Nehru Vs Jinnah: Jawahar Lal Nehru और Mohammad Ali Jinnah क्यों दूर हो गए थे? Vivechna (BBC Hindi)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 7 янв 2025

Комментарии • 1,1 тыс.

  • @amyayavar
    @amyayavar 3 года назад +41

    कोई आश्चर्य नहीं हुआ मुझे बीबीसी की ये रिपोर्ट देख कर..
    वो अपने ब्रिटिश मालिकों के लिए इतना ईमानदार है कि ऐसी रिपोर्ट बना डाली, जिसमें ऐसा बताया गया कि भारत का विभाजन केवल जिन्ना और नेहरू की महत्वाकांक्षाओं के कारण हुआ.. अंग्रेज़ तो बड़े महान थे, सब भारत के विकास और अखंडता के लिए प्रयासरत रहे.
    ये तो यहीं के लोग जिनके कुकर्मों से भारत विखंडित हो गया..
    बहरहाल, रेहान फजल शानदार हैं.

  • @youthwave
    @youthwave 3 года назад +104

    फजल साहब की खुली सोच को सलाम । इसे कहते हैं स्वस्थ पत्रकारिता ...

    • @nishaverma4173
      @nishaverma4173 2 года назад +2

      and what about hard working people like Arnab Goswami and Sudhir Tiwari ?

    • @s1d14
      @s1d14 2 года назад +3

      @@nishaverma4173 both are modern Jinnah.

  • @ajaykulkarni5624
    @ajaykulkarni5624 3 года назад +31

    भारत का इतिहास सूने तो सिर्फ आपकी लब्स में.
    संगीत जैसी आपकी आवाज मंत्र मुग्ध कर देती हैं.

  • @mayankuniyal408
    @mayankuniyal408 3 года назад +127

    रेहान सर बीबीसी विवेचना की पहचान बन गए हैं ,यह मेरा पसंदीदा कार्यक्रम है

    • @adityaK12
      @adityaK12 10 месяцев назад +1

      Mera bhi.

    • @indubala3155
      @indubala3155 Месяц назад

      Do not believe BBC.
      It has hidden regional geo political agenda in the subcontinent as assigned to it by always calculative hitech dollarcracy.
      Moreover, it is anti -Hindu.
      SriHanuman.

  • @mdmahtabmashaallahalam1300
    @mdmahtabmashaallahalam1300 3 года назад +35

    बहुत ही जबरदस्त स्टोरीज आप ने दिखाया यह देखने के बाद हमें बहुत सारे में जानकारी मिली
    मैं दिल से बीबीसी चैनल हमारे दिल में बसता है
    सबसे ज्यादा सच्चा और भरोसेमंद चैनल है बीबीसी

  • @KBN358
    @KBN358 3 года назад +129

    One like for Journalist's Incredible Voice

  • @beyondinfinity3876
    @beyondinfinity3876 3 года назад +36

    One of the best video regarding nehru and jinnah!

  • @charuchandradiwan192
    @charuchandradiwan192 2 года назад +3

    रेहान साहब साधुवाद।ऐसे ही सच केवल सच से सराबोर ऐतिहासिक जानकारी देते रहिये।ईश्वर आपको स्वस्थ और मस्त रखें।जय हिंद।

  • @king-wu5ng
    @king-wu5ng 3 года назад +15

    आप का विबेचना जानदार शानदार लाजवाब होता है👌
    Aap ka vibechana jandar shandar lalwab hota hai 👌

    • @ashishgadborikar6569
      @ashishgadborikar6569 3 года назад +1

      👍👍
      👍👍👍
      👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

  • @lordvondon
    @lordvondon 2 года назад +75

    Jinnah always looked for differences meanwhile Nehru always searched for similarities.

    • @sanobermughal2531
      @sanobermughal2531 Год назад +5

      Jinnah never wanted partition.....he was in favor of one Hindustan only.....he assumed himself Hindustani first then Muslim....watch .....was Jinnah secular.....that video amazed me too

    • @baldevsingh8715
      @baldevsingh8715 Год назад +1

      Nehru was great follower of Chanakaya and Machiavelli, Jinnah was frank and truthful!

    • @muhammadshakir5452
      @muhammadshakir5452 6 месяцев назад +1

      Jinnah was in Congress even before Moti Lal nehru!

  • @abhijeetpandey5582
    @abhijeetpandey5582 3 года назад +41

    सत्ता का चक्कर बाबू भईया सत्ता का चक्कर😛😛😛

  • @kaustubhSharmahi
    @kaustubhSharmahi 3 года назад +45

    Khubsurat aawaz...Rahan Fazal

  • @JDinRussia
    @JDinRussia 3 года назад +7

    बीबीसी न्यूज हिंदी टीम को मेरा नमस्कार 🙏
    श्री रेहान फ़ज़ल जी से मेरा एक निवेदन है कि देश की आजादी में उन वीरों (किरदारों) को सामने लाने का प्रयास करें, जो आज भी पर्दे के पीछे छुपे हुए हैं।

  • @Raj0520
    @Raj0520 3 года назад +37

    Nehru's vision and country after 75 years India is still a vibrant world's largest democracy and secular republic....while Jinnah's pakistan a theocratic state with no democracy where military rules over public leaders and a rogue state.
    Who was a better visionary leader.....the choice is there for everyone to see.

    • @mohammadshafaq8919
      @mohammadshafaq8919 3 года назад +4

      What largest democracy? These are all bookish terms. From Aug 5 2019 you snatched Internet and calling facility from kashmir for around 500 days! What democracy are you talking about where people of kashmir who are just asking for right to self determination as promised by India to them are being killed raped by your occupying forces. Muslims are mass murdered for eating cow? This is your democracy ? Kashmiri students are beaten up whenever a match takes place between ind and pak no matter who wins. Being a kashmiri my favourite player is babar azam and my favourite team is Pakistan and you know on that I can get killed in India. India is basically a hindutva state under the cover of secularism. #fuckyourdemocracy

    • @surenderrao3103
      @surenderrao3103 3 года назад +2

      @@mohammadshafaq8919 no internet equals no democracy

    • @mohammadshafaq8919
      @mohammadshafaq8919 3 года назад +5

      @@surenderrao3103 kashmir has never seen the so called democratic face of India. We only India as an occupier who occupies our land.

    • @surenderrao3103
      @surenderrao3103 3 года назад +5

      @@mohammadshafaq8919 that I agree .about democracy or lack in Kashmir But to say india is occupying force like Israel in palestine Is Kashmir has been a part of India for five thousand years . much before Arabia became Islamic .one of the important schools of Hinduism trikaula shaivism if from kasmir .so bhai don't call india occupiers

    • @mohammadshafaq8919
      @mohammadshafaq8919 3 года назад +1

      @@surenderrao3103 kashmir has never been a part of India. Yes we had Hinduism in kashmir some 700 years ago but that doesn't mean we were Indian. Kashmir was always a separate and independent nation since ages. We have our recorded history of 5000 years old and never do our historians call us Indians! India is exactly following Israel policies in kashmir and India is an occupier just like Israel occupies Palestine. We the people of kashmir reject India and its policies and we want our right to self determination

  • @Vivekkumar111
    @Vivekkumar111 3 года назад +66

    Jinnah is not ready to work under nehru and VICE versa। This result in partition of India। Very sad।

    • @abd9772
      @abd9772 3 года назад +4

      Exactly... Dharm ik shosha tha..

    • @newsjunkieish
      @newsjunkieish 3 года назад +9

      It's true that they did not want to work under each other. But the decision for Partition was taken by the British. We had no option but to accept. Otherwise the Btits won't have left.

    • @newsjunkieish
      @newsjunkieish 3 года назад

      @@rokeyakhatun61645 😂😂😂😂😂

    • @newsjunkieish
      @newsjunkieish 3 года назад +3

      @@rokeyakhatun61645 Aap logo ka problem yahi hai. Ek kitaab pqdh lete hai aur decision bana lete hai. Pure region ki history padhiye, saare stakeholders ke views padhiye. Uss time ke doosre colonies Mein Kya hua padhiye. Yeh Jinnah aur Nehru ki life story padhna zaroori nahi hain. Pakistan banna tha kyuki uss time ke Imperial masters ko chahiye tha. Nehru Jinnah nahi hote, to bhi yahi hota.

    • @Ayush-zp3ql
      @Ayush-zp3ql 3 года назад +1

      Dono ke dono power ke bhookhe the ...chor the sale

  • @radhakinnarofficial9486
    @radhakinnarofficial9486 3 года назад +58

    *सभी खुश रहो किन्नर समाज को आप सब के बीच लाने की छोटी सी कोशिश हे सभी का support चाहिए* 💕❤️💯

    • @learnwords.
      @learnwords. 3 года назад +3

      We all respect you.
      You are not different,
      You are special. You all are.

    • @mr.junedansari1167
      @mr.junedansari1167 3 года назад +5

      100%

    • @designerpotandplanter1004
      @designerpotandplanter1004 3 года назад +1

      इसमें आपकी कोई गलती नहीं यह तो प्रकृति की गलती है जो आप भुगत रहे हो हम अपने खुशियों में आपको शामिल करते हैं आपका एहसान और स्नेह मांगते हैं यह हमारा सबका समाज है इसमें अच्छे और बुरे लोग दोनों तरह के होते हैं

    • @viratsinghrajput123
      @viratsinghrajput123 3 года назад +3

      Bahut hi aslil chanel hai tumhara...

    • @unknownvideo5748
      @unknownvideo5748 3 года назад

      @@viratsinghrajput123 😂😂😂

  • @sumitbhatia000
    @sumitbhatia000 3 года назад +17

    What a research .
    What a reporting
    Hope our Indian media will learn something from u

  • @harishlohar3987
    @harishlohar3987 3 года назад +40

    Thanks god for blessed us visionary nehru as freedom fighter and PM for long time to liberate our nations soul, what we are worlds largest vibrant democracy, secular nation, second largest military power, science and space, Top 5 economy according to purchasing power. Happy Independence Day🇳🇪. Jai Hind.

    • @Cricknock911
      @Cricknock911 2 года назад

      Hahaha nyc joke....largest Democratic country....

    • @kritagya.Rajawat
      @kritagya.Rajawat 2 года назад +2

      @@Cricknock911 pakistan’s economy has crashed real reason lack of education , please google which country is world’s largest democracy it will show the world’s oldest country called india before that bharat .

  • @fk9174
    @fk9174 3 года назад +38

    आज जिन्ना की वजह से देश अलग ना होता तो शायद आज अपना भारत वर्तमान समय में सुपर पॉवर देश होता अपना देश 😥😥😥

    • @simplestudyvlogs1025
      @simplestudyvlogs1025 3 года назад +8

      सुपर पावर अच्छे लोगो से बनता है ।जिसका नेता ही धर्म का अफीम चाटकर बटवारा चाहता था ।अच्छा हुआ कचड़ा बाहर निकल गया ।

    • @jijaji5363
      @jijaji5363 3 года назад

      @K.s ,,, Bhai Lol 😂😂😂😂

    • @Arman.ff.555
      @Arman.ff.555 4 месяца назад

      Batwara angrejon Ne karvaya tha aur vah Gandhi Ji Se Milkar kara tha

    • @umashankarjangid8848
      @umashankarjangid8848 3 месяца назад

      ​​@@simplestudyvlogs1025अच्छे लोग तो किसी भी कौम में नही है हिन्दू मुस्लिम सब में ही बुरे लोग हैं

    • @extreme4642
      @extreme4642 3 месяца назад

      Achha hai partition ho gaya nahi toh yeh pakistan, bangladesh aur India kay musalman milkar hum Hinduon ka jeena haraam kar dete. Achha hua partition ho gaya.

  • @comedyhouse8663
    @comedyhouse8663 3 года назад +75

    जवाहर लाल नेहरू और अली जिन्ना दोनों को सत्ता की भूख थी इसलिए आपस में लड़ते थे 😉😉😉

    • @AlokOberoy
      @AlokOberoy 3 года назад +1

      Right

    • @nimad6704
      @nimad6704 3 года назад +5

      बिल्कुल सही बोला इसलिए सरदार पटेल के पक्ष में जनता फैसला दिया और गांधी जी ने बना दिए नेहरू को पीएम 😐😐

    • @latadubey8513
      @latadubey8513 3 года назад

      Sahi kaha

    • @ajit1592
      @ajit1592 3 года назад

      Ji nhi ek maal ke chakar me... Or kon thi sbko pta hai

    • @sadabahargeet6405
      @sadabahargeet6405 3 года назад +1

      No ,one wanted a united India and one wanted a country on basis of his bogus two nation theory

  • @shakilahmad2046
    @shakilahmad2046 3 года назад +60

    Nehrujis vision was progressive that religion can not be the basis of any country,no congress Leader was in favour of Jinnah becoming PM.Nehru led India to a great nation with Industrial and scientific progress and the condition of Pakistan is precarious because of misuse of religion.Nehruji was right and most competent person for PM of India.

    • @alihammadshah
      @alihammadshah 2 года назад +6

      Nehru was a closet Hindu nationalist, Jinnah wanted protection for Muslims in Indian constitution and Nehru refused. Nehru son the later PM of India called India a Hindu Raj, India's secularism was only a veneer to get international support. The oppression of Muslim and almost zero political relevance in India shows what Nehru's vision led to for Indian Muslims.

    • @shakilahmad2046
      @shakilahmad2046 2 года назад +15

      @@alihammadshah If u r from pakistan I have nothing to say because u belong to a failed state.Hindus say Nehruji was pro muslims,u r saying he is pro hindu but the fact is he was a true nationalist democrat,.No constitution in the world gives protection to a particular community,it is for the betterment of all,Indian constitution is best in the world.Muslims r themselves to blame
      for their measurable condition,yes Govt also deprive us,but we did not take care of relevent education for muslims,India will never be a hinduraj,it will remain secular democracy because Nehruji has given India avery strong foundation of democracy and secularism.

    • @cp12298
      @cp12298 2 года назад

      @@shakilahmad2046 *Sabka time ayega*
      If not tomorrow than for sure one day we will rise just like China (just 30 years ago, China was one of the poorest nations)
      Btw Muhammad Ali Jinnah, the man who destroyed Might Akhand Bharat 💪

    • @cp12298
      @cp12298 2 года назад

      @@shakilahmad2046 We all know what is happening in India with Indian Muslims, BJP is trying to put a Hindu CM in IoJ&K (a Muslim majority state). QuaideAzam was right, there is no place for Muslims in Hindu India.

    • @shakilahmad2046
      @shakilahmad2046 2 года назад

      @@cp12298 Mr Jinnah was a disaster for we muslims,see the precarious of condition of pakistan now a failed state.May be that in last 8 yrs we r facing some trouble but still we r better placed than pakistanis

  • @AlokOberoy
    @AlokOberoy 3 года назад +104

    *निष्कर्ष :- सत्ता के लिये स्वार्थ से पूर्ण लिप्सा ने हिन्दुस्तान का विभाजन करवाया।*

    • @OMPRAKASH-ji2mk
      @OMPRAKASH-ji2mk 3 года назад +3

      कुर्सी का ही चकर था

    • @rajkumarpaul2364
      @rajkumarpaul2364 3 года назад +1

      Islia netaji ko apne hi desh mai rahane nhi dia

    • @rajeshdwivedisahar1251
      @rajeshdwivedisahar1251 3 года назад

      Jinna tumhari .....😂

    • @AnantKumar-ji1re
      @AnantKumar-ji1re 3 года назад +1

      @@OMPRAKASH-ji2mk Kursi ke chakkar se bada 2sra chakkar tha. Vibhajan me Bhartiyon ki bhumika doem darze ki thi. Ek aupniweshak mahaprabhuon ke charno me lote laga raha tha, "Hame Pakistan do". 2sra na na karte haan kar baitha. Partition angrezon ne kiya.

    • @epicxd75
      @epicxd75 3 года назад

      Jinnah ne woh kar dikaya jo log Impossible kehte te

  • @abhijeetpandey5582
    @abhijeetpandey5582 3 года назад +102

    काश उस वक़्त ही कोई जिन्ना या नेहरू में से किसी एक को टपका देता तो हाल ऐसा नही होता😛😛

    • @vishalchoudhary7326
      @vishalchoudhary7326 3 года назад +22

      jinna ko tapkana thaa kunki agar nehru marte toh hamara desh bhi pak ke tarah ho jata

    • @kirannair7815
      @kirannair7815 3 года назад +19

      Sahi Kahe nathuram ko een dono ki supari deni chahiye thi. Kam se kam bapu tho bach jaate.

    • @kirannair7815
      @kirannair7815 3 года назад +10

      @@vishalchoudhary7326 nehru my foot!! we had better than him. Sardar Patel was the top candidate for PM on those days by congress committee.

    • @vishalchoudhary7326
      @vishalchoudhary7326 3 года назад +17

      @@kirannair7815 are behan 1951 me phela election hua thaa aur patel phele he expire kar gaye the.
      Book parda karo whatsapp kaa gyaan naai

    • @fahadkhan454
      @fahadkhan454 3 года назад +9

      Mai hota jina ko paka pal deta

  • @sv3656
    @sv3656 3 года назад +29

    Conclusion: दो इंसानो की महत्त्वाकांक्षाओ ने एक अखंड देश को विभाजित कर दिया।

  • @faizalahmed9568
    @faizalahmed9568 3 года назад +11

    Agar pakistan bnta hi nhi toh logo ki zameen, jaan, relatives, natural resources sab kuch ek rehta aur shyd hum china aaj jaha h waha hum hotey.....
    Jinnah ki soch na hoti toh Muslim league or RSS dono na hotey.....
    Kitne Mandir hotey, kitne sare gurudwara hota and the important Kartarpur...
    Pakistan na bnta toh na Sikh bhaiO ko sehna parta aur na Bengalis ko sehna parta....

  • @akaj188
    @akaj188 3 года назад +32

    Rehan Fazal is simply brilliant and it is a treat to watch his very informative narrative videos.

    • @rahulpandeyeknekbanda7970
      @rahulpandeyeknekbanda7970 3 года назад +1

      Ashwani kuch tameez seekho aap politics me

    • @akaj188
      @akaj188 3 года назад

      @@rahulpandeyeknekbanda7970 Sir Namaskaar Thanks for replying

    • @rahulpandeyeknekbanda7970
      @rahulpandeyeknekbanda7970 3 года назад +1

      @@akaj188 welcome bhai ji 🙏

    • @akaj188
      @akaj188 3 года назад

      ​@@rahulpandeyeknekbanda7970 Sir OK

    • @fiazalikhan
      @fiazalikhan 2 года назад

      Reality of randibaaz, zani, pivot ,chain smoker. Pagal eh Azam jinnah.
      Below in English
      تمہارے باپ دادا نے اس ملک کے لیے خون دیا اور تم لوگ ایک پاگل جناح کی بات سن کے ملک چھوڑ کے بھاگ،
      جنہ ایک شرابی تھا،وہ ایک زانی تھا،وہ ہندوؤں کا ایجنٹ تھا،اس کی
      بہت شاری ناجائز اولاد ہے۔
      انڈیا کے مقابلے میں پاکستان اور بنگلہ دیش ایک
      ٹائلٹ اور باتھ روم ہیں
      Jinnah was alcoholic and fornicator(father of many illegal childrens), he had no knowledge of Islam not even basic knowledge(like namaz, roza), (Jinnah is father of Nusli wadia).
      An alcoholic and fornicator can't create a nation he was tool, what ever is taught in Pakistan about him are lies created by his sister(she had eye on his property, when Jinnah joined politics from nowhere she started leaving with him). She glorified a scoundrel jinnah by creating dummy stories.
      He barrowed the concept of two nation theory from his guru savarkar(self declared veer, he use to get pension from British as gift)
      He was used by Nehru, pant, RSS and Nehru's illegal sasural(British).
      Jinnah was doubtful person, he saved sardar Patel when they were allegations of mismanagement of lakhs of money ofAhmedabad corporation Gujarat.
      He sacrificed everything to save his best friend sardar Patel, Pakistan was created by jagirdar muslims (not common muslims) they were not even 1% of total muslim population,
      Common muslim had no right to vote.
      Pakistan was planned by British,jinnah agent of rss,Patel and Nehru.
      On 14 aug 1947
      When lakhs of hindus,muslims and Sikhs were massacared he was enjoying party with Britishers surely alcohol and women's were on menu.(I have invitation card if you want to see give your email, Facebook, Twitter account I will post).
      Allama Iqbal and other leaders wanted proportionate partition/United India with equal participation, what jinnah got is tip from Nehru and Patel,
      Pakistan and Bangladesh is like toilet and bathroom of big Mansion.
      After partion and lot of bloodshed when he was counting his dates he accepted his mistake before Liaquat Ali and was feeling guilty.
      L.K. Advani (rss,enemy of true faith)visited the grave of jinnah to thank jinnah(slave of ill minded Hindus)
      Jaswant Singh (rss) wrote a book praising jinnah.
      In recent gathering(2022, April) in Gujarat rss praised jinnah as great leader.

  • @abuhanzalaalamin1207
    @abuhanzalaalamin1207 3 года назад +13

    Every episode may your kind self is absolutely wonderful thank you sir

  • @epicaffairs
    @epicaffairs 3 года назад +41

    Facts from history:
    The countries, in addition to India, which mark a national day on August 15 are - Bahrain, North Korea, South Korea, and Liechtenstein.

    • @akshaybankar6781
      @akshaybankar6781 3 года назад

      And one more republic of Congo

    • @onaisarehmani2884
      @onaisarehmani2884 3 года назад +2

      Afghanistan 🇦🇫

    • @epicaffairs
      @epicaffairs 3 года назад +1

      @@onaisarehmani2884 Taliban regime in AFG is not a recognised government. So, we can't include Afghanistan.

  • @Tusharabhan
    @Tusharabhan 3 года назад +3

    Nehru ne Maulana Azad ke jaisa ek mohra pahle hi bana liya, lekin us Maulana ko bhi 1 sal me samajh aa gaya to usne ek kitab likhi
    INDIA WINS FREEDOM

  • @abhyzhek
    @abhyzhek 3 года назад +18

    I guess the epic tales of independence would always excite the Indian subcontinent to everyone living here be it Pakistan, India , or Bangladesh.

  • @nabakachari2760
    @nabakachari2760 3 года назад +4

    History and reporting, both are hearttouching.

  • @nomadicsoul9156
    @nomadicsoul9156 3 года назад +21

    Nehru was visionary, Jinnah was reactionary. 🙏

    • @KiranPatil-tj8mq
      @KiranPatil-tj8mq 3 года назад +6

      What nehru was visinory? He had playboy life when country was suffering with poor people. He also had sex with lady mountbatten. U need to read book u will understand how this guy was most distraous for our country.

    • @nomadicsoul9156
      @nomadicsoul9156 3 года назад

      @@KiranPatil-tj8mq I think u haven't read about him.
      Do you gain knowledge from watsapp..??

    • @KiranPatil-tj8mq
      @KiranPatil-tj8mq 3 года назад +2

      @@nomadicsoul9156 There are so many books on it. its on you whether u wanna belive it or not. He was english man in indian avatar. british used spy lady mountbatten which both jinnah and nehru liked from their college days. some people say he even had sex with her which is kinda meintioned in her letter. he made sure that english culture never dies in india from religion, language and education system that is designed to produce slaves. same laws are still there. when american, french revolution happened they completely abolished british laws. but it didnt happen in india. both jinnah and nehru also use to eat beef and pig meat.
      There are lot of things u child dont know. u honestly think only east india company looted us? there were multiple companies that looted us and they still exist. nehru made contract with them. basically we never had independence even now. Currently british gov hiding documents of mountabatten and wants to demolish them as it might damage UK-india relation. but irish historian filed a case against it. U r still child u have no idea how this country and people suffered. its on you whether u wanna belive it or not.
      15th aug 1945 - japan lost and surrenderd to britian
      15th aug 1947 midnight - india got independence. why did british gave independence on same day?

    • @INT007M
      @INT007M 3 года назад

      @@KiranPatil-tj8mq you are right at your place. But we had only two options nehru and jinnah. There was no MODI that time. In such condition nehru was only option for india. 👍🏻 so please don't creat dispute here nehru did lot of creativ works for development of india. 👍🏻

    • @KiranPatil-tj8mq
      @KiranPatil-tj8mq 3 года назад +3

      @@INT007M nehru was only option? Then u didn't know anything, we had sardar patel, netaji (who knows whether he was killed or not ) and many more. But sadly we didn't get what we deserved.

  • @shahabuddinalam2830
    @shahabuddinalam2830 3 года назад +13

    Nehru's thought is better than jinnah

    • @PkTrek
      @PkTrek 3 года назад +2

      Jinnah ko pata tha Muslims ko cow k nam pe kata jye ga tbi unhon ne apni zindgi ki qurban ki Muslims ko azad krwaya Hindutwa regime se

  • @wani.official
    @wani.official 3 года назад +8

    Classic Jinnah...Indeed He was great...Ind was great earlier but not now , here politicians have destroyed the brotherhood between hindus and minorities ...it is brotherhood between hindus and muslims which makes ind great......

  • @prathamyadav6584
    @prathamyadav6584 3 года назад +22

    sir, your voice is just incredible

  • @vedishablogs1498
    @vedishablogs1498 3 года назад +1

    Abhivadan swikar kijiye Rehan fazal ka....bahot sundar sadrikaran hai aapka..

  • @balkishorprasadyadav6415
    @balkishorprasadyadav6415 3 года назад +4

    रेहान फजल जि बीबीसी विवेचना का वाहिद अवाज है । बालकिशोर यादव , मधेस नेपाल से

  • @FerozKhan-bs1du
    @FerozKhan-bs1du Год назад

    Fazal sahab is one of the best orator of Hindustani language in BBC.

  • @Albutyt
    @Albutyt Год назад +3

    Jinnah personality was one of the most rare personalities in the history of india. He was intelliegent, charismatic and yet so empty of emotions. Nehru and Gandhi were quite overwhelmed with emotions and they were common man leaders.

  • @hitendersingh6285
    @hitendersingh6285 2 года назад +2

    Thanks mhomad Ali Jinah 75 years freedom For Hindu 🕉

    • @baloch0p
      @baloch0p 2 года назад

      Also freedom to Muslim

  • @mehmoodrana8753
    @mehmoodrana8753 3 года назад +19

    Jinnah was a great leader Allah shower his blessings on him ameen

    • @baibhav11
      @baibhav11 3 года назад +6

      He was a coward.

    • @Malikiumer1219
      @Malikiumer1219 2 года назад

      @@baibhav11 nehru was the biggest coward in the world

    • @Malikiumer1219
      @Malikiumer1219 2 года назад

      @@baibhav11 nehru was the biggest coward in the world

    • @moonwalkar7214
      @moonwalkar7214 2 года назад

      @@baibhav11 phele to toilet se ho kr aja

    • @classicprintcard1410
      @classicprintcard1410 2 года назад

      @@baibhav11 1+₩₩₩₩₩₩3₩111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

  • @nisarfangari8759
    @nisarfangari8759 3 года назад +22

    Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru Ji was the Greatest Beloved Leader of the middle of the Twentieth Century who has been marked,valuàted and given the most unique and ambitious directions by the Mahatma Gandhi Ji resulted not only to the Independence of India but for the most valuable Sovereign and Good Governance gifted by the Constitution of India as the most auspicious and valuable Sovereign to India and its Great Nation.Further it will not be an exaggeration if it is said that Sardar Patel Ji was not only the greatest analytical dominent leader of the Middle Century Who got 75percent of votes out of the twelve votes for the First Prime Minister of India and even though Mahatma Gandhi Ji has given chance to the Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru Ji due his kindness, honesty, royalty and nearness to the British Empire and besides the same Pandit Ji was the most beloved leader of the World of his Time.Hence Mahatma Ji had given preference in the same for the oriented results and best performance as well as the Good Governance.Thanks you so much with excuse.Your most sincere obedient truly NH Fangari KALYAN W Mumbai Maharashtra India

  • @GeoPoly55
    @GeoPoly55 3 года назад +10

    Jinaah was a merciless devil. He took millions of lives

    • @Mohammadali-cs8gi
      @Mohammadali-cs8gi 3 года назад

      and ofcourse you and every other kam bakht is an angel. spare us the crap and lies.

    • @GeoPoly55
      @GeoPoly55 3 года назад +1

      @@Mohammadali-cs8gi calm down man. He had merciless personality. He sown the seed of hatred among people. Have a look in history and enlighten. Of course being a Pakistani it's your inborn right to abuse us. Your country originated from the pond of blood of innocent people. Jinnah brought the idea of religion based state which no longer survived finally broke up in 2 pieces.
      Bangladesh born, once again it is at the verge of collapse. The sooner you accept the truth it will good for your people

  • @yogendersharma3481
    @yogendersharma3481 3 года назад +7

    पंडित नेहरू जी को सादर नमन 🙏🏻

    • @MohitYadav-pd7nn
      @MohitYadav-pd7nn 3 года назад +2

      @@rajangaur1351 kis history ki baat kar rahe ho? WhatsApp university forwards ki, BJP IT cell posts ki ya Mr. Modi k fake statements ki?
      Rahi baat girls ki, toh that was his personal life, how does his personal life affect you that much?

  • @aswadliaqat3633
    @aswadliaqat3633 3 года назад +6

    Thank you Sir for A independent motherland

    • @ankitpandey2613
      @ankitpandey2613 3 года назад +2

      Lmao. Independent.

    • @siddiquedogar7060
      @siddiquedogar7060 3 года назад +1

      @@ankitpandey2613 .Aa gye okaat py, isi liay jinah ko ptta tha Aap logon ka.

  • @beyondinfinity3876
    @beyondinfinity3876 3 года назад +20

    Nehru was way progressive than barbarian jinnah!

    • @irpmedia6600
      @irpmedia6600 2 года назад

      burnt a$s endian 😂 😂
      Jinnah, the destroyer of Akhand Bharat
      1 Jinnah vs Sardar Patel, Nehru, Gandhi, Baldev Singh, Sheikh Abdullah, Abul Kalam Azad, Mountbatten
      💪

  • @zeeshan5483
    @zeeshan5483 3 года назад +15

    Muslim League was bitter opposition to Congress .

  • @nimad6704
    @nimad6704 3 года назад +8

    सरदार पटेल के समर्थन में जनता ने पीएम चुना' लेकिन गांधी जी ने नेहरू को बना दिया____सबसे बड़ी भूल साबित हुई____😐😐😐😐

    • @santoshsp1062
      @santoshsp1062 3 года назад

      bhai, agar sardar patel pm bnte ho apna bharat bhut chhota sa hota,, jo hota hai aache ke liye,, jinna ya nehru me se koi ek bnna chahiye tha

    • @ashishsambalpuriya9604
      @ashishsambalpuriya9604 3 года назад

      Nehru kukur tha 😂😂😂😂

    • @Raj0520
      @Raj0520 3 года назад +1

      😂😂🤣 janta ne??
      Abe Bharat ke janta me Gandhi ke baad Nehru sabse lokpriya neta the.....Pehla election 1952 me hua agar 1947 me hota to nisandeh Nehru ko hi desh ki janta chunti uss waqt.

    • @khivrajsinghshekhawat3134
      @khivrajsinghshekhawat3134 3 года назад

      Sardaar vallabhbhai Patel ji nu sadder Naman 🙏

    • @devendra3686
      @devendra3686 2 года назад

      इलेक्शन से पहले तो सरदार जी की मृत्यु हो गई थी जनता ने कभी सरदार जी को प्रधानमंत्री नहीं चुना

  • @dr.balgovindsingh9268
    @dr.balgovindsingh9268 3 года назад +3

    रेहान साहब का दिलचस्प विश्लेषण भी विवेचना को रुचिकर बनाता है साथ ही खनकती आवाज सोने पर सुहागा है।आज की विवेचना अच्छी तो है लेकिन मन में कुछ टीस भी छोड़ गयी है। जो यह है जहाँ तक मुझे या मेरे जैसों को पता है कि कांग्रेस और मुस्लिम लीग कभी भी अपने -अपने हिस्से के भारत के एक मात्र प्रतिनिधि नहीं थे तब इन दलों ने भारत को किस अधिकार से बाँट दिया।भारत तो भारत के हर नागरिक तब भी था और आज भी है।एक बार सबसे पूछ लेते मतलब जनमत संग्रह करा लेते फिर जो होता देखा जाता।साथ ही यदि भारत मेरे जैसे सामान्य भारतीयों के पूर्वजों की जागीर नहीं था तो इन दोनों नेहरू और जिन्ना के बाप की भी जागीर नहीं था भारत।इनके बीच व्यक्तिगत दूरियां घटे या बड़े यह भारत का विषय नहीं था। यह इनका निजी मामला था। मेरी राय में दोनों ही चौथे, पांचवें श्रेणी के पद लोलुप नेता थे जिन्होंने पूरे भारतीय उप महाद्वीप की भारी क्षति की है।जिसकी भरपायी होना मुश्किल ही है। धन्यवाद, रेहान भाई।

    • @Arman.ff.555
      @Arman.ff.555 4 месяца назад

      Angrej Nahin Chahte the ki janmat sangrah ho aur na hi Nehru aur Gandhi Chahte the jabki Muslim League Ne janmt sangrah Ko Kaha Tha

  • @tahirismail3937
    @tahirismail3937 3 года назад +17

    Today's hinduvta extremist ideology proved that Jinnah was right.
    Thank you Jinnah for beloved paksitan ❤️

    • @vishwanathiari
      @vishwanathiari 3 года назад +3

      Ate you Balochi? Thanking Jinna?

    • @latadubey8513
      @latadubey8513 3 года назад +2

      And what about Bangla desh which theory u apply here

    • @smitashah3833
      @smitashah3833 3 года назад +2

      Agar koi Indian hindutva ke khilaf bole to samaj ata he khud ek Islamic republic country bana ke kehte ho ke Hindutava extremist he vah 👍👍

    • @tahirismail3937
      @tahirismail3937 3 года назад

      @@smitashah3833 I'm talking about hinduvta RSS ideology not about Hinduism.

    • @tahirismail3937
      @tahirismail3937 3 года назад +2

      @@latadubey8513 Bangladesh is a Muslim country and our brother country.
      Not a part of India so two nation theory is valid

  • @assamteabyvinay
    @assamteabyvinay 3 года назад +22

    No comparison between zinnah and Nehru... Zinnah had no vision, only religious fanatics, and opportunities

    • @coolboi1621
      @coolboi1621 3 года назад +1

      Right

    • @mmalam8148
      @mmalam8148 3 года назад

      Randia killed gandhi

    • @farrukhhussain582
      @farrukhhussain582 3 года назад +2

      You r wrong Jinnah was a great leader

    • @anik-dn2iw
      @anik-dn2iw 2 года назад

      Jinnah was realistic and Nehru was either blind or liar.no doubt muslims and hindus are entirely different .aik ni ho skty aj b ap ki indian movies ma jo kch udr k muslims k liay bolty ho us sy pta chlta ha aj b aaaaj b muslims ko kitna sa hindus k brabar status daty ho?? Us wqt toh muslims or b bury haal ma thy.lndia ma koi dako lutaira rapist kch b ho bomb dhmaka aatank vadh syasi qatal sb ka ilzam m7slums py lga k qatal e aam krty ho

    • @mohammed_sadiq.
      @mohammed_sadiq. 2 года назад

      @@farrukhhussain582 sala nashedi jinna angrezogi gulam

  • @mahendramehra9486
    @mahendramehra9486 3 года назад +2

    Jai hind rehan sir

  • @uawokensleeplion2709
    @uawokensleeplion2709 2 года назад +3

    I like Nehru big thinking .. but ... Jinnah is our father . love you from ur neighbor 🇵🇰😊

  • @kavijagdishkhatana3486
    @kavijagdishkhatana3486 3 года назад +1

    सीधी बात ये है कि दोनों के निजी स्वार्थ ने भारत को हिंदुस्तान और पाकिस्तान में बांट दिया

  • @ashfaqmd5978
    @ashfaqmd5978 3 года назад +12

    दोनों प्रधानमंत्री के लिए लड़े और देश का बंटवारा हुआ।

  • @chandrabhushan4753
    @chandrabhushan4753 3 года назад

    Today....revised this video. Brilliant Rehan Fazal Ji.

  • @sankeeesharma7910
    @sankeeesharma7910 3 года назад +4

    Two reason - dono primeminister bnana chahte the
    Dono ko Mountbatten ki wife pasand thi college time ki classmate thi , or tbi se dono ek dusre ka competition tha , tbi dono muslimleage ka leader aur congress ka leader bne

    • @skypatr0l
      @skypatr0l 3 года назад

      Aurat ka chakkar babu bhaiya
      Aurat ka chakkar

  • @AZ-hk5ly
    @AZ-hk5ly 2 года назад +1

    No Comparison of Muhammad Ali Jinnah with anyone in Sub Continent. In his times he was ahead of any atleast 5 Decade's.

  • @habiburrehman4494
    @habiburrehman4494 3 года назад +6

    Thank u Muhammad Ali Jinnah.

    • @KaranKumar-bx6gw
      @KaranKumar-bx6gw 3 года назад +2

      Yes thanks to Jinnah for taking crap to Pakistan... Some crap is left behind kindly take them as well

  • @SuperAbd
    @SuperAbd 3 года назад

    Vivechna ek master piece hai

  • @shirazbangash2215
    @shirazbangash2215 3 года назад +3

    Having known the current situation of india and discrimination against muslims, christians and sikh we all have to thanks to Jinnah he fought for our future, otherwise we would have been living in same condition as of muslims in india now adays…

    • @kundanverma4183
      @kundanverma4183 3 года назад

      What about the conditions of minority in Pakistan?

    • @humayunzafer4705
      @humayunzafer4705 2 года назад

      Jinnah-A great visionary leader of Muslims who had farsightedness and vision to see India after 2014 and heard demand of majority Hindus for genocide of Indian Muslims.

    • @rodriguesroshan
      @rodriguesroshan Год назад

      All tension in present India is because of Jinnah's Muslim League. They should have fought the British along with Congress.

  • @devendrasinghrana1884
    @devendrasinghrana1884 2 года назад

    Bahut khubsurat story..like

  • @rameshwardass640
    @rameshwardass640 3 года назад +5

    Best presentation 👌

  • @neerajsrivastav3246
    @neerajsrivastav3246 3 года назад +2

    Apki awaz sunne ko mazboor kar deti hai 🌹🌹🌹

  • @ShivamKumar-gj7xm
    @ShivamKumar-gj7xm 3 года назад +43

    Not country should made on religion , language and culture. It breaks peace in society.

    • @CA_119
      @CA_119 3 года назад +3

      *Israel

    • @farannezam7371
      @farannezam7371 3 года назад

      Israel

    • @CA_119
      @CA_119 2 года назад

      @Ajit Kumar
      😂🤣
      Bawaqoof Pashtuns ka land ha..Ab kiya Imran khan Israel phunch jai..Pathano ki zameen ha Israel

  • @ramugurjar6491
    @ramugurjar6491 2 года назад

    Gjb ptkar Hindi bhut achi he sir ki

  • @sboss2929
    @sboss2929 3 года назад +3

    Sir aapki voice bahut achhi hai

  • @chandrabhushan4753
    @chandrabhushan4753 3 года назад

    Aap bhi mera abhivadan swikar kijiye ...Rehan Fazal Ji....Aap hero hain.

  • @prateeksingh7845
    @prateeksingh7845 2 года назад +10

    All indian institutions have been built by Nehru, no other Indian government could make anything, be it a congress or a BJP government. Sitting in the drawing room and criticizing Nehru is a new age fashion.

  • @vikashjaiswal3491
    @vikashjaiswal3491 3 года назад

    You are a beautiful diamond of BBC

  • @timotheechameleon5918
    @timotheechameleon5918 3 года назад +12

    "Nehru aur Jinnah dono kyo dur ho gaye the?"
    Kyoki dono ko hi PM banna tha!

    • @CA_119
      @CA_119 3 года назад +4

      M.Ali Jinnah nay PM ban nay kay liyi Pakistan nahi banaya...Infact Nehru India ka 10 sal PM raha😂🤣

    • @timotheechameleon5918
      @timotheechameleon5918 3 года назад +1

      @@CA_119 Bichare Jinnah ke sath dhokha hua 😂😂. Lut gaya bechara

    • @maliksahab8551
      @maliksahab8551 3 года назад +1

      @@timotheechameleon5918 if jinnah wants he was the first PM of all indai. When gandhi offer him

  • @ramswaroopkushwah8607
    @ramswaroopkushwah8607 3 года назад +1

    koi bhi topic ho, Rahan sir ko de do, lagta h jese, eye witness h, Hats off Sir....

  • @asifshabbir4601
    @asifshabbir4601 3 года назад +9

    The great leaders of both countries both worked hard for their own country

  • @ganeshbhakuni8448
    @ganeshbhakuni8448 4 месяца назад

    Very nice Rehan sir

  • @kamranali914
    @kamranali914 3 года назад +6

    M Ali Jinnah was a wise leader he knew what majority would do with Sikhs and muslims , today in the govt of bjp it is more than 100 percent proven, salute to Mr jinnah

    • @saifali-qj2hs
      @saifali-qj2hs 3 года назад +3

      @@rky1 haha india k halaat btao log oxygen k liye roads par mar rahay hotay sharam to tum logo ko ati nahi

    • @kamranali914
      @kamranali914 3 года назад +1

      @@rky1 😁😅😁 if pakistan is black listed it would survive but India would not as china new world power is going to crush India 😁😙

    • @smitashah3833
      @smitashah3833 3 года назад +1

      Abe pagal he Hindu or Muslim dono sale dono aaj tak samaj nahi pay ke ye angrez ne khel khel dia agar india United rehta to usme itna potential tha ke firse super power ban jata

    • @kamranali914
      @kamranali914 3 года назад

      @@rajangaur1351 if it is so then it is respected and appreciated but at large India is a living hell for minorities

    • @kedarisgreat
      @kedarisgreat 2 года назад

      At least India has minorities
      Pak ate all its minorities in last 75 years.

  • @SpSingh-jv3ne
    @SpSingh-jv3ne 25 дней назад

    Great update

  • @sachingoyal7229
    @sachingoyal7229 3 года назад +7

    India ka partition ho jaye taki jinnah naye bharat ke vikas me rode na atkaye. - Nehru
    I completely agree on this.

    • @coolboi1621
      @coolboi1621 3 года назад

      👍🏼

    • @coolboi1621
      @coolboi1621 3 года назад

      Jinnah ka koi vision nhi tha country ko lekar bas usko pm bana tha

  • @shashisingh-ow2ko
    @shashisingh-ow2ko 3 года назад +2

    Rihan sir you are the backbone of true indian journalism

  • @sheku1803
    @sheku1803 3 года назад +13

    Hum doobara ek honge...2 logo ki satta ki bhook ne sub continent ka kabada kar diya hai...... 🇮🇳🙏

    • @kamrankhanzada3874
      @kamrankhanzada3874 3 года назад

      Aik hokar kia.karna.he

    • @muhammadyahyyakhan2869
      @muhammadyahyyakhan2869 3 года назад

      Rakh milege baniyo ko badi qurbani Dee h pakistan k liye itni asaani se nhe jaaney deinge kaat daaleinge

  • @armonumj
    @armonumj 3 года назад +1

    शानदार रेहान जी।

  • @WaqarAhmed-cf2oy
    @WaqarAhmed-cf2oy 3 года назад +8

    No doubt M A Jinnah was a great leader jinnah always believed unity faith and discipline and he proved if you are an honest man nothing impossible for U live example in front of U in the shape of PAKISTAN

    • @c.augustedupin8860
      @c.augustedupin8860 3 года назад +3

      Pakistan is an almost failed state
      The so called jinnah legacy is a failed state

    • @abbasjillani6079
      @abbasjillani6079 3 года назад +1

      How pakistan is failed state pakistan GDP 300 billion pakistan nuclear state how you explain pakistan failed state

    • @kedarisgreat
      @kedarisgreat 2 года назад

      Meanwhile today, as per Dawn news.
      A Hindu man was arrested for marrying Muslim woman.
      What a creation by Quad.
      Waqar Sahab……lagay raho

  • @yashwantsingh7
    @yashwantsingh7 3 месяца назад

    अच्छी जानकारी

  • @bijendrasharma6012
    @bijendrasharma6012 3 года назад +5

    Thanks for a nice information, Sir 🙏🥀

  • @ShyamKharkar
    @ShyamKharkar 5 месяцев назад

    🙏नमस्कार sir 🌹🌹🙏

  • @adulgorsi7919
    @adulgorsi7919 3 года назад +8

    Jannaha was the great leader

  • @jiqbal8480
    @jiqbal8480 2 года назад +1

    Mohammed Ali jinnah was the greatest leader ever in the history of this world he created a new country for the poor and oppress people of the sub continent which is called Pakistan. Pure land. Pavitar dharti

  • @humayunzafer4705
    @humayunzafer4705 2 года назад +2

    Mohammad Ali Jinnah-The Quide Azam is a great leader of Muslims in region. He had clear vision of two nation theory at the time of partition based on which he very rightly demanded a separate nation for muslims in subcontinent.
    Today, Indian muslims are facing prejudicial attitude from Hindu majority to the extent that they are demanding genocide of Muslims. I am grateful to my parents who migrated and left their homeland in pain after partition but they secured their generation from endless pain and uncertain future of being a second class citizen.

    • @tejabhadu2822
      @tejabhadu2822 2 года назад +1

      Ye tumhari galat fahmi hai Indian Muslim puri duniya me sabse khus hai, Pakistan ki tarah roj blast nhi hote or na hi baluchistan ki tarah army dwara mare jate hai or jo apne purkho ki dharti k tukde kare wo kabhi great nhi Ho sakta agar Jinnah great hai to shekh mujibar rahman ko gaddar kyo kahte ho or mujibur rahman ne to bangaliyo ko unprofessional army se bachane k liye esa kiya, agar Jinnah Sahi hote to unke banaye mulk k tukde nhi hote or abhi bhi log usi mulk me azad baluchistan k liye lad rahe hai, baki Jinnah musalman bhi nhi tha, jo Britishers k sath pork meat khata ho, sarab pita ho wo musalman kaise ho sakta hai, Britishers ki likhi hui Books pak me ban hai nhi to puri jankari tum logo ko mil jati.

  • @sairabathconcepts3673
    @sairabathconcepts3673 3 года назад

    Rihan ji dhanyawad

  • @AdeshSrivastavaOfficial97
    @AdeshSrivastavaOfficial97 3 года назад +3

    Proud on Nehruji 🙏🇮🇳

  • @vid553
    @vid553 3 года назад +1

    Neharu aur jinnah ki shakhshiyat aur vichar par ek video banaye Sir apake liye meri request hai Ye two person's ki life aur unake vichar samaj ke prati soch hamine pata honi chahiye please sir ek video Dale

  • @deepakkar418
    @deepakkar418 3 года назад +6

    Koi kuch bhi kohe nehuru make india great . Right now what people said about him. Even in this era govt unable to control the corona death .so every people have some lack But nehuru will always be Great .

  • @kasimansari497
    @kasimansari497 3 года назад +2

    Thanks for your best ripoting

  • @araizsiddiqui9975
    @araizsiddiqui9975 3 года назад +3

    Beautiful story

  • @dillipdash5936
    @dillipdash5936 3 года назад +2

    Great insight Sir.

  • @faisal7044
    @faisal7044 3 года назад +3

    Excellent research

  • @valentinevipin7551
    @valentinevipin7551 3 года назад +2

    Thanks for this information.

  • @rajivsharma5648
    @rajivsharma5648 3 года назад +3

    उस समय पार्टीशन बहुत ही खतरनाक था

  • @nice-bj4dn
    @nice-bj4dn 3 года назад +1

    Wah Rehan g

  • @fizzaandleeb3630
    @fizzaandleeb3630 2 года назад +6

    Long live quaideazam Muhammad Ali jinnah..Love u always..u were a great leader of this world😍❤❤

    • @drgurjar5719
      @drgurjar5719 2 года назад

      666665666666666666

    • @drgurjar5719
      @drgurjar5719 2 года назад +1

      66

    • @jiqbal8480
      @jiqbal8480 2 года назад +1

      Mohammed Ali Jinnah the great leader 🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🌹

  • @surajkrgupta3899
    @surajkrgupta3899 3 года назад

    इसी तरह जानकारी चाहिए।