When JM was giving her speech at the end the plaintiff’s smile was so real & genuine, he was so grateful to win his case and it showed! Made my heart smile ❤🥹
only this time the judge caught herself when she started to ask him why he took the pictures . she has a habit of telling people to take pictures and then being suspicious of them when they do take pictures .
@@marleonetti7Agree. I think because usually when people have pictures, they are altered or not the right date. I've seen litigants do it before on the people's court. She was just skeptical which is her job.
at 7:20 When the judge was asking him why he took photos before during and after, she almost made is sound like it was suspicious, yet at the very end praises him for being so thorough...
She wasn't sounding suspicious. When she said it's not his first rodeo, it means he has had customers like this in the past. So he took photo proof to show he did the work.
On top of everything else, the plaintiff gave her a very low rate to clean up that toilet of a property! Good job on his documentation with a signed contract, plus pictures of before, during, and after!
If it's not written within the 4 corners of the contract, then it doesn't exist. This guy clearly had all of his ducks in a row and this lady was oh so clearly trying to scam whoever did the work and get it all done for as close to free as possible. I still can't believe that after the pics and all of the work that he did, she still withheld half of his payment THEN tried to sue for another $400. What a piece of work!
That lady is a millionaire he rushed her because the contact was written on the back of a used paper, your comment shows what’s wrong with the US and that is most rush to judgment before all the facts is known . As she said at the end Karma will get him and you remember that also
She thought she was getting the grass cut for $600 not 1200. She said she was gonna have someone else do the landscaping stuff. All could’ve been avoided if she just read what he wrote instead of blind signing the paper.
im split on this one because i do believe her when she said he was a fast talker that told her he would do everything she was asking for the 1200 . he also testified earlier in the case that he was never told about the garage and then later in the case he admitted that she did show him the garage and he did not want to include it in the total price but i dont think he fully communicated that to her and she thought she was signing something that only pertained to the lawn because thats probably how he presented it to her and he took advantage of her language barriers . the judge was right to be suspicious about this not being his first lawsuit because he most likely has done this to alot of elderly people and people who do not understand reading and writing english very well . he probably only picks the jobs with people he can get over on .
She wanted that mess taken care of for $200. Are you kidding me ? Can you imagine what was in the garage , especially with the look on his face when he spoke of it ?
No way, I think she understood exactly what she was doing. She had no leg to stand on when it came to the garage. It wasn't on the contract anywhere. She is an awful liar though. 😂
Language barrier? She even knew words like compulsive liar. Maybe she's delusional or shameless instead hence thanking the judge when she was insulting her.
i often think 'this person isnt as stupid as they are pretending to be' the defendant isnt a stupid woman, she knew exactly what she had agreed to never planned on paying for the work
Agree. I know sometimes language barriers are a problem but some people act like they can't understand when they can. She knew what she signed and regretted it later
@Clarissa Lowery What would you call her then? I guess in your eyes being black is a bad thing? If she were white, I’m sure you would have kept your big woke regurgitating perpetual victim mouth shut!
So let me get this straight. She signed a contract indicating she'd pay him $1,200 for the job. (Let's say she honestly thought that the garage clean-out was part of that.) She paid him $600 and refused to pay any more, then hired someone else to do the garage for $400. So she ended up paying a total of $1,000 for a job that she had been willing to pay $1,200 for. And then she wants HIM to give HER $400 back? So that she only ends up paying $600 for the entire thing, and he only gets $200 for the massive amount of work he did? That's so insane I can't even begin to comprehend what her thinking is. The contract doesn't say anything about the garage. If you don't like it, don't sign it. Plus, I have to say that $1,200 for that entire job was an unbelievably good price. I paid $1,700 for a yard clean-up that was much less than that. Now, I live in an expensive area, but still. He gave her a phenomenal deal, and she tried to screw him. What a greedy and dishonest woman.
He has it together and is an example for older people who act as if they can't learn technology.. Stay up on game... And if u don't know how to do something concerning technology.. Google and RUclips are your best friends. He used that phone the way it should be used and documented everything perfectly. I pray to stay knowledgeable as I get older. Good case.
Living in a retirement community, I can tell you some older people simply can’t. Their minds are not able to comprehend it. Some of that is due to the beginnings of Alzheimer’s and dementia. I don’t expect them to understand. I help them instead.
I think the plaintiff took advantage of the defendant inability to understand. Her English is not that well and he admitted he walked through the garage with her before signing the contract and I believe the defendant thought the price included him doing her garage since he looked at it before signing anything.
I get so tired of entitled Karens or Kevins who don't seem to understand how a contract works or don't seem to understand that they aren't entitled to free stuff.
Someone said she's a millionare? Doesn't have anything to do with the case but was wondering. People agree for services and then don't want to pay. I don't get it.
She is not the first person I’ve heard say “thank you” in a different cultural context. I think it may be People from the Caribbean. I hate how JM hasn’t caught on…
@@kevai6290 meaning judge would say something not in their favor and the person would say “thank you” . Evidently it’s not taken in the American context of what thank you should mean.
@@none8726 but what do you think the cultural context is - what do you think they mean when they’re saying thank you? I’ve googled it, can’t find anything. Maybe it’s just someone misunderstanding and thinking something was said in their favour.
@@ShortyLexiex3 ahah I’m curious what these people heard that we didn’t hear? She had no evidence and could not prove anything. “I was going to pay him 1200 just to cut grass.” Ummm sure
There's a contract!! How can she say that he was supposed to do certain things when it was not written down? He did the right thing. She should have had someone clean up that yard while tenants were living there.
I mean the plaintiff acted like the garage was something she was making up at the beginning then he admitted that it was discussed but not a part of the " original deal". All I'm saying is he made it seem like she was crazy when he knew what she was referring to
probably bc she acted like he was originally hired to do the garage when that’s not the case. she talked in circles, explaining very little and while i do understand that could be due to a language barrier, it’s quite simple. she signed a contract saying the payment was for the lawn related stuff with no mention of the garage. not sure how youre going to imply he did something wrong
She just wanted to do cheap like her friends had told her to do in America. Not done this way when you sign a contract. She did not mention the yardwork that was not in the contract. She was a mess and knows English very well.
Even with such an edifying speech at the end, J M dampens the effect by raising her voice to reflect her impatience with the plaintif ... needs checking.
I think the was miscommunication.... she gave him 600 I ain't giving nobody 600 bucks to clean my yard let alone 1200 I'll do it mtself😢but seriously maybe she thought the 12 was for both Marv she didn't read it and just signed it after he wrote it be because the discussed it right before.... not saying he was being sneaky but that she didn't understand what he was charging her for and her not reading it and just signing it fkd her so it's still her fault but i can see why she is truly confused
😂The defendant’s countersuit is a quote from someone who says they’ll the garage for $400.; the work hasn’t been done yet.😂 She’s trying to get the plaintiff to pay for that.
Exit interview: "The judge didn't hear everything." She's not going to let you ramble on without showing any proof. What did you think the contract was for???
She is too old to be a judge!!👩⚖️ the guy in the photo standing 20 feet away from camera sheet less and he said!!! I took the pictures! F me dead!!! This is crazy!!!🤪
The defendant lost because She didn't get the whole job in writing. The plaintiff is a liar. First he she their was no mention of cleaning the garage Then he said they talk about doing it after the the lawn.
This women was delusional, even by the end the lesson she got was to not trust this guy, really, that's what you learned today ? She did not listen to anyone not the contractor when the job was being discussed and not the judge when it was explained what signing something means and that evidence not stories wins a case. I meet people like this now and then, good to have them sign something because they move their heads around like they are listening but that does not mean anyone is home taking notes.
She didn't pay him because he did not clean her garage so she wanted him to pay her to have someone else clean her garage. So this guy should just pay to have her garage cleaned. GOT IT. SCAM SCAM SCAM
When JM was giving her speech at the end the plaintiff’s smile was so real & genuine, he was so grateful to win his case and it showed! Made my heart smile ❤🥹
only this time the judge caught herself when she started to ask him why he took the pictures . she has a habit of telling people to take pictures and then being suspicious of them when they do take pictures .
Same!🙂
He broke my heart with that smile. Sooooo sweeeet.
@@marleonetti7Agree. I think because usually when people have pictures, they are altered or not the right date. I've seen litigants do it before on the people's court. She was just skeptical which is her job.
Spoilers! 🤦
I really like this guy! He did well with both the contract and the pictures.
His little giggle near the end was adorable.
Okay🤣 somebody needs a boyfriend 😜
It was adorable! He was so proud lol
Loved the end speech JM gave at the end about somebody finally listened to her advice about tp & a crayon
Me too and the man thanking her was sweet, i felt bad for both but he seems honest and his job must be really hard ☹️
she has a habit of telling people to take pictures and then being suspicious of them when they do take pictures .
She didn't want to pay him and still dared to sue him for $400 🤦♀️😂😂😂
at 7:20 When the judge was asking him why he took photos before during and after, she almost made is sound like it was suspicious, yet at the very end praises him for being so thorough...
thank you
She does that often and it's so contradictory
I didn’t think she sounded suspicious. Just sounded like she wanted to know and understand.
Or she could have been asking his reason so those watching learn.
She wasn't sounding suspicious. When she said it's not his first rodeo, it means he has had customers like this in the past. So he took photo proof to show he did the work.
I am SO CONFUSED by her defense!!!
Entitlement and delusion
On top of everything else, the plaintiff gave her a very low rate to clean up that toilet of a property! Good job on his documentation with a signed contract, plus pictures of before, during, and after!
amen.document everything you do in life because there's always someone out there to bring you down I know from experiences and still going through it
That’s what that Supreme Court candidate did. His father kept journals and advised him to do that.
Wow,look at how clearly she speaks in the hallway! Absolutely no language issue there! She clearly tried to scam the nice dude!
If it's not written within the 4 corners of the contract, then it doesn't exist. This guy clearly had all of his ducks in a row and this lady was oh so clearly trying to scam whoever did the work and get it all done for as close to free as possible. I still can't believe that after the pics and all of the work that he did, she still withheld half of his payment THEN tried to sue for another $400. What a piece of work!
That lady is a millionaire he rushed her because the contact was written on the back of a used paper, your comment shows what’s wrong with the US and that is most rush to judgment before all the facts is known . As she said at the end Karma will get him and you remember that also
She's a lowly scammer. Plain and simple, the defendant is a SCAMMER.
She thought she was getting the grass cut for $600 not 1200. She said she was gonna have someone else do the landscaping stuff. All could’ve been avoided if she just read what he wrote instead of blind signing the paper.
To be fair 1200 is an amazing process for the yard it was horrible I know landscapers that wouldn't touch it for less than 3k
That lawn was more than cutting grass. It was a huge mess. I believed him when he said she never mentioned the garage initially.
Not reading a contract you sign is stupid and totally her fault.
'Nobody steals from Creed Bratton and gets away with it. The last person to do this disappeared. His name? Creed Bratton."
🤣🤣🤣
😂😂
😂😂😂
I love how she keeps side eyeing him. Basically threatening him
She’s the scam artist and expects everything done for her to be for free. Glad he won, he deserves pay for his work
She wanted a lot done for nothing.
im split on this one because i do believe her when she said he was a fast talker that told her he would do everything she was asking for the 1200 . he also testified earlier in the case that he was never told about the garage and then later in the case he admitted that she did show him the garage and he did not want to include it in the total price but i dont think he fully communicated that to her and she thought she was signing something that only pertained to the lawn because thats probably how he presented it to her and he took advantage of her language barriers . the judge was right to be suspicious about this not being his first lawsuit because he most likely has done this to alot of elderly people and people who do not understand reading and writing english very well . he probably only picks the jobs with people he can get over on .
@@marleonetti7 I believe her too , bless her
Omg defendant is totally Haitian, she is literally my grandmother on my Haitian side😂😂😂
She wanted that mess taken care of for $200. Are you kidding me ? Can you imagine what was in the garage , especially with the look on his face when he spoke of it ?
Judge Marilyn is tough but she's fair!
There is clearly a language barrier, maybe that's what caused the confusion.
God Bless Them Both🙌🏿
Amen 👍
I think the language barrier complicated things. Also, the defendant is doing a poor job at lying. 🤣
they're both speaking English
No way, I think she understood exactly what she was doing. She had no leg to stand on when it came to the garage. It wasn't on the contract anywhere. She is an awful liar though. 😂
Absolutely awful liar😁🤣😟
Language barrier? She even knew words like compulsive liar. Maybe she's delusional or shameless instead hence thanking the judge when she was insulting her.
That's called an accent. She spoke more eloquently and was easier to understand than some "urban" people they've had on the show.
i often think 'this person isnt as stupid as they are pretending to be'
the defendant isnt a stupid woman, she knew exactly what she had agreed to
never planned on paying for the work
Agree. I know sometimes language barriers are a problem but some people act like they can't understand when they can. She knew what she signed and regretted it later
The black girl in the audience behind her is trying really hard to understand what tf she’s talking about 😂
She really is lol but I understand her Cleary because my daddy is a Haitian
Why you gotta say black girl why not just the young lady 🙄
@@clarissalowery9629 You say it like it's a negative thing. If she's a black girl, she's a black girl.
@Clarissa Lowery What would you call her then? I guess in your eyes being black is a bad thing? If she were white, I’m sure you would have kept your big woke regurgitating perpetual victim mouth shut!
@@4everThoughtful LOL! Right! Why are people so freaking unnecessarily fragile?
And that's why pictures are so important. It and the contract proved his case!
its the random "thank you" for me...lady you're losing!! 🤣
at the exit interview, even her friend seemed like she'd had enough, and wasn't surprised in the slightest that she had lost.
That lying lady’s face is driving me crazy
(Finger in air) “uoop! Uooop!”
She resembles a man, and her wig doesn’t look good.
@@paulaboynton8299Why do you have to bring up appearances? Weird.
Everyone that looses says “I didn’t get enough time to prove my case”
"Thank-You!"
😂
The defendant lied at least 3 times.
It was In the winter.....I came in June...🤣
She was holding his money. She is scrambling for that story.
Damn defendant wanted all that work for $200 WOW
I nearly fall asleep with the talking pace of the man lol
Just in case you did fall asleep, he won his case. LOL!
@@justjared2009 🤣🤣🤣
“Cool beans, man! I live by the quarry. We should hang out by the quarry and throw things down there.”
I think it might be possible that she just completely misunderstood the yard guy.
If you don't read and understand a contract but you still sign it, the problem is yours, not the worker's.
So let me get this straight. She signed a contract indicating she'd pay him $1,200 for the job. (Let's say she honestly thought that the garage clean-out was part of that.) She paid him $600 and refused to pay any more, then hired someone else to do the garage for $400. So she ended up paying a total of $1,000 for a job that she had been willing to pay $1,200 for. And then she wants HIM to give HER $400 back? So that she only ends up paying $600 for the entire thing, and he only gets $200 for the massive amount of work he did? That's so insane I can't even begin to comprehend what her thinking is. The contract doesn't say anything about the garage. If you don't like it, don't sign it. Plus, I have to say that $1,200 for that entire job was an unbelievably good price. I paid $1,700 for a yard clean-up that was much less than that. Now, I live in an expensive area, but still. He gave her a phenomenal deal, and she tried to screw him. What a greedy and dishonest woman.
Shame on her. That guy didn’t deserve that. $1200 was nothing for that mess.
This full glam beat on JM is GORGEOUS 😍
This is a slick KAREEN
Looking forward to Adrian 's two cents.....
🤣🤣 I was looking for his comment just now. You made me laugh with this one!
Haha. Me too!
Well a black woman lost against a white male. Judge Milan has to be racist!
My guess: Something something. Judge is racist. Something something, she should have bought a company to do the work, not hired someone.
@@horsie371 and JM really stuck it to her! When will black people figure out to not go on this show???
Good evening beautiful people
Good evening .
Good evening
Good evening, Angela🦋
6:10
Literally she was like “uh oh! I’m losing! Time to change my story!”
She said, its only money 💰..Then pay the man!!! Wow!!
She knows she was lying 😂😂
That girl in the audience is driving me nuts.
Which one ... ? Lol
@@k0chana6 I’m thinking the one with the bangs in the second row
@@kathyvierra I think she looks more like Aubrey Plaza. She is pretty.
This lady is confused and very confusing!
I agree.
Look at Aunt Esther....
😂😂😂 I have no words...no words. Go head auntie Esther Go head!😊
It is only money, but the stupid refused to pay.
Good job by the man.
She had a valid complaint
He has it together and is an example for older people who act as if they can't learn technology.. Stay up on game... And if u don't know how to do something concerning technology.. Google and RUclips are your best friends. He used that phone the way it should be used and documented everything perfectly. I pray to stay knowledgeable as I get older. Good case.
Living in a retirement community, I can tell you some older people simply can’t. Their minds are not able to comprehend it. Some of that is due to the beginnings of Alzheimer’s and dementia. I don’t expect them to understand. I help them instead.
I think the plaintiff took advantage of the defendant inability to understand. Her English is not that well and he admitted he walked through the garage with her before signing the contract and I believe the defendant thought the price included him doing her garage since he looked at it before signing anything.
Wrong
I get so tired of entitled Karens or Kevins who don't seem to understand how a contract works or don't seem to understand that they aren't entitled to free stuff.
He told her anything besides the yard would be extra.
Everytime someone loses its because the other person lied, they didn't have enough time or didn't get to show their side.
Someone said she's a millionare? Doesn't have anything to do with the case but was wondering. People agree for services and then don't want to pay. I don't get it.
I'd say that he did AT LEAST 1,200 dollars worth of work on that lawn IF NOT MORE!!!
Trees will grow in the lawn, they spread via watersprouts from the roots.
Wow she really took advantage of him.
The girl with bangs behind the defendant looks just like Aubrey Plaza. She’s so pretty.
She is not the first person I’ve heard say “thank you” in a different cultural context. I think it may be People from the Caribbean. I hate how JM hasn’t caught on…
What’s the “cultural context”
@@kevai6290 meaning judge would say something not in their favor and the person would say “thank you” . Evidently it’s not taken in the American context of what thank you should mean.
She’s Haitian
@@none8726 but what do you think the cultural context is - what do you think they mean when they’re saying thank you? I’ve googled it, can’t find anything. Maybe it’s just someone misunderstanding and thinking something was said in their favour.
wrong and judge knows from being of cuban decent.
If the judge listens maybe she can figure out what the lady is saying. Her and judge Mathis really grind my gears sometimes 🤬
They (tv judges) all can do that from my experience.
@@elvickRULES especially Judy in the sky
The lady wasn't saying anything to prove her case... and she had no evidence.
Exactly
@@ShortyLexiex3 ahah I’m curious what these people heard that we didn’t hear? She had no evidence and could not prove anything. “I was going to pay him 1200 just to cut grass.” Ummm sure
I hope she didn't end up doing the Voodoo Curse on him.
I hope she did
There's a contract!! How can she say that he was supposed to do certain things when it was not written down? He did the right thing. She should have had someone clean up that yard while tenants were living there.
He kept looking up at the ceiling. I've seen some untruthful people do this before. IJS
I mean the plaintiff acted like the garage was something she was making up at the beginning then he admitted that it was discussed but not a part of the " original deal". All I'm saying is he made it seem like she was crazy when he knew what she was referring to
probably bc she acted like he was originally hired to do the garage when that’s not the case. she talked in circles, explaining very little and while i do understand that could be due to a language barrier, it’s quite simple. she signed a contract saying the payment was for the lawn related stuff with no mention of the garage. not sure how youre going to imply he did something wrong
Probably because he said no he won’t do this right now and let’s do the other stuff now and she crazily not paying him because of the garage lol 😂
I think he is Mr. Jekyll and Hyde type that went over there sweet talked her and took advantage but she will be ok and get hoodoo on him🤣
@@payableondeath9091 Bull CRAP
I caught that too!
Oh! The thing was, He was in a hurry.
She just wanted to do cheap like her friends had told her to do in America. Not done this way when you sign a contract. She did not mention the yardwork that was not in the contract. She was a mess and knows English very well.
This lady is NOT very smart. 🙄
Good on him .I would of seen her coming a mile away
That's the best I've seen!
Just the landscaping and gutter repairs was definitely worth $1200, if not more. That was a lot of work!
Even with such an edifying speech at the end, J M dampens the effect by raising her voice to reflect her impatience with the plaintif ... needs checking.
I think the was miscommunication.... she gave him 600 I ain't giving nobody 600 bucks to clean my yard let alone 1200 I'll do it mtself😢but seriously maybe she thought the 12 was for both Marv she didn't read it and just signed it after he wrote it be because the discussed it right before.... not saying he was being sneaky but that she didn't understand what he was charging her for and her not reading it and just signing it fkd her so it's still her fault but i can see why she is truly confused
She's thinks it's unfair.
😂The defendant’s countersuit is a quote from someone who says they’ll the garage for $400.; the work hasn’t been done yet.😂 She’s trying to get the plaintiff to pay for that.
“Creed Bratton has never declared bankruptcy. When Creed Bratton gets in trouble, he transfers his debt to William Charles Schneider.”
What is your major malfunction? 😆
@@KrazeeClark ruclips.net/video/HtIrAzPlrrM/видео.html
What?
@@cfp11 BOBODY.
Exit interview: "The judge didn't hear everything." She's not going to let you ramble on without showing any proof. What did you think the contract was for???
When people lose, it's always because the other side is a compulsive liar. Not that they're wrong... no...
I loved the face she took and said he is a liar lol XD
She is too old to be a judge!!👩⚖️ the guy in the photo standing 20 feet away from camera sheet less and he said!!! I took the pictures!
F me dead!!! This is crazy!!!🤪
The defendant lost because
She didn't get the whole job in writing. The plaintiff is a liar. First he she their was no mention of cleaning the garage Then he said they
talk about doing it after the
the lawn.
Defendant full of crap. She doesn’t listen. Wanted everything done for nothing. 1,200 for that mess was a bargain.
KAREEN LOST
wa wa wa wa wa
I LOVE her accent.
Just not her scruples.
Well the plaintiff got his money but he won't be getting any free oxtail stew or jerk chicken.
She's not cooking no jerk chicken She's Haitian
She isn’t Jamaican at all so no oxtail or jerk chicken.
Wrong country, wrong food.
She's Haitian b smh
@@firstladypie760 oxtail stew and jerk chicken isn't only Jamaican. Haiti, Jamaica, Barbados, Bermuda, Caymen, Turks... all do jerk chicken
What type of landscaper calls weeds trees?!
Mr. Ermantrout stopped working for Saul Goodman and started a landscaping company
I dont think she heard her out.
This woman is so confused
The Kumbalay Lion King internet princess lady lol
This women was delusional, even by the end the lesson she got was to not trust this guy, really, that's what you learned today ? She did not listen to anyone not the contractor when the job was being discussed and not the judge when it was explained what signing something means and that evidence not stories wins a case. I meet people like this now and then, good to have them sign something because they move their heads around like they are listening but that does not mean anyone is home taking notes.
Mona peye mesye ya tande 😂😂😂
I think there was a misunderstanding between the two.
I dont get why harvey ask people questions when he is lawyer and knows all the right answers anyways
The defendant looks like Ella's Fitzgerald
Yard worker. He hardly knew her.
Some folks can be so cheap when it comes to paying for workmanship which is justified
She didn't pay him because he did not clean her garage so she wanted him to pay her to have someone else clean her garage. So this guy should just pay to have her garage cleaned. GOT IT. SCAM SCAM SCAM
Good
He's a liar.
FINALLY AFTER 17 YEARS SOMEONE IS LISTENING ,HAHAHAHAHAHHAHA
Its strange sometimes it seems like their was just no meeting of the minds and other times it seems like she was trying to put one over on him