Shabbar Debates Imran Khan, Jamaat-e-Islami & The CPEC Controversy
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 16 сен 2024
- Explore issues in Pakistan today. Shabbar shares his thoughts on whether staying in Pakistan was a mistake and why not move to India to correct it. We also discuss the role of Imran Khan and Asim Munir in decision-making with foreign embassies and question when these decisions will be made public.
Dive into the social norms in politics and what changes could turn in favor of Jamaat-e-Islami. This Podcast raises questions about the future of the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC)
Please support us by subscribing to our channel, sharing our content, and engaging with us. Even if our work doesn't resonate with you, we'd appreciate your feedback. Raftar is not merely a content company that produces meticulously researched, high-quality videos about the economy, youth issues, gender roles, and sports. More than that, we represent a movement for social change. We cannot make a difference without your participation and support.
For more amazing content, SUBSCRIBE NOW!
RUclips
/ @raftartv
RUclips
/ @raftarnewsofficial
RUclips
/ @raftarsports
Website:
raftar.com/
Salute to this gentleman for brutally stating the truth so boldly.
His TALKIN from his ass. His an Asshole
Mr. Shabbir is first Shia BUT against any Khomani type Revolution in Pakistan although he likes Khomani.
We all are Muslims from day one to at the end without any disputes.
What if he starts to talk about the issues and shortcomings of india ? Would you still listen to him ? And not call him a clown ? 🤣😂
Pigs😂 are deep in Islam.
@@9Rehankhan19he will not. He has said India is not Piggistan 😂. Get real.
What Pakistan needs:
1. End of IPPs
2. End of Extensions
3. End of reapportionment of every retired officers especially army generals
4. End of all privileges to every state servant (Army, judiciary, parliament, beurucracy etc.)
5. Free and Fair elections
These things must be provided to Pakistan, otherwise Pakistan may see the worst situation of public unrest more than Bangladesh.
Exactly bro these are the demands in need of todays centuryies
Pakistan problems has these solutions
1- Free and fair elections by evm- vvpat technology or other advanced technology
2- Referendum on either the political system in pak should be based on presidential or parliamentary system.
3- Divide every province of pakistan into two parts north/south and on basis of better administration (north punjab/south punjab, North sindh/ south sindh) Etc- And give Provincial status tooo Gilgit Baltistan and Azad Kashmir
4- Jooo bheee natural resources hain pak mee petrol,gas,coal unnnn seee anne waleee revenue usss district kaa 70% tak share unnnkeee pass hogee yane unnn natural resources see anee wala revenue kaaa 70% wooo district ki elected govt rakhegi rakheengee baki federal govt or province koo sirf kuch heee hisssa milegaa.
5- Pure pakistan meee ek standard digital or fixed tax policy banaou jismeee 15 seee zyada tax naaa hooo direct or indirect or 10lac seee kam.kamane walae peee tax naa hooo or food item peee 5% seee zyada tax naa hoooo or
in taxes kooo bant deeya jayee
5- taxes kooo federal govt kooo
5- taxes provincisl govt
5- taxes municipal govt koooo
6-NFC award kooo change kiyeaa jayeee budget kaaa revenue kaaa share 70-75% federal govt appne pass rakhee (provinces appna tax revenue khud collect karee) or isske sath PFC(provincial finance commision)districts koo milne walee paisee or District financial commision (jooo district govt aggey villages or tehsils koooo deee)
7- Pure pakistan directly elected districts govts and village govt(panchayat raj/india) kee election hooo or constitution mee jese pm or cm kee roles or powers likhee hain wesee hee mayor ki powers or responsibility likhh deee jayee (water, sewrage Police, cleanliness) or tax collection jese water tax property tax, motor vehicle tax, service tax, sab mayor collect kareee or local govt kaa subject provinces see leekeee federal govt keee pass or election bhee unke election commision karwayee naa kee provinces.
8- Pak mee yeee Ethnic based qota system govt jobs mee khtam karkee sareew recuritment 100% css exams or merit or ussske professional degree based peee hooo or pak meee single national curriculum laggo kese karna hain usski planning kiiyee jayee
9- The federal and provincial election should be held seprately(Matlab provincial or federal govt kee election ek din peee naa hooo) There should be a gap of 3 months To 6 months
10- Abolish care taker govt
11- Remove perks, privillages, Protocoals, benefits of every beaureacrate, lawmakers(mna), judges, Military officers.
12- Restoration of student unions
It won't happen unless Sharia is implemented in Pakistan
Root cause the source of ur problem is religion
Pakistan need only
1 thigh
Totally boycott India
No relationship with India
The host is clean shaven but has huge beard in his tummy. ( it is always evident from his squirmishness when faced with a religious dilemma) .
So what's wrong?
It may seem like it but apart from that it seems like that it is an effective way of interviewing Shabbar sb as they are then forced to reveal more details so that layman like us can get to know more
@@AliHasan-bw7kmeverything, everything is wrong with is/0m
Host ko boht issue hai Shabbar zaidi k india walay bayan sy, kya galat kaha hai shabbar zaidi ny? Sahe to keh rha hai .
😜💯👍🏻@@MohsinAzizOfficial
India parts starts 1hr 10 mins...thank me later
😂😂😂
Thanks bhai
indians and their obsession with Pak.
@@anubhav440 🙏 thanks
@@Mlridgekeep an eye on the enemy when they discuss you
I watch full programme only If Shabbar ji is there...
He speaks universal truth...
Not all the time 🤡
So don't get carried away with his pro India stance
@@I...2728He is Pro- Pakistan. He sees everything through this pro Pakistan Prism.
Shabbar is a clown
Only fight between Pakistan establishment and irman Khan is CPCE China Trade.. 😂😄😄one thing is common between them is USA😄😅
@@I...2728he is not pro Indian he is kinda right
Jamaat did good work when they were elected in Karachi for local govt. I have seen change in my area which was significant.
All of the roads are broken after rain, no jamati is to be seen, they are as much corrupt and hypocrite as ppp.
Infact they are more morally and intellectually corrupt.
Just look at their latest drama of dharna, Jamatis are truly a cult.
Afghanistan jao Molvi
Shabbar sahab here I will disagree with you about JI.
JI is the MOST and ONLY Real DEMOCRATIC party. The son/daughter doesn’t become the head of the party. They have regular REAL elections inside the party and the head is chosen based on true DEMOCRACY. Something which ALL other parties in Pakistan completely LACK.
@@aunnasir q Pakistan aap ne banaya tha? aap ke malkiyat hai?
Mr. Shabbir is first Shia BUT against any Khomani type Revolution in Pakistan although he likes Khomani.
We all are Muslims from day one to at the end without any disputes.
This person Love Pakistan more than his life. Try to understand his words. He is true nationalist. Respect.
Yes and if you loved your brain a lil bit like you claim he does pakistan then you would not have commented this shit.
he is zionist ... not muslim and saying he is shia... but he is not... there is no space of anti palistanian in shia sect...
Only fight between Pakistan establishment and irman Khan is CPCE China Trade.. 😂😄😄one thing is common between them is USA😄😅
@@9886268 wrong.
I see a lot of butthurt comments against Shabbar Zaidi.
Most of those comments are from religious-minded people. Shame on you, for not realizing the truth and the bravery this man is exuding WHILE LIVING IN PAKISTAN! Most people don't have 1% of the courage Shabbar sir has in speaking the truth!
People, please learn to understand that religion has got NO RELEVANCE in the affairs of the state! There is NO NEED to involve Islam or any other religion in the working of the state. Religious political parties should be banned at all costs!
and the country should operate under the framework of a Social Welfare state.
And PLEASE STOP SAYING THAT PAKISTAN WAS MADE IN THE NAME OF ISLAM - this is YET ANOTHER LIE that the establishment propagated to keep the public under the control of the elites.
This islamic republic or riyasat-e-madina is a LIE, used to misguide people. Pakistan does NOT NEED to become a khilafat. this is all bs used to misguide people so that they don't think about the actual deficiencies of the state (inflation, poverty, education etc)
Everyone has an equal right to live in the state, practice their own religion - but do not bring religion into the working of the society. Religion is your personal choice, NOT an instrument of the state!
He nailed it about his Israel statement as Pakistani sleeping Nation did not protest at all against Israel anywhere including in Universities.
Ap apny sher ma sirf 1ghanty k liya protest kr k dekha dain pir 6 mehnay zamanat karwaty guazr gain gay oo bhai ap ka mulk isreal hi chala raha ha yaha azad kon ha sub ghulum hain bus Allah hadiyat dy
@@talhapardasi3181 Americans ko police ny ni pakra? Bacho ny apni education dao pr ni lgai waha? Bachy deport ni huy waha?
Poora pakistan isreal ke loan pe chal raha Hai IMF mein 80% Israel hi betha hai
Only fight between Pakistan establishment and irman Khan is CPCE China Trade.. 😂😄😄one thing is common between them is USA😄😅
😢
Mr.Shabbar Zaidi is a Jewel of Pakistan, the jewel must be protected at all cost.
How
@@muhammadammar6289 he should be locked in jail and protected there
With all my due respect Shabbar Sahab 50℅ bat sahe karte hain aur 50℅ bat galat karte hain...
@@ehsanjavaid1858 why are you said this?
Why are you said this?
Iski waja yh hai keh yeh kuxh batein assume krty.
He is 100 percent correct and talk in neutral way.
Jamat e Islami ke khilaaf zehar ugal raha hai ye shakhs.
Shabbar Zaidi is the only logically sound person in Pakistan…. Love you Mr Shabbar ❤❤
Always a big respect for shabbar bhai. From 🇮🇳
Nice to see ❤ from 🇵🇰🇵🇰
Always big respect for shabbar sir from India🇮🇳. He is the person in Pakistan who really understand this subcontinent
I have never seen such a brave person in world. New avatar of Che Guevara. Love and respect. Nobody in have courage like you. Only person who have this type of courage was Nelson Mandela.
Maaaannnnnnn wtttttffffff you are talking about. WHat have ypou smoked?????????????????????????????
Please wake up. He is not brave. He is compromised
He is so brave that he left PTI when establishment started crack down on PTI
He is a fu***ng liar
@@usmanalikhan2947 he left PTI and FBR way before cracking down start.
If punjabi politicians want power generation in punjab and bot outside Punjab which is cheaper, then they have already decided on greater punjab 😮
stop complaining and start working,.... your budget is in PPPs hand, question them not Punjab
. Shabar Zaidi is an ocean of knowledge. The limit of intelligence is over on this guy. And is a great wealth of information. But the way in which he has talked about America and China and described the differences and explained the facts. That America is much better in favor of Pakistan than China. It is absolutely true that Pakistan will never get anything from China, it is a war of interests. And Shabbar Zaidi's knowledge and knowledge about India is amazing
Shabbir Zaidi saheb said the truth by quoting the shayari, absolutely correct.
Take any Islamic country, destruction is amongst themselves.....no outsider......
Yes and destruction in our islamic country are your shabbar saab himself
Hello Raftar Team,
I just wanted to express my appreciation for consistently inviting Shabbar Zaidi to your show. He is one of my favorite guests-knowledgeable, intellectual, and honest. Please continue to feature him on your show regularly if possible.
Thanks!
cant wait good work raftar I m addicted to listening shabbar shab
Right im also
Me too
Exactly! I wish they could bring him more in their upcoming shows
Only fight between Pakistan establishment and irman Khan is CPCE China Trade.. 😂😄😄one thing is common between them is USA😄😅
Hassan nisar should be with him then see the movie
Politicians from Punjab want IPPs in Punjab to garner votes.
The fact that transmitting electricity is cheaper than transmitting Fossil Fuels means shit to them.
I am pretty sure they are not even literate enough understand drawbacks of all this.
I wonder why Mr. shabbar zaidi never speaks about the genocide being carried out by Pak army for more than 60 decades in Balochistan? Is he scared talking about Balochistan?
Frist person who say for pakistan truth
Pakistan survival is in one thing- ban all religious parties to participate in politics. Otherwise, bloodshed never will stop.
HE IS BLUNT BECAUSE HE SPEAKS THE TRUTH WITHOUT GONG ZIG ZAG
Shabbar Zadi is truly intellectual.
People don’t like him because he speaks the truth and point blank
Yes
Haha.... Pls open ur eyes.... He is one clever person
100% Panjabi politicians, Punjabi establishment the real enemy of Karachi
😢
Shabbar podcast each month is a must 🎉
I think he is mix-used personality he exposed some truths but he also have some real mental problems
indeed, Host Must invite other guests too with him. to balance
pagal admi he yeh shabbar naaie... yeh apny ko shia kehta hai aur israel k sath hai...
Only fight between Pakistan establishment and irman Khan is CPCE China Trade.. 😂😄😄one thing is common between them is USA😄😅
@@muhammadhasan-1999 🤣
@@muhammadhasan-1999 jab hakikat puri tarha dekhna lagti h ...
Tab mentally problem hona lagta h kyu ki itni kadwi Sachi dekh ker
He is very uninformed about JI and its women wing ....bano Qabil is an example, it allowed all sorts of women and with the way they dressed
Me jhud jamat-e-islami ko support karta hu aor mere walid ne hamesha is jamat ki Fi-sabelillah khidmat ki h
Par agar is Jamat ki history deke to inho ne hamesha establishment k sat deal ki h .. Hamesha dharna start karke 1 din ese ghaib hojate h k log heran hojate h k kia hogea..
Aor Universities me inke young larko ne jo danday leke zabardssti burqay pehnwae h larkio ko aor larka larki ko ek sat dek k jo zulm kia h wo sab k samne h.
They got used by Establishment or had common interest, like fighting in 1971 war, Afghan war...but they never got political benefit out of it...but thats the past
Did JI side with establishment since Munawwar Hassan while all parties were enjoying hybrid regimes while in government
@@baqai92 mene inki niyyat par kabi shak nahi kia aor na kabi karunga.. Ye wahid esi party h jaha nasal dar nasal party ki sadarat muntaqil nahi hoti balke merit par hoti h.. Mere ghar me hazaro inke monthly jo Booklet issue hoti h wo pare h...
Liken jo chez mene apni ankho se deki h osko deny nai karsakta .. Universities me jo maar peet inke Tulabaa ne ki h wo shaid Karachi k elawa kisi aor city me nahi deki mene...Aor onko backing party k logo ki taraf se hi milti h islea itne bahadur banjate h
@@Zamaday I agree with this problem. This moral policing has to stop and I think this issue has been addressed somewhat by Hafiz Naeem.
Only fight between Pakistan establishment and irman Khan is CPCE China Trade.. 😂😄😄one thing is common between them is USA😄😅
I am sure pakistan will not listen to sane voice of Shabbar Zaidi as its bound to go down the drain 😂
Bhai sub sy zayda viewership shabber zaidi ki hoti hai last 1 year sy
I hope it does.... Double agent
Shabbat Zaidi speaks truth. Pakistanis don’t want to face the truth and continue to leave in dreams .
Shabbar shab such a brave man ❤❤
I will agree with Mirasi term. Mirasi term is right for criticism and it is a great satire.
Thanks raftar for bringing Shabbar sahab once again. Waiting for more from you
Shabbar should be PM
Then all the India -Pakistan problem will be solved 😊
Islam khatre mein aajaayega
@@tank939 Islam will become true Islam
@@Shobyw Lol
shabbar can become your daddy
Salam.
Anchor bhai got emotional and took it personally from 34mins onwards.😢😮.
Brother, stay professional and control your emotions ❤😂🎉😊. Respect
He is calm throughout bhai
@Nasir-
Very true
Wonderful. Shabbar Saab you stand for humanity, not any religion. My respect 🙏🏽🙏🏽
Shabbar sahab here I will disagree with you about JI.
JI is the MOST and ONLY Real DEMOCRATIC party. The son/daughter doesn’t become the head of the party. They have regular REAL elections inside the party and the head is chosen based on true DEMOCRACY. Something which ALL other parties in Pakistan completely LACK.
Shabbar Zaidi, despite his vast knowledge couldn't research on this. I know some of the leaders, including Qazi Hussain Ahmed sb marhoom and the recent one who resigned after election.. they were really great people and JI does high level scrutiny before selecting the amir or giving seat.. no other party is as good as them in this regard.
@@bumblebee9912 they don’t select. They have proper elections.
Iam a indian. I sincerely salute this man. 🙏👍
The reason for watching raftaar is only sir shabbar zaddi sb great mind with logical debate
This anchor evades the facts and refuse to accept realities of Pakistan.
This person's knowledge is extraordinary. One can disagree with some of his statements, but overall, he speaks the truth courageously. I'm always happy to see him in a podcast.
Only fight between Pakistan establishment and irman Khan is CPCE China Trade.. 😂😄😄one thing is common between them is USA😄😅
I am a Shia Muslim. If Jamat e Islami women do Hijab. then this is a good thing. Why Shabbar sb is commenting on their personnel lives.
Try to understand the whole context of what he was actually saying, he said will all women of Pakistan be allowed in this country to choose whatever they wear normally in thier personal life, no blasphemy of the concept of veiling of religious women, but the hypocrisy of them to filled thier vote bank on the name of religion.
Only fight between Pakistan establishment and irman Khan is CPCE China Trade.. 😂😄😄one thing is common between them is USA😄😅
it is a good thing? like iranian mullah are doing with women? why r u imposing ur ideology on others?
میں خاندانی جماعتی ہوں بھیا، میری وائف، بہن اور بھابیاں کوئی چہرے کا پردہ نہیں کرتیں۔۔۔۔
ہم ترغیب ضرور دیتے ہیں، زبردستی کبھی نہیں کرتے ۔۔
کراچی سے جیتی کئی خواتین بلدیاتی امیدوار پردہ نہیں کرتی اور جماعت نے انھیں ٹکٹ دیا ہوا ہے۔
@@abdulmoiz6760with all due respect please share the names of the candidates you mentioned above.
Greetings from Singapore, Zaidi Sab should be given honorary citizenship in India.
Baseless points with no rationale, specifically on JI and its ongoing protest.
what was baseless about those points. Why JI was getting all media coverage but protest in Balochistan was not even discussed once.
@@sherirathor4513 does this prove JI is B team for Talibans or Army? Does this prove there are 350 people sitting in the protest? Does this prove that ordinary women aren't allowed in JI protests/programmes?
I mean, what does this prove?
he should be Pm
Skukar he Pakistan me bhe koi open minded aur liberal mind insan mojod he , is extremism k ghutte hoe dor me shabbar sahab aik fresh air ki tarah hain.....❤❤
Absolutely 💯
✅
@ProDoctor7 by your dictionary liberal means anti islamic?
By definition, Islamic means through subjugation.
Man of the words❤
The most confused person on earth
jo reality hai wohi bola. ek pure nulk ko khatam karne ke sapne dekhna bakhchodi hai
@@muhammaddanish1531 real🤣🤣🤣
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Apko iski batye samj nhi aai phir
Looks like you are talking about yourself😅
shabbar zaidi is best well wisher of pakistan n india .
Shabbar Zaidi is highly intelligent and mostly right. When he talks you can listen for hours . Gem of Pakistan ❤
Very enlightening. Please keep doing more talk shows with this gentleman.
The things which he says should be listened and understand with a sound mind. He speaks of his experience and extensive international (not only vacations but actuals corporate) exposure. We all as a nation should understand that not everybody is wrong. Yes may be some of the things are a bit hanky panky but just take the points which are in our benefit. Thanks
Shabbar is brave with his genuine points, mostly genuine. But he's high on secularism. Hating extremism that is labelled by religion and hating religious activism are 2 different things.
Shabbar Zaidi lost his credibility during first 3 minutes of this vlog.
Absolutely wrong
Truth is bitter
Only fight between Pakistan establishment and irman Khan is CPCE China Trade.. 😂😄😄one thing is common between them is USA😄😅
Do One Episode With __
Shabbar & Mufti Tariq Masood. 👍
ہم دعا گو ہیں آپ اس نظام میں بہتری کا باعث بنے ,آمین
Shaban zadi zindabad the real hero of Pakistan pure truth and his courage towards freedom of speech through knowledge on civil society, economics and religion amazing
Sari baatain sahi hoon gi. JI, ISRAEL, America ke mutaliq koi Pakistani aisi baat nhi krsakta hai. He really needs to rethink his mindset
he is zionist...
Baat to sai hai bheek to America se mangte hai
havent watched such an amazing podcast for a long time. didnt know we all needed a Zaidi saab in our lives
Sir your podcast is meaning less with shabbir zaidi he doesnt know what he saying
Bhai yah toe angraezi seekh lae…nahi to koyee aur bhaasha mae likh
Adnan Sami Got Indian Citizenship. Famous Singer.
This man talk wrong perception about Islamic point of view.Afsoos hamary mulk may dini taleem ka miyar bohat Kam hn😢
Konse muslim mulk me sabse acha hai ?
I am so glad and thankful to raftar !!!!! for giving us another Shabbar episode! all time favorite guest 🙏🤩 and please always have Faisal bhai Interview him! They have the best chemistry 😆
Dittooo
The whole conversation is very biased, the host also has nothing preparation. There are no references in the entire conversation, only assertions.
Also both idiots should re-read about Jamaat-e-Islami, people like Shabar have done nothing but spread intellectual chaos. Raftar should work on their quality content and review to invite such people in podcasts.
Lol, Jamaate Islami was literally one of the political parties that worked against the creation of Pakistan.
They are wolves in sheep's clothing. If they're not the Taliban they are as bad as the Taliban for Pakistan in the LONG TERM, plus I have a feeling that they low-key support the Taliban in their endeavours.
Shabbar Zaidi is a Great Man!!
He is Honest and Straightforward which is Unlike 99% of Pakistanis!!
💯% agreed with Mr Zaidi . Should all religious cults ban.
100%
شبر صاحب جماعت اسلامی سے واقف نہیں ہیں- جماعت کے نظام کو سمجھ لیں گے تو پکے جماعتی ہوجائیں گے
جماعتی منافقت کی آخری حدود سے بھی آگے ہیں جب ہی ان کو کوئی بھی shit نہیں دیتا۔
Shia Jamati kaisy hoga ?
سود کھانے والے بندے سے آپ عقل کی توقع کر رہے ہیں؟
Just note the tone of talking and debate. Before listening the question rising voice there is no talking manner
💯💯💯💯💯💯
Kalabagh Dam is the best solution to end "provincialism" on energy and water resources.
If there can be Halal Dams in other provinces then there has to be a Halala Dam in Punjab too.
Disappointed from Shabbar Zaidi the way he held Jamaat e Islami with TLP or other sectarian religious panties. He clearly doesn't know a bit about JI. The anchor should have questioned him better
Who brought the thunder squad in universities?
@@saadjamilkhan4674no one other than jamati😂😂
Jammat and TLP are two sides of a coin
@@AsadAhmed-ym8qv absolutely not
Indeed
فرقہ وارانہ جماعتوں اور جماعت اسلامی میں فرق بھی نہیں کر پا رہے اور بحث ایسے کر رہے جیسے جماعت پہ سب سے بڑے ایکسپرٹ یہی ہیں
عقل سے پیدل لبرل یوتھیا
Shabbar sahab here I will disagree with you about JI.
JI is the MOST and ONLY Real DEMOCRATIC party. The son/daughter doesn’t become the head of the party. They have regular REAL elections inside the party and the head is chosen based on true DEMOCRACY. Something which ALL other parties in Pakistan completely LACK.
jawahar lal nehru remained pm of india for 17 yrs not 24 yrs
Ajj dil se acha laga anchor ke sawalat pr ke is ny islam ko defend kiya mashallah ❤️
@@extremeloveforAllah konsay islam ko,barelvi,deobandi,Shia ,ehl e hadith?
aa gya molbi
Islam ko defend first time kar ha h??? Toh 9/11 kya tha phir????😂😂😂😂
@@31souravmondal9/11 ka islam se kya taluk?
@@stateofvictory2779 usdin koi ek yahud bin laden chote chote do building ko jake kissi de diya tha muuhhhha karke.... ye defend nhi to kya tha phir??
Only rational person in pakistan. He is quite open in his thinking
JI❤
Most talented and brave man Mr Shabbar zaidi, we want you as a top leader of Pakistans govt with ik and with the free hands. You are the hope.
I like raftar for being upfront and being firm on the 2 nation theory. The 2 nation theory is what holds Pakistan together, orelse we might as well join India. Shabbir Zaidi is a big representative of the secular society, which wants religion to be out of the system, preferring Western values over all. They want the economy to be lead by interest, and a society where you are able to commit sins publicly without shame. The 2 nation theory had the purpose of the partition was to separate our culture and religion from the Hindus and Sikhs, by creating a Muslim majority country with Islamic principles, and having an Islamic democracy, instead of a secular democracy like the West. The secular ideology has proven poisonous for Pakistan over 77 years. The establishment knows that the majority of the public are in favour of religion being a top priority, even if not acted upon. This is why they use Islam for secular politics in a bad way, and to further push for secularism by using the media and today's secular intellectuals to prove that Islam is not fit for modern day issues. They have been trying to brainwash the public for decades, and the closest they came to secularism was with Musharrafs Martial Law. We need to stick to the 2 nation theory, plain and simple. Anyone against it, should be heavily refuted through knowledgeable scholars.
You didn't get it. Shabbir Zaidi si saying Pakistan was created by Ambedkar to save Kafirs from Muslims not the other way round. There is no democracy in Islam. Democracy means secularism and liberalism. Pakistan has commited to be a secular state in UN. Pakistan cannot decide 2 nation theory - it is upto Indian Muslims to move to Pakistan or not.
Islam and Democracy cannot go hand in hand. Democracy stands in principle of liberalism and equality. If a country is "islamic" , by definition it can't be equal.
@@rohitroll2119 @vinsin328 . You guys don't even know what Islamic Law is. Secularism or liberalism is not necessary in a democracy. Rather the majority determine a democracy. Democracy is also a theory, and till this day, the common man has been fooled to believe his views matter to the power holders. Democracy can be viewed in different perspectives, either the majority of people (rarely implemented) or majority of the stakeholders (mostly implemented), or majority of the wise and intellectuals (rarely implemented). An Islamic government can use any kind of governance system, as long as Islamic Law is implemented with no burden of foreign interference. An Islamic democracy would have highly intellectuals who are guided by the Islamic Law (or scholars) as the preference for representing the public views. Islamic governance can't be a secular state, because secularism demands that religion is a personal belief, not a universal belief, and religion shall not interfere in total aspects of law. The 2 nation theory was to divide 2 nations upon different religions and traditions, 1 of who believed Islam to provide for all aspects of life, including governance.
@@ShezinaTariq Rule of majority is just tribalism. Without liberalism and Equality , democracy cannot survive. That's why there's no successful Islamic democracies.
Please make this intelligent person for prime minister of Pakistan, he have the solution for pakistani problems .Ranjit Bawa 🎉
Not just Shias and Ahmadis, Pakistan commits a "Palestine" in Balochistan (which was invaded and occupied in violation of a Standstill Agreement) and Pashtun/Tribal Areas every single day. And even the people in Kashmir are unhappy with Pakistan now (in addition to the old pre-existing Sindhi & Mohajir issues in Sindh/Karachi).
Idiotic podcast. He has no clue what he is talking about Islamic parties.
He doesn't even know that no one in pakistan considered syed ahmed khan islamic..he worked for britishers and often associated with freemasons as well.. however learning english was not against islam and the molvi of that time was wrong in this regards.
he is speaking on the behalf of 50% population. jab puchwade me dande parenge iran or afghanistan jaise tab akal aayegi
More than 50% of the population agrees with him.
Shabar I like your comments about USA and Shabar is right that Pakistan, Jordan, Saudi Arabia and The Egypt Establishments are indirectly supporting Israel.
He's going crazy day by day...
Send him to india if he loves to be an indian...
And why do you think India will take him? And what about two nation theory?
so u hat🤣e india?
One of the most open podcast in Pakistan.
Appreciated for not beeping anything. 👍🏻
I thought he was liberal but this video and his aggression during islamic discussion showed his hate for Islam. He wants Pakistan without Islam.
So Pakistan cannot exists without Islam.
Yes, he is against Islam and its implementation in the society as a system.
Yes because inserting Islam into everything has worked so well for Pakistan in the last 70 years
Only fight between Pakistan establishment and irman Khan is CPCE China Trade.. 😂😄😄one thing is common between them is USA😄😅
@@KanishQQuotes If you believe Pakistan have been following Islamic teachings from the last 70 years, you must be the person who thinks Modi follows the footprints of Bhagavad Gita.
The best quality of this host is that he listens very peacefully to the guest.
Shabbar is correct about JI. I cannot visualize all ladies in offices and banks wearing shuttlecocks
You are right , wese bhe in ki jamat se aik bhe woman kabhe progress ker k aage ayi he??😢😮
Listen bro does your progressive partyies even a pitty think about the poor and lower middle class people of pakistan kiseee maa keew lal mee ittne himmat thee keee in IPP keee khilaf protest kareee
@@ProDoctor7 they are only there to give birth to kids
@@masroorkhalil9655 I think entire Pakistan should stop paying bills and bills should be paid by ppp and PMLN politicians only for screwing the country!!
@@ProDoctor7read book Jamat Islami women the symbol of modernity by Amina Jamal
Punjabi army is the biggest threat to security of Pakistan.
Seems Shias have real grudge against Sunnis leadership and Jamat e Islami.
They don't want an Islamic rule.
Correction: they dont want sunni Muslim's rule. Otherwise we all know what will happen to them.
Yaar sunni here. Even I don’t want Islamic rule.
Democratically chalao Malaysia ki tarhan.
@@anotherchannelyetagain exactly my point..
In last 5 minutes ,it is clear that anchor can't tolerate and digest the truth of partition.
Really enjoyed it !!
Espiecially the End 😂😂
Nice questions by sir fisal and answers by shabr ziaddi
I'm Molana but Shabbar is 100% right
Right ✅ thanks
Sorry for your past Molana g
😂
Jamaat e islami ❤️
Overall Mr. Shaber bluntly told the truth about the situation in Pakistan and is to blame but I request him not to speak about Religion because you are not a religious scholar. Apart from that you are truly a gentleman.
Jamat e Islami ❤️❤️❤️ Hafiz Naeem Ur Rehman ❤️💞💖
Big fan of Shabar Zaidi
Good 👍
After 45 minutes conversation of Sabar Zaidi is 100% right about provinces preferences mentality totally agree with his points 🙌👌👏👏👏
Don't go with words. He is totally into the same. When he is in the govt, he does the same. He is confusing every one. This is called the business n politics in disguise.
Shabbar isn’t right in so many ways.
Poor Madrsa Knowledge Jihadhi Journalists.
He looks Knowledge person Zero Knowledge