This was really an interesting debate. I am a Catholic myself but not a practicing one, however in this debate, both were very knowledgable and know their stuff well. I have to agree with both of them with much of what was said. Mr. Micallef explains really well, you really enjoy listening to him even if you don't agree with him on certain issues.
Though the names of Moses and others in the biblical narratives are Egyptian and contain genuine Egyptian elements, no extrabiblical sources point clearly to Moses. No references to Moses appear in any Egyptian sources prior to the fourth century BCE, long after he is believed to have lived.
Ix-xjenza hi attivita kwintessenzjalment Kattolika. Pemezz taghha qed niskopru u nifhmu l holqien u minnu naghrfu l id Tal Hallieq. Tista' tghid li din hija anglu iehor ta meta nghidu li Alla halaqna fix xbieha tieghU. Kapaci nosservaw u nifhmu l logika Tal holqien.
Ricky fl ahhar mill ahhar temmen u ma temminx f Alla kulhadd jaf x inhu tajjeb u x inhu hazin. Gesu gie jipperfezzjona it testment il qadim. Gesu jghidilna hobb lill ghajrek bhalek nnifsek. Ma qal xejn hazin.
Mhux il-punt! Dik qalha wkoll il-Buddha. Jien ghalija li nghixu fl-ghama biex nevitaw veritajiet skomdi ma tghogobni xejn. Importanti li l-verita' b'xi moghod tohrog.
Skond il bibbja Il mara tal farawni sabet tarbija tat twelid go qoffa fi xmara. Jista xi hadd jghidli kif Dan Mose kien jaf li hu Lhudi??? Jekk rabbewh l Egizzjani suppost kultura u lingwa Egizzjana biss kellhu. Fil fatt Mose tfisser l ttella mill ilma.
Tkunx banana , dan is suggett huwa espressjoni ta opinjoni mhux il verita assoluta. Jekk trid il verita fittxa go fik. Awnekk biex nitghallmu min xulxin qedin mhux biex nfittxu ic certezza f mose. Jekk trid hekk habbat bieb ihor.
Jekk qed tiddiskreditah just ghax Teologu kattoliku, kull ma qieghed taghmel hu li tghix go echo chamber. Ma tistax tghid li mhux qed jiddibatti tajjeb. Ma naqbilx l-anqas jien mal-fehmiet tieghu, imma mhux ghax kattoliku! Sempliciment ghax fl-arfument tieghu qieghed idahhal assunzjoni qawwija, dik li Alla huwa l-mutur.
Dak it Teologu la qal li hu kristjan prattikanti ma jista qatt ikun ma jkunx BIASED minn dak li jemmen. Imnalla l Univers ma jifhimx il lingwa tal bnedmin.
Bro! Min m'huwiex biased? Ghalekk issir diskussjoni, biex kullhadd jghid il-biases tieghu u nhabbtu l-ideat. Biased kemm trid imma knowledgeable u dak li jghid ma jaqalawx minn sormu.
Jin ghalija It testment l Antik u t testment l Gdid huma zewgt Allat differenti wiehed jikkastiga w jitlob sagriffici w liehor jahfer u jibat lil ibnu biex isalva lil umani kolla
Hi, sur Azzopardi, jien Justin it-Teologu. Interessanti ħafna dan l-argument u naqbel miegħek 100%. Infatti fi żmien l-ewwel insara diġa' kellek komunitajiet "Insara" li totalment abbandunaw it-Testment il-Qadim u bdew iqisu l-Alla tat-TQ bħala l-Alla tal-Ħażen. Tajjeb li ngħidu li dawn damu jgħammru sas-seklu 14 WK u kienu twaqqfu joperaw mill-Papa Innocenz. Għalhekk kif spjegajt fil-podcast, il-Knisja Kattolika kontemporanjament tagħmilha ċara li speċjalment fejn jidħol it-TQ irridu nifhmu s-sitwazzjoni ta' dak iż-żmien meta qed jinkiteb ktieb partikolari, l-aġenda tal-awtur, kulturi, influwenzi mitoloġiċi tal-madwar, u anke kif ġrajjiet kontemporanji influwenzaw il-kittieb. Din tidher ċara fit-TQ hekk li l-kotba qed jinkitbu mil-lenti Ebrajka, fejn ħlief gwerer, oppressjonijiet, u telf ta' art ma rawx. Allura jridu joħolqu l-idea tad-Divin li hu qisu TERMINATOR li min iħabbatha miegħu, ħażin għalih. Simili bħal-lum fejn ikollok persuna jibża' minn dellu imma mbagħad imur id-dar u jaqla' l-ħdura u mibegħda fuq Facebook. Min naħa l-oħra l-Evanġelji qed jinkitbu minn lenti b'influwenzi Rumani/Griegi/Lixandrin. Lenti li ftit li xejn rat telf u oppressjonijiet. Qed nitkellmu fuq komunitajiet li tista' tgħid kellhom id-dinja f'idejhom.
Interessanti hafna, looking forward ghal li jmiss. Grazzi
keep going I like your programs
This was really an interesting debate. I am a Catholic myself but not a practicing one, however in this debate, both were very knowledgable and know their stuff well. I have to agree with both of them with much of what was said.
Mr. Micallef explains really well, you really enjoy listening to him even if you don't agree with him on certain issues.
You can tell they respect each other very much. Only good things can come out from such a debate.
Nteressanti hafna, grazzi
Interessanti hafna
Ghadni ha narah dan Sayan imma herqan bil kbir. Grazzi Ricky , grazzi justin u l kulhadd tal hin taghkom.
INTERESSANTI HAFNA. Grazzi lit-tnejn li intom. Komplu ghallmuna.
Hemm xi iehor jew? Grazzi
Though the names of Moses and others in the biblical narratives are Egyptian and contain genuine Egyptian elements, no extrabiblical sources point clearly to Moses. No references to Moses appear in any Egyptian sources prior to the fourth century BCE, long after he is believed to have lived.
Prosit, interessanti hafna
Easter eggs jghidulhom meta jtik hints ta x ha jigri. Fil films specjament.
Ix-xjenza hi attivita kwintessenzjalment Kattolika. Pemezz taghha qed niskopru u nifhmu l holqien u minnu naghrfu l id Tal Hallieq. Tista' tghid li din hija anglu iehor ta meta nghidu li Alla halaqna fix xbieha tieghU. Kapaci nosservaw u nifhmu l logika Tal holqien.
Ilallu xi ġmiel! Prosit!
Ommi Ricky ezatt kif nahsibha jien
Ricky fl ahhar mill ahhar temmen u ma temminx f Alla kulhadd jaf x inhu tajjeb u x inhu hazin. Gesu gie jipperfezzjona it testment il qadim. Gesu jghidilna hobb lill ghajrek bhalek nnifsek. Ma qal xejn hazin.
Mhux il-punt! Dik qalha wkoll il-Buddha. Jien ghalija li nghixu fl-ghama biex nevitaw veritajiet skomdi ma tghogobni xejn. Importanti li l-verita' b'xi moghod tohrog.
Skond il bibbja Il mara tal farawni sabet tarbija tat twelid go qoffa fi xmara.
Jista xi hadd jghidli kif Dan Mose kien jaf li hu Lhudi???
Jekk rabbewh l Egizzjani suppost kultura u lingwa Egizzjana biss kellhu.
Fil fatt Mose tfisser l ttella mill ilma.
Kompli segwi, ghadu kemm tela' issa l-video, ser jitkellmu propju fuq hekk.
Iva naf nahseb kien jghix hemm it teologu u gi rrinkarnat fid dinja go Malta biex itina t tarif preciz ta dak iz zmien.
Tkunx banana , dan is suggett huwa espressjoni ta opinjoni mhux il verita assoluta. Jekk trid il verita fittxa go fik. Awnekk biex nitghallmu min xulxin qedin mhux biex nfittxu ic certezza f mose. Jekk trid hekk habbat bieb ihor.
Jekk qed tiddiskreditah just ghax Teologu kattoliku, kull ma qieghed taghmel hu li tghix go echo chamber. Ma tistax tghid li mhux qed jiddibatti tajjeb. Ma naqbilx l-anqas jien mal-fehmiet tieghu, imma mhux ghax kattoliku! Sempliciment ghax fl-arfument tieghu qieghed idahhal assunzjoni qawwija, dik li Alla huwa l-mutur.
Proset Rik Tal Anlologia Tal Klandestini Mal Lhud Ta Zmien Mose.Proset Ukoll Ta Dal Podcast,Tal Genn
Dak it Teologu la qal li hu kristjan prattikanti ma jista qatt ikun ma jkunx BIASED minn dak li jemmen.
Imnalla l Univers ma jifhimx il lingwa tal bnedmin.
Bro! Min m'huwiex biased? Ghalekk issir diskussjoni, biex kullhadd jghid il-biases tieghu u nhabbtu l-ideat. Biased kemm trid imma knowledgeable u dak li jghid ma jaqalawx minn sormu.
Jin ghalija It testment l Antik u t testment l Gdid huma zewgt Allat differenti wiehed jikkastiga w jitlob sagriffici w liehor jahfer u jibat lil ibnu biex isalva lil umani kolla
Ghandek ragun. Jien narhom bhala rakkonti allegorici iktar minn xejn.
Hi, sur Azzopardi, jien Justin it-Teologu. Interessanti ħafna dan l-argument u naqbel miegħek 100%. Infatti fi żmien l-ewwel insara diġa' kellek komunitajiet "Insara" li totalment abbandunaw it-Testment il-Qadim u bdew iqisu l-Alla tat-TQ bħala l-Alla tal-Ħażen. Tajjeb li ngħidu li dawn damu jgħammru sas-seklu 14 WK u kienu twaqqfu joperaw mill-Papa Innocenz. Għalhekk kif spjegajt fil-podcast, il-Knisja Kattolika kontemporanjament tagħmilha ċara li speċjalment fejn jidħol it-TQ irridu nifhmu s-sitwazzjoni ta' dak iż-żmien meta qed jinkiteb ktieb partikolari, l-aġenda tal-awtur, kulturi, influwenzi mitoloġiċi tal-madwar, u anke kif ġrajjiet kontemporanji influwenzaw il-kittieb. Din tidher ċara fit-TQ hekk li l-kotba qed jinkitbu mil-lenti Ebrajka, fejn ħlief gwerer, oppressjonijiet, u telf ta' art ma rawx. Allura jridu joħolqu l-idea tad-Divin li hu qisu TERMINATOR li min iħabbatha miegħu, ħażin għalih. Simili bħal-lum fejn ikollok persuna jibża' minn dellu imma mbagħad imur id-dar u jaqla' l-ħdura u mibegħda fuq Facebook. Min naħa l-oħra l-Evanġelji qed jinkitbu minn lenti b'influwenzi Rumani/Griegi/Lixandrin. Lenti li ftit li xejn rat telf u oppressjonijiet. Qed nitkellmu fuq komunitajiet li tista' tgħid kellhom id-dinja f'idejhom.
Totalment differenti is siwazzjoni il gwerra ta lukraina u l gwerra ta israel ... check your facts
To be fair ma kienx qed jghid li l-gwerer huma l-istess. Qed tiggeneralizza. Qieghed isib xi similaritajiet.
Grazzi, podcast bis sens