@@roshnaammu6395 she's still working hard because we see her improve little by little every aespa comeback but her raps has always been on point since debut 💯✨🤘
@@TheSeriousAnalysist don’t forget that she’s the one who recorded so even if it’s pre recorded you can’t deny her awesome vocals plus we’ve heard her in Coachella she has amazing vocals no doubt
@@Starevluv it’s live, look at winter’s neck veins during her high note towards the end, you don’t just strain those veins and arteries without actually applying pressure on them, it’s live.
Girls is a nice song. listening it again now the members vocals range amaze me. the song structure give me excitement alot. i enjoy the stage much better than i thought
I'm very disappointed in the fan that just flat out ignored NingNing. Sasaengs spread false rumors to the real fans so she didn't get anything from the fans. She worked her rear to make sure her fellow members got their stuff from the fans like letter and such. Her members are sad that she didn't get anything.If someone is spreading hate about the group your a fan of make sure that there are facts before you believe someone else.
live, zoom in or watch a winter focus of this stage, during the last high note focus on her neck veins. Your neck veins don’t pop up as if they’re that strained without you applying pressure on them, it’s live.
I dislike girls choreography because it depend on camera work and when it live only some members eat this choreography also they're not sing live here you can see how different next level and girls performance, btw karina is so cool her footwork always amazing
Karina sp and aura her visuals also skills born to be a performer ❤️🔥
Omg love Winter’s growl at @3:13. You can clearly hear her voice.
Giselle dance is improved a lot.....
She never danced bad, you guys say idol female who make mistakes dances bad and need to improve but with male that's totally different
Honestly Giselle was a 100 since day 1 :)
@@subilynnoweight2090 yes....she worked very hard......
@@roshnaammu6395 she's still working hard because we see her improve little by little every aespa comeback but her raps has always been on point since debut 💯✨🤘
@@subilynnoweight2090 yes my friend
although the backtrack is so loud but you can hear their voice, it's nice to see them try to sing it live and I love this performance
The comments saying they’re lip syncing, I can hear it’s live with some backtrack obviously just leave aespa alone y’all are obsessed
Because they don’t hve job to do that’s why 😂
So clear! And I was there!
Winter vocal really amazing
it's lipsync
@@TheSeriousAnalysist don’t forget that she’s the one who recorded so even if it’s pre recorded you can’t deny her awesome vocals plus we’ve heard her in Coachella she has amazing vocals no doubt
@@TheSeriousAnalysist it’s literally live
@@Starevluv it’s live, look at winter’s neck veins during her high note towards the end, you don’t just strain those veins and arteries without actually applying pressure on them, it’s live.
@@TheSeriousAnalysist A ya cierra el anastasio como arta ver a los envid0sos en estos vídeos, han cantando en vivo muchas veces.
SLAYYYYY QUEENS!!
they did so well and ik so proud!They are eating CD'S!!!!
Stan aespa=Stan talent
Thank u very much for uploadting our aespa video's ❤️
Girls is a nice song. listening it again now the members vocals range amaze me. the song structure give me excitement alot. i enjoy the stage much better than i thought
aespa kalian luar biasa ..❤❤❤❤
Live!!!Go Queens!!!!
I'm very disappointed in the fan that just flat out ignored NingNing. Sasaengs spread false rumors to the real fans so she didn't get anything from the fans. She worked her rear to make sure her fellow members got their stuff from the fans like letter and such. Her members are sad that she didn't get anything.If someone is spreading hate about the group your a fan of make sure that there are facts before you believe someone else.
Huh? Clarify please
She's the sweetest!! So sad She's treated like that :(
winter is so eye catching
I love this song Thank you for video ❤
THE OUTFITS HERE WERE AMAZING
gigi soooo pretty
why some people are obsessed with aespas lip sync? like every group does it, accept or not, it’s a fact. like let this girls breathe
Cause people never watch other group, they do care alot about aespa, even they don't look at their idol anymore 😂😂
because groups like stayc or lesserafim sing live now
@@Seungcris they sing 1-2times live and i’m sorry but they sound unstable.
because we want real performances, its that simple. Dont make excuses, theyre idols and their job is to sing
@@Seungcris singing live but still emm...
Giselle!!!! J'AIME ❤❤❤
So Cool
Ningning seems to have a problem with her ear or something
Cool 😎
Ning Ning
I saw a fan only capturing ningning💖
Winter 1:28 did "heheyyy"
People just pretend don't know if they do great performance, but if they do one mistake everyone just be evil to them
How much mony people in there????
Are they singing live? or with vocal assistance
live, zoom in or watch a winter focus of this stage, during the last high note focus on her neck veins. Your neck veins don’t pop up as if they’re that strained without you applying pressure on them, it’s live.
It's not
It’s live
I dislike girls choreography because it depend on camera work and when it live only some members eat this choreography also they're not sing live here you can see how different next level and girls performance, btw karina is so cool her footwork always amazing
AR인 것 같은데 마지막 윈터 고음은 라이브네 ㄷㄷ 겹쳐서 들림
에스파 실력이 라이브 립싱크 구분못할정도긴 하지
ការរួមភេទជាមួយមនុស្សវ័យជំទង់ រំលេច៖ វ័យជំទង់ជាវ័យដែលផ្លាស់ប្តូរទាំងផ្លូវកាយ អារម្មណ៍ ផ្លូវចិត្ត ជាវ័យដែលរាងកាយលូតលាស់ ហើយអ័រម៉ូនភេទក៏ប្រែប្រួល ត្រៀមខ្លួនចូលដល់អាយុបន្តពូជ ដូច្នេះហើយទើបចាប់ផ្តើមយកចិត្តទុកដាក់ចំពោះភេទផ្ទុយ។ ខ្ញុំចាប់ផ្តើមចង់សាកល្បងអ្វីៗ។ ចង់មានឯករាជ្យភាពរបស់ខ្លួន
They look sad for some reason :(
full lypsinc wtf
닝닝 머리 왜 불편해보이지
그냥 카리나랑 윈터만 보인다... 지젤 똥뱃살...다이어트 안하냐
제니바라마라시라이강소문: 외잠고우청강백시훤천기자류행속개번라제엘티이종개속신달동가젤폰전화스마트라수마트라가라어데로요내사니갈데알바아이라앙글라그라먼와이파이도앙글라앙그래니가공얌봉얌미얌맏ㅎ알지로뿅뿅뿅얏얏얏봉갸가겨거얀얕얏야아톰이옛날그대론줄아나...뿅뿅뿅뿅뿅!~~~30번첫날소리좀내읽고하루에10회줄여나중에는안보고하루세번만...! 각색주문이라도정방향비망각질위해●●\ 실시!ºº콱, 그라고함숨자고정벙향생활해라...
립싱크 그만 좀 하면 안되나
라이브다 막귀야
립싱크 자주 하는건 사실이지만 이젠 라이브 립싱크 구분도 못하네
가서 보고온 지인도 너무잘한다 칭찬했구만
깔생각만하지말고 귀좀파라
Its their company not them
@으쩌라구여 thiss
This is live you can hear their breaths at last part
윈터는 계속 들으면 라이브임 근데 지젤은 모르겠음
Lip sync again 😅 boycott SM artist for fooling audiences
they at least giving more energy than blackpink 💀
Their high notes can destroy them 😂😂😂😂 blonks
@@victorchaudhary6219 blinks,This isn't necessarily the case if it's blackpink fans who talk like that, so it's better to keep your mouth shut
@@sw3et9 why u dragging bp into this lmao😭
@@sw3et9 of course Aespa have more energy since they only need to lip sync and dancing
블랙핑크랑 차이점이지. 블핑은 라이브실력으로 미국 케이팝 덕후 아닌 애들도 실력보고 입덕함. 공연의 본고장 미국인데 미국인들이 듣는 귀 훨씬 수준높음.
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ에스파도 라이브 함~ 둘다 대단한 그룹인데 얻다 대고 비교질 함?
Shut up
ㅋㅋㅋ블핑보다 에스파가 노래훨씬잘함
블핑은 콘서트때 리사빼고춤도다틀리던데
공연의본고장미국 ㅋㄲ 개오글
@@hihi-po2tb 그래서 미국갈때마다 립싱크질이나 하는 에스파수준??ㅋㅋㅋ 노래 못한다는 트와이스도 미국공연만큼은 라이브로 다한다 ㅋㅋ 나라망신 짱스파 수준
aespa = lip sync. they are not singer. just dancer.
Need attention?
bro u can clearly hear them breathe at the last part :)
@@julixoanne btw she blinks..and i already read some of her comments about aespa
C'mon you need new ears!
They are live singing