Just in case there are any people watching and wanting to guess who are blue/yellow colour-blind, the soap is mostly black and grey with a royal blue and a slightly purple-blue a bit like an Indigo. On top there is some blue mica shimmer which is a lighter blue than the other shades used. And then the glitter on top is all holographic (features the entire rainbow - like the back of a CD/DVD). And the soap cane is white and grey to look a bit like the moon. Was thinking it would be useful to describe the colour families even if its not the specific pigments being used because not everyone is going to be able to see the colours well. :)
This is such an oddly specific and rare group of people to gear a comment towards but it's so wholesome that someone actually thought about such a small group of people enough to make a comment for them
Wow honestly I can't even explain how happy and thankful I am to have found this comment! I am blue/yellow colorblind but still just like... assumed she mixed her colors too close together and they were just gray and that's why I wasn't seeing any variation, and then I started scrolling through comments to look at guesses and found you! It's odd to say if you don't experience it but I always forget that I'm colorblind! Now I know what this soap actually looks like 😆 Thank you!
@@juliejunkyardx You're welcome! In the other video she did she sort of mentioned the colour families at the end (and lots of comments discussed the colours), but in this one didn't. I could tell that it would be next to impossible to guess at this one because the colours are really quite close especially in terms of tone - they're all pretty cool and dark toned. And the two blues are blended and the two greys are blended.... I'm glad that my comment was able to help someone!
i have such a love/hate relationship with the secret soap series. on one hand, i like getting my brain working, figuring out the clues and, of course, seeing the wonderful things katie and co. creates! on the other hand, I NEED TO KNOW NOW 😂😂
I just got my first bar of your soap in the mail. I have ADHD and a lot of sensory issues that make certain textures extremely unpleasant for me. However, I also have textures that really help me relax or feel less anxious or just make me happy in general to touch (some fabrics, cats/dogs, squishy things, etc). When I started watching your channel ALL I wanted to do was touch the soap and feel what it feels like since I'm such a tactile person who just likes to learn by doing and learns through sensation easily. So I just got my first bar of your soap and it came yesterday and I literally just held it for a while. As stupid as that sounds. 😂 I left it in my room (which is a good sized room) with the door closed and it was in a Ziploc bag today and when I came home and opened my door, the whole room smelled like the soap. 😁 Smells so good!!! Thank you for doing what you do. I really enjoy your videos more than you know.
*I litterally just held it for awhile Doesn't sound stupid to me. I'm a very tactile person too, so I might do this myself. Or I keep going back to pick up, and look at things that really make me happy.
@@PlayLyss I do that with soaps I buy then think they are too pretty to use. I've tried to get a royalty soap but as I'm in the UK between the time difference and how fast they sell out the stars haven't aligned yet lol x
"...and they're in their perfectly lit studio, in I don't know, Washington state, and there's dahlias growing outside, and there's ivy growing inside..." I'm DYING!
Maybe the first one could also be "Nothing Gold Can Stay"? Just because the poem mentions a flower as well as the color green, which both appear in the first soap.
@@kathrynalexander9033 Oh! That's a good possibility, as well. The first thought I had, when I saw the first clue was "the woods are lovely dark and deep".
I have been binge watching your videos for weeks, whoamikidding, months! I will always be a fan, Katie. You gave me the courage to make the leap from FIVE years of melt and pour soap making, and selling, to cold process. And now I am so absolutely in love with it. ❤
There's nightmare before Christmas too... A lot of tim Burton's movies really. In a similar vibe and with that blue colour and the clue, it's making me think of coraline too... A young female hero theme??
okay here's my take: i agree w whoever said bedtime stories and that this one is the arabian nights. the light left on in the house implies that someone is still awake (telling stories). the reason i think this one is the arabian nights includes the fact that the moon stays the same but the sky changes (different nights) and the top looks like the ocean from one of the stories in the book. i also think the first one was the princess and the pea :)
@@artsygal112 Oh I was confused about the last one. I was in between fairy tales, like every else and Classical Paintings. I guest Mona Lisa for the last one, but I see how Frida could also be the inspo.
YES. But, would she actually read Poe?!! He's SO dark & straight up scary. And, does Hans actually have anything remotely "spooky" looking?! LOL! I'm on the hunt / search... LOL!
Since becoming a mom, I don't really find the time to read like I used to... But thx. And yes, I can see the "dark" of the little mermaids. I wasn't thinking of the Little Mermaid...
@@michellecrutchfield8701 I can imagine being a mom is pretty time consuming, but hoping you can get time to yourself, even if it isn't reading lol. I'm not super knowledgeable about Hans' other work but from I know he does have a few more morbid tales, but alot of them are just very sad.
She is confident that we won’t get it and we all know she isn’t a big fan of “ spooky “ stuff like Tim but wouldn’t that potentially “ throw us off” and be like oh no she doesn’t like spooky stuff so it isn’t anything Tim burton style but wouldn’t that be the perfect thing to guess because it’s the complete opposite... looking at the first one that looks so much like Sally’s colours and then the pea on top that could represent the pea soup and then this one where the moon is so is so prominent and you can clearly see that’s a cliff/ mountain edge that could potentially be the spiral that sally and jack stand on I’m guessing nightmare before Christmas 🙌🏻
I’m gonna say the series is Shakespeare inspired. This makes me think of MidSummer’s Night Dream, and honestly that would be right up Katie’s literature loving alley
I enjoy watching your videos because your conversation is very relatable and fun, you and your brother's videos are enjoyable to watch because you are yourselves and have a good sense of humor and creativity. Some other soap RUclipsrs are boring to watch because they are too serious.
I agree with the people saying that she does not like spooky things and she doesn’t watch scary movies there’s some movies that we think are just cartoons were scary to her, so it probably isn’t Tim. She likes to get her designs pretty close to her theme So I don’t think it’s van Goghs starry night because there’s a lot of yellow in it and more blues than black. I want to say Disney fantasia like a couple of other people but she just the Disney princesses
Elpida Bika Kind of but she always matches her theme to her soap and starry night has a lot of yellow so I think she would’ve put yellow swirls if she was trying to do starry night
I really dont know why, but I think is classical music. I'm not sure about the first one but THIS IS MOONLIGHT SONATA BY BETHOVEN. I could just be really wrong but... at least I tried
Mine was a RUclips ad because I was able to skip the one right around when she was cutting was her ad because I wasn't able to skip. She only puts one ad in her videos which is why I won't skip the RUclips ad
That was my guess as well back on the first video! But I've never seen the cartoon, so I in truth can't say if what I'm seeing really lines up with the show.
You’re so sweet for giving away all this free information :). Even though I don’t plan on making soap for a good while, I find it so kind you don’t charge for every recipe.
The scent: Lunar Eclipse from Natures Garden The theme for this soap: Secret Window, Secret Garden by Stephen King. My guess for the first soap was the Secret Garden Frances Hodgson Burnett. I think this is the secret collection. Ironic as it is the secret soaps of 2020.
She doesn't like spooky things AT ALL and Secret Window, Secret Garden is a rather gory and disturbing story. Its definitely not something she would like.
@@rayneb2595 I agree, however she did say that this was not her idea so she could be basing the soap design for some of these on the description of others. The Ghibli soap was the same. Kenny had seen castle in the sky but she hadn't.
Dear duchess, you are the most authentic the way you present yourself. I really like your non artificial attitude. The instagram perfection is not real life and it may teach people that they aren’t acceptable they way they are or look. But imperfections are the real thing! Greetings from Munich, Germany.
The secret soap series is definitely based on Tim burton!! This one is the night before Christmas !!! Look at the moon and the texture that looks like the hills!
I adore nightmare before Christmas and corpse bride so I’d love if that was the theme! However, I can’t figure out a connection to the tea party and the creepy house in the end screen?
Okay, this isn’t a popular guess and it’s probably wrong, but…I think the theme could be Disneyland rides. The first one was the teacups, this one is the haunted mansion…
I feel like if this one was haunted mansion there would be some purple for the wall paper or teal for the ghosts. I would love some Disney ride themed soap though!!
The color scheme for the 1st secret soap matches PERFECTLY with the picture of the ride from 1959 I saw on google just now and the top embeds matched with designs on the sides of the cups. And this one , soap #2, reminds me of the full moon shown behind the mansion in one of the photos I just looked up also. I know she googles reference pics for her soaps and they may be the same ones she used for inspo! I think you nailed it! Can't wait to see what #3 is!
Seeing a lot of people saying Tim burton. But Katie frequently says she doesn't do spooky. She doesn't like dark themes much at all. So I'm leaning towards literature based, like fairy tales. Or artwork
That’s fair, but I’m her rapunzel vid she says something about unwholesome Disney movies getting their time under the spotlight in august of twenty twenty so I guess it’s possible
@@georgieleigh7941 lol. Maybe she is trying to throw us off. In all honesty, I hope its Tim burton. That would be so cool. I remember last year so many people wanted hocus pocus and she was like nope. Other channels have done it. Too spooky for me. Lol
Guys, remember, she is CONFIDENT we won't guess this one! So don't think of anything too popular, think of hidden gems or something forgotten about in modern day. I'm still sticking with Over the Garden Wall, though, as while it has a cult following, it's not so popular that everyone knows about it...and I in truth have never seen it myself either! But at the very least, the house shown here makes me think of the clips I've seen of the cartoon.
The house do give vibes of the show, but overall everything feels more faerie like than purgatory (as the show is). It actually fells like a dark fearie or something of the sorts
She doesn't like scary things, and overt the garden wall is quite disturbing. She doesn't even like Nightmares Before Christmas and OTGW is a lot worse than that.
@@rayneb2595 The guesses at the end and her 3rd soap actually really match the show, which I finally watched on Hulu. I have a full comment on it on the video for soap #3 but yeah...I'm feeling more confident it could be Over the Garden Wall. She says she doesn't like scary things and that's EXACTLY why it could very well be that. She is absolutely confident we're not going to guess this, which means we need to subvert our normal expectations and think outside the box from the Katie we normally know. This said, I can't piece the imagry for soap 1 and this one is...vague. There's a scene in the show where the siblings are sleeping under the stars and the little brother has a wild dream in the clouds. The night sky of that scene could've inspired this soap, but that feels like I'm reaching. But that third soap...it fits so dang perfectly, it's scary. Plus the guesses of the tea setting, the house, and so far the cat all fit the show very well. That's why I'm not ready to give up on Over the Garden Wall being the theme.
I guessed twelfth night lol -- the soaps themselves totally look like they could be themed after Shakespeare plays, if it weren't for the hints at the end.
I saw someone guess "Famous Artists" in the last video's comment section they said that one was Frida Kahlo and it does have the colors of her "Tea and Smoke" painting and then the tea set. I am going to say not just famous artists but "Famous Modern Artists" or "Famous Modern Female Artists" . This one could be Louis Dodd, it has the colors of "Moon with Halo and Clouds" and she does have a painting called "Night House With Lit Window" and that is just what it is too.
Okay... how about this: Disney's Haunted Mansion. There was a section of the ride that was dedicated to what could be called a "Moonlight Picnic." It wasn't terribly popular, but it is part of the history of the ride...
I said this last time, I still think it’s A series of unfortunate events. This is the house at the end is Count Olaf’s. The first soap reminded me of the colors of the book bindings, not to mention the picture at the end reminds me of the pictures they used in the books themselves to allude to the themes of the book or the next book... etc.
minakorei omg I love a series of unfortunate events, but I'm not sure if it fits with the soaps. Also she doesn't strike me as a person who would read the series
I'm getting "Starry Night" vibes from this. I think a Van Gogh theme would be amazing, but given the hint, it appears like it might be Tim Burton like other people have said!
The colors, the moon and the mansion as a hint in the end just reminds me sooooo much of Coraline! The tea is also part of the movie so my guess is that Coraline is the main theme :)
omg ya now that you say that, it does seem like it, maybe multiple tim burton movies? cause the first mystery soap looked like the colors of sally from nightmare before christmas
@@wolfpacklover4 Coraline is not a Tim Burton movie (they have a very similar style though!!) Katie's first tip was a set of tea and if you search on RUclips for "Coraline tea" you will see a scene from the movie that have two characters with a similar color palette from the first soap and accessories that reminds a lot the first soap imbeds + Coraline's yellow raincoat complete the first color palette :)
@@wolfpacklover4 nightmare before Christmas isn't Tim burton either. Both movies were produced by Henry Selick which is why they look so similar. Also Katie has said before that she doesn't like spooky and that she'd never make anything inspired by such.
I love your personality beauty and skill. This combo makes you my favorite soap maker. I have watched other channels and they're good but i keep coming back because you're fun and passionate💜
Is this a soap dedicated to Princess Yue? An Avatar-themed soap series? Even the clues at the end; tea for Uncle Iroh, the creepy house representing Hama/"The Witch" of the Southern Watertribe
It feels like it could be ATLA themed, but maybe thats just me hoping desperately that it is. But the four layers in the first soap looked like they could represent the four nations! And the green soap gumball is the CABBAGES!
I remember this book from when I was younger, one that was a children’s version of the Blue Book of Fairy Tales. It had the princess and the pea, among other stories that were more spooky. This just reminds me of that a bit
This has to be the nightmare before Christmas..... The moon. The original with the colors of Sally's dress. The paw prints of Zero.... The roses and the green peas for the soup... Everything makes sense now!!!!!
Going off my Harry Potter theory, at first I thought the Shrieking Shack which would explain why you did a full moon soap because Lupin would have to hide in the Shack every full moon when he transformed. But it looks more like the house from the beginning of Goblet of Fire where Wormtail hid with Voldemort before his return, which Wormtail was only able to do because he escaped during the full moon after Lupin transformed hence the full moon soap. So it’s a reach but I’m sticking with Harry Potter.
It has got to be Hans Christian Anderson stories! The first one was probably The Princess And The Pea and this one is What The Moon Saw! The cane represents the moon... I think that the fragrance oils are some kind of “sky/spring breeze” from Nature’s Garden
Part of the allure of birds is their shape.. I feel like a soap based on a bird would look too square. If it was based on bird feathers that might look cool though
When someone mentioned Goodnight Moon for this soap I thought maybe the first one could be A Bad Case of Stripes if the theme was picture books. The black frosting matches the main character's hair, the green gumball represents the lima beans she loves, the heart represents how she learned to love herself for who she is, and of course the stripes. Though I don't think either of those books go with the end of video clues.
I made some guesses on the last one. I'm still getting dark fairy tale vibes like Grimm Fairy Tales or Tim Burton movies. Or dark musicals , plays, ballets (no idea how to call that one theme, lol). Getting Into the Woods vibes from this one. But I also like other people's suggestions that the theme is Nightmare before Christmas and this is Jack's hill or Corpse Bride. And a totally out the box suggestion if Johnny Depp characters in movies. (Soap 1: Mad Hatter in Alice in Wonderland; Soap 2: Sweeney Todd from Sweeney Todd or Ichabod Crane from Sleepy Hollow). So fun to watch this unfold and try to guess.
I will admit, the last secret soap series I was taking notes, listening carefully but I didn't have a clue. This time around I'm taking notes and listening to EVERY WORD, inflection, flash of editing! I'm like, "Is that a clue? Is that a clue? Wait, is that a clue?" This is tons of fun, thank you! (From your royal court gobie1kenobie) think Obie won kenobie and you will say it right.
Oh yes thanks I'm guessing the same! I thought I was the only one thinking this. It was my first thought as soon as I saw the roses and stars... it just fits perfectly🌹
I'm getting the Edgar Allen Poe feel from this batch. I can almost heard the Raven whispering Nevermore...nevermore... Love your creation by the way, you make everything fun. :)
Agatha Christi? I'm getting a lot of "classic mystery novel" vibes. I love how the moon turned out. As for the fragrance oil, I'm guessing Nature's Garden, something like Dark Musk or Lunar Eclipse, maybe.
Excited to guess! By the way Katie pls say what type of color you’re using (this blue color or my green colorant is fine) because I’m colorblind and sometimes I just can’t tell if it’s a brown or a purple. Love your channel!
I’m not sure if she said in the video, but in case she didn’t - the large bucket was black, then she did gray, navy and royal blue in the smaller buckets 😊 And the top was dusted with blue, as well.
The secret soap theme is Hans Christian Anderson stories! The first soap was The Princess and the Pea and this one is What the Moon Saw!
o O f
I think she actually got it-
i feel like you're right.
this sounds perfect...
Thanks y’all ☺️
Just in case there are any people watching and wanting to guess who are blue/yellow colour-blind, the soap is mostly black and grey with a royal blue and a slightly purple-blue a bit like an Indigo. On top there is some blue mica shimmer which is a lighter blue than the other shades used. And then the glitter on top is all holographic (features the entire rainbow - like the back of a CD/DVD). And the soap cane is white and grey to look a bit like the moon.
Was thinking it would be useful to describe the colour families even if its not the specific pigments being used because not everyone is going to be able to see the colours well. :)
This is such an oddly specific and rare group of people to gear a comment towards but it's so wholesome that someone actually thought about such a small group of people enough to make a comment for them
Wow honestly I can't even explain how happy and thankful I am to have found this comment! I am blue/yellow colorblind but still just like... assumed she mixed her colors too close together and they were just gray and that's why I wasn't seeing any variation, and then I started scrolling through comments to look at guesses and found you! It's odd to say if you don't experience it but I always forget that I'm colorblind! Now I know what this soap actually looks like 😆 Thank you!
This just made my heart so happy.
@@juliejunkyardx You're welcome! In the other video she did she sort of mentioned the colour families at the end (and lots of comments discussed the colours), but in this one didn't. I could tell that it would be next to impossible to guess at this one because the colours are really quite close especially in terms of tone - they're all pretty cool and dark toned. And the two blues are blended and the two greys are blended....
I'm glad that my comment was able to help someone!
That's so nice!
I feel like this just confirms my famous painter/ works of arts theme! This is Vincent Van Gogh/starry night!
i have such a love/hate relationship with the secret soap series. on one hand, i like getting my brain working, figuring out the clues and, of course, seeing the wonderful things katie and co. creates! on the other hand, I NEED TO KNOW NOW 😂😂
Jessica Rose SAME
glad to see I'm not the only one struggling here XD It's a genius concept though. Who knew soaps could generate so much suspense!
@@Melissandrel i know!! katie's a mastermind 😁
I'm more of the second part, I need to know now 😂
I feel the same way!
I just got my first bar of your soap in the mail. I have ADHD and a lot of sensory issues that make certain textures extremely unpleasant for me. However, I also have textures that really help me relax or feel less anxious or just make me happy in general to touch (some fabrics, cats/dogs, squishy things, etc). When I started watching your channel ALL I wanted to do was touch the soap and feel what it feels like since I'm such a tactile person who just likes to learn by doing and learns through sensation easily. So I just got my first bar of your soap and it came yesterday and I literally just held it for a while. As stupid as that sounds. 😂 I left it in my room (which is a good sized room) with the door closed and it was in a Ziploc bag today and when I came home and opened my door, the whole room smelled like the soap. 😁 Smells so good!!! Thank you for doing what you do. I really enjoy your videos more than you know.
*I litterally just held it for awhile
Doesn't sound stupid to me. I'm a very tactile person too, so I might do this myself. Or I keep going back to pick up, and look at things that really make me happy.
I cut my soap into a smaller bar so I can leave half in my t-shirt drawer and make them smell yummy. It also helps harden it up a bit more
@@gobie1kenobie oh that's a good idea!!
@@Paperscrapper I'm glad I'm not the only one 😂
@@PlayLyss I do that with soaps I buy then think they are too pretty to use. I've tried to get a royalty soap but as I'm in the UK between the time difference and how fast they sell out the stars haven't aligned yet lol x
"...and they're in their perfectly lit studio, in I don't know, Washington state, and there's dahlias growing outside, and there's ivy growing inside..." I'm DYING!
The shade lol
I live in Washington and was like 👀
@@entie_kat8578 same or actually grew up in Washington and moved out of state recently
Yep, that just cracked me up 😂
definitely Tim Burton themed! Last soap was Sally from a nightmare before christmas, and this one is corpse bride inspired!
I have the same guess but i was thinking more sleepy hollow vibes
this has been exactly my thoughts as well!
Ooo this one is good 2
OH! Tim Burton makes a lot of sense!
We're heading towards halloween as well!
my suggestion for the catchphrase for getting ready: "I'm bringing safety back"
"...Here!." 😂
The absolutely inhuman noise I just let out at "LET'S MAKE SOME SOAP"
Literally have never seen a clip more accurate in my LIFE
Theme: nightmare before Christmas
1st: sally
2nd: jacks hill
Robert Frost: First one was "Peck of Gold". This one is "Acquainted with the Night"...
I think you're right!! That seems exactly what the theme is.
That is so smart
Maybe the first one could also be "Nothing Gold Can Stay"? Just because the poem mentions a flower as well as the color green, which both appear in the first soap.
@@kathrynalexander9033 Oh! That's a good possibility, as well. The first thought I had, when I saw the first clue was "the woods are lovely dark and deep".
I agree with this answer. Well done.
I have been binge watching your videos for weeks, whoamikidding, months! I will always be a fan, Katie. You gave me the courage to make the leap from FIVE years of melt and pour soap making, and selling, to cold process. And now I am so absolutely in love with it. ❤
Maybe it's not "Let's get ugly!" Maybe it's "Let's get safe!"
Darkwing Duck's Let's Get Dangerous🤣🤣🤣
Still thinking Tim Burton movies. This one makes me think of Sleepy Hollow.
I said Tim Burton last round too. 😃 I can see Sleepy Hollow, but I first thought of Corpse Bride when I saw it.
Also Tim Burton but this made me think of edward scissor hands
krx I was thinking of that too but wasn’t sure I was right. 😂 I was thinking there might’ve been white involved if it was for her dress but 🤷🏼♀️
There's nightmare before Christmas too... A lot of tim Burton's movies really.
In a similar vibe and with that blue colour and the clue, it's making me think of coraline too... A young female hero theme??
I questioned this too, but she's said repeatedly that she doesn't watch anything spooky or creepy, and I think Sleepy Hollow would fall into that.
okay here's my take: i agree w whoever said bedtime stories and that this one is the arabian nights. the light left on in the house implies that someone is still awake (telling stories). the reason i think this one is the arabian nights includes the fact that the moon stays the same but the sky changes (different nights) and the top looks like the ocean from one of the stories in the book. i also think the first one was the princess and the pea :)
Sorry I skipped to the end....BUT
CLASSICAL PAINTINGS
This looks like a Starry Night soap.
I'm hoping this is the secret soap inspo 🙏🏻
I replied last video that the soap had been Frida Kahlo...cause I agree, it gave me those exact feels!
Saaaame
Lol. I just said that out loud!
i thought that too but why use silver vs gold? the starry night has those same colors and yellow :(
@@artsygal112 Oh I was confused about the last one. I was in between fairy tales, like every else and Classical Paintings. I guest Mona Lisa for the last one, but I see how Frida could also be the inspo.
Everything is dragon themed. Even if it's not, it still is.
The color in the thumbnail is the most magical color I have ever seen!
GIRL. I'M LIVING FOR IT. I know a lot of people love the pastels and such, but dark and sparkly is sooooo my jam. More like this please! 😍 😍
Classic literature, Hans Christian Andersen, Edgar Allan Poe possibly
YES. But, would she actually read Poe?!! He's SO dark & straight up scary. And, does Hans actually have anything remotely "spooky" looking?! LOL! I'm on the hunt / search... LOL!
Corpse bride
@@michellecrutchfield8701 little mermaids pretty dark contextually tbh, I'd give that a read.
Since becoming a mom, I don't really find the time to read like I used to... But thx. And yes, I can see the "dark" of the little mermaids. I wasn't thinking of the Little Mermaid...
@@michellecrutchfield8701 I can imagine being a mom is pretty time consuming, but hoping you can get time to yourself, even if it isn't reading lol.
I'm not super knowledgeable about Hans' other work but from I know he does have a few more morbid tales, but alot of them are just very sad.
She is confident that we won’t get it and we all know she isn’t a big fan of “ spooky “ stuff like Tim but wouldn’t that potentially “ throw us off” and be like oh no she doesn’t like spooky stuff so it isn’t anything Tim burton style but wouldn’t that be the perfect thing to guess because it’s the complete opposite... looking at the first one that looks so much like Sally’s colours and then the pea on top that could represent the pea soup and then this one where the moon is so is so prominent and you can clearly see that’s a cliff/ mountain edge that could potentially be the spiral that sally and jack stand on I’m guessing nightmare before Christmas 🙌🏻
Oooh smart! I never even considered anything Tim Burton related at all!
I agree. That's what I was thinking
That’s a super good theory!!!!
Or this one could be a corpse bride the the blue and yellow soap is Alice in wonderland?
I’m gonna say the series is Shakespeare inspired. This makes me think of MidSummer’s Night Dream, and honestly that would be right up Katie’s literature loving alley
I’m getting an “Into the Woods” musical theme
I need "Are you girls ready to ruin your aesthetic?!" as a gif
I need that entire monologue in a gif.
Not gonna lie, watched this part twice lol!
I enjoy watching your videos because your conversation is very relatable and fun, you and your brother's videos are enjoyable to watch because you are yourselves and have a good sense of humor and creativity. Some other soap RUclipsrs are boring to watch because they are too serious.
I agree with the people saying that she does not like spooky things and she doesn’t watch scary movies there’s some movies that we think are just cartoons were scary to her, so it probably isn’t Tim. She likes to get her designs pretty close to her theme So I don’t think it’s van Goghs starry night because there’s a lot of yellow in it and more blues than black. I want to say Disney fantasia like a couple of other people but she just the Disney princesses
Elpida Bika Kind of but she always matches her theme to her soap and starry night has a lot of yellow so I think she would’ve put yellow swirls if she was trying to do starry night
I’m loving how everybody has their own interpretation 💜
I really dont know why, but I think is classical music. I'm not sure about the first one but THIS IS MOONLIGHT SONATA BY BETHOVEN. I could just be really wrong but... at least I tried
That was my first thought, too. :)
I love that idea either way! 🥰
Such a beautiful idea!
Katie: and here is the second hint
RUclips: haha nope here is an ad
Smacked us right in the face with a commercial.
She was the one who put the add there
Everyone else: STOP THE ADDS
Me: INEVER GET ADDS DURING HER VIDEOS WHAT IS GOING OOOON??? I JUST WANT AN ADD :(
I thought the ad was the hint at first and I was sooo confused
Mine was a RUclips ad because I was able to skip the one right around when she was cutting was her ad because I wasn't able to skip. She only puts one ad in her videos which is why I won't skip the RUclips ad
The theme is famous artists, the forst was frida kahlo, this is starry night by Van Gogh
If this was starry night I'd feel like there'd be more gold/yellows like there are in the painting.
@@Nyanka1123 I agree! Starry night would have yellow circles for the stars and a mix of blues and yellows!
1:18 Katie talking about that cottagecore/witchtok aesthetic has got me vibin hard 😍😍😍 what a dream!
I'm still getting 'Over the Garden Wall', but I'm not sure how many other people watched that one.
you kidding? that's my favorite show of all time. Think it was pretty popular with our generation!
I love that show and I'm gen z it is so good.
Also I have the limited edition of the sound track on vinyl.
That was my guess as well back on the first video! But I've never seen the cartoon, so I in truth can't say if what I'm seeing really lines up with the show.
@@BewareTheLilyOfTheValley it truly does
If this is not the series... I want an over the garden wall bar anyways.
I agree with some that this is, Tim Burton’s “Nightmare before Christmas” First one is Sally’s dress and this one is jack’s hill and moon..
And she talked about music at the end! Here I was thinking Beethoven Sonata's, but your guess makes so much more sense.
You’re so sweet for giving away all this free information :). Even though I don’t plan on making soap for a good while, I find it so kind you don’t charge for every recipe.
I’m still feeling like it’s a Johnny Depp film theme. This one is screaming Sleepy Hollow at me. Love this soap so much!!!!
The scent: Lunar Eclipse from Natures Garden
The theme for this soap: Secret Window, Secret Garden by Stephen King.
My guess for the first soap was the Secret Garden Frances Hodgson Burnett. I think this is the secret collection. Ironic as it is the secret soaps of 2020.
I was thinking about Secret Garden for the first soap too, but the colors of the layers just seemed off for that particular theme
i think youre onto something!!! would love for that to be the theme!
She doesn't like spooky things AT ALL and Secret Window, Secret Garden is a rather gory and disturbing story. Its definitely not something she would like.
@@rayneb2595 I agree, however she did say that this was not her idea so she could be basing the soap design for some of these on the description of others. The Ghibli soap was the same. Kenny had seen castle in the sky but she hadn't.
Cool idea!
Dear duchess, you are the most authentic the way you present yourself. I really like your non artificial attitude. The instagram perfection is not real life and it may teach people that they aren’t acceptable they way they are or look. But imperfections are the real thing! Greetings from Munich, Germany.
The secret soap series is definitely based on Tim burton!! This one is the night before Christmas !!! Look at the moon and the texture that looks like the hills!
I thought the 1st one was very sally
Ooooo true true true
Definitely getting The Nightmare before Christmas vibes again. The last one screamed Sally.
I agree
I adore nightmare before Christmas and corpse bride so I’d love if that was the theme! However, I can’t figure out a connection to the tea party and the creepy house in the end screen?
Everyone is just focused on the soap and I’m over here like:
oOOooO mUsiC
I need to know what the 'hint music' is. That would be perfect background for working times.
I like her. And her laugh is contagious! I love that she teaches you....This is awesome! She is a real person. I love it!!
This soap turned out really pretty, I love how the full moon looks.
Okay, this isn’t a popular guess and it’s probably wrong, but…I think the theme could be Disneyland rides.
The first one was the teacups, this one is the haunted mansion…
I feel like if this one was haunted mansion there would be some purple for the wall paper or teal for the ghosts. I would love some Disney ride themed soap though!!
I think you are on to something....
I can see it definitely
I think this is it!
The color scheme for the 1st secret soap matches PERFECTLY with the picture of the ride from 1959 I saw on google just now and the top embeds matched with designs on the sides of the cups. And this one , soap #2, reminds me of the full moon shown behind the mansion in one of the photos I just looked up also. I know she googles reference pics for her soaps and they may be the same ones she used for inspo! I think you nailed it! Can't wait to see what #3 is!
DEFINITIVELY NIGHTMARE BEFORE CHRISTMAS! My favorite ANNND my wedding theme!
Seeing a lot of people saying Tim burton. But Katie frequently says she doesn't do spooky. She doesn't like dark themes much at all. So I'm leaning towards literature based, like fairy tales. Or artwork
That’s fair, but I’m her rapunzel vid she says something about unwholesome Disney movies getting their time under the spotlight in august of twenty twenty so I guess it’s possible
But didn’t she said she’s so confident this year that we won’t get it maybe she’s picked spooky because she knew it would throw some people off ?..
@@georgieleigh7941 lol. Maybe she is trying to throw us off. In all honesty, I hope its Tim burton. That would be so cool. I remember last year so many people wanted hocus pocus and she was like nope. Other channels have done it. Too spooky for me. Lol
I’m thinking this is either “fairy tale” or “witch of the woods” themed
That’s what I was thinking! The picture at the end gives me big Baba Yaga vibes
I was thinking similarly, strong cottagecore vibes
Im thinking Fairy Tale as well
I was thinking the same thing.
I love that you offer everything free. I haven’t made soap but I know that if I want to, I can pop over here and you’ll help me.
I’m getting major grimm’s fairy tales vibes but also... Neil gaiman??
Guys, remember, she is CONFIDENT we won't guess this one! So don't think of anything too popular, think of hidden gems or something forgotten about in modern day. I'm still sticking with Over the Garden Wall, though, as while it has a cult following, it's not so popular that everyone knows about it...and I in truth have never seen it myself either! But at the very least, the house shown here makes me think of the clips I've seen of the cartoon.
The house do give vibes of the show, but overall everything feels more faerie like than purgatory (as the show is). It actually fells like a dark fearie or something of the sorts
I think this is a good guess, however the embed of the moon should have been the iconic first quarter moon
She doesn't like scary things, and overt the garden wall is quite disturbing. She doesn't even like Nightmares Before Christmas and OTGW is a lot worse than that.
@@rayneb2595 The guesses at the end and her 3rd soap actually really match the show, which I finally watched on Hulu. I have a full comment on it on the video for soap #3 but yeah...I'm feeling more confident it could be Over the Garden Wall. She says she doesn't like scary things and that's EXACTLY why it could very well be that. She is absolutely confident we're not going to guess this, which means we need to subvert our normal expectations and think outside the box from the Katie we normally know.
This said, I can't piece the imagry for soap 1 and this one is...vague. There's a scene in the show where the siblings are sleeping under the stars and the little brother has a wild dream in the clouds. The night sky of that scene could've inspired this soap, but that feels like I'm reaching.
But that third soap...it fits so dang perfectly, it's scary. Plus the guesses of the tea setting, the house, and so far the cat all fit the show very well. That's why I'm not ready to give up on Over the Garden Wall being the theme.
this soap is so gorgeous. reminds me of starry night.
This makes me thinks of Shakespeare’s “A Midsummer Night’s Dream” is this inspired by that?😮
It's weird that I guessed that as the first soap and it could be this one as well :D
This is what i was thinking as well
I guessed twelfth night lol -- the soaps themselves totally look like they could be themed after Shakespeare plays, if it weren't for the hints at the end.
I guessed that too!
I was thinking either Shakespeare or maybe classic paintings.
I'm sticking with a halloween series. Just giving me tim burton vibes, hocus pocus vibes
I was thinking of Coraline
@@FiddleKat oh coraline, yes
That blue mica makes the top looks velvety and lovely.
I definitely still feel like this is ferngully, this soap reminds me of the dream worth keeping scene
I saw someone guess "Famous Artists" in the last video's comment section they said that one was Frida Kahlo and it does have the colors of her "Tea and Smoke" painting and then the tea set. I am going to say not just famous artists but "Famous Modern Artists" or "Famous Modern Female Artists" . This one could be Louis Dodd, it has the colors of "Moon with Halo and Clouds" and she does have a painting called "Night House With Lit Window" and that is just what it is too.
Katie making soap is definitely me baking and is soooooooo relatable
Okay... how about this: Disney's Haunted Mansion. There was a section of the ride that was dedicated to what could be called a "Moonlight Picnic." It wasn't terribly popular, but it is part of the history of the ride...
Disney rides passed thru my mind too.
I like this guess.
Ooh yes! We have the teacup ride and haunted mansion so far as the clues
And she has also been talking about missing Disneyland, too. Good guess!
I said this last time, I still think it’s A series of unfortunate events. This is the house at the end is Count Olaf’s. The first soap reminded me of the colors of the book bindings, not to mention the picture at the end reminds me of the pictures they used in the books themselves to allude to the themes of the book or the next book... etc.
minakorei omg I love a series of unfortunate events, but I'm not sure if it fits with the soaps. Also she doesn't strike me as a person who would read the series
Now this celestial soap is my favorite! Totally my aesthetic
I'm getting "Starry Night" vibes from this. I think a Van Gogh theme would be amazing, but given the hint, it appears like it might be Tim Burton like other people have said!
Instead of the "let's get ugly" tagline I'm thinking of the little tune that Evan & Katelyn sing "Science adjacent with Evan and Katelyn, yeah!"
Yes
What a collab that would be! I want it!!!!
ooh what about E and K’s resin time thing though
@@aspillust Katie's could be "safety time, safety time!"
God, I love your personality in these videos! So cheerful and enjoyable to watch!
I think the soaps are based off of Tim Burton directed films. This soap could be The Corpse Bride because of the moon on the movie cover.
The colors, the moon and the mansion as a hint in the end just reminds me sooooo much of Coraline! The tea is also part of the movie so my guess is that Coraline is the main theme :)
omg ya now that you say that, it does seem like it, maybe multiple tim burton movies? cause the first mystery soap looked like the colors of sally from nightmare before christmas
@@wolfpacklover4 Coraline is not a Tim Burton movie (they have a very similar style though!!) Katie's first tip was a set of tea and if you search on RUclips for "Coraline tea" you will see a scene from the movie that have two characters with a similar color palette from the first soap and accessories that reminds a lot the first soap imbeds + Coraline's yellow raincoat complete the first color palette :)
@@lamarquita7768 oh! My mistake I thought coraline was Tim Burton. Lol but it does make sence
@@wolfpacklover4 nightmare before Christmas isn't Tim burton either. Both movies were produced by Henry Selick which is why they look so similar. Also Katie has said before that she doesn't like spooky and that she'd never make anything inspired by such.
I love your personality beauty and skill. This combo makes you my favorite soap maker. I have watched other channels and they're good but i keep coming back because you're fun and passionate💜
Is this a soap dedicated to Princess Yue? An Avatar-themed soap series? Even the clues at the end; tea for Uncle Iroh, the creepy house representing Hama/"The Witch" of the Southern Watertribe
This was my guess in the first video and I'm definitely not ruling it out!
I'm getting that vibe as well
It feels like it could be ATLA themed, but maybe thats just me hoping desperately that it is. But the four layers in the first soap looked like they could represent the four nations! And the green soap gumball is the CABBAGES!
I love this guess because I've been binging atla!
I remember this book from when I was younger, one that was a children’s version of the Blue Book of Fairy Tales. It had the princess and the pea, among other stories that were more spooky. This just reminds me of that a bit
I haven't got a clue, and if it's literature I'm stumped...BUT that clue scene with the music, crickets and the artwork is so dreamy...I love it!
I’m thinking you are going for a “Hocus Pocus” theme. I’m getting a Sanderson Sisters vide :)
“here’s the second hint” *Ad starts* *ad is Dr.Evil yelling HOW ABOUT NO*
My ad was about moon jewelry. I was confused for a half a second
NO!
I read it in his voice! 🤣🤣🤣
Uh uh, no way!
definitely getting some old story/painting vibes from the collection so far.
“Let’s make some soap”
Me - spends 10 minutes cleaning up juice that I spit across the room.
The scent is from nature's garden and the soap theme is hans christian anderson
I usually just watch your videos for fun ! And to relax after a long day but Now I want this soap! Definitely getting it when the collection releases!
“Are you girls ready to ruin your aesthetic?”
said 2020.
Classical Literature for the theme, I think: I'm getting Midsummer Night's Dream vibes from this one...
Ooh I think you might be right! I’m getting Edgar Allan Poe vibes from this one
I feel like the theme is shakespeare so some reason. Think her first soap was henry v. And this might be midsummer nights dream.
SAME
My exact thought for this one too
gurllll. you don't need to be a glamour. WE ALL LOVE YOU FOR YOU!!
I've never been this early! So excited with these colors.
Same 🙃
Honestly i relate to you way more than i relate to the "perfect instagram soap" people lol
This has to be the nightmare before Christmas..... The moon. The original with the colors of Sally's dress. The paw prints of Zero.... The roses and the green peas for the soup... Everything makes sense now!!!!!
Me: doesn't need more soap
Also me: wants this bar so much
Going off my Harry Potter theory, at first I thought the Shrieking Shack which would explain why you did a full moon soap because Lupin would have to hide in the Shack every full moon when he transformed. But it looks more like the house from the beginning of Goblet of Fire where Wormtail hid with Voldemort before his return, which Wormtail was only able to do because he escaped during the full moon after Lupin transformed hence the full moon soap. So it’s a reach but I’m sticking with Harry Potter.
I was thinking the same thing. Harry Potter all the way.
Yep. Yep. Yep. Totally agree.
I was thinking Harry potter too on the first one, how did you explain the embeds?
And I don't really see some relevance with the teapot
THETowandAA the answer to that is “I’m working on it”! Lol
Crazy witch Umbridge. She drank tea.
I just wanted to say I LOVE the matte effect with the top of this one
It has got to be Hans Christian Anderson stories! The first one was probably The Princess And The Pea and this one is What The Moon Saw! The cane represents the moon...
I think that the fragrance oils are some kind of “sky/spring breeze” from Nature’s Garden
The secret soap theme is shakespearean plays. This one is midsummernights dream, the previous one is romeo and juliet
🙂you’re so cute in your safety gear because of your humor and humility 😄😂 love to see it
love your work!!!! why don't you do a series based on birds? like peacock bird of paradise and so on?
Part of the allure of birds is their shape.. I feel like a soap based on a bird would look too square. If it was based on bird feathers that might look cool though
@@AN-ou6qu yes yes! That is exactly what I meant! Sorry if it wasn't that clear 😊
When someone mentioned Goodnight Moon for this soap I thought maybe the first one could be A Bad Case of Stripes if the theme was picture books. The black frosting matches the main character's hair, the green gumball represents the lima beans she loves, the heart represents how she learned to love herself for who she is, and of course the stripes. Though I don't think either of those books go with the end of video clues.
I'm getting "goodnight moon" vibes so maybe children's bedtime sorties
I love the top on this one. Kind of looks like waves crashing together. Not sure what to guess but I’m excited to see what comes next!
I made some guesses on the last one. I'm still getting dark fairy tale vibes like Grimm Fairy Tales or Tim Burton movies. Or dark musicals , plays, ballets (no idea how to call that one theme, lol). Getting Into the Woods vibes from this one. But I also like other people's suggestions that the theme is Nightmare before Christmas and this is Jack's hill or Corpse Bride.
And a totally out the box suggestion if Johnny Depp characters in movies. (Soap 1: Mad Hatter in Alice in Wonderland; Soap 2: Sweeney Todd from Sweeney Todd or Ichabod Crane from Sleepy Hollow).
So fun to watch this unfold and try to guess.
The ideas I read and I liked:
-Disney world rides/attractions. -Hans C. Andersen historíes. -Tim Borton. -Famous painters
Ooh spacey! It's like a midnight sky!
I will admit, the last secret soap series I was taking notes, listening carefully but I didn't have a clue. This time around I'm taking notes and listening to EVERY WORD, inflection, flash of editing! I'm like, "Is that a clue? Is that a clue? Wait, is that a clue?" This is tons of fun, thank you! (From your royal court gobie1kenobie) think Obie won kenobie and you will say it right.
Me: Write that down! Write that down! It could be a hint!
Tell me your thoughts!
I’m still sticking to the bedtime story theme, maybe an enchanted woods. And this soap my guess will be; The Arabian Nights
Wow that soap looks like a full moon night 🌌 so pretty 😍
I wish it was Dr. Who themed, mostly with this soap, but I digress.
Now that I see this one I think the theme is the book “The Little Prince”. The rose on the first one and the night sky in this one.
Ohhhhh good guess
Thats a great guess I love that book
Oh yes thanks I'm guessing the same! I thought I was the only one thinking this. It was my first thought as soon as I saw the roses and stars... it just fits perfectly🌹
I guessed that too!
I had the same thought! I absolutely love that book!
I'm getting the Edgar Allen Poe feel from this batch.
I can almost heard the Raven whispering Nevermore...nevermore...
Love your creation by the way, you make everything fun. :)
Agatha Christi? I'm getting a lot of "classic mystery novel" vibes. I love how the moon turned out.
As for the fragrance oil, I'm guessing Nature's Garden, something like Dark Musk or Lunar Eclipse, maybe.
It's Agatha Christie, just so you know.
Excited to guess! By the way Katie pls say what type of color you’re using (this blue color or my green colorant is fine) because I’m colorblind and sometimes I just can’t tell if it’s a brown or a purple. Love your channel!
I am also colorblind so a lot of the colors look the same to me.
I’m not sure if she said in the video, but in case she didn’t - the large bucket was black, then she did gray, navy and royal blue in the smaller buckets 😊 And the top was dusted with blue, as well.