Allah’s Hand! The Attributes of Allah (Swt) | Shamsi & Yusuf | Speakers Corner
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 сен 2024
- Support our efforts:
✔️Donate here: www.gofundme.c...
👉
✔️ Our Website: theall-loving....
📌Yusuf asked Brother Shamsi about #salafi aqeedah and #Allah’s hand from hadith at #speakersCorner Hyde Park.
✅ Please share this: • Allah’s Hand! The Attr...
🤚Disclaimer: The views and opinions of partakers in these debates and videos in don’t represent the views of ‘The All-Loving’ in any shape of form but are a representation of what takes place at speakers Corner.
💎This video is created by & for the “The All-Loving”. Feel free to re-upload and share.
Surah 3 verse 7 says 'And no one knows it's interpretation except Allah:
It is He who has sent down to you, [O Muḥammad], the Book; in it are verses [that are] precise - they are the foundation of the Book - and others unspecific.1 As for those in whose hearts is deviation [from truth], they will follow that of it which is unspecific, seeking discord and seeking an interpretation [suitable to them]. And no one knows its [true] interpretation except Allāh. But those firm in knowledge say, "We believe in it. All [of it] is from our Lord." And no one will be reminded except those of understanding.
- Saheeh International
Just to hear it on person, Marsha'Allah....it helps when one hears in person and many will benefit insha'Allah....May Allah guide us all, Amiin.🌹
Ameen
This is why you should watch brothers who only use Quran and sunnah to prove our beliefs if you want to learn. Yusef went to Ali dawah and Ali couldn’t explain his point. Shamsi cleared everything up MashAllah.
True that. I wish Ali Dawah gets the msg.
Ali dawah is too busy demonstrating how to oppose Allah and his messenger by shaking women’s hand
@@Randomhandlename you sad pathetic losers.
@@Randomhandlenameproof ?
@@Player_Zeesh search on RUclips
Thank you bro I learned a lot may Allah swt reward you
CORRECTION:
He meant to say Adam with his own hands. Its most Definitely not Iblis ALLAH created whith his own hands.
@Faiaz Malekzadeh there were jinns before Iblis he was nor the first Jinn to be created.
@@MrBigdaddykon no iblis is the first jinn
He said iblis was created with Allah’s power
Brother یوسف is by far most patient man I've seen to stand in front of Shamsi.
probably themost patient and respectful man at the park and hes younger than them all. The older guys are the ones that playstubborn acting like they cant recieve dawah but even the most learned of scholars are open too dawah.
Alhamdulillah
1: Say, ˹O Prophet,˺ “He is Allah-One ˹and Indivisible˺;
2: Allah-the Sustainer ˹needed by all˺.
3:
He has never had offspring, nor was He born.
4: And there is none comparable to Him.”
Allah has human form, he has face, eyes, chin, two right hands and fingers, leg and one foot. Allah sits on his throne, but he some times enters the lowest heaven, which is his own creation. Allah also prays for muhammad to himself, so allah has feelings.
@@chomo54andbabyaisha97 That's the belief of wahabbism which is a deviation
@@mikailshakes4514 no thats not in the books of wahhabi idiot
@@cublucublu1314 Syekh Utsaimin says "God is like Adam has a face, eye, hand and foot" (Ibnu Utsaimin, Syarh Al-Aqidah Li bnu Taimiyah Dar ats-Isuraya page 107,293)
@@cublucublu1314 Syekh Bin Baz says "God's height is the same as Adam's height which is 60 hasta or around 30 meters" (Majmu fatawa al-Allamah Abdul Aziz Ibnu Baz, Dae A-Hfa, series 4, fatwa nunber 2331 page 368)
Funny how Shamsi didn’t mention the verse in Al-Imran about clear and unclear verses . Shamsi is deceptive
the brother became a Salafi alhamdulillah, the Ashari/Jahmis have been refuted a billion times by the great scholars,yet some blind followers wanna follow their desires
@MusaLdn He came a 2nd time to Shamsi in another video. You should easily find it. Its also from 3 years ago. But he dissapeared and no one knows his current state. I hope he is still sincere and upon the truth insha Allah
Masallah..Yusuf is a very profound young brother.
Profound in the book of salafis. But dont believe in it.
He got caught lying all the time
What’s so hard to understand? Allah confirmed his attributes, Allah created Adam with his hands. And no one can even imagine what Allah looks like. However it befits Allah he is that way. We don’t know anything about Allah other than what Allah has confirmed in the Quran. ? Why are people saying salafi believe allah has hands when no salafi believes that? 😐🤔
Brother if you people would like to go into metaphysics of Almighty..Which prophet prohibited, the creator of the heavens and earth created you with sperm ..You are a created being who has given you the right to discuss about nature of physical nature of the almighty..In the Quran it mentions Allah Hu nur samaawat wal ard then take that as well as literal ..Humans cannot comprehend Almighty period enough of nonsense being uttered in the name of Almighty ...Let us stay in our limit we are formed by sperm he is the creator and all living ...
@Freedom fighter Request you to kindly read the prophet Clearly stated a believer does not slander, curse or abuse others. you a person created from sperm you own your existence to the the one ever living ..Don't you know Holy Quran clearly state humans have been given ilm e kalil (limited access to knowledge)..How and who has given authority to state about nature of Almighty..Need to be in our limits we are created beings not creator of our selves..Need to have fear of Almighty..If according to you someone is ahle this or Ahle that are you feeding them or giving them money to sustence.??. ..Quran clearly states don't claim yourself pure It's almighty who.knows..If you have understanding about something the least you can state this is how understood it..The brother asked question because some people do anthromophism that's the main thing..
@Freedom fighter I feel you need to have of fear of Almighty for not understanding your limits and where the limit of Almighty starts...You calling me a name in front of Almighty you will be accountable that's all I can say..Each group does that your group also accuse others also accuse if you have a problem that's you need to deal with it..Deen is of Allah you and I are not custodian .
So the Hand is a metaphor. A hand is a palm with five fingers.
If you say God did not say it as a metaphor, then God contradicts himself when he says there is nothing like him.
@@911beats but a hand on a creature isn’t 4 fingers 1 thumb, a hand of a clock has no fingers. So stop using your very limited brain to make something up.
Allah SWT said he breathed into Adam AS his Ruh. Breath neccisitates the action of respiration but that is an attribute of a contingent being so clearly this is a Metaphor, in the same way the word yyid is a metaphor, That hand is the thing used to commit action, so this is a Metaphor for the action Allah SWT takes.. Thats my opinion wa Allahu a3lam
It is correct. They love to compare hearing seeing and living to prove that hand is meant literally but that isn’t even a fair comparison to begin with. Eyes and ears is a more fair comparison. That’s 1. Secondly Allah says He is All hearing and All seeing, which human claims that they are all hearing or all seeing? Literally nobody, so there’s that. That example does not favor them at all. Let the salafis try again.
@@FinalBoss429 Yes it's a very rudimentary argument tbh, it's meant to convince people who think 'aristotilian Logic' is the only way to prove something and they set up these little arguments that trap people lol when it's obviously not true what they're saying. It's just a game and it is what Allah swt called as 'vain reasoning' in the Quran I believe.. But that's why they need so much violence to make people agree with them around the world lol they need to force you to agree without thinking
@@FinalBoss429 Cause I don't remember Maliki's in the Maghreb just killing everyone who doesn't agree lol even with the Shia they debated them until the Maghreb was Sunni.. And many of them were basically Ash'aris like Abd Al Qadir of Algeria
The real attack on wahabism and salafism is that they should condemn monarchy and render it haraam only shura should be promoted for government affairs these people support monarchy type government that all sahaba were against
The Sunni caliphs were monarchs
I’m Sory shamsi but the brothers point is very valid
Did any of the Companions asked about Yadd? They did not because they understood but because they didn't bother as the meaning of the Ayah was conveyed by the use of the word Yadd
Why are they making a big deal about this. Allah speaks in the Qur'an in metaphorical language at times, common sense will tell you that Allah doesn't have a hand. That is anthropomorphic.
So Quran is metaphorical
@@alexandriarona2299 I didn't say the Qur'an is metaphorical. The Qur'an mentions that it is read in, the muhkam(decisive), and mutashabihat (allegorical).
@@defrocker0569 it doesn’t say that. So please don’t speak with ignorance. There is verses that clear only layperson can understand and verses not clear only scholars understand doesn’t mean Quran is not clear. The Quran has no contradictions. Allah says in Quran none receive admonition except men of understanding. And Allah says he reveals the Quran in Arabic so it’s clear to understand
My advise to you learn what this means before posting and learn from tafseer cause what u just said is speaking of Allah without knowledge therefore even kufr can make fun of us
Lol that guy always be talking calm just make sure you don't piss him off. Always chewing . I like both shamsi and Yusuf
Do you have any Yusuf socials ?
Aqeedah of Ahlus Sunnah in regards to the names and attributes of Allah (the prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم and his companions رضي الله عنهم اجمعين):
-Affirm for Allah what he attributes to himself in the Qur’an and authentic Sunnah in a way that befits His majesty.
In the following way:
-Don’t resemble the attributes to anything as there is nothing like Allah.
“There is nothing like Him: He is the All Hearing, the All Seeing.” (42:11)
-Don’t Distort/change or specify about the attributes what Allah hasn’t.
-Don’t ask how the attribute exactly is (as no one has ever seen Allah).
-Don’t negate/reject the attributes of Allah.
They made not a just estimate of Allah as is due to Him. And on the Day of Resurrection, the whole of the earth will be grasped by His Hand and the heavens will be rolled up in His Right Hand. Exalted is He, free of all imperfections, High above all that they associate as partners with Him.’ (Surah Az-Zumar: 67)
“And the Jews say, ‘The hand of Allah is tied up.’ Chained are their hands, and cursed are they for what they say. Rather, both His Hands are extended, He spends however He wills…” (Al-Mā’idah: 64)
“[Allah] said, ‘O Iblees, what prevented you from prostrating to that which I created with My hands? Were you arrogant [then], or were you [already] among the haughty?’” [Saad 38:75].
“(Remember) the Day when the Shin shall be laid bare (i.e. the Day of Resurrection) and they shall be called to prostrate themselves (to Allâh), but they (hypocrites) shall not be able to do so.” (68:42)
“And the Face of your Lord full of Majesty and Honour will abide forever.”
(55:27)
“And I endued you with love from Me, in order that you may be brought up under My Eye” (20:39)
“Floating under Our Eyes, a reward for him who had been rejected!” (54:14)
“Everything will perish except His Face.” (28:88)
Side point: The Hadith About 2 Right Hands:
"And both of His hands are right (يَمِينٌ) hands."
Sunan an-Nasa'i 5379
The word يَمِينٌ/ يُمنا comes from the word, Blessed = تَيَمُّن, this Hadith is talking about how Allah’s hands are blessed. Simple. The Arab’s in the time of the Prophet used to believe the left hand was cursed.
Salafi’s do not believe that the hands of Allah are organs at the end of the forelimb of certain vertebrates that exhibits great mobility and flexibility in the digits and in the whole organ. It is made up of the wrist joint, the carpal bones, the metacarpal bones, and the phalanges.
Salafi’s don’t believe the shin of Allah mentioned in the Qur’an is the front part of the leg below the knee.
Salafi’s don’t believe the eye which Allah mentions about himself in the Qur’an is made up of three coats, which enclose the optically clear aqueous humour, lens, and vitreous body. The outermost coat consists of the cornea and the sclera; the middle coat contains the main blood supply to the eye and consists, from the back forward, of the choroid, the ciliary body, and the iris.
These are human attributes ^. Allah’s attributes are not like ours. They befit His majesty.
"And there is none co-equal or comparable unto Him." (112:4)
“And (all) the Most Beautiful Names belong to Allâh, so call on Him by them, and leave the company of those who belie or deny (or utter impious speech against) His Names. They will be requited for what they used to do.” (7:180)
You erred. Stop at the verses and leave it as that. Don't go too deep.
At the same time don't always take the attributes literally.
@@blackflag6976 no, we take them literally. In a way that befits Allah SWT. We don’t use metaphors.
@@a.d2019 No, that's a Bid'ah. I don't know where you get the idea that we should take the attributes literally.
The literal meaning of hand is a limb ie. Something attached to a body.
@@a.d2019 So he has hands but does not have hands?
That is making a category error:
The quran claims hands, but allah has an abstract notion of hands, and the concrete thing and its abstraction are not identical, so it is wrong semantics.
I love you allah
Allah doesn't love you.
Dragon Star Allah loves everyone
Abbas Al Allah doesn't love the oppressors
@@dragonstar4770 dear brother, why would anyone of us speak about the love from Allah sounhanahoe wa ta’ala to an individual where it is for us unknown how Allah feels towards this individual specifically, I advise myself and all my brothers to not fill in what we do not know and He is all knowing, may He forgive us
@@Hustle_prodigy1 You need to read your Quran before you make a comment like that.
Surah ikhlas
In the name of Allah, Most Gracious, Most Merciful.
Say: He is Allah, the One and Only;
Allah, the Eternal, Absolute;
He begetteth not, nor is He begotten;
And there is none like unto Him.
What you think of Allah is not him.
You have to understand the arabic language and culture to anderstand what Allah means in quran.
1. Your hands are tied = you are stingy
2. I take My hands away from you = i take My protection from you
3. When your Mother says Come eat food, and you say No, and she repond i have made it with My both hands = its me Who made the food
Etc. Etc.
Like when Allah says hes on hes arsh/throne.
Throne symbolizes power
So if someone ask Who sits on the throne? they do not ask for the chair they mean Who is in power.
So when quran say Allah is on arsh does not mean he sit on an chair it means Allah is in power.
I love you my brother shamsi, but for sake of islam and dawah inshallah this Will help you on way from a sincere brother 👍
Sorry english is My second language i hope you understand what i mean 😊
Subhanallah you're disrespecting the Attributes of Allah, which He describes himself in his Book and which we know from the Sunnah of the Messenger s.a.w.
Please follow the Athari Aqeedah and not the Asharia.
We don't make any interpretation, so it can fit in your mind.
The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "On the Day of Resurrection Allah will hold the whole earth and fold the heaven with His right hand and say, 'I am the King: where are the kings of the earth?" '
حَدَّثَنَا أَحْمَدُ بْنُ صَالِحٍ، حَدَّثَنَا ابْنُ وَهْبٍ، أَخْبَرَنِي يُونُسُ، عَنِ ابْنِ شِهَابٍ، عَنْ سَعِيدٍ، عَنْ أَبِي هُرَيْرَةَ، عَنِ النَّبِيِّ صلى الله عليه وسلم قَالَ " يَقْبِضُ اللَّهُ الأَرْضَ يَوْمَ الْقِيَامَةِ، وَيَطْوِي السَّمَاءَ بِيَمِينِهِ ثُمَّ يَقُولُ أَنَا الْمَلِكُ أَيْنَ مُلُوكُ الأَرْضِ ". وَقَالَ شُعَيْبٌ وَالزُّبَيْدِيُّ وَابْنُ مُسَافِرٍ وَإِسْحَاقُ بْنُ يَحْيَى عَنِ الزُّهْرِيِّ عَنْ أَبِي سَلَمَةَ.
Reference : Sahih al-Bukhari 7382In-book reference : Book 97, Hadith 12USC-MSA web (English) reference : Vol. 9, Book 93, Hadith 479 (deprecated numbering scheme)
So whats you explanation now?
Go back to Sunnah and accept everything!!!!
when a man asked Imam Malik about the meaning of Quran 20:5, "The Merciful established Himself over the Throne," it is related that "nothing affected Imam Malik so much as that man's question," and the jurist fervently responded: "The 'how' of it is inconceivable; the 'establishment' part of it is known; belief in it is obligatory; asking about it is an innovation
@@3-Kashmir
Thats my aqeedah. Imam malik is amazing ma sha Allah
With all due respect you are incorrect brother Malik Kav. try your best to not interpret the statements of Allah yourself and mistransposing attributes that are not affirmed and get lost into symbolism. this is how sufis gets deviated.
@@Kekekfkkekrkrke Saying Allah has a litteral hand makes it fit in my mind. You cannot not have it both ways. I take whatever meaning is more powerful. Allah having a hand is not powerful, it's a attribute of a human.
That one time I saw Shamsi out of ammunition. Because what he's defending is not his but his elders'.
Brother Shamsi. You're quite knowledgeable. But do not justify your elders in manhaj if they seem to have misunderstood something. A hand is a hand and is a limb. The use of the word in Quran is just a metaphor. We cannot imagine the Being of Allah in any way.
It’s not a metaphor. If you tell me that is a metaphor, you’re giving the kuffar the playground to play with the Qur’an. Because why can’t different things be metaphorical? If Allah SWT tells us something we take it as it is, who are you to tell classified scholars who’ve spent more years learning than you have been living that “they have misunderstood something but you have got it right”. We affirm what Allah swt affirms for himself without asking how, without distorting the meaning (what you did by saying it’s a metaphor). And last but not least without liking it to the creation.(in a way that befits his majesty).
@@a.d2019 جزاک اللہ خیرا
It is not metaphor...!
It is true hand
The way befits his majesty “allah”
When you say metaphor, you just disable the meaning of the word. This is against the salaf aqeedah.
Say it is a true hand the way befits allah majesty
Without disable or distortion the meaning and with out saying how...!
Cuz allah affirmed to him self that,
@@hamzahalharbi4566 exactly my brother, people often try to say “Allah is saying hand but it means power” but why did Allah SWT create iblis with his power in the Quran? Why didn’t he use the same word for Adam alayhi salam. So if people say it’s metaphor their just contradicting themselves.
@@a.d2019 The Qur'an was revealed in Arabic: إِنَّا أَنزَلْنَاهُ قُرْآنًا عَرَبِيًّا
And each Prophet was sent with the language of its people:
وَمَا أَرْسَلْنَا مِن رَّسُولٍ إِلَّا بِلِسَانِ قَوْمِهِ
The Prophet Muhammad was also an Arab .
And Arabic is a beautiful language - full of figurative speech.
There are literally 1000's of examples - I'll give 10 examples - 5 from Qur'an :
1- Did the Prophet have "WINGS"?
وَاخْفِضْ جَنَاحَكَ لِلْمُؤْمِنِينَ
"And lower your wing to the believers." (15:88).
Meaning: humble yourself.
2- Do walls have a "WILL"?
فَوَجَدَا فِيهَا جِدَارًا يُرِيدُ أَن يَنقَضَّ
"Then they found in it a wall (that) want(ed) to collapse." (18:77).
Meaning: that was about to collapse.
3- Can you ask a "TOWN" - can a town talk?
وَاسْأَلِ الْقَرْيَةَ
"And ask the town." (12:82).
Meaning: ask the people of the town.
4- Was there a "KNOT" in the tongue of Moses"?
وَاحْلُلْ عُقْدَةً مِّن لِّسَانِي
"And untie the knot from my tongue." (20:27).
Meaning: remove my speech impediment.
5- Holding "FIRMLY" to the Book:
يَا يَحْيَىٰ خُذِ الْكِتَابَ بِقُوَّةٍ
"O Yahya, hold firmly to the Book." (19:12).
Meaning: stick to it's rules and guidance.
It is sufficient for the believer to accept & believe whatever Allah has said about himself without going deep into the verses of the Muthashabihat (verses in which only Allah knows the true meaning). However the Hizbis (those with a Cult mentality) have created their own set of principles of beliefs which they term as "Aqeedah" which they use to divide & attack the rest of the Ummah. These beliefs are based solely upon theological differences of opinion amongst the Scholars, which are not necessary for the lay person to delve deeply into because they are differences of opinion based upon on the verses of the Muthashabihat. They deem anyone who does not believe in the same theological beliefs of their scholars regarding these verses of Muthashabihat that they are out of the fold of Islam. SubhanAllah.
They call themselves big words like "People of Sunnah" & handpick certain Hadith with which they use to create divisions but ignore those that call for mercy & unity solely because they differ on the opinion of the scholars they follow on the verses of the Muthashabihat.
Wake up oh Ummah. These are the very people who are silent about the mass slaughter & forced starvation of Muslims in Yemen by the treacherous regime whom they blindly defend even though they have clearly sided with the disbelievers in unjustly slaughtering innocent Muslims. The very people who are silent about the regime they defend who are inviting evil practices and fitnah to spread across the holy lands. These very people proclaim to be of the people of the "Sunnah" & that they follow the way of the "Salaf". The true people of Sunnah & the Salaf would never behave as they do. It is easy to claim such things but the reality is very far from the truth.
You only have to see the way these people behave in their arrogant and harsh approach towards others & are highly intolerant to valid differences of opinion amongst the scholars. They make it a habit to attack other Muslims including scholars & their tongues are very sharp when it comes to making Takfir upon another believer.
They have made theological differences of opinion of the scholars regarding verses of Muthashabihat as "fundamental" aspects of Aqeedah so as to completely block & prevent unity & in order to move away from the rest of the Ummah whom they deem as being out of the fold of Ahlus Sunnah.
They have an superiority complex called Saved Sect Syndrome (SSS) and it's a very debilitating disease of the heart.
May Allah save us from those who divide the Ummah. Ameen
@b king they follow the stance of a very small number of scholars yet declare those that oppose them to be out of the Ahlus Sunnah. Then that would include the vast majority of Scholars of the past and present including the great Mujtahid Imaams and greats such as Imaam Nawawi, Ibn Hajar Al Asqalani and many many more.
Oh Ummah do not be deceived by their following "Qur'an and Sunnah" and following the "Salaf" rhetoric. It's just a way to attract the ignorant towards their hizbi sect.
Why are you promoting bid’ah?
@@Salafiyahisthehaqq where is he promoting bidha?
@@inspirationalguy81 we need to stick to QURAN nad sunnah.
@@cublucublu1314uniting upon falsehood is a bidah and one that calls to it is upon misguidance.
Salam, wich website is he speaking about at the end please? Salam
Not iblees he meant ADAM
Allah Taala Allah loves all peoples in around the earth and the world allah bless all the time allah always allah all the time
Elenna Brown I think you are absolutely wrong that Allah loves all peoples as written in the Qur'an
Qur’an 30:43-45-Then turn thy face straight to the right religion before there come from Allah the day which cannot be averted; on that day they shall become separated. Whoever disbelieves, he shall be responsible for his disbelief, and whoever does good, they prepare (good) for their own souls, that He may reward those who believe and do good out of His grace; surely He does NOT LOVE the unbelievers.
@@tesfekidan if jesus loves non believers why will they go to hell?
Yousaf 👍
Not EVERYTHING in Quran is to be pondered upon. For example Yaseen. So indulging in getting into fruitless pondering is waste of time. If you understand the spirit of the Ayah where the word Yadd is used just leave it at that. Don't become like those mentioned in the incident of the cow asking stupid things about the color age n all the stupid thing about the sacrificial animal. Deen is about common sense as mentioned in Surah Ash-Shams.
He avoided when the brother said ALLAH runs towards the one who makes Tawbah
You can't conceptualize being alive in your mind but the hand you cant, being alive is a adjective and a hand is a noun. Don't come with that bullshit about contradictions. Hearing and being alive is the same in not giving pictures in our mind, but the hands and other humanlike features, come on brothers, why don't you open you mind.
Man, the Salafis are bluffs. As long as the Riyals keep coming, we will still be in this circular limpo. How come shamsi once refuse taawil then accept it the 2nd time?
U approve tawil when you like and refuse it when you do not like? What kinda methodology is this? Who other than Ibn Taiymiha did this classification?
One day the Riyals will stopped coming and will finally see the end if Wahabis
If anybody believes that Allah has body parts then even if je says that its not like human steel he is misguided. Read Aqida tut Tahawi for Authentic Aqida or creed of our Salaf, I mean Ahle Sunnah wal Jamah. Sa'ad Ibne Harun from Bangladesh 🇧🇩
no-one talks about body parts, it talks about hands.
I have seen this brother asking the same questions To Mohammad Hizab and Adnan Rashid also. So clearly he has this agenda. Now we can clearly see in this video how Brother Shamsi is answering his questions and his face expression is like he is burning inside because shamsi has benn answering all his questions and he doesn't have anything to say
Salafis tend to attribute direction, movement, place and other unbefitting impossibilities for Allāh
Ahlus Sunnah Wal Jammah accept the verses from the Quran and the statements of the Prophet [peace be upon him] how they were intended and we leave the meaning of them to Allāh. This is why it’s important to understand the verses and act on how Ulema of the past spoke about them. They negated Allāh being in a literal direction. They also negated place and movement for Allāh. We already have statements of the ulema of the past so modern day interpretations of Allāh being confined to a location/direction/place are not to be accepted.
Ibn In al-Jawzi-may
Allah ta’Ala have mercy upon him-said:
"whoever says 'He rose with His Essence' has made Him [Allah) the object of sense perception."
[Dafa Shubh al-Tashbih, p. 102.]
Al-Hafiz al-Dhahabi said in his book Al- Uluw, after citing the
statement of Yahya b. 'Ammar:
"Nay, we say that He is, with His
Essence, above the Throne and His knowledge encompasses everything":
"Your statement with His Essence
is from your own bag"'
[Al ‘Uluw p263]
imam Badr al-Din b. Jama'a- may Allah have mercy upon him-
said:
Whoever believes that the [ISTAWA] with respect to Him [Allah], the Exalted, is understood like the qualities of the contingent beings and says: "He rose with His
Essence" or says: "He rose in reality [haqiqatan]," then he has innovated this extraneous expression that is neither
affirmed in the Sunna nor reported from any of the Imams that are followed.
[īdah -al Dalīl p107]
Imam ibn' Abd al-Barr - may Allah have mercy upon him-said
"And a group ascribed to the sunna said that He, the Exalted descends with His Essence! This statement is rejected, because He, Exalted is His mention, is not a locus for movement and He
has nothing from the signs (characteristics) of the creation."
[Al-Istidhkar, 8:153]
He also said in his refutation against someone who said that “ He
descends with His Essence”
"This is rejected Llaysa bi-shayin]
according to the people of understanding among Ahl al-Sunna because it is a modality [kayfiyya], and they flee from that because
it is only suitable for something that is directly encompassed, and Allah, the Exalted, is transcendent above that.
[Al-Tamhid,7:143.]
Imam ‘Ali ibn Abi Taalib رضي الله عنه is reported to have said
,
كان- الله- ولا مكان، وهو الان على ما- عليه- كان
,
“Allah was without place, and He is now as He was [then].” ((الفرق بين الفرق لأبي منصور البغدادي [ ص / 333 ] ))
Imam Ahmad Ibn Salamah, Abu Ja^far at-Tahawiyy, who was born in the year 237 after Hijrah, wrote a very famous book called al-^Aqidah at-Tahawiyyah. He mentioned that the content of his book is an explantion of the creed of Ahlus-Sunnah wal Jama^ah, which is the creed of Imam Abu Hanifah, who died in the year 150 after Hijrah, and his two companions, Imam Abu Yusuf al-Qadi and Imam Muhammad Ibn al-Hasan ash-Shaybaniyy and others. He said in his book:
قال الإمامُ أَبو جَعْفَرِ الطَّحَاوِىُّ السَّلَفىُّ: "تَعَالى عن الحُدُودِ والغَاياتِ والأَركانِ والأَعضَاء والأَدَوَاتِ. لا تَحوِيهِ الجِهَاتُ السّتُّ كَسَائِرِ المُبْتَدَعَاتِ".
which means: > Such is the saying of Imam Abu Ja^far who is among the heads of Salaf. Abu Ja^far explicitly stated that Allah is clear of being contained by the six directions. The six directions are above, below, ahead, behind, right, and left.
Qadi Abu Ya’la al-Hanbali says, “Indeed, Allah Most High is not to be described with [residing in a] place.” (Daf’ Shubah al-Tashbih, P: 43)
Also the great Mufassir Ibn al-Jawziy al-Hanbaliy said in his book "Daf^ Shubah at-Tashbih" page 58: "The obligation upon us is to believe that the self of Allah ta^ala is not contained in a place, and He is not attributed with change nor movement".
- And Ibn al-Jawziy also said: "Some people lied when they heard about the Sifat (attributes of Allah) and interpreted them according to the physical meanings, such as those who claimed that Allah literally descends from the sky and moves from one place to another. This is an ill understanding, because the one who moves would be from a place to a place, and that necessitates that the place is bigger than him and that requires movement, and all of that is impossible to be attributed to Allah the Exalted
Also, Salafis tend to state they know what “Yad” means and they say it means “hand”, but when asked, “What does [“hand”] mean?” They get stumbled and contradict themselves by stating they know the meaning but cant even answer what is meaning themselves.
When one understands and contemplate that in reality, we do not know what Yad means. If one say it means “hand”. You have two options
1. Saying “I don’t know what hand means.”
2. You state that Allāh has hands like His creation but they don’t look like His creation.
The second is blasphemous because one resembling Allāh to His creation by giving him the same meanings as His creation. Basically one would be stating “Allāh has a hand like ours but it doesn’t look like ours” this is kufr.
That’s why it’s important to think about what one believes in.
Ahlus Sunnah wal Jammah believe in all of Allah’s attributes without resemblance or likeness to His creation. When it comes to attributes such as Yad, we leave the meaning to Allāh. This is Tafwīd Al-ma’na. We do not state Yad means this or that because one would give a meaning that in reality they don’t even know. Such as how Salafis can’t say what “hand” means without defining it in a way that resembles the creation.
I care about you and hopefully this opens your eyes in shaa’Allah
Salafis give a direction to Allah? We say that Allah swt is above his arsh and the arsh is above the 7 heavens. We don’t give a literal direction to Allah swt. From a Hadith we know that there’s is 500 years of travel time between each heaven. At what speed one might ask? Allaho3alem. And also a Hadith where a woman came to the messenger of Allah and the prophet saw said to her where is Allah? She pointed up and said above the heavens. The prophet replied who am I? She said you’re the messenger of Allah. And then the prophet saw said “grant her freedom, as she is a believing woman”. So it’s clear that Allah swt is above the creation. How and where exactly? We can’t ask. Because that’s of the unseen and only belongs to Allah. Jazzakallahu khayran.
@@a.d2019 if you mean above as Exaltation and not direction then that’s fine. If you mean above as literally above with direction then that’s invalid. Many Salafis claims above means direction and place.
Regarding the Slave Girl Hadith, read the commentary on it. It wasn’t to prove direction or place. You can read from Qadi Iyad on the matter as a source.
In the Arabic language “ayna” can relate to rank.
I honestly feel like there’s a disconnect from the interpretation of people today and ulema of the past.
Imam Abu Mansur al-Baghdadiyy said in his book, Al-Farqu Bayn alFiraq page 333:
قال الإمام أبو منصور البغدادي (429 هـ) في الفرق بين الفرق صفحة 333: "وأجمعوا (أهل السنة) على أن الله لا يحويه مكان ولا يجري عليه زمان. وقد قال الامام علي رضي الله عنه (كان- الله- ولا مكان، وهو الان على ما -عليه- كان اهـ. أي بلا مكان. وقال: "إن الله تعالى خلق العرش إظهارًا لقدرته لا مكانا لذاته"
Which means: "They (AhluSunnah) unanimously agreed that Allah is not contained in a place and that time does not lapse on Him. Contrary to what the Hishamiyah and Karramiyah (Groups that liken Allah to the creations) claimed that Allah is touching (or sitting on) the throne. Imam Aliy said: "Allah existed eternally and there was no place & He now is as He was; without a place. "He created the Arsh indicating His power, not to sit on it".
Imam Abu Mansur al-Baghdadiyy related in his book, Al-Farqu Baynal-Firaq, that Imam ^Aliyy, the fourth of the caliphs, may Allah reward his deeds, said:
نقل الإمامُ أبو منصور البغدادىُّ في كتابه "الفَرْقُ بينَ الفِرَقِ" أن الإمامَ علىَّ بنَ أبِى طالب رضى الله عنه قال: "كان الله ولا مكان، وهو الآن على ما عليه كان".
which means: >
Imam Hafidh al-Bayhaqiyy said in his book, Al-Asma'u was-Sifat, on page 400: Al-Bayhaqiyy also said:
@@ReturningRuh you’re quoting me some imams when I quote you ahadith and verses… by saying that Allah swt is above the creation and above his throne. Does not mean that he’s in a specific place above the creation. Because we’re talking about the unseen here. So to even say that you have “places” above the 7 heavens is nonsensical. And I will not argue with the people of desires because the fact you mentioned the name “wahabi” tells me enough about you’re aqeedah. Because if you would follow the ahlul sunnah. And the way of the Sahabah and the salaf. You would not name anyone a wahabi. And I would never take any information from a Sufi regarding Islamic matters. May Allah guide me and you.
@@a.d2019 I notice he hasn’t even read most of the stuff he’s quoting properly. Adh-Dhahābī was not against affirming literal Uluww of Allāh, he was just saying “He is above His Throne” does not need the addition “In His Essence”, not that He disagreed with it.
And I wonder why he can’t quote any of the Quran, Sunnah or the Salaf on this issue, May Allāh guide us.
@@hoseno854 Sorry for the late response, Allahuma barek. Yeah I’ve noticed that aswel. Just wasn’t bothered to type down entire essay’s 😅.
May Allah guide Br Yusuf. He claims to be a Zaidi
@abdul sharif looking forward for the video proof
Agree he says he's Zaidi
Yusuf is talking about the physical you gave examples of attributes.
Two different things....
What is your point?
Do you even know what attributes are?
Allah is not abstract. He is a living thing. Nothing like him no one know his essence but we know his attributes
no, there's asmaa wa sifaat, names and attributes. Muslims shouldn't speak about physical things when we talk about Allah most High. The understanding is that Allah has attributes and the attributes are not metaphors or comparable to the physical things, parts, etc of created beings. Allah is unique and indivisible.
Are Majorities of muslims is Ashhari's currently? I really want to know
Majority of muslims don't know these terms to begin with.
Allah can hear and we can hear but allah dont need ears to hear
The true salaf have gone may Allah swt be pleased with them
Can somebody tell me why make takwil? I don't get it
Anyone who believes God has physical hand is mushriq because matter is confined to a location.. That means God is confined to a location. This is the aqeeda of salafi(those who accuse all others to b mushriq) are themselves as mushriq
Did you watch the video?
Did he say alif laam mim is only huruuf?
This salafi aqidah is new, started after Jaad bin Durham...and ibn taimiya...and so forth...they can't trace the history of this aqidah older than this, O shamsi may Allah guide you on the right path, you are better than what you are..seek the truth
@Freedom fighter Nice way your father taught you to speak...."shut up" "ignorant"...what more from the salafi dictionary did he teach you?...Now again if you have a little shame don't attribute this style of speach to our Prophet ﷺ
@Ismail Saleh Brother I am not here for hatred...I only talk to people if discussion goes friendly...
I am from ahlussunnah Wal jamaaAh..I need to understand here...when you say Aqidah, what do you mean?..you mean Mazhab or my Aqidah regarding some specific thing?
@Ismail Saleh hanafi ...and I don't believe in taqleed in the subject of Aqeedah..
Karwan adab you speak like a Shia
@@mountainleopard5370 How do I speak to you brother, first you would have to study about Imam Abu Hanifa رحمة الله عليه...
So Allah swt has a literal SHIN but unlike the shin of Muhammad pbuh who Allah swt created ...The shin of Allah is real but in the way it befits Him!
This is a lie!
Do you even understand what has been said! THERE IS NONE LIKE ALLAH DO YOU DENY HIS ATTRIBUTES?
@@alexandriarona2299 The one who has light ....Erm we know from your pea brain what is not a shin of Allah swt.So what is a shin of Allah swt?
Alexandria Rona ye so why say Allah has a shin but not like ours? Of course Allah isn't like us but why the names? It's metaphors
هل خلق الله عز وجل إبليس بيده ؟ 4:50 min
شمسي راجع نفسك
15:30 "are you hayy? " xD
@@agadirand4four347 I mean that phrase is usually used by the authorities
Does aschari say that ALLAH has hands?
No we stick to the Arabic and Say Allah has a Yadh. We stick to the arabic. Because translating it to english will cause people to believe Allah is like a human
But asharis will gladly translate hayy (alive) and not distort and translate into English what hypocrisy and double standards
@@Randomhandlename It's noy Hay it's Al Hay which is Ever Living.
@@brace_yourself thank you for your correction my point still stands
@@brace_yourself Allah is alive and we are alive but asharis will gladly say Allah being alive means him being alive bunch of hypocrites
There is no Ayat where Allah says, that He has Hands.
You should not make such claims on the Book Of Allah S.W.T when you dont know, Surah Saad verse 75
قَالَ يَٰٓإِبْلِيسُ مَا مَنَعَكَ أَن تَسْجُدَ لِمَا خَلَقْتُ بِيَدَىَّ ۖ أَسْتَكْبَرْتَ أَمْ كُنتَ مِنَ ٱلْعَالِينَ
[Allah] said, "O Iblees, what prevented you from prostrating to that which I created with My hands? Were you arrogant [then], or were you [already] among the haughty?"
@@mohammedaziz962 show me an Ayat, where Allah says, he has hands.
@@istanbul3874 You are right brother, there is no Ayat, since the word has more than 1 meaning.
@@mohammedaziz962 Wrong translation, the word has more than one meaning. Now bring a verse which says that Allah has hands.
@@step6660 Yes Brother, your point is right, but even if you take every Word in the Quran literally (which would be Wrong, because it contradicts the generell laws of speech), there is no Ayat, where Allah says, I have Hands.
Does Yusuf have a channel
What is more powerful, that the hand means his power or that it means a literal hand? So if Shamsi met Allah, would he recognize it as a hand?
3:56 😂 Ali dawah. Shamsi gets so triggered when he hears that name. 😂
If you want to understand the logic of Muatazalah, Ashariah,Rafidah... etc. just watch and listen to this thug.. ofcourse not Shamsi
Athari Creed
Your contradicting your self shamsi you say the hearing of Allah is not literal to ours as we know it but yet the whole argument is we do not know what Allah Subhanattawalah looks like but you a firm a feature referencing the Quran we’re we are told we cannot even imagine Allah my bro these are the mistakes of your scholars you salafi must accept as all humans make mistakes please wake up and wash your face in cold water
That white guy is trolling.
I think he's Iraqi
Pseudo salafi aqeedah is different than imam ahmed bin hanbal aqeedah
Elaborate?
What is shamsi whatsapp
Shamsi is scared this Yusuf is full of truth questions , ,if you allow him to engage to shamsi, the truth will exposed.
How u know that??
Örjan Karlsson look at the video in shamsi channel
Trust me when I say shamsi has more knowledge. Yusuf is a zaidi and he states that. Shamsi is more educated in Quran. U see Yusuf can’t give a definition of the ayat that shamsi is defining. Yusuf won’t take the ayat as it’s explained. Yusuf is complicating Islam. Talking about old and new fus7a
@@Abu-Yazid22 that white guy is trolling and being provocative.
Screwup fora name, shhhhhhhh
This young man asking same question all the time wondering why ?
I believe he is a clever man and he is sincere and he is trying hard to prove his Aqeeda right to feel comfortable about his zaidi faith, I believe one day he will give up and follow sunnah and salaf.
Yeah some people on the park called him Ma'na boy, either he's stubborn-struggling to learn about the truth or he wanted to find something else just pray for him may Allah granted taufeeq and hidayah for all of us.
Yusuf has revealed last week he is a zaydi shia
@Mohammad Mughal watch vid with him and mo deen talking to hijab
Exactly.
This brother shamsi is extremely mis guided, trying to compare Allah subhanwatalah to humans... the living of human is they will die, Allah lives and will never die... go back to surah iklaas, simple! Nothing is like Him, the science of aqeedah came into place to protect people from these thoughts. If you try to imagine Allah subhanwatalah , just remember He is nothing of what you can imagine.. wait until we enter paradise InshaAllah and we will see the Almighty InshaAllah
Your misguided, Allah himself said he has two hands which is of course unlike he's creation
@@iimiboy then the hands become a metaphor,
Not a literal hands. Unless you don't understand the meaning of words.
Not metaphorical hands
Otherwise Iblees would've replied to Allah swt and said: and you Allah as well created me by your hands. So saying the hands are power or ability or.... any metaphorical explanation will not be right. As Allah swt created with his hands only Adam out of all the humanity, the jinn and the angels. Allah has hands as he and his messenger SAAWS both affirmed... we don't know how but we have to believe that he has 2 hands but nothing like him.
To make it easy to understand if I say that I've seen an alien looks like octobus with hands so directly people imagine that the alien hands are not like ours...
And this is with something is created... so what about the creator that nothing like him and whatever you imagine he is not like what's in your imagination.
Allah swt said that he has 2 hands so we believe him and his messenger and we don't have to know how...
This same guy went to Mohammed hijab loaded with the same question and look at the difference between him and Shamsi .. clear evidence vs distorted tangent from Mohammed hijab
1spiders1 by Allah shamsi was clear as day, and hijab made me feel like I didn’t know anything about Islam. But I like hijab, but this explanation by Allah a baby can understand, may Allah give us understanding
Zaba Khan yes hijab is a good brother may Allah keep him upright, the problem with Hijab is that he is all over the place. This excessive philosophy, Ibn Taymia likened the pursuit of philosophy to climbing a very tall and difficult mountain in order to obtain some camels meat. Its considered pointless. Also this Fat Boy his intention is to cause doubt and spread his false understanding, shamsi never gave him a chance or a platform. Also problem nowa days is people just want followers and numbers and they are willing to accommodate all sorts of nonsense in order to achieve this and increase their social media.
1spiders1 he actually became a salafi after this conservation, he mentioned on his Twitter
Can Allah "hear" the dumb? Yes of course. یوسف is right in saying He hears but not the way we hear. The human language cannot encompass Allah's صفات. But to make us fools understand He has to use our language which is insufficient when it comes to envisage Allah. So as mentioned in Quran, He has no semblance of anything we poor humans can attribute to Him. So just leave this useless discussion and concentrate on Tableegh and self improvement
Yusuf is a troll 😁
Shia in Sunni clothing - me thinks.
Ashari is Ahlusunnah
Youssef*
@LTS What is ahlul bidah ?
بارك الله فيك شمسي .
@Samir Dizco صوفي من قبل
@Samir Dizco أعوذ بالله منك يا مارق
Ismael سبحان الله اصبح مارق في كلمتين 😂
Bin uthaymeen aqeedah is different than imam ahmed bin hanbal
No it isn’t
@@Shathrwan that’s completely false. This word limb is never used! Tad does not mean limb!
The Aqeedah of Imam Ahmad Rahimahullah is the same as Shiekh Uthaymeen Rahimahullah.
He was a well known athari, do you think I haven’t read Usool us Sunnah!
He has a book called rad ‘alaa al-jahmiyyah, if you had even read these books or even better understood them! Then you would know that what you are saying is a lie!
Show me a single place where Sheikh Uthaymeen Rahimahullah said the word, أعضاء and attached this to Allah!
@@Shathrwan hahaha
@@Shathrwan I laughed at how you wish to debate me. You think the religion is about debates?
And public debates? Really?
This type of debating the deen of Allah is not praiseworthy.
As mentioned by Imam Ahmad Rahimahullah in his Usool us Sunnah, have you not read his book?
Also I am still waiting for you to provide a reference where Sheikh Uthaymeen Rahimahullah believed Allah has limbs. Audhubillah min Dhaalik!
Show me, affirming Hands for Allah does not means limbs, Yad does not mean Limb!
Show me from the books of the Shiekh where he said this!
Also you don’t know my level so don’t assume, I might have to start quoting some narrations from the Messenger SullAllahu alayhi wassalam very soon if you carry on whining, also Ibn Abbas and Abdullah Ibn Masood RadiyAllahu’anhuma!
I wonder if you will start accusing them of tajsim as well!
@@Shathrwan you don’t know my level and you don’t know my age, therefore don’t speak upon matters that are ‘ilm ul ghayb to you.
Oh yeah, you do that with Allah so how can I expect you not to do it with me.
I don’t debate in an unpraiseworthy fashion ad I follow the aqeedah of Imam Ahmad Rahimahullah .
اكمل الآية...والراسخون في العلم ............شمسي انت تتكلم عن جهل ....
Sometimes more intellectual one becomes the dumber he becomes. Simple principles regarding Allah's Attributes cannot be understood by them. Not saying Yusuf is dumb as I hope he is sincere in his questions. But hardcore Ashari's, you can't tell them anything. Even their own school of aqeedah went through a change.
That was somewhat not true. Ashari came from mu'tazilah but is a creed of the Ahlusunnah since it doesn't deviate from Allah's attributes
@@mikailshakes4514 what do you mean came from mu’tazila? From my understanding imam ashari ra repented from mu’tazila. And the ashari creed came about combating the mu’tazila intellectually
@@Mrcontrolfreak21 Imam Ashari was a mu'tazila at one point, that's what I mean
@@mikailshakes4514 yeah but aschari refuted the mutazilla. And i have another question: does the aschari say that ALLAH has hands
Wahabi will crush salami Islam
What does matnah mean
Do you mean the word (Maanah) (المعنى) or the Q they asked meaning of Yad Allah ?
ma'na = meaning
Yusuf needs to learn more about ahlou sounnah aquida( ashâirah wal matourîdiyyah). The ambiguities of shamsi are easy to refute. I really want to debate with him. Can someone tell me where shamsi is?
One of the ambiguities of shamsi is to say a false analogy by saying if Allah exists. The meaning of existence of Allah is different to our existence meaning.
Look at the difference, Allah exists without first and end, without a body, without soul etc and our existence is based of first and end, body, soul, body parts etc. So the meaning is totally different.
It’s very simple to understand.
The ulamah of tawhid have specified that the ressemblance in the words doesn’t imply the resemblance in the meaning, this rule is applied to all languages.
I really want to debate with shamsi and in front of yusuf if possible incha Allah.
How was Shamsi created? There was a physical cause by his parents.
In regards to Adam pbuh there was no physical cause.
Shamsi say literal real Hands of Allah swt were used. Allah swt is in need of Hands. May Allah swt guide this fitna
Allah does not need anything
But we have to affirm what Allah swt affirm to himself...
He has hands that befit his majesty, not like our hands or any hand you can imagine....
it's not up to us brother to pick and choose the attributes of Allah swt
@@saeedarab74 It's not affirmation by Allah but words. Hands is a word. No words can ever describe Allah swt. The Throne of Allah is a Throne that we can never imagine so it's just a word.
@@malhamaulkubra4437
Merciful, God, great are words and they do describe Allah swt
Allah in the quran said that he created Adam with his two hands. Do you believe what Allah said....
Of course you do...
He had an agenda and failed trying to confuse SHAMSI.....
Shamsi you are wrong
wahabi believe that Allah subhanahu wata'ala like makhluq has hand, face etc
@Kenān Abū Omar owning but not the same hand
Wahabi Anthrophormorphism. To believe Allah resembles his creation is shirk and not the belief of a Muslim
Allah lives, we live also. Does this mean Allah is like creation? No.
Allah sees, we see also. Does this mean Allah is like creation? No.
Allah says:
و السماوات مطويّات بيمينه
And the heavens, he will roll in his right hand.
Does this mean he will roll the heavens in his might/power? No. In his hand. You can literally google search narrations whereby the Prophet ﷺ mentioning Allah’s hands.
The position of Ahlul sunnah is that Allah has hands, there is not like his hands anything from creation. Belief he has hands is wajib and questioning the howness of Allah’s hands is innovation.. what’s so difficult to understand
@@papac7940 The Ahle sunnah wa al jamaat accept all verses in the Quran. But the reason why many have left the folds of Islam is because they take these verses litrely which in a result is Idol worship. Tafsir is the most important thing. To understand the quran. And in many of the Wahabi Salafi books they liken Allah to his creation, give him direction, space etc. And this results in idol worship (Anthropomorphism).For Allah is free from creation what they ascribe to him. All examples given by Allah in the Quran in terms of hands, speech, etc are metaphorical for us to understand
@@wahabinajdislayer2487 How do Wahhabis attribute time and space to Allah ?
Which scholar said, it must ONLY be understood metaphorically.
(Verses about hand, eye..... )
@@Naatchooe The founder of the Wahabi sect Muhammad ibn Abdul Wahab Najdi al Tammimi (250 years ago) said it in his famous book Katab at Tauheed. He promoted this shirk from himself by likening Allah to his creation with many more evil statements. He is the Mujadid for the Salafi Wahabi Ahle Saud. Hence Salafis/Ahle Hadith/Deobandi such as Zakir Naik, Tariq Jameel, Mufti menk, Tauseef ur rehman and many more today adhere to his manhaj. So the root of the tree of Wahabism is Shirk. Therfore its scholar's who are its branches are promoting this. Other than Kitab at Tauheed, Ibn Taymiya who is their hero any many more corrupt are their influences. Whats in their books is absolutely shocking. #SayNOtoWahabism
@@papac7940 Allah exist, not lives fam lol.
The minhaj (Islam Iman and Ihsan) of the Salaf is not the Wahhabi minhaj (tawheed)
his muslims need to give al'lah permission to be al'lah hahahahahahahahahahahaha LOL
Wow surely God would reveal a book that is not so complicated?
@Sahibzada Haider ali It is clear you have been PLAYED by the Devil within Islam from a very young age. Once you set yourself free... you WILL be liberated from this evil ideology.
@@Prophet_Google it is clear you have no clue what you're talking about
@@issy02tubez I am sure ALLAH knows best for you... face reality the devil has poisined you from a very young age.
@@Prophet_Google what do you say about, who believe that god has died , or god can be a man, or god is 3 in 1. I think that is the teaching of the devil, if you don't believe me ,ask the jew.
@@UsmhBillalPharmb You can try to change subject will not work... face reality... which you avoid at your peril.
and because they hearkened not to the Word of God they are given over to a reprobate mind
ليس كمتله شيء
Allah is free from time and space
This statement is false
There is nothing like him’ (Surah Shura v.11)
Time and space are a creation of Allah and Allah is not in need of his creation
@@zola_moments of course no one said creation is like him he also said he is above his arsh that is a place and he also comes down to the lowest heaven at the last of part of the night that is time in the manner that befits his majesty your statement is completely false and baseless
@@Randomhandlename We are nearer to him than (his) jugular vein." 50:16
@@zola_moments yes he is in knowledge as mentioned by Allah in another verse nice try tho
My attributes are I have 2 hands one is on my left. I have 2 eyes. I have 2 shins. I have 2 feet. I have a face. I smile. I have a nafs. I know how they work but I am not their Creator. I am bound by time and space. I know how the 7 day week works. I run and walk on the ground which supports my body to do this.
Allah swt has Attributes including Foot Shin Hands etc the salafis say. They know what they are NOT. So what are they then? How can you believe in them 'literally' if you cannot understand the Hands?
Allah is Alive. Why don’t you say being alive is also of Human Nature?
Allah is all hearing and all seeing. So Allah Hears and sees. We also hear and see.
But are these comparable? These are just descriptions. Nothing is like Allah
Bro Malhama just don't get lost in assumptions and start comparing limbs.
Hear and perceive what's Allah has been affirmed with all his perfection. you don't have to assume to know and understand.
@@Pain-jw3uu Allah is ever living dumbo.
I had a life with a beginning...
@@Pain-jw3uuDo fish for example need feet? No. They do need the senses like eyes...
Do you need fins like a fish? No you need feet.
What does a fish and you have in common? Eyes... Life.... Living.
Allah is Ever Seer Ever Hearer...
Allah does not need Hands or Feet or Shin 😂
How dumb are some Muslims...
Do you claim Allah has 2 Right Hands too like these fools claim?
@@malhamaulkubra4437, that's right Allah is Al Hai Ul Qayyum.
Isa isn't Jesus Christ Jesus Christ is God Word of God come in the flesh he was crucified he died was buried and on the third day he was resurrected to eternal Glory he is Glorified in the Father Glorified in the Holy Spirit Glorified in the resurrection Glorified in His Word he Knows The Hour Of His Return👉✝️👈The resurrection and the life eternal
This is totally wrong and deviant.
17:00 Man hearing requires creation which is 2 ears. Without ears it is impossible to hear - to hear other creations the boundary swt by Allah swt for us. We need created organs to see and hear. Shamsi is a foolish creation
But does man hear?
Wobblers are lost
Yup
You are both more than welcome to the park unfortunately you won’t be able to bring your dreams as proof with you 😆
08451281 we don’t need dreams when it comes to debating so called people off the salaf by the way did allah or the
Prophet mention anything about Ibn tamiyah it why you following books from a cowboy ?
Advice to shamsi don't make up stories......there's things in the Quran no one can explain....and scholars avoid talking about them ....shamsi you should know your limits don't make fool of yourself. 😁🌷😁🌷
Freeman 19 your the fool.
@@1spiders1 you are Donkey and you think shamsi knows about Islam. He doesn't know shit, because he speaks Arabic you think he is a scholar....what a foolish clown you are....🌷
Freeman 19 can you give an example of such verses in the Quran?
@@mountainleopard5370 I hope you understand Arabic, otherwise you need to see the scholar shamsi the one who can understand Simple Arabic...
Freeman 19 you knob be quite