The one from 2021 Fall (Baker Collection) just seems the best to me, and I love the packaging. Thank you for doing this video, it's so interesting! I wish repackaged didn't mean changed.
Oh nice! My sister agrees that version is the best🥰 I feel like the biggest difference was that the staying power really changed with the faceted collection. Thank you for watching!
@@MeetMsMarie I agree, it's like every time a scent comes out for a 2nd and 3rd repackage, the power decreases. I have noticed this trend. I am ok reapplying this particular scent a million times but I also feel like the lotion does last a while and primarily use the lotions and creams for lasting power.
It’s so interesting how each version is so different! I recently tried the faceted packaging of Bonfire Bash and I love it! Other versions always seemed too smoky to me. Thank you so much for doing such an in-depth review! 🥰
Oh I have an older packaging of Bonfire Bash and it does lean a bit too smoky at times! I need to smell it again (if it hasn't all sold out lol maybe😆)
Thanks for your scientific approach to this. Your findings add to my suspicions that the Faceted Collection is the most watered down version of a scent for the highest cost (regular price with no sale or coupons). I'm going to start boycotting the Faceted collection because it's just not worth it! I'm going to miss SPC when they stop making it!
I am hoping for a SPC perfume! That would be perfect and hopefully address the lasting power issue. Sunshine Mimosa in that packaging is also weak compared to the original. I redeemed a free reward for a SPC body cream recently and ended up exchanging it because of the how little it lasted.
I agree the Faceted collection is the most watered down version. I bought the Faceted mist in Strawberry Pound Cake and Champagne Toast last month and wound up returning both mists. Too weak compared to the non-faceted ones I already own.
The strawberry pound cake in travel size is my favorite ❤️ I tried the 2 newest strawberry pound cake and it is not as good as the older version. Hoping they will release a farm house collection with the same scent.
Loved the Farmhouse chalkboard packaging as well💜 I missed out on the plum scent that came out for that collection and now I'm curious about it, but SPC will forever be #1 for me.
Interesting results. I have the faceted collection version of SPC & for some reason I never liked SPC until now. I have no complaints, but I also have nothing to compare it to
That's good yours performs well! I've had quality issues mainly with candles and some have bad or weaker batches. I may sample SPC in every location I go to just to test it out.
I do think the faceted is definitely lighter but if you don't have anything to compare it to, then it would make sense that you would love it. It's still really good because it's an awesome scent, but it's just now it is watered down and higher priced:( But if I ran out, I would still get it lol!
I think if I didn't have the previous versions I wouldn't notice the decrease in staying power. I'm hoping BBW improves the quality of the formula! If I run out though I will buy the faceted packaging😅
You know I have a feeling there are also quality control issues with the FFM. The ones at my BBW store all smelled mainly of alcohol and were weak. I experienced a similar issue with Beach Nights so I ended up passing. I need to smell SPC again but I think it sold out😳 Glad yours lasted long!
It's more apparent when you do a side by side comparison😓 I like the smell of almost all of them but find myself reapplying more with the newer ffm, repackages included😮💨
Hm that's a bit hard. Maybe try your luck with Ebay, but maybe see if there are any popular reselling websites where you live since some are region specific.
The one from 2021 Fall (Baker Collection) just seems the best to me, and I love the packaging. Thank you for doing this video, it's so interesting! I wish repackaged didn't mean changed.
Oh nice! My sister agrees that version is the best🥰 I feel like the biggest difference was that the staying power really changed with the faceted collection. Thank you for watching!
@@MeetMsMarie I agree, it's like every time a scent comes out for a 2nd and 3rd repackage, the power decreases. I have noticed this trend. I am ok reapplying this particular scent a million times but I also feel like the lotion does last a while and primarily use the lotions and creams for lasting power.
It’s so interesting how each version is so different! I recently tried the faceted packaging of Bonfire Bash and I love it! Other versions always seemed too smoky to me. Thank you so much for doing such an in-depth review! 🥰
Oh I have an older packaging of Bonfire Bash and it does lean a bit too smoky at times! I need to smell it again (if it hasn't all sold out lol maybe😆)
Thanks for your scientific approach to this. Your findings add to my suspicions that the Faceted Collection is the most watered down version of a scent for the highest cost (regular price with no sale or coupons). I'm going to start boycotting the Faceted collection because it's just not worth it! I'm going to miss SPC when they stop making it!
I am hoping for a SPC perfume! That would be perfect and hopefully address the lasting power issue. Sunshine Mimosa in that packaging is also weak compared to the original. I redeemed a free reward for a SPC body cream recently and ended up exchanging it because of the how little it lasted.
I agree the Faceted collection is the most watered down version. I bought the Faceted mist in Strawberry Pound Cake and Champagne Toast last month and wound up returning both mists. Too weak compared to the non-faceted ones I already own.
L
The strawberry pound cake in travel size is my favorite ❤️ I tried the 2 newest strawberry pound cake and it is not as good as the older version. Hoping they will release a farm house collection with the same scent.
Loved the Farmhouse chalkboard packaging as well💜 I missed out on the plum scent that came out for that collection and now I'm curious about it, but SPC will forever be #1 for me.
Interesting results. I have the faceted collection version of SPC & for some reason I never liked SPC until now. I have no complaints, but I also have nothing to compare it to
That's good yours performs well! I've had quality issues mainly with candles and some have bad or weaker batches. I may sample SPC in every location I go to just to test it out.
I do think the faceted is definitely lighter but if you don't have anything to compare it to, then it would make sense that you would love it. It's still really good because it's an awesome scent, but it's just now it is watered down and higher priced:( But if I ran out, I would still get it lol!
@@meredithmetcalfe2329 Same! If I ran out of all my SPC stash I would be running to B&BW to get the faceted version immediately🏃♀️😂
@@MeetMsMarie ❤❤❤💯
I have the weakest version oh man 😩
I think if I didn't have the previous versions I wouldn't notice the decrease in staying power. I'm hoping BBW improves the quality of the formula! If I run out though I will buy the faceted packaging😅
Thanks for doing this!
No problem! Thank you for watching. I appreciate it😊
I have this scent too
It's a good one!🍓🍰
thats odd the one you said that only lasted an hour, lasted a whole day on my wrists for me until i took a bath.
You know I have a feeling there are also quality control issues with the FFM. The ones at my BBW store all smelled mainly of alcohol and were weak. I experienced a similar issue with Beach Nights so I ended up passing. I need to smell SPC again but I think it sold out😳 Glad yours lasted long!
Thanks for your information!! I dont think I've ever owned strawberry pound cake. Im just not a big fan of this scent!
You're welcome! SPC is a very polarizing scent. & thanks for watching!
Im exchanging mine tomm for the buttercups and Bellini
Great choice! I plan to buy a mini in that scent hopefully during SAS!
This confirms my suspension that the one I have doesn't last as long and it isn't as strong as the one i just bought for my daughter.
It's more apparent when you do a side by side comparison😓 I like the smell of almost all of them but find myself reapplying more with the newer ffm, repackages included😮💨
Does anyone know where I can buy the 2021 version? with worldwide shipping
Hm that's a bit hard. Maybe try your luck with Ebay, but maybe see if there are any popular reselling websites where you live since some are region specific.
Soo basically the ones with the best packaging don’t last got it 😂
I actually like the first packaging the best but yes depending which one you prefer😉
The faceted is so ugly
It's definitely overused. If the scents lasted longer I wouldn't mind as much but sadly nope😑