How to extract, analyse and present data in scoping reviews

This presentation provides a practical approach to extracting, analysing and presenting data within scoping reviews, with step-by-step examples.
Chaired by Prof Zachary Munn and presented by Dr Danielle Pollock, together with experts from the JBI Scoping Review Methodology Group, this presentation discusses the JBI Scoping Review Methodology Group’s latest paper, ‘Recommendations for the extraction, analysis, and presentation of results in scoping reviews’, now available online first at JBI Evidence Synthesis jbievidencesynthesis.com
Panelists featured from JBI Scoping Review Methodology Group:
- Assoc Prof Hanan Khalil
- Dr Lyndsay Alexander
- Assoc Prof Catrin Evans
- Dr Érica Brandão
The JBI Scoping Review Network provides useful resources for download and links to scoping review methodology and publications.
Learn more about the network here: jbi.global/scoping-review-net...
00:00 - 04:01 - Welcome
04:01 - 11:19 - What are scoping reviews?
09:55 - 17:44 - Deciding between a systematic and scoping review approach
17:44 - 18:44 - Should I include critical appraisal in a scoping review?
18:44 - 23:58 - Principles when extracting evidence
23:58 - 30:57 - Creating an extraction information sheet
30:57 - 34:06 - Types of data analysis
34:06 - 36:28 - Qualitative data
36:28 - 39:47 - Scoping review case study
39:47 - 41:11 - Process of inductive analysis
41:11 - 43:29 - Presenting data
43:29 - 45:00 - PRISMA-ScR
45:00 - 47:37 - Scoping Review Network
47:37 - 52:31 - Rapid reviews vs scoping reviews
52:31 - 54:18 - Differences between scoping reviews and mapping reviews
54:18 - 58:05 - Limitations of studies included a scoping review
58:05 - 1:02:17 - Automation and tools for data extraction
1:02:17 - 1:03:09 - Covidence vs NVivo
1:03:09 - 1:06:42 - Distinguishing between scoping and systematic reviews
1:06:42 - 1:09:13 - Is there such a thing as a rapid scoping review?
1:09:13 - 1:11:58 - Study title vs content
1:11:58 - 1:14:19 - Quotes from qualitative studies
1:14:19 - 1:16:20 - Scoping review vs qualitative evidence synthesis
1:16:20 - 1:20:15 - Summary
Resources:
Recommendations for the extraction, analysis, and presentation of results in scoping reviews - journals.lww.com/jbisrir/full...
Scoping Review Network - jbi.global/scoping-review-net...
JBI Manual for Evidence Synthesis - Chapter 11 Scoping Reviews - synthesismanual.jbi.global
#jbiebhc

[@dorcasmalahlela2805]

I have a student whose scoping review has so many articles, and this has helped to focus the presentation of the data. Thank you

[@karenko2645]

This was so incredibly helpful. You just saved an occupational therapy student. Thank you.

[@JBIEBHC]

Glad to know it helped!

[@priscillabahaw5673]

I am going to sign up for this network , this is beyond educational as an early career academic in the Caribbean

[@JBIEBHC]

Fantastic, we're so pleased to hear it!

[@etimbukumana4382]

This was amazing and really helped focus my work on the scooping review. Thank you for all you and the JBI SCR group do.

[@annmariefarrell8014]

Excellent presentation - so clear and helpful. Thank you

[@riversidechiropractic2817]

This was a fantastic (and very timely) presentation! Well done and thanks.

[@ROSITANADIYAHHIRFIYANAUPM]

That is so helpful, thanks!

[@margarettaylor6020]

That was so helpful, many thanks

[@ThiagoSantosdaSilva]

Excelente! Muito esclarecedor!

[@AndresPierobon]

Very helpful webinar, Cheers!

[@robinjullies4563]

Thank you this was so helpful!

[@mayasurg6962]

It is very great and helpful!

[@researcherguide]

hi. we shouldn't extract systematic reviews retrieved from the searching phase of our Scoping reviews???

[@danteperez5347]

How to remove duplicate records across the sources before screening?

[@JBIEBHC]

There are tools that can assist with the deduplication process before screening, such as Covidence, SRA-Deduplicator, and EndNote. JBI SUMARI is currently developing this feature and will be available to users soon!

[@timothydebrah6741]

Great presentation. How can I join JBI?

[@JBIEBHC]

You can join the JBI Scoping Review Network by subscribing to: global.us15.list-manage.com/subscribe?u=b7a3429cdeb2d9125de40e149&id=3f5cb73e72

[@JBIEBHC]

The Network newsletter includes latest publications, resources and events. You can also check out the JBI Scoping Review Network website at: jbi.global/scoping-review-network

[@timothydebrah6741]

Let me see what is happening here!