although Ningning is not the main dancer, but her stage performance is the best. It's not only the body that moves but Ning Ning is also playing with his facial expressions ❤️❤️❤️
KARINA truly got everything down. Just look how good she is with the choreography. One thing about Karina is that she will always give her 100%. You can see every detail through her fingers, in the way she moves, her footwork and body fluidity. Her movement is the sharpest and most powerful while showing futility and great dynamics. Her energy is unique and her stage presence just not kidding. SM has a jackpot with her. KARINA the ACE
@@MissElaine121 Karina is most beautiful member, but she's also the only one wearing ugly boots. winter is 2nd beautiful member but her hairs have been destroyed. let alone other 2 disturbing foreigners.
@@MissElaine121 suck?? Karina looks so natural and gorgeous, also the top visual of Kpop. There is no confirmation that Karina had any surgery before and most of female idol nowadays has small surgery since it is their choice for have better looking in the music industry. Just so jealous of Karina being so pretty, famous and talented, her nose is even better than your appearance and personality lol
Ningning is a monster, she kills everything on stage from the beginning and there is not a performance where she does not give the best of herself, is present on this and charismatic. A true queen, she was born to shine, her talent is always present and will never be extinguished. MY BIAS!! ❤️👑🔥
my heart is still fluttering hearing karina's voice during her line. the way she dance is always too perfect. and her visuals which is driving me insane
@@kilammada6306 They haven't sung Girls live yet. On Good Morning America Black Mamba, Next Level and Life's Too Short were live (and sooo well done), Illusion and Girls weren't (do read my second edit note though!). This Girls perfomance isn't live either, yet. Here's to hoping we'll soon get to hear them sing live (while dancing) on a music show for the first time. 🤞 (edited "Black Mamba and Savage" in to "Black Mamba, Next Level and Life's Too Short") edit again: rewatched their Girls performance on Good Morning America several times; I was already pretty sure their mics were on there despite them not actually singing (you can hear breathing not related to the prerecorded vocals). After rewatching, it seems to me however that Winter did belt some high notes over the very heavy prerecorded vocals from 3:20 onwards (in the Good Morning Amarica video). It's really difficicult to distinguish though.
@@kilammada6306 usually for the first week of kpop promotions, groups dont sing live (most likely to show their performance and let the audience focus on the song perhaps?)
@@livingg2331 They sing live, you can watch the ( aespa cam m countdown) at the end they add a video when aespa interacts with fans, and they sing together
@@_azzahraz That doesn’t means that the performance here is live. We’ve heard them singing live, they sound really great but not like that. This is a flawless performance that no human can physically achieve.
Ningning is the real ace of Aespa. Visual, dance, vocal, stage presence.....she owns every performance. Let's hope SM actually gives her the promo and solo activities she deserves.
@@sneezey1856 Que Ningning tenga mejor presencia no la hace un "as" karina aquí es la única que puede ser llamada objetivamente como all-rounder y más adelante si se puede quizás y es el "as" no Ningning sorry :/
Omg I think this’s one of the stage they showed their facial expression the most. Ningning killed this stage!!! Winter and Gigi get a lot more better from previous cb, I just wanna cry 😭
Karina makes me cry. It's a combination of her absolute, ethereal beauty, her charisma, and my feeling proud, for her and for Aespa. So yeah, the song is right when it says, "I'll make you cry".
aespa is a legendary girl group. It seems like they recently debuted as SM rookies, and seis break so many records and reach incredible heights that it’s hard to believe that the group is only 1.5+ years old. In such a short time they have achieved a lot, it is commendable. With every comeback they are getting better, the girls have come a long way!!
the fans really love Ningnings stage presence!! She’s just going to keep getting bigger and bigger & her vocals are so top tier !! She was born to be a star
That camerawork at 3:58 was totally brilliant and combined with our girls' breathtaking stage presence it was like I was watching a MV rather than a music show stage. Nobody else is doing it like aespa at the moment.
Karina is the real ACE in AESPA and of those rare ace in Kpop : Great dancer, good vocalist and a nice rapper + cute stage presence, she's the whole package
winter never disappoints, not only is she one of the prettiest 4th gen's idol but she also keeps proving to us that she is an all-rounder + her stage presence improved so much.
Debuting karina was one of SMs best decisions! A true ace: vocals, rap, dance, visuals, stage presence, and she's the leader! She slays every comeback!
@@onlychaa her stage presence is great. What are u talking about ? I do understand that the chroeo of girls isn't that good compared to their other songs but still karina have the best stage presence. Tho this stage doesn't focus on karina much but her fancam shows her stage presence very well.
@@S1LVERCLOUD if you compare her for example to another idol like Yuna she doesn’t have good facial expressions. Plus, the one with the most stage presence imo are Giselle and NingNing.
@@onlychaaI don't want to compare Karina with her team mates. But I find Karina's stage presence is best along with NingNing. And I find Karina's facial expressions more natural and good compared to yuna; In itzy Yeji has the best stage presence and expressions in my opinion.
Im rooting giselle since their debut song bec I'm very excited to see the first sm rapper and yeah, she's never dissapoint me in every comeback. Her rapping skills is getting better and better, please keep improving giselle❤️
????? 본인이 남자 인지 여자 인지 모르겠는데 외모로 아주 뿅 같네 뿅갔어 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 남자면 좋아하면서 그저 하고싶은 마음 뿐 사귀고싶은 마음뿐 여자면 너무 예뻐서 미칠 거 같애 하는여자들 ㅎㅎㅎㅎㅎ 그리고 전 참고로 남자임 또 오래 갈지 못 갈지 모르는데 ㅋㅋㅋ 참 너무 좋아해서 미치겠다 너무 난리다 여자든 남자든 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
I felt really emotional when I heard the fanchant. They used to perform during covid restriction, now they have MYs cheering and showing them bunch of love. aespa looks happier as well as they could perform in front of MYs, let's keep support them! ^^
everyone performs in the group, but the one who has always been constantly engaged and killing performances is Ningning. She's an artist who has been in charge since the beginning and gives everything, I love her and she will always manage to be good because she was born for that. She is an ARTIST
i don't care what people say about giselle she is my bias, my darling, and in this era my girl is so shining like her beauty is really increasing, she's really amazing I love you aeri, 💘
Better than aespa can only be aespa themselves in the new comeback, because with each comeback they are getting better and better!! aespa are the future of k-pop and it's an undeniable fact that they are the leaders of their generation. They are breaking incredible records even though this group is so young. In just 1.5 years they have done such a great job, it is truly commendable!!
Ahhhhh *NINGNING* how can it be so perfect?! It's radiant!! WINTER is a very cute little baby. I wish the stylist would improve GISELLE's clothes more like a rapper, although she looks beautiful anyway! KARINA Best Center Ever!!!
This comeback was legendary!NingNing vocals,Winter high notes,Giselle rap and Karina swag they’re are the best!
Is it juz i sense zero stage presence is this stage..mybe cuz they lipsync..idk..
@@izz9854 … they weren’t lip syncing this was literally live, there was even a clip of them doing soundcheck
@@hyunlixxie2662 lol this is literally lipsync isn't clear?
@@chiraaz0 if they did soundcheck it literally means they sing live yk
Karina and ningning stage presence is literally on the next level----
are u blind? ningning has only 1 facial expression throughout
@@ex8394 She is charismatic and consistent.
NINGNING EATS EVERY STAGE THIS GIRL IS INSANE
although Ningning is not the main dancer, but her stage performance is the best. It's not only the body that moves but Ning Ning is also playing with his facial expressions ❤️❤️❤️
she's my bias!
She’s like an actress, she really expresses the song
Is it juz i sense zero stage presence in this stage..mybe cuz they lipsync..idk..
The queen
KARINA truly got everything down. Just look how good she is with the choreography. One thing about Karina is that she will always give her 100%. You can see every detail through her fingers, in the way she moves, her footwork and body fluidity. Her movement is the sharpest and most powerful while showing futility and great dynamics. Her energy is unique and her stage presence just not kidding. SM has a jackpot with her. KARINA the ACE
because other 3 members are much uglier than Karina
Her nose looks way too fake
@@MissElaine121 Karina is most beautiful member, but she's also the only one wearing ugly boots. winter is 2nd beautiful member but her hairs have been destroyed. let alone other 2 disturbing foreigners.
@@MissElaine121 but looks better than all idols
@@MissElaine121 suck?? Karina looks so natural and gorgeous, also the top visual of Kpop. There is no confirmation that Karina had any surgery before and most of female idol nowadays has small surgery since it is their choice for have better looking in the music industry. Just so jealous of Karina being so pretty, famous and talented, her nose is even better than your appearance and personality lol
Ningning has a charming look, her vocals, dance, expression and stage presence are the best
Ningning is a monster, she kills everything on stage from the beginning and there is not a performance where she does not give the best of herself, is present on this and charismatic. A true queen, she was born to shine, her talent is always present and will never be extinguished. MY BIAS!! ❤️👑🔥
She deserves more love along with Aeri. She's such a natural 😍
ture!!!!!!
I couldn't agree more. Her charisma is natural. She really belongs to the stage
I love to see Ningning loved
2:18 I AM IN LOVE....
카리나 엔딩 완전 디즈니 공주 아니냐고 ㅠㅠㅠ
karina really killed this girls performance so well. this song is definitely her era
Agree
Totally agree.
my heart is still fluttering hearing karina's voice during her line. the way she dance is always too perfect. and her visuals which is driving me insane
Are they singing live now?
@@kilammada6306 They haven't sung Girls live yet. On Good Morning America Black Mamba, Next Level and Life's Too Short were live (and sooo well done), Illusion and Girls weren't (do read my second edit note though!). This Girls perfomance isn't live either, yet. Here's to hoping we'll soon get to hear them sing live (while dancing) on a music show for the first time. 🤞
(edited "Black Mamba and Savage" in to "Black Mamba, Next Level and Life's Too Short")
edit again: rewatched their Girls performance on Good Morning America several times; I was already pretty sure their mics were on there despite them not actually singing (you can hear breathing not related to the prerecorded vocals). After rewatching, it seems to me however that Winter did belt some high notes over the very heavy prerecorded vocals from 3:20 onwards (in the Good Morning Amarica video). It's really difficicult to distinguish though.
@@kilammada6306 usually for the first week of kpop promotions, groups dont sing live (most likely to show their performance and let the audience focus on the song perhaps?)
@@livingg2331 They sing live, you can watch the ( aespa cam m countdown) at the end they add a video when aespa interacts with fans, and they sing together
@@_azzahraz That doesn’t means that the performance here is live. We’ve heard them singing live, they sound really great but not like that. This is a flawless performance that no human can physically achieve.
The “with my friends” part is EVERYTHING!!!
Yea
Ikr that part caught me off guard first listen
KARINA'S VOCALS, DANCE, AURA, AND STAGE PRESENCE IS JUST 𝗖𝗛𝗘𝗙 𝗞𝗜𝗦𝗦
karina is so passionate about everything when it comes to performing on stage. she never misses a beat and her overflowing charisma too
Winter's charisma makes everything look so effortless
Karina just keeps getting better and better, i love her sooo much!!!
Karina is out of this world. She’s so pretty and talented.
I love her dancing, I just can’t get over it
Karina looks unreal, like a doll wow, love the robot dance break, everyone slayed, we them girls
GISELLE KILLING IT
NINGNING KILLING IT
KARINA KILLING IT
WINTER KILLING IT
AESPA MURDERING THE STAGE
Ningning is the real ace of Aespa. Visual, dance, vocal, stage presence.....she owns every performance. Let's hope SM actually gives her the promo and solo activities she deserves.
Dance no karina is an ace dance,rap,vocal,presence
@@calebcupido3389 let them praise ningning
@@calebcupido3389 Karina is an all rounder but her presence isn’t as good as ningning
@@sneezey1856 personally agree, she can do everything quite well but i don’t find myself being attracted to her sp as much which is completely fine.
@@sneezey1856 Que Ningning tenga mejor presencia no la hace un "as" karina aquí es la única que puede ser llamada objetivamente como all-rounder y más adelante si se puede quizás y es el "as" no Ningning sorry :/
타이틀인덴 이유가 있는법!
묘하게 강력하게 응원해주는거 같아서
출근길에 듣고 여전사로 출근함
ㅇㅈㅇㅈ
Karina's expression and charisma is killing me!!
Too bad the cameraman was zooming on the stage rather than on her when she was singing 😒
I can never take my eyes off Ningning SHE IS JUST SO PERFECT
Ningning is the real ace of Ae: Visual, Vocal, Dance , stage stage performance skills...
Giselle did perfect job on today's perfomance!!proud of her so much:((
Karinas presense on stage is amazing Even if she has the second least Lines i cant take my eyes of her
Omg I think this’s one of the stage they showed their facial expression the most. Ningning killed this stage!!! Winter and Gigi get a lot more better from previous cb, I just wanna cry 😭
Karina is totally killing this with her moves and vocal. She’s good!
Karina's visual is so breathtaking. she's sooo damn prettyyy 😻
Ngl, I am loving Karina's vocals in this comeback, it just sounds so good
SM HIT THE JACKPOT WITH KARINA!! She's a full package. Main dancer, lead rapper and sub vocal of aespa. She's so talented y'all
Seriously though main dancer singing like a main vocal.
And a cutie 🥰
She’s more than a sub vocalist from what she’s shown us
When they stood together as 4 at the beginning….. her visual/impact is legendary lowkey
Her dance moves are so satisfying to watch. It's full of energy without overdoing it
Winter's stage presence is insane.
Ningning's voice , dance , rap and stage presence. She is indeed an it girl of Korea.
but she's chinese lmao, not to say that she's not great but how would that work
She’s really not though 🤷♀️
she is actually chinese
@soobin’s left dimple 😂
😂😂
Giselle visual,vocal,dance,rap so perfect
Yasshh 🔥❤️
Yashh slayy Giselle
Agree
❤️🔥❤️🔥
I love her god
NINGNING SHE IS PERFECT SHE IS AMAZING
I love the fanchat, when my's shout "Karian, Giselle, Winter, Ningning" I really want to see them live and cheer with them
Why no one is talking about Giselle? Her stage presence and charisma are insane. Also red hair with bangs looks so good on her
Bruh cause people who speak about her are enjoying her rap, visual,vocal, and dance and outfits and fuck so many things uk 😻
she looks bored
She doesn't stand out for a rapper and compare to others its sure
She did amazing!
@@jinjisoo784 what others? only soyeon and yuki are better than her.
Giselle literally slay♥️
Karina never fails to capture my eyes on every comeback the outfit they give her is amazing it looks beautiful on her
Ningning stage presence is amazing
Ningning never disappoints and they are singing live they are so stable stan aespa
there not singing live hahaha but there are great performances
I don’t think they’re singing live yet, but I think they will soon :))
I love how powerfully they come through the mics, like “we’re CD quality live, you didn’t know?”
They are not singing live
Not live.
Karina makes me cry. It's a combination of her absolute, ethereal beauty, her charisma, and my feeling proud, for her and for Aespa. So yeah, the song is right when it says, "I'll make you cry".
No one talks about GISELLE's dancing, she's improved a lot, the rapping is also very good, GISELLE SLAYYYYY
Ikr❤😭
Aeri has come a long way and with our love and support I'm sure she'll do even better
yep, she's my bias, she's amazing< 3
SLAYYYY🔥🔥🔥💗💗💗
not the racist and desi mocking girl... come on yall can do better than that
@@fk-gt5gs uh? Pls watch ur mouth
NINGNING ISN’T A HUMAN SHE’S AN ANGEL
dog eating cant be an angel lol
@@mrpun96 ok white person, you are racist cuz you aren’t Asian and you are mad that Asians are pretty unlike you white kid.
@@mrpun96 what…
@@mrpun96 someone with that name who's hiding their face shouldn't really talk . like all this is behind the phone screen , nothing else .
My angel‼️
giselle looks soooo beautiful, that hair cut and color really suits her 😍
Winter's vocals are out of this world. She's really radient in this stage, k-pop's *ace*
Miyeon can easily outsing them all lol
No
@@miyeonbestvocalist683 Then go praise miyeon under Gidle's video 😭
Dont bring miyeon here. Don you ever use her name.
@@miyeonbestvocalist683 lol you made this account 2 days ago just to hate on aespa? Wow the effort. Keep it up Ur increasing the views
Giselle improved a lot, I'm so proud of her
aespa is a legendary girl group. It seems like they recently debuted as SM rookies, and seis break so many records and reach incredible heights that it’s hard to believe that the group is only 1.5+ years old. In such a short time they have achieved a lot, it is commendable. With every comeback they are getting better, the girls have come a long way!!
Karina never disappoints 🔥 she’s an Ace
everyone should recognize more karina as one of the best main dancer in kpop not only in æspa. her dance moves are so powerful and smooth
Karina is great >!
Girllsss
Every knows she is good 😂😂
Karina and yeji has similar aura. They are both leaders, aces of their respective group.
all rounders*
NINGNING IS TRULY AESPA MAIN SLAYER I MEAN LOOK AT HER 😭😭
Karina’s stage presence is so GREATTTT 💙💙
Ningning and Giselle are so talented
the fans really love Ningnings stage presence!! She’s just going to keep getting bigger and bigger & her vocals are so top tier !! She was born to be a star
Gisele really stood out to me, girl is stunning, and she really has a captivating presence. She slayed those raps and vocals!
That camerawork at 3:58 was totally brilliant and combined with our girls' breathtaking stage presence it was like I was watching a MV rather than a music show stage. Nobody else is doing it like aespa at the moment.
NINGNINGS STAGE PRESENCE ISN’T NORMAL !! IT’S A RARE THING THAT WE ALL SHOULD BE THANKFUL FOR
They are singing live or not?
@@brishtibanerjee2808 liveee !! Listen to Ningning at her first part
@@brishtibanerjee2808 It's clearly not live
@@brishtibanerjee2808 live broo please
@@brishtibanerjee2808 it's live vocal they even did sound check before
Karina killing it !! She is the ace!!!
Winter is so amazing in this live ❤❤❤ My ultimate bias ❤
Im so happy that Giselle finally gets the recognition she deserves, everytime she comes on the audience screams
Karina's dance is so powerful waw she's so pretty too
all rounder karina leggo
Karina is the real ACE in AESPA and of those rare ace in Kpop : Great dancer, good vocalist and a nice rapper + cute stage presence, she's the whole package
Karina still slays even though she don’t have many screen lines
NINGNING REALLY SCREAMED “ cultural reset “ when she debuted 😭😭 “ this girls stage presence is captivating I can’t not watch her on stage
Best stage presence!!👏🏻
나만 도깨비불보다 이 노래가 더 좋나...다른 넥스트레벨이나 세비지는 첨에 들었을 때 읭?스러웠는데 이건 듣자마자 괜찮았는데....근데 안무는 진짜 아니야...
Boy eat shit be careful of what u say u can't even do what they are doing bitch ur embarrassing get a life grow up stfu
안무 멋진데?
@@KingKing-di8wr 네
저 철권 안무 만든사람 진짜 ;ㅋㅋㅋ첨봤을때 저게 먼고...손발 오그라드는 병맛 안무같았음
안무 다같이 잘살리면 겁나 멋질것같긴한데 ..
Wow... Ningning really looks great with her soft pink hair
Everything about Karina is perfect
윈터는 여전사처럼 멋있고 너무 귀엽고 이쁘네요😀
winter never disappoints, not only is she one of the prettiest 4th gen's idol but she also keeps proving to us that she is an all-rounder + her stage presence improved so much.
She amazes me, it’s like you can see power when you look at her. It’s above confidence, I don’t know if there’s a word for what she has
why not many ppl can c this...Winter is so Gucci ! it slaps
NINGNING STAGE PRESENCE AND VOCALS
카리나 왤케 청순하냐 진짜 존나 아름다움
NINGNING IS ON FIRE 🔥😭
Karina is a god! Even if there is no special hairstyle it still stands out.
What do you mean about the shape?
😂
@@octopusmusic332 hairstyle(I typed the wrong word😂)
Fr where is our Karina with bangs 😩
닝닝 춤 진짜 잘춘다...♡♡
Debuting karina was one of SMs best decisions! A true ace: vocals, rap, dance, visuals, stage presence, and she's the leader! She slays every comeback!
Karina is literally a perfect idol. SHE'S ACE !! Her CG visuals are everything. She's very adorable too 🤍😭
for real. karina excels in dancing, singing, rapping, and her visuals are crazy
Yeah. Everything but not a lot stage presence.. :/
@@onlychaa her stage presence is great. What are u talking about ? I do understand that the chroeo of girls isn't that good compared to their other songs but still karina have the best stage presence. Tho this stage doesn't focus on karina much but her fancam shows her stage presence very well.
@@S1LVERCLOUD if you compare her for example to another idol like Yuna she doesn’t have good facial expressions. Plus, the one with the most stage presence imo are Giselle and NingNing.
@@onlychaaI don't want to compare Karina with her team mates. But I find Karina's stage presence is best along with NingNing. And I find Karina's facial expressions more natural and good compared to yuna; In itzy Yeji has the best stage presence and expressions in my opinion.
I really like Ningning and Winter in this comeback. They look so cool and savage 🥰
Winter's dancing and stage presence is insane, couldn't take my eyes off her. She's so captivating
Same!! She’s stunning 🥰
Im rooting giselle since their debut song bec I'm very excited to see the first sm rapper and yeah, she's never dissapoint me in every comeback. Her rapping skills is getting better and better, please keep improving giselle❤️
Yes and her vocal is also getting better and better, now she even stronger than some main/lead vocal of the 4th gen !
Yessss she's improve verry well 🔥❤️
Can't wait for her solo 💦
@@octopusmusic332 i think it's too early for aespa having Solos and if they have solo the 1st will probably be Karina
Omg why!!! Ningning is this beautiful with that damn outfit...
Popular Opinion- Everyone agrees that AESPA is an all visual group
Yes.
YES
Yes
Fact
Fact yes
Winter looks so beautiful and gorgeous
Her voice is too attractive and beautiful
Karina looks so pretty in white dress
Her voice is so heavenly
닝닝이 정말 멋지다❤❤❤❤❤
Giselle rap is amazing...I think she is my new bias. Let's go Aespa
Karina really PROVES everyone that she didn’t come to play. She’s truly an ALL-ROUNDER
걸즈 대박 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 짱스파 최고지ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
????
?????
본인이 남자 인지 여자 인지 모르겠는데
외모로 아주 뿅 같네 뿅갔어 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
남자면 좋아하면서 그저 하고싶은 마음 뿐 사귀고싶은 마음뿐
여자면 너무 예뻐서 미칠 거 같애 하는여자들
ㅎㅎㅎㅎㅎ
그리고 전 참고로 남자임
또 오래 갈지 못 갈지 모르는데 ㅋㅋㅋ
참 너무 좋아해서 미치겠다 너무 난리다
여자든 남자든
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
I felt really emotional when I heard the fanchant. They used to perform during covid restriction, now they have MYs cheering and showing them bunch of love. aespa looks happier as well as they could perform in front of MYs, let's keep support them! ^^
everyone performs in the group, but the one who has always been constantly engaged and killing performances is Ningning. She's an artist who has been in charge since the beginning and gives everything, I love her and she will always manage to be good because she was born for that. She is an ARTIST
the way giselle says the "part of my heart" has me on a chokehold
i don't care what people say about giselle she is my bias, my darling, and in this era my girl is so shining like her beauty is really increasing, she's really amazing I love you aeri, 💘
yuppp
Yeppp!! I’ve fallen in love with her since Black Mamba era😭❤️❤️❤️
our black queen😍😍
Yes our desi queen🥰
She's my bias too and I support her
GISELLE EXPRESSIONS IS ANOTHER LEVEL💯❤️🔥
SM songs on first listen : *confusion*
SM songs on 5th listen: *aggressively bopping*
Ningning's stage presence 🔥
Ningning best performer🔥 She keeps improving everytime
Better than aespa can only be aespa themselves in the new comeback, because with each comeback they are getting better and better!! aespa are the future of k-pop and it's an undeniable fact that they are the leaders of their generation. They are breaking incredible records even though this group is so young. In just 1.5 years they have done such a great job, it is truly commendable!!
Winter look like a pretty cat and really have angelic voice , she is everything!!
GISELLE YOU ROCK THE STAGE !
Ningning queen of vocals 💗
Ning is the definition of Performer, an amazing ACE with amazing stage presence & facial expressions no need to talk about her charisma.
Ahhhhh *NINGNING* how can it be so perfect?! It's radiant!! WINTER is a very cute little baby. I wish the stylist would improve GISELLE's clothes more like a rapper, although she looks beautiful anyway! KARINA Best Center Ever!!!