im not hating on her, shes good and very pretty, but she just doesn't give this naughty youngest sister vibe which the character phoebe is...shes more like innocent and soft spoken
Agreed...I watched this and the aired episode in small sections, pausing one to watch the other and Alyssa does a better job portraying many emotions in her acting and speech while Lori can only show one emotion at a time
After watching that unreleased episode with Lori Rom... Alyssa was literally born to play the role of Phoebe! that rebellious brat, careless and sexy as hell! Phoebe (Alyssa Milano) has always been my favorite character.
it was upsetting though to see alyssa telling shannen to leave the show or she will. I never wanted to see anyone leave the show. It would have been nice to do a POWER OF 4!!!
*the dynamic didn’t feel right compared with alyssa. it felt like shannon and lori were the older siblings and piper was the youngest. but with alyssa you could tell which order the sisters came in*
How in the name of all that is good in the world did Lori not know this was about witchcraft? If she had issues with it why would she even do this pilot at all? Did she read the script?
i knew that which is rlly cool and have u seen a video 6 months ago that alyssa Milano said that they might be making charmed movies on Netflix soon even though the reboot is going on.
@@charmedchannel1237 i would wish for that. the only problem with that is that the rights are owned by cw and i dont think its possible to go both ways at the same time, so we probably have to wait until the reboot is done
Not gonna lie I’m glad they replaced her Bc she does give the vibe the show needed and I feel Alyssa did. They had better chemistry tbh. This is just kinda cringe 😬
Lori did a good job with the role and analyzing and breaking down the script. The tone of her voice is very mature almost as if she was meant to play a more mature role, and she doesn't give off the, "I'm the youngest sister" vibe that Alyssa gave off as Phoebe.
They should've kept the "save your pennies" line after Phoebe said she'll pay her back. Sick burn and really solidifies how broken their relationship was in the beginning
Ugh it’s so wrong, she’s too tall and doesn’t really fit in with the other two. She doesn’t look like she could be their sister and what is with that accent she has. I’m really glad Alyssa played Phoebe
@@charmedchannel1237 I've been searching for years now but I've been unable to find the full, unaltered, episode. It's either missing a huge chunk, dubbed in Spanish for some odd reason, or it's this version with the huge banner and foreign subs. Ugh.
Don't like her as Phoebe, she would have made a brilliant Paige. The acting throughout just seemed fake and beyond forced with Paige especially compared to her other role's the actress played where she's brilliant.
This person took the time and effort to screen capture this piece of gold, and you come here, free of charge, and still complain about a watermark? Really?
No the real attic is in a house across the street and 2 Down it is owned by the same person who owns the real house someone posted a video last year of him touring the real attic. They changed the windows in the show that's about it everything else is the same besides the decorations of course
It actually does have a very small attic. You can see the windows from the side of the house. They call it a widows walk according to the owner of the house
I think Lori Rom as Phoebe Halliwell should have been the best actress to keep on this show but it's ashamed bout her leaving personal reasons and her religion.
@@rayoflight6505 she did a interview saying her and a cast mate were having issues and the show runner ruled in the other cast mate favor her and the lady who play piper were friends at the time
@@rayoflight6505 I don’t know at the time I wrote this another commenter on A video comparing the two pilot stated this and someone backed it up. So I comment that look it up I didn’t care to much to fact check it 😂😂😂😂😂
It's too bad they changed so many things from the original pilot. It was perfect. It had key scenes zat kud have changed the direction of the entire show. I mean 11:43 for example Piper looks way more freaked by the power out due to her superstitious nature. It establishes her character n it gives more room for her character. Then, her character evolution wud have taken a greater take. I mean zat's the main thing I have to say in most shows n especially Charmed zat every new idea just pops out in the episode only. Not before. But I understand that the producers wanted a greater take on their sisterhood as it's the basis but it shud have been done this way to show Prue n Phoebe's difference of thought, Piper being annoyed of being also sandwiched between these two's fights n her irrational fear due to her superstitious nature. It was the best way. Now, I don't know fr budget cuts but it sure was the best thing to do. I mean I love alyssa's more wild nature compared to Lori's more comical take on it, in particular scenes n situations but in some Alyssa's personality as Phoebe just doesn't suit the situation. Lori's part suits it best. I mean I don't know. N last I really loved the idea of Prue still not trusting Phoebe until the end where she trusts Phoebe in being able to fight Jeremy n believing in their goodness. Though it does clash with Prue's protector attitude. However, it established from the beginning zat the sisters really love each other n will do anything to protect each other. I mean everybody thinks zat Prue, Piper n Phoebe's Trio was 1 with a protector (Prue) who is always in front or centre n Piper n Phoebe being the children who need to be protected but it's not true. That part up till season 3 works fr Prue to be able to know zat Piper n Phoebe have grown mature n responsible n zat they can share the authority. She doesn't need to always take the burden all by herself. She has to start seeing her sisters as equals to her. N she does it great. This wud have established zat thought from the beginning itself. Personally I wud have loved to see Lori up till the end of the show as Phoebe but it's only my love for the old times but yeah I might have wanted to see Phoebe in particular situations but then again I don't know Lori's talents much so she might have been able to transition to Alyssa's naughty n wild nature. Zat's the problem, Lori never got to expand her talents as Phoebe so we will never know if she was a great actor or not. I love Phoebe. I'm not saying she's not great. She's awesome. It's just me. You don't have to like it. I'm just saying wat I think of it.
N then it's not even the official pilot kuz it was just done to attract the attention of the Channel. Scenes wud have been reshot, bettered, other scenes wud have been added, the acting wud have been polished n all zat. The producers wud still have a chance to give Lori the dynamics of Alyssa. I really hope that Lori did have been able to do the naughty n wild character of Phoebe. I know her Church didn't appreciate of her doing her part as a witch. I have no idea of it wud have allowed Lori to play the sexy n wild parts. Now, I pray Lori was not like not comfortable with these kind of scenes kuz maybe she wud have gone by herself even if she had no opposition from her Church. I don't know. I'm just saying. I'm scandalized.
This is a bad take. From the minute Lori walks in she has no presence and sounds like she’s reading lines not actually being the character. She sticks out like a tall awkward sore thumb.
I feel that both actresses do a very good job, and each highlight different aspects of phoebe's character. I perfer Alyssa, but the other didn't have the same dynamics or feel.
im not hating on her, shes good and very pretty, but she just doesn't give this naughty youngest sister vibe which the character phoebe is...shes more like innocent and soft spoken
Very true. She could have been a good alternative to Piper tho, if Holly wasn't around
Agreed...I watched this and the aired episode in small sections, pausing one to watch the other and Alyssa does a better job portraying many emotions in her acting and speech while Lori can only show one emotion at a time
And she definitely doesn't have Milano's T&A
After watching that unreleased episode with Lori Rom... Alyssa was literally born to play the role of Phoebe!
that rebellious brat, careless and sexy as hell!
Phoebe (Alyssa Milano) has always been my favorite character.
it was upsetting though to see alyssa telling shannen to leave the show or she will. I never wanted to see anyone leave the show. It would have been nice to do a POWER OF 4!!!
This is shockingly good quality. I wish I could find the full version of this.
love that this was filmed ini the actual house used for the exterior shots !
thanks. Most people love the unaired. But Alyssa is better.
Ahhh i was wondering why the interior looked different 😅 thanks!
*the dynamic didn’t feel right compared with alyssa. it felt like shannon and lori were the older siblings and piper was the youngest. but with alyssa you could tell which order the sisters came in*
Yeah no she wasn’t adding any chemistry to the trio
How in the name of all that is good in the world did Lori not know this was about witchcraft? If she had issues with it why would she even do this pilot at all? Did she read the script?
anyone else noticed that they filmed this pilot in the real house on the carrol ave?
i knew that which is rlly cool and have u seen a video 6 months ago that alyssa Milano said that they might be making charmed movies on Netflix soon even though the reboot is going on.
@@charmedchannel1237 i would wish for that. the only problem with that is that the rights are owned by cw and i dont think its possible to go both ways at the same time, so we probably have to wait until the reboot is done
oh nvm i didnt read the whole thing and ya that would be wrong to steal the house and put it all on cw as their own
It's cool to see inside the actual house but I prefer the one they made for the series
Not gonna lie I’m glad they replaced her Bc she does give the vibe the show needed and I feel Alyssa did. They had better chemistry tbh. This is just kinda cringe 😬
The chemistry is so cringe. I'm so glad Alyssa came into the picture. It seemed more like real sisters.
9:41 it's too bad Alyssa didn't the sarcasm right in the "please say yes" line. Lori had it right.
ya
Yeah I think Lori did a pretty good job overall. People hate on her because they're used to Alyssa.
Lori did a good job with the role and analyzing and breaking down the script. The tone of her voice is very mature almost as if she was meant to play a more mature role, and she doesn't give off the, "I'm the youngest sister" vibe that Alyssa gave off as Phoebe.
@@darrylssupershortshow8264 Even though she is in fact younger than all of the Charmed actresses. 😂
Lori could have easily have been piper and holly as Phoebe
i like this version of finding the book of shadows better than the one with alyssa
A different Andy and Pheobe? Weird!! Lol
She didn’t fit in with them Alyssa was the best choice for Phoebe
The special effects were much better here than in the aired pilot.
Fun fact, most of the special effects in this episode were used in the aired pilot.
We want see the unaired season 3 final
Agreed
what happened in that one?
One of that exsist!!? I need to see it!!
They should've kept the "save your pennies" line after Phoebe said she'll pay her back. Sick burn and really solidifies how broken their relationship was in the beginning
I’m sure she would have grown into the role given the chance.
It's so crazy, her and Alyssa sound SO similar at certain points
Ugh it’s so wrong, she’s too tall and doesn’t really fit in with the other two. She doesn’t look like she could be their sister and what is with that accent she has. I’m really glad Alyssa played Phoebe
She sounds older than Prue too and too serious
Where did u get the unaired pilot?? Is it on a dvd they put out?
no it's on youtube from someone i don't own the copy
@@charmedchannel1237 I've been searching for years now but I've been unable to find the full, unaltered, episode. It's either missing a huge chunk, dubbed in Spanish for some odd reason, or it's this version with the huge banner and foreign subs. Ugh.
Its definitely not on the DVD copies. I have the DVDs of the show. I didn't like her as Phoebe. Alyssa Milano will always be Phoebe Halliwell
Don't like her as Phoebe, she would have made a brilliant Paige. The acting throughout just seemed fake and beyond forced with Paige especially compared to her other role's the actress played where she's brilliant.
They should’ve casted her as Paige lol
Yeah they should have casted her as Paige too LOL
CHARMED CHANNEL 123 rose made a terrific Paige.....
I agree that Lori would have made a great Paige but I also love Rose in that role
Lori didn't want to be on the show
She left because after reading the script and auditioning and everything she suddenly found out it was about witchcraft lmao
Was the bloody filmora banner necessary in these videos.
I agree.
I think this video has the Filmora watermark on it when they uploaded this video. :(
If you don’t pay for the actual filmora, then that watermark appears on everything.
Very annoying.
Thumbs down
This person took the time and effort to screen capture this piece of gold, and you come here, free of charge, and still complain about a watermark? Really?
Best thing they ever could have done was add Alyssa and change Andy.. those two actors did Norma work in those roles
why did they change the spell? what happened?
hm... I have no idea. They should have kept it. I even don't know why they even redid it.
CHARMED CHANNEL 123 they redid it because Lori is not the perfect fit.
@@dcrazypersiancat Lori left for personal reasons, and I think they mean the spell
is the attic here the actual attic of the real house?
has to be
nope, that house doesn't have an attic.
No the real attic is in a house across the street and 2 Down it is owned by the same person who owns the real house someone posted a video last year of him touring the real attic. They changed the windows in the show that's about it everything else is the same besides the decorations of course
It actually does have a very small attic. You can see the windows from the side of the house. They call it a widows walk according to the owner of the house
I think Lori Rom as Phoebe Halliwell should have been the best actress to keep on this show but it's ashamed bout her leaving personal reasons and her religion.
so Alyssa wasn't in it at first? too bad they didn't leave it that way,then clda kept shannon
Shannon the reason she left
@@makaylahswain8517 how do you know? Lori has never revealed why she left only that it was for personal reasons. Why lie?
@@rayoflight6505 she did a interview saying her and a cast mate were having issues and the show runner ruled in the other cast mate favor her and the lady who play piper were friends at the time
@@makaylahswain8517 what interview? Link or it didnt happen.
@@rayoflight6505 I don’t know at the time I wrote this another commenter on A video comparing the two pilot stated this and someone backed it up. So I comment that look it up I didn’t care to much to fact check it 😂😂😂😂😂
I’m sorry but Lori Rom she’s really good but Alyssa Milano was born to play Phoebe Halliwell.
It's too bad they changed so many things from the original pilot. It was perfect. It had key scenes zat kud have changed the direction of the entire show. I mean 11:43 for example Piper looks way more freaked by the power out due to her superstitious nature. It establishes her character n it gives more room for her character. Then, her character evolution wud have taken a greater take. I mean zat's the main thing I have to say in most shows n especially Charmed zat every new idea just pops out in the episode only. Not before. But I understand that the producers wanted a greater take on their sisterhood as it's the basis but it shud have been done this way to show Prue n Phoebe's difference of thought, Piper being annoyed of being also sandwiched between these two's fights n her irrational fear due to her superstitious nature. It was the best way. Now, I don't know fr budget cuts but it sure was the best thing to do. I mean I love alyssa's more wild nature compared to Lori's more comical take on it, in particular scenes n situations but in some Alyssa's personality as Phoebe just doesn't suit the situation. Lori's part suits it best. I mean I don't know. N last I really loved the idea of Prue still not trusting Phoebe until the end where she trusts Phoebe in being able to fight Jeremy n believing in their goodness. Though it does clash with Prue's protector attitude. However, it established from the beginning zat the sisters really love each other n will do anything to protect each other. I mean everybody thinks zat Prue, Piper n Phoebe's Trio was 1 with a protector (Prue) who is always in front or centre n Piper n Phoebe being the children who need to be protected but it's not true. That part up till season 3 works fr Prue to be able to know zat Piper n Phoebe have grown mature n responsible n zat they can share the authority. She doesn't need to always take the burden all by herself. She has to start seeing her sisters as equals to her. N she does it great. This wud have established zat thought from the beginning itself. Personally I wud have loved to see Lori up till the end of the show as Phoebe but it's only my love for the old times but yeah I might have wanted to see Phoebe in particular situations but then again I don't know Lori's talents much so she might have been able to transition to Alyssa's naughty n wild nature. Zat's the problem, Lori never got to expand her talents as Phoebe so we will never know if she was a great actor or not. I love Phoebe. I'm not saying she's not great. She's awesome. It's just me. You don't have to like it. I'm just saying wat I think of it.
N then it's not even the official pilot kuz it was just done to attract the attention of the Channel. Scenes wud have been reshot, bettered, other scenes wud have been added, the acting wud have been polished n all zat. The producers wud still have a chance to give Lori the dynamics of Alyssa. I really hope that Lori did have been able to do the naughty n wild character of Phoebe. I know her Church didn't appreciate of her doing her part as a witch. I have no idea of it wud have allowed Lori to play the sexy n wild parts. Now, I pray Lori was not like not comfortable with these kind of scenes kuz maybe she wud have gone by herself even if she had no opposition from her Church. I don't know. I'm just saying. I'm scandalized.
This is a bad take. From the minute Lori walks in she has no presence and sounds like she’s reading lines not actually being the character. She sticks out like a tall awkward sore thumb.
What’s with the zat instead of that ? Jesus Christ.
@@dbetaki8846 kud, kuz, zat... that's so annoying and disrespectful to the language.
The book of shadows is smaller then in the official show
Where can I find the instrumental version of the intro from the DVD menu?
this is the link: ruclips.net/video/uRsuOUxPn5I/видео.html
@@charmedchannel1237 thank you :)
@@Stef_Peeters no problem
I feel that both actresses do a very good job, and each highlight different aspects of phoebe's character. I perfer Alyssa, but the other didn't have the same dynamics or feel.
Ok but seeing how it turned out after season 3 I would've preferred her over alissa
Why did Lori leave the show after the pilot and there was another Andy didn't really like him perfer Ted Knight as Andy
Because she’s a terrible actress lol and the network wanted someone with presence/sex appeal
@@barbarakenny3041 A lot of people theorize she left due to religious reasons, not sure how much I trust that though.
I miss Lori. 😭💔
I mean if lori was in the show I think shannen wouldn't have left the show of charmed.
I’ve hear Lori didn’t get along with both Holly and Shannen
@@keti.rg.editzzz Lori left Because of her Religious Beliefs.