It's about stupidity. Crowds of such 'stars' that left Russia 2 months ago are whining and want to come back. But the point is the audience doesn't want their performances.
Ballerinas are NOT delicate. They a fierce and strong. These individuals will take you out. I appreciate this story. I dislike your wording. These athletes are beautiful, exquisite, giant tolerance for pain, disciplined, elegent, & well honed, fighters. I'm glad you covered this, I've been worried.
As a former professional ballet dancer, I am so proud of those in the dance community like Olga Smirnova and Alexei Ratmansky who, with great courage and love, have taken a stand against the insanity of war, and have taken their art and beauty beyond the shadow of a ruthless dictator...
@@DianaMoon11428 the war crimes, the intentions behind the different conflicts and the repercussions they had globally are key when you make a distinction and we must. You can’t compare these wars. Your assumption that I supported any of the US wars is wrong. But bringing them up here doesn’t negate the facts about the Ukraine and the shameful, cruel, inhumane crimes the Russians are committing. It’s despicable and it’s breaking the world.
First things first. Olga and Sergei's decision are really courageous. Humanity. That's it. Secondly. I'm not even a ballet dancer or choreographer but to say I'm heartbroken is an understatement.
I really enjoyed Polina’s story. She is such a charming, poised, confident, and focused young lady and her English is excellent. I really hope she can flourish as a dancer at the Dutch ballet and go on to a strong career.
this brought such a lump to my throat... Polina taking her mom's perfume to remind her of home was so poignant. And the beauty these dancers are creating and preserving. . the heart of humanity is in the arts and these people are all (in different ways) sacrificing and striving to protect that heart. . .
The arts will survive. Sending love to all artists who are suffering. I’m so happy for those who have made it to safety. Thank you to all the ballet dancers of the world, making our world more beautiful. xoxoxox
@@QQnowQQlater Both of the statements you said are false. If you define a job as something you can make a living off of, there are more than enough artists living solely off of income they derived from their artistic endeavors. Same with people who play esports or are professional video game testers. Your notion of a "real" job is completely arbitrary
Olga Smirnova is one of my heros. Thank you, Olga, for the great sacrifices you've made in order to loudly and clearly denounce Putin's ugly and brutal invasion of a neighboring country. You are a beacon of peace in this horrible conflict.
All the more poignant when you realize just how brainwashed and disconnected half the Russian population have become under putin and his strictly controlled propaganda media
These ballet dancers are incredible! They are unbelievably strong, although they look fragile on stage. "At least I can be honest with myself " - one of the most difficult things in life.
I really do applaud this young women’s strength and courage. I apply it to all of these talented dancers and choreographers featured here. It could not have been easy to sacrifice everything. you see her pain she allows herself to be vulnerable and I so appreciate her honesty. She hit the nail on the head, if you’re not a soldier even if you’re not Putin if but you’re Russian it hurts to having to watch people made to suffer in the name of your country
@@manfredneilmann4305 Thank you kindly! I am disabled, so I get confused sometimes. I will try to be more careful from now on. English is also my second language
@@evelynvongizycki1017 you are incredibly gracious! Way more than I would have been. Your English and punctuation is better than a lot of native American English speakers. (I use the word “native” here to mean people who were born (native = born) in a place that speaks American English; I don’t mean Native Americans, the indigenous people of the Americas.) Keep on commenting! You are fantastic!
@@SharynS. Thanks for all the love here. I cry and cry for my friends still in the Ukraine. One of them is so brave he is reporting from there and has interviewed Zelenskyy and is on CNN the other day. Thank you for all of the support
One now old former dancer. I wonder what has happened to her. Natalia Makarova. She fled in 1970 to the West and had a 19-year career there. Returned in 1989 to then Leningrad, now St. Petersburg and have had a long career since then, instructing Russian and other nationalities dancers. Until the 24th. of February. If there is somebody truly heartborken, is her, I can bet on it. She's and old woman now and wouldn't want to flee again, I guess. Sigh.
Not everybody is a hero. It takes a lot of courage to leave all behind: family, work, house, friends, pets, your city, your personal history, your whole life!
To me they do not look fragile. A fragile body cannot perform the way they do. They are strong in body and in mind. While also having a sense for music, poetry and emotion. Harder than any sports that just relies on strength.
Wow.. this is powerful and everyone in this piece is grounded in their feelings and their decisions to take a stand. I congratulate them for having the courage of their convictions. I pray for great happiness and success for All of these people .
A simple description of these wonderful people-COURAGE, RESILIENCE despite pain, INTEGRITY through willingness to face down ruthless power. God Bless Them.
I cannot enough express my admiration for her brave stand. She will always know that when it counted she did the right thing, made the difficult choice. She has not sold her soul. It will show in her art.
Right?. I certainly do. In these days I remember ho much I love so many facets from Russian culture and art. The basso-profondos. Their cinema (you have to see the Shakesperean adaptations, fabulous). My beloved Tschaikovsky, and Rimsky-Korsakov, Borodin. And....I remind myself that Prokofiev was....Ukrainian (during Soviet times). and that there both Russian AND Ukrainian cossacks, singing to their banduras and all. Until 24th. of February I had the pleasure of watching "Coppelia" presentation back in 2007 starring Osipova at the Bolshoi. And now I...cry. The formidable Nutcracker adagio, at Act second which starts the pas-de-deux...man, the same. A kind of painful mourning if you undesrstand what I mean.
Huge respect for those parents and professionals that are putting their names on the line to keep their kids safe not only now, but to keep their passion and livelihood going.
@@kdub10009 lmao "in your opinion"? And you are who, precisely? Why should anyone take your opinion on ballet seriously? It's a no-name hovel in comparison with the Bolshoi.
@@sarahpengelly8439 Even an anonymous RUclips commenter, without establishing themselves as an art history expert, can tell you the difference in merit between a Rembrandt and some second-rate artist from the current period, or the difference between the Cannes and some local student film festival. The same applies to this.
well, they're certainly not playing swan lake, they wouldn't want to send that message. the swan lake broadcast thing was because it was the designated place holder in later years of the soviet union for when big things were happening and the party was still busy figuring out what to do and what to tell the people. it wasn't broadcast to signify crisis, it was broadcast at times of crisis when they didn't know what to broadcast. TV rain made swan lake their last broadcast from russia though
well, they're certainly not playing swan lake, they wouldn't want to send that message. the swan lake broadcast thing was because it was the designated place holder in later years of the soviet union for when big things were happening and the party was still busy figuring out what to do and what to tell the people. it wasn't broadcast to signify crisis, it was broadcast at times of crisis when they didn't know what to broadcast. TV rain made swan lake their last broadcast from russia thoughwell, they're certainly not playing swan lake, they wouldn't want to send that message. the swan lake broadcast thing was because it was the designated place holder in later years of the soviet union for when big things were happening and the party was still busy figuring out what to do and what to tell the people. it wasn't broadcast to signify crisis, it was broadcast at times of crisis when they didn't know what to broadcast. TV rain made swan lake their last broadcast from russia thoughwell, they're certainly not playing swan lake, they wouldn't want to send that message. the swan lake broadcast thing was because it was the designated place holder in later years of the soviet union for when big things were happening and the party was still busy figuring out what to do and what to tell the people. it wasn't broadcast to signify crisis, it was broadcast at times of crisis when they didn't know what to broadcast. TV rain made swan lake their last broadcast from russia thoughwell, they're certainly not playing swan lake, they wouldn't want to send that message. the swan lake broadcast thing was because it was the designated place holder in later years of the soviet union for when big things were happening and the party was still busy figuring out what to do and what to tell the people. it wasn't broadcast to signify crisis, it was broadcast at times of crisis when they didn't know what to broadcast. TV rain made swan lake their last broadcast from russia thoughwell, they're certainly not playing swan lake, they wouldn't want to send that message. the swan lake broadcast thing was because it was the designated place holder in later years of the soviet union for when big things were happening and the party was still busy figuring out what to do and what to tell the people. it wasn't broadcast to signify crisis, it was broadcast at times of crisis when they didn't know what to broadcast. TV rain made swan lake their last broadcast from russia though This they're certainly not playing swan lake, they wouldn't want to send that message. the swan lake broadcast thing was because it was the designated place holder in later years of the soviet union for when big things were happening and the party was still busy figuring out what to do and what to tell the people. it wasn't broadcast to signify crisis, it was broadcast at times of crisis when they didn't know what to broadcast. TV rain made swan lake their last broadcast from russia though
Makes you wonder if they would be more competitive as a nation to allow Nationals worldwide to represent them on an international stage like the Olympics. ...like other countries do.
It would have been more of a loss if the whole Ballet Company upped and left and said FU Putin in the process. But of course the Bolshoi as noted was used by the Tsar and the Soviet Leadership etc, as firstly a source of prestige and secondly to put on ballet’s with a propaganda/ political message . To tell the world and the populace how good they have it.
@@sandgroper1970 true!. However, over a 100 defecting to dance in other countries is a substantial, and the ones who left to fight for Ukraine, and their tour being canceled, has got to hurt.
This is an incredible program, thank you for providing it to us. One dancer leaves to save his country, another very young dancer is pushed west by her family to save her life, and another, a prima ballerina with the world at her feet, leaves to save her soul. I pray this insane attack on Ukraine ends, and all three of these dancers along with the others who have fled or who are fighting, will soon be together to dance on stage, exorcising their pain and celebrating the victory of free people over oppressors.
Unfortunately, Svetlana Zakharova, one of the main ballerinas of the Bolshoi, is 100% Ukrainian (from Lutsk), and is, disgustingly, a huge Putin supporter. :(
@@JayChoi1118 Try Googling Zakharova and Putin and see how many photos come up. She spoke out in favor of annexing Crimea and in support of the DPR. Both her and her husband are listed as being those who've participated in pro-war events. She was banned from returning to Ukraine due to her pro-Putin activities.
It's good that people in the arts are taking a stand! Like he says; it's about humanity and cannot be just written off as "politics". Citizens all need to do their part to hold their government accountable. Apathy is the enemy of righteousness. Although it may be uncomfortable to question authority in such an environment people must be willing to do that for the higher purpose of defending humanity, and must condemn inhumanity. No leader is worth leaving one's conscience at the door.
I just watched some interviews with relatives of russian soldiers who died in ukraine. one of them (a mother I think) said that the russian soldiers are there to "defend peace", and when asked who they are defending russia against, she said "I don't know anything about politics". 👁👄👁
@@Ass_of_Amalek at least the son of the Russian mother did not die in vain.. unlike the Ukrainians.. His mother was right.. I'm sure western media didn't tell you UkrainianAzofNazis killed 14 thousand ethnic russian Ukrainianskis since they broke the Minsk peace agreement in 2008 As an American, I'd love To be in the right but haven't since WW2
it’s heartbreaking for the ballet community and it’s heartbreaking to see what’s happening. russia is a big part of ballet history and to see its performers ashamed of it makes my heart ache. i love ballet and it’s a big part of my life and i’ve been wondering what’s going to happen to ballet during these troubling times. for a lot of us ballet dancers ballet is life and it’s hard to do anything else. we eat sleep and breathe ballet. i’m glad that she’s trying to get these young dancers out of that situation so they can dance again. one split second decision can change so many lives. it’s awful that these kids have to go through this. ballet shouldn’t be used as a weapon. any dance style shouldn’t be used as a weapon and it makes me so sad to see this beautiful art form has been turned into this weapon. i’m glad that these people have been able to escape and be able to continue with their passion and the thing they love.
War is always ugly anywhere for whatever reason. However, the Russian people we should not dislike ! Russian musicians are banned, like wonderful Alexander Malofeev in Canada ! Never mix politics with the Arts. Also Russian Ballet dansers, writers, musicians etc. bring their love and dedication to a darkened world as comfort and light. We should respect them and never hate them, because they have nothing to do with war. When pianist Malofeev was cancelled after he arrived in Canada he said:" All there is left for me to do is pray and cry". He is 20 ! (Holland)
Highest regards to Madame Olga Smirnov and Mr. Ratmansky. I love and admire both of their works and so very proud that I could also be proud of their humanity in the face of adversity. There are some other ballet dancers who left their positions in Russia and either back to their country of origin or defected in a sense to other companies around the world. Yet there are other dancers who aren't Russians who didn't want leave the best ballet school in the world (there are many comparable schools in the world) and didn't want to waste many years of training there already. I know there're some Japanese dancer who couldn't bare to leave the company in Rossia or throw away the opportunity to work in Bolshoi or Mariinsky after graduating from their schools. There are times when you need to make a stand as Mr. Ratmansky said in the interview. Do you stand for humanity or dictatorship ?
it's easy to say when you have a chance just to take a taxi and go to NY. And - he is good and makes the right choice, doesn't matter that he made money there right before the war, it was ok for him to work in dictatorship, but simple people will be blamed for not having chance to move to another country. I adore this modern hypocrisy and victim blaming.
@@akam1779 I don't think it's hypocrisy modern or old. And who is victim here ? The real victims are the ppl getting killed by Russian dictatorship. The fact Russian government makes their citizens from all walks of life to choose by stepping on an icon. It was called FUMIE (stepping picture ) of Madonna or Crist on cross and if refuse you're killed in Edo era. it's a modern world now so you don't have to dedicate your life for these choices but simply moving elsewhere there're ways to do that. You watch Evgeny Pulshenko of skating fame going gun ho on nationalistic pride. And bad mouthing those who do not agree and stand by his side. He's lost my respect right away. An Olympian who should be enlightened by going all over the world yet he disregards the idea of freedom and democratic ideas. Simpleton who are brain washed after all.
@@mikiohirata9627 the fact that you say "simply moving elsewhere" shows that you don't understand that moving to another country is whatever but not "simple". This "simply" sounds like mocking. Actions make people bad, not passports or the place of birth. I know plenty of good brave people in Russia, and I know plenty of stupid infantile and unkind people from "good" countries. And I don't see anything impressive in the action of this choreographer - there's nothing impressive in taking a plane to the country where you've already had a job.
there are many dancers that have family and lives - careers in Russia that don't approve of Putin's war that are being used as political pawns. It is not so easy to just say, "I must get out and leave everything." You cannot uniformly say they are all supporting this war and want it to persist. If they do speak against it they will be punished. They are caught trying to survive just like many others. Hopefully the stupidity and pointlessness of this war will end soon and these artists can continue to pursue their careers without the same spotlight of politics.
So glad.that there are Russian's standing up for what is Right & standing up Against Putin. I pray that Putin is taken out of power quickly for the good of Everyone ✨🙏✨
Russian ballet has survived the Revolution, World War I, World War II, and politics. Interesting to hear Smirnova say... NO REGRET, as loud as ballet throughout world history. Since selection as students, these incredible dancers privileged by the gods have built that fortress but let's not forget that the Russian people have had a long history since the tsars and since then they have endured the attacks and doctrines of heinous governments. My first ballet teacher was Russian, a beautiful lady with deep blue eyes. She used to cry when memories of her land in Russia invaded her thoughts, every day. Unpleasant memories of when the government took everything from her family and despite that, she missed her homeland. I always wondered what would happen to the ballet, what would happen to the dancers in the Ukraine war. May peace come as soon as possible for the Ukrainians
How does One send peace... Please don't say thoughts and prayers. Jah love rastafari praises blessings Tucson Arizona Sonoran desert 🏜️ Jah sisters Jah jerrymylitis Jah everything everyone solidarity
@@pango-y8j There are many ways to “send peace”. It doesn’t always mean LITERAL. Sometimes you need to understand semantics. And please enlighten me with all this JAH jargon you intertwined within your sentences. It doesn’t make any sense. 🤷🏻♂️ Peace be with you 🌴☀️🌴
There is one more dancer who has suffered from the war, it is Artem Datsyshyn, from National Opera and Ballet Theatre, who was killed by Russian occupants. I believe he deserves to be mentioned in context of war & ballet. I'm quite (not) surprised though that all the praise in comments under this video goes to Olga Smirnova, who decided to leave the country and her theatre when all the foreign performances of Bolshoi were cancelled. At the same time, Oleksii Potiomkin who had to stop his work to save the country, is barely mentioned in the comments. Oleksii and many other Ukrainian dancers don't know when they will be able to dance again. Artem will never dance again. And still, all the attention and sympathy goes to Russian dancer who had to change her workplace because the previous one became less convenient. This is how imperialism works.
Thanks for this comment!! Indeed loss of Ukrainian people is incomparable. But most of the commentators seem to be blinded. Or just working for Russian propaganda.
I totally agree with you. Moreover, we should consider that "moving to another country from Russia" is more often is just a matter of saving oneself than a political statement.
I don't think calling it less convenient is fair. She left her home, her family etc. And I think it's difficult to speak out when you're surrounded by propaganda. But I still agree. We should mention and focus on the Ukrainian dancers. They deserve our support.
@@leonamay8776 Thank you for your support! By "less convenient" I meant that Bolshoi had to cancel their performances abroad, which surely affects the career of the dancers who stayed there.
"She said, at least I can be honest with myself". Smirnova lives her truth, and by being honest with herself, it makes her a fair person. And it will be easier for her, to find peace. I admire Smirnova very much.
It’s so sad 😞. These dancers are absolutely incredible. They work willingly SOOO hard . And the Russian Ballet is truly spectacular. Putin is distorting the foundation of culture in his own country. Changing it in to a world of paranoia and fear of the outside world. A man’s Actions, mirrors that man’s true nature
@@anomanderrake3593 What is your point? Why do you keep trying to change the subject? No matter what one said or didn't say about a different situation; it doesn't justify Russia's having invaded Ukraine and destroying everything and everyone in sight.
@@anomanderrake3593 what are you rabbiting on about. Some of my best friends are Syrian Christian refugees. Who had to leave Syria because their OWN GOVERNMENT completely destroyed their home and huge areas where they lived on the pretext that ISIL was 'hiding' in those suburbs. But they vehemently say that was an out right lie and that is was because it was a Christian area. There was noting to do with NATO just the Syrians with the help of Russia causing more destruction in the fake pretext of 'fighting ' ISIL' ( The family DOES NOT call the terrorists ISIS and say that Russia and the Syrian Governments were terrorists too as much as ISIL. You need to get the information from the real refugees not fake news
@@micheledix2616 Thank you for telling the truth about the situation with refugees in Siria.. Russia is also highly responsible for chaos in there, pretending to fight with Isis, but being no better than terrorist themselves.. And this despicable WAGNER people,who basically just killing Sirian civilians.. Real mess and distraction only brought by those russian army
Be clear- the world is not against Russia - but Putin's aggression . The BEST of Russia is its high culture - which it shares with the world. All this is at risk of being undone by a return to a backward - looking quasi soviet state... Artists are amongst those needed to help push Russia into a peaceful, co-operative future ...hopefully.
Well, the West was always against Russia. Look how many European powers have tried to conquer Russia. You will get to look why Russia hates West so much? Why they are paranoid of West? Why they have huge distrust towards West? The West is always out there to destroy Russia. In fact, Harry Truman once said that Russia if divided into multiple smaller countries will be easy to be manipulated.
Unfortunately, too much of its high culture has been co-opted by the government. There are terrific artists who have spoken out against their countries aggression, but they're rapidly losing their place in Russia's remaining civil society.
@@kabardinka1 the point is this high culture now exist only in closed groups, what is, unfortunately, the minority of the population in the state. moreover, there are mostly in cities such as Saint-P and Moscow(
Unfortunately, it is not Putin who raped and tortured thousands of Ukrainians. According to different independent researches, more than 70% of Russians support war (and this is more than 100 mln people). They are the carriers of that cultural code, as well. There have been many great Russian writers, compositors, ballerinas, of course. However, this "high culture" has been largely instrumentalized. I believe one of the reasons why the world was not acting against the invasion of 2014 is because of that culture, that was promoted largely abroad. Part of oil money went on weapons, but part was spent on promoting of Russian culture abroad. I just wish people were more conscious of the imperialist nature of Russian culture. I wish people who read Dostoyevsky knew that the same years that his biggest works were written, there have been few laws issued that forbade publishing of books in Ukrainian language in the whole empire. I wish people knew some of xenophobic and ukrainophobic texts of the same big and famous Russian writers. And question whether Putin and 100 mln of Russians and the culture can exist as totally separate units that don't have any impact between them. Whether it is accidental that Russian leaders constantly show aggression against Ukrainian people? If it is just Putin's aggression, and before it was just Stalin's terror, and before it was just Katherine's imperialism... Blaming just one person for all the crimes is a comfortable position, but it opens little perspective for discussion and possible future change.
It's amazing to see how the dance community is helping fellow dancers to escape to somewhere safe. I love to see how quick to action the community was to helping...how small and tight knit the communityh is and yet it can change and help the lives of how many dancers. I just wish they could transport the families as well. The Russian dancer...I hope she knows that not everyone only sees her as Russian and has anger with her because of that.At least for me...I feel for the average Russian people because they are suffering and will continue to suffer because of what their government has decided to do.
Some wonderful news for a change in this dreadful period in our lives……these dancers have dance in their blood and are incredible….it’s so good that this window shows a certain number being given the chance to still follow their dreams. I wish them all the very best, and hope their families stay safe. Godbless them all. 🙏🙏🙏🙏💕💐💐💐
Whenever I see these instances of how bravely the people of Ukraine are standing up for their country against the toughest of odds, it gives me hope for the future of our humanity. We salute you, and your brave struggle will never be forgotten. Slava Ukraine!!
Not a single american singer, artist, sportsman was questioned about wars in Iraq, Syria, Afghanistan, Yemen, Lybia. Not a single made any statement or provided any comments.
There is a line from a Country Western song, sorry but I can''t ask the author of the song it goes something like this "You have to stand for something or you will fall for anything". These people stood for something, they will not fall!
RESPECTS and GOD'S EYE'S and BLESSINGS!!!!! FOR ALLLL THESE PEOPLE. Please GOD OOOOH HOLY FATHER GOD IN HEAVEN THAT NEVER SLUMBERS SEND LOTS LEGIONS OF ANGELS TO WATCH OVER ALL THESE RUSSIANS AND UKRAINIAN BALLETDANCERS. THANK YOU AMSTERDAM FOR HELPING THESE DANCERS WITH COMFORT IN THEIRE MINDS. HOLLAND ALWAYS HAS A HEART FOR THOSE WHO ARE IN NEED. INDEED HOLLAND IS VERY GENEROUS.🏆🏆🏆 THANK YOU HOLLAND. GOD BLESS YOUR PEOPLE WHEREVER THEY ARE. 🎉🎉🎉🏆🏆🏆🏆😍😍😍😍 THANKS for sharing this with the WORLD.
The line Russia crossed was the border with Ukraine. I was previously all in favour of drawing Russia closer to Europe, since we share so much culture and history. The invasion was the line crossed for me too.
Russia is still a beautiful country; their culture is very interesting and the people in general are very nice. I kinda feel sorry for them, as Russia is led by a complete madman, who cares nothing about Russia or its people, unless it also benefits himself.
@@DanielBrongers Your perception of Russia is distorted as it has been distorted for a long time for most of western people. Russia is not what you think it is and it's not about Putin and his gang at power at all. Russia is the last Empire. Dostojevski wanted to believe that evil comes to Russia from outside world but even he was convinced later that Russia itself is evil. I'm glad that it became obvious to the civilized world now. If even for a short period of time but still. Most of russians want ukrainians to suffer, most of them want collective west to suffer as well and they support Putins efforts with all their heart. Today. After Ukraine's win they start to look for guilty ones and their new leader will say that evil Putin is the only person to blame. And soft west agrees with this conseption. No Nuremberg 2.0, no nothing.
As a Russian, I am very happy that we are drawing away from Europe and its culture of capitalism, racism, and exploitation. We don't need any of that. We'll be happy with the rest of the subaltern around the world.
@@an-eh2wn So part of your happy non-capitalistic, non-racist, non-exploited world is to brutalise other people, even those of the same background and cultural history as you?
You are an individual. Countries all have had bad leaders at certain time look at Germany for example. But we don't hate Russians or any other countries people. Only the individuals from any country that do terrible things. So hold your head up high. Your an awesome person and a true Russian. I'm from New Zealand. ❤️ A few bad people doesn't make everyone from a place. Bless you.
i remember watching the Bolshoi Theatre when in Melbourne back in 2018. Back then, life seemed so carefree. their elegant moves made me realise how beautiful ballet. one day, i want to go again and see it. Ballet moves you and its heartbreaking whats happening there in Russia/Ukraine.
@@anomanderrake3593 This thread is about Russia and Ukraine, not Afghanistan, Libya, Syria or NATO. Posts involving them have no place here; but yes, inhumane acts anywhere by anyone is a problem. At the same time, one bad action does not justify another.
@@djondjon Of course, hypocrites only care about Ukraine and no others. Do you know that the US is still occupying Iraq and Syria? Do you know that 400k people have died in Yemen because of Saudi Arabia whom NATO supports? You don't care of course.
‘...dealings with artists, for instance, require great prudence; they are acquainted with all classes of society, and for that reason dangerous; they are hardly ever satisfied, and when you have too much to do with them, you are sure to have des ennuis (trouble)’ - King Leopold of Belgium to England's Queen Victoria, 10 October 1845
Paulina I want to give her a hug. I hope she reads Pink Club by Emma Bruce it shows anyone not just dancers to never give up their dreams. The story follows a dancer but some of the life experiences she goes through in sure many will find relatable.
Horrible discrimination against Russian ballet artists and anything Russian no excuse for it, on either side to use it politically. Russian ballet will always be the best that's for sure.
What courage these people have to stand against that murderous dictator. Wonder how such a thing would be played out in USA, we may get that opportunity sooner than later the way the GOP and ignorant mentality is prevalent in this country.
And then I heard 'n.55 goes to Stuttgart', and it brought memories from the past, almost 40 years ago, when I was in my second year at that school, sneaking upstairs to get a glimpse on the 'older' students: at that time, there was an exchange / collaboration between the John-Cranko school and a Russian ballet, I think it was the Kirov. There was still the cold war and the wall in Berlin standing, but nonetheless, ballet made it possible...
Yes these people are rich and beautiful and spoiled, but their art is necessary for humanity. Humans need rocket scientists, and ballet dancers, and comedians, in order to have a reason to get up in the morning and have meaning in life. Abstract thinking is what gave humans language and tool making and started on the path off of the savannas and into the first cities. Turning our backs on it would end civilization and put us back 10 thousand years. Humanity would also collapse without farmers and nurses and carpenters and retail workers, you need both for progress.
rich and spoiled? Surely you're not talking about the dancers. Most professional ballet dancers make very low salaries compared to the hard work and hours they put in.
Very few if them are "rich and spoiled" but they are all dedicated and hard-working. The most dedicated, hard-working and talented may become famous, rich etc, but very few compared with top professional sports/music people etc - why single these peaceful people out? Bombing schools, hospitals, cities and villages to bits is a much better way of contributing to society.
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
This is making me cry.
“Doesn’t matter what they have to do, they have to dance.”
The words of true fellow passionate professionals.
Exactly. Let them dance. No journalist should stop them.
Ballet is ALL
This made me cry really. I am also a ballet dancer and this is just 😭
@@t3x14s Well done. All we can do is promote peace... and improve technique! :)
Pure wisdom from the ex- Bolshoi choreographer about why he had to leave Russia - 'This is not about politics, this is about humanity....'
It's about stupidity. Crowds of such 'stars' that left Russia 2 months ago are whining and want to come back. But the point is the audience doesn't want their performances.
Ballerinas are NOT delicate. They a fierce and strong. These individuals will take you out. I appreciate this story. I dislike your wording. These athletes are beautiful, exquisite, giant tolerance for pain, disciplined, elegent, & well honed, fighters. I'm glad you covered this, I've been worried.
I have to agree with you.
My cousin Crissy is a stunningly beautiful girl
and Professional Ballerina. Her strength is incredible.
As a former professional ballet dancer, I am so proud of those in the dance community like Olga Smirnova and Alexei Ratmansky who, with great courage and love, have taken a stand against the insanity of war, and have taken their art and beauty beyond the shadow of a ruthless dictator...
Beautifully put.
You. I've Seen you! You Have my Heart ❤️
Did you say the same when the US invaded Iraq?
@@DianaMoon11428 your whataboutism is misplaced.
@@DianaMoon11428 the war crimes, the intentions behind the different conflicts and the repercussions they had globally are key when you make a distinction and we must. You can’t compare these wars. Your assumption that I supported any of the US wars is wrong. But bringing them up here doesn’t negate the facts about the Ukraine and the shameful, cruel, inhumane crimes the Russians are committing. It’s despicable and it’s breaking the world.
First things first. Olga and Sergei's decision are really courageous. Humanity. That's it.
Secondly. I'm not even a ballet dancer or choreographer but to say I'm heartbroken is an understatement.
Their tragedy. Your drama.
Sergei Poulenin is my God
I'm just a little American Girl... but ballet is Mine...
You Have to Dance...
The name of the choreographer is not Sergei. He's name is Alexei Ratmanski
I really enjoyed Polina’s story. She is such a charming, poised, confident, and focused young lady and her English is excellent. I really hope she can flourish as a dancer at the Dutch ballet and go on to a strong career.
She is just a stupid as Yeltsin and she a thing without dignity
Dutch is Great
She will flourish, of that I am sure.
Dutch ballet? Does such a thing exist?
@@Milava-zq5xu No.
this brought such a lump to my throat... Polina taking her mom's perfume to remind her of home was so poignant. And the beauty these dancers are creating and preserving. . the heart of humanity is in the arts and these people are all (in different ways) sacrificing and striving to protect that heart. . .
It takes a lot to make this leathery old bear cry but the perfume did it.
The arts will survive. Sending love to all artists who are suffering. I’m so happy for those who have made it to safety. Thank you to all the ballet dancers of the world, making our world more beautiful. xoxoxox
who cares. art isn't a real job... like playing video games...
@@QQnowQQlater Big misunderstanding! Art is totally different from playing video games.
@@JayChoi1118 literally just as useless. Get a real job.
@@QQnowQQlater who cares about your opinion? Replying to comments on RUclips isn’t a real job either…
@@QQnowQQlater Both of the statements you said are false.
If you define a job as something you can make a living off of, there are more than enough artists living solely off of income they derived from their artistic endeavors. Same with people who play esports or are professional video game testers. Your notion of a "real" job is completely arbitrary
It's so refreshing to see people with integrity and courage being celebrated again.
Olga Smirnova is one of my heros. Thank you, Olga, for the great sacrifices you've made in order to loudly and clearly denounce Putin's ugly and brutal invasion of a neighboring country. You are a beacon of peace in this horrible conflict.
Huge respect for this people who fight against this horrible war and huge respect for the Russian ballerina. 💙💛❤
But it was and is okay to hate on Germans because of Hitler,pssh
@@SpaceRanger187 nobody said that?
That last statement Smirnova made, "At least I can be honest with myself" sent chills down my spine.
All the more poignant when you realize just how brainwashed and disconnected half the Russian population have become under putin and his strictly controlled propaganda media
These ballet dancers are incredible! They are unbelievably strong, although they look fragile on stage. "At least I can be honest with myself " - one of the most difficult things in life.
@Yes 973 because they aren’t soldiers. And also because it takes more then soldiers to win a war
"At least I can be honest with myself" - Bravo Smirnova and Ratmansky! You inspire and empower so many with your words and actions!
"..at least, I can be honest with myself" - я горжусь тобой, Оленька 💟
Bravo!
You can't help but feel proud of her morals and proud of all the good Russian people that are against this Invasion.
Those words are so very true , "Be true to yourself," so so lacking in our own government....
@@theodoresweger4948 May I ask, which government?
I really do applaud this young women’s strength and courage. I apply it to all of these talented dancers and choreographers featured here. It could not have been easy to sacrifice everything. you see her pain she allows herself to be vulnerable and I so appreciate her honesty. She hit the nail on the head, if you’re not a soldier even if you’re not Putin if but you’re Russian it hurts to having to watch people made to suffer in the name of your country
I totally agree with your comment! But have you run out of any marks of interpunction (like commas and/or full stops)?
@@manfredneilmann4305 Thank you kindly! I am disabled, so I get confused sometimes. I will try to be more careful from now on. English is also my second language
@@evelynvongizycki1017 Please, never mind the hateful person here. You are doing great. Love from Texas 🥰
@@evelynvongizycki1017 you are incredibly gracious! Way more than I would have been. Your English and punctuation is better than a lot of native American English speakers. (I use the word “native” here to mean people who were born (native = born) in a place that speaks American English; I don’t mean Native Americans, the indigenous people of the Americas.) Keep on commenting! You are fantastic!
@@SharynS. Thanks for all the love here. I cry and cry for my friends still in the Ukraine. One of them is so brave he is reporting from there and has interviewed Zelenskyy and is on CNN the other day. Thank you for all of the support
My salute to all these men and women who made a stand against the Russian aggression.
These Russian stars of ballet are even bigger stars in the eyes of world humanity. I only wish more Russian stars had this attitude and courage.
One now old former dancer. I wonder what has happened to her.
Natalia Makarova. She fled in 1970 to the West and had a 19-year career there. Returned in 1989 to then Leningrad, now St. Petersburg and have had a long career since then, instructing Russian and other nationalities dancers. Until the 24th. of February.
If there is somebody truly heartborken, is her, I can bet on it. She's and old woman now and wouldn't want to flee again, I guess. Sigh.
Not everybody is a hero. It takes a lot of courage to leave all behind: family, work, house, friends, pets, your city, your personal history, your whole life!
To me they do not look fragile. A fragile body cannot perform the way they do. They are strong in body and in mind. While also having a sense for music, poetry and emotion. Harder than any sports that just relies on strength.
Wow.. this is powerful and everyone in this piece is grounded in their feelings and their decisions to take a stand. I congratulate them for having the courage of their convictions. I pray for great happiness and success for All of these people .
Fine. But other artists should not be forced to take sides. Ballet dancers do not decide politics.
@@peace-now But they are being used in politics and propaganda.
@@peace-now No one is forcing anyone to do anything except Putin
@@peace-now I never said they should AND I never said they did! I'm talking about the people in this video.
A simple description of these wonderful people-COURAGE, RESILIENCE despite pain, INTEGRITY through willingness to face down ruthless power. God Bless Them.
huge admiration and respect for you miss Olga for speaking the truth...such courage and bravery!
I cannot enough express my admiration for her brave stand. She will always know that when it counted she did the right thing, made the difficult choice. She has not sold her soul. It will show in her art.
У них есть совесть и дух, которых вам явно не хватает
To those Ukrainians who are now in Amsterdam; Welcome to the country of the Netherlands (my country). Slava Ukraini!!!
6 minutes in and tearing up. I have no idea why this tiny facet of the war in Ukraine would hit me so hard.
Right?.
I certainly do. In these days I remember ho much I love so many facets from Russian culture and art. The basso-profondos. Their cinema (you have to see the Shakesperean adaptations, fabulous). My beloved Tschaikovsky, and Rimsky-Korsakov, Borodin. And....I remind myself that Prokofiev was....Ukrainian (during Soviet times). and that there both Russian AND Ukrainian cossacks, singing to their banduras and all.
Until 24th. of February I had the pleasure of watching "Coppelia" presentation back in 2007 starring Osipova at the Bolshoi. And now I...cry. The formidable Nutcracker adagio, at Act second which starts the pas-de-deux...man, the same.
A kind of painful mourning if you undesrstand what I mean.
@@guerramarioalberto I do understand what you mean.
Ukrainians are an example of bravery. 🇺🇦❤️
Slava Ukraine, and Vive La Resistance.
Anti-democracy Nazis, that do not respect Donbass civilians' independence.
Huge respect for those parents and professionals that are putting their names on the line to keep their kids safe not only now, but to keep their passion and livelihood going.
Dutch National Ballet Academy?! Not a bad place to land under the circumstances!
I didn't realise it was held in such high esteem.
It’s a great great company, and a terrific school. In my opinion the company is stronger, with a better repertoire, than Bolshoi.
@@kdub10009 lmao "in your opinion"? And you are who, precisely? Why should anyone take your opinion on ballet seriously? It's a no-name hovel in comparison with the Bolshoi.
@@an-eh2wn and who are you precisely to describe it as a no-name hovel.
An anonymous expert on dance of course.
@@sarahpengelly8439 Even an anonymous RUclips commenter, without establishing themselves as an art history expert, can tell you the difference in merit between a Rembrandt and some second-rate artist from the current period, or the difference between the Cannes and some local student film festival. The same applies to this.
Funny you should mention that, because my friend in Moscow mentioned that they've been playing Tchaikovski on TV for the past two weeks.
well, they're certainly not playing swan lake, they wouldn't want to send that message. the swan lake broadcast thing was because it was the designated place holder in later years of the soviet union for when big things were happening and the party was still busy figuring out what to do and what to tell the people. it wasn't broadcast to signify crisis, it was broadcast at times of crisis when they didn't know what to broadcast. TV rain made swan lake their last broadcast from russia though
well, they're certainly not playing swan lake, they wouldn't want to send that message. the swan lake broadcast thing was because it was the designated place holder in later years of the soviet union for when big things were happening and the party was still busy figuring out what to do and what to tell the people. it wasn't broadcast to signify crisis, it was broadcast at times of crisis when they didn't know what to broadcast. TV rain made swan lake their last broadcast from russia thoughwell, they're certainly not playing swan lake, they wouldn't want to send that message. the swan lake broadcast thing was because it was the designated place holder in later years of the soviet union for when big things were happening and the party was still busy figuring out what to do and what to tell the people. it wasn't broadcast to signify crisis, it was broadcast at times of crisis when they didn't know what to broadcast. TV rain made swan lake their last broadcast from russia thoughwell, they're certainly not playing swan lake, they wouldn't want to send that message. the swan lake broadcast thing was because it was the designated place holder in later years of the soviet union for when big things were happening and the party was still busy figuring out what to do and what to tell the people. it wasn't broadcast to signify crisis, it was broadcast at times of crisis when they didn't know what to broadcast. TV rain made swan lake their last broadcast from russia thoughwell, they're certainly not playing swan lake, they wouldn't want to send that message. the swan lake broadcast thing was because it was the designated place holder in later years of the soviet union for when big things were happening and the party was still busy figuring out what to do and what to tell the people. it wasn't broadcast to signify crisis, it was broadcast at times of crisis when they didn't know what to broadcast. TV rain made swan lake their last broadcast from russia thoughwell, they're certainly not playing swan lake, they wouldn't want to send that message. the swan lake broadcast thing was because it was the designated place holder in later years of the soviet union for when big things were happening and the party was still busy figuring out what to do and what to tell the people. it wasn't broadcast to signify crisis, it was broadcast at times of crisis when they didn't know what to broadcast. TV rain made swan lake their last broadcast from russia though
This they're certainly not playing swan lake, they wouldn't want to send that message. the swan lake broadcast thing was because it was the designated place holder in later years of the soviet union for when big things were happening and the party was still busy figuring out what to do and what to tell the people. it wasn't broadcast to signify crisis, it was broadcast at times of crisis when they didn't know what to broadcast. TV rain made swan lake their last broadcast from russia though
Perhaps Putin should get some maillots and play Rothbart. So very proper.
With Russia's Ballet being such a source of pride for Putin, this is quite a loss. It may seem silly to some, but it won't be to Putin.
Makes you wonder if they would be more competitive as a nation to allow Nationals worldwide to represent them on an international stage like the Olympics.
...like other countries do.
It would have been more of a loss if the whole Ballet Company upped and left and said FU Putin in the process. But of course the Bolshoi as noted was used by the Tsar and the Soviet Leadership etc, as firstly a source of prestige and secondly to put on ballet’s with a propaganda/ political message . To tell the world and the populace how good they have it.
@@sandgroper1970 true!. However, over a 100 defecting to dance in other countries is a substantial, and the ones who left to fight for Ukraine, and their tour being canceled, has got to hurt.
This is an incredible program, thank you for providing it to us. One dancer leaves to save his country, another very young dancer is pushed west by her family to save her life, and another, a prima ballerina with the world at her feet, leaves to save her soul. I pray this insane attack on Ukraine ends, and all three of these dancers along with the others who have fled or who are fighting, will soon be together to dance on stage, exorcising their pain and celebrating the victory of free people over oppressors.
Amazing integrity of these people
Olga Smirnova’s grandfather is a Ukrainian. So she has Ukrainian blood.
Tbh, many Russians have some relatives in Ukraine or from Ukraine. It adds another layer of sadness and tragedy to the whole thing
Unfortunately, Svetlana Zakharova, one of the main ballerinas of the Bolshoi, is 100% Ukrainian (from Lutsk), and is, disgustingly, a huge Putin supporter. :(
@@kabardinka1 How did you know that? Any evidence?
@@JayChoi1118 Try Googling Zakharova and Putin and see how many photos come up. She spoke out in favor of annexing Crimea and in support of the DPR. Both her and her husband are listed as being those who've participated in pro-war events. She was banned from returning to Ukraine due to her pro-Putin activities.
It's good that people in the arts are taking a stand! Like he says; it's about humanity and cannot be just written off as "politics". Citizens all need to do their part to hold their government accountable. Apathy is the enemy of righteousness. Although it may be uncomfortable to question authority in such an environment people must be willing to do that for the higher purpose of defending humanity, and must condemn inhumanity. No leader is worth leaving one's conscience at the door.
I just watched some interviews with relatives of russian soldiers who died in ukraine. one of them (a mother I think) said that the russian soldiers are there to "defend peace", and when asked who they are defending russia against, she said "I don't know anything about politics".
👁👄👁
@@Ass_of_Amalek at least the son of the Russian mother did not die in vain.. unlike the Ukrainians..
His mother was right.. I'm sure western media didn't tell you UkrainianAzofNazis killed 14 thousand ethnic russian Ukrainianskis since they broke the Minsk peace agreement in 2008
As an American, I'd love To be in the right but haven't since WW2
PunchUp not LeftRight Its a ClassWar WakeUp jimmy dore, is that you?
it’s heartbreaking for the ballet community and it’s heartbreaking to see what’s happening. russia is a big part of ballet history and to see its performers ashamed of it makes my heart ache. i love ballet and it’s a big part of my life and i’ve been wondering what’s going to happen to ballet during these troubling times. for a lot of us ballet dancers ballet is life and it’s hard to do anything else. we eat sleep and breathe ballet. i’m glad that she’s trying to get these young dancers out of that situation so they can dance again. one split second decision can change so many lives. it’s awful that these kids have to go through this. ballet shouldn’t be used as a weapon. any dance style shouldn’t be used as a weapon and it makes me so sad to see this beautiful art form has been turned into this weapon. i’m glad that these people have been able to escape and be able to continue with their passion and the thing they love.
War is always ugly anywhere for whatever reason. However, the Russian people we should not dislike ! Russian musicians are banned, like wonderful Alexander Malofeev in Canada ! Never mix politics with the Arts. Also Russian Ballet dansers, writers, musicians etc. bring their love and dedication to a darkened world as comfort and light. We should respect them and never hate them, because they have nothing to do with war. When pianist Malofeev was cancelled after he arrived in Canada he said:" All there is left for me to do is pray and cry". He is 20 ! (Holland)
Highest regards to Madame Olga Smirnov and Mr. Ratmansky.
I love and admire both of their works and so very proud that I could also be proud of
their humanity in the face of adversity. There are some other ballet dancers who left their
positions in Russia and either back to their country of origin or defected in a sense to
other companies around the world. Yet there are other dancers who aren't Russians who
didn't want leave the best ballet school in the world (there are many comparable schools
in the world) and didn't want to waste many years of training there already.
I know there're some Japanese dancer who couldn't bare to leave the company in Rossia
or throw away the opportunity to work in Bolshoi or Mariinsky after graduating from their schools.
There are times when you need to make a stand as Mr. Ratmansky said in the interview.
Do you stand for humanity or dictatorship ?
it's easy to say when you have a chance just to take a taxi and go to NY. And - he is good and makes the right choice, doesn't matter that he made money there right before the war, it was ok for him to work in dictatorship, but simple people will be blamed for not having chance to move to another country. I adore this modern hypocrisy and victim blaming.
@@akam1779 I don't think it's hypocrisy modern or old. And who is victim
here ? The real victims are the ppl getting killed by Russian dictatorship.
The fact Russian government makes their citizens from all walks
of life to choose by stepping on an icon. It was called FUMIE (stepping picture ) of Madonna or Crist on cross and if refuse you're killed in Edo era.
it's a modern world now so you don't have to dedicate your life for these
choices but simply moving elsewhere there're ways to do that.
You watch Evgeny Pulshenko of skating fame going gun ho on nationalistic pride. And bad mouthing those who do not agree and stand by his side.
He's lost my respect right away. An Olympian who should be enlightened
by going all over the world yet he disregards the idea of freedom and democratic ideas. Simpleton who are brain washed after all.
@@mikiohirata9627 the fact that you say "simply moving elsewhere" shows that you don't understand that moving to another country is whatever but not "simple". This "simply" sounds like mocking. Actions make people bad, not passports or the place of birth. I know plenty of good brave people in Russia, and I know plenty of stupid infantile and unkind people from "good" countries. And I don't see anything impressive in the action of this choreographer - there's nothing impressive in taking a plane to the country where you've already had a job.
Ballet has fascinated me all my life and I love that ballerinas have taken a stand
there are many dancers that have family and lives - careers in Russia that don't approve of Putin's war that are being used as political pawns. It is not so easy to just say, "I must get out and leave everything." You cannot uniformly say they are all supporting this war and want it to persist. If they do speak against it they will be punished. They are caught trying to survive just like many others. Hopefully the stupidity and pointlessness of this war will end soon and these artists can continue to pursue their careers without the same spotlight of politics.
That’s a self aware and courageous Russian ballerina who opposes her country’s war and leaves her country
Just look at her face... she's a soulless robot.
So glad.that there are Russian's standing up for what is Right & standing up Against Putin. I pray that Putin is taken out of power quickly for the good of Everyone ✨🙏✨
I'm so impressed with their English skills. Beautiful dancers with hopefully bright futures.
Courageous human beings
Huge respect for these ballet dancers for taking a stand against a brutal unjust war.
I hope that the Russian dancing artist can be the light, where the darknes is. Brave lady. I hope all god for her.
Thank you for taking the time to speak about such an unknown topic as this
Russian ballet has survived the Revolution, World War I, World War II, and politics. Interesting to hear Smirnova say... NO REGRET, as loud as ballet throughout world history. Since selection as students, these incredible dancers privileged by the gods have built that fortress but let's not forget that the Russian people have had a long history since the tsars and since then they have endured the attacks and doctrines of heinous governments. My first ballet teacher was Russian, a beautiful lady with deep blue eyes. She used to cry when memories of her land in Russia invaded her thoughts, every day. Unpleasant memories of when the government took everything from her family and despite that, she missed her homeland. I always wondered what would happen to the ballet, what would happen to the dancers in the Ukraine war. May peace come as soon as possible for the Ukrainians
My heart goes out to all of them. I can’t even imagine what that must feel like. I send peace 🙏🏻🕯🙏🏻 to all affected 🇺🇦🇺🇸✌🏻☮️.
🌴☀️🌴
How does One send peace... Please don't say thoughts and prayers. Jah love rastafari praises blessings Tucson Arizona Sonoran desert 🏜️ Jah sisters Jah jerrymylitis Jah everything everyone solidarity
@@pango-y8j There are many ways to “send peace”. It doesn’t always mean LITERAL. Sometimes you need to understand semantics.
And please enlighten me with all this JAH jargon you intertwined within your sentences. It doesn’t make any sense. 🤷🏻♂️
Peace be with you
🌴☀️🌴
What about those 14000 people killed in the Donbass regions for the last 8 years and more than 20k wounded.
There is one more dancer who has suffered from the war, it is Artem Datsyshyn, from National Opera and Ballet Theatre, who was killed by Russian occupants. I believe he deserves to be mentioned in context of war & ballet.
I'm quite (not) surprised though that all the praise in comments under this video goes to Olga Smirnova, who decided to leave the country and her theatre when all the foreign performances of Bolshoi were cancelled. At the same time, Oleksii Potiomkin who had to stop his work to save the country, is barely mentioned in the comments.
Oleksii and many other Ukrainian dancers don't know when they will be able to dance again. Artem will never dance again. And still, all the attention and sympathy goes to Russian dancer who had to change her workplace because the previous one became less convenient. This is how imperialism works.
Thanks for this comment!! Indeed loss of Ukrainian people is incomparable. But most of the commentators seem to be blinded. Or just working for Russian propaganda.
I totally agree with you. Moreover, we should consider that "moving to another country from Russia" is more often is just a matter of saving oneself than a political statement.
I don't think calling it less convenient is fair. She left her home, her family etc. And I think it's difficult to speak out when you're surrounded by propaganda.
But I still agree. We should mention and focus on the Ukrainian dancers. They deserve our support.
@@leonamay8776 Thank you for your support! By "less convenient" I meant that Bolshoi had to cancel their performances abroad, which surely affects the career of the dancers who stayed there.
Incredibly strong and brave Olga Smirnova. I hope this awful war will end soon 🙏
We need to stop punishing the people for the actions of leaders!
"She said, at least I can be honest with myself". Smirnova lives her truth, and by being honest with herself, it makes her a fair person. And it will be easier for her, to find peace. I admire Smirnova very much.
how interesting they never reacted on Crimea annexation, or invasion in Donbass, Georgia, Syria and now suddenly they speak up
It’s so sad 😞. These dancers are absolutely incredible. They work willingly SOOO hard . And the Russian Ballet is truly spectacular.
Putin is distorting the foundation of culture in his own country. Changing it in to a world of paranoia and fear of the outside world. A man’s Actions, mirrors that man’s true nature
Did you say that when NATO destroyed the middle east and murdered millions and sent millions of refugees all over Europe!
@@anomanderrake3593 What is your point? Why do you keep trying to change the subject? No matter what one said or didn't say about a different situation; it doesn't justify Russia's having invaded Ukraine and destroying everything and everyone in sight.
@@djondjon Of course not just like it doesn't justify Ukraine bombing Donbas for the past 8 years but you never cared.
@@anomanderrake3593 what are you rabbiting on about. Some of my best friends are Syrian Christian refugees. Who had to leave Syria because their OWN GOVERNMENT completely destroyed their home and huge areas where they lived on the pretext that ISIL was 'hiding' in those suburbs. But they vehemently say that was an out right lie and that is was because it was a Christian area. There was noting to do with NATO just the Syrians with the help of Russia causing more destruction in the fake pretext of 'fighting ' ISIL' ( The family DOES NOT call the terrorists ISIS and say that Russia and the Syrian Governments were terrorists too as much as ISIL. You need to get the information from the real refugees not fake news
@@micheledix2616 Thank you for telling the truth about the situation with refugees in Siria..
Russia is also highly responsible for chaos in there, pretending to fight with Isis, but being no better than terrorist themselves..
And this despicable WAGNER people,who basically just killing Sirian civilians..
Real mess and distraction only brought by those russian army
Thank You 60 minutes for never stopping to produce Top Tier programming for those of us who want to view life from the inside...
A voice of reason.
Be clear- the world is not against Russia - but Putin's aggression . The BEST of Russia is its high culture - which it shares with the world. All this is at risk of being undone by a return to a backward - looking quasi soviet state... Artists are amongst those needed to help push Russia into a peaceful, co-operative future ...hopefully.
Well, the West was always against Russia. Look how many European powers have tried to conquer Russia. You will get to look why Russia hates West so much? Why they are paranoid of West? Why they have huge distrust towards West? The West is always out there to destroy Russia. In fact, Harry Truman once said that Russia if divided into multiple smaller countries will be easy to be manipulated.
Unfortunately, too much of its high culture has been co-opted by the government. There are terrific artists who have spoken out against their countries aggression, but they're rapidly losing their place in Russia's remaining civil society.
@@kabardinka1 the point is this high culture now exist only in closed groups, what is, unfortunately, the minority of the population in the state. moreover, there are mostly in cities such as Saint-P and Moscow(
Unfortunately, it is not Putin who raped and tortured thousands of Ukrainians. According to different independent researches, more than 70% of Russians support war (and this is more than 100 mln people). They are the carriers of that cultural code, as well.
There have been many great Russian writers, compositors, ballerinas, of course. However, this "high culture" has been largely instrumentalized. I believe one of the reasons why the world was not acting against the invasion of 2014 is because of that culture, that was promoted largely abroad. Part of oil money went on weapons, but part was spent on promoting of Russian culture abroad.
I just wish people were more conscious of the imperialist nature of Russian culture. I wish people who read Dostoyevsky knew that the same years that his biggest works were written, there have been few laws issued that forbade publishing of books in Ukrainian language in the whole empire. I wish people knew some of xenophobic and ukrainophobic texts of the same big and famous Russian writers. And question whether Putin and 100 mln of Russians and the culture can exist as totally separate units that don't have any impact between them. Whether it is accidental that Russian leaders constantly show aggression against Ukrainian people? If it is just Putin's aggression, and before it was just Stalin's terror, and before it was just Katherine's imperialism... Blaming just one person for all the crimes is a comfortable position, but it opens little perspective for discussion and possible future change.
It's amazing to see how the dance community is helping fellow dancers to escape to somewhere safe. I love to see how quick to action the community was to helping...how small and tight knit the communityh is and yet it can change and help the lives of how many dancers. I just wish they could transport the families as well. The Russian dancer...I hope she knows that not everyone only sees her as Russian and has anger with her because of that.At least for me...I feel for the average Russian people because they are suffering and will continue to suffer because of what their government has decided to do.
SO COOL AND CALM IN THE FACE OF TRAGEDY. THAT GOES FOR ALL THE UKRAINIANS. I AM SURE GOD WILL HELP YOU SOMEHOW.
"no regrets.... Because at least I can be honest with myself." Certainly a poignant yet inspiring way to end the vid.
Some wonderful news for a change in this dreadful period in our lives……these dancers have dance in their blood and are incredible….it’s so good that this window shows a certain number being given the chance to still follow their dreams. I wish them all the very best, and hope their families stay safe. Godbless them all. 🙏🙏🙏🙏💕💐💐💐
Whenever I see these instances of how bravely the people of Ukraine are standing up for their country against the toughest of odds, it gives me hope for the future of our humanity. We salute you, and your brave struggle will never be forgotten. Slava Ukraine!!
These people are inspiring
Not a single american singer, artist, sportsman was questioned about wars in Iraq, Syria, Afghanistan, Yemen, Lybia. Not a single made any statement or provided any comments.
There is a line from a Country Western song, sorry but I can''t ask the author of the song it goes something like this "You have to stand for something or you will fall for anything". These people stood for something, they will not fall!
The amazing grace of a ballet dancer certainly does shine a light upon the stumbling ugliness of war...
🇿🇦🕊🇺🇦
She is such a hero...
RESPECTS and GOD'S EYE'S and BLESSINGS!!!!! FOR ALLLL THESE PEOPLE. Please GOD OOOOH HOLY FATHER GOD IN HEAVEN THAT NEVER SLUMBERS SEND LOTS LEGIONS OF ANGELS TO WATCH OVER ALL THESE RUSSIANS AND UKRAINIAN BALLETDANCERS. THANK YOU AMSTERDAM FOR HELPING THESE DANCERS WITH COMFORT IN THEIRE MINDS. HOLLAND ALWAYS HAS A HEART FOR THOSE WHO ARE IN NEED. INDEED HOLLAND IS VERY GENEROUS.🏆🏆🏆 THANK YOU HOLLAND. GOD BLESS YOUR PEOPLE WHEREVER THEY ARE. 🎉🎉🎉🏆🏆🏆🏆😍😍😍😍
THANKS for sharing this with the WORLD.
Beauty in the middle of tragedy. Another Ukraine story bringing me to tears.
The line Russia crossed was the border with Ukraine.
I was previously all in favour of drawing Russia closer to Europe,
since we share so much culture and history. The invasion was
the line crossed for me too.
Russia is still a beautiful country; their culture is very interesting and the people in general are very nice. I kinda feel sorry for them, as Russia is led by a complete madman, who cares nothing about Russia or its people, unless it also benefits himself.
@@DanielBrongers Your perception of Russia is distorted as it has been distorted for a long time for most of western people. Russia is not what you think it is and it's not about Putin and his gang at power at all.
Russia is the last Empire. Dostojevski wanted to believe that evil comes to Russia from outside world but even he was convinced later that Russia itself is evil.
I'm glad that it became obvious to the civilized world now. If even for a short period of time but still. Most of russians want ukrainians to suffer, most of them want collective west to suffer as well and they support Putins efforts with all their heart. Today. After Ukraine's win they start to look for guilty ones and their new leader will say that evil Putin is the only person to blame. And soft west agrees with this conseption. No Nuremberg 2.0, no nothing.
As a Russian, I am very happy that we are drawing away from Europe and its culture of capitalism, racism, and exploitation. We don't need any of that. We'll be happy with the rest of the subaltern around the world.
@@an-eh2wn So part of your happy non-capitalistic, non-racist, non-exploited world is to brutalise other people, even those of the same background and cultural history as you?
Top notch reporting. Left me in tears.
Literally shows only one side, without any semblance of nuance or complexity, and people are really out here calling this "top notch reporting."
You are an individual. Countries all have had bad leaders at certain time look at Germany for example. But we don't hate Russians or any other countries people. Only the individuals from any country that do terrible things. So hold your head up high. Your an awesome person and a true Russian. I'm from New Zealand. ❤️
A few bad people doesn't make everyone from a place. Bless you.
Thank you for documenting this.
i remember watching the Bolshoi Theatre when in Melbourne back in 2018. Back then, life seemed so carefree. their elegant moves made me realise how beautiful ballet. one day, i want to go again and see it. Ballet moves you and its heartbreaking whats happening there in Russia/Ukraine.
" I had to leave everything" that is so moving.
I have such respect for olga smirnova. Giving up such privileges to stand up for the rights of others and the pride of your country is amazing.
I don't blame most Russian people nor the unknowing conscripts sent in against their knowledge to be cannon fodder. It is not their fault.
My problem with the conscripts is the inhumane acts they commit.
@@djondjon I guess when you are given a gun, alcohol and no responsibility, humans become animals
@@djondjon Like in Irar, Afghanistan, Libya and Syria where NATO left millions of dead bodies.
@@anomanderrake3593 This thread is about Russia and Ukraine, not Afghanistan, Libya, Syria or NATO. Posts involving them have no place here; but yes, inhumane acts anywhere by anyone is a problem. At the same time, one bad action does not justify another.
@@djondjon Of course, hypocrites only care about Ukraine and no others. Do you know that the US is still occupying Iraq and Syria? Do you know that 400k people have died in Yemen because of Saudi Arabia whom NATO supports? You don't care of course.
“They have to dance” 😢😢♥️
A prerequisite for a good artist is to be a good man in the first place. if he is not a good man, he cannot be an artist. full stop.
‘...dealings with artists, for instance, require great prudence; they are acquainted with all classes of society, and for that reason dangerous; they are hardly ever satisfied, and when you have too much to do with them, you are sure to have des ennuis (trouble)’ - King Leopold of Belgium to England's Queen Victoria, 10 October 1845
Humble Russians ❤️🙏♥️
What about 2014 when russia anexated Crimea and attack Ukraine on the east? Was no problem for her then?
This is huge alert to real artists to not be manipulated.
In dire times, you'll know WHO you are, by your choice.
Paulina I want to give her a hug. I hope she reads Pink Club by Emma Bruce it shows anyone not just dancers to never give up their dreams. The story follows a dancer but some of the life experiences she goes through in sure many will find relatable.
In Chinese we say 道德勇氣。 these people have it.
Horrible discrimination against Russian ballet artists and anything Russian no excuse for it, on either side to use it politically.
Russian ballet will always be the best that's for sure.
First come to you city russian ballet , then come russian rockets )))
Good for the rest of the world that they can inherit these superior ballet dancers.
Why nervous?You come from the best of the best ballet-dancers in the world..
Great document. Art helps us face the trials with courage 🌺🙏🙏
Well done young lady. May your God Bless you.
What courage these people have to stand against that murderous dictator. Wonder how such a thing would be played out in USA, we may get that opportunity sooner than later the way the GOP and ignorant mentality is prevalent in this country.
If Ukrainians believe that they have dug up the Black Sea, then it is not surprising to learn about the Ukrainian ballet🔥
Really, really, great piece - thank you.
Oh my, Polina is kind of today Winton for the ballet world.
Very courageous 💙 💛. Thank you for this heartfelt story
She is so right, I held respect for Russia and what they went thru in past wars, and now this is dispicable action by an obsessed delusional leader...
NO WAR SHOULD BE THE FUEL FOR CREATIVE ART.
And then I heard 'n.55 goes to Stuttgart', and it brought memories from the past, almost 40 years ago, when I was in my second year at that school, sneaking upstairs to get a glimpse on the 'older' students: at that time, there was an exchange / collaboration between the John-Cranko school and a Russian ballet, I think it was the Kirov. There was still the cold war and the wall in Berlin standing, but nonetheless, ballet made it possible...
“Honest with myself” great answer Polina❤️❤️❤️🤗😘
Yes these people are rich and beautiful and spoiled, but their art is necessary for humanity. Humans need rocket scientists, and ballet dancers, and comedians, in order to have a reason to get up in the morning and have meaning in life. Abstract thinking is what gave humans language and tool making and started on the path off of the savannas and into the first cities. Turning our backs on it would end civilization and put us back 10 thousand years. Humanity would also collapse without farmers and nurses and carpenters and retail workers, you need both for progress.
literally isn't...
@@QQnowQQlater troll identified👀
rich and spoiled? Surely you're not talking about the dancers. Most professional ballet dancers make very low salaries compared to the hard work and hours they put in.
Very few if them are "rich and spoiled" but they are all dedicated and hard-working. The most dedicated, hard-working and talented may become famous, rich etc, but very few compared with top professional sports/music people etc - why single these peaceful people out? Bombing schools, hospitals, cities and villages to bits is a much better way of contributing to society.