JMCD-12S4... The Best TaoBao NAS case of 2024? Jonsbo N5 who?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 8 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 97

  • @ph33lix
    @ph33lix Месяц назад +9

    Thank you for taking the time to document this case and even taking it apart as far as you did. It is very enlightening and now, I too want one.
    Well done! Subscribed!

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  Месяц назад +2

      Thank you! Glad it was helpful, I've encountered some nuances while building this one that I can't wait to share, should have the build video out soon.

  • @ObiYo1
    @ObiYo1 Месяц назад +7

    Wow the quality of this 1st video is really promising, I'm subscribed and really look forward to the final build! 👍🏻

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  Месяц назад +1

      Thank you. It’s coming. I had to order some last minute adapters as my psu didn’t have enough molex connectors to run the basement off 2 independent leads. Also have a m.2 e key to 2.5gbe arriving tonight.

  • @Jlomb436
    @Jlomb436 6 дней назад +1

    Dude, i bought this on Taoboa after watching your video. Seems like a more compact N5 that still supports full ATX options. The process took about 30 minutes with translating, but it was $144 shipped without fans or cables. Supposedly shipping is 6-8 business days via Air Freight express, so I shall wait and see! Super excited to try this thing out.

  • @BerkeleyDavis
    @BerkeleyDavis 2 месяца назад +23

    Rails are never pointless. Especially if someone wants to be able to work on their unit without having to have a separate surface like a table or desk around. I don't have to take a single server out of my homelab rack to work on it, and I love that.

    • @Bytional
      @Bytional Месяц назад

      Then I would like a full length case instead of this one, I won't say it's pointless but it's niche

    • @BerkeleyDavis
      @BerkeleyDavis Месяц назад

      ​@@BytionalIn the video he said rails would be pointless. That's what my comment was referencing.

    • @Bytional
      @Bytional Месяц назад

      @@BerkeleyDavis I know, that's why I kind of agree with him, it's niche in this case.
      It's a NAS case, most people buy these won't use a server rack and it's not even full length.

    • @BerkeleyDavis
      @BerkeleyDavis Месяц назад

      ​@@Bytional But it is a rack case... I would imagine that anyone going out of their way to buy a rack case intends to use it in a rack. Otherwise there are ample non-rack options available.

  • @kazumakazuma5814
    @kazumakazuma5814 6 дней назад +1

    Finally a useful review on this, thank you!

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  6 дней назад +1

      @@kazumakazuma5814 thank you! I haven’t been home much lately due to business travel, but I should have an update video hopefully before the holidays or whenever the next time I get more than a few hours at home.

    • @kazumakazuma5814
      @kazumakazuma5814 6 дней назад

      @@iLVTechCorner thank you, looking forward to it.

  • @ericasante8545
    @ericasante8545 2 месяца назад +4

    Crazy .. lol we tested. This case for project. Amazing cooling and airflow.

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  2 месяца назад +1

      At the time I purchased this my biggest issue with the Jonsbo N3 was airflow. Psu blocked the cpu cooler from getting any and my i7-12700k was always running hot in that thing.

  • @TheAndred1
    @TheAndred1 Месяц назад +1

    Thank you .Going to look into this one .I'm a novice but I really want to build my own with a heavyweight motherboard. Subscribed and looking forward to seeing your build

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  Месяц назад +1

      Thank you! Really appreciate the sub, I'm editing the build video now, but need to shoot the last little bit as I was waiting for some parts to come in. I'm hoping to have it done ASAP.

  • @Maunose
    @Maunose 10 дней назад +1

    I wish they had a 4U version with Half Height PCI slots… That would be just perfect for my setup.

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  10 дней назад

      im sure something like that exists, but probably wouldn't be short depth.

  • @Garageland16
    @Garageland16 Месяц назад +5

    I really wish their was a USA based re-seller for these. That sketchy purchasing experience along with super expensive shipping is kinda nuts. Great video though!

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  Месяц назад +1

      Definitely agree, would be nice, but it's also a weirdly niche "enthusiast" product, not optimized for enterprise, and can be intimidating for general consumer.

    • @Jlomb436
      @Jlomb436 6 дней назад +1

      If it helps, I just ordered this via Taoboa for $144 shipped to California without the fans or cables. Supposedly 6-8 business days. I'll let you know how it goes if you're interested.

  • @diazrocks
    @diazrocks 2 месяца назад +1

    would love to see you build one and see the ordering process as well! nice video man. keep it up!

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  2 месяца назад +1

      Thank you, I have a quick exit review of the Jonsbo N3 lined up, then the build in this case, Just finished building but will need to go back and re shoot some of the ending as I was up til about 3 am working on it and got tired of the camera being in the way.
      I will have some time this week while im on a business trip, I can probably get a quick video on the ordering process done during the week.

    • @jaturnley
      @jaturnley 2 месяца назад +2

      I ordered one off a random AliExpress vendor about 4 months ago. Took about a month to arrive (22 days, IIRC), partly because I had them put the fans in for me (which I strongly recommend, putting them in would have been a major PITA and requires removing a metric ***load of screws, as shown in the video).
      Mine came with an internal 2.5" cage which was completely pointless and had to be removed (which was not easy to do, it's screwed to the side of the case and you need a long slender screwdriver to get to two of the screws) because it sits right behind the PSU and there simply isn't room for the cables from the PSU with it in there. If you see one without that cage like the video shows, that's the one to get.
      Overall, I recommend this case. It's really well built, and is literally the only short depth full height full ATX NAS chassis on the market. Awesome airflow in both chambers, and the backplanes work flawlessly; I have 6 enterprise SATA drives in mine and they run at the full expected speeds. I had a couple of SATA SSDs in it to see how they fared and they did the same. It's fairly quiet due to using desktop parts, and it can be even quieter if you use silent fans like Noctua or BeQuiet. This can sit in the same room with you with NAS drives in it and you won't know it's there.
      The downsides are the number of screws in the thing - it's crazy how many there are, and really hard to figure out what ones need to come out for what components to be removed. The cable routing is not great, but works - your SAS cables need to be a half meter longer than whatever you think they will need to be due to the only pass through being under the PSU, and there's no cable management mechanisms in here whatsoever, so be prepared for that with some stick-on ones. Lastly, the motherboard size is limited to standard ATX; no EATX and no server boards other than something like an ASROCK Rack MicroATX.
      I'm using mine as an UNRAID NAS/Homelab server with an ASROCK Rack x470 server board, a Ryzen 3900X with a stock Zen Spire cooler, 128GB of RAM, a couple of cheap NVME drives, a quad port 12gbit SAS HBA, a dual port 10Gbit NIC, and an ARC A380 GPU. Temps are excellent, installation was easy (other than that stupid 2.5" cage), and it's quiet and stable. It sits above my rackmount UPS and under all my network gear in 12U short depth rack. Can't ask for more.

    • @LouieVBBp
      @LouieVBBp Месяц назад

      @@jaturnley Honestly I was super excited at first because of the 2.5" cage but thought I would have room to extend it to accommodate more drives, now that I've gotten the build done, honestly the cage is the perfect size but I might need to invest in custom length psu cables because the cables are all being managed under the cage with little to no room for anything else in there.
      This case would be absolutely perfect if it were maybe 2-3 inches deeper, but I totally understand the sizing and wanting to make the footprint as small as possible.
      Overall im really happy with it, I got an Asrock mobo in there as well and hopefully will have a video on the build as soon as I get back from my trip next week.

  • @Bytional
    @Bytional Месяц назад +1

    I would suggest Van Loong NAS H8-N, 8bay*3.5 + 4 NVME U2, takes ATX PSU and Mobo, soild build and better backboard, double 12CM fans for hard divers and 3 8cm fans for Mobo, no rails, only downside is the half height PCIE slots.

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  Месяц назад

      @@Bytional thanks for the heads up on that case, It looks like a solid one. It’s not quite able to accommodate what I’m looking for or the parts I already have. But does seem to have some serious cooling which is nice. Have you made a build with that case? I’d be Interested in hearing about your experiences with it. Thanks!

  • @Captn_Grumpy
    @Captn_Grumpy Месяц назад +1

    I need this in my life :)
    Cant say the N5 impressed me. Too many compromises for the regular consumer market. Too expensive compared to these cheaper rackmount gear.
    Thanks for putting this out there.

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  Месяц назад

      I’m curious... What compromises did you feel the N5 had? I’ve been looking into getting my hands on one once it’s more widely available, so I’d love to hear your thoughts. Was it the build quality, features, or something else that didn’t impress you?
      If you were to redesign or improve the N5, what would you change? Always interesting to hear how people would tweak these cases! Thanks for checking out the video, and if you haven’t already, feel free to subscribe for updates on my future builds and reviews!

    • @Captn_Grumpy
      @Captn_Grumpy Месяц назад

      @@iLVTechCorner Off the top of my head. The drive bays is immediately front of mind.
      Seeing NASCompares initial review the metal looks to have been reduced in gauge since the original sample.
      I prefer the PSU placement on the JMCD although neither are great, the N5 seems to increase depth unnecessarily and I think height but that can be countered by the JMCDs increased width.
      I much prefer the backplanes on the JMCD, the N5 feels more like "its what we had", with different activity light and numbering. For the price I just feel they should have done better.
      It also looks like there is more customisability in the JMCD, that space on the opposite side of the PSU is screaming for more drives :)
      Also the 2.5 mount, despite being in the way a little, I prefer in the JMCD over the almost afterthought mounting in the N5.
      Personal preference, but I hate the timber panelling and I prefer the industrial look of the JMCD.
      All of that said if the price is reasonable when local pricing is finalised it might come out closer to the JMCD (with postage and accounting for possible faffing around) and ultimately I will weight up my options.

  • @Elemino
    @Elemino 2 месяца назад +3

    Not bad for a first video. I’ll be watching.
    - Tech-Know Scope

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  2 месяца назад

      Thank you, Much appreciated. Working on some of the filming skills, im a bit shakey for b-roll but trying to work on that too, it might take a little bit but hoping to improve quite a bit.

    • @Elemino
      @Elemino 2 месяца назад +1

      @@iLVTechCorner For B Roll, make sure you have a tripod with a video head. Small rig makes a great one that competes with others that cost many times more.

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  2 месяца назад

      @@Elemino Looking at maybe getting a slider too, do you think that would be helpful or save it and get a gimbal instead?

    • @Elemino
      @Elemino 2 месяца назад

      @@iLVTechCorner tripods are always needed, sliders, not so much. Many people that get them for b roll say they ultimately stop using it. Unless you plan to start shooting weddings and commercials, I wouldn’t.

  • @nadtz
    @nadtz Месяц назад +3

    Rails are anything but useless for something that is supposed to be rack mount but I can see this appealing to a lot of people who might not care too much about rack mounting it. 6U is too much to lose for only 12 bays if you did want to rack it but in a lot of ways this looks to be a pretty neat NAS chassis given you can fit full ATX motherboard and PSU and it looks like it has pretty good cooling.

    • @Cynyr
      @Cynyr Месяц назад +1

      While i sort of agree with you, the big draw here to me is the half depth. If there were non-crazy 15” deep disk shelves out there I'd be happy with that too. Not all of us have room for 36"+ deep servers. So this + 3 3u nodes + switch + 2u patch panel would all fit in 18u. I'd say you could get a ups in 24u too, but I'm not aware of any 15" deep upses. Basically I'm wanting to cram a rack under a desk.
      The Silverstone RM61-312 is a very similar case.

    • @nadtz
      @nadtz Месяц назад

      @@Cynyr Sliger makes a bunch of 15" depth cases, a couple of them can hold 10 drives, have rails available and they do it in 3u. That's just off the top of my head I'm pretty sure I've seen a couple other short depth storage chassis that are 3-4u so I have no idea why one would waste 6u unless you absolutely need to use an ATX motherboard or you just really wanted that case.
      Most 'consumer' rackmount UPS's aren't even 15" in depth (mine is 10") so that's not a problem either unless again you want some monster UPS that's 20" depth for some reason.

    • @Cynyr
      @Cynyr Месяц назад

      @@nadtz at 3u you need a sfx psu rather than atx (+$). The 3701 is miniitx and 15" deep but 10 + 4 bays getting 10g+ ethernet, a hba, and transcoding on mini-itx is an issue. The 3702 gives you uatx motherboards, but moves out to 18" deep and still needs sfx psus. It probably would still fit under a desk. My ideal would be uatx motherboards, atx psus, and at most 18" deep. So basically a 4u version of the 3702.
      The cx4712 is close but it's 24" deep because it goes for eatx motherboards. The neat thing about the 370x cases is you can make them a das easily.

    • @nadtz
      @nadtz Месяц назад

      @@Cynyr SFX PSU's don't cost much more than a decent ATX PSU si I can't really see that as an issue if it saves 3u.
      If you have 3 3u's why do you need to do transcoding on the NAS? CPU with IGPU is also an option if you absolutely need to do it on a NAS. Then you only need HBA and NIC or a motherboard with 10GbE is also an option so you can fit a GPU.
      Had to dig around to find the model number but the ED412H40-E would work if you don't mind Alibaba and can squeeze 19" instead of 18".

    • @nadtz
      @nadtz Месяц назад

      @@Cynyr ED412H-Q1 from the same seller, 12 bay 4U 400mm depth and it looks like you can squeeze in an ATX motherboard. Can't say anything about how good/bad the case or seller is but still gives you 2U more to play with.

  • @PeterBrockie
    @PeterBrockie 15 дней назад

    This is what the N5 should have been. A desktop/rackable case with a decent design (although I'm not convinced 4x92mm fans can keep 12 modern drives under control), and damn SFF connectors on the backplane so you don't have sata cables everywhere. I think Jonsbo has been getting lazy with their designs after the N3. The N4 was a joke and the N5 seems overpriced for what it is considering they couldn't even be bothered to respin the backplanes with SFF connectors.

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  10 дней назад

      Would have love to see Jonsbo have a convertible desktop/rackmount design. But honestly Im happy with the N5 because they checked a lot of the boxes that they normally miss. It's big enough to get some serious cooling which hasn't been the case with most of their n series. I feel like they always just give up on the caddies and backplane and just re use parts they have in the parts bin, but I'd take Jonsbo's backplane and rubber straps over Sligers system any day.
      I do hope that Jonsbo one day makes a system with a better backplane and a better caddy system, but baby steps I guess.

  • @davidalonso9871
    @davidalonso9871 2 месяца назад +2

    Really nice video. New suscriber here, waiting for more content.

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  2 месяца назад

      Thank you, I plan on having an exit review of the outgoing Jonsbo N3 as well as the build video, but might have a few more vids planned out as im already planning upgrades.

  • @whatwhat-777
    @whatwhat-777 Месяц назад +1

    I want more videos around this case

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  Месяц назад +1

      I'd be happy to make more videos around this case! I've already uploaded a build video, and I'll be posting an update to it soon. If there's anything specific you'd like me to cover, let me know, and I'll include it. Don’t forget to subscribe and hit the notification bell so you don’t miss the updates!

    • @whatwhat-777
      @whatwhat-777 Месяц назад +1

      @@iLVTechCorner I’m so into this case that I just dropped $350 (shipping included!) to bring it into my network rack! 😆
      Going to turn it into my beefy Proxmox server. I saw you did an Unraid build, and I’m super curious-how's the Unraid performance, and what are the drive/CPU temps under load, especially with a 10-gig card in there?
      Also, are the fans noisy, or will they need the magical touch of some Noctua fans to make it whisper quiet?
      My wallet’s weeping, but my rack is about to be chef’s kiss! Can’t wait for your next update!

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  Месяц назад

      @@whatwhat-777 Congrats on picking up the case! Your Proxmox server is going to look amazing in that rack.
      For Unraid performance, it's been rock solid. The drive temps in the hot-swap bays stay under 40°C, even during parity checks, and the SSDs inside the case hold steady at around 40°C, even at idle. They don’t fluctuate much since they’re positioned right behind one of the case fans, keeping them nice and cool.
      I haven’t added a 10-gig card yet, but it's something I’m considering down the line-so stay tuned for that!
      On the fans, I originally thought about upgrading to Arctic P12 Max fans, but the airflow has been great so far. I might swap them out eventually, but it'll probably be for aesthetics (maybe some RGB to keep the blue theme) rather than for noise or airflow.
      Also, I’m thinking about swapping the Noctua L9i for the BeQuiet SlimRock 2 since I have it lying around and could probably sell the L9i more easily. Just an idea I’m playing with!
      Your rack IS going to be chef’s kiss, can’t wait to hear how it all turns out! Thanks again for the support!

  • @Cooper3312000
    @Cooper3312000 Месяц назад +1

    Wish it was available with a nvme u.2 backplane. Those driver second hand are becoming more affordable.

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  Месяц назад

      There is one. I think the 2nd one in my description has the option for a backplane with NVMe/u.2

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  Месяц назад

      My bad. It was the third link (2nd TaoBao link) has an option for 4 of the 12 bays to be NVMe u.2 drives.

  • @juzzotec
    @juzzotec Месяц назад +1

    I would prefer the Jonsbo N5 but this is an option.

  • @hamany99
    @hamany99 Месяц назад +1

    Does it come with fans, or have to be bought separately? I noticed in AliExpress some are selling it with additional fans. Thank you.

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  Месяц назад +1

      @@hamany99 they sell it in 3 variations, you can buy bare bones (no fans no cables), you can get it with cables only (SFF to SATA breakout), or you can get it with cables and fans. I got the one with the cables and fans because the 3 fans were cheaper then the cheapest 3 fans at microcenter and the cables are directional so finding them on amazon would be a pain.

    • @hamany99
      @hamany99 Месяц назад +1

      @@iLVTechCorner Thank you.

    • @hamany99
      @hamany99 Месяц назад +1

      @@iLVTechCorner Any idea if I'm also required to get a directional cable for (SFF-8643 to SFF-8087)?

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  Месяц назад +1

      @@hamany99 I believe those should be bidirectional, it’s my understanding that only the SATA breakout cable is directional

  • @georgebostel2847
    @georgebostel2847 2 месяца назад +2

    Trying to find this case from the UK, soo difficult 😢

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  2 месяца назад +4

      I had a hard time finding it anywhere outside of AliExpress and TaoBao, would a video of the ordering process I used help?

    • @georgebostel2847
      @georgebostel2847 2 месяца назад

      @@iLVTechCorner I was trying to find on Aliexpress also, where you thinking unraid or truenas for a device like this?

  • @LouieVBBp
    @LouieVBBp Месяц назад +1

    Great Video!

  • @Michaelmaertzdorf
    @Michaelmaertzdorf Месяц назад +2

    I see 3x SAS 12G connectors, most raid controllers have 2x SAS3, do all 3 rows work if "only" 2x is connected?

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  Месяц назад +3

      Nope. It’s not one big backplane, it’s 3 individual 4 bay backplanes. So they aren’t connected to each other.

    • @Michaelmaertzdorf
      @Michaelmaertzdorf Месяц назад +1

      @@iLVTechCornerthats a shame, so you would need an 8i card and use 3 of the 4 connectors so you can use all 12 slots...
      Thats quite the nummer, neat case overall tho.

    • @tim3172
      @tim3172 Месяц назад

      @@Michaelmaertzdorf You would use a 16i card, LSI 9300-16i, etc.

  • @davidalonso9871
    @davidalonso9871 2 месяца назад +1

    It needs more passtrough for cables.

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  2 месяца назад

      having almost finished the build, yea that cutout at the bottom is tight for the 3 sff to sata cables. The top one under the PSU was fine for me to get 2 leads down to the backplane with room for more to fit.

  • @forcom5
    @forcom5 2 месяца назад +1

    I could really use this. Can you post the product listing on either of the sites you got it from?

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  2 месяца назад +1

      I updated the videos description to include it.

    • @forcom5
      @forcom5 2 месяца назад

      @@iLVTechCorner Sweet! Thanks!

  • @V1N_574
    @V1N_574 2 месяца назад +1

    This looks more enterprise build, N5 is more home use. I prefer a sata plate and 120mm fans.

    • @LouieVBBp
      @LouieVBBp Месяц назад

      Right on man! I'm still looking at the N5 to transplant old gear into and maybe use as an off site at my parents house.

  • @Mitchomi
    @Mitchomi 10 дней назад +1

    Has anyone actually rackmounted this? The price went up after this video was made too

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  10 дней назад

      Unfortunately I haven't tried gotten a rack yet. I've been home maybe a total of 6 days in the last month. Travel a lot for work and its busy season. Probably wont happen until after the holidays but I'll update once I get a small rack for under my desk.

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  10 дней назад

      Just double checked the price, its still looks like its 15cny cheaper because of a coupon. Dont forget to check Superbuy for coupons too....

  • @LudvigLindell
    @LudvigLindell 2 месяца назад

    A slightly higher, 8U?, version with 24 bays would be amazing.

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  2 месяца назад

      They have a 4u with 24 bays or a 4u with 36 bays but pci on the back is only half height. The biggest difference will be that the case will be A Lot deeper.

    • @LudvigLindell
      @LudvigLindell 2 месяца назад +2

      @@iLVTechCorner sounds like normal rack cases. It's the length of this one that is interesting.

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  2 месяца назад

      @@LudvigLindell 100

  • @moogs
    @moogs Месяц назад +3

    Jonsbo N5 is gonna crush this thing. Thing is fugly.

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  Месяц назад

      Right on man! I'm planning on getting my hands on an N5 once they are available stateside so be on the lookout for that video.

  • @selfhosted
    @selfhosted 2 месяца назад +1

    Does it only support SAS drives or will it also support Sata drives aswell? Great first video btw!

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  2 месяца назад

      Thank you & Sas is backwards compatable with sata in most cases, but yes this will accommodate sata.

  • @KelleyBetsy-m8u
    @KelleyBetsy-m8u 2 месяца назад

    Maye View

  • @edhahaz
    @edhahaz 22 дня назад +1

    Maybe, but not fancy looking.

  • @DanielTekmyster
    @DanielTekmyster Месяц назад +3

    Awful design….

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  Месяц назад

      What don’t you like and how would you change it?

  • @tangodown2721
    @tangodown2721 Месяц назад +1

    Product link goes to some Chinese login page..nope

  • @oxxysaurus
    @oxxysaurus 2 месяца назад +1

    Rails would be pointless? Lol, you clearly don't work with this sort of thing regularly.

    • @iLVTechCorner
      @iLVTechCorner  2 месяца назад +3

      Nope. Not at all. This is a hobby but this case does not have any mounting options for rails, so may not be the best case for someone looking for a case on rails.