Abhishek ji, bro, you are not made for Arzoo ji-type channel (please, no offence) discussion. You are, of course, a professor by degree, but I bow my head because you are truly a Guru. What an intellectual, philosophical discussion. Pervaiz Sir is a great guy, and he should observe India and Indian philosophy as key to his ancestral land. Abhishek Ji is an apt assistance to him. I want this discussion again and again, no chest-thumping just intellectual philosophical discussion in a respectful way. I just loved it.
Great discussion, but it should be cleared by misha ji that India is a geographical Identity not religious. And Hindu word came from Himalayas.❤ Ribaha ji you are Great to make this discussion happened.👍👌
Abhishek is demolishing the self assigned conceit and hubris of a muslim intellectual Pervaiz, who was not prepared to debate on an honest and innocent and unbiased platform like Ribaha's. Kudos to Ribaha
Seedhi c baat hai agar Muslim secular bnega tab hi mai secular bnuga. Ek trfa wala daur khatam. Internet mai sab mil jata ki kis dhram ya mazabh ki kya soch hai. Ab bewkoof nhi bna skte.
Jai israel Jai israel Jai israel Jai israel Jai israel Jai israel Jai israel Jai israel Jai israel Jai israel Jai israel Jai israel Jai israel Jai israel Jai israel
Ribah, don't just stop after this; make it your weekly or monthly concept. Bring this duo again and again, this kind of discussion is the only way out between both the countries.
The word Hindu was given to the people living between Himalaya mountain and Indu mahasagar(Indian Ocean). It was a geographical identity like Africa. We call a Lion , Elephant in africa as African Lion, African Elephant irrespective of the various countries in Africa. Similarly people living in our geographical area were called Hindus.
Hoodbhoy Indian history started 6000 years before , not when mughal invaded Bharat. Not learning our history is disgraceful Only learning mughal history is disgraceful. Nothing wrong with safronization , it is always better than green tint.
Abhishek, You should have countered the African theory by this: India itself once was a part of Africa and later broke and merged with Asia so it was not invaded at that time. Indian civilisation started from India only.
Oppenheimer, Szilard , Glenn seaborg , Klaus Fuchs, Ernest Lawrence,Hans Bethe, were main scientists in Manhattan project , tell hoodbhoy , Einstein theory to making bomb was herculean task , but hey pakistani always find short cut.
We Hindus never do something wrong or right because it was told by Shiva, Ram Or krishna.... We do it right or wrong with our own consciousness based on the time and circumstances.
Hoodbhoy , Science is based on assumption and observation and with test we proved our theory and theory can be revised , NOTHING IS FACT FOREVER. Certain matters are UNDEFINED IN SCIENCE, where they have fitted observations and predicted new observations successfully. An undefined or an infinity means that the mathematical model fails and a new physics model/theory has to be found. Terminal velocity is not exist in vacuumed, p=0 As an oldest civilization of sanatan , We have some observations and based on certain theory we are working on our beliefs. Science can not reach the level of human desire and belief. You represent a religion not civilization , correct that ,is still in an infancy,
It is not what the media speaks. In India it is what the government decides. In India none of the major political parties have declared that they want to make India a Sanatan Rastra.
He says in beginning that he believes in science , As a student of science he should read on topics where he is not a subject matter expert, else he is attending friday mullah lectures. He is BLABBERING in public platform for last few years about HINDU / SANATAN DHARMA , He is with his half cracked knowledge mixing religion and DHARMA , RELIGION CONCEPT WAS NOT THEIR BEFORE ABRAHAMIC INVENTED RELIGION CONCEPT. THAT IS WHY WE DO NOT HAVE A BOOK , WE HAVE BROAD PRINCIPLES OF LIFE , THAT WE FOLLOW , OUR PRINCIPLES NOT WRITTEN AS A FACT , INFECT IT IS REINVENTED WITH EVER CHANGING WORKD , 1000 YEARS BEFORE WRITTEN BOOK FOLLOWER NOT GOING TO TEACH SCIENCE. FIRST YOU PROVED THAT THE BOOK YOU READ ARE NOT RELEVANT IN THIS DAY AND AGE.
If There were no humans in India before Africans came then how it will be an invasion rather they will become original inhabitants.... What are you talking about Hoodbhoy.
Ribha Aaj ek sahi aadmi ko leke aaya. We respect hoodbhoy sir. Raja Umar aur zain ul abdin and amara jaise dumb illogical Bina knowledge ke log ko leke aake propaganda karke chale jaate hi proofs ni dethe. Divik and Junaid and dr. Parvez jaise log ko knowledge wo kis cheez bataye tho knowledge and proofs ke saath bolthe hi we like and love this type of people. Wo bak bak karne logon ko chod ke Aisa log ko leke aao.
India was part of African continent, over million years ago it was separated and collided with Asia, Himalayan range was part of it , So yes , india was part of africa , Now teach hoodbhoy some geography lesson , His theories are bunkam. Guys has no knowledge og history , geography, ,i doubt he has any science fundamentals know how.
@@kaffir6763 Hehe mere Imaginary Chuwa jb bh tha ap bhi ha Islam ma jahlat tabh thi ab bhi ha, jese Hindism mai cast sysytem jesi jahlat tabh thi ab bhi ha ....
@WorldwithoutReligion-j1l bhai jaan hum hinduo ko kyo dekhey , hamrey Islam main khoon kharabey , katal k alawa kuch aur hai , aap hinduo k cast system ki baat kar rahey ho pehli baat to mujhey bolna hi nahi chaiye phir bhi kya Islam main unch nich nahi hai , agar nahi hai to main btau aur samjhu tum ko , Islam mainbjor jabardasti nahi hai etc .
@@kaffir6763 apka Islam ha humara nahi, doosra Being a Rationalist haar ghatiya cheez per tanqeed karna mera Insani fareeza ha .... jitna Ghatiya Islam christnity aur degaar mmazhab ha utna hi ya use ziyada ghatiya Hindisum bhi ha ... Cast system jesi jahlat kisi Dharam mai nahi
kattar majhab khatam hogaa...mangadhant kahaaniyon wale majhab ka anth ab kareeb hai...deeya bujhane se pahle fadfadaata hai,,ab inka tel (oil) khatam ho chuka hai...Parvez sir, with due respect I am saying...Bharat ne aur duniyaa ne iss kattar mazhab ke naalayak logon ko kai saalon se jhelaa hai...but now enouff is enough..Kattar majhab se duniyaa ko jaan chhudaani hi padegi
डार्विन के विचार का जवाब ये है अगर आप विज्ञान मानते हैं तो भारत भी आफ्रीका का ही पार्ट था जब खंड टुटने लगे इस लिए हमारा डि एन ए एक है। समय चाहिए तो खंड लुटने का समय खोज लिजिए
Prof Houdbhoy, it will be good to know which Indian laws, in your esteemed view, discriminate against minorities in India, which prompted to you to make that statement in the context of India's secularism. If anything, there are some special laws to 'protect' some of the social practices of the minorities, despite promulgation of a common civil code being one of the directive principles of the Indian Constitution.
Islam se hajar hajar Saal pehele hamara AURB Rusi Arab me rehke Mahadeb 🙏🏿 ko pujtethai . Yohi Rusi AURB ke namke anusar ARAB DES naam huahai aur hamara yohi Mahadeb Makeswar ko musalman pujtehain 💐🙏🏿🧡 . BHARAT ek Swayam sampurna RASTRA hai . Pervez sahab BHARAT ko dhundnekeliye BEED ko janapadega .🇮🇳🫡👋
It seems Prof. Hoodbhoy is not aware that Pakistan's constitution debars non Muslims from being the President or Prime Minister of Pakistan. How could he say that Pakistan's constitution gives Hindus the same rights as Muslims?
Prof Houdbhoy, you narrated your experience of being able to screen your film on Kashmir in JNU and being heckled in Mumbai as an indication of growing intolerance in India. As someone who joined JNU in 1970, I can tell you that the university's ecosystem even then was intolerant of even left wing professors (one of them a reputed historian in the history departrment) who were even mildly critical of the leftist ideology. You do not perhaps watch the Indian TV debates where the 'growing intolerance' is routinely, and most aggressively, countered by the panelists. You also mentioned about Manusmriti. I am sure you know that it was not a divine book and the current Indian laws are not based on its tenets. (By the way, the same book also says that "Gods are pleased where women are worshipped".) India has moved, as it should have; what is happening now is a tussle between conflicting ideologies, as against domination of just one world view earlier. I know these comments will not reach you, but if somehow you do get to read them, do not dismiss them as the rant of a 'Hindutavawadi", whcih I am not.
Very interesting debate ..while I agree with both on many points,i disagree on some too..I agree with the recognition of Hindu history and it should be respected by Muslims living here in India,they should be taught the truth,but I disagree on making India a Hindu Rashtra, I don't want what was done with Hindus in Pakistan,to be repeated on muslims in India,I know hindus are not as extreme as Muslim but I don't want to take a risk.
Pushyamitra Shunga, the Brahmin king killed the maximum Buddhist monks and spread the Brahmin Dharma over most part of India. During the rule of Ashoka, the Buddisam flourished but in the rule of Pushtamitra almost finished in India. Pushyamitra Shunga and Shankaracharya tried to finish the Buddhism ...🙏🙏🙏🙏💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💔💔💔💔💔
Parveez hoodboy can critisize Hinduism oe India but will not say anything against Muslim because he need to say in muslim country. Otherside hindus also criticised hinduism
India should be Hindu Rashtra and charge Muslims for staying in India.
Currently,they charging Bharat 😂😂😂due to blessings of Gan,, di Ji 😂😂
Still, muslims hate Gan ,, di ji😂😂
Ehsan faramosh,kaum😂😂
They must because they have already take their share of land in 1947 by voting for Pakistan. Now this land belongs to hindu, budh sikhs and jains
All the credit goes to Mohan for sowing seeds.
@@lafachampion 👍Mohan Gand ji is main culprit.
Still Rahul Vinci feels , Gandi Sir name will help him 😂😂
Hoodboy is an expert at Al-Taqqiyya…He just ran away……when he cannot distinguish between religion and dharma, what can expected of him ?
Abhishek ji, bro, you are not made for Arzoo ji-type channel (please, no offence) discussion. You are, of course, a professor by degree, but I bow my head because you are truly a Guru. What an intellectual, philosophical discussion.
Pervaiz Sir is a great guy, and he should observe India and Indian philosophy as key to his ancestral land. Abhishek Ji is an apt assistance to him.
I want this discussion again and again, no chest-thumping just intellectual philosophical discussion in a respectful way.
I just loved it.
Great discussion, but it should be cleared by misha ji that India is a geographical Identity not religious. And Hindu word came from Himalayas.❤ Ribaha ji you are Great to make this discussion happened.👍👌
Abhishek is demolishing the self assigned conceit and hubris of a muslim intellectual Pervaiz, who was not prepared to debate on an honest and innocent and unbiased platform like Ribaha's. Kudos to Ribaha
Salute to Abhishek ji
Seedhi c baat hai agar Muslim secular bnega tab hi mai secular bnuga. Ek trfa wala daur khatam. Internet mai sab mil jata ki kis dhram ya mazabh ki kya soch hai. Ab bewkoof nhi bna skte.
I do not think Pervaiz will ever face Abhishek again.
Dr hoodbhoi has read only half the philosophy
Clean shave hai per pet me small dari hai
Jai israel Jai israel Jai israel Jai israel Jai israel Jai israel Jai israel Jai israel Jai israel Jai israel Jai israel Jai israel Jai israel Jai israel Jai israel
Old wine in New bottle .
Mishra ji
Science start with observation
But
This is hoodbhoy
He start with theory
U r smart
Ribah, don't just stop after this; make it your weekly or monthly concept.
Bring this duo again and again, this kind of discussion is the only way out between both the countries.
Hoodbhoy Aaj ghar ja ke gayetri mantra ka jaap karega 😂😂😂😂
thank you Abhishek bhai for opening my eyes mujhe lagta tha yeh banda scholer hai. 😲😲😲
The word Hindu was given to the people living between Himalaya mountain and Indu mahasagar(Indian Ocean). It was a geographical identity like Africa. We call a Lion , Elephant in africa as African Lion, African Elephant irrespective of the various countries in Africa. Similarly people living in our geographical area were called Hindus.
Hoodboy is pakistani having pakistani mindset
So he is putting Jilebiya and Jilebiya
Not speaking on radical Islamic ideology
Hoodboy is indeed a Razakar at core
Never thought about Prof. Hoodbhoy being soooooo "NAIVE"? Sorry sir, but it's a FACT? THANKS 🇮🇳 JAI HIND 🇮🇳 AND JAI BHARAT 🇮🇳.
Hoodbhoy
Indian history started 6000 years before , not when mughal invaded Bharat.
Not learning our history is disgraceful
Only learning mughal history is disgraceful.
Nothing wrong with safronization , it is always better than green tint.
Indian history is much before 10000 years
Bring Jaipur dialogues sanjay dixit sir and this Pakistani in debate
Allah ne dono haathon se Adam ko banaya😂😂😂
Pervaiz Hoodbhoy, has turned radical after his retirement, maybe his software has been updated by____. My earlier respect for him is depleted.
Bahut badhiya debate 👌👌
Both are super knowledgeable person.. respect 🙏🏼
117 crore Hindus
125 crore Sanatanis including Sikhs, Jains and Buddhists
India will soon be a Hindu nation
Don't worry
Liar! Professor?
Truth is realised, where matter is transcended. Thoughts are matter, science will agree sometime. Thoughtless awareness is awakening to Truth.
Hodbhoy andar se Muslim hai
Pakistanis are real hindu due to Sindhu river.
Ribaha's smile says it all, bless you beti
Wonderful program. Abhishek, I’m proud of you.
Abhishek, sir, why are you so apologetic in your intro , very surprising 😮
Abhishek, You should have countered the African theory by this: India itself once was a part of Africa and later broke and merged with Asia so it was not invaded at that time. Indian civilisation started from India only.
Oppenheimer, Szilard , Glenn seaborg , Klaus Fuchs, Ernest Lawrence,Hans Bethe, were main scientists in Manhattan project ,
tell hoodbhoy , Einstein theory to making bomb was herculean task , but hey pakistani always find short cut.
We Hindus never do something wrong or right because it was told by Shiva, Ram Or krishna.... We do it right or wrong with our own consciousness based on the time and circumstances.
sanatani lakho sal se he aur ye banda africa se jodta he .
Hoodbhoy , Science is based on assumption and observation and with test we proved our theory and theory can be revised , NOTHING IS FACT FOREVER.
Certain matters are UNDEFINED IN SCIENCE, where they have fitted observations and predicted new observations successfully. An undefined or an infinity means that the mathematical model fails and a new physics model/theory has to be found.
Terminal velocity is not exist in vacuumed, p=0
As an oldest civilization of sanatan , We have some observations and based on certain theory we are working on our beliefs. Science can not reach the level of human desire and belief.
You represent a religion not civilization , correct that ,is still in an infancy,
people who might have invaded india but they did not convert people.
It is not what the media speaks. In India it is what the government decides. In India none of the major political parties have declared that they want to make India a Sanatan Rastra.
He says in beginning that he believes in science , As a student of science he should read on topics where he is not a subject matter expert, else he is attending friday mullah lectures. He is BLABBERING in public platform for last few years about HINDU / SANATAN DHARMA , He is with his half cracked knowledge mixing religion and DHARMA , RELIGION CONCEPT WAS NOT THEIR BEFORE ABRAHAMIC INVENTED RELIGION CONCEPT.
THAT IS WHY WE DO NOT HAVE A BOOK , WE HAVE BROAD PRINCIPLES OF LIFE , THAT WE FOLLOW , OUR PRINCIPLES NOT WRITTEN AS A FACT , INFECT IT IS REINVENTED WITH EVER CHANGING WORKD , 1000 YEARS BEFORE WRITTEN BOOK FOLLOWER NOT GOING TO TEACH SCIENCE.
FIRST YOU PROVED THAT THE BOOK YOU READ ARE NOT RELEVANT IN THIS DAY AND AGE.
Great Salute to Abhishek Sir nobody can compare with Abhishek Sir in each and every angle so proud of 🙏❤️
If There were no humans in India before Africans came then how it will be an invasion rather they will become original inhabitants.... What are you talking about Hoodbhoy.
Ribha Aaj ek sahi aadmi ko leke aaya.
We respect hoodbhoy sir.
Raja Umar aur zain ul abdin and amara jaise dumb illogical Bina knowledge ke log ko leke aake propaganda karke chale jaate hi proofs ni dethe.
Divik and Junaid and dr. Parvez jaise log ko knowledge wo kis cheez bataye tho knowledge and proofs ke saath bolthe hi we like and love this type of people.
Wo bak bak karne logon ko chod ke Aisa log ko leke aao.
Dharam is science
AKHAND SANATAN
VHAARATA 🌄 VERSHA
WITHOUT
FOLLOWERS OF ARABIC
ALTAKAYA 💀 SATAN.
Question was on malala and Abdul ,
Answer was on safronization in India
Dhul chahere pe thi , aaina saff karta raha
India was part of African continent, over million years ago it was separated and collided with Asia, Himalayan range was part of it ,
So yes , india was part of africa ,
Now teach hoodbhoy some geography lesson ,
His theories are bunkam. Guys has no knowledge og history , geography, ,i doubt he has any science fundamentals know how.
Jab say Islam aur Muslman is keynat main aaya tab sey Insan , Insaniyet aur Animals k liye khatra
Han warna usey pehle ... toh Brahman mazey mai aur Dalit Gutter mai 🙃
@@WorldwithoutReligion-j1l brahman tab bhi tha aur aaj bhi hai aur dalit kuch nahi hotta , , Islam ka pehla jihadi Mohamad tha aur hai
@@kaffir6763 Hehe mere Imaginary Chuwa jb bh tha ap bhi ha Islam ma jahlat tabh thi ab bhi ha, jese Hindism mai cast sysytem jesi jahlat tabh thi ab bhi ha ....
@WorldwithoutReligion-j1l bhai jaan hum hinduo ko kyo dekhey , hamrey Islam main khoon kharabey , katal k alawa kuch aur hai , aap hinduo k cast system ki baat kar rahey ho pehli baat to mujhey bolna hi nahi chaiye phir bhi kya Islam main unch nich nahi hai , agar nahi hai to main btau aur samjhu tum ko , Islam mainbjor jabardasti nahi hai etc .
@@kaffir6763 apka Islam ha humara nahi, doosra Being a Rationalist haar ghatiya cheez per tanqeed karna mera Insani fareeza ha .... jitna Ghatiya Islam christnity aur degaar mmazhab ha utna hi ya use ziyada ghatiya Hindisum bhi ha ... Cast system jesi jahlat kisi Dharam mai nahi
Abhishek doesn't come with preparation. He leaves everything incomplete. Kindly complete the quote n well explain the meaning.
kattar majhab khatam hogaa...mangadhant kahaaniyon wale majhab ka anth ab kareeb hai...deeya bujhane se pahle fadfadaata hai,,ab inka tel (oil) khatam ho chuka hai...Parvez sir, with due respect I am saying...Bharat ne aur duniyaa ne iss kattar mazhab ke naalayak logon ko kai saalon se jhelaa hai...but now enouff is enough..Kattar majhab se duniyaa ko jaan chhudaani hi padegi
Sharma sir yah ek bebkoof hai use sirf aapna sahi dikhana hai
डार्विन के विचार का जवाब ये है अगर आप विज्ञान मानते हैं तो भारत भी आफ्रीका का ही पार्ट था जब खंड टुटने लगे इस लिए हमारा डि एन ए एक है। समय चाहिए तो खंड लुटने का समय खोज लिजिए
Abhishek ji salute 🫡 ❤
Sir musalmano ki problem Islamic ideology hai yo galat ko galat nahi bol sakte hai aaj ke time me Islamic ideology insaniyat khilaf hai
Special knowledge is science . bishesh gyan.
Abhishek sir ne last me hath jode lakin wo bande ne tata kiya ????
Very poorly read Pervezji about our history. It is natural. But then he should limit himself to his Islam only😊
Well done Rianna ji best episode
Dr. Abhishek Sir only in one for me who can defend Mulla moulobi by logical thinking ❤❤❤
Prof Houdbhoy, it will be good to know which Indian laws, in your esteemed view, discriminate against minorities in India, which prompted to you to make that statement in the context of India's secularism. If anything, there are some special laws to 'protect' some of the social practices of the minorities, despite promulgation of a common civil code being one of the directive principles of the Indian Constitution.
Islam se hajar hajar Saal pehele hamara AURB Rusi Arab me rehke Mahadeb 🙏🏿 ko pujtethai . Yohi Rusi AURB ke namke anusar ARAB DES naam huahai aur hamara yohi Mahadeb Makeswar ko musalman pujtehain 💐🙏🏿🧡 . BHARAT ek Swayam sampurna RASTRA hai . Pervez sahab BHARAT ko dhundnekeliye BEED ko janapadega .🇮🇳🫡👋
Ribha ji aaj ka episode best episode from India 🇮🇳
It seems Prof. Hoodbhoy is not aware that Pakistan's constitution debars non Muslims from being the President or Prime Minister of Pakistan. How could he say that Pakistan's constitution gives Hindus the same rights as Muslims?
I am not fully agree with Abhishek
Bravo! Encore!
Prof Houdbhoy, you narrated your experience of being able to screen your film on Kashmir in JNU and being heckled in Mumbai as an indication of growing intolerance in India. As someone who joined JNU in 1970, I can tell you that the university's ecosystem even then was intolerant of even left wing professors (one of them a reputed historian in the history departrment) who were even mildly critical of the leftist ideology. You do not perhaps watch the Indian TV debates where the 'growing intolerance' is routinely, and most aggressively, countered by the panelists. You also mentioned about Manusmriti. I am sure you know that it was not a divine book and the current Indian laws are not based on its tenets. (By the way, the same book also says that "Gods are pleased where women are worshipped".) India has moved, as it should have; what is happening now is a tussle between conflicting ideologies, as against domination of just one world view earlier. I know these comments will not reach you, but if somehow you do get to read them, do not dismiss them as the rant of a 'Hindutavawadi", whcih I am not.
Parvej, ribah do no ke sar ke upar se gaya 😂😂😂
Inko sirf allah ho akbar
samjame aata hain 😂😂
Ribaha India India karne se achha 😂😢 Apne mulk ke haalat pe dhyan do😂😮 Bahot jaldi 4 tukde me batne wala hai 😂😢😅
aaj mujhe ye pata laga hoody ka gyan.
Aum , AMEN , Ameen are same except in pronounciation.
Abhishek aap ek comunist mind vale ko nhi samjha sakte 😢😢
Very interesting debate ..while I agree with both on many points,i disagree on some too..I agree with the recognition of Hindu history and it should be respected by Muslims living here in India,they should be taught the truth,but I disagree on making India a Hindu Rashtra, I don't want what was done with Hindus in Pakistan,to be repeated on muslims in India,I know hindus are not as extreme as Muslim but I don't want to take a risk.
Ribaha yeh best episode tha .
Verry good discussion I like ❤
Pushyamitra Shunga, the Brahmin king killed the maximum Buddhist monks and spread the Brahmin Dharma over most part of India. During the rule of Ashoka, the Buddisam flourished but in the rule of Pushtamitra almost finished in India. Pushyamitra Shunga and Shankaracharya tried to finish the Buddhism ...🙏🙏🙏🙏💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💔💔💔💔💔
Professor Hudbhoy ko aaj naani yaad dila diya Abhishek ji ne.......
India need to learn from Thailand and make India a Sanatan Dharma State ASAP
Ribaha keep it up.
dr misra it good you asked some searching and probing questions.
Very good debdt sir phir se ek bar lambi debdt kro
Good debate
Ye puruna video, Hoodbhoy ke samne ye bandaa big Zero
Good discussion
Abhishek mishra r9cks
Jhakas Dr Abhishek I was looking at Rhibha and she like oh oh facial reaction two elder debating and younger ok ok no 😅😅😅
Systimitic knowledge of anything that's mean science
Parveez hoodboy can critisize Hinduism oe India but will not say anything against Muslim because he need to say in muslim country.
Otherside hindus also criticised hinduism
Abhishek ji dil khush ho gaya...zara wo bhi suna dete jumbo deepe bharat khande wala shloka jo lakho saal purana hai...
Super cute 👌👌👌👌👌👌👌
Beta Rigveda me hai Hindu word.
❤
is this old video ?
YP ur right
Parvej ko tution lena padhe ga ab😂😂😂
Mano Mat, Jano. Osho
Ribaha ji I ❤ you so much 😍
Most vibrant???? 😑
Dr Abhishek had clesrly outshined Dr Parvez . Dr Parvez seems to be poor listner and has deep rooted self beliefs
Old video again uploaded
👍👍👍👍👌👌👌👌❤❤❤❤😍😍😍😍🥰🥰🥰