The Torah -- which was given in front of an entire nation, from God, which the Muslims agree happened -- is perfection. The Quran -- which was supposedly revealed to one man (who fucked little kids) alone with no witnesses, and has plenty of human errors in it because it is not divine like the Torah -- is not perfection
some jews lie about their belief and it appears with these kinds of questions... they will say all of what that rabbi says and then they will help "them" when needed and shield them from facing justice, i think this is a brilliant question he even needed to dig a little deeper and i think uncle maliki maybe made a mistake here be calling him out like this.
@@notoftentold4076 The interviewer should start gaining knowledge about what he talks about and every else like him. People call themselves to Islam, but when we preach them about Al-Wala' wa Al-bara'a, they call it “that’s what the terrorists believe in”
Biggest respect to that Rabbi. Burger King attitude (have it your way) towards religion is pure hypocrisy and ignorance. If you disagree and won't adopt the core tenet of it's teaching then don't identifies yourself as it's follower, you'll only bring shame and perversion
The similarities in previous texts (Torah, Gospel) have with Islam just goes to show you that, once upon a time, those religions were chosen by Allah SWT at their respected times before their texts were corrupted. Islam is the final testament and has been preserved by oral tradition and written preservation.
Assalamualaikum, it was always the same religion, different rulings maybe but it was always "God is One". The people of the book are following another path of what it should be, they are upon deviance from the truth. May Allah guide us all to the right path!
"those religions were chosen by Allah", wrong, it was Islam all that time, but the children of Israel made it into a racial religion, Judaism, and when Isa preached Islam and later ascended to heaven, people deviated from Islam again and made it into a cult, Christianity.
I appreciate this Rabbi. I have rarely heard jewish voices that say that belief in God is central to being a Jew, that it cannot be separated from Jewish identity according to what Judaism has historically and universally-outside of the West-been understood.
Even i had to search what is Al Wala wal bara means. Anyways. Yes! What rabbi was taking is Al wala wal bara in Islam meaning you love or leave for the sake of your master your lord creator of this whole universe creator of heaven and earth Allah.
@@essa200911 i dunno it made me laugh when i saw " wrong religion" 😂 it is so stupid i dunno what do say. It is 2024 we still talk about "religions" and which one right which one wrong.. there is no God, there is no religion, these are all fictions.
@@inci7892 I mean this is your conviction not an argument! It is not smart to call anything stupid or laugh with don’t knowing why when you have no argument that disproves God or the question about is there a right religion or not. Also, I believe you don’t understand the difference between fiction and illusion. You can imagine things exist in reality like imagining hand which is a thing exist any many have so you did not come with anything from nothing but you will be illusional if you say the short guy is taller than the tall guy because it is contradiction. These are basic necessary intellect. You don’t need to see water to believe that Water and Thirst exist. We are in 2024 which means we need to get rid of the backyard nonsense beliefs like Something comes by Nothing. It is well known today that infinite regression is impossible because if you have an iphone and you plugged it in charger then this charger plugged it in multi plug extension then you plugged the multi plug extension with another multi plug extension…etc to infinity of plugging. This will never charge your phone and you need to plug them in “source” of power to make your iPhone charged and cut rationally the infinite series of plugging which is missing the rational main thing which is the source so you can not keep saying who created who in this creation because you will end up irrationally forgetting about the first cause who has characteristics of independence and absolute power and will to create or all the will not come or start to exist. This is common sense that all of this did not start by Nothing because Nothing has no will, it is nothing but everything came “ from “ nothing by the almighty Creator. This is the only rational common sense reality. What other options we have? They all disproven, Something can not be created By nothing and this creation can not create itself because this is also rational the pregnant woman can not give birth of herself. You can look at your foot and say there is no God but you can’t look at the sky and say there is no God. 🎤
@@inci7892 I mean this is your conviction not an argument! It is not smart to call anything stupid or laugh with don’t knowing why when you have no argument that disproves God or the question about is there a right religion or not. Also, I believe you don’t understand the difference between fiction and illusion. You can imagine things exist in reality like imagining hand which is a thing exist any many have so you did not come with anything from nothing but you will be illusional if you say the short guy is taller than the tall guy because it is contradiction. These are basic necessary intellect. You don’t need to see water to believe that Water and Thirst exist. We are in 2024 which means we need to get rid of the backyard nonsense beliefs like Something comes by Nothing. It is well known today that infinite regression is impossible because if you have an iphone and you plugged it in charger then this charger plugged it in multi plug extension then you plugged the multi plug extension with another multi plug extension…etc to infinity of plugging. This will never charge your phone and you need to plug them in “source” of power to make your iPhone charged and cut rationally the infinite series of plugging which is missing the rational main thing which is the source so you can not keep saying who created who in this creation because you will end up irrationally forgetting about the first cause who has characteristics of independence and absolute power and will to create or all the will not come or start to exist. This is common sense that all of this did not start by Nothing because Nothing has no will, it is nothing but everything came “ from “ nothing by the almighty Creator. This is the only rational common sense reality. What other options we have? They all disproven, Something can not be created By nothing and this creation can not create itself because this is also rational the pregnant woman can not give birth of herself. You can look at your foot and say there is no God but you can’t look at the sky and say there is no God. 🎤
No, I think he's pretty spot on. At least I don't want a "non-religious" muslim making an "Islamic" state where the religion is basically non existent, replaced by nationalism.
Secular Muslim: 1. Muslim means submitted to the will of God. 2. Secular means that has an attitude disassociated from God or religion. Question: To whom the secular “Muslim” submits his will?
If I'm not mistaken the host was with TRT travelling around eating food from various countries. I tried to watch because I love food but I could not because I thought he was a bit smug. May be he's not an arrogant person but his on-screen personality made me think he was while with TRT. Here he seems shallow.
You can either be french, english or whatever nationalist identity, or you can be a Muslim, the two can not go together. The Rabbi knows that very well, but sadly the host has no idea.
I cant take it to interviewer for that's his job for asking tough question, but surely its kinda annoying. In the end, rabbi speak the truth. May Allah bless him guidance, insha'Allah.
He is very right...i totally agree with him.n all firm believers will say same thing.hypocrites do not use our religion for your vile agendas.be Judaism be islam be christianity.
Even IOF could do adzan, I was surprised. And I was shocked someone said to me on IG that we muslims worship Muhammad and Allah has four legs and she got the information from imam on YT, wtf? What do you think of this? Many claim themselves muslims but they are not, they are just trying to spread lies about islam. And that host is clueless 😒
if they want a state they should go to europe not middle east, it was eu rope eans who tormented them most previously before creation of their proxy in middle east with the people they themselves tormented and it was romans who were from europe who kicked their alleged forefathers out of levant more than 2k years ago. Even if their ancestry claim are legit it still makes it wrong to try and claim 2k year old dirt since there are other people around the world who can make similar claims based on their ancient history but i highly doubt the world would put up with it if everyone started invading each other for ancestral lands
No offense, this "interviewer" is a snake. He is no different than Piers Morgan. At least Piers screams and shouts what he is. This guy tries to be sneaky with it. Why would you try and force your point of view or other points of view onto your guest? The whole point of an interview is to lay out questions and see what the guest's views on it. Not force your own views onto others. Bear in mind that my opinions here are solely based on this short part of the interview. I didn't watch the whole thing, so I don't know the context of the whole interview itself. But for this part, he is definitely trying to force his views and beliefs onto the Rabbi.
@nazmul_khan_ "playing" Devil's advocate is one thing, but why is he trying to force it on the guest? Ask the "devil's advocate" questions and accept whatever the guest's point of view on it. Not keep on trying to push a specific response from the rabbi
@@m.d.f3797 because the Jews keep pushing these points, and he wanted the Rabbi to give refutations which we can learn from and use against the J-bros.
@@m.d.f3797he is presenting the points that the J-bros always push, so by making the rabbi refute these arguments, he is allowing us to learn how to use points from their religion to counter their own arguments
What are your views on Middle Nation's view on normalization, on how it takes away power from US and gives Atab nations more negotiation power. (Personally it feels wrong, because i don't trust leaders enough with using their power wisely, and priorities life over money)
The host said Muslims will react to that differently - I disagree with the brother. A Muslim in action agrees with the Rabbi 100%. Whereas a Muslim in name only will disagree with the Rabbi. Islam and Judaism have fundamentals. If you disagree or want to change them (them being the word of God) are you really a Jew or a Muslim?
I think the host was just asking a question as he said and he explains the context of his question , this had nothing to do with his understanding of Al Wala wAl Bara !!??
@@Redery001 No, it's not about the host! The host ask the question that would lead the guest to give him that answer , it's not about the host level of understanding any concepts, but the title of this video is the problem.
@@saifmaher3429 the host was clearly not understanding and kept going back to same question. I saw another part of the interview and he just seemed like hes afraid to be cancelled
What is a non-religious jew ? It's like saying a non religious Christian. If you identify by a religion you're religious by definition. Or am I not understanding English?
The Jews calling non-Jews the Goy (Gentile), while the Arabs calling non-Arab the Ajam. Every Friday prayers the Imam will mention in "Selawat Taslim" between the 2 sermons.
@@KrimzunFlarebut it is 😉 It could be true that this Rabbi did not mean to use it as an insult, but they all know the real definition of it. And considering he’s not a layman but a rabbi, that word slipped out of his mouth rather casually.
Al Wala to ally and associate and Al Bara to disown and keep away. in otherwords wala to islam and muslims and bara to kufr and kaafireen. The rabbi didnt touch on this principle in this clip.
"Verily, we are free from you and whatever you worship besides Allâh: we have rejected you, and there has started between us and you hostility and hatred for ever until you believe in Allâh Alone" - 60:4 Repent from your atheism before death comes knocking on the door.
Muslims need to follow Islam which is Perfection
nobody needs to, we are all free to do as we please.
@@ThecRL0if someone wants to follow Islam strictly, he has the freedom and right to do so.
@@ThecRL0 jump to the future year 2090 if you are free
@@ThecRL0 rent free
The Torah -- which was given in front of an entire nation, from God, which the Muslims agree happened -- is perfection. The Quran -- which was supposedly revealed to one man (who fucked little kids) alone with no witnesses, and has plenty of human errors in it because it is not divine like the Torah -- is not perfection
I'm a Muslim and it's so frustrating when the host is absolutely CLUELESS!! ABSOLUTE DISGRACE
some jews lie about their belief and it appears with these kinds of questions... they will say all of what that rabbi says and then they will help "them" when needed and shield them from facing justice, i think this is a brilliant question he even needed to dig a little deeper and i think uncle maliki maybe made a mistake here be calling him out like this.
Rabbi spoke 💯% facts
The interviewer should listen to him
@@notoftentold4076
The interviewer should start gaining knowledge about what he talks about and every else like him. People call themselves to Islam, but when we preach them about Al-Wala' wa Al-bara'a, they call it “that’s what the terrorists believe in”
Biggest respect to that Rabbi. Burger King attitude (have it your way) towards religion is pure hypocrisy and ignorance. If you disagree and won't adopt the core tenet of it's teaching then don't identifies yourself as it's follower, you'll only bring shame and perversion
respect to someone whose whims and desires beliefs altered the religion of Allah ﷻ and persecuted the muslims
the interviewer doesn't get what it means to have faith.
does he? or is he testing the rabbi?
I mean he said a 'non religious' jew. What does that even mean ?
Sounds like the host is a Snæke 🐍
Because his job is ask tough questions.
I’ve met the Rabi in person and he is an extremely humble believer of God. Really kind hearted soul.
The similarities in previous texts (Torah, Gospel) have with Islam just goes to show you that, once upon a time, those religions were chosen by Allah SWT at their respected times before their texts were corrupted. Islam is the final testament and has been preserved by oral tradition and written preservation.
Assalamualaikum, it was always the same religion, different rulings maybe but it was always "God is One".
The people of the book are following another path of what it should be, they are upon deviance from the truth.
May Allah guide us all to the right path!
Aqeedah was the same, only fiqhee rulings were different.
The Quaran is just a bad copy of the bible with some heresies thrown in
actually, it shows muhammad stole from them when he made his fake religion up
"those religions were chosen by Allah", wrong, it was Islam all that time, but the children of Israel made it into a racial religion, Judaism, and when Isa preached Islam and later ascended to heaven, people deviated from Islam again and made it into a cult, Christianity.
I appreciate this Rabbi. I have rarely heard jewish voices that say that belief in God is central to being a Jew, that it cannot be separated from Jewish identity according to what Judaism has historically and universally-outside of the West-been understood.
Even i had to search what is Al Wala wal bara means. Anyways. Yes! What rabbi was taking is Al wala wal bara in Islam meaning you love or leave for the sake of your master your lord creator of this whole universe creator of heaven and earth Allah.
Love and hate for the sake of Allah.
When the jew has a better understanding of faith then you. Exhibit A.
Subhan’Allah
Subhan’Allah
This is just incredibly frustrating.
that's because the Jew's faith is of a divine religion, while a Muslim's is of a fake, non-divine, man-made religion
Sad state of affairs liberal values are more dear to Muslims than islamic ones. This explains our state more than anything...
May God give him guidance
This guy amazes me even if he is in wrong religion but he is sincere when it comes to try to stick to the beliefs
Wrong religion 😂😂😂
@@inci7892
What is funny about that
Yeah I am not Jewish
@@essa200911 i dunno it made me laugh when i saw " wrong religion" 😂 it is so stupid i dunno what do say. It is 2024 we still talk about "religions" and which one right which one wrong.. there is no God, there is no religion, these are all fictions.
@@inci7892
I mean this is your conviction not an argument! It is not smart to call anything stupid or laugh with don’t knowing why when you have no argument that disproves God or the question about is there a right religion or not. Also, I believe you don’t understand the difference between fiction and illusion. You can imagine things exist in reality like imagining hand which is a thing exist any many have so you did not come with anything from nothing but you will be illusional if you say the short guy is taller than the tall guy because it is contradiction. These are basic necessary intellect. You don’t need to see water to believe that Water and Thirst exist. We are in 2024 which means we need to get rid of the backyard nonsense beliefs like Something comes by Nothing. It is well known today that infinite regression is impossible because if you have an iphone and you plugged it in charger then this charger plugged it in multi plug extension then you plugged the multi plug extension with another multi plug extension…etc to infinity of plugging. This will never charge your phone and you need to plug them in “source” of power to make your iPhone charged and cut rationally the infinite series of plugging which is missing the rational main thing which is the source so you can not keep saying who created who in this creation because you will end up irrationally forgetting about the first cause who has characteristics of independence and absolute power and will to create or all the will not come or start to exist. This is common sense that all of this did not start by Nothing because Nothing has no will, it is nothing but everything came “ from “ nothing by the almighty Creator. This is the only rational common sense reality. What other options we have? They all disproven, Something can not be created By nothing and this creation can not create itself because this is also rational the pregnant woman can not give birth of herself. You can look at your foot and say there is no God but you can’t look at the sky and say there is no God.
🎤
@@inci7892
I mean this is your conviction not an argument! It is not smart to call anything stupid or laugh with don’t knowing why when you have no argument that disproves God or the question about is there a right religion or not. Also, I believe you don’t understand the difference between fiction and illusion. You can imagine things exist in reality like imagining hand which is a thing exist any many have so you did not come with anything from nothing but you will be illusional if you say the short guy is taller than the tall guy because it is contradiction. These are basic necessary intellect. You don’t need to see water to believe that Water and Thirst exist. We are in 2024 which means we need to get rid of the backyard nonsense beliefs like Something comes by Nothing. It is well known today that infinite regression is impossible because if you have an iphone and you plugged it in charger then this charger plugged it in multi plug extension then you plugged the multi plug extension with another multi plug extension…etc to infinity of plugging. This will never charge your phone and you need to plug them in “source” of power to make your iPhone charged and cut rationally the infinite series of plugging which is missing the rational main thing which is the source so you can not keep saying who created who in this creation because you will end up irrationally forgetting about the first cause who has characteristics of independence and absolute power and will to create or all the will not come or start to exist. This is common sense that all of this did not start by Nothing because Nothing has no will, it is nothing but everything came “ from “ nothing by the almighty Creator. This is the only rational common sense reality. What other options we have? They all disproven, Something can not be created By nothing and this creation can not create itself because this is also rational the pregnant woman can not give birth of herself. You can look at your foot and say there is no God but you can’t look at the sky and say there is no God.
🎤
This is the problem in all umam, hypocrites. May Allah protect us from this
This is haram to say.
@@apexinn whats haram is how ignorant Muslims are
Allahumma ameen
He is an honest Rabbi ❤
No, I think he's pretty spot on. At least I don't want a "non-religious" muslim making an "Islamic" state where the religion is basically non existent, replaced by nationalism.
I think mutual respect is a must in talks.
I love you brother❤❤❤
Secular Muslim:
1. Muslim means submitted to the will of God.
2. Secular means that has an attitude disassociated from God or religion.
Question: To whom the secular “Muslim” submits his will?
I agree with Jewish because as I Muslim I will never be secular and nationalist and play in my religion
Assalam-u-alaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatahu
وعليكم السلام
wa aleyum salam wa rahmatullah wa barakatuh
Asamu aleykium ❤
If I'm not mistaken the host was with TRT travelling around eating food from various countries. I tried to watch because I love food but I could not because I thought he was a bit smug. May be he's not an arrogant person but his on-screen personality made me think he was while with TRT.
Here he seems shallow.
Many Muslims don't understand, love what He loves, hate what He hates.
Muslims have to follow the true scholars
The Rabbi might as well be a sheikh 😂
May Allah guide him for standing up for the truth
Yes he is also very soft spoken
You can either be french, english or whatever nationalist identity, or you can be a Muslim, the two can not go together. The Rabbi knows that very well, but sadly the host has no idea.
Those are nationalities, not a belief system. You can be a French, English, Indian, and a Muslim. He was referring to conflicting ideologies.
@@amatulfulani6390 Yes and nationalism conflicts with Islam, not having a nationality
I cant take it to interviewer for that's his job for asking tough question, but surely its kinda annoying.
In the end, rabbi speak the truth. May Allah bless him guidance, insha'Allah.
True brother. Great catch
You got muslims and you got Muslims
and each of them are following a fake, non-divine religion
And the rabbi seems to understand the fallacy of secularism better than the Muslim host ...
Aslamo alykum Maliki, Can you please give me the link for this clip, I want to see the whole video please brother, thank you.
the symbol on the video is from middle east eye channel ? maybe you can start from there. 😊
found it for you. title The Story of Orthodox Jews Rabbi Elhanan Beck on middle east eye podcast
Muslims need to be better with not just accepting everybody who takes Islam by name and wants to live a secular life. Rabbi is on it 👍🏽
He is very right...i totally agree with him.n all firm believers will say same thing.hypocrites do not use our religion for your vile agendas.be Judaism be islam be christianity.
Very interesting. Brother can we get a link to the original interview in the description please.
Yes, الولاء و البراء
Well done brother.
Surprising how smart the Rabbi was.
why is it surprising? his religion is a divine one, unlike islam
@@DavidDemurs I hope you know that Jews hate Jesus and your religion
@@DavidDemursLemme guess, Greco-Roman godman worshipping Christian talking?
@@DavidDemursProve Islam is not divine???
@@DavidDemurs what are you yapping about again?
That's fire
SubhanAllah
Even IOF could do adzan, I was surprised. And I was shocked someone said to me on IG that we muslims worship Muhammad and Allah has four legs and she got the information from imam on YT, wtf? What do you think of this? Many claim themselves muslims but they are not, they are just trying to spread lies about islam.
And that host is clueless 😒
So right
hes part palestinian too
It was difficult to listen to the host answering about "Secular muslims". This is not playing devils advocate, just simply ignorance.
if they want a state they should go to europe not middle east, it was eu rope eans who tormented them most previously before creation of their proxy in middle east with the people they themselves tormented and it was romans who were from europe who kicked their alleged forefathers out of levant more than 2k years ago. Even if their ancestry claim are legit it still makes it wrong to try and claim 2k year old dirt since there are other people around the world who can make similar claims based on their ancient history but i highly doubt the world would put up with it if everyone started invading each other for ancestral lands
nice to see you agree it's their ancestral land
@@DavidDemurs did you miss the word "alleged"?
I know 👃 suffers from reading comprehension but this is just sad.
😂
No offense, this "interviewer" is a snake. He is no different than Piers Morgan. At least Piers screams and shouts what he is. This guy tries to be sneaky with it. Why would you try and force your point of view or other points of view onto your guest? The whole point of an interview is to lay out questions and see what the guest's views on it. Not force your own views onto others.
Bear in mind that my opinions here are solely based on this short part of the interview. I didn't watch the whole thing, so I don't know the context of the whole interview itself. But for this part, he is definitely trying to force his views and beliefs onto the Rabbi.
He is playing devils advocate, you are too quick to judge
@nazmul_khan_ "playing" Devil's advocate is one thing, but why is he trying to force it on the guest? Ask the "devil's advocate" questions and accept whatever the guest's point of view on it. Not keep on trying to push a specific response from the rabbi
@@m.d.f3797 because the Jews keep pushing these points, and he wanted the Rabbi to give refutations which we can learn from and use against the J-bros.
@@m.d.f3797he is presenting the points that the J-bros always push, so by making the rabbi refute these arguments, he is allowing us to learn how to use points from their religion to counter their own arguments
What are your views on Middle Nation's view on normalization, on how it takes away power from US and gives Atab nations more negotiation power. (Personally it feels wrong, because i don't trust leaders enough with using their power wisely, and priorities life over money)
hahaha, nice video. But how scary its is for the ummah, that a Jew understand it better then most of muslims...
Because most of the so called muslims are munafiqun, sad but that is the true
I think he was playing devil's advocate.
I the way he spoke was more like playing devils homey
He was really weird when he compromised on Islam.
The Rabbi is the real McCoy . Respect
Why not give the name of the rabbi?
Rabbi Elhanan Beck
But does he understand shama lama ding dong
That had nothing to do with walaa and baraa... but it's a shame a host like that represented us
The host said Muslims will react to that differently - I disagree with the brother. A Muslim in action agrees with the Rabbi 100%. Whereas a Muslim in name only will disagree with the Rabbi. Islam and Judaism have fundamentals. If you disagree or want to change them (them being the word of God) are you really a Jew or a Muslim?
Clueless interviewer 😂
I feel sorry for him.
Host is not equipped to have these kind of conversations
anyone knows the rabbi's name?
Rabbi Beck
I think the host was just asking a question as he said and he explains the context of his question , this had nothing to do with his understanding of Al Wala wAl Bara !!??
Thats right. I feel he was only playing devils advocate
@@anisdesai4692 yeah.
Host didn't understand basic simple concept
@@Redery001 No, it's not about the host! The host ask the question that would lead the guest to give him that answer , it's not about the host level of understanding any concepts, but the title of this video is the problem.
@@saifmaher3429 the host was clearly not understanding and kept going back to same question. I saw another part of the interview and he just seemed like hes afraid to be cancelled
No qaht he is saying correct, and as you said Muslim will react differently, yeah are acting differently & they suffering because of that
What is a non-religious jew ? It's like saying a non religious Christian. If you identify by a religion you're religious by definition. Or am I not understanding English?
Damn he really called everyone else a gentile
It’s not an insult though.
The Jews calling non-Jews the Goy (Gentile), while the Arabs calling non-Arab the Ajam. Every Friday prayers the Imam will mention in "Selawat Taslim" between the 2 sermons.
@@KrimzunFlarebut it is 😉 It could be true that this Rabbi did not mean to use it as an insult, but they all know the real definition of it. And considering he’s not a layman but a rabbi, that word slipped out of his mouth rather casually.
@sleepx3651 not all Jews hold the same view about the inferiority of the Gentile soul. The biggest instance of this is Moses Maimonides
Al Wala to ally and associate and Al Bara to disown and keep away. in otherwords wala to islam and muslims and bara to kufr and kaafireen. The rabbi didnt touch on this principle in this clip.
this murtad interviewer cant understand the plain talk of the rabbi lol
Where did they get this joker interviewer from
2 evils 😈
The host talks too much and doesnt make sense.
Al wala wal bara is a Khariji concept. Thanks for exposing yourself.
This claim of yours is false, denying the Quran, blasphemy, read Ali Imran Verse 118, Maida 51
"Verily, we are free from you and whatever you worship besides Allâh: we have rejected you, and there has started between us and you hostility and hatred for ever until you believe in Allâh Alone" - 60:4
Repent from your atheism before death comes knocking on the door.
?????????????????????????????????????????
Wrong!
LOL WHAT? Bruh, read the Qu'ran please.
Respect to the Jewish believer.
Interviewing Muslim doesn't have genuine understanding of Orthodox Islam. He is pretty secular in his views