Stone Wall or Native Stone Row: Top 5 Ways to Tell the Difference. Episode 38

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 57

  • @Paunguliaq
    @Paunguliaq 7 дней назад +6

    Hi Stephen, This clarification is excellent and timely. I find all of your videos and educational walks so helpful and informative. Before I met you, I never recognized the stone walls I run across in the woods as Native American, even though I knew they were out there and thought I was looking for them. Now, I cannot unsee the Stone Rows as anything but Native structures and cannot believe how common, widespread, and important these monuments are.
    Your work is so valuable and comprehendible. Thank you.

    • @Stones_and_Stories
      @Stones_and_Stories  7 дней назад +1

      I’ve got one coming up that will really swizzle one’s mind. The row has no clear native features, runs along a road and property lines, and would clearly be viewed as a property marker, but…

    • @gaspipe7548
      @gaspipe7548 2 дня назад

      They aren’t this is complete garbage. All these walls can easily be attributable to colonial settlement

  • @liddybird3608
    @liddybird3608 3 дня назад +3

    I loved this. I wasn't aware that Native Americans made these. Fascinating.

  • @margomoore4527
    @margomoore4527 3 дня назад +2

    So cool! I have wondered-now I know! Thank you!

    • @Stones_and_Stories
      @Stones_and_Stories  2 дня назад +1

      Happy to help!

    • @gaspipe7548
      @gaspipe7548 2 дня назад

      This guy is complete BS. Iam sure he’ll get a you channel on Bigfoot and the Loch Ness monster soon enough. Dont believe a word of this nonsense.

  • @Stillwater933
    @Stillwater933 7 дней назад +2

    Great video. Thank you for these 5 techniques.

  • @SERFINUSA
    @SERFINUSA 3 дня назад +1

    Thanks for the excellent vid! I've been fascinated by stone structures ever since I read about them in Mysteries Of New England, decades ago. To the best of my recollection, when the natives were asked about the walls, they said they'd always been there.
    When I wander the woods along the Colebrook reservoir at the MA/CT line, you can find newly formed walls that run along the waterway. these walls are formed when the res is high in winter and the ice flow literally bulldozes them into being.
    Any conversation about the origin of stone walls should include the effects of ice and glaciers.

    • @Stones_and_Stories
      @Stones_and_Stories  2 дня назад

      @@SERFINUSA all of these structures post date the glaciers. The glaciers came through this area and would have ground out anything that was here. That being said, it also gives us some proof that structures were not made by glaciers, as they often rest in some level of the soil, and there was no soil left by the glaciers, just sand, rock and a dense clay like material.

  • @terryatpi
    @terryatpi 3 дня назад +2

    Subscribed. Cool stuff. Thanks

    • @Stones_and_Stories
      @Stones_and_Stories  3 дня назад +1

      @@terryatpi thank you. Hopefully you can find more interesting material on the channel. Looking forward to hearing about it.

  • @blakebufford6239
    @blakebufford6239 3 дня назад +1

    There are many stone walls in the East Bay area of California. (Contra Costa County). Most can probably be explained (and have been explained) as simply property boundaries, cattle barriers etc. However I have encountered them on steep ridge backs only a few yards long and running perpendicular to the ridge line and over boulders as you explain here. One just ended on the edge of a steep slope stacked on top of a sandstone outcropping. Some sre only a foot high. Very intriguing.

    • @Stones_and_Stories
      @Stones_and_Stories  3 дня назад +2

      @@blakebufford6239 native traditions occasionally span wide areas, and sometimes are very localized. Don’t can vary. That being said, I am of the mind that here in New England, a fair amount of boundary walls were “adopted” as they were already there and it’s a lot easier to use them than move a few tons of rock yourself. I will have a video out shortly that shows a wall that most would think was a boundary wall, but….

  • @koof1776
    @koof1776 5 дней назад +2

    Good stuff~

  • @WilliamJamesGilbertIIakaJamie
    @WilliamJamesGilbertIIakaJamie 7 дней назад +2

    Nice video ... I myself live on a site & also have stone rows they left behind ... Keep your eye out for rocks similar in size and of same type of stone and you will find totems to put back together...

  • @leonardcontarino7940
    @leonardcontarino7940 4 дня назад +1

    very interesting, thanks

  • @petevenuti7355
    @petevenuti7355 6 дней назад +1

    I was waiting for this video!

    • @Stones_and_Stories
      @Stones_and_Stories  6 дней назад +1

      Hopefully I didn’t keep you waiting too long. Anything else in this genre on your mind I could cover?

    • @petevenuti7355
      @petevenuti7355 6 дней назад +1

      @Stones_and_Stories I'm staying subscribed, I'm sure I'll find answers to questions I didn't think to ask.

  • @lor3999
    @lor3999 2 дня назад

    Love the algorithm ❤ Jack Benny & then Native American details , all with morning coffee. 👍🏼 Glad to subscribe.

  • @Bizarreparade
    @Bizarreparade 21 час назад

    Good job bud!

  • @robbcairl3728
    @robbcairl3728 3 дня назад +1

    I came across an obvious serpent effigy a few years ago next to a swamp. 30-40’ long with a beautiful serpent head stone (4x3x2’) at one end of the winding row of stones. I couldn’t generate much interest though, it’s an hour long hike or a 45 minute bushwhack from the other direction. My question is, how rare are these things? Especially one so well preserved with such a perfectly diamond/serpent head shaped stone at one end.

    • @Stones_and_Stories
      @Stones_and_Stories  3 дня назад +1

      @@robbcairl3728 that’s an interesting question. I think in the Algonquian lands they seemed to be somewhat common, although that is difficult to tell, as most of the land has been developed. My guess is that they were used quite often for ritual purpose, such as a winter solstice event. I came across one in Wampatuck state forest (Hingham, ma) mountain biking there one day, so either I have some tremendous luck finding them, or they are more common than expected.

    • @robbcairl3728
      @robbcairl3728 3 дня назад +1

      @@Stones_and_Stories thanks for your reply. I showed this serpent effigy to a friend who regularly hikes with Native American historians and she was impressed but hasn’t convinced her friends to visit the site. There is orange/red flagging near it and my friend said that’s the color a local Native American uses for his discoveries so it has obviously been recognized by experts.
      I very much liked this video and subscribed, looking forward to watching more.

  • @kathleenseb8950
    @kathleenseb8950 4 дня назад

    Love this (fancy graphics fun). Thank you!!!

    • @Stones_and_Stories
      @Stones_and_Stories  3 дня назад

      @@kathleenseb8950 the graphic part was kind of fun to put together!

  • @EdTheFed77
    @EdTheFed77 2 дня назад

    Interesting. Ancient stone walls are everywhere here in Massachusetts. I was only aware of two types, namely pasture walls and field walls, made by early settlers. But I thought #5 was kind of speculative. Not sure about that one.

  • @robadair
    @robadair 22 часа назад

    How do you confirm these? Is this just speculation?

    • @Stones_and_Stories
      @Stones_and_Stories  19 часов назад

      While this video makes assertions (for brevity) my other long form videos rely on and cite published research. For other videos that cite external research, see ruclips.net/video/SIL5DC7wwfI/видео.htmlsi=ytoI9vGQ3BZcQprk
      ruclips.net/video/3_HQMHc1Fec/видео.htmlsi=GnTingu7tMJrdfAB
      And
      ruclips.net/video/bLddDLQVQTg/видео.htmlsi=p-MIZBVj_1jvpQK2

  • @bobrinck1
    @bobrinck1 4 дня назад

    What is your background in archaeology?

    • @ecamp6360
      @ecamp6360 День назад

      Who cares? Only rank credentialists with their heads up their silos.

  • @hollyh64
    @hollyh64 3 дня назад +1

    We have ancient walls on our property. Some are colonialist built, some we don’t know why there are there. One lonely huge boulder in the woods has about 10 larger rocks (where they were carried there) on top of it. I keep thinking it’s native. We have found native tools (skinning tool and axe head) in our yard and near some rock walls. Would really love to know what that lonely rock - with rocks on top, meant.

    • @hollyh64
      @hollyh64 3 дня назад +2

      I should have also said that our home was built in 1757.

    • @Stones_and_Stories
      @Stones_and_Stories  2 дня назад +1

      Ok, let’s dig into that a bit. I’ll post some info in the community section over the next day or so. Want to do a bit more research, but what you likely have is what Mary and James Gage refer to as an “On stone cairn” or a cairn that has a base boulder. That comes from their expanded first edition “A Handbook of Stone Structures in Northeastern United States.” More to come.

    • @Stones_and_Stories
      @Stones_and_Stories  2 дня назад

      This is a link to a general write up on cairns. It states that the meaning of only a few types of structures have been passed down or are understood. But there is a section on cairns on base stones with some examples of just a few stones comprising the cairn. www.stonestructures.org/html/cairns.html

  • @dirtwizard5647
    @dirtwizard5647 4 дня назад +4

    You find a rattlesnake or Copperhead it's yours 😂

    • @Stones_and_Stories
      @Stones_and_Stories  2 дня назад +2

      We do have an occasional rattlesnake in New England. But I’ve never seen out outside of Texas or New Mexico.

    • @dirtwizard5647
      @dirtwizard5647 2 дня назад +2

      @Stones_and_Stories I live in the Blue ridge mountains, Timber rattlers and copperheads are everywhere. Copperheads tend to favor damp areas, but both love cover. You will only see the movement. P. S never had a rattle snake rattle at me. All of them were deadly still. My record is about 6 foot long and 15 rattles about the size of your upper arm ✌️❤️😂

    • @lor3999
      @lor3999 2 дня назад +1

      @@Stones_and_Stories , WE DO ?! In New England ? 👀👢👢

    • @Stones_and_Stories
      @Stones_and_Stories  2 дня назад +2

      @ not very many. But a few.

  • @johnmcelroy2120
    @johnmcelroy2120 4 дня назад +1

    Do think arrowheads are there to

    • @Stones_and_Stories
      @Stones_and_Stories  4 дня назад +2

      @@johnmcelroy2120 I have seen very few. But other stone tools are more prevalent.

  • @thunderboomer8726
    @thunderboomer8726 3 дня назад +1

    Robert Thorson, considered the expert on New England’s stone walls, refuses to acknowledge that these Native American structures exist! It’s only recently that some archaeologists are considering it. This despite the fact that several early colonists wrote about existing walls and wondered about them! So I’m curious as to how you came to be a believer. Have you ever checked out the Trail Through Time in Acton, MA? That town has consulted with Native Americans, and the ceremonial stone piles and rows are clearly marked and explained.

    • @Stones_and_Stories
      @Stones_and_Stories  3 дня назад +1

      @@thunderboomer8726 I have not been up to action, but will make the trip at some point. It’s a well studied area. I too grew up in New England and thought all walls we settler made. It’s been my time in this single forest that made me dig into the stone structures that were left my ancient natives. I’ve been here for 15 years now and started researching and documenting years ago. I’m amazed at how much is here, but how little people know about it, and how few care. The more I explore I learn, and then consume a great deal of documented research to ground my observations.

    • @gaspipe7548
      @gaspipe7548 2 дня назад

      The guy is correct this nothing but fiction.

  • @EdTheFed77
    @EdTheFed77 2 дня назад

    Interesting. Ancient stone walls are everywhere here in Massachusetts. I was only aware of two types, namely pasture walls and field walls, made by early settlers. But I thought #5 was kind of speculative. Not sure about that one.

    • @Stones_and_Stories
      @Stones_and_Stories  2 дня назад

      I have a few other episodes on snake effigies. ruclips.net/video/3_HQMHc1Fec/видео.htmlsi=AVjFS1F7GIoTU9K_

    • @Stones_and_Stories
      @Stones_and_Stories  2 дня назад

      Here is another. There are at least 5 in this forest alone. Short walls that serve no practical purpose, all very close to bodies of water. The serpent was an important spirit animal in this area. ruclips.net/video/zGFyqUc8jeU/видео.htmlsi=Epimi5Sm7gr_V-I_