The break in the middle is much better than on the original recording. It's much more dramatic. But that shouldn't surprise me. They're one of those rare bands that does great live versions of thier songs
There are people who can't think clearly anywhere you go. As well as the United States. That doesn't mean that everyone is that way. Some of the best music came from the USA. So stop being snobs. Great video, and amazing song by the way! :D
This song reminds me of the old man who live next door when I was growing up. He told me, that during the Depression, he had to "Queer with the Queers," for money to eat.
(end of my response) Someone was actually saying Shirley usually sounds perfect but sometimes does have her nights off, then some jerk replied that if the first guy thought what he thought, it was because he didnt love garbage enough; so I came in and said that thinking what guy#1 thinks doesnt show a lack of garbage love, but just enough distance and artistic critic which enables one to recognize when the band has a night off. Get it?
LOLOLOLOLOL. I'm American, and I love this little conversation going on here. It's so true. Americans are quite....errrr.....not bright? By the way, this is a great, great song.
yea i know, i love Shirley and all, I just heard a couple concerts where she sounded off, she sounds just fine here, but I mean every great one has thier off nights right?
ok once more I seem to be misunderstood by you here lol. I do know the difference: sounding perfect is more related to the technical part of the performance, singing perfectly well it's clear, the singer is always in the key blabalabl and having a night off is when out of tiredness, repeted shows etc your voice is a little weak and you cant give it all that very night. I think everybody will agree on that. What I was saing was, again, in response to an older comment.
Hmm yet The Simpsons is indeed a brilliant show and if I am correct, there are Americans behind its creation, yes? Let's not stereo-type because as a woman who's lived a whole lot of places, I could shred you.
That's stupid? First, you cant utter a rule about artistic preferences, why should someone have to do, like sth better etc?? and then yeah, most of the time lives are better and bmore loved than the recorded versions, but just because it's garbage, shirley one doesnt have to find that's always perfect. Try to think by yourself for once, you know, to have some artistic and criticl sense, taste and consciousness. Even if, and I'm sure kevpark will agree with me on that, here shirley sounds great
One of my top 3 Garbage songs ever! Shirley is beautiful and her voice is memorising!
This performance is fantastic, Shirley is an amazing performer
Hope to see them together again someday
I watch this performance every morning.
best version of this STILL outstanding song!
one of the best things i've ever seen! it's on my top 10.
I always liked her voice since the first time I ever heard! ^^
She's amazing. They're amazing!
they sound amazing live. first time ive seen a live video of em
Garbage are so effective "live." Another great performance.
God bless this woman!
I watch this performance every afternoon =]
Love this group!
The break in the middle is much better than on the original recording. It's much more dramatic. But that shouldn't surprise me. They're one of those rare bands that does great live versions of thier songs
Vocally she's fantastic on that performance... I wish I could see them live :(
I LOVE IT Thanks for uploading this awesome video
It's about her twisted mind and how exciting it could be that's all. It's great.
god bless that lady !!!
wua .. es muy genial la version en vivo
Garbage are legends.
wonderful girl very very
I love her
Shirley is supercool!! good chick! :) and good song!!
Shirley: number 1 frontwoman! love u
46 years old, can you believe it? still... my kind of girl
she looks so gorgeous here
Tolle Band!
There are people who can't think clearly anywhere you go. As well as the United States. That doesn't mean that everyone is that way.
Some of the best music came from the USA. So stop being snobs.
Great video, and amazing song by the way! :D
perfecto !
thanks :)
3rd April 2005 - Cologne, Germany.
This song reminds me of the old man who live next door when I was growing up. He told me, that during the Depression, he had to "Queer with the Queers," for money to eat.
Spooky night club music.
"Is everyone here american or something?" HAHAH, ZING!
(end of my response) Someone was actually saying Shirley usually sounds perfect but sometimes does have her nights off, then some jerk replied that if the first guy thought what he thought, it was because he didnt love garbage enough; so I came in and said that thinking what guy#1 thinks doesnt show a lack of garbage love, but just enough distance and artistic critic which enables one to recognize when the band has a night off. Get it?
Words have differently meanings in different countries.
LOLOLOLOLOL. I'm American, and I love this little conversation going on here. It's so true. Americans are quite....errrr.....not bright?
By the way, this is a great, great song.
Хороша чертовка)
DAmn Shirley Manson looks so old now on Terminator.
HAHAHAAA!!!!!
true.
ñami ñami ñami
goddamn, she looks good with long curly hair.
yea i know, i love Shirley and all, I just heard a couple concerts where she sounded off, she sounds just fine here, but I mean every great one has thier off nights right?
thats what i say
where did this performance take place? (by the way, it's amazing)
2005
TBH..Im just here for Butch Vig :)
Great song about odd timid people. It's not about homosexuals per an interview by them.
sexxy
She doesn't! She has a dog named Veela, but no kids.
ok once more I seem to be misunderstood by you here lol. I do know the difference: sounding perfect is more related to the technical part of the performance, singing perfectly well it's clear, the singer is always in the key blabalabl and having a night off is when out of tiredness, repeted shows etc your voice is a little weak and you cant give it all that very night. I think everybody will agree on that. What I was saing was, again, in response to an older comment.
she fuckin rocks i love her im gay she only woman i find attractive!!!
this makes Paramore look like crap!
nice performance!
Hmm yet The Simpsons is indeed a brilliant show and if I am correct, there are Americans behind its creation, yes? Let's not stereo-type because as a woman who's lived a whole lot of places, I could shred you.
@LissG76 I prefer t look at her, not the mic.
Has anyone else noticed that some shows Shirley sounds great and in alot others she sounds horrible? no offense or anything I just noticed that
That's stupid? First, you cant utter a rule about artistic preferences, why should someone have to do, like sth better etc?? and then yeah, most of the time lives are better and bmore loved than the recorded versions, but just because it's garbage, shirley one doesnt have to find that's always perfect. Try to think by yourself for once, you know, to have some artistic and criticl sense, taste and consciousness.
Even if, and I'm sure kevpark will agree with me on that, here shirley sounds great
That's because Paramore are crap!