Liz's lines gives goosebumps. She is literally is the main vocalist I want. Never brag her highnotes all the time. A humble singer. Love her. I never regret choosing her as my bias.
actually all members carry but they take diff part, i think yujin and liz sing in high tone especially at high part and the other members harmonize with deep/low voice.i could hear leeseo and wonyoung at the back too. they really improve a lot
The first verse is actually harder than the chorus to sing cause it's such in a low whispery register. Thus Leeseo and Wonyoung being able to sing better in other lines than their first lines.
Omg these girls are so talented! I especially adore Liz's (our main vocalist ofc :)) ,Yujin's (another great vocalist) and Leeseo's vocals. Like she's only 16 years old and has this beautiful voice. I hope they'll let Wonyoung sing live too, she also has an amazing voice, I hope that she'll be satistied and will be able to sing more during live performances. I accept it bc no one's perfect, right?
@@barunetta241 Kpop profile is not always correct. The only thing that is confirmed about IVE, is that Yujin is the leader. They don’t have fixed positions like NMIXX, but it is obvious who the main vocalist is. Which should be Liz since she has the best technique out of everyone. I mean she can literally sing AESPA songs, so it’s obvious that she’s the main vocalist.
@@MochieeeMoon exactly. She totally sang here. Her lines are in the low register so obviously she sounds quiet. She cannot shout or be loud and be low at the same time!
Keren bangettt!!! Makin stabil guys 😭👍🏻 Boleh ngga sih berharap ini SOTY 😭 harus SOTY sihh ini. Bahkan albumnya juga berharap bisa AOTY. Lagu²nya bagus lhooo 😭
they are ALL glowing, i think this comeback is really going to change how ive is viewed by the general public, they worked really hard and starship finally gave their talent justice instead of feeding their popularity out of hate. i'm very happy for them :) and they genuinely seem confident and more at ease, i think big things are coming ahead for them
It's rare that an idol gives the high notes their all when they know that the backing vocals will cover them. I'm incredibly impressed by Liz and her professionalism, as well as Yujin, although I think Liz is more consistent. Amazing for such young artists. I think Leeseo is definitely improving and has done a great job covering Rei as well.
@@sisirinsara4061 actually if you see the mnet stage's lyrics (on bottom left), can be seen who lead the chorus on live stages. 1st chorus : wonyoung, yujin 2nd chorus : yujin, leeseo 3rd chorus : yujin, wonyoung That's why at last half part of 3rd chorus on mnet stage you can hear wony's vocal slightly
she always has so many lines lol, just in kitsch, love dive and after like but in eleven, not your girl, blue blood, cherish, royal and other song she has so much lines.
Liz and Yujin slayed with their vocals ❤ Wonyoung, Leeseo and Gaeul was also good but I think this song do not showcase their vocals since its more on high parts. I'm sure that all Ive members are good singers. Please stop spreading hate ❤
y'all can hate them all you want but you can't deny that they can sing and they've improved and keep getting better, especially leeseo who's still practically a child.
I know that they can sing well but why the agency doesn't allow them to sing live more back then? Or is it just how they branding this girl group so they can get more attention? They're wonderful and good at sing tho
Liz Yujin very good🎉 Gaeul Leeseo good🎉 Wonyoung very very bad, really need to re-evaluate your attitude to the profession, practice more rigorously with yourself 👎👎👎👎
![[MR Removed] STRAY KIDS - LALALALA (KBS2 Music Bank) MR제거 20231110 (Live Vocals)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qcSODIKz_Yo/mqdefault.jpg)
![[MR Removed] STRAY KIDS - LALALALA (KBS2 Music Bank) MR제거 20231110 (Live Vocals)](/img/tr.png)
![[CLEAN MR Removed] IVE(아이브) - HEYA (해야) | Mnet Mcountdown 240502 MR제거](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/6MJ9WUy0dS4/mqdefault.jpg)
![[4K] IVE - “I AM” Band LIVE Concert [it's Live] K-POP live music show](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ak490-PtOuU/mqdefault.jpg)
Liz's lines gives goosebumps. She is literally is the main vocalist I want. Never brag her highnotes all the time. A humble singer. Love her. I never regret choosing her as my bias.
YES. THIS. Her voice brings me so much happiness ❤
YES! THINK SO >_
Yujin and Liz high note wow im so proud of you! Thumbs up!
Yujin and Liz carry the chorus
I can hear wonyoung too
actually all members carry but they take diff part, i think yujin and liz sing in high tone especially at high part and the other members harmonize with deep/low voice.i could hear leeseo and wonyoung at the back too. they really improve a lot
Liz slaying the notes in every lines gave me goosebumps
Actually I think that wonyoung is good and stable in this performance. Fighting wy❤
The first verse is actually harder than the chorus to sing cause it's such in a low whispery register. Thus Leeseo and Wonyoung being able to sing better in other lines than their first lines.
The thing people don’t understand that the low parts are way harder to sing while dancing instead of high notes
Agree
LIZ doesn't skip any lines 🤧🔥
True artist
@@djdb1214 all of them was true artist
Wonyoung sounds much better compared to their last stage!
Leeseo's voice is the sweetest❤
She's still a kid yeah
Omg these girls are so talented! I especially adore Liz's (our main vocalist ofc :)) ,Yujin's (another great vocalist) and Leeseo's vocals. Like she's only 16 years old and has this beautiful voice. I hope they'll let Wonyoung sing live too, she also has an amazing voice, I hope that she'll be satistied and will be able to sing more during live performances. I accept it bc no one's perfect, right?
Liz, mainvocal??????
@@mac-hs1xu yes, she's now the group's unofficial main vocalist according to ive's kpop profile
@@barunetta241 Kpop profile is not always correct. The only thing that is confirmed about IVE, is that Yujin is the leader. They don’t have fixed positions like NMIXX, but it is obvious who the main vocalist is. Which should be Liz since she has the best technique out of everyone. I mean she can literally sing AESPA songs, so it’s obvious that she’s the main vocalist.
Wonyoung literally sang here. Istg wonyoung only has her own fans, even ‘dives’ are against her now
@@MochieeeMoon exactly. She totally sang here. Her lines are in the low register so obviously she sounds quiet. She cannot shout or be loud and be low at the same time!
LIZ IS INSANEEEE
1:13 1:21 woahhhh leeseo sounds SO good
+2:18
+2:31
I swear Wonyoung can sing but the company just didn't train her properly, and because of that she always get the hates and criticism.
Ikr she did great today and she keeps improving comeback too
True. She can sing, but she can't sing while dancing.
@@fennekindol2503 she just did now tho and did it in the concert
@@ablackheartedblinkwholoves3259
FYI it’s not a concert it’s a performance stage
@@LauriceJane79001 what do you think they are doing in a concert other than performing? Selling onions?
liz and yujin 😳
wonyoung sing very well in this stage, she always give us improvements, proud of her 💕
The chorus is crazy😍😍😍
they slayed
Keren bangettt!!! Makin stabil guys 😭👍🏻
Boleh ngga sih berharap ini SOTY 😭 harus SOTY sihh ini. Bahkan albumnya juga berharap bisa AOTY. Lagu²nya bagus lhooo 😭
soty soty lahhh😋😋😋
リズ、ユジンもすごいけど、イソってこんな歌うまかったけ？！声量もあるしすごい！🎉
they are ALL glowing, i think this comeback is really going to change how ive is viewed by the general public, they worked really hard and starship finally gave their talent justice instead of feeding their popularity out of hate. i'm very happy for them :) and they genuinely seem confident and more at ease, i think big things are coming ahead for them
It's rare that an idol gives the high notes their all when they know that the backing vocals will cover them. I'm incredibly impressed by Liz and her professionalism, as well as Yujin, although I think Liz is more consistent. Amazing for such young artists. I think Leeseo is definitely improving and has done a great job covering Rei as well.
I didn't notice that Wonyoung also sings the chorus.
It's actually Liz and Yujin's voice
@@sisirinsara4061 I don't think yujin or Liz or even any ive pronounce "fantasy" like that except wonyoung. Even the "stage" sounds like wonyoung.
they’re all singing the chorus but liz and yujin take over the high notes, you can even hear leeseo’s “big big stage” as well
@@sisirinsara4061 actually if you see the mnet stage's lyrics (on bottom left), can be seen who lead the chorus on live stages.
1st chorus : wonyoung, yujin
2nd chorus : yujin, leeseo
3rd chorus : yujin, wonyoung
That's why at last half part of 3rd chorus on mnet stage you can hear wony's vocal slightly
@@mnbvcxzsomeone2560 I don't think that's accurate though. Because the voices don't change at all in the chorus even when WY or LS are "leading"
Literally Liz’s parts give me goosebumps ✨✨
istg liz hit the notes effortlessly
Wonyoung seems so comfortable and happy this era i hope she keeps on improving
Just wanna say liz is a good vocalist ❤️
The "so that is who I am" part really sounds satisfying
Liz is so beautiful❤❤
Gaeul is so stable yujin too
Leeseo improved quite a lot im shocked
2:25this high note❤❤❤
MR 제거 잘 제거 한듯. 구독한다.
Liz finally having lines that will make her shine more ❤
she always has so many lines lol, just in kitsch, love dive and after like but in eleven, not your girl, blue blood, cherish, royal and other song she has so much lines.
Yujin n Gaeul❤️🌹😍♥️
Leeseo 🫶🫶🫶🫶🫶😍
yujin😮😮
really love it
Their duet is awesome. 👏
wonyoung beneran ngebuktiin. proud of you girl! ❤
Wony kamu yg terbaik. Kamu telah mengevaluasi dirimu dengan baik. untuk kedepannya ,semoga lebih baik lagi dari ini❤
Liz and Yujin slayed with their vocals ❤
Wonyoung, Leeseo and Gaeul was also good but I think this song do not showcase their vocals since its more on high parts. I'm sure that all Ive members are good singers. Please stop spreading hate ❤
i'm so proud of these girls TT their hard work on this album has paid off greatly. ❤
LIZ YOUR VOICE GIRL ❤❤❤❤
wow the high notes are legit. LOVE IT
leeseo surprised me
Liz, yujin, leeaso, gaeul❤️
😪
ot4 stan leave ive alone
Kindly leave our fandom if you don't support all the members 💕
You can’t even spell Leeseo name correctly 😭
If you can’t support all the members then leave.
@@MochieeeMoon lmaooooo
원영아 노래실력 많이 늘었다. 라이브 잘 못해도 계속 라이브 해줘 하면 할수록 늘거야
맞아요! Couldn’t agree more! If they keep lip-syncing, they’ll never get better. But I believe, this comeback will help them improve a lot!
Yes, Yujin did well but let’s not pretend we don’t want to hear Liz sing the main high note.
omg liz
Leeseo's so stable. i'm so happy she's shining
Yujin and liz ❤
Great live vocals for all the girls
omg its amazing
Wow liz
1:23 that random sound got me-
Finally a 4gen girl group that actually sings live 😭😭😭😭
y'all can hate them all you want but you can't deny that they can sing and they've improved and keep getting better, especially leeseo who's still practically a child.
天啊 大家都唱得超好
so basically, liz is the only who's singing live in the chorus with her full chest voice? a great vocalist!! starship, don't waste her.
she’s leading the chorus, her and yujin. the other are backing vocals
no yujin is leading it and then liz, w a little wy and leeseo vocals
It is obviously Yujin who is leading the chorus because of the excessive amount of strain.
liz and yujin (also wonyoung, leeseo, gaeul, rei but they don't sing the "so that's who I am.")
I know that they can sing well but why the agency doesn't allow them to sing live more back then? Or is it just how they branding this girl group so they can get more attention? They're wonderful and good at sing tho
they always allowed live singing? i can find you stages from all their comebacks where they sang live if u want.
Wtf🤣
Your existence is wtf.
와 ~리얼 라이브 못한다는 사람들 다 어디 갔어? 이거 들어 봐라 아이브 라이브 짱 이다
you really can't rely Wonyoung when it comes to live singing.
no hate just fact 💯
oh really? then you should watch her royal, blue blood, and my satisfaction performance at fancon 😏
@@happygal7574 oh really? hahaha that's why she surpassed Ariana Grande with her high notes 🤭😂
ah i see keep hating on her then, have a good day pal
@@happygal7574 gurl I really don't hate, I state facts 😙
@@dj-kt8zi is not fact, wonyoung 1st part was harder to sing than the chorus cause lower register was harder to sing while dancing
우쩌;;;; 라이브가 엉망이네...
아..거기가 좋아하는 그룹에서도 빌드업 없이 3옥솔 그냥 꽂는거 보고싶다...
Liz Yujin very good🎉
Gaeul Leeseo good🎉
Wonyoung very very bad, really need to re-evaluate your attitude to the profession, practice more rigorously with yourself 👎👎👎👎
seek heIp you wy anti commenting this on every ive mr removed… you look siIIy because wy did good here
Wonyoung is not "VerY veRy BaD" and try to evaluate idols properly :D
Both of her lines she sang them so SU
Eh??? Seems you have a problem with your ears 😂
at least sing her WHOLE lines