Artemiy, probably the reason why I think that you think that this mod isn't polished because I don't think it was because of the devolopers, I think it was because people was rushing the devolopers.
The real deal with incredibox is that all of the combination always makes banger sounds, it shouldn't have to be acapella, even the vanilla version give up on some of the version
I think Artemiy, though has valid points, and is his own opinion, is being a little nit-picky and compares it to his own mod a lot. And a lot of people are when it comes to this mod (and others of similar theme). To say it's "cliché" to have robots and scary things, although has some truth to it, doesn't mean a certain mod, or version "owns" that style. If that were the case, all mods would "copying" another version. This is less of an argument with Artemiy, as there are valid criticisms, however, it's more of an argument to people who dislike the mod just because "it's like Dystopia!!1!" However, my opinion is coming from a guy who thinks Brazil is pretty good, and doesn't think Alive is as good as everyone says it is.
i just dont get why so many mods try to tell a story through the bonuses instead of just making the bonuses actual bonuses. every incredibox version up until dystopia were actual tunes, and even then dystopia still had catchy numbers. every mod that takes the dystopia angle just plays a backing track with nothing else included. whats the point of using a bonus if it's hardly music?
I do like the mod but there's still a lot of problems, like effect 3's teeth, some notes and animations, there sprite tilting (which just makes them look like cardboard), etc. I just think it would be better of they took more time, maybe beta tested it, got feedback, and didn't set a release date 4 fucking times they would have been easily one of the top mods
While I do admittedly like a lot of the sounds, I have to agree with you that there are a lot of glaring problems with this mod, not that it’s bad but just that I think there is a lot I feel could have been done better or needed more time. Yes I am aware that people rushed coldbox and their team to make this but they also kept setting many release dates which I feel for passion projects like this or travis tend to do much more harm than good. Hell Fnaf security breach is much bigger example of something being rushed by its creators and its fans and given a scope that kept growing when it really shouldn’t have been. In terms of the sounds and aspects from the mod itself… I hate comparing things to cliches and saying stuff copies others, that being said, I agree there are elements that feel out of place. The steam and mask for beat 4 feel forced in since in the beta version of mechanic, he only had a visor that covered his eyes but a beat that felt way too quick to be realistically done in person. Here the beat is slowed down and more realistic but this change is pointless now that the mouth is covered and made from pistons and steam that feel shoehorned in. It would have been so much better to see lip syncing to it. Effect 3 while it has been kept through all 3 versions of this mod with changes throughout still feels out of place and I’m not sure why they kept it. I wanna say I have a controversial opinion that I absolutely love voices that have the traits of effects and vice versa (examples to me would include little miss’ effect 3 and voice 5, the love’s effect 2 voices 2 and 5 and Augury’s voice 5). I love voice 5 a lot despite it being more of an effect however it has issues that hold it back a lot. It is way too quite compared to a few melodies and voices and the clipping between each note make the voice not work on its own and feel too much like an effect when I feel it would be a great choir without them. Lastly, Melody 5’s animation feels lazy to me. I feel there could have been much more that could have been done comparing it to dystopia’s beat 2 (in the first demo of mechanic, the sound was a whistle which I imagined would have a sort of vibrating and blur effect but no). Having the head static like this feels boring which unfortunately is an issue that also bleeds over to bonfire even more so. Before I finish this probably needlessly long and overwritten comment, I want to say this. As someone who’s favourite versions and mods of incredibox are the more unorthodox and techy/sci-fi stuff like Alive, Dystopia, Augury and Travis, I am tired of a lot of mods being more focused on making scary or overly complex and grandeur mods (I know RB kind of fits into this category but he has more refined his own style and uses his own limitations and inspiration from incredibox to make his stuff stand out and makes some of my favourite mods. People should take inspiration from them on smaller parts of their own mods not for big things like polos and sounds). I know I am absolutely not cut out to try making a mod especially not a good one as if I did it would be my first time, but from looking at this and some other mods that I didn’t like I did learn one thing for if I ever do try it out. Sounds come first, designs after. Try to beatbox the sounds and see if they sound good out loud and able to be done in person before putting them in mods. You don’t have to entirely use organic sounds if it doesn’t sound good even after a thousand takes, as long as it can be done in person then you can try to make use if editing samples to recreate what you are trying to beatbox.
I think you will like bonfire more than mechanic,i mean i like mechanic(effect 4 carries for me)but bonfire sounds nice so im excited to see yoyr reaction abt it
I just realized how Artemiy pronounces “GIF”. It’s not “gif” or “jif”, it’s GIFT! Not sure if he said the wrong word or if that’s just what he calls it, but I find it a bit funny.😅
Bro of some these comments r actually mad stupid ngl ☠️, they complaining about your own opinion, some of the creators already know and don't really care. I remember one of them in the premiere and they didn't care they were mostly laughing and pretty chill, some of these comments gotta chill like on god.
Personally, I found this mod kinda…forgettable? I mean, I’m not trying to insult it and please don’t take this as an invitation to harass people. But the designs, while I know they are supposed to be distinctive, don’t really stick out to me and I forget them easily. Also same thing with the sounds. I usually like creepy/eerie/weird sounds, like the ones in Airline, Two Faces, and especially Evadare. But I can’t remember most of the music from here. If you like this mod, then I guess I can see the appeal but for me it just doesn’t click.
Effects, melodies were the only things that were good. Voices sounded off tune and weird and beats were eh. just average mod beats. Mechanic, id say it would be a 6/10. Melodies were a BOP. Absolutely good and smooth, though i think melody 1 needs a lil more work. Effect 3 or something the WIP one sounds like a melody. Beats though were better and the voices too were good. Just a little rushed. Bonfire, Is an 8.2/10
This mod has nothing to do with incredibox. The voices and effect 5 are the only polos that actually use human sounds for once, everything else is just effortless when it comes to sounds. If people wanna take inspiration from other creators, then how about the creators of incredibox themselves instead of RB and his repetitive community. And also, Dystopia's lore told through it's three bonuses was simplistic and easy to understand, making it more memorable. Both Evadare and Arbox do not follow that rule of simplicity in the bonuses and quite frankly I hate it. I'ma take a wild guess here and say that it's not gonna look any better with coldbox
For me the voices are ok but they don’t fit especially the chorus voices and effect 4 I think has too much also I despise the sound of beat 5 it’s tooo high pitched I liked the old one but my biggest problem is that the animation of the Melodie’s just aren’t great melody 3 is fine and melody 5 is okay, i Iike melody 4 but I wish it kept its more bouncy head from the old version. But mechanic is still good I love beat 3. Coldbox isn’t that great and suffers the issue of things having too much sounds in 1 guy
Another shitty Dystopia ripoff with way too over detailed designs, out of place inconsistencies between colors, tones, and beats that don’t sound well together. Sounds that are obnoxiously "scary" and other sounds that are way too minor to even be noticeable by themselves, and don’t forget bonuses that tell a cryptic, uninteresting story through an automatic walking simulator about a society overrun by technology. I’m tired with mods that follow these exact cliches. Maybe So Far So Good knows exactly what they are doing by returning to their beatbox roots. We need more simple mods that aren’t over the top, as much as I like mods like Armed. I just want to see more mods that are more simple and humble. Travis was a futuristic mod in many ways (aside from the tribal characters) but it was simple, it’s characters fulfilled a purpose, it didn’t hurt to look at. It was memorable and well made and shows that you don’t have to follow every single cliche to make a futuristic mod. *EDIT:* now before die-hards continue to call me an evil heartless man for not liking this mod I do admit I am being rather harsh, but I stand by my point. This mod took a long time to develop and it was made by passionate people, but by calling this mod a shitty ripoff (which it honestly probably is) I’m not attempting to harass the developers but call attention to the obnoxious amount of repetition found in most Incredibox mods.
and people think im a hater by just reviewing the mods, and saying ANYTHING negative about something. yeah, i also would like to see more simpler mods, that would focus more on sounds than overcoming the designs complexity.
Coldbox is a small mod and the head developer's first mod, so dont expect anything revolutionary with coldbox at least for now, and as for simple and humble mods, that should go to the fan-made unreleased album mods that are executed well and or perfectly and doesnt age like crap (Looking at you RB's two faces)
@@artemiykopych There is a difference between constructed criticism and being a dick. Every small developer mod you have reviewed so far, can be summarized you trashing them. Instead of giving valid feedback and providing some sense of positive reinforcement. You're just saying that is "bad" or "oh god this is not good." Having some negative opinions on people's work is completely okay. Not every single product is going to be perfect and of course people need to learn that. However, your criticism paints an overwhelming standard and expectation. People are labeling you as a hater because your attitude comes across as a "Travis Stan." Travis is successful because it was worked on by developers with remarkable talent. Not everyone is skilled like those people. Creative communities have a spectrum of talent. Some are good, some are bad, and some are amazing. I don't blame you for being disappointed because there are many gems in this modding community. However, there is a difference between being disappointed with cliche aspects or unpolished animation compared to being an asshole. If you're going to harp on the cliche qualities of smaller mods. Then you should absolutely shit on the originals and the "better" mods of this game. That's because they all mimic each other! These "cliche" things is what you call a formula. "If it ain't broke, don't fix it." These cliche things are so common in creative mediums because they WORK. I totally understand getting frustrated with the same concept but painted different colors. None of that is going to change though unless someone produces a new original idea. But that's not my problem with you though. My problem with you is that your videos are so absurdly harsh on these small creators. You start every video with "oh no, this doesn't look good already." Never giving these creators even a chance to show off their product. Yes, of course some of them are really bad but that doesn't mean you shouldn't give them at least the respect they deserve on the screen. If these mods are so bad according to your standards, why even bother going through the efforts to publish a video about them? You should review these first before showcasing them on your channel. It's extremely unfair to practically bully these people who put their time and possibly their own money to share a product that they are proud of and were just too excited to wait. Maybe try to be more merciful with your comments and your supposed feedback. "It wasn't worth waiting for Mechanic" that is such an insincere comment. Especially following up after " I checked the game files and it was bad!" Come on dude...Kindness is a choice and your behavior reflects your awful attitude towards small developers who do this as a hobby.
![Noob To Max With DRAGON REWORK In Blox Fruits [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LnBMOinoOvA/mqdefault.jpg)
Artemiy, probably the reason why I think that you think that this mod isn't polished because I don't think it was because of the devolopers, I think it was because people was rushing the devolopers.
There is such thing called "don't listen to these people, and take your time on polishing the mod"
@@artemiykopych yeah but they unfortunately they are getting weaker to the audience
@@artemiykopych sadly the more you do that, the louder people scream
@Ringadingding without
Okay so that means the fans are the ones to be blamed for most bad games, like FNAF SB.
I think that what makes an Incredibox mod good is the fact that you could make all sounds with your mouth.
@@bigboi757 ahem evadare
@@bigboi757 tomfoolery is here tho
The real deal with incredibox is that all of the combination always makes banger sounds, it shouldn't have to be acapella, even the vanilla version give up on some of the version
@@saltysalt844 um, no they don't? The only sound that doesn't use acapella is the 8-bit polo, the others use voice effects at most
try effect 2 and fail miserably
the mods are a very unique take on incredibox. I hope to see the reaction soon
I think Artemiy, though has valid points, and is his own opinion, is being a little nit-picky and compares it to his own mod a lot. And a lot of people are when it comes to this mod (and others of similar theme). To say it's "cliché" to have robots and scary things, although has some truth to it, doesn't mean a certain mod, or version "owns" that style. If that were the case, all mods would "copying" another version. This is less of an argument with Artemiy, as there are valid criticisms, however, it's more of an argument to people who dislike the mod just because "it's like Dystopia!!1!" However, my opinion is coming from a guy who thinks Brazil is pretty good, and doesn't think Alive is as good as everyone says it is.
I was mostly comparing it as a joke, so dont take it seriously xd.
@Artemiy Kopych Oh, sorry then. I have the joke literacy of a squirrel, so I tend to miss a thing or two.
brazil is underrated asf
I JUST REALIZED THAT EFFECT 3 USES THE OLD EFFECT 3 (specifically the demo effect 3)
yes, I just now realize that.
i just dont get why so many mods try to tell a story through the bonuses instead of just making the bonuses actual bonuses. every incredibox version up until dystopia were actual tunes, and even then dystopia still had catchy numbers. every mod that takes the dystopia angle just plays a backing track with nothing else included. whats the point of using a bonus if it's hardly music?
Y’all remember when the bonuses were just corny music videos? (Little Miss, The Love, whatever v6 is called)
@@AceTechn0 Alive
I want to be the first person to make corny bonus music instead of telling stories. C:
@@AceTechn0theyre not corny lmao its the mods that are corny
@@deIuxe corny in a lovable sort of way
"This note is fine and then he goes AOUAOAAHAUOAOAAAH"
8:50 :
Artemy :melodies!
Me saws the first one: XBOX!
“NO WAY, IS THIS THE GUY FROM DYSTOPIA?”
Beat 2, the slightly Tuctom-looking beat:
Ngl I kinda love the mod to be honest.
artemiy:"ok this guy just beatboxes"
the incrediman:*litterally is just a box*
I like how incredimen said it's music time
Effect 4 Is Just Monk and Souffle Combined Into One Polo
7:00 bro the "creepy" guy has been in here since the demo, put out way before armed.
15:50 artemiy makes the noise
I do like the mod but there's still a lot of problems, like effect 3's teeth, some notes and animations, there sprite tilting (which just makes them look like cardboard), etc.
I just think it would be better of they took more time, maybe beta tested it, got feedback, and didn't set a release date 4 fucking times they would have been easily one of the top mods
While I do admittedly like a lot of the sounds, I have to agree with you that there are a lot of glaring problems with this mod, not that it’s bad but just that I think there is a lot I feel could have been done better or needed more time.
Yes I am aware that people rushed coldbox and their team to make this but they also kept setting many release dates which I feel for passion projects like this or travis tend to do much more harm than good. Hell Fnaf security breach is much bigger example of something being rushed by its creators and its fans and given a scope that kept growing when it really shouldn’t have been.
In terms of the sounds and aspects from the mod itself… I hate comparing things to cliches and saying stuff copies others, that being said, I agree there are elements that feel out of place.
The steam and mask for beat 4 feel forced in since in the beta version of mechanic, he only had a visor that covered his eyes but a beat that felt way too quick to be realistically done in person. Here the beat is slowed down and more realistic but this change is pointless now that the mouth is covered and made from pistons and steam that feel shoehorned in. It would have been so much better to see lip syncing to it.
Effect 3 while it has been kept through all 3 versions of this mod with changes throughout still feels out of place and I’m not sure why they kept it.
I wanna say I have a controversial opinion that I absolutely love voices that have the traits of effects and vice versa (examples to me would include little miss’ effect 3 and voice 5, the love’s effect 2 voices 2 and 5 and Augury’s voice 5). I love voice 5 a lot despite it being more of an effect however it has issues that hold it back a lot. It is way too quite compared to a few melodies and voices and the clipping between each note make the voice not work on its own and feel too much like an effect when I feel it would be a great choir without them.
Lastly, Melody 5’s animation feels lazy to me. I feel there could have been much more that could have been done comparing it to dystopia’s beat 2 (in the first demo of mechanic, the sound was a whistle which I imagined would have a sort of vibrating and blur effect but no). Having the head static like this feels boring which unfortunately is an issue that also bleeds over to bonfire even more so.
Before I finish this probably needlessly long and overwritten comment, I want to say this. As someone who’s favourite versions and mods of incredibox are the more unorthodox and techy/sci-fi stuff like Alive, Dystopia, Augury and Travis, I am tired of a lot of mods being more focused on making scary or overly complex and grandeur mods (I know RB kind of fits into this category but he has more refined his own style and uses his own limitations and inspiration from incredibox to make his stuff stand out and makes some of my favourite mods. People should take inspiration from them on smaller parts of their own mods not for big things like polos and sounds).
I know I am absolutely not cut out to try making a mod especially not a good one as if I did it would be my first time, but from looking at this and some other mods that I didn’t like I did learn one thing for if I ever do try it out. Sounds come first, designs after. Try to beatbox the sounds and see if they sound good out loud and able to be done in person before putting them in mods. You don’t have to entirely use organic sounds if it doesn’t sound good even after a thousand takes, as long as it can be done in person then you can try to make use if editing samples to recreate what you are trying to beatbox.
i want a jazz incredibox
This is going to be amazing!
p.s. the last voice does a little “hou” sound at the start of his loop
I actually did expect voice 5 to have lyrics.
I feel like ColdBox is my favorite mod creator
In the demo, Melody 4 reminded me of gravity falls, now it doesn’t because it changed…
You need to listen to bonfire it sounds so tasty
When are you going to do a breakdown of armed ?
After the Coldbox stuff
when i download it it doesnt show the mechanic one it only shows travis
Because you go into incorrect link. There is other one, which leads to the developers video
@@artemiykopych oh
I think you will like bonfire more than mechanic,i mean i like mechanic(effect 4 carries for me)but bonfire sounds nice so im excited to see yoyr reaction abt it
17:31 No way is riviera
melody one's mask looks like the style of the aphex twin logo
I can agree though we never mention that we rushed it since cs said he would release it a few days ago and even missed it so I hope it makes sense
Эхх а я помню когда только вышла первая версия и еще тогда coldseamer сказал что надо все по новой
Are you also gonna check out bonfire???
Later
Hey Artemiy, how do I pronounce your last name? Is it kopych or Korych? (Russian speaker)
I have a special video about how to pronounce it lol
I just realized how Artemiy pronounces “GIF”. It’s not “gif” or “jif”, it’s GIFT! Not sure if he said the wrong word or if that’s just what he calls it, but I find it a bit funny.😅
How to get
Me waiting for shpongle
bro 🥶
@@hahasalu2791 what?
15:49 HUUUUUUAAUHHHHHHHH
26:00 𝓱𝓾𝓪𝓱𝓾𝓾𝓾𝓱
Bro of some these comments r actually mad stupid ngl ☠️, they complaining about your own opinion, some of the creators already know and don't really care. I remember one of them in the premiere and they didn't care they were mostly laughing and pretty chill, some of these comments gotta chill like on god.
I'm gonna stop doing that.
I think the melodies are so good, but voices are kinda bruh. I didn't feel the "mechanic" sounds, the mode is unfinished in my opinion
Mechanic voices are as good as splaatbox melodies
💀
o maximo que vi foi tipo 2 br... mais voce so pode estar usando um nome portugues... ou nao
Я думаю что у мода могло было быть каплю больше оригинальности, например, немного изменить как звучит 1 бит, 1 голос слишком банален, а так мод 7/10
I honestly like the Travis mod
This mod is not bad
Just needs a little tiny bit more improvement no offense to the creators
Also, the 4th effect has PlayStation eyes if you noticed
Gordon Ramsay vibe
Personally, I found this mod kinda…forgettable?
I mean, I’m not trying to insult it and please don’t take this as an invitation to harass people.
But the designs, while I know they are supposed to be distinctive, don’t really stick out to me and I forget them easily.
Also same thing with the sounds. I usually like creepy/eerie/weird sounds, like the ones in Airline, Two Faces, and especially Evadare. But I can’t remember most of the music from here.
If you like this mod, then I guess I can see the appeal but for me it just doesn’t click.
Effects, melodies were the only things that were good. Voices sounded off tune and weird and beats were eh. just average mod beats. Mechanic, id say it would be a 6/10.
Melodies were a BOP. Absolutely good and smooth, though i think melody 1 needs a lil more work. Effect 3 or something the WIP one sounds like a melody. Beats though were better and the voices too were good. Just a little rushed.
Bonfire, Is an 8.2/10
Melody 4 is the guy from invasion
My 5th melody doesn't do that.
It got a little update bro, changing some sounds
This mod has nothing to do with incredibox. The voices and effect 5 are the only polos that actually use human sounds for once, everything else is just effortless when it comes to sounds. If people wanna take inspiration from other creators, then how about the creators of incredibox themselves instead of RB and his repetitive community. And also, Dystopia's lore told through it's three bonuses was simplistic and easy to understand, making it more memorable. Both Evadare and Arbox do not follow that rule of simplicity in the bonuses and quite frankly I hate it. I'ma take a wild guess here and say that it's not gonna look any better with coldbox
The voices on mechanic are trash, ngl
For me the voices are ok but they don’t fit especially the chorus voices and effect 4 I think has too much also I despise the sound of beat 5 it’s tooo high pitched I liked the old one but my biggest problem is that the animation of the Melodie’s just aren’t great melody 3 is fine and melody 5 is okay, i
Iike melody 4 but I wish it kept its more bouncy head from the old version. But mechanic is still good I love beat 3. Coldbox isn’t that great and suffers the issue of things having too much sounds in 1 guy
я его протестил уже когда он только что вышел
I like mechanic
Cool
Another shitty Dystopia ripoff with way too over detailed designs, out of place inconsistencies between colors, tones, and beats that don’t sound well together. Sounds that are obnoxiously "scary" and other sounds that are way too minor to even be noticeable by themselves, and don’t forget bonuses that tell a cryptic, uninteresting story through an automatic walking simulator about a society overrun by technology.
I’m tired with mods that follow these exact cliches. Maybe So Far So Good knows exactly what they are doing by returning to their beatbox roots. We need more simple mods that aren’t over the top, as much as I like mods like Armed. I just want to see more mods that are more simple and humble.
Travis was a futuristic mod in many ways (aside from the tribal characters) but it was simple, it’s characters fulfilled a purpose, it didn’t hurt to look at. It was memorable and well made and shows that you don’t have to follow every single cliche to make a futuristic mod.
*EDIT:* now before die-hards continue to call me an evil heartless man for not liking this mod I do admit I am being rather harsh, but I stand by my point. This mod took a long time to develop and it was made by passionate people, but by calling this mod a shitty ripoff (which it honestly probably is) I’m not attempting to harass the developers but call attention to the obnoxious amount of repetition found in most Incredibox mods.
and people think im a hater by just reviewing the mods, and saying ANYTHING negative about something.
yeah, i also would like to see more simpler mods, that would focus more on sounds than overcoming the designs complexity.
See i feel bad for artemiy hes targeted for criticizing and its not a bad thing and i just dont get it
Coldbox is a small mod and the head developer's first mod, so dont expect anything revolutionary with coldbox at least for now, and as for simple and humble mods, that should go to the fan-made unreleased album mods that are executed well and or perfectly and doesnt age like crap (Looking at you RB's two faces)
@@Apollothepolo yeah fr
@@artemiykopych There is a difference between constructed criticism and being a dick. Every small developer mod you have reviewed so far, can be summarized you trashing them. Instead of giving valid feedback and providing some sense of positive reinforcement. You're just saying that is "bad" or "oh god this is not good." Having some negative opinions on people's work is completely okay. Not every single product is going to be perfect and of course people need to learn that. However, your criticism paints an overwhelming standard and expectation. People are labeling you as a hater because your attitude comes across as a "Travis Stan." Travis is successful because it was worked on by developers with remarkable talent. Not everyone is skilled like those people. Creative communities have a spectrum of talent. Some are good, some are bad, and some are amazing. I don't blame you for being disappointed because there are many gems in this modding community. However, there is a difference between being disappointed with cliche aspects or unpolished animation compared to being an asshole. If you're going to harp on the cliche qualities of smaller mods. Then you should absolutely shit on the originals and the "better" mods of this game. That's because they all mimic each other! These "cliche" things is what you call a formula. "If it ain't broke, don't fix it." These cliche things are so common in creative mediums because they WORK. I totally understand getting frustrated with the same concept but painted different colors. None of that is going to change though unless someone produces a new original idea. But that's not my problem with you though. My problem with you is that your videos are so absurdly harsh on these small creators. You start every video with "oh no, this doesn't look good already." Never giving these creators even a chance to show off their product. Yes, of course some of them are really bad but that doesn't mean you shouldn't give them at least the respect they deserve on the screen. If these mods are so bad according to your standards, why even bother going through the efforts to publish a video about them? You should review these first before showcasing them on your channel. It's extremely unfair to practically bully these people who put their time and possibly their own money to share a product that they are proud of and were just too excited to wait. Maybe try to be more merciful with your comments and your supposed feedback. "It wasn't worth waiting for Mechanic" that is such an insincere comment. Especially following up after " I checked the game files and it was bad!" Come on dude...Kindness is a choice and your behavior reflects your awful attitude towards small developers who do this as a hobby.
See I was feeling the beats but then the voices were all just… _bad_
Feifvdndhs
do you use bluestacks to play?