I was quite surprised to know that tzuyu is not a ambassador of any brand . I means girl she is so pretty and got a good height. She can be a perfect model of many brands.
She’s so right about this Jyp has a record of mistreating some twice members like Jeongyun and Dahyun but I would say Tzuyu’s case is the worst she’s literally one of the most talked about visuals of K-pop but we barely get to see her having brand deals and she never debuted as an actress and now they’re making fun of her? So insensitive
@@marshallarjuna4072 kang Mina did amazing in Cafe Minamdang and Kim Sejeong was well received for her role in Business Proposal. Krystal is another phenomenal actress that has made a name for herself and honed her skill.
@@________ag680She is a Chinese girl, She thinks something like Taiwanese exist that's why companies can't take her because it can be a violation of one China Policy.
And?? It doesn't negate the fact that jyp doesn't treat her like she is the most popular member of twice even though she is, but they keep doing this kind of shit to her. Her still shining is not because of jyp, it's despite them
@@loelds4817 No, JYP definitely does bear some responsibility for not adequately protecting their artist and understanding conflicts and complicated politics. And just so you know, most Chinese netizens didn't like her apology either and were angry at JYP. If JYP had come out and explained how they should've done better with handling such a sensitive topic and clarified that it wasn't Tzuyu's fault, it would've been much better for pretty much everyone involved.
@@scholarssolutions6735 It wasn't until this video I saw the agreements. Before, I saw no trace of this subject aside from "Top 10 saddest Kpop moments"
Because this video is misleading. Jihyo wasn't imitating apology. She had just worn a similar looking out. She never said anything even remotely related to tyuzu's apology video. Ppl just pointed out the outfit and caused a backlash
@@JustGotALifethat’s good to hear. I was thinking the same thing, why in the world would she do that. Tzuyu having to apologise like that was not funny in the slightest.
Tzuyu being the most popular member despite receiving so little promotions. She’s so humble and strong despite the adversities, that’s why she’s my bias ❤
Yes I do agree. Tzuyu despite having no solo activities little to no lines still managed to garner so much popularity. Why? Because she has that natural IT factor that people in the industry work so hard to have. But its something you are born with. Where you don’t have to say a word or even crack a smile and all eyes are on you. The minute Tzuyu actually has her own thing going for her, she will sky rocket into stardom. Its a shame she is being held back
Please be for real, she doesn't have the skills to be a solo artist, especially in xenophobic Korea. Other activities yes, but her lines are quite appropriate considering her level.
@@faceofvision why do you think they turn to acting even without formal acting training. Simple, they can't sing. Suzy couldn't even handle Genie and she has the most lines i Miss A.
Jihyo DID NOT RECREATE THE VIDEO and there was not a single mention of it. It only caused backlash due to people noticing the similarity in the outfit and background and since then the it has been deleted and an apology has been issued. If there is any criticism it would be toward the show and their managers for not seeing this coming. Stop spreading misinformation and blaming jihyo for this.
1. Tzuyu is actually global ambassador for 'POND'S Bright Miracle. No, it's not a company like Rolex, but you can't say she's not an ambassador of any brand. 2. Tzuyu also attended Louis Vuitton 2020 Cruise Spin off Show in 2019 which is a not fashion week, but it's a fashion show. 3. No solo parts? What? She literally was the chorus in what is love. She also has a part in one spark, she's the buildup right before it's Chaeyoungs part. Lol. But nobody wants to acknowledge facts. Just believe what they want to believe.
One thing about Tzuyu in Twice she has a good line development history She improved so much and has gained so many parts coming from sounds like Knock knock and TT where her parts were smaller to set me free and one spark
it's just that it's quite small compared to her juniors who have less experience and time, she is a respected senior from a MAJOR girl group, it was the nation's girl group and the it group of that gen, Tzuyu was one of the top beauties of her gen as well, she really should have such deals and schedules. but, i think it could be her personality that she is more quiet and reserved, such things may not spark her interest, it's hard to know since she is the member we know the least probably
@@aniolkaharmonia Yeah I agree, I mean, she hasn't really said anything about it on Bubble, at most, she basically posts pictures of her dogs. Which is fine because they're really adorable lol. But yeah, we really don't know and she isn't vocal like some of the members, she's pretty quiet.
@@imtherealone.6268 fr, like i wish it was easier to tell what she wants cos i could actually see it being possible that she prefers to not engage in too much idol activity, but i could also see it being a very real possibility that she feels surpressed. at the very least, though, she does engage in activities, like you listed above! it's not like she's locked up in the jyp dungeons
Bc thats korean people racist😅imagine u are not korean but forced to act like u are korean😅JYP so mess it up bc make tzuyu to make force apologize..bro..JYP cant think??bro...how stupid was that..he is the CEO but he make stupid decision for his artist..
Because of China. China doesn't see Taiwan as a country, they see it as a rebellious province of China that they will use military force to bring in back inline. If you want to make most money you dont piss off china since you know they will buy huge amounts of albums, will sell out a stadium if they let you perform. So as a company who wants to keep doors open to China then forcing her to apologize makes sense, however the company knowing how China is should have had more foresight to begin with and should have helped tzuyu with her introduction.
Why did jihyo agree to it???? Like... bro you're the most senior active group in the company, and you can't refuse to play a gag, that directly makes fun of one of the most traumatizing and humiliating moments of one of your group's members? you can't even say no? What is this? That was not very cash money of her
Yeah i don't understand why she woukd agree to do that i love jihyo and she has been one of the best leaders of kpop. I really don't understand hiw she agreed to do it .
@@OGseouliteso if we’re gonna assume that Tzuyu didn’t know about it how can we say that Jihyo did this because she wanted to? If they’re not allowed to assume that she knew about it then you’re not allowed to assume Jihyo did it willingly without being a hypocrite.
🇹🇼 Taiwan is its own country. im proud to say my country recognize them. We greatly appreciate Taiwan and its people for always supporting my small country.
Taiwan doesn't have de jure independence. Less than 20 countries in the world recognize it, just because your country does does not make it a sovereign nation. And ironic you say Taiwan when you're using the Republic of China flag, which Taiwan even admits to being in its own constitution.
@@meganlee8235 I mean that kind of proves that Taiwan isn't its own country because they don't have their own flag. Their flag is the Republic of China's flag. There isn't one flag for the Republic of China and one for Taiwan. There's only one for both.
@@meganlee8235 China and the Republic of China are not the same thing. China is the People's Republic of China. The Republic of China is Taiwan. Only 12 countries recognize Taiwan as its own country. I suggest looking up the tensions between China and Taiwan. You will see the difference between the Republic of China and the People's Republic of China.
No one talks about how tzuyu is the visual but gets barely any screen time and it’s always pushed aside in the groups photos, she barely gets any lines and is always in the back in choreographys.
Her personality is too shy for a solo activity. She is as pretty as a doll but that is all that there is to it. Her vocals are decent, but not strong enough for solo.
I’ve ALWAYS thought how come she was never pushed like we see some idols everywhere nowadays and she was super super famous especially in the first couple of years she debuted. So sad..
@@Plutoneedlove she stays the leader? Lmao, doomed is a strong word. as long as she doesn’t fuck shit up big time anymore then they’ll all be just fine with their careers and public appearance.
@@cosas_de_gatos she agreed to doing it 😭 it’s possible for her to say that she doesn’t want to do something even if yall think that the staff was the only part of this
Jihyo still has eyes and a brain, its very obvious what they were doing, yall need to stop infantilizing this grown woman acting like she cant put 2 and 2 together. The fans knew right away, do you think jihyo is dense enough to not have any idea? No right?
Jihyo should be ashamed of herself & JYPE absolutely needs to respect the foreign members more. It's actually so upsetting. First the elevator video, then the apology and her own leader is mocking her? Disgusting.
I agree with her. It's so cruel to make a joke out of that situation. Tzuyu had to apologize when she didn't do anything wrong, and she was harrased a lot online at a very young age. JYPE owes her an apology.
Taiwanese media said they had countless brands and TV shows and stuff approaching her for Taiwan promotions but it was all rejected... she renewed for twice only... they kinda has this 10 year promise ... maybe that's why.. Taiwanese media is the only one revealed of her opportunities being rejected ... God knows what else got rejected for her..
I always thought she had the potential to be a it girl like she perfect for it but she gets nothing like her company does not promote her or give her anything solo so it’s like they won’t let her even try to shine very weird
She does zooc advertisements from what i can tell and she currently is doing a solo event and pop store. So although shes not doing huge brands like fendi/prada she still has some that she gets asked for. Not all the members have big deals either so its a bit over protective. I get it since shes a friend of the mom, and i get why the mom complains too its her daughter her princess and wants the best. But looking outside of the box and being objective you can see she does get her chances to promote and do solo things too. As for the jihyo thing when i first saw the teaser it never reminded me of Tzuyu's apologies video so i can see how everyone involved missed it. Even side by side at start of this video it might look similar but gives off different vibes.
Tzuyu is already very popular but could’ve been made it so much bigger in the fashion industry and all if only she was actually treated right. Girly literally lost her spark, her confidence after that whole incident. People did support her later but never properly apologised and JYPE is holding her down very obviously. I agree with Matilda, Tzuyu deserves so much more.
I think that tzuyu is a vital part of twice, along with every single member. But its the fact she is the most popular one in the group thats making JYP not want to promote her to avoid a Miss A incident. If she is already this popular, giving her more solo projects might make her overshadow the group. It might not feel fair but i think JYP is just trying to prevent any conflicts with twice's image
tzuyu def deserves an apology, and if jihyo did agree to do that, that is actually so messed up. even if it is an inside joke, its not something u say to the lublic. If jihyo didnt agree but was forced to for the show, then i wont blame her but if she didnt im really dissapointed in her because she is the leader and doing this? not ok
Lol until she mentioned it i didnt realise how she isnt any brand ambassador or has any solo activities, fashion week etc. I fully expected her to be considering her visuals and popularity. Good on Matilda - shes well known in Taiwan too
the fact it was the friend of tzuyu’s mom that had to point it out like? and why put Jihyo in that spot it isn’t funny idk if jihyo was made to do it but where are the boundaries? JYP GIVE TZUYU MORE SOLO PARTS you give every other twice member promotions what about Tzuyu and the fact she was so kind to renew her contact for everyone else 🥹😭😭 JYP GIVE HER PROMOTION! 💀💀🥹🥹🥹😭😭😭😭
tzuyu maybe pretty but her vocals and stage is not strong enough for solo activities. you can feel her shyness. it maybe attractive to a few but solo activities needs strong stage presence but she is good in fashion week instead of dahyun. but well it is the italians or parisians who select who they want to be ambassadors
I think Tzuyu needs to improve on SP as an opera singer and preformer myself, and she’s 100% not the most popular member. All members get promoted based on how much profits they make and not favouritism
Eh no she's definitely very very popular and constantly goes viral for her visuals. She literally wouldn't have gotten into Twice if it weren't for people wanting her to get in because she was so popular for being pretty.
@@scholarssolutions6735 Just becaue she's popular or goes viral doesn't mean her songs or fancams will go viral. Her stage presence reminds me of pre debut wonhee sometimes IMO You're misinterpreting me and thinking that I meant that Tzuyu isn't popular. Sure, she is popular but definitely not for SP, vocals, or dance. She's not ready for a solo.
@@rathodlalita4926 Again I'm an opera singer, the reason you might think she's the most stable is because she's stiff. Her voice is the flattest in twice but her lower range is alright. I'd say stability wise Mina and Chaeyoung beat her easily, but Tzuyu at least seems to have basic vocal skills after attending a concert from them a while back. Also, I'm pretty sure Nayeon fancams had the highest views, at least for Alcohol free. Tzuyu was nowhere near the top three. The SP not being good is also the main reason she isn't getting solos so I still stand by my opinion. I love her but most idols work better as a group and YG is the only company that specifically invests in members so that they hold their own as soloists imo
@@hayley4032 lamo it was jihyo who has the most view famcam in alcohol free bc of her reveling outfit nothing else and jyp is trying so hard make nayoen the most popular member she have the best outfit in twice she get the most line even tho she isn't main vocalist she is always in center she have the most brand deal she get the most screen time while tzuyu doesn't get good outfit she get like 10 second line she barely get any scene time jyp doesn't give her any solo promotion even tzuyu's mother called out jyp for mistreated tzuyu still manage to be the most popular twice member bc she is it girl material while even sana is more popular then nayoen and pls go and check one spark mr remove video tzuyu was the only one singing clear and loud with 3 mix while mina didn't even try to sing same gosh to chae 😭 anyway u can't chang the fact that she is the most popular member in twice
I don't say Tzuyu apologizing for rasing her flag is good (and Tzuyu is my bias)but Chaeyoung doesn't need to apologize and you should probably move on from that incident if it doesn't affect or concern you
@@Thelma-gv5eooh so neo nazis aren’t supposed to apologize? chaeyoung is a grown woman who went through years of school and most likely learned about the holocaust in SEVERAL years of the schooling. it may not effect that one person but having the mindset of “it doesn’t effect me so it doesn’t matter just get over it” and spreading it around is so harmful and keeps the train of hate crimes, racism, xenophobia, zionism, and antisemitism going
@@stansongjia even I go through years of school but never heard of this "the holocast" situation and what do you expect from Chaeyoung that she give up on being an idol or she take her own life because of the hate,Yea she's a grown women who is uneducated and only went to high school for 5 days what do you expect to learn for those 5 days of schooling and then we went back to elementary school which is also a unnecessary because(if I'm not wrong)Korean kids need learn about their culture and history more than anything and that's what we did in India too.To say she learned about foreign affairs for Several years of schooling doesn't even make sense........and just by wearing that shirt doesn't mean she is a neo nazis,choose your words wisely before you speak
@@Thelma-gv5eo does hitler ring any bells to you? world war 2? 1940’s germany? some schools call it different things and refer to it in different ways.in most parts of the world the holocaust is taught in primary school and up so even if she only went to highschool for 5 days she should still know. i expect chaeyoung to understand the history and severity of her actions and apologize more than a few sentences after committing a hate crime and posting her antisemitism. if she had a history class in her many years of learning then she would know about the holocaust even if she was taught about korean culture first. to say that she is a neo nazi makes complete sense if you understand and know what was on her shirt and the severity of it
tzuyu has amazing visuals and a beautiful voice, i definitely believe she could’ve gotten a lot farther and gained much more recognition had she not been under JYP. i hope she doesn’t decide to renew her solo contract and does what’s best for her - she deserves so much more than what crumbs JYP is giving her.
@@OxygenC2 first of all, sm has one 4th gen group and they clear most gg of the generation when they sing (even the rappers a decent vocalists) and it's not up to artists to chose of they sing live. Second of all, Tzuyu is 3rd gen and she is around Yeri's level. Aka still the least "shining" one.
I always wondered why she wasn't an ambassador of a major brand, most of the time the visual/most popular member becomes an ambassador first in the group. Also I did notice how she barely has any solo activities, appearing on any show, modelling and advertising or attending fashion events. Its honestly sad cause I see all the other members having fun and getting all these opportunities when they aren't working as Twice but Tzuyu barely has any. I hope she leaves JYP or does smth abt this...
She might not have those solo activities because she doesn't want it. She might value the free time and limited travelling alot more than the constant schedule you get with being an ambassador and so on. A black shirt on a white background is also not enough to say it was an intentional re-creation of her apology. I'd want to hear this from Tzuyu before I belive it's a problem.
Tzuyu doesn't have solo activities or brand deals yet New Jeans members had brand deals when they were still rookies! How is that fair? JYP needs to stop suppressing Tzuyu and I am so disappointed in Jihyo🥺
makes me mad that jihyo did that knowing it was mocking not only tzuyu but also making light of something so serious that is still following tzuyu to this day. tzuyu deserves better
That apology was one of the most horrible things a rookie group had to do to appease the public. It was so dumb, they literally handed her two flags and she got hate for it. I am also weirded out that anyone thought making fun of it was a good idea, it was literally a forced apology video and she looked like she had been crying
Tbh, if i were Tzuyu i don't think i would've stayed with jyp......... Don't get me wrong ! I don't want her to leave. Never. However, throughout her idol career and life, i feel like she's been very mistreated like this video says ( few lines, no solo activities, forcing her to appologize for nothing,...) even though she's the most popular member. I get that, to most, she's not the most talented but she can sing and can dance and has outstanding visuals, she should be able to shine in comebacks. Also as a huge patriotist who loves her country more than anything i'd be really upset about appologizing for waving my country's flag ngl. So #JusticeforTzuyu ❤
I don’t know how this was approved and allowed to air. Did they not think of the public’s reaction to this? Even though the members may have moved on from it, it’s still a serious and offensive issue in Kpop. It shouldn’t be mocked.
If she was given opportunities by JYP, she'd be thriving. What excuse JYP can give at this point? They're now a senior group and her scandals are way back. I'm curious what she asked in her contract tho to renew.
I never knew she didn't have any brand endorsement.. she is always sidelined in the group but I never knew she didn't have any brands with her popularity looks and height...
Tzuyu is (no offense) the most beautiful member of twice? How does she not been to a fashion event on her own? How is she not an ambassador?? She's beyond gorgeous
Tzuyu is daughter of wealthy parents. I doubt that her parents will let her be mistreated or suppressed to sign another contract with JP and not help her and recommend her to go to other companies.
Lol what kind of leader will agree to even be involved in any program that says to make fun about something that is so personal and serious to their own group member who they've been with for almost a decade (atp they're more family than co workers) let alone do the acting themselves and shoot it all and then agree to upload it ..... didn't expect this from jihyo
She agreed to re sign for the group not for her self. JYP continues to treat her terribly and yet she smiles and keeps working. No solos no ambassador brands and never goes to fashion week when the rest of them do. The worst is Jihyo, her Leader agreeing to do that stupid parody. More reasons to always Support Her and not JYP. Very disappointed in the company and the group.
Jihyo would NEVER do that. There were unintentional similarities to the apology video therefore it was taken down and the production apologized. Jihyo did nothing wrong and the teaser was not made as a joke or a replica, there was absolutely no correlation intentionally.
The fact is, except for Sana, most of the members don't have really luxury brand endorsements like Blackpink. So, I'm not sure what that's about. Did every member of Twice have a solo? Are we trying to make something out of nothing?
she is a true friend of her mother
Ofcourse ✨ but no one's talking about this
yeah..
Fr...
Like they made her apologize for a stupid reason, never gave her any solo part still she stayed for onces aah i love her sm 🥺
She definitely didn't do it for ONCEs 😂.
She would be cancel badly if it wasn't for JYP .
It might seem stupid for you but its not
@@Lovechaeyoung_ are you chinese?
@@magrybiwhat do you mean
I was quite surprised to know that tzuyu is not a ambassador of any brand . I means girl she is so pretty and got a good height. She can be a perfect model of many brands.
100% she has offers but jyp denied them. There's no way as the favorite visual she never had any.
Ikr. she's the most popular member and considered one of the prettiest idols in kpop. There's no way she hasn't gotten any offers from brands
She's the ambassador of ponds i think? Search it
She was definitely offered but jyp denied. There’s no way she was never offered.
I think we should appreciate her more for her talent than her looks...
She’s so right about this
Jyp has a record of mistreating some twice members like Jeongyun and Dahyun but I would say Tzuyu’s case is the worst she’s literally one of the most talked about visuals of K-pop but we barely get to see her having brand deals and she never debuted as an actress and now they’re making fun of her? So insensitive
Actress???? Idols in acting is the stupid thing that ever happen in Korea.
@@marshallarjuna4072no there are plenty of great actresses that were formerly idols. It is a better career pathway with more reliable longevity
@@dongysakura418 nope. Does not seem great actor/actress in OUR eyes.
@@marshallarjuna4072 kang Mina did amazing in Cafe Minamdang and Kim Sejeong was well received for her role in Business Proposal. Krystal is another phenomenal actress that has made a name for herself and honed her skill.
@@marshallarjuna4072 In YOUR eyes. Not WE
Poor tzuyu😢 she deserves better
But why does any brand collaborate with her. I think she is most popular member
@@________ag680She is a Chinese girl, She thinks something like Taiwanese exist that's why companies can't take her because it can be a violation of one China Policy.
@@________ag680favouritism exist in k-pop
She literally shined in this last comeback😭
And?? It doesn't negate the fact that jyp doesn't treat her like she is the most popular member of twice even though she is, but they keep doing this kind of shit to her. Her still shining is not because of jyp, it's despite them
@@thissitescertifiedhousecat8107 I am not disagreeing. I was just stating that she got some decent lines this time. I hope it continues. She shined😁.
This one yes but what with the 9 years before that 💀
TZUYU’S MOM’S FRIEND SPITTING FACTS FR 💯
It feels great knowing I wasn't the only one who agrees the forced apology they made Tzuyu do was stupid. She definitely deserves better fr
Chinese netizens were literally sending death threats to Tzuyu and JYP headquarters. Its not JYPs fault. Blame the chinese netizens.
@@loelds4817 don't worry, I'd never disrespect JYP. I was mainly annoyed by those that made her do it and as you said, it was the C-Netizens
Lol this is literally a popular opinion. What "I wasn't the only one"? Everyone pretty much agrees with you.
@@loelds4817 No, JYP definitely does bear some responsibility for not adequately protecting their artist and understanding conflicts and complicated politics. And just so you know, most Chinese netizens didn't like her apology either and were angry at JYP. If JYP had come out and explained how they should've done better with handling such a sensitive topic and clarified that it wasn't Tzuyu's fault, it would've been much better for pretty much everyone involved.
@@scholarssolutions6735 It wasn't until this video I saw the agreements. Before, I saw no trace of this subject aside from "Top 10 saddest Kpop moments"
Why’d jihyo even agree to do that?.
Because this video is misleading. Jihyo wasn't imitating apology. She had just worn a similar looking out. She never said anything even remotely related to tyuzu's apology video. Ppl just pointed out the outfit and caused a backlash
@@JustGotALifethat’s good to hear. I was thinking the same thing, why in the world would she do that. Tzuyu having to apologise like that was not funny in the slightest.
Thanks for clearing that up cause I was about to (very reluctantly) unstan jihyo
Tzuyu being the most popular member despite receiving so little promotions. She’s so humble and strong despite the adversities, that’s why she’s my bias ❤
Yes I do agree. Tzuyu despite having no solo activities little to no lines still managed to garner so much popularity. Why? Because she has that natural IT factor that people in the industry work so hard to have. But its something you are born with. Where you don’t have to say a word or even crack a smile and all eyes are on you. The minute Tzuyu actually has her own thing going for her, she will sky rocket into stardom. Its a shame she is being held back
Please be for real, she doesn't have the skills to be a solo artist, especially in xenophobic Korea. Other activities yes, but her lines are quite appropriate considering her level.
@@faceofvision I agree, there's literally a reason why some members get more lines than others.
@@faceofvision Neither do most idols who turn actors or some like Sakura, but they still go big in Korea. 😮💨
@@OxygenC2 do you even read what you reply to, I was talking about singing. Since when do we call actors "artists" and speak about their "lines"?
@@faceofvision why do you think they turn to acting even without formal acting training. Simple, they can't sing. Suzy couldn't even handle Genie and she has the most lines i Miss A.
I swear tzuyu and my bias in twice she cares about once and her members i love her sm.. ❤
She's a real one for that,tzuyu has been always mistreated unfortunately
Tzuyu would slay on the Met Gala
Jihyo DID NOT RECREATE THE VIDEO and there was not a single mention of it. It only caused backlash due to people noticing the similarity in the outfit and background and since then the it has been deleted and an apology has been issued. If there is any criticism it would be toward the show and their managers for not seeing this coming. Stop spreading misinformation and blaming jihyo for this.
Thank you for this, i was like “theres no way jihyo would do that though?”
If it looks like a duck, sounds like a duck, walks like a duck, it’s a duck. Don’t cover for this type of messed up stuff. Don’t be disgusting.
Say it louder for the people in the back.
I also heard that it was her introducing herself as a member of a show.
💯It’s like people don’t check the comment section before yapping, they’re using this as an apology to bash Jihyo and insult others
Thank you for clarifying I was so disappointed in her. But yeah she would never do that to their maknae.
I'm glad Tzuyu has a family friend that stands/stood up for her & speaks/spoke out/up about the mistreatment.
This has been on my country’s news because I’m ✨Taiwanese ✨
Has it really? Are people standing up for her there? ♡
@@seolarsi not sure but probably
1. Tzuyu is actually global ambassador for 'POND'S Bright Miracle. No, it's not a company like Rolex, but you can't say she's not an ambassador of any brand.
2. Tzuyu also attended Louis Vuitton 2020 Cruise Spin off Show in 2019 which is a not fashion week, but it's a fashion show.
3. No solo parts? What? She literally was the chorus in what is love. She also has a part in one spark, she's the buildup right before it's Chaeyoungs part. Lol.
But nobody wants to acknowledge facts. Just believe what they want to believe.
One thing about Tzuyu in Twice she has a good line development history
She improved so much and has gained so many parts coming from sounds like Knock knock and TT where her parts were smaller to set me free and one spark
If she'd been a korean person or maybe even Japanese, it would be wayyy more than these crumbs.
it's just that it's quite small compared to her juniors who have less experience and time, she is a respected senior from a MAJOR girl group, it was the nation's girl group and the it group of that gen, Tzuyu was one of the top beauties of her gen as well, she really should have such deals and schedules. but, i think it could be her personality that she is more quiet and reserved, such things may not spark her interest, it's hard to know since she is the member we know the least probably
@@aniolkaharmonia Yeah I agree, I mean, she hasn't really said anything about it on Bubble, at most, she basically posts pictures of her dogs. Which is fine because they're really adorable lol. But yeah, we really don't know and she isn't vocal like some of the members, she's pretty quiet.
@@imtherealone.6268 fr, like i wish it was easier to tell what she wants cos i could actually see it being possible that she prefers to not engage in too much idol activity, but i could also see it being a very real possibility that she feels surpressed. at the very least, though, she does engage in activities, like you listed above! it's not like she's locked up in the jyp dungeons
She has a point, Tzuyu deserves better.
i still dont get why its bad for her to raise her countrys flag....that whole thing made no sense.
Bc thats korean people racist😅imagine u are not korean but forced to act like u are korean😅JYP so mess it up bc make tzuyu to make force apologize..bro..JYP cant think??bro...how stupid was that..he is the CEO but he make stupid decision for his artist..
There is probably a big feud between China and Taiwan and since jyp don't wanna lose chinese fans, he forced her to apologize.
Because of China. China doesn't see Taiwan as a country, they see it as a rebellious province of China that they will use military force to bring in back inline. If you want to make most money you dont piss off china since you know they will buy huge amounts of albums, will sell out a stadium if they let you perform. So as a company who wants to keep doors open to China then forcing her to apologize makes sense, however the company knowing how China is should have had more foresight to begin with and should have helped tzuyu with her introduction.
China doesn't recognize Taiwan as an independent country, so Chinese fans were mad at her, and some still hate her to this day
@@floweryquetteYeah but even after that twice still got banned in China.
Taf, Tzuyu deserve better. She has been given such bad treatment in JYP Entertainment.
i can’t believe jihyo would agree to that…
Tbh same, like how...
what has happened???
@@user-ot4py3cm5m watch the video
Im so disappointed in jihyo
Yeah
Jype never let her shine she only renewed her contract bcz of group members
Why did jihyo agree to it???? Like... bro you're the most senior active group in the company, and you can't refuse to play a gag, that directly makes fun of one of the most traumatizing and humiliating moments of one of your group's members? you can't even say no? What is this? That was not very cash money of her
Yeah i don't understand why she woukd agree to do that i love jihyo and she has been one of the best leaders of kpop. I really don't understand hiw she agreed to do it .
well obviously twice jokes about that incident since Jihyo was joking about, she had had to get approval from Tzuyu to have done it.
@@xuoqq7930you don’t know that and I’m doubtful Tzuyu even knew about it, it’s still tasteless to do something like that
If they find this incident funny then they have a poor poor understanding of the world’s affairs. Tzuyu deserves better
@@OGseouliteso if we’re gonna assume that Tzuyu didn’t know about it how can we say that Jihyo did this because she wanted to? If they’re not allowed to assume that she knew about it then you’re not allowed to assume Jihyo did it willingly without being a hypocrite.
🇹🇼 Taiwan is its own country.
im proud to say my country recognize them. We greatly appreciate Taiwan and its people for always supporting my small country.
Taiwan doesn't have de jure independence. Less than 20 countries in the world recognize it, just because your country does does not make it a sovereign nation. And ironic you say Taiwan when you're using the Republic of China flag, which Taiwan even admits to being in its own constitution.
@@scholarssolutions6735that’s the Taiwan flag though 🙄
@@meganlee8235 I mean that kind of proves that Taiwan isn't its own country because they don't have their own flag. Their flag is the Republic of China's flag. There isn't one flag for the Republic of China and one for Taiwan. There's only one for both.
@@kayla68779 What are you on about? You do know that there’s 2 different flags right? 🇨🇳 = China 🇹🇼 = Taiwan
@@meganlee8235 China and the Republic of China are not the same thing. China is the People's Republic of China. The Republic of China is Taiwan. Only 12 countries recognize Taiwan as its own country. I suggest looking up the tensions between China and Taiwan. You will see the difference between the Republic of China and the People's Republic of China.
She is an ambassador for Ponds
I totally agree, tzuyu deserves more ❤
No one talks about how tzuyu is the visual but gets barely any screen time and it’s always pushed aside in the groups photos, she barely gets any lines and is always in the back in choreographys.
frfr
tzuyu is a true beauty, inside and out. i hope in future she is treated better.
In spite of facing all these mistreatments, Tzuyu decided to stay as Twice Member. She really loves Twice and Onces 🥺🥺🥺
Nah you idiit lmao she's just making money, she has nothing without Twice
Her personality is too shy for a solo activity. She is as pretty as a doll but that is all that there is to it. Her vocals are decent, but not strong enough for solo.
her being pretty is so good for her to be an ambassador for a brand like jyp just doesnt want to cus he sucks
I’ve ALWAYS thought how come she was never pushed like we see some idols everywhere nowadays and she was super super famous especially in the first couple of years she debuted. So sad..
Knowing Tzuyu’s insane popularity in S Korea it’s crazy that she’s not an ambassador of a brand.
She’s a true friend. But if that’s the case She’s being mistreated
Bro, Jihyo should NOT have recreated that knowing that Tzuyu was SIXTEEN when it happened.
Not trying to infantilize Jihyo but I don’t think she did it because she wanted to, I mean she’s her friend and friends don’t do that to each other.
But she did so now what? I’m so disappointed in her tbh, she’s the leader too WERE SO DOOMED
@@Plutoneedlove she stays the leader? Lmao, doomed is a strong word. as long as she doesn’t fuck shit up big time anymore then they’ll all be just fine with their careers and public appearance.
@@Bunny_xoxo. so since she did do it, I guess she isnt a real friend to Tzuyu
@@kpopggfan2524She never was and never cared, She always have been JYPs Obedient Girl.
Tzuyu often is called as a really natural beauty yet she doesn't have any brands of luxury house at all! She is like Yoona of SNSD.
I definitely agree with Matilda, although Tzuyu is the most biased member, she is so mistreated. Tzuyu has so much talent too.
Poor Tzuyu, I personally thought she was amazing in one spark.
she was really selfless when she renewed her contract- mistreated but knew her fans still wanted her to be in the group
Amen I agree with Matilda Tzuyu,s Mom
Jihyo didn’t remake Tzuyu’s apology video, she introduced herself as a new member of a variety show.
its so obvious on what she was trying to do and portray. the outfit, the hair, the script, almost everything resembled tzuyu’s apology
@@stansongjiaJihyo doesn’t pick the script, or the outfit, so it’s the staffs fault then
@@cosas_de_gatos she agreed to doing it 😭 it’s possible for her to say that she doesn’t want to do something even if yall think that the staff was the only part of this
Jihyo still has eyes and a brain, its very obvious what they were doing, yall need to stop infantilizing this grown woman acting like she cant put 2 and 2 together. The fans knew right away, do you think jihyo is dense enough to not have any idea? No right?
@@fjnxtgdjsjeeh6073or maybe yall cant just stfu and stop trying to paint ppl out to be what they aren't just because yall are fuckin stupid?
Jihyo should be ashamed of herself & JYPE absolutely needs to respect the foreign members more. It's actually so upsetting. First the elevator video, then the apology and her own leader is mocking her? Disgusting.
I agree with her. It's so cruel to make a joke out of that situation. Tzuyu had to apologize when she didn't do anything wrong, and she was harrased a lot online at a very young age. JYPE owes her an apology.
I think Tzuyu has been invited to fashion week around the globe but JYP chooses to send members like Dahyun or Momo instead for whatever reasons.
Taiwanese media said they had countless brands and TV shows and stuff approaching her for Taiwan promotions but it was all rejected... she renewed for twice only... they kinda has this 10 year promise ... maybe that's why.. Taiwanese media is the only one revealed of her opportunities being rejected ... God knows what else got rejected for her..
If you don't know anything shut your mouth. Don't drag momo and dahyun in in this mess
I always thought she had the potential to be a it girl like she perfect for it but she gets nothing like her company does not promote her or give her anything solo so it’s like they won’t let her even try to shine very weird
She does zooc advertisements from what i can tell and she currently is doing a solo event and pop store. So although shes not doing huge brands like fendi/prada she still has some that she gets asked for. Not all the members have big deals either so its a bit over protective. I get it since shes a friend of the mom, and i get why the mom complains too its her daughter her princess and wants the best. But looking outside of the box and being objective you can see she does get her chances to promote and do solo things too. As for the jihyo thing when i first saw the teaser it never reminded me of Tzuyu's apologies video so i can see how everyone involved missed it. Even side by side at start of this video it might look similar but gives off different vibes.
Tzuyu is already very popular but could’ve been made it so much bigger in the fashion industry and all if only she was actually treated right. Girly literally lost her spark, her confidence after that whole incident. People did support her later but never properly apologised and JYPE is holding her down very obviously. I agree with Matilda, Tzuyu deserves so much more.
I never seen Jihyo with her hair like that before EVER, she wouldn’t be happy her self if her past controversies were brought back right.
thats a real friend of her mother ong
Also tzuyu's line are so short in every song.
I think that tzuyu is a vital part of twice, along with every single member. But its the fact she is the most popular one in the group thats making JYP not want to promote her to avoid a Miss A incident. If she is already this popular, giving her more solo projects might make her overshadow the group. It might not feel fair but i think JYP is just trying to prevent any conflicts with twice's image
She renewed because her own vocals and stage presence isn't good enough for solo
Fans are really gullible 😂😂😂
It's always army 😭
@@angongd455 why do you think any opinions becomes invalid just because you belong to a different fandom like are we meant to deny facts?
@@zoi7582 shut up hater u said that she can't sing she is just a sub vocalist yet she outsing bts lead vocalist aka jimin
I always wondered why she never gets more marketing opportunities, her visuals and physique is literally the standard. 🤦♂️
Tzuyu deserves better and dont hate on JIHYO please it wasnt her fault. Its the production team's fault
She was only 16 at that time and they still make fun of her tsk...what a rude people
atp, i’m not really that surprised if kpop members who are not korean are being treated like this. this is practically an old song.
Yes she is right jyp never treat her well
tzuyu deserves better tbh 😭 matilda is an amazing person for that
tzuyu def deserves an apology, and if jihyo did agree to do that, that is actually so messed up. even if it is an inside joke, its not something u say to the lublic. If jihyo didnt agree but was forced to for the show, then i wont blame her but if she didnt im really dissapointed in her because she is the leader and doing this? not ok
Lol until she mentioned it i didnt realise how she isnt any brand ambassador or has any solo activities, fashion week etc. I fully expected her to be considering her visuals and popularity. Good on Matilda - shes well known in Taiwan too
the fact it was the friend of tzuyu’s mom that had to point
it out like? and why put Jihyo in that spot it isn’t funny idk if
jihyo was made to do it but where are the boundaries?
JYP GIVE TZUYU MORE SOLO PARTS
you give every other twice member promotions
what about Tzuyu and the fact she was so kind to
renew her contact for everyone else 🥹😭😭
JYP GIVE HER PROMOTION! 💀💀🥹🥹🥹😭😭😭😭
Tzuyu 🫶🫶🫶 We love you infinitely!
Tzuyu deserves better...
I really don't understand how could JYPE let this happen. I'm very disappointed at this.
Tbh the maknae line in twice deserves better they def can shine much brighter
tzuyu maybe pretty but her vocals and stage is not strong enough for solo activities. you can feel her shyness. it maybe attractive to a few but solo activities needs strong stage presence but she is good in fashion week instead of dahyun. but well it is the italians or parisians who select who they want to be ambassadors
I think Tzuyu needs to improve on SP as an opera singer and preformer myself, and she’s 100% not the most popular member. All members get promoted based on how much profits they make and not favouritism
Eh no she's definitely very very popular and constantly goes viral for her visuals. She literally wouldn't have gotten into Twice if it weren't for people wanting her to get in because she was so popular for being pretty.
@@scholarssolutions6735 Just becaue she's popular or goes viral doesn't mean her songs or fancams will go viral. Her stage presence reminds me of pre debut wonhee sometimes IMO
You're misinterpreting me and thinking that I meant that Tzuyu isn't popular. Sure, she is popular but definitely not for SP, vocals, or dance. She's not ready for a solo.
@@hayley4032 Lamo her famcam get the most views in twice her sp isn't that good but she have the most stable vocals in twice after 3mix
@@rathodlalita4926 Again I'm an opera singer, the reason you might think she's the most stable is because she's stiff. Her voice is the flattest in twice but her lower range is alright.
I'd say stability wise Mina and Chaeyoung beat her easily, but Tzuyu at least seems to have basic vocal skills after attending a concert from them a while back.
Also, I'm pretty sure Nayeon fancams had the highest views, at least for Alcohol free. Tzuyu was nowhere near the top three. The SP not being good is also the main reason she isn't getting solos so I still stand by my opinion. I love her but most idols work better as a group and YG is the only company that specifically invests in members so that they hold their own as soloists imo
@@hayley4032 lamo it was jihyo who has the most view famcam in alcohol free bc of her reveling outfit nothing else and jyp is trying so hard make nayoen the most popular member she have the best outfit in twice she get the most line even tho she isn't main vocalist she is always in center she have the most brand deal she get the most screen time while tzuyu doesn't get good outfit she get like 10 second line she barely get any scene time jyp doesn't give her any solo promotion even tzuyu's mother called out jyp for mistreated tzuyu still manage to be the most popular twice member bc she is it girl material while even sana is more popular then nayoen and pls go and check one spark mr remove video tzuyu was the only one singing clear and loud with 3 mix while mina didn't even try to sing same gosh to chae 😭 anyway u can't chang the fact that she is the most popular member in twice
now i understand why twice members have a group chat without jihyo
honestly, considering the treatment she got and being forced to apologize for that, i understand why people didn’t find it funny
Tzuyu had to make a full on apology JUST for raising her flag but Chaeyoung on the other hand...
I don't say Tzuyu apologizing for rasing her flag is good (and Tzuyu is my bias)but Chaeyoung doesn't need to apologize and you should probably move on from that incident if it doesn't affect or concern you
@@Thelma-gv5eooh so neo nazis aren’t supposed to apologize? chaeyoung is a grown woman who went through years of school and most likely learned about the holocaust in SEVERAL years of the schooling. it may not effect that one person but having the mindset of “it doesn’t effect me so it doesn’t matter just get over it” and spreading it around is so harmful and keeps the train of hate crimes, racism, xenophobia, zionism, and antisemitism going
@@stansongjia even I go through years of school but never heard of this "the holocast" situation and what do you expect from Chaeyoung that she give up on being an idol or she take her own life because of the hate,Yea she's a grown women who is uneducated and only went to high school for 5 days what do you expect to learn for those 5 days of schooling and then we went back to elementary school which is also a unnecessary because(if I'm not wrong)Korean kids need learn about their culture and history more than anything and that's what we did in India too.To say she learned about foreign affairs for Several years of schooling doesn't even make sense........and just by wearing that shirt doesn't mean she is a neo nazis,choose your words wisely before you speak
@@Thelma-gv5eo does hitler ring any bells to you? world war 2? 1940’s germany? some schools call it different things and refer to it in different ways.in most parts of the world the holocaust is taught in primary school and up so even if she only went to highschool for 5 days she should still know. i expect chaeyoung to understand the history and severity of her actions and apologize more than a few sentences after committing a hate crime and posting her antisemitism. if she had a history class in her many years of learning then she would know about the holocaust even if she was taught about korean culture first. to say that she is a neo nazi makes complete sense if you understand and know what was on her shirt and the severity of it
@@stansongjia 🤣🤣OK ok ok you won she should probably go to jail nah 😂😂
tzuyu has amazing visuals and a beautiful voice, i definitely believe she could’ve gotten a lot farther and gained much more recognition had she not been under JYP. i hope she doesn’t decide to renew her solo contract and does what’s best for her - she deserves so much more than what crumbs JYP is giving her.
What agency would she shine in then?
@@faceofvisionSM, HYBE.
@@OxygenC2 you need vocals to shine in sm 💀
@@faceofvision yeah in 2nd gen SM maybe. SM since 4th gen or so woild rather have lipsyncing than live pitch correction lololol
@@OxygenC2 first of all, sm has one 4th gen group and they clear most gg of the generation when they sing (even the rappers a decent vocalists) and it's not up to artists to chose of they sing live.
Second of all, Tzuyu is 3rd gen and she is around Yeri's level. Aka still the least "shining" one.
I always wondered why she wasn't an ambassador of a major brand, most of the time the visual/most popular member becomes an ambassador first in the group. Also I did notice how she barely has any solo activities, appearing on any show, modelling and advertising or attending fashion events. Its honestly sad cause I see all the other members having fun and getting all these opportunities when they aren't working as Twice but Tzuyu barely has any. I hope she leaves JYP or does smth abt this...
The friendship between members is very strong.
why would jihyo agree to sm like that... that is not funny...
Ya that's what I was thinking to like what the heck
She didn’t. She was not recreating the clip, it was just a comparison made by viewers
Omg , that’s actually true !! I never noticed she’s so popular visually yet no fashion brands nor collabs ??
Yup, because if they just promote her a bit more she will take over the whole industry
She might not have those solo activities because she doesn't want it. She might value the free time and limited travelling alot more than the constant schedule you get with being an ambassador and so on.
A black shirt on a white background is also not enough to say it was an intentional re-creation of her apology.
I'd want to hear this from Tzuyu before I belive it's a problem.
That’s why I was so surprise that POND’s Thailand managed to get her 🥹 my girl deserves so much better
Tzuyu doesn't have solo activities or brand deals yet New Jeans members had brand deals when they were still rookies! How is that fair? JYP needs to stop suppressing Tzuyu and I am so disappointed in Jihyo🥺
Why are you bringing newjeans and as once even i am disappointed in jihyo
@@kashvi4016 I mean no disrespect to NJ I am merely stating a fact👍🏾
makes me mad that jihyo did that knowing it was mocking not only tzuyu but also making light of something so serious that is still following tzuyu to this day. tzuyu deserves better
That apology was one of the most horrible things a rookie group had to do to appease the public. It was so dumb, they literally handed her two flags and she got hate for it. I am also weirded out that anyone thought making fun of it was a good idea, it was literally a forced apology video and she looked like she had been crying
Tbh, if i were Tzuyu i don't think i would've stayed with jyp......... Don't get me wrong ! I don't want her to leave. Never. However, throughout her idol career and life, i feel like she's been very mistreated like this video says ( few lines, no solo activities, forcing her to appologize for nothing,...) even though she's the most popular member. I get that, to most, she's not the most talented but she can sing and can dance and has outstanding visuals, she should be able to shine in comebacks. Also as a huge patriotist who loves her country more than anything i'd be really upset about appologizing for waving my country's flag ngl. So #JusticeforTzuyu ❤
Man imagine you worked and practiced you butt off training only to be treated badly by our company!
I don’t know how this was approved and allowed to air. Did they not think of the public’s reaction to this? Even though the members may have moved on from it, it’s still a serious and offensive issue in Kpop. It shouldn’t be mocked.
If she was given opportunities by JYP, she'd be thriving. What excuse JYP can give at this point? They're now a senior group and her scandals are way back. I'm curious what she asked in her contract tho to renew.
I never knew she didn't have any brand endorsement.. she is always sidelined in the group but I never knew she didn't have any brands with her popularity looks and height...
Tzuyu is (no offense) the most beautiful member of twice? How does she not been to a fashion event on her own? How is she not an ambassador?? She's beyond gorgeous
her mom is just speaking facts as for jihyo, very disappointed in her. I mean she knew it was a serious time in her life. disrespectful
Tzuyu is daughter of wealthy parents. I doubt that her parents will let her be mistreated or suppressed to sign another contract with JP and not help her and recommend her to go to other companies.
Her family is in Taiwan being rich in Taiwan doesn't mean much in Korea also anything they do need jypes approval... its contract afterall...
it's ok. Miss Tzuyu is probably richer than all your favs combined. She ll be fine
My fave is Dara. That would be impossible 😅
@@OxygenC2srry.....who dara?
Are you talking about Dara from 2NE1
@@Marissory yes
High wealth does not equal great mental health.
Don't be dim.
Lol what kind of leader will agree to even be involved in any program that says to make fun about something that is so personal and serious to their own group member who they've been with for almost a decade (atp they're more family than co workers) let alone do the acting themselves and shoot it all and then agree to upload it ..... didn't expect this from jihyo
How is a company going to debut nine members but never treat them with equity
5:00 nah it’s Psy, and he was so funny for that😭 when I saw that long ago I was laughing my ass off and not really cringing at it
STAN AUNTIEEE🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣❗️❗️❗️❗️❗️
she spoke facts it needed to be said
I had no idea her name was cheweee I’ve been calling her tizz uweee or tizz uww you this entire time 😅
She agreed to re sign for the group not for her self. JYP continues to treat her terribly and yet she smiles and keeps working. No solos no ambassador brands and never goes to fashion week when the rest of them do. The worst is Jihyo, her Leader agreeing to do that stupid parody. More reasons to always Support Her and not JYP. Very disappointed in the company and the group.
Agree. Jyp and her member jihyo too
Jihyo would NEVER do that. There were unintentional similarities to the apology video therefore it was taken down and the production apologized. Jihyo did nothing wrong and the teaser was not made as a joke or a replica, there was absolutely no correlation intentionally.
The fact is, except for Sana, most of the members don't have really luxury brand endorsements like Blackpink. So, I'm not sure what that's about. Did every member of Twice have a solo? Are we trying to make something out of nothing?
Chewy is so kind 🥺🥺 she love nayeon 😭