Spying on the citizens of individualistic ideas....same bastards you feds are....by the way you will never catch any Russian Spies....they are everywhere....check your department
As a cybersecurity nerd I've always found kinda sad that a lot of IoT devices seem actually useful or interesting but they're (intentionally or not) a hotspot for spyware and security vulnerabilities
Convenience usually means easier for the consumer. (Ex. Less Steps Needed) The inconvenience goes to the the company”s product. Therefore the steps that were taken out for the consumer are now in the hands of the company’s own agendas
Damn a pip boy would be really sick hahaha. Idk if it would be as practical to wear on an everyday basis but surely what it did do it would have the potential to do much better
Yeah, I remember about 10 years ago being so excited for the future when all this smart tech was being introduced. But then I learned just privacy invading and dystopian it all is, and I began to view it as if it’s literal poison. Still though, at least in recent years I’ve discovered all the open source projects that people have made, and it’s given me hope that I can have all the tech without the loss of privacy. But if a cool piece of tech has been invented, but it’s not open source yet, then I don’t even view as being fully invented yet tbh.
its insane how quickly and silently we went from "free, but you pay with your data" to "not free, but you also pay with your data" The shadiness of spyware aside, at least originally you got something out of it, or you'd pay for something but keep your privacy. Now it just exists by default, you pay for the product twice.
I love how that ECG app has to ask for your birthdate just to even know if you're "allowed" to use the app. There is exactly one reason for this: if you're a child, it's illegal for them to harvest your data. With this prompt they're openly admitting that they do not give a fuck about your privacy.
it's actually not an option, they HAVE to ask you that, because they store it on THEIR servers, so THEY would get into trouble if they collected a child's data unwittingly, even if they're a perfectly good company that does nothing shady but also that's what you read the TOS and such stuff for, what do they say they can do with your data, like if they don't "share your personal information with select partners" or such, then it might be reasonably fine
@@jan_harald A perfectly good company that does nothing shady doesn't have to store that data on its servers. You can (and should be legally forced to) keep that kind of sensitive data local unless EXPLICITLY requested otherwise.
On the Apple Watch there is a like “system” DOB for core functionality that doesn’t get shared with the apps. Each individual app (EKG, blood oxygen, VO2 max exe) asks separately for your DOB (sometimes only for the year), and each individual app has a different age limit (IIRC EKG is 22+, but VO2 max? is 20+). You can give each app a contradictory DOB and it won’t care, so long as the DOB provided for each app is before the cutoff date in that app only. I know I have lied to one of the apps before and there is zero pushback, and you can just renter a new DOB if it says you are too young. Clearly it’s just covering their legal liability with the AF stuff, there is no reason for them to collect this specific DOB when you already have an iPhone and an Apple Watch and thus have agreed to 3? licence agreements (iTunes/Apple ID, iOS and WatchOS), and have probably provided a more specific date of birth in other places. Also you can opt out of having this stuff stored on the cloud by turning off iCloud sync for health in settings, and this data is (according to Apple) stored with end to end encryption. I’m actually pretty sure this specific DOB is completely local as moving to a new watch you need to explicitly opt back in to ECG and renter your DOB here. I agree it’s not ideal but it’s pretty standard for Apple, which is basically just barely better than Google and sketchy android but not as good as full libre stuff.
The gadgetbridge project allows you to connect a smartwatch without going through its native spyware setup. Most of the native features that you would have had with the app from whatever vender the watch was from work. There are also a lot of forks for in development dsvices, I think you could probably find most of the major company's watcher there. Documentation is pretty good for if you feel the need to add a device for yourself. Its also on fdroid, so that's always a plus.
@@dani1999n You need to know that some Smartwatches which are supported by gadgetbride need to obtain a token for communication. Some of them rely on extracting the token from the proprietary App such as for Xiaomi Mi Band's from Version 3 upwards. That means, you have to make an account, log into it with internet access, pair the watch, use Termux (if Root is available) and extract the token from the Apps's data. You can find more info on their wiki under Huami devices or something. Take care on what type of watch you'd get to avoid this task.
Thank you for your knowledge! I have a watch for 1 year (that was a gift) that I don't use because spyware app. Thanks to you and gadgetbridge (couldn't find it before without the name), I now have a working smartwatch that keeps my health datas for myself. as @timlpde said, it was a bit of pain to pair with the auth key needed, but after a few hours of pain I'm now happy.
I believe the best option (especially if you like your SmartWatch to be a fitness tracker) is garmin. - excellent sensors for tracking (i use it for swimming and it tracks the distance + stroke rate and a ton of other metrics. but it is very good for all kind of sports) - You can set up the device without a phone or bluetooth. it never needs to connect to anything. Bluetooth can be deactivated. all data is only stored offline on your watch. - if you connect it via the usb cable, you can access all the data on your pc as it shows up as a generic mass storage. Garmin has data formats that are documented so you could back up and store all your data offline on your pc and write your own data processing (so you get a "foss garmin connect" (maybe something like that already exists)) as far as i know there is a open source sdk for garmin too
I'm highly considering getting a Garmin ngl. just still not sure if I should go with the Forerunner series or the fenix one (if you have any reviews about them go on, I don't care about spending lots of money on a product if it's high quality)
@@vicstoron Got a forerunner 35. I'm not sure about the newer models but it isn't exactly a "smart watch", it's a sport watch. You don't have to worry about proprietary spyware when there are no apps on it. You get all the benefits of tracking your training/fitness without all the bullshit that comes with "modern smart watches".
Quickly becoming one of my favorite tech youtubers. Not only does your content interest me, and fit my needs, but it is also very informative and entertaining! Another video upload I've enjoyed. Thanks Outlaw, looking forward to more videos.
@@kingdededelicious operation security It's said in the military that there's like 5 operations you always have to do to survive, and the most known and in common use outside the battlefield its that, opsec
Best feature for smart watches is yet to come. It's nearly there. It's already there on some lesser-known Chinese watches. It's glucometer. My diabetic friend has bought one, tested it for weeks with both the watch and classic needled glucometer. It was shockingly accurate. No idea how it works without a needle, that's some black magic level of science. But holy hell it works. When this gets needed certificates and arrives onto more popular mainstream brands - these watches will actually start saving lives. Because for diabetics a device that passively monitors blood sugar level and notifies when it gets out of safe levels is literally a life-saver.
Right now, I'm wearing a Garmin Tactix 7. I like that it has the Stealth Mode option which (at least, if it functions as advertised) disables all wireless connectivity for a bit of added privacy. Mostly, I just use it to see what time it is, but having offline maps stored locally on the device is really what sold me on it. I've never paired it to my phone and don't intend to. That being said, if someone ever made a rugged, open source pipboy that had a similar set of features, I'd ditch my $1300 smart watch and get that in a heartbeat.
I've been using the Tactix Delta for over a year now and I feel the same. Garmin makes the best smart watches right now but I wish they weren't so expensive and that the OS was open source. And you know, for all the advancement in the last 10ish years, I'd still love to just have my old Pebble 2. Pebble were just a few years ahead of their time.
… you bought a $1,300 smart watch to keep it offline, not pair it with your phone, and store some offline map data on it? That’s gotta be the dumbest shit I’ve ever heard bro 😂😂😂
On the pipboy idea, no need for a new device, phones are already 90% there. I'm imagining something like a wrist phone hub that has extra sensors and charges your phone with it's own battery, with some slight UI changes to make it easier to use the phone in landscape mode. Might be a reason for smaller smartphones to make a comeback.
Pretty disturbing that there was spyware to begin with. Nothing out of the ordinary, though; just another day in this fucked-up world! :D Ah, yes, data collection, so amazing.
In case you don't know about it there's an amazing video by a guy who worked for IBM developing a pioneering Linux smartwatch back in the day. Although it didn't take off, a lot of the developments were used in later smartwatches.
IoT is actually a cool hobby if you are into tech. With something like Home Assistant on an Rasperry Pie you can do pretty cool stuff, and if you know React you can Build your own Dashboards. Paired with Shelly or similar devices you can make your home smart and be the only one with access to your data. You can even integrate your Smart Watch and write a script that emails you a personal health report every month.
gatekeeping features on the device you payed for with DRM is already a thing. Some of the sensors are just broken without a subscription to fitbit. Others may be censored by region, like Samsung features turning off outside of South Korea.
Kitbashing together some form of Pipboy from available materials sounds fun. I was thinking of getting one of those cheap arm-band phone holders from the dollar store, plopping in a cheap smartphone I'd been using as a e-reader (got it during a Black Friday sale for like $3) and wearing it on my forearm just to get an idea how comfortable or uncomfortable that would be as well as if it would work better with the phone placed under my forearm or on top like most watches would be situated. Then going from there and experimenting to see what features I'd like to try. Hmm, I wonder if anyone's tried building a smartwatch using an ESP32 module......
There are people still using their pebble smartwatches. There was a sleep tracking app available back when I used my Pebble Time. Unfortunately the only heart-rate enabled pebble watch had rubber side buttons that deteriorate and fall apart eventually.
Yeah, I had the first model of the Pebble. Loved it so much, I convinced a friend to get one even though it was already the age of Rebble. Only reason I didn't use Morpheuz more was because I never got used to wearing a watch to bed. I wish we saw more watches like it that focused on battery life and always-on displays.
I still use my pebble, got it in middle school. But I've always been mad that I cheaped out and didn't get the time steel. They were cheap asf brand new when I was buying, but I'm cheap asf too
Step tracking is spot on but the heart rate monitor wasn't all that accurate to begin with, they would have needed a few iterations possibly. Shame they fell through.
@@Camoceltic Sleep as Android is pretty stellar, but yeah, you have to be used to wearing it to bed. I got used to taking it off for 1 hour per week which is pretty awesome.
I got a Huawei Watch and flashed Astroid on it. The process was actually pretty simple and has the advantage that I don't have to install crappy spyware from Huawei. I'm pretty happy the watch is fantastic for what I want from it. So mainly sports and as mp3 player when I run. For people who also do sports and do not want to be distracted or better want to track their progress I can only recommend it.
You can find the instructions on the website. It's really not a complicated process. Even I got it done, and I'm not the most technically savvy person by far. It basically just amounts to enabling developer options, changing a setting and running a few commands through your terminal. You can even keep Asteroid parallel to the original os if you want.
I was just thinking bout this the other day when once of the people from my gym asked if I would get an Apple Watch (I wouldn’t, but I can’t deny the fitness and text capabilities are appealing) . Thanks for satisfying my curiosity a bit.
For me, its the G-SHOCK GBD200-1. Classic square g-shock with some basic fitness tracking that displays right on the watch. Sure, you can connect it to an app on your phone, but you don't have to.
For me it's the GW-M5610U, the fact that it perfectly syncs the time with a radio signal is "smart" enough for me. It tells me the time, it has a few time alerts available, it has a stopwatch, it has a timer, it has world time, it's solar powered, it's shock resistant and water resistant, what more do you want from your watch?
@@kalgonzo148 The only model that can rival it is the GW-9400 with the sensor. However 1) it's way more expensive and 2) it's way more bulkier. The GW-M5610U is probably the cheapest daily driver that just runs itself.
I've been looking into buying a Pinetime recently and I remember reading that Sleep for Android supports the Pinetime, and is a great sleep tracking app. I have yet to try it but I sure am excited to
Some time ago, I had the opportunity to try a Xiaomi MI band. I liked the experience, I realized how good it is for checking the time without taking out my phone. It convinced me to think about buying a $20 Casio in the future.
I bought both a sealed and an unsealed PineTime last year, and the TLDR is that the software Pine put on (infinitime) pretty much sucks, although it is getting better every few months. There is a lot more development happening however on other OSs for the PineTime, like Wasp-os and the OS from the Zephr watch also runs on PineTime. Personally, given Pine64's pretty good reputation in the opensource / openhardware space, which is a space where many companies just take your cash and run let alone keep supporting software for real products, I think the PineTime is the perfect watch for the privacy-concious to rally around. These watch OS' are small and easy to reason about, and they can even run a python REPL.
You mentioned a lot of the valuable parts of a smartwatch, but something that doesn't get acknowledged enough is how much more convenient notifications and speaker calls on the watch are. Being able to set up timers easily, use them to control my phone's camera, change music while working out, and have a full calculator, my calendar, and the forecast, I use my watch for basically everything I can do on my phone but reading or watching videos. I'm pretty excited about the resurgence of e-ink and the possibility I could use a cheap phone for reading and emails and have my watch for everything else (yes, I cant watch videos on e-ink, but I don't watch stuff outside the house anyways.)
Is it, though? Seems like doing all that stuff is a nightmare on a watch. Even phones can barely do it well, I don't see how they can get watches right. Take calendar for example. You can see, what? Today's events? No option for a 30 day view that's useful? A terrible user interface that takes forever, and you may as well use a phone or computer? I just don't see the use of the interface. I think good AR will be far better.
@@O1OO1O1 Before you read: I am talking about my experience with stock Samsung watch and phone if you have no interest save yourself some time. Most people use calendar to check current day events, you can create new ones with voice commands, but the 30 day view doesn't show your future appointments. Yet it is good enough to keep track of your day and you may do your planning and checking of future appointments once or twice a day in the computer and focus on the day with the smartwatch. Answering or denying calls is a breeze, just a quick swipe or even a gesture using the accelerometer and I'm talking. Speak to text is quite decent for longer answers, there are preprogrammed quick replies and the qwerty keyboard with swipe typing is good enough for the edge cases.
I agree. Aside from normal watch functions, I use my gear s2 primarily for calendar, weather, and email reading purposes. It's great for when I'm walking somewhere and want a quick, small dashboard of what I have going on.
For many of my activities even a phone is bare bones. But yeah, everyone has different need and wants. Yet there still are open software solutions that grant you your features without the privacy concerns
I've wanted to put together my own pip-boy with a raspi, still working on figuring out how to aquire the internal hardware to work on it. I do have an idea on how to make the buttons and dials work though, since QMK is pretty customizable.
I have a garmin instint and tbh I can't see why it would ever be e-waste. Unlikely to break and the features it has now will be just as good in 20 years. Only the more phone like smartwatches become ewaste.
I agree with the last pip-boy comment. I've had for the last couple of years a mighty need to make my own smart watch, kinda like the ZSWatch. After some months tho, I thought that I'd be better to just go full-on cyberpunk and make a bigger wearable. Maybe something that could fit the entire foremarm, put a keyboard, a linux distro, make it like a tiny pc, maybe something crazier. It'd be fun and I'd get a cool device (and some bragging rights) in the end.
The only good smart watch I've ever owned was a Pebble, nothing else has really gotten the point of the smart watch aside from pebble. My checklist: Needs a battery that lasts a minimum of a week, needs an always on display as a gesture to turn on the display prevents easy casual time/stat tracking, needs an app store thats open to third party developers, finally fitness tracking is nice but it should be secondary to checking and responding to notifications, and features relating to time keeping and schedule management. I don't mind the watch being reliant on a phone, it's just gotta have features that reduce the need to pull out my phone
A couple things I've seen current smartwatches are alike to the pebble are in price and battery life. What matters to me is that it lacks a touch screen. No real replacement for the Pebble yet, how long has it been again? A decade?!
I was given a used Apple Watch recently and I like it well enough. I’m not really convinced of the need for these things, but they are cool. I would love to try out the PineTime though.
I built my own device but mostly cause I cannot wear a normal watch while wearing an orthotic device. So I embedded the sensor in orthotic for SpO² and pulse and have magnets and pogopins to clip on the watch I made. So it's an add on for my orthotics. I have SpO² sensors on forhead and legs to calculate orthostatic differences. Not something watches can do and I needed the extra feedback.
As someone who really wants the health tracking features, I think I hate the lack of good smart watches with a burning passion moreso than any other consumer electronic device.
I use the open-source app Gadgetbridge with a Fossil Hybrid watch. It's a good compromise (some smart features, notifications, HR tracking, etc - but all data stays on my device, I don't have the closed-source manufacturer app installed, and the watch has no connectivity apart from bluetooth to my phone). It also works with Mi Fit / AmazFit bands, etc.
I have a garmin watch because they allow you to access their api. I have a app I wrote that has a web hook and it receives all my data instantly after I complete a workout. Apple wants you to be a large company to access the HealthKit api
While it probably isn't the most secure strictly speaking, I use Garmin devices. Particularly those in their fitness tracker category rather than anything labelled as a "smart watch", all the fitness tracking, but limited options for connectivity with various phone apps to the fitness tracker. Phone Notifications is about as much as you can hope for and honestly that is more than I need.
I got a Fitbit after years of refusing to get a 24/7 tracker. It helped me fix my sleep and stuff but now I am pretty sure there is a digital me being sold by Fitbit somewhere
according to teclore you can use Garmin watches and download your data offline to a computer. Therefore, you don’t even have to use the Garmin services that track you
I've been using a Pinetime for almost two years. It ain't bad. The stock wristband isn't something you'd want to wear while sleeping, but it's standardized and easy to swap it out for something more comfortable. I'd say about 95% of my usage of it is just to play 2048 at the bus stop without running down my phone's battery.
My favorite brand of sport watches are Suunto which directly compete with garmin but dont have unecessary things like wifi and just handles the sport things greatly, though they are pretty expensive since they are hand assembled in Finland, but overall much more secure than the orher brands.
The ZSWatch looks pretty nice! 4 buttons, round display, I'm curious what the upcoming version will look like! Sadly it looks like it doesn't have a transflective MIP LCD but needs backlight to be visible. I used to wear a Pebble until a year ago, and I don't want to miss full button operation, always-on sunlight-visible screen and several days of battery life. I can live without health/activity tracking, touch screen and things like phone calls on the watch. So last year I replaced my Pebble Steel with a Garmin fenix 6S Pro which comes pretty close. But now I miss the Pebble's open ecosystem, and somehow also its geekiness...
I like my Casio, has a BT App to set the time ( used it practically once for that, with internet to the app disabled, because apparently you could do geolocation with BT ), but otherwise dump as eff... Sometimes, just sometimes, life needs to be a bit easier.
An always on display is important for it to function as a watch IMO, I wonder if one will pop up in a nice case, waterproof and heart monitoring with an eink display.
I use a Ticwatch Pro with Kali Nethunter. Since it’s an older model (but top end), it’s easier to root and has developer support and is actually not that much more expensive than the Pine Time while being a lot more premium and feature packed.
I got the fossil hr hybrid watch I feel it's a compelling product. Battery last for about a month it is a traditional watch with hands but the face is eink and has productivity functions of a smart watch.
Actually you can disable most of the proprietary bloatware if not all, just by using adb commands. You can connect adb wifi and give some commands from your computer, for disabling stuff. Also, you can disable most manufacturer apps just by going into the settings, app info, and tapping disable. Problem is that those apps are often needed to get good tracking
I still wear an iPod Nano 6 from 2010 with a watch band attached to it. Its definitely outdated and only connects to a PC/mac over a wired connection, but lack of wireless connectivity other than fm radio, microphone or anything of that sort makes it pretty much impossible to use as a tracking device, and it still looks like a smartwatch despite technically not being one.
I used to use my Mi Band 3 with Gadgetbridge (on F-Droid). For these devices I'm mostly interested on the fitness related features. So full on smartwatches are not on my alley, that's the reason I prefer smart bands instead. The problem with that I had with Gadgetbridge is regular loss of connection with the device and that the UI is horrendous. looking at the heart rate graph makes my eyes bleed, the same for the sleep dashboards.
if youre looking for a pipboy style watch, garmin has something very similar. they have some pretty cool stuff as far as wearables go i just havent done enough research on them or been able to audit one myself to see whats all going on under the hood.
afaik you don't need to connect it bluetooth to your phone app or anything and you can just transfer the files of your training to a computer and open them with another app etc so issues with spyware don't seem to really exist on it if you just wanna use it for basic stuff like monitoring training/sleeping
This is part of the reason I stopped using a smartwatch after the Pebble died. The main reason is that I checked my phone way too much during the day. I didn’t need a constant buzz on my wrist and yet another way for people to reach me.
Mainstream watch with custom ROM would probably be my choice, though I am not in the market for a smartwatch right now. When I got my phone, I bought a used one that was already flashed with LineageOS, it was only like €20 over market price, so certainly worth it.
Probably gonna go tic watch in the future however I absolutely love the idea of open source watches. Hell, I could come up with plenty of uses for a pipboy
great video. I absolutley LOVE smart watches and I really cannot live without them... one thing that is stopping me from using say Graphene OS (well buying a pixel phone) is cus I just love my galaxy watch 4 too much... maybe pay the conseqeunces for it who knows.... the pine time is a step in the right direction... Asteriod OS is pretty interesting and I don't think it is too much hasel to load onto one of the fossil family of watches but it lacks so many features INCLUDING BLUETOOTH in some cases; whilst bluetooth is pretty insecure, no notifcation relay is just not a useable smart watch... hhhh.
⌚ I like it. Great little smartwatch, heartrate monitor works well, use it all the time without fail (over year with it). Only issue I've had is needing to get around to fixing stepcounter. At the price you can't beat it. Always exciting seeing new features in firmware upgrade. 🙂 Fun FOSS option.
As some have already said, i think the best choice to make here is to use a non-LTE watch with the GadgetBridge app, ensuring all your data stay on your phone.
Just had to double check to see if the phones were being sold to the public and it seems like they're moving forward with that. Are there any plans to make any videos on one in the future?
My watch has 3 little hands, that spin around in circles, over and over and over. I look down at it, and suddenly I know the time. This is as technology advanced as I want my watch.
been using a huawei watch (2015) w/ asteroid OS (as shown from abt 5:22, not actually a custom rom btw!) since about year, i really like it although of course it does not have the features the original wearOS had. connecting to it also was never a problem, as with the charging cable there is the whole USB interface available. I do not use it for fitness or sleep tracking, so i can't report on the usability of it in that area.
I have a Casio F105W on a nato strap really cheap but lasts 7-10 years on a charge, have good backlight, and does very little except tell the time, it's the perfect watch imo. simple, cheap, reliable, small. i even saw a video of a guy freezing his Casio F91W in a solid piece of ice then putting the watch into boiling water and lastly tumble washed it for 16 minutes and it still worked.
I have been thinking about moving from my pine time to a garmen. First of yes, I do like my pine time, but I had to move to an apple phone because my old phone was no longer going to support some apps. So what happens is on the apple phone, you cannot receive notifications on you ye watch because of apple. The reason I would chose garmen is because I think they get most of there money through the watches and other devices instead of selling data to advertisers .( I don’t know if they even do make money from advertisers.
I got a garmin fenix 7 solar and I cant image using other smartwatch. The fact that there are offline maps and the watch counts how many reps have you done is a gamechanger for me.
9:26 Zac Freedman on here made a custom pipboy that's pretty cool you should check it out it's super nerdy and can attach and detach alot of stuff. Only reason I'm mentioning it is because mental outlaw said pipboy at the end.
I bought a pinetime and a bangle.js 2, but haven't played with them yet. I was planning to put waspos on the pinetime so that its more like the bangle and I don't have to reflash everytime I want to make a modification. They will serve as sleep tracker and I also might put one on each hand and try to stream position for a really bad kinect type thing in godot. I will probably have to get a more standard watch and put asteroidsOS for the my other use case, music when running, without having to take my whole phone with me, though I could just get a non wrist mounted mp3 player. Also, once its got something more android/linux based, should be able to adb or maybe even ssh into it, so that rather than just sending scripts to a slow interpreter, maybe you can upload optimised binaries?
garmin vivosmart 4 would be nice without the cloud data thru the Android. Size is small but not readable at my age. Buzzes for "new goal reached" should be blocked too. Nice video.
I have a Garmin instinct 2. It has everything the other watches have just in black and white with a battery that last weeks! What really makes me love it is the stealth mode that stops the watch from sending out signals that could cause you to be tracked. Another is a kill switch that will let you wipe your data off the watch.
The pinetime, banglejs, pebble etc .. are more of fitness trackers than smart watches.. when you think of it that way, You'll appreciate the fewer features and longer battery life (20-30 days on my bip) they come with as opposed to smart watches which run full multi tasking oses but you have to charge every couple of days.. just like your phone, laptop etc... As for privacy, as long as your smart watch doesn't connect to internet directly (read: has no LTE/wifi), any watch supported by gadgetbridge app is good enough imo. Your data stays with you on your phone. The device can only talk to that nice open source app via. Bluetooth. No privacy worries at all.
Can you please do a new video on this, covering things like the Gadgetbridge app, if there has been any news in terms of rootability/better custom roms, compatibility with newer models etc?
If I am to design and build a smartwatch from zero I would definitely add a NFC and 125kHz module, a 300-900MHz general purpose modem and a infrared interface. I would definitely want to use it in conjunction with access control systems.
I have a pinetime and it lasts maybe 5 days with it mostly on my desk, 3 or 4 days wearing it to work. The heartrate monitor is kind of trashy (sometimes saying i have 60 beats per minute) and the gadgetbridge app doesn't record it anyway. Mostly use the accelerometer to turn the screen on from a brisk wrist rotation, but you can just make it hypersensitive to always stay on. The biggest reason it stays at home is just that you can't see the time and music controls/song title at the same time, and that I didn't get a dev version to even try some smart home stuff. An ESP32 watch might be better if you just want some way to control offline smart home things over zigbee or something, since it only has a bluetooth antenna.
correct me if I'm wrong but, couldn't you use a Garmin watch for these? I know about the Garmin app and that it's proprietary but I think that in some models (or maybe most of them) you can just connect it to your computer and transfer the files of your training for the day and analyze it over some other program that can read the type of file etc. imo this is the best option (unless someone has a counter) and I'm highly considering getting a Forerunner here myself
Don't worry, we will be sure to keep hardware level trackers just for y'all.
oh thanks fbi, I can call you up to play games at my house easier (don't mind the door)
I would expect no less! 🥰
I'll turn your leg to spaghetti
AHH FBI, a bunch of liars who claim our country hacked your 2016 election....
Spying on the citizens of individualistic ideas....same bastards you feds are....by the way you will never catch any Russian Spies....they are everywhere....check your department
As a cybersecurity nerd I've always found kinda sad that a lot of IoT devices seem actually useful or interesting but they're (intentionally or not) a hotspot for spyware and security vulnerabilities
Made explicitly for this reason. Willing panopticon.
@Not gonna lie you can wait a little more, i aint clicking it
Convenience usually means easier for the consumer. (Ex. Less Steps Needed) The inconvenience goes to the the company”s product. Therefore the steps that were taken out for the consumer are now in the hands of the company’s own agendas
Damn a pip boy would be really sick hahaha. Idk if it would be as practical to wear on an everyday basis but surely what it did do it would have the potential to do much better
Yeah, I remember about 10 years ago being so excited for the future when all this smart tech was being introduced. But then I learned just privacy invading and dystopian it all is, and I began to view it as if it’s literal poison.
Still though, at least in recent years I’ve discovered all the open source projects that people have made, and it’s given me hope that I can have all the tech without the loss of privacy. But if a cool piece of tech has been invented, but it’s not open source yet, then I don’t even view as being fully invented yet tbh.
its insane how quickly and silently we went from "free, but you pay with your data" to "not free, but you also pay with your data"
The shadiness of spyware aside, at least originally you got something out of it, or you'd pay for something but keep your privacy. Now it just exists by default, you pay for the product twice.
Very well-said!
It's sick is what it is.
Similar happened with cable tv. First it was pay for no ads…
You will own nothing and be happy.
I don't pay for anything
I love how that ECG app has to ask for your birthdate just to even know if you're "allowed" to use the app. There is exactly one reason for this: if you're a child, it's illegal for them to harvest your data. With this prompt they're openly admitting that they do not give a fuck about your privacy.
it's actually not an option, they HAVE to ask you that, because they store it on THEIR servers, so THEY would get into trouble if they collected a child's data unwittingly, even if they're a perfectly good company that does nothing shady
but also that's what you read the TOS and such stuff for, what do they say they can do with your data, like if they don't "share your personal information with select partners" or such, then it might be reasonably fine
@@jan_harald A perfectly good company that does nothing shady doesn't have to store that data on its servers. You can (and should be legally forced to) keep that kind of sensitive data local unless EXPLICITLY requested otherwise.
@@jan_harald you say that but all it takes is one "privacy agreement" update to fuck you over.
Plus, they could verify the data in better ways. Like a contract, rather than asking personal info.
On the Apple Watch there is a like “system” DOB for core functionality that doesn’t get shared with the apps. Each individual app (EKG, blood oxygen, VO2 max exe) asks separately for your DOB (sometimes only for the year), and each individual app has a different age limit (IIRC EKG is 22+, but VO2 max? is 20+). You can give each app a contradictory DOB and it won’t care, so long as the DOB provided for each app is before the cutoff date in that app only. I know I have lied to one of the apps before and there is zero pushback, and you can just renter a new DOB if it says you are too young.
Clearly it’s just covering their legal liability with the AF stuff, there is no reason for them to collect this specific DOB when you already have an iPhone and an Apple Watch and thus have agreed to 3? licence agreements (iTunes/Apple ID, iOS and WatchOS), and have probably provided a more specific date of birth in other places.
Also you can opt out of having this stuff stored on the cloud by turning off iCloud sync for health in settings, and this data is (according to Apple) stored with end to end encryption. I’m actually pretty sure this specific DOB is completely local as moving to a new watch you need to explicitly opt back in to ECG and renter your DOB here.
I agree it’s not ideal but it’s pretty standard for Apple, which is basically just barely better than Google and sketchy android but not as good as full libre stuff.
The gadgetbridge project allows you to connect a smartwatch without going through its native spyware setup. Most of the native features that you would have had with the app from whatever vender the watch was from work.
There are also a lot of forks for in development dsvices, I think you could probably find most of the major company's watcher there. Documentation is pretty good for if you feel the need to add a device for yourself. Its also on fdroid, so that's always a plus.
you're a godsend man, had no idea 3rd party apps were available with zero built in tracking bullshit
Thank you for the based knowledge
@@dani1999n You need to know that some Smartwatches which are supported by gadgetbride need to obtain a token for communication. Some of them rely on extracting the token from the proprietary App such as for Xiaomi Mi Band's from Version 3 upwards. That means, you have to make an account, log into it with internet access, pair the watch, use Termux (if Root is available) and extract the token from the Apps's data. You can find more info on their wiki under Huami devices or something.
Take care on what type of watch you'd get to avoid this task.
Thank you for your knowledge!
I have a watch for 1 year (that was a gift) that I don't use because spyware app. Thanks to you and gadgetbridge (couldn't find it before without the name), I now have a working smartwatch that keeps my health datas for myself. as @timlpde said, it was a bit of pain to pair with the auth key needed, but after a few hours of pain I'm now happy.
@@TIMLPDE yh i have an amazfit one and i did have to get a python script to scrape it from the official app's data folder
I believe the best option (especially if you like your SmartWatch to be a fitness tracker) is garmin.
- excellent sensors for tracking (i use it for swimming and it tracks the distance + stroke rate and a ton of other metrics. but it is very good for all kind of sports)
- You can set up the device without a phone or bluetooth. it never needs to connect to anything. Bluetooth can be deactivated. all data is only stored offline on your watch.
- if you connect it via the usb cable, you can access all the data on your pc as it shows up as a generic mass storage. Garmin has data formats that are documented so you could back up and store all your data offline on your pc and write your own data processing (so you get a "foss garmin connect" (maybe something like that already exists))
as far as i know there is a open source sdk for garmin too
I'm highly considering getting a Garmin ngl.
just still not sure if I should go with the Forerunner series or the fenix one (if you have any reviews about them go on, I don't care about spending lots of money on a product if it's high quality)
I have a Garmin Forerunner. Super ugly but does the trick.
@@vicstoron i got a fenix 6 and its so great
If it doesn't come with the spyware, I'm not even interested.
@@vicstoron Got a forerunner 35. I'm not sure about the newer models but it isn't exactly a "smart watch", it's a sport watch. You don't have to worry about proprietary spyware when there are no apps on it. You get all the benefits of tracking your training/fitness without all the bullshit that comes with "modern smart watches".
Quickly becoming one of my favorite tech youtubers. Not only does your content interest me, and fit my needs, but it is also very informative and entertaining! Another video upload I've enjoyed. Thanks Outlaw, looking forward to more videos.
Advertising with 'No spyware!' would be a good selling point. but do most zoomers really care?
zoomers basically swim in bad opsec
what's an opsec?
sincerely,
a zoomer
@@kingdededelicious Operational Security, I believe
@@kingdededelicious operation security
It's said in the military that there's like 5 operations you always have to do to survive, and the most known and in common use outside the battlefield its that, opsec
Most don’t care. But I would
Best feature for smart watches is yet to come. It's nearly there. It's already there on some lesser-known Chinese watches. It's glucometer. My diabetic friend has bought one, tested it for weeks with both the watch and classic needled glucometer. It was shockingly accurate. No idea how it works without a needle, that's some black magic level of science. But holy hell it works. When this gets needed certificates and arrives onto more popular mainstream brands - these watches will actually start saving lives. Because for diabetics a device that passively monitors blood sugar level and notifies when it gets out of safe levels is literally a life-saver.
That's pretty awesome, actually. If it's spyware free that'd be perfect!
It measures it through your sweat
Right now, I'm wearing a Garmin Tactix 7. I like that it has the Stealth Mode option which (at least, if it functions as advertised) disables all wireless connectivity for a bit of added privacy. Mostly, I just use it to see what time it is, but having offline maps stored locally on the device is really what sold me on it. I've never paired it to my phone and don't intend to.
That being said, if someone ever made a rugged, open source pipboy that had a similar set of features, I'd ditch my $1300 smart watch and get that in a heartbeat.
I've been using the Tactix Delta for over a year now and I feel the same. Garmin makes the best smart watches right now but I wish they weren't so expensive and that the OS was open source.
And you know, for all the advancement in the last 10ish years, I'd still love to just have my old Pebble 2.
Pebble were just a few years ahead of their time.
@@DI0NY5US They are more expensive because your data isn't subsidizing the cost of the product. I miss my Pebble...
… you bought a $1,300 smart watch to keep it offline, not pair it with your phone, and store some offline map data on it? That’s gotta be the dumbest shit I’ve ever heard bro 😂😂😂
@@BasedHyperborean seriously! you could buy a decent PC with that dough.
bro spent 1.3k on a watch to not use it 💀
On the pipboy idea, no need for a new device, phones are already 90% there. I'm imagining something like a wrist phone hub that has extra sensors and charges your phone with it's own battery, with some slight UI changes to make it easier to use the phone in landscape mode.
Might be a reason for smaller smartphones to make a comeback.
And ui changes can be probably made just by installing custum launcher
Pretty disturbing that there was spyware to begin with.
Nothing out of the ordinary, though; just another day in this fucked-up world! :D
Ah, yes, data collection, so amazing.
We're living in the cyberpunk dystopia, just without the fancy neon stuff
@@intifadayuri depends on the area
@Scarlett Witch 🅥 can yall bots just get fked?
@@intifadayuri if I'm going to have my data collected, I want the fancy neon stuff
@Scarlett Witch 🅥 spammer
In case you don't know about it there's an amazing video by a guy who worked for IBM developing a pioneering Linux smartwatch back in the day. Although it didn't take off, a lot of the developments were used in later smartwatches.
2:12
2:24
3:38
4:56 4:58 4:58 4:56
IoT is actually a cool hobby if you are into tech. With something like Home Assistant on an Rasperry Pie you can do pretty cool stuff, and if you know React you can Build your own Dashboards.
Paired with Shelly or similar devices you can make your home smart and be the only one with access to your data. You can even integrate your Smart Watch and write a script that emails you a personal health report every month.
Any projects started s of yet ?
Who wants to just be able to tell time, Ur hilarious man.. and SO MUCH great content… this is my new favorite RUclips channel by leaps and bounds 👏
gatekeeping features on the device you payed for with DRM is already a thing. Some of the sensors are just broken without a subscription to fitbit. Others may be censored by region, like Samsung features turning off outside of South Korea.
Man, I really enjoyed this video. Please keep making more about things like this.
Honestly glad to see people are interested in it.
Kitbashing together some form of Pipboy from available materials sounds fun. I was thinking of getting one of those cheap arm-band phone holders from the dollar store, plopping in a cheap smartphone I'd been using as a e-reader (got it during a Black Friday sale for like $3) and wearing it on my forearm just to get an idea how comfortable or uncomfortable that would be as well as if it would work better with the phone placed under my forearm or on top like most watches would be situated.
Then going from there and experimenting to see what features I'd like to try. Hmm, I wonder if anyone's tried building a smartwatch using an ESP32 module......
Thank you for sharing, keep up the great content!
There are people still using their pebble smartwatches. There was a sleep tracking app available back when I used my Pebble Time. Unfortunately the only heart-rate enabled pebble watch had rubber side buttons that deteriorate and fall apart eventually.
@Scarlett Witch 🅥 Unexpectedly wholesome?
Yeah, I had the first model of the Pebble. Loved it so much, I convinced a friend to get one even though it was already the age of Rebble. Only reason I didn't use Morpheuz more was because I never got used to wearing a watch to bed. I wish we saw more watches like it that focused on battery life and always-on displays.
I still use my pebble, got it in middle school. But I've always been mad that I cheaped out and didn't get the time steel. They were cheap asf brand new when I was buying, but I'm cheap asf too
Step tracking is spot on but the heart rate monitor wasn't all that accurate to begin with, they would have needed a few iterations possibly. Shame they fell through.
@@Camoceltic Sleep as Android is pretty stellar, but yeah, you have to be used to wearing it to bed. I got used to taking it off for 1 hour per week which is pretty awesome.
I got a Huawei Watch and flashed Astroid on it.
The process was actually pretty simple and has the advantage that I don't have to install crappy spyware from Huawei.
I'm pretty happy the watch is fantastic for what I want from it.
So mainly sports and as mp3 player when I run.
For people who also do sports and do not want to be distracted or better want to track their progress I can only recommend it.
How do you flash astroid?
@@profound369
You can find the instructions on the website.
It's really not a complicated process.
Even I got it done, and I'm not the most technically savvy person by far.
It basically just amounts to enabling developer options, changing a setting and running a few commands through your terminal.
You can even keep Asteroid parallel to the original os if you want.
I was just thinking bout this the other day when once of the people from my gym asked if I would get an Apple Watch (I wouldn’t, but I can’t deny the fitness and text capabilities are appealing) . Thanks for satisfying my curiosity a bit.
The pinetime development kit actually looks pretty interesting... Seems like the middle ground between a finished product and developing your own.
For me, its the G-SHOCK GBD200-1. Classic square g-shock with some basic fitness tracking that displays right on the watch. Sure, you can connect it to an app on your phone, but you don't have to.
For me it's the GW-M5610U, the fact that it perfectly syncs the time with a radio signal is "smart" enough for me. It tells me the time, it has a few time alerts available, it has a stopwatch, it has a timer, it has world time, it's solar powered, it's shock resistant and water resistant, what more do you want from your watch?
@@supra107 Impressive. Very nice choice.
@@kalgonzo148 The only model that can rival it is the GW-9400 with the sensor. However 1) it's way more expensive and 2) it's way more bulkier. The GW-M5610U is probably the cheapest daily driver that just runs itself.
@@supra107 That sounds like what I have. It's put up with some serious abuse.
@@maxscott3349 The model name and the module version is always engraved on the backplate of the watch.
I've been looking into buying a Pinetime recently and I remember reading that Sleep for Android supports the Pinetime, and is a great sleep tracking app. I have yet to try it but I sure am excited to
I had no idea the pinewatch existed. I have a pinepower and love it. Ordered the watch ti mess around with, thanks for this video.
Thanks for pointing out the pine time. I'll try it out
Some time ago, I had the opportunity to try a Xiaomi MI band. I liked the experience, I realized how good it is for checking the time without taking out my phone. It convinced me to think about buying a $20 Casio in the future.
I bought both a sealed and an unsealed PineTime last year, and the TLDR is that the software Pine put on (infinitime) pretty much sucks, although it is getting better every few months. There is a lot more development happening however on other OSs for the PineTime, like Wasp-os and the OS from the Zephr watch also runs on PineTime. Personally, given Pine64's pretty good reputation in the opensource / openhardware space, which is a space where many companies just take your cash and run let alone keep supporting software for real products, I think the PineTime is the perfect watch for the privacy-concious to rally around. These watch OS' are small and easy to reason about, and they can even run a python REPL.
You mentioned a lot of the valuable parts of a smartwatch, but something that doesn't get acknowledged enough is how much more convenient notifications and speaker calls on the watch are. Being able to set up timers easily, use them to control my phone's camera, change music while working out, and have a full calculator, my calendar, and the forecast, I use my watch for basically everything I can do on my phone but reading or watching videos. I'm pretty excited about the resurgence of e-ink and the possibility I could use a cheap phone for reading and emails and have my watch for everything else (yes, I cant watch videos on e-ink, but I don't watch stuff outside the house anyways.)
Basically. I use my phone less because of this. Siri has improved my life drastically.
Is it, though? Seems like doing all that stuff is a nightmare on a watch. Even phones can barely do it well, I don't see how they can get watches right.
Take calendar for example. You can see, what? Today's events? No option for a 30 day view that's useful? A terrible user interface that takes forever, and you may as well use a phone or computer?
I just don't see the use of the interface. I think good AR will be far better.
@@O1OO1O1
Before you read: I am talking about my experience with stock Samsung watch and phone if you have no interest save yourself some time.
Most people use calendar to check current day events, you can create new ones with voice commands, but the 30 day view doesn't show your future appointments. Yet it is good enough to keep track of your day and you may do your planning and checking of future appointments once or twice a day in the computer and focus on the day with the smartwatch.
Answering or denying calls is a breeze, just a quick swipe or even a gesture using the accelerometer and I'm talking.
Speak to text is quite decent for longer answers, there are preprogrammed quick replies and the qwerty keyboard with swipe typing is good enough for the edge cases.
I agree. Aside from normal watch functions, I use my gear s2 primarily for calendar, weather, and email reading purposes. It's great for when I'm walking somewhere and want a quick, small dashboard of what I have going on.
For many of my activities even a phone is bare bones. But yeah, everyone has different need and wants. Yet there still are open software solutions that grant you your features without the privacy concerns
I've wanted to put together my own pip-boy with a raspi, still working on figuring out how to aquire the internal hardware to work on it. I do have an idea on how to make the buttons and dials work though, since QMK is pretty customizable.
“When a wrist watch becomes old, its an heirloom,
When a smartwatch becomes old, its an e-waste”
-Michael Fisher [Mr. Mobile]
My 10 year battery casio watch:
I have a garmin instint and tbh I can't see why it would ever be e-waste. Unlikely to break and the features it has now will be just as good in 20 years. Only the more phone like smartwatches become ewaste.
I have a BangleJS2 smartwatch and love it. I'm surprised you didn't bring that one up.
I agree with the last pip-boy comment. I've had for the last couple of years a mighty need to make my own smart watch, kinda like the ZSWatch. After some months tho, I thought that I'd be better to just go full-on cyberpunk and make a bigger wearable. Maybe something that could fit the entire foremarm, put a keyboard, a linux distro, make it like a tiny pc, maybe something crazier. It'd be fun and I'd get a cool device (and some bragging rights) in the end.
The only good smart watch I've ever owned was a Pebble, nothing else has really gotten the point of the smart watch aside from pebble. My checklist: Needs a battery that lasts a minimum of a week, needs an always on display as a gesture to turn on the display prevents easy casual time/stat tracking, needs an app store thats open to third party developers, finally fitness tracking is nice but it should be secondary to checking and responding to notifications, and features relating to time keeping and schedule management. I don't mind the watch being reliant on a phone, it's just gotta have features that reduce the need to pull out my phone
A couple things I've seen current smartwatches are alike to the pebble are in price and battery life. What matters to me is that it lacks a touch screen. No real replacement for the Pebble yet, how long has it been again? A decade?!
I was given a used Apple Watch recently and I like it well enough. I’m not really convinced of the need for these things, but they are cool. I would love to try out the PineTime though.
I built my own device but mostly cause I cannot wear a normal watch while wearing an orthotic device. So I embedded the sensor in orthotic for SpO² and pulse and have magnets and pogopins to clip on the watch I made. So it's an add on for my orthotics. I have SpO² sensors on forhead and legs to calculate orthostatic differences. Not something watches can do and I needed the extra feedback.
As someone who really wants the health tracking features, I think I hate the lack of good smart watches with a burning passion moreso than any other consumer electronic device.
I use the open-source app Gadgetbridge with a Fossil Hybrid watch. It's a good compromise (some smart features, notifications, HR tracking, etc - but all data stays on my device, I don't have the closed-source manufacturer app installed, and the watch has no connectivity apart from bluetooth to my phone). It also works with Mi Fit / AmazFit bands, etc.
I have a garmin watch because they allow you to access their api. I have a app I wrote that has a web hook and it receives all my data instantly after I complete a workout. Apple wants you to be a large company to access the HealthKit api
While it probably isn't the most secure strictly speaking, I use Garmin devices. Particularly those in their fitness tracker category rather than anything labelled as a "smart watch", all the fitness tracking, but limited options for connectivity with various phone apps to the fitness tracker. Phone Notifications is about as much as you can hope for and honestly that is more than I need.
I got a Fitbit after years of refusing to get a 24/7 tracker. It helped me fix my sleep and stuff but now I am pretty sure there is a digital me being sold by Fitbit somewhere
according to teclore you can use Garmin watches and download your data offline to a computer. Therefore, you don’t even have to use the Garmin services that track you
Garmin also has stealth modes. Their watches are pretty popular with military members so they make them with privacy concerns in mind.
I've been using a Pinetime for almost two years. It ain't bad. The stock wristband isn't something you'd want to wear while sleeping, but it's standardized and easy to swap it out for something more comfortable.
I'd say about 95% of my usage of it is just to play 2048 at the bus stop without running down my phone's battery.
The bluetooth is very promiscuous, at least on WASP-OS. I haven't used InfiniTime in a while.
My favorite brand of sport watches are Suunto which directly compete with garmin but dont have unecessary things like wifi and just handles the sport things greatly, though they are pretty expensive since they are hand assembled in Finland, but overall much more secure than the orher brands.
PSA: everyone with a garmin watch has a 85%+ chance of being a fed
Guess I am a fed.
You can tell by the fluorescence
not only the watch glows in the dark
And a 100% chance of being on strava
The ZSWatch looks pretty nice! 4 buttons, round display, I'm curious what the upcoming version will look like! Sadly it looks like it doesn't have a transflective MIP LCD but needs backlight to be visible. I used to wear a Pebble until a year ago, and I don't want to miss full button operation, always-on sunlight-visible screen and several days of battery life. I can live without health/activity tracking, touch screen and things like phone calls on the watch. So last year I replaced my Pebble Steel with a Garmin fenix 6S Pro which comes pretty close. But now I miss the Pebble's open ecosystem, and somehow also its geekiness...
I like my Casio, has a BT App to set the time ( used it practically once for that, with internet to the app disabled, because apparently you could do geolocation with BT ), but otherwise dump as eff...
Sometimes, just sometimes, life needs to be a bit easier.
An always on display is important for it to function as a watch IMO, I wonder if one will pop up in a nice case, waterproof and heart monitoring with an eink display.
I'd honestly rock a pip-boy style device
I have a pinetime. Can vouch for the fact that the heart rate monitor is a bit inaccurate occasionally
I use a Ticwatch Pro with Kali Nethunter.
Since it’s an older model (but top end), it’s easier to root and has developer support and is actually not that much more expensive than the Pine Time while being a lot more premium and feature packed.
Hit the nail right on the head. What we really need is a Pip-Boy
Did not expect powerlifting b-roll on this channel, two worlds collide
I got the fossil hr hybrid watch I feel it's a compelling product. Battery last for about a month it is a traditional watch with hands but the face is eink and has productivity functions of a smart watch.
Actually you can disable most of the proprietary bloatware if not all, just by using adb commands. You can connect adb wifi and give some commands from your computer, for disabling stuff. Also, you can disable most manufacturer apps just by going into the settings, app info, and tapping disable. Problem is that those apps are often needed to get good tracking
Pine time looks great for me. IDC about fitness tracking.
Someday I’d like one of those Garmin watches for Hiking and camping.
I own a BangleJS Watch 1 and it works amazing!
Learning about smart watches was terrifying but I love my Gamin Fenix 7 so much :(
Neat.
I’ve been looking for a smartwatch, might look into the pinetime
There is also bangle js2. I own one and its very good for my daily tasks.
There is another option to get the leaked bootloader for chinese watches or gadgetbridge watches and enjoy all the benefits of specs and privacy
I have the PineTime, and it's really good.
I still wear an iPod Nano 6 from 2010 with a watch band attached to it. Its definitely outdated and only connects to a PC/mac over a wired connection, but lack of wireless connectivity other than fm radio, microphone or anything of that sort makes it pretty much impossible to use as a tracking device, and it still looks like a smartwatch despite technically not being one.
I already own a pinetime and its really great
I used to use my Mi Band 3 with Gadgetbridge (on F-Droid). For these devices I'm mostly interested on the fitness related features. So full on smartwatches are not on my alley, that's the reason I prefer smart bands instead. The problem with that I had with Gadgetbridge is regular loss of connection with the device and that the UI is horrendous. looking at the heart rate graph makes my eyes bleed, the same for the sleep dashboards.
I wear some rando Timex watch I got at a garage sale for dirt cheap because it needed a new battery.
It's a nice watch!
if youre looking for a pipboy style watch, garmin has something very similar. they have some pretty cool stuff as far as wearables go i just havent done enough research on them or been able to audit one myself to see whats all going on under the hood.
afaik you don't need to connect it bluetooth to your phone app or anything and you can just transfer the files of your training to a computer and open them with another app etc so issues with spyware don't seem to really exist on it if you just wanna use it for basic stuff like monitoring training/sleeping
This is part of the reason I stopped using a smartwatch after the Pebble died. The main reason is that I checked my phone way too much during the day. I didn’t need a constant buzz on my wrist and yet another way for people to reach me.
New Mental Outlaw vid 😍
Got to have a high dpi oled screen or what's the point?
Mainstream watch with custom ROM would probably be my choice, though I am not in the market for a smartwatch right now. When I got my phone, I bought a used one that was already flashed with LineageOS, it was only like €20 over market price, so certainly worth it.
Probably gonna go tic watch in the future however I absolutely love the idea of open source watches.
Hell, I could come up with plenty of uses for a pipboy
Ah thats interesting just a few days ago i came across the ZSWatch too (zephyrs smart watch)
You can buy tablet PC's like the dell 5290 2in1 or the Microsoft surface tablets, these are life changers for people that move quite a bit
ZSwatch looks pretty nice, altough I'm not big enough of a consoomer to need a smart watch at this point
Nice username.
Same lol I just brought me a watch that looks like a calculator instead 🤝
great video. I absolutley LOVE smart watches and I really cannot live without them... one thing that is stopping me from using say Graphene OS (well buying a pixel phone) is cus I just love my galaxy watch 4 too much... maybe pay the conseqeunces for it who knows.... the pine time is a step in the right direction... Asteriod OS is pretty interesting and I don't think it is too much hasel to load onto one of the fossil family of watches but it lacks so many features INCLUDING BLUETOOTH in some cases; whilst bluetooth is pretty insecure, no notifcation relay is just not a useable smart watch... hhhh.
pip boy would be awesome! but i reckon it would be heavy af on the hand
⌚ I like it. Great little smartwatch, heartrate monitor works well, use it all the time without fail (over year with it). Only issue I've had is needing to get around to fixing stepcounter. At the price you can't beat it. Always exciting seeing new features in firmware upgrade. 🙂 Fun FOSS option.
Nice
As some have already said, i think the best choice to make here is to use a non-LTE watch with the GadgetBridge app, ensuring all your data stay on your phone.
Just had to double check to see if the phones were being sold to the public and it seems like they're moving forward with that. Are there any plans to make any videos on one in the future?
My watch has 3 little hands, that spin around in circles, over and over and over. I look down at it, and suddenly I know the time. This is as technology advanced as I want my watch.
been using a huawei watch (2015) w/ asteroid OS (as shown from abt 5:22, not actually a custom rom btw!) since about year, i really like it although of course it does not have the features the original wearOS had. connecting to it also was never a problem, as with the charging cable there is the whole USB interface available. I do not use it for fitness or sleep tracking, so i can't report on the usability of it in that area.
I have a Casio F105W on a nato strap really cheap but lasts 7-10 years on a charge, have good backlight, and does very little except tell the time, it's the perfect watch imo.
simple, cheap, reliable, small. i even saw a video of a guy freezing his Casio F91W in a solid piece of ice then putting the watch into boiling water and lastly tumble washed it for 16 minutes and it still worked.
I have been thinking about moving from my pine time to a garmen.
First of yes, I do like my pine time, but I had to move to an apple phone because my old phone was no longer going to support some apps. So what happens is on the apple phone, you cannot receive notifications on you ye watch because of apple.
The reason I would chose garmen is because I think they get most of there money through the watches and other devices instead of selling data to advertisers .( I don’t know if they even do make money from advertisers.
I got a garmin fenix 7 solar and I cant image using other smartwatch.
The fact that there are offline maps and the watch counts how many reps have you done is a gamechanger for me.
9:26 Zac Freedman on here made a custom pipboy that's pretty cool you should check it out it's super nerdy and can attach and detach alot of stuff. Only reason I'm mentioning it is because mental outlaw said pipboy at the end.
The lilygo T-Watch is a esp32 based device with LoRa, Bluetooth, wifi, and gives so much potential but the esp32 is a power hungry thing.
I bought a pinetime and a bangle.js 2, but haven't played with them yet. I was planning to put waspos on the pinetime so that its more like the bangle and I don't have to reflash everytime I want to make a modification. They will serve as sleep tracker and I also might put one on each hand and try to stream position for a really bad kinect type thing in godot. I will probably have to get a more standard watch and put asteroidsOS for the my other use case, music when running, without having to take my whole phone with me, though I could just get a non wrist mounted mp3 player. Also, once its got something more android/linux based, should be able to adb or maybe even ssh into it, so that rather than just sending scripts to a slow interpreter, maybe you can upload optimised binaries?
im using an old garmin. Its a dumb "smartwatch" but it does what i need, and has a gps feature which is nice for hiking
garmin vivosmart 4 would be nice without the cloud data thru the Android. Size is small but not readable at my age. Buzzes for "new goal reached" should be blocked too. Nice video.
I have a Garmin instinct 2. It has everything the other watches have just in black and white with a battery that last weeks!
What really makes me love it is the stealth mode that stops the watch from sending out signals that could cause you to be tracked. Another is a kill switch that will let you wipe your data off the watch.
The pinetime, banglejs, pebble etc .. are more of fitness trackers than smart watches.. when you think of it that way, You'll appreciate the fewer features and longer battery life (20-30 days on my bip) they come with as opposed to smart watches which run full multi tasking oses but you have to charge every couple of days.. just like your phone, laptop etc...
As for privacy, as long as your smart watch doesn't connect to internet directly (read: has no LTE/wifi), any watch supported by gadgetbridge app is good enough imo. Your data stays with you on your phone. The device can only talk to that nice open source app via. Bluetooth. No privacy worries at all.
Can you please do a new video on this, covering things like the Gadgetbridge app, if there has been any news in terms of rootability/better custom roms, compatibility with newer models etc?
If I am to design and build a smartwatch from zero I would definitely add a NFC and 125kHz module, a 300-900MHz general purpose modem and a infrared interface. I would definitely want to use it in conjunction with access control systems.
Do any of these watches have a NVD comparable screen mode though? Or a low battery usage mode so it can last for days with minimal use?
I have a pinetime and it lasts maybe 5 days with it mostly on my desk, 3 or 4 days wearing it to work. The heartrate monitor is kind of trashy (sometimes saying i have 60 beats per minute) and the gadgetbridge app doesn't record it anyway. Mostly use the accelerometer to turn the screen on from a brisk wrist rotation, but you can just make it hypersensitive to always stay on. The biggest reason it stays at home is just that you can't see the time and music controls/song title at the same time, and that I didn't get a dev version to even try some smart home stuff. An ESP32 watch might be better if you just want some way to control offline smart home things over zigbee or something, since it only has a bluetooth antenna.
correct me if I'm wrong but, couldn't you use a Garmin watch for these?
I know about the Garmin app and that it's proprietary but I think that in some models (or maybe most of them) you can just connect it to your computer and transfer the files of your training for the day and analyze it over some other program that can read the type of file etc.
imo this is the best option (unless someone has a counter) and I'm highly considering getting a Forerunner here myself