the way they're singing live, but their voices are so stable and powerful that it almost feels like it’s recorded, they ate the CD with RED VELVET OUR VOCAL QUEENS
It's really impressive for a rookie to have this live singing stability. They were trained so hard for this. Maybe it's really true that SM artists were trained to sing while running on a treadmill. Good job girls you all did so well. ❤
@@celesteponce2261 its normal to have backtrack tho nowadays to filter out the unstable vocal during singing+dancing... but sometimes yes the backtrack is too lound that the idols vocal sink but its not their fault
@arya Wiratama singing live+back track. I think its not pre recorded like their live stage before. When i could hear ningning breath so clear and giselle out of breath sometimes
The vocals sound too flawless to not be pre-recorded, or at least that’s how it sounds like to me. I think sometimes this is producer’s decision rather than the artists’. But if they were indeed singing live then darn, they are so talented.
They're all main vocals but Today they didn't sing Live. Its a pre-recorded Vocals, which made the perf "sounds" Live due to the breathing voice etc. I hope they will sing Live tomorrow since its Mucore~
@@Mrsange-mw4qr this is obviously live.. yes ofc they would use backtrack during the chorus.. but if u compare the verses you clearly can hear the difference between the recorded and pre-record version.. they sound so different.. and you can clearly hear them breathing
@@jenxning8743 I highly believe that being called an ace in kpop is because of being well rounded idol. She's not just visual, she is a stable singer and dancer. She can even surpass any main vocalist out there because of her stability, plus she is a lead dancer and has so many potential. Kpop is seen as singing while dancing, so being great both in that field at the same time means already so much. All members are great on their own field, but we can't deny who's the real ace here.
Everyone's vocals slay, but there's something about Ningning's voice that especially draws me in. (Edit: Didn't want *some* people misinterpreting my compliment kthx)
@@randomfeeds812 you can obviously tell its live if you are a real fan and been listening to their previous stages tho. These haters are shocked bc queens are too stable.
YES it's live. The vocals are quite different especially Giselle's part, Winter's bridge and Ningning's highnotes. I compared their performance last week and now. I think the only backtrack is the chorus.
Some vocals are pre-recorded, especially the bridge. There's no way there can be live singing can be that heavily processed. The way to know is took if they're supporting from their diaphragm or to see if there's DOUBLE SINGING VOICE. Just compare it with Bilng Bling, Wooah, SKZ, STAYC , ITZY. They have double vocal singing. One - backtrack, two - live singing. Majority of the parts are just one vocal (pre-rec). STAN AESPA STILL! No doubt on their vocals on studio, the argument only revolves around stability now.
@@chedgatchalian8401 well, i know there is still a back track and it was live, but we have to remember that their mics are on and they sang. at this point, i am not doubting their stability because they will not debut in sm if their voices aren't ready
Hatters gonna hate but stars always shinning. How manny hate things hatters gave to them, they will always shinning and slay the stage because they're stars
This is what live singing sounds like. > Breathing could be heard > Their mics moving could be heard > Shakiness of Voices while dancing * So yeah they are singing live. What do you expect? They're from sm.
@@SANDY_JOE sorry but due to their powerful vocals you thought it's prerecorded lmao. this is lready live :) the first week of promotions were precorded but this one and the new ones coming are already live.
@@Ordinarypeople_05 it’s a pre recorded vocals without extra editing. it’s not the right body language of someone who is singing in the higher register.
@@dmnsngie This has nothing to do with being tone-deaf but this is definitely pre-recorded, clear as day 😅 Not that there's anything wrong with it lol I still love them. They just need to be given a real chance to sing live and I'm sure they will slay. Peace ✌️
@@shironeko6164 2nd week promos are live singing what r u talking abt? Didn't you hear Ningning's lil shaky voice when hitting the high note? And Giselle's a lil flat on her part. I could also hear two layers of voices. They didn't sing the chorus and ayayaya part only.
@@dmnsngie it has nothing to do with being a hater, a hater wouldn't spend so much time debating. We are just stating the truth and prevent the 'live vocal' comments get into true haters hand and they start to use this to shame our fandom.
@@shironeko6164 i am not even wearing earphones but i can already tell that their vocals are different from last week, yes the pre record is still there and it was loud, but they sang, literally sang.
ningning highnotes are no joke , winter stable high voice , karina slayed the performance , giselle rap not pre record , that's our queens .. AESPA | MY
Yessss. I don’t know why they keep pushing it. It’s obvious that they sing live. STAN AESPA !! By the way, can you my Full Dance Cover AESPA “Black Mamba”?? Thanks!!
WINTER’S VISUALS WINTER ENDING FAIRY WINTER VOCALS I can see why she’s so popular in korea and why everyone is whipped for her she is definitely a stan attractor
"KARINA IS CHARISMATIC GURL" "GISSELE IS SWAG GURL" "WINTER IS PRETTY GURL n SWEET VOCAL" "NINGNING IS GOLDEN VOCAL n SEXY MAKNAE" AND AESPA IS ROTY!!!!!!!!
This totally live guys not pre-record. You can spot the breathing when gisselle and ning ning sing. And when winter sing bridge her voice change a bit when she dance the lower part of choreo. "Naega anida" part
@@taekookreal7630 lol their pre-recorded vocals last week are too clean compared to this. Also, the volume of audio is constantly changing because of their constant movement.
this is a live performance. they are very good. their voice is stable and the dance is powerful. I also really like today's clothes and beauty. Winter's voice is very stable, ningning with its very stable high notes, stable karina dance, and also deep giselle voice that is stable and her interesting swag style. Really like Aespa's appearance today.
This is totally live it’s just their prerecorded MR is too loud. You can clearly hear Giselle catching up to her lines while dancing and Ningning sang her high note a key lower than the original. Karina is such a doll! Center position secured. Ningning is officially my bias now look at that *maknae on top* attitude!
Y'all can really hear the difference between the stages last week and now. It is obviously live singing when I hear Ningning's "heyeahhhhh" at the bridge. They're just so good to make it sound like a studio version but you can still hear the difference. 2nd week of promo is live singing tho.
I love how Ningning looked at Karina before hitting the high note!! karina even smile at her like a proud mom 🥺
That that karina is my bias and ningning is bias wreaker
@@hey....2483 sameeee
hey I'm a Small RUclipsr and I Have cover Blackpink icecream
please watch it🙏🙏
@@hey....2483 for me it's opposite Ning ning is my bias and karina wrecker
Ningning is my bias and Karina is my bias wrecker!!
By the way, can you my Full Dance Cover AESPA “Black Mamba”?? Thanks!!
they are singing live yet so stable. SM VOCALS Y'ALL
Ikrr..i mean woww!!
They are not actually.. It's prerecorded
@@taekookreal7630 it's confirmed live babe try again
They are not
TaEkOoK rEaL no some parts are different from other times they’ve performed. This obviously doesn’t mean it’s live but it’s very likely it is
ningning's stage presence is no joke. She looks so gorgeous here
yess
no..Because she looks gorgeous everyday
She gives me CEO energy all the time! I love her sm 😭
@@Jennifer-rl5ot thissss! Especially when looked at her previews.. Expensive
Love her!!!!
Winter's hair 😍😍 her expressions , High notes.... is not a joke 😍😍😍❤️ she's so beautiful 😍
Aespa : Ayayayayayaya
Cameraman : *LEMME DANCE TOO GIRLS*
Lmao
Cameramen on crack
LMAO
LMAO
MY GOODNESS SHSHSHSH
Ningning killed the high note. She looks badass with this outfit. I'm in love with her stage presence 👑🔥
Same her facial expressions killed it
Giselle and Winter are ending fairy are not joke.
also
Karina and Ningning are amazing dancer and vocalist
That's why i love Aespa to Stan.
Winter looks so pretty. She looks like a goddess.
the way they're singing live, but their voices are so stable and powerful that it almost feels like it’s recorded, they ate the CD with RED VELVET OUR VOCAL QUEENS
cause it’s recorded, i’m a fan though
@@badgurlvibe7956 their mic is on though
@@badgurlvibe7956 i think its live?
@@badgurlvibe7956 their breath are heard btw :)
It's pre recorded
i really love listening to winter’s “colors”
same >
Can u tell me te
Time*
@@berry-xp8cn 1:29
Me too, her voice sounds lil bit rock
Ningning's HIGHNOTE gave goosebumps, yes lets show those haters how powerful aespa is
Hey I'm a Small RUclipsr and I Have cover Blackpink icecream
please watch it🙏🙏
Ningning has such a beautiful voice 😍😌
Winter's visual is so charismatic^^
SM ARTISTS NCT and AESPA killing us with their stable live vocals omg. Stan them, yall.
seriously. choreo too. they are whole packages.
Yeah our vocalist really sound so stable
hey I'm a Small RUclipsr and I Have cover Blackpink icecream
please watch it🙏🙏
All sm Artist has stable vocals
Also super junior and TVXQ. Their legends 👍
It's really impressive for a rookie to have this live singing stability. They were trained so hard for this. Maybe it's really true that SM artists were trained to sing while running on a treadmill. Good job girls you all did so well. ❤
they are eating cd for whole meal,aespa's vocal is not joke
They sing so well, but always they make playback. Is obviously, but is not their fault, the problem is SM.
How is it their fault? The label is just looking out for their artists.
@@celesteponce2261 its normal to have backtrack tho nowadays to filter out the unstable vocal during singing+dancing... but sometimes yes the backtrack is too lound that the idols vocal sink but its not their fault
@arya Wiratama singing live+back track. I think its not pre recorded like their live stage before. When i could hear ningning breath so clear and giselle out of breath sometimes
yoksi our queen
2:23 Karina smiling to NingNing like she tells, "That's my favorite part, sweetie"..😄
her wink made me faint 😭😭
She’s acts like a mom for them she was like *come on you can do it mommy is with you sweetie*
SM vocal is no joke
Ning Ning is 4th generation vocal Queen
I literally just realised, the vocal line is WinNing.
WINNING LOL
And ShinNING!!
Hey I'm a Small RUclipsr and I Have cover Blackpink icecream
please watch it🙏🙏
Yeah winter sound so stable at the bridge part
EW NOOOO ALL NINGNING USES IS AUTO TONE SHE HAS NO REAL TALENT WINTER IS 4TH GEN VOCAL QUEEN
Winter sounds exactly like recorded version
She is just unbelievable
Visual ace
The vocals for this performance are pre-recorded... I'm also a fan but let's not convince everyone these vocals are real live vocals when they're not
Visual with talent indeed.
@@ubergamer2010 It's live. Go check their mr removed. The creator said that the previous performances were pre-recorded but this one isn't.
The vocals sound too flawless to not be pre-recorded, or at least that’s how it sounds like to me. I think sometimes this is producer’s decision rather than the artists’. But if they were indeed singing live then darn, they are so talented.
Gowon Gang “Im also a fan but-“ nice try.
To anyone who doesn’t believe that they did the vocals live... Watch them sing in the car park video.
They really are singing mostly live.
Yeahhh..that a prove
link pls
But we need to hear them sing live on stage while dancing 💃🏻
@@bobuwu8080 this is live
@@sitihajar4788 This isn't live and it's fine. They are rookies after all
Winter has a beautiful face which is so fantastic that she can fit in any concept.
true
karina's stage presence is on another level.
SM really do be serving CD's and Studios as their food. We stan stable queens.
Don't forget SM water...
sm give them cd and water that taste like water😂😂😂
Frrr
Itz pre-recorded
This is not Live.... Hopefully in mucore though
Their voice is stable. Do not worry about ÆSPA vocals, I suspect they are all main vocals!!!
Lipsing stupid 😂😂😂
They're all main vocals but Today they didn't sing Live. Its a pre-recorded Vocals, which made the perf "sounds" Live due to the breathing voice etc. I hope they will sing Live tomorrow since its Mucore~
@@Mrsange-mw4qr this is obviously live.. yes ofc they would use backtrack during the chorus.. but if u compare the verses you clearly can hear the difference between the recorded and pre-record version.. they sound so different.. and you can clearly hear them breathing
@@Mrsange-mw4qr are u high?
@Sandra wdym
Winter isn't just a visual, she's an ace
Her last Hey Mamba in the end of song, omg, that so great
@@vynguyenrhm I think all members are an ace
@@jenxning8743 can't we just praise winter alone?
@@prasadgodi5086 I never say anything bad about winter she's my bias I just said my opinion is there something wrong?
@@jenxning8743 I highly believe that being called an ace in kpop is because of being well rounded idol. She's not just visual, she is a stable singer and dancer. She can even surpass any main vocalist out there because of her stability, plus she is a lead dancer and has so many potential. Kpop is seen as singing while dancing, so being great both in that field at the same time means already so much. All members are great on their own field, but we can't deny who's the real ace here.
I'm living for Winter ending fairy... She's so unreal.
So pretty
Wow I didn't expected that Giselle would came with her bangs. She's getting prettier. And that WinSelle ending fairy is just...😭🔥
yesss ! giselle with bangs is a goddess !
I do GISELLE & WINTER makeup tutorial on my channel. check it out !
Nobody is going to talk about how good there stylists is for this stage.
Everyone literally look so good especially ningning im dhsjsjs
@@ainasya5041 which one is ningning
@@antifragile-tz7oh the one with black straight hair
@@ainasya5041 thank you
@@antifragile-tz7oh 2:22 es ella.
winter is the definition of being stunningly, beautiful, and talented
Everyone's vocals slay, but there's something about Ningning's voice that especially draws me in.
(Edit: Didn't want *some* people misinterpreting my compliment kthx)
Same! I lover her vocals so much ❤️
seduced? she's underage
Especially those long IJEEEEEEEE part
i love her vocals too♡
You can't use 'seduce' word. This song is not even sexy oke.
they're all qualified as main dancer, vocalist, and visual..Only AESPA can do that y'all stan them✊
blackpink have all that too? um 🧐🧐
@@frzrsgf6224 pls this is aespa, sure blackpink are too, but pls respect aespa okay?
@@cassandrajahnke5892 why yall always have to drag another group in especially blackpink when aespa fans just tryna praise their girlss. Just shhhh 🤫
@@cassandrajahnke5892 em.... this is aespa dear not blackpink 😁 sure blavkpink are too, but pls respect
You right no need to drag BP in here so y’all better not drag BP or disrespect them and aespa is killing it
The fact they are singing live really left me shock. their vocals are so stable for rookie omg. INDEED AESPA ROTY AESPA MONSTER ROOKIE
Are they singing liveee for real? I was shocked at first too it sounded the same in their other performance. They're stableeeee tho. No wonder
@@pacumachaibeae.2494 yes it is live
@@pacumachaibeae.2494 some parts sound really different from last week
it's seems like pre record 🤔
@@someone-bq5rt its NOT. this is their 2nd week and all idols will sing live
Winter is the original visual in Aespa, period.🥰
They are singing live. Their vocals are so stable. Stan aespa, y'all.
im not hating btw its prerecorded :(. i hope SM let them sing live :(
Really is it really live? I don't think so, i don't know if they are too good, but i think it's prerecorded
It's prerecord :) . But Aespa did well
it's pre recorded :"(
@@jennerkim1988 i think it's really live. You can spot the difference when winter bridge her voice change a bit cause of the lower movement
Why is Giselle so underappreciated? She's literally so beautiful and she shines dude😭😭
yesssssss she caught my attetion all the timeeeeeeeeeee
on point, dud3 😭
Give them some time they just debuted, she'll definitely have her time to shine
YESSS
I KNOW RIGHT!!
Ningning's Stage Presence, charisma , Vocal & Dance is one of Best for Real 👍💕
I agree
he looks a lot like jennie balckpink
@@ulyanurizzatun6987 she*
Winter stage presence ! She’s so gooood
Aespa: *ayayayayayaya*
Cameraman: **starts dancing with them**
Best comment 😂😂😂
cameraman on crack at 1:57
lmaoo
Lmao
Lol
The fact that they are singing live and their voices are so stable. As expected, SM vocals.
Winter: unreal, goddess, angel, icon, breathtaking, princess, queen, prettiest, most elegant, gorgeous ALL OF THEM
Ningning looks more confident here. She's shining.
Ikr
Shiningning
May bc these outfits are lowkey more confortable
@@chip_t her hairstyle too, her hair is just flowy here and her make up is not so strong but she is the one that is strong
Ningning's stage presence is on another level. Ningning Ace, Ningning Queen!
SHE IS NOT AN ACE SHE CANT EVEN SING,DANCE OR RAP 😒 KARINA,WINTER AND GISELLE ARE ACES
@@Realaccount29l993 she's the main vocalist ehehhehe
@@Realaccount29l993 LMAO a pressed Ningning hater here! Ningning's the multitalented Queen and Ace of Aespa sorry not sorry
Where are the haters who were waiting for their live? Look at these talented queens. SM main vocal of K-pop.
those haters is insecure now. aespa slap them so hard !
I do GISELLE & WINTER makeup tutorial on my channel. check it out !
Agree %100
they keep telling that this is pre recorded even tho im sure they hear the mic is on. but they wont accept that lolll
Couldn't agree more
I mean they're such beautiful and talented girls
@@randomfeeds812 you can obviously tell its live if you are a real fan and been listening to their previous stages tho. These haters are shocked bc queens are too stable.
YES it's live. The vocals are quite different especially Giselle's part, Winter's bridge and Ningning's highnotes. I compared their performance last week and now. I think the only backtrack is the chorus.
SO STABLE AND STRONG
I am not even wearing headphones and i can already tell that they really are singing live
We don't need earphones to hear that it's live. We ain't deaf like haters
Some vocals are pre-recorded, especially the bridge. There's no way there can be live singing can be that heavily processed. The way to know is took if they're supporting from their diaphragm or to see if there's DOUBLE SINGING VOICE.
Just compare it with Bilng Bling, Wooah, SKZ, STAYC , ITZY. They have double vocal singing. One - backtrack, two - live singing. Majority of the parts are just one vocal (pre-rec). STAN AESPA STILL! No doubt on their vocals on studio, the argument only revolves around stability now.
@@chedgatchalian8401 well, i know there is still a back track and it was live, but we have to remember that their mics are on and they sang. at this point, i am not doubting their stability because they will not debut in sm if their voices aren't ready
Winter voice and visual is EVERYTHING
Hatters gonna hate but stars always shinning. How manny hate things hatters gave to them, they will always shinning and slay the stage because they're stars
they slap those haters with their talent !
I do GISELLE & WINTER makeup tutorial on my channel. check it out !
Hey I'm a Small RUclipsr and I Have cover Blackpink icecream
please watch it🙏🙏
@@RebClaire29 are they got the first win?
@@yejinimmm5004 no
@@faezesh1235 its been 11 days?
This is what live singing sounds like.
> Breathing could be heard
> Their mics moving could be heard
> Shakiness of Voices while dancing
* So yeah they are singing live. What do you expect? They're from sm.
I couldnt hear their breathing ?
@@kiwiiyqlos5788 You have a bad ears hahahahaha
@@kiwiiyqlos5788 listen to it again with max volume. I'm not even wearing earphones but I can hear it.
@@kiwiiyqlos5788 it means that you are deaf lol
@@kiwiiyqlos5788 im not even using my earphone but i heard their breathings. u have a problem bruh
Haters forgot that SM makes their trainees sing while running on a treadmill. This shouldnt be a shock to anyone.
For real??
wow, well their training is paying off with amazing vocals!
@@valentinaodriozola2103 Everyone Know how sm trained there artist with their technique
@@SANDY_JOE they're used pre-recorded while they first stage at hot debuted, its normal for rookies but now they're singing live
@@SANDY_JOE sorry but due to their powerful vocals you thought it's prerecorded lmao. this is lready live :) the first week of promotions were precorded but this one and the new ones coming are already live.
Winter’s visual is so ethereal >~
Who is the most stable member in your group in live singing?
Aespa: YES.
well.. it’s prerecorded so yes
@@clique7417 no it's live vocal
@@clique7417 no . It's live lol . They do pre record after 1 week .
@@Ordinarypeople_05 it’s a pre recorded vocals without extra editing. it’s not the right body language of someone who is singing in the higher register.
@@clique7417 stay pressed. But its LIVE
SM BE LIKE:
LEMME FLEX MY ARTIST'S VOCALS AND LET THEM SING LIVE AND MAKE EVERY HUMAN A BLACK MAMBA.
Just wait and someone will say that this is pre-recorded ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ aespa's vocal literally made their haters tone deaf ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@dmnsngie This has nothing to do with being tone-deaf but this is definitely pre-recorded, clear as day 😅 Not that there's anything wrong with it lol I still love them. They just need to be given a real chance to sing live and I'm sure they will slay. Peace ✌️
@@shironeko6164 2nd week promos are live singing what r u talking abt? Didn't you hear Ningning's lil shaky voice when hitting the high note? And Giselle's a lil flat on her part. I could also hear two layers of voices. They didn't sing the chorus and ayayaya part only.
@@dmnsngie it has nothing to do with being a hater, a hater wouldn't spend so much time debating. We are just stating the truth and prevent the 'live vocal' comments get into true haters hand and they start to use this to shame our fandom.
@@shironeko6164 i am not even wearing earphones but i can already tell that their vocals are different from last week, yes the pre record is still there and it was loud, but they sang, literally sang.
ningning highnotes are no joke ,
winter stable high voice ,
karina slayed the performance ,
giselle rap not pre record ,
that's our queens .. AESPA | MY
Winter es demasiado hermosa, su voz y presencia, su estilo de baile, todo me encanta, enserio es muy bella.
If you’re not still convinced that this is live. You better let them win to hear how great their voices are.
Yes haters should vote for them 😜
yes true, this is too good to be live specially that they're still rookies
Who win today
Yes we need an encore stage to choke the haters.
Yessss. I don’t know why they keep pushing it. It’s obvious that they sing live. STAN AESPA !!
By the way, can you my Full Dance Cover AESPA “Black Mamba”?? Thanks!!
Still cant take my eyes off Karina + Their vocals are so stable wow
This is insane
They singing live and they sounded like the studio version. Yesss this girls are from SM, no doubt..
Winter serving S Class visuals.
WINTER’S VISUALS WINTER ENDING FAIRY WINTER VOCALS I can see why she’s so popular in korea and why everyone is whipped for her she is definitely a stan attractor
True
yes she isss I watch aespa because of her, and then I eventually became a MY
WINTER SOUNDS THE SAME OR EVEN BETTER LIVE, I'M SO AMAZED LIKE GIRL YOU'RE ALREADY AN ACE, WHAT DO YOU WANT FROM US? OUR HEARTS? OK, HERE, TAKE IT 👉❤️
No Its not prerecorded
@@SANDY_JOE dude, it's live, watch the mr removed
@dxichi I am not saying %100 living performance but not %100 prerecorded ı know differences between raw vocal and prerecorded
@@SANDY_JOE
Pre-recorded or not, it is still their vocals 😁😁😁
NINGNING IS GORGEOUS AF AND HER VOCAL SLAYYYYY
those highnotes tho... stable queen
Queen slayed
winter hair is the best in this era and especially this outfit, im still waiting for winter comeback with long hair😭
okay karina is serving us both visual and talent.
STAN AESPA!! FIGHTING AESPA!!
Not yall saying this is pre recorded when it's live 🙄 yall just aren't ready to face the fact that aespa is beyond your expectation💜🌙⭐🦋
Haters be saying it's pre-recorded yet we can see the girls breath heavily
they slap those haters with their talent indeed. Haters are shaking !
I do GISELLE & WINTER makeup tutorial on my channel. check it out !
aespa made haters' insanity go brrrrr ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
Very true 💗
Just proves that Aespa’s voice are unbelievable. Haters can just eat their words.
Vocals, performance, and visuals are overwhelming.
Winter is unbelievable 😍 in Black Mamba and every song 🎵 😉♥️
THEIR VOCALS ARE SO STABLE, HOLY SHIT.
is it live?? their vocal is greatt tho
@@seanaedwin7273 Yes it's live show😭
@@oumdy are you sure? This is live?
@@asninurhayati05 iya mba live
@@asninurhayati05 You can hear Ning Ning's voice slightly swaying in her part.
Popular Opinion:
Aespa is the CD
they are eating CD's!!! I guess that's what SM artists do for their hobby lol
i can’t take my eyes off karina she’s unbelievable her moves hit different no wonder she’s the center and the main dancer
1:57 idk whether i want to laugh or cry
😂
@@sofiarusanova4431 I- 😂
I couldn’t breathe
He wanted to be a part of it too.
🤣🤣
Giselle ending faiiryyyyu
I'm always anticipating Karina's smile during Ningning's highnote. So precious.
WINTER ENDING FAIRY SO GORG
Karina just has unwavering confidence.
Ningning looks beyond pretty with that hair style!
FOR REALLLLL! Sm should let her hair down more often
@@user-zu5bw7qx6b yes yes yes i love to see that!
Karina's body proportion is totally SNSD type. Hope they will get bigger than SNSD some day as their successor
Hello সাদিয়া
Yeah!
Karina's body goals
Apu are you Bengali?
Bengali?
Now say it with me, "you CANNOT touch SM artists when it comes to vocals." 💅✨
Upupp🤭
Tama Yan bebe
Hey I'm a Small RUclipsr and I Have cover Blackpink icecream
please watch it🙏🙏
1:58 the camera man wants to dance too 😭❤️
Karina breathes PERFECTION God blessed her
Music Bank: Girls you're singing live today.
aespa: make it everyday.
this is not PR? wow they're killin it🔥
@@saelasetyawati2326 no it's live vocals. Live singing but a pre-recorded performance for a Live Show. Hope that makes sense. 😊
hey I'm a Small RUclipsr and I Have cover Blackpink icecream
please watch it🙏🙏
winter is the prettiest girl, just look at her.
they all is pretty. but winter is on another level !
I do GISELLE & WINTER makeup tutorial on my channel. check it out !
winter and giselle as ending fairies, visual attack
"KARINA IS CHARISMATIC GURL"
"GISSELE IS SWAG GURL"
"WINTER IS PRETTY GURL n SWEET VOCAL"
"NINGNING IS GOLDEN VOCAL n SEXY MAKNAE"
AND
AESPA IS ROTY!!!!!!!!
You had me when ning ning is the sexy maknae
Yeah winter sound so stable and her voice is so beautiful
I'm even more convinced that the SM cafeteria is only full of CDs...
Karina's smile when NingNing look at her before NingNing hit tge note is so cute
Wow that was so cute😃
Winter era Black Mamba dengan rambut panjang menurut ku paling cantik
KBS ending the performance off with Winter is probably the best thing they did.
Exactly!
Hey I'm a Small RUclipsr and I Have cover Blackpink icecream
please watch it🙏🙏
Their visuals, outfits, vocals, expressions are🔥🔥
Karina looks like a Barbie doll!!!!!
This totally live guys not pre-record. You can spot the breathing when gisselle and ning ning sing. And when winter sing bridge her voice change a bit when she dance the lower part of choreo. "Naega anida" part
You can hear their breath in prerecorded too lol
@@taekookreal7630 how about at 1:40 when ningning take a breath?
AESPA serving both visual & vocal right !
I do GISELLE & WINTER makeup tutorial on my channel. check it out !
Also the high notes of Ningning in bridge is shaky.
@@taekookreal7630 lol their pre-recorded vocals last week are too clean compared to this. Also, the volume of audio is constantly changing because of their constant movement.
No one debuts like this anymore, the talent!!!!
this is a live performance. they are very good. their voice is stable and the dance is powerful. I also really like today's clothes and beauty. Winter's voice is very stable, ningning with its very stable high notes, stable karina dance, and also deep giselle voice that is stable and her interesting swag style. Really like Aespa's appearance today.
Winter is a long waited IDOL for us. Why? Because she can do everything
Visual
Dance
Sing
Entertain
She is the whole package idol that we wait to see
Actually all of them though
Not rap but karina can do
hey I'm a Small RUclipsr and I Have cover Blackpink icecream
please watch it🙏🙏
OMG this is LIVE singing now?
2:24 Karina's smile to NingNing saying: "Yes girl! Sing!"
Proud sister
winter‘s ending is really wonderful
Im proud of their live voices ! Sm vocals never disappointing. Ningning + winter vocal bring synergies 🔥🔥🔥
Their voices are so freaking stable, you cant tell apart whether this is live or not. Sm’s groups never disappoint.
This is totally live it’s just their prerecorded MR is too loud. You can clearly hear Giselle catching up to her lines while dancing and Ningning sang her high note a key lower than the original.
Karina is such a doll! Center position secured. Ningning is officially my bias now look at that *maknae on top* attitude!
Winter reminds me about ROSÉ. Both are hidden ace. Just like diamonds 💕
Aespa really said mics on, so haters who say they cant sing let this be the video that will slap you.
KARINA BEST GIRL
GISELLE BEST GIRL
WINTER BEST GIRL
NINGNING BEST GIRL
AESPA BEST GIRLS :D
Y'all can really hear the difference between the stages last week and now. It is obviously live singing when I hear Ningning's "heyeahhhhh" at the bridge. They're just so good to make it sound like a studio version but you can still hear the difference. 2nd week of promo is live singing tho.
Winter's Voice is a way of life 👌