the film. It was very much based upon his book "My Early Life".
As for my Churchill books they are down on the bottom left hand side, just out of shot.
Your mention of Irish soldiers fighting on both sides of this war remembered me the last Spanish Civil War.
Because, according to Hugh Tomas, there were Irish volunteers also on both sides of that war. At 1936 some members of the IRA were pro fascists and others were pro communists. So, the first group fought in the army of the far right Spanish side, lead by general Franco. I suppose that they were part of the Spanish Legion. And the other IRA members enlisted as part of the International Brigades that Stalin recruited at Paris.
I know that there were also Italians on both sides and that during the battle of Guadalajara, mainly fought by the Italian Army sent by Mussolini to support Franco, the Italian Batallion Garibaldi, part of one of the International Brigades, was also involved.
It would be very interesting to know if the Irish men of the IRA, communists and fascists, fought each other directly also on that war.
What an amazing story. Thanks for sharing.
These irish fascists were known as the blueshirt's.
Was Churchill a member of a Highland regiment in that picture as he's wearing Glengarry headwear and was he an officer in a Highland regiment in his early year's.
No he wasn't but he did become Lt. Colonel in the Royal Scots Fusiliers during the First World War.
My great-grandfather served in the 46th company of the Ulster Imperial Yeomanry (aka Belfast Yeomanry) in the 2nd Boer War. Trooper Richard Maze was captured along with 7 others of his company at the battle of Lindley on May 30, 1900. Fortunately (for me!) he was only grazed by a bullet but 4 others, including the trooper next to him, were killed!
Thanks for sharing your family story from the Boer war.
My great grandfather and his brother stacked the stones on the tracks. My father has a old newspaper clipping that described the events
Thanks for watching my video & for taking the time to share your family story.
The River War by Winston Churchill. (Read both single and two-volume books)
The Malakand Field Force by Winston Churchill.
Churchill's Trial: Winston Churchill and the Salvation of Free Government by Larry P. Arnn.
Thoughts and Adventures by Winston Churchill.
The Man-Eaters of Tsavo by Lt. Colonel J.H. Patterson, D.S.O.
The Seven Lives of Colonel Patterson: How an Irish Lion Hunter Led the Jewish Legion to Victory.
Thank you for sharing.
Could you do a video on Percy Fawcett sometime? He claimed to have seen Winston Churchill in disguise in the Western Front theatre after his Dardanelles disgrace. Percy Fawcett - very fascinating British explorer, worthy of a good vid.
Percy Fawcett is a new one on me. You have sparked my interest.
@@TheHistoryChap The book about him is called, "The Lost City of Z." I think Brad Pitt was in a recent movie based on this book. Percy Fawcett was an artillery man in WW I and then he became the great Amazon explorer whose mysterious disappearance in the deep jungle has fascinated people for generations, a little like Amelia Earhardt. Viewers would love his story!