Say and believe whatever you want, but SHINee was fricken' flawless here, and I for one believe this was live. Perhaps there was some sound editing, but I've watched them perform long enough to make my own assumptions. I LOVE these guys, and to me, a performance isn't true unless they sing for real, and this was real. SHINee is only continuing to prove how they've grown and expressing themselves as true musicians. I hope they blow everyone away with their comeback like I know they can. :)
16-03-2023 escuchando esta cancion y siempre la sensacion es la misma, no me cansare de amarlos , son lo mejor que pude encontrar en mis peores momentos de vacio... ahora entiendo cuando dicen que hay un grupo que refleja tus emociones y sentimientos, y ellos lo son... SHINee en lo personal lo mejor
I love Minho and his voice is just so raw and emotional, I'm so happy that SM is finally letting him sing.Taemin is improving everyday and he's just perf. Key is just amazing at everything of course and I love his voice *~*. Onew didn't have as many parts in this song but his voice is so much like an angels holy crap. Then there's Jonghyun who is just perfect, his voice is amazing and his singing skills are like...I can't even...he's just...UGH perfect human being right here. SHINee forever
They are so perfect... i don't know how i can describe my feeling now... beeing showol for long time and always see they grow so much.... i'm cying when hear this song although i still don't know the meaning of this song... i proud to be SHAWOL.... i just hope they will be always together forever :)
This might be my favorite Shinee performance yet. They've all improved a lot, especially Taemin, Key, and Minho. I mean, wow. Shinee is so well-rounded and I'm convinced they're the SM group that most consistently puts out quality material. They fully deserve so many awards that I'm sure they'll get for this album. Excuse me, I just have a lot of feelings right now. Bless those 5 angels
pre-recorded or not, it's still their real beautiful voices. shinee barely uses autotune anyway. this song made me cry...it just makes me so excited for the next album.
You could hear that the audio was not recorded from one of the camera standing in the room. But I'm very sure that's 100% live. There are different ways to record a live preformance, u know. They probably took the audio from their mics and added the accompaniment.
I love SHINee's ballad song. It brings out a lot of SHINee's charm and vocal. They can sing, dance and both at the same time. What can you expect more? From a happy Shawol who is listening to their album and waiting for the freaking awesome MV to come out T_____T
this is beautiful.... DEAR SHINee, I CAN'T LEAVE YOU... THOUGH YOU KILLING ME CONTINOUSLY... BUT SOMEHOW YOU ARE THE REASON FOR EVERYTHING OF ME.. I LOVE YOU, WITH ALL MY HEART AND SOUL... THANK YOU FOR BEING SHINee.. MY SHINee... TT__TT
their singing has improved so much! :O taemins singing was perf .... keys singing was perf everyones singing was perf theu all looked perf .... so basically their perfect ;)
will you have sometimes fellings that you are close in some place that no one can went I have that fellings always when I listen SHINee ballad songs....why? becouse it's my own heaven No one can by like them Their are amazing just becouse they always give more then 100% on their performence
i've seriously watched this over and over again and omigosh i am just so unbelievably proud of our boys. watching them grow up has been a beautiful experience and i'm glad i got to be a part of it. also HOLY CRAP TAEMIN'S HIGH NOTE!!!
many people say SHINee lipsync now.. it bcoz SHINee voice was improve so much .. so people cant tell different live peformance with lipsync peformance SHINee Daebakk !!!
Taemin's high note is too amazing. His singing's skill has improved really much since their debut. And I love Key's voice so much, it's sweet, and I feel like I'm melting :)
....>_>. You know at least a third of the people who are sitting in the audience are music critics. Now don't you think they would've noticed if SHINee was trying to sell them a live performance when it's actually lipsynced? And don't you think that would've been reflected in their reviews? But the reviews were 100% positive. So of course this wasn't lipsynced, SHINee doesn't want to dig their own graves lol. I do admit there /might/ have been a little bit of audio editing for this VIDEO.
It are a really good song, but I think that they have not share equally the lines fair. Enough.... It was stil a good song from SHINee! But it could be better if Jonghyun have got more lines!..
![[Eng] SHINee Roleplay: calling their "girlfriends"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QugW-UjgVjg/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Eng] SHINee Roleplay: calling their "girlfriends"](/img/tr.png)
![[SHINee Music Spoiler_2] 떠나지 못해 Live [ENG SUB]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LOLiueb9gas/mqdefault.jpg)
대박...다섯명 다 노래 왜케 잘해 최고다..
유일무이 샤이니
Jjong's voice is undeniably perfect.
jonghyun's voice is so powerful.. they can hit high notes even they are sitting.
Mi Jonghyun es un ARTISTA en letras mayúsculas, único. 👑✨👑💙🥰
como no llorar con esas hermosas voces trasmitiendo tanto sentiemiento , Jonghyun amo su vos...💔💔💔💔
Say and believe whatever you want, but SHINee was fricken' flawless here, and I for one believe this was live. Perhaps there was some sound editing, but I've watched them perform long enough to make my own assumptions. I LOVE these guys, and to me, a performance isn't true unless they sing for real, and this was real. SHINee is only continuing to prove how they've grown and expressing themselves as true musicians. I hope they blow everyone away with their comeback like I know they can. :)
Hermosa voz vos de mi bling bling jonghyun como lo extraño
The girl who was cry. I love her
This is so beautiful :')
SHINee is really talented group. I LOVE SHINee
진짜 노래왜케다잘불러... 내가 봤을땐 보이그룹중 최강인듯
OMG Jonghyun true high tone.
Thank you, Jonghyun-ah. You did so well.
Eles são perfeitos 👏💙
Anyone else crying waterfalls here?? TT ^ TT SHINee is too perfect!~
16-03-2023 escuchando esta cancion y siempre la sensacion es la misma, no me cansare de amarlos , son lo mejor que pude encontrar en mis peores momentos de vacio... ahora entiendo cuando dicen que hay un grupo que refleja tus emociones y sentimientos, y ellos lo son... SHINee en lo personal lo mejor
kEY oppa el mejor jonghyun tu voz lo maximo shinee es lo maximo oooooo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Amazing voice SHINee!!!
That girl at 4:22-4:37 is me in my room in front of my computer crying myself a legit river , but worse. :))
Even though I have no idea what they're singing about this song still almost made me teat up!! That is the power SHINee has on us Shawols T.T
I love Minho and his voice is just so raw and emotional, I'm so happy that SM is finally letting him sing.Taemin is improving everyday and he's just perf. Key is just amazing at everything of course and I love his voice *~*. Onew didn't have as many parts in this song but his voice is so much like an angels holy crap. Then there's Jonghyun who is just perfect, his voice is amazing and his singing skills are like...I can't even...he's just...UGH perfect human being right here. SHINee forever
legitly started crying because this was so beautiful.
my favorite SHINee song. :D
taemin key and minho's voice have improved so much! beyond words, shinee. beyond words /sobs everywhere
Its awesome i cant desribe it in words just gonna cry
POR FAVOR ....que VOS... EN EL MIN 4:28... JONGHYUN ES IMPRESIONANTE... !!!!!
their voices are INSANE. my loves ;____;
That song was so beautiful (even thoigh I couldn't understand a word). TaeMin oppa's voice has also improved a lot. Hwaiting oppa!! 3
I love this album too, I think I really love this one,cause I like almost all the music and I hope, the next album will better, keep SHIning SHINee
They are so perfect... i don't know how i can describe my feeling now... beeing showol for long time and always see they grow so much.... i'm cying when hear this song although i still don't know the meaning of this song... i proud to be SHAWOL....
i just hope they will be always together forever :)
It's so good to see that the singing is more evenly spread now. It feels more like a collaboration now!
this is so beautiful. made me and the fans cry T__TT so touching
Beautiful
So Beautiful TT...
Stop playing with my heart strings.
WOW!!! *tears are falling* such amazing song sang by amazing band SHINee ♥
Lo más hermoso que he escuchado.
This might be my favorite Shinee performance yet. They've all improved a lot, especially Taemin, Key, and Minho. I mean, wow. Shinee is so well-rounded and I'm convinced they're the SM group that most consistently puts out quality material. They fully deserve so many awards that I'm sure they'll get for this album. Excuse me, I just have a lot of feelings right now. Bless those 5 angels
OMG tears just rolled down my face... that was too beautiful~
pre-recorded or not, it's still their real beautiful voices. shinee barely uses autotune anyway. this song made me cry...it just makes me so excited for the next album.
Adoro ami SHINee siempre los mejores.2022
You could hear that the audio was not recorded from one of the camera standing in the room. But I'm very sure that's 100% live. There are different ways to record a live preformance, u know. They probably took the audio from their mics and added the accompaniment.
4:16 to 4:31
Oh Jonghyun ❤️
I feel like I could listen to this for the rest of my life.
I love SHINee's ballad song. It brings out a lot of SHINee's charm and vocal. They can sing, dance and both at the same time. What can you expect more?
From a happy Shawol who is listening to their album and waiting for the freaking awesome MV to come out T_____T
I was so hard crying when Taemin sang his high note.. This song is full of pain and that makes it so beautiful
I love it ~~good song ^^
Love shinee forever~~
that was beautiful...
good night... jonghyun...
Kibum!!!! You did so good honey, I wasn't expecting that!!!! SHINee killing you with feels since 2008!
That was so amazing. I cant even.....ugh perfection
It was a really beautiful moment :-)
SERIOUSLY WANT CHAPTER 2 ASAP THIS IS AMAZING AHHH EVERYONE GO SUPPORT OUR SHINEE AND BUY THEIR ALBUM ON ITUNES
Oh my! Minho's voice is beautiful!!
Forever loving Shinee's ballads :3
omg! taemin's high note and key's voice omo!!!!!
i loved Misconceptions of You for its upbeat song (especially spoiler
We love shinee
this is beautiful.... DEAR SHINee, I CAN'T LEAVE YOU... THOUGH YOU KILLING ME CONTINOUSLY... BUT SOMEHOW YOU ARE THE REASON FOR EVERYTHING OF ME.. I LOVE YOU, WITH ALL MY HEART AND SOUL... THANK YOU FOR BEING SHINee.. MY SHINee... TT__TT
goosebumps!!
their singing has improved so much! :O taemins singing was perf .... keys singing was perf everyones singing was perf theu all looked perf .... so basically their perfect ;)
The fact that I don't know what they're saying, but I felt like they were singing to me.
will you have sometimes fellings that you are close in some place that no one can went I have that fellings always when I listen SHINee ballad songs....why? becouse it's my own heaven
No one can by like them Their are amazing just becouse they always give more then 100% on their performence
i've seriously watched this over and over again and omigosh i am just so unbelievably proud of our boys. watching them grow up has been a beautiful experience and i'm glad i got to be a part of it. also HOLY CRAP TAEMIN'S HIGH NOTE!!!
PERFECTO !!!
FANS WERE CRYING. THAT'S JUST TRUE LOVE ALRIGHT.
I can't hold it when I heard taemin's high note ........perfect five... Perfect live OMG ....
Wow!!!!!!!!!!! It's fabulous!!!
these boys❤❤❤ their voices were amazing; the emotion they put into the song was just so djshsbjcjsajdh i cant even describe it. 사랑해요 샤이니 오빠
WOW THAT'S AMAZING...
4:40 that note~ just beautiful
Love this.... x3
SHINee ❤️
omfg asdfghjkl; they're too perfect, this song is so amazing thank god i can get this album! shinee hwaiting :)
Taemin high voice :) i love it .
this video is edited, they put the audio but shinee did live in this.
Shinne maybe you need singing like this in sm town tour in other country because song like this can proof shinee can singing very weel
i miss you, KJH!
although I can't understand Korean, but I can feel the sadness. cuz there were some ppl crying.
So lovely. I love you Kibum. I love you Jonghyun. I love you Onew. I love you Taemin. I love you Minho. I love you all SHINee~~
this is not lip synch, use your earpiece and listen to it properly. Compare this one and their mp3 version, its different.
Taemin~~ Only with listen his voice make me sad
Love his voice and love him 3
many people say SHINee lipsync now.. it bcoz SHINee voice was improve so much .. so people cant tell different live peformance with lipsync peformance
SHINee Daebakk !!!
omg i would love it if some korean person put up a korean lyrics then i will translate it in google translator
from their new album Dream Girl chapter 2
KEY!!!!
SHINee SHINee
because it is not...those who went to the spoiler meeting wrote their report....
part 2 of the album in april ^^
I CANNOT FUNCTION. the amount of replays i made T__T
Taemin's high note is too amazing. His singing's skill has improved really much since their debut.
And I love Key's voice so much, it's sweet, and I feel like I'm melting :)
Omg I've died and gone to heaven :3
You tell them!
....>_>.
You know at least a third of the people who are sitting in the audience are music critics.
Now don't you think they would've noticed if SHINee was trying to sell them a live performance when it's actually lipsynced?
And don't you think that would've been reflected in their reviews?
But the reviews were 100% positive.
So of course this wasn't lipsynced, SHINee doesn't want to dig their own graves lol.
I do admit there /might/ have been a little bit of audio editing for this VIDEO.
I do not think it is lip sync. I know SHINee's lip sync from live pretty well and they're not good at faking it.
This isn't Lip Synced.. you don't hear taemin's voice crack a little.. (i'm not a antis) SHINee Jjang !!
It are a really good song, but I think that they have not share equally the lines fair. Enough.... It was stil a good song from SHINee!
But it could be better if Jonghyun have got more lines!..
DAMMIT SHINEE!! WHY ARE YOU DOING THIS TO ME?!
I LOVE TAEMIN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
My husband sings so good!!!! My Taemin!!!! Wahhhhhh *Dies*
From a baby who sings very little lines to a man who can reach high notes. I proud of Taemin.
TAEMIN WHAT THE FUCK WAS THAT SCREAM