did you forget what they tried to do in Niger? west does not care for justice and peace so long their citizens are safe! France like any EU is a tail of USA.
Yeah, I also have to say no. France is filled with discrimination and prejudice, some they even made into law. Although happy with their new stance, but I won't be padding them on the back. They have a long road to go and show no desire to acknowledge it, let alone make changes.
I am one month old. I attended my mother's womb university. I studied history there, and I can tell people to stop learning about Zionism from Wikipedia or any Western corrupt media.
The US loves using that word because it allows you to hear about them dying and think of it as an enemy that died. But if you use the term "resistance fighters", then you understand who is the oppressed and who are the aggressors/occupiers
Very refreshing to hear someone call out the term "terrorist" as what it is. It's a crude and lazy term to demonize an individual rather than explain or debate the reason behind their action. The "they're evil" and "we're good" is complete political rubbish that plays into our innate desire to be virtuous.
You are ignoring what hamas/palestinians are doing by attacking Israel and Israel settlers. Of course Israel will fight back. Show me one case when Israel attacked without being provoked.
It’s really crazy, it’s like people like war. They say that they are evil and that’s it. They offer no solutions (or ridiculous ones) and don’t look other groups who are far away from them as humans, just numbers (or human shields). And then we have to audacity to call our selves civilised and morally superior.
Well they are partly to blame for this mess. The Brits betrayed Hussein bin Ali King of the Hejaz, Hashemite Sharif of Mecca. Research the Arab Revolt. and Hussein-McMahon correspondence The Brits made a deal with France, research Sykes-Picot Agreement 1916 Those lands were basically stolen 1916. There are some other components to this story the creation of (i.e. Zionist) late 1800's. names to research. 1. Vladamir (Ze'ev) Jabotinsky (Ukrainian)1890-1940 Participated in the 1903 world zionist convention, he voted and rejected the Uganda proposal. 2.Theodor Herzl creator of the zionist congress formed in 1897. There are more layers but you can discover them for yourself.
France is just feeling the pressure and wants to claim, after this is over that “they supported the oppressed side”. Justice and freedom is not telling Muslim women what they can and can not wear.
one man’s terrorist is another man’s freedom fighter. well said! hate begets hatred, it is a never ending cycle. as long as we see others as 'i am this, you are that', we can never truly united. there's always gap between us waiting to break apart.
@@mimic6494 He was arguing that it is subjective, but it is very clear what terrorism is. When Hamas targets civilians, for political reasons, they are a terrorist group. The guy wants to muddy the water, because he agrees with the goals of Hamas, but does not want to say it.
I don't know how people said this is terrorism. the freedom fighter is trying to get attention for freedom. Every single human wants freedom yes or not?
What can we, regular ppl, 'always' do to show our support and indignation ? An action that doesn't even required asking for permission. An action that cannot be stopped. Always remember
Looking at the subject from a legal angle Security Council 242 gives the rights to expel or detain anyone in their territory. Not that I agree with violence from either side, but you really can't punish someone (Palestinians) for asking for their rights. SC 242 quote; " The resolution calls for the withdrawal of Israeli troops from the occupied territories, acknowledges the claim of sovereignty, territorial integrity and political independence of every state in the region and calls on the UN Secretary-General to appoint an Envoy to facilitate an acceptable solution to the conflict. "
These are the current members of the UN Human Rights Council: Angola, Burkina Faso, Cameroon, Democratic Republic of the Congo, Eritrea, Nigeria, Senegal, Somalia, Togo, Afghanistan, Bahrain, Bangladesh, Fiji, India, Nepal, Pakistan, Philippines, Qatar, Bulgaria, Czech Republic, Slovakia, Ukraine, Argentina, Bahamas, Chile, Mexico, Peru, Uruguay, Australia, Austria, Denmark, Italy, Spain. Not exactly a bastion of humanity...
@@surojeetchatterjee i am sorry to break this to you but humans are not consistent and they lie, the value of words is always low actions speak louder than words
@@graveperil2169Well now whenever someone says if they are terrorists I’ll probably ask which country labeled them so, if the USA and Isreal are in that List I’d be like are you sure? I will do independent research first. That’s what happens when there is lack of consistency clearly due to bias and greed.
@@graveperil2169 Then there will be chaos around the world. No one will get peace. My way or high way ideology doesn't work. It will only increase conflict & wars around the world.
2:20 Hamas had 44% of the Palestinian vote in 2006... By contrast, around 60% of the population of Gaza wasn't even born or of voting age when Hamas was elected. For the West Bank that number is over 50%. It's a fair point that Hamas might enjoy the support of the Palestinian population, but to support that point you need way better evidence that a very old election that didn't even had the participation of the majority of today's Palestinian population.
The US called the Mujahideen freedom fighters in Afghanistan battling against the Soviets and called them terrorists when they attacked the US. The terms are useless.
Last time checked France is not one of the biggest trading partner with Israel, criticize as much as you want but other than sanctions, then confront USA and IDF on the ground other than that what exactly condemnation means? It’s a real question.
Part of this conflict that isn't being talked about is Hamas's use of rockets and what they intended to see when they were launching rockets at Israel. They were hoping for mass devastation of Israel and only the self defense capabilities of Israel changed that outcome. If you can be upset about the IDF landing their munitions on targets that they have identified as military forces then a statement against Hamas blind firing rockets in Israel's direction is WORSE because they don't care about what they are trying to hit. They're not aiming these things they're launching them. Just because Hamas is overmatched doesn't mean that they have the right to blind fire their munitions with impunity.
Recognize the state of Palestine and get rid of some level of hypocrisy. It will secure and gurantee security for both Palestainian children and Israeli colonial children
You miss the point. Israel had Left wing governments and more centrist governments that negotiated a peace agreement with the Palestinians, but in the end not only did the Palestinians fail to accept an agreement, they launched an intifada against Israel, murdering more than 1000 civilians. This person claims it’s the occupation, but why do the Palestinians always back out when it’s time to sign? 1937, 1947, 1967, 2000 and 2008. Also, between 1948 and 1967 Jordan occupied the West Band and Jerusalem and Egypt occupied Gaza. Why didn’t they establish a country then? They had 20 years!
Why no one challenged him that gaza is left by Israel in 2005? Or why he compares the hamas as government who rejects Israel right to exist to "some Israeli don't support two state solution"? Or that last election in gaza was in 2006, 2009 in west Bank. Very strange.
Hamas won less than 50 percent of the election eighteen years ago . Half of the population of Gaza is under 18 . Another 20 percent were too young to vote in the only election. Therefore 14 percent (or less) of the current population ever voted for Hamas. Many of that 14 percent had 18 years to find out what Hamas was really like. Those 18 years saw much more conflict in Gaza than ever before , including 38 years under Israeli occupation, 19 years under Egyptian occupation and over 30 years under British occupation. Hamas cannot be considered as anything other than group who rule by terror, conduct terrorist attacks and in reality did nothing to stop many of the 14 percent to change their minds. Hamas only emerged in the late 1980"s and was never a mass popular movement, only gaining relative popularity after Fatah (political wing of PLO) had declined in popularity from the 1980"s and failed to impress Gazan's even after they won local elections in 1993.
The problem is: since its origin, , Hamas doesn't accept other solution than a Islamic State "from the river to the sea". How to make an agreement with Hamas? Israel has acceoted the two state solution according to UN Resoltion in 1947. The problem was: no arab country has accepted Israel. And now we are in this "lock-in" situation.
I'm curious why no one denies that the West uses double standards or even hipocracy... but when there are anti-Semitics, they easily discuss this. but then again. about double standards, why don't they say "we don't do double standards".. This makes me believe that they are indeed double standards
Terror is an emotion, you can't wage war on emotions...its irrational. Terrorist and international terrorism is a fear tactic designed to generate hate toward another group.
I am trying to understand these called specialists.... Hamas...Israel...recognized organizations or states are not the matters. The problem is the actions, the criminalities, the ways of war that the people are using. Cutting the heads of people without discrimination, bombing without thinking of children...ignorance of international rules... This is whatwhat makes hamas or other organizations terrorists. Israel is fighting for its survival. If it doesn't fight it will finish. How hamas is using his freedom? How israel will become if hamas is free for all of his activities?
What type of foolishness is this..if you plan and execute a large deadly assault of rape brutality and murder on innocent civilians you are a terrorist...smh. sad
Powerful nation like France should act on the side of Justice and humanity to resolve this conflict.
did you forget what they tried to do in Niger? west does not care for justice and peace so long their citizens are safe! France like any EU is a tail of USA.
If they cared they would not let this problem fester to begin with. They are white.
Last thing the world needs is France spreading "Justice and humanity"
@@xXxBo5sANaCxXxexactly!! I don't know which nation have more blood on hands...
@@xXxBo5sANaCxXx
“America spreading freedom and democracy” 2.0
We should not forget the German occupation of France and the French Resistance. The Germans called the French Resistance at that time terrorist.
You can compare the situation, Palestine was never an independent country therefore it was never occupied
The Germans never offered France a country that was turned down
Don't forget half the country collaborated with them though.
@@juliepetit2032 and yet they continue to give these settlers billions
@@TinaHenderson-cl9mbAfter the War many faced the death penalty
Enough is ENOUGH! All humans deserve freedom and equal rights!!!
But to some Palestinians are not humans!
@@jchung5265, some Palestinians are not humans but monsters, rather! 🤮
The Germans support Genocide against the Palestinian people. Obviously the Germans would support Genocide. It surprises no one on this planet.
Terrorist is just what the big army calls the little army
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Right!
@@David-qc1zp It sure is right, isn't it …
@@David-qc1zp Laugh David: the joke is on you > your new name is Goliath…
There was a time when the English used to call Americans terrorist 1776
We still do
Bush and Blair-brothers in arms -they both have blood on their hands
I'm glad france is changing its stance to a more unbiased peaceful one
No, it’s just overrun by Islamic fundamentalist now
yes
Lol. nope.
Yeah, I also have to say no. France is filled with discrimination and prejudice, some they even made into law. Although happy with their new stance, but I won't be padding them on the back. They have a long road to go and show no desire to acknowledge it, let alone make changes.
Weren't they the ones who helped Israel develop nukes
Only one month old babies think it started on October 7.
I am one month old. I attended my mother's womb university. I studied history there, and I can tell people to stop learning about Zionism from Wikipedia or any Western corrupt media.
I condemn Monday
The US loves using that word because it allows you to hear about them dying and think of it as an enemy that died. But if you use the term "resistance fighters", then you understand who is the oppressed and who are the aggressors/occupiers
Targeting people at a dance festival and civilians in their homes is t*rr*sm, you coward.
Thank you for speaking the truth
Very refreshing to hear someone call out the term "terrorist" as what it is. It's a crude and lazy term to demonize an individual rather than explain or debate the reason behind their action. The "they're evil" and "we're good" is complete political rubbish that plays into our innate desire to be virtuous.
You are ignoring what hamas/palestinians are doing by attacking Israel and Israel settlers. Of course Israel will fight back. Show me one case when Israel attacked without being provoked.
"Terrorist" is the side that can't afford nice uniforms.
It’s really crazy, it’s like people like war. They say that they are evil and that’s it.
They offer no solutions (or ridiculous ones) and don’t look other groups who are far away from them as humans, just numbers (or human shields). And then we have to audacity to call our selves civilised and morally superior.
So happy to see common sense here
@@alexpkeaton4471we should set up a uniform fund😊
Wow , he nailed every question she asked .
IF THERE WAS NO OCCUPATION , THERE WOULDN''T BE ANY CONFLICT .
Very smart and honest person .
BRAVO .
Simple man and is the Truth
Quite simple ultimately…
100 percent correct
France wants to be on the right side of history.
@@hdibenshushan6025 not true. Many French, no matter their religious beliefs, don't support this slaughter
It is another white flag for them.😊
France had many attacks on civilians in the last decade. Will France say that "terror" label is inappropriate.
About time.
Well they are partly to blame for this mess.
The Brits betrayed Hussein bin Ali King of the Hejaz, Hashemite Sharif of Mecca.
Research the Arab Revolt. and Hussein-McMahon correspondence
The Brits made a deal with France, research Sykes-Picot Agreement 1916
Those lands were basically stolen 1916.
There are some other components to this story the creation of (i.e. Zionist) late 1800's.
names to research.
1. Vladamir (Ze'ev) Jabotinsky (Ukrainian)1890-1940
Participated in the 1903 world zionist convention, he voted and rejected the Uganda proposal.
2.Theodor Herzl creator of the zionist congress formed in 1897.
There are more layers but you can discover them for yourself.
Respect to this Man speaking truth.
totally agree
The world needs France to be a force for justice and freedom. Don't be like Germany, always on the wrong side of history.
France is just feeling the pressure and wants to claim, after this is over that “they supported the oppressed side”.
Justice and freedom is not telling Muslim women what they can and can not wear.
What a great guy! One of the best I’ve seen!
one man’s terrorist is another man’s freedom fighter. well said! hate begets hatred, it is a never ending cycle. as long as we see others as 'i am this, you are that', we can never truly united. there's always gap between us waiting to break apart.
If a group commits' terrorist actions they are terrorists.
You are missing the point of the quote. By your logic if a group fights for freedom he is then a freedom fighter?
@@returnofCrusadewere you not listening to the guy? His whole point was terrorist is not an objective term
@@mimic6494 He was arguing that it is subjective, but it is very clear what terrorism is. When Hamas targets civilians, for political reasons, they are a terrorist group. The guy wants to muddy the water, because he agrees with the goals of Hamas, but does not want to say it.
Pakistan murdered 2 million hindus in 1971.Why isn't the world talking about that?
Finally, they are starting to state the truth of what is happening! It is not Hamas at all
Every word out of IDF mouths is pure fairytale!
Would Gandi be called terrorist when Indian kicked British out of India?
Ask the people of Kashmir. Free Kashmir now
What a great, albeit short interview. Very enlightening. Thank you.
I don't know how people said this is terrorism. the freedom fighter is trying to get attention for freedom. Every single human wants freedom yes or not?
Unfortunately whole world is just watching the injustice and is not capable of doing anything to stop it😢
Very honestly stated. Very well analyzed. Thanks!
Wow finally, thank you for bringing another point of view to social media,
Great interview. France, take the lead🇫🇷
Bravo!
I congratulate this man for being on the side of justice
“ The Coe issue is Occupation.”
🎯
What can we, regular ppl, 'always' do to show our support and indignation ? An action that doesn't even required asking for permission. An action that cannot be stopped. Always remember
France is a great nation, happy to have it back on the side of justice
Can you'll imagine,this conflict is going on for sooo long, that people specialize in it, wow, crazy if you ask me.
The truth is only one
He speaks the truth.
Looking at the subject from a legal angle Security Council 242 gives the rights to expel or detain anyone in their territory. Not that I agree with violence from either side, but you really can't punish someone (Palestinians) for asking for their rights.
SC 242 quote;
"
The resolution calls for the withdrawal of Israeli troops from the occupied territories, acknowledges the claim of sovereignty, territorial integrity and political independence of every state in the region and calls on the UN Secretary-General to appoint an Envoy to facilitate an acceptable solution to the conflict.
"
These are the current members of the UN Human Rights Council: Angola, Burkina Faso, Cameroon, Democratic Republic of the Congo, Eritrea, Nigeria, Senegal, Somalia, Togo, Afghanistan, Bahrain, Bangladesh, Fiji, India, Nepal, Pakistan, Philippines, Qatar, Bulgaria, Czech Republic, Slovakia, Ukraine, Argentina, Bahamas, Chile, Mexico, Peru, Uruguay, Australia, Austria, Denmark, Italy, Spain. Not exactly a bastion of humanity...
Well Said
Hes completely right
thanks for telling the truth about war crimes
I hope France will ignite the liberté, égalité, fraternité spirit. Stand on the right side of history. Vive la France 🇨🇵
Oppressive side uses this termonology......
but some times it's justified
@@graveperil2169 but things doesn't work based on sometimes. One has to be consistent otherswise the value of words decreases.
@@surojeetchatterjee i am sorry to break this to you but humans are not consistent and they lie, the value of words is always low actions speak louder than words
@@graveperil2169Well now whenever someone says if they are terrorists I’ll probably ask which country labeled them so, if the USA and Isreal are in that List I’d be like are you sure? I will do independent research first. That’s what happens when there is lack of consistency clearly due to bias and greed.
@@graveperil2169 Then there will be chaos around the world. No one will get peace. My way or high way ideology doesn't work. It will only increase conflict & wars around the world.
Free West Africa of France. Free New Caledionia of France. Free Reunion of France. Free Tahiti of France.
Shame on British, USA, Canada and most of Europe! France is not blind!
Wow, is refreshing to listen to such a matured mind.
2:20 Hamas had 44% of the Palestinian vote in 2006... By contrast, around 60% of the population of Gaza wasn't even born or of voting age when Hamas was elected. For the West Bank that number is over 50%.
It's a fair point that Hamas might enjoy the support of the Palestinian population, but to support that point you need way better evidence that a very old election that didn't even had the participation of the majority of today's Palestinian population.
The US called the Mujahideen freedom fighters in Afghanistan battling against the Soviets and called them terrorists when they attacked the US. The terms are useless.
True
This is such a resonable discussion. It's refreshing to hear that someone in the West is thinking more clearly than the leaderhsip
Unlike USA, they listened to the voice of people, not the Special Interest
This is what,you can't have hate agenda.....Hate is for the act not for the People,this gentleman is a picture of that.
Pakistan murdered 2 million hindus in 1971.Why isn't the world talking about that?
What?
A man who speaks common sense.
Hopefully peaceful coexistence will prevail
Wow, first time I hear reasonable French speaking. By God, the first time.
If France loves Palestinians so much, they should take them, all 5.5 million of them. Israel is tired of them living on their territory
Why do a program from news that sould be less than 1 min. The programming dosent work anymore
It explains please.
Thanks for posting.
Last time checked France is not one of the biggest trading partner with Israel, criticize as much as you want but other than sanctions, then confront USA and IDF on the ground other than that what exactly condemnation means? It’s a real question.
Proud of this man for telling the truth openly.
This guy is intelligent and speaks sense. But which western leader is listening ?
Part of this conflict that isn't being talked about is Hamas's use of rockets and what they intended to see when they were launching rockets at Israel. They were hoping for mass devastation of Israel and only the self defense capabilities of Israel changed that outcome. If you can be upset about the IDF landing their munitions on targets that they have identified as military forces then a statement against Hamas blind firing rockets in Israel's direction is WORSE because they don't care about what they are trying to hit. They're not aiming these things they're launching them. Just because Hamas is overmatched doesn't mean that they have the right to blind fire their munitions with impunity.
It would be great to get an interview with the respected Norman Finkelstein.
This guy is crazy and hypocrite. I bet he would speak differently idf his niece were ar Nova festival.
Recognize the state of Palestine and get rid of some level of hypocrisy. It will secure and gurantee security for both Palestainian children and Israeli colonial children
You miss the point. Israel had Left wing governments and more centrist governments that negotiated a peace agreement with the Palestinians, but in the end not only did the Palestinians fail to accept an agreement, they launched an intifada against Israel, murdering more than 1000 civilians. This person claims it’s the occupation, but why do the Palestinians always back out when it’s time to sign? 1937, 1947, 1967, 2000 and 2008. Also, between 1948 and 1967 Jordan occupied the West Band and Jerusalem and Egypt occupied Gaza. Why didn’t they establish a country then? They had 20 years!
Spot on!
Why no one challenged him that gaza is left by Israel in 2005? Or why he compares the hamas as government who rejects Israel right to exist to "some Israeli don't support two state solution"? Or that last election in gaza was in 2006, 2009 in west Bank. Very strange.
Hamas won less than 50 percent of the election eighteen years ago . Half of the population of Gaza is under 18 . Another 20 percent were too young to vote in the only election.
Therefore 14 percent (or less) of the current population ever voted for Hamas. Many of that 14 percent had 18 years to find out what Hamas was really like. Those 18 years saw much more conflict in Gaza than ever before , including 38 years under Israeli occupation, 19 years under Egyptian occupation and over 30 years under British occupation.
Hamas cannot be considered as anything other than group who rule by terror, conduct terrorist attacks and in reality did nothing to stop many of the 14 percent to change their minds.
Hamas only emerged in the late 1980"s and was never a mass popular movement, only gaining relative popularity after Fatah (political wing of PLO) had declined in popularity from the 1980"s and failed to impress Gazan's even after they won local elections in 1993.
The problem is: since its origin, , Hamas doesn't accept other solution than a Islamic State "from the river to the sea". How to make an agreement with Hamas?
Israel has acceoted the two state solution according to UN Resoltion in 1947. The problem was: no arab country has accepted Israel. And now we are in this "lock-in" situation.
France likes to show that it's different to the English speaking powers
Bravo monsieur finaly a neutral opinion on french tv
Everyone plays the game to his/her best interest.
Bravo la France
I'm curious why no one denies that the West uses double standards or even hipocracy... but when there are anti-Semitics, they easily discuss this. but then again. about double standards, why don't they say "we don't do double standards".. This makes me believe that they are indeed double standards
Double standards are new norm…..reasoning and rational thinking are old fashioned and obsolete
😮interessant
Terror is an emotion, you can't wage war on emotions...its irrational.
Terrorist and international terrorism is a fear tactic designed to generate hate toward another group.
Very good !
"Considered": Transzendentalphilosophie (Darwinian and Marxian epistemological and ontological) versions of reason as Causa Sui?
God bless him, I really hope that people like him find more chance to show the reality. 😢
its like saying ukrainian army are terrorist, people have right to fight the occupiers,Palestine has the right to defend.
Very interesting.
They've made empathy a bad word, how can you truly defeat your enemies without empathy (empathy isn't sympathy).
😢
Maybe a NATO and EU handled Two state solution even have turkey secure bordwrs and government movements in that region
So we have only to debate the goals? Really? If the goal is just, any method is possible?
The frog is right.
I am trying to understand these called specialists....
Hamas...Israel...recognized organizations or states are not the matters. The problem is the actions, the criminalities, the ways of war that the people are using.
Cutting the heads of people without discrimination, bombing without thinking of children...ignorance of international rules...
This is whatwhat makes hamas or other organizations terrorists.
Israel is fighting for its survival. If it doesn't fight it will finish.
How hamas is using his freedom?
How israel will become if hamas is free for all of his activities?
France24 presents an important approach like Freedom Fighters vs Terrorists🌎🌎🌎🌎🌎War is a dirty business since 4:44 the Paleolithic times.
REDUCTIO AD ABSURDUM: Declaring an organisation as terrorist, and then calling it out for disobeying internationally accepted laws and rules.
What type of foolishness is this..if you plan and execute a large deadly assault of rape brutality and murder on innocent civilians you are a terrorist...smh. sad
Gaza and West Bank are Israel sovereign territory according to the international law uti possidetis juris
Very very strange....MSM everywhere r doing the same thing.
Something very fishy is going on
Viva France
We honour the honourfull
france has lost a lot of influence in africa and this is the opportunity to gain fame again. if it is serious, go ahead.
when Macron said stop killing brown people, that was an eye opener
HAARETZ said that ISRAEL built the BUNKER+TUNNEL under AL SHIFA HOSPITAL. (JAN.12th.2009 -HAARETZ)
October 7 Palestine Independence Day
France shall leave the clown show and stop being embarrassing
How do you say Bxxl Sxxt in French??
Try to live with people who don't believe in tolerating others !!!
Then you understand israeli politics better🙏🏽👍🙏🏽👍🙏🏽👍🙏🏽
This is about the Gaza gas resources I have a vid on it.