GEM is the best! She has the complete package! By far she has been the most consistent singer in this show in terms of ranking. She consistently delivered what she has planned and this is professionalism.
What a great show!! 邓紫棋做了一个超高难度的表演，坐着又彈还要唱又長又高的音，技巧、气量和琴藝少一点都不行，唱得很Blue，很有味道，她的歌声唱这種歌很有優勢； 韓磊这首唱到情感点上了，很抓人。外傳他唱破音，根本沒这回事，他用了比較滄桑的腔去唱，並不是什么破音，那些人到底懂不懂？ 張杰本是不錯，但事實上出了大問題，反正有一段沒了詞，可惜一点也得現實，因為每一个都唱得很好； 張宇这一塲强差人意，有几个地方的音控制不好，而且这種唱法不太適合他； 茜拉一貫的穏，很难出問題，除非特別出色的才能超越她； 動力火車高音很準，兩个人很有墨契，是精采的表演，只有一点点節奏上的問題和唱漏一点点的詞，不太明顯； 周笔暢可以說是精采的表演，但唱得並不是很突出。 个人認為排名：邓紫棋－韓磊－茜拉－動力火車－周笔暢－張宇－張杰。
i like 张杰. his actually very honest about his feeling towards every performance. he truly loves music and respect everyone. i don't think his treating this as a competition but more like a platform to meet other singers :) and i respect that. 张杰 go go go!
紫棋, you're always on my mind the absolutely best singer. You never give up since the beginning you attend this show until today. Great - I support you forever! Greatest love of Switzerland.
I must say that Jason is such a gentleman! He has what it takes to be a star. On stage and off stage. His personality will win over many hearts. This is a grate show...introduced to the world many talented young artists like GEM and Jason. Brought back the charm of older ones like Han Lei - classic! Helped showcase a young super talent from Malaysia. At the end of the day it is not the singing but the personality that will win BIG time!
Han Lei is just incredible, I feel that he's the only one in competition who just does things his own way instead of trying too hard to please the audience. He has his own taste, and you can just see the difference age and experience can bring to a singer. simply amazing. I can feel every new thing he is trying is for himself. Besides his wife is soo freakkkiiin BeautifulLL!! Dayyyuum!!! you're the MAN Han LEi!!!
I like his other performance except this BeiJing BeiJing, a bit not suitable for his voice. His voice is too grande for this lonely song. However, I have to say that he is still the best singer technically in this competition. And, I predict, he or GEM will take no 1 spot this season.
Please, Power Station 动力火车 deserves so much more recognition. They are living proof that their singing talent and ability does not depreciate with age. I remember listening to their songs when I was a little kid. (I'm a 91' kid) and I still am listening and loving their music! I love how they always stay true to the genre of music they love. I hope more people can pay attention to their vocals and appreciate their music. 加油，动力火车！
BiBi has tried very hard to beat G.E.M. and this time she came so close. I am afraid she has exhausted all the tricks. Good try anyway. Shila's voice is more like Camomile from Japan. She is kind of album singer than a concert artist. She doesn't have the high pitch as G.E.M. but she certainly can sing into your heart, so soft and smooth. Zhang Jie is very talented and entertaining, and he does have a beautiful voice despite lacking certain virility. I like his attitude and effort though. Han Lei is very good, skillful and always touching but I am afraid the younger ages may not share the same inmost feeling as the mature groups. Chang Yu, the most entertaining and the funniest singer among all. Actually I like him a lot for his unique voice and interpretation of most songs. I am glad he made it to the final round. Power Station, what can I say ? I can imagine how much I enjoy listening to their albums in my spare time, so harmonized and relaxing. Unfortunately they are a little less appealing as other front runners in terms of putting a good show in front of audience. And finally, G.E.M.. If I have a chance to choose an artist among these seven to represent as a manager for show business, I wouldn't waste a second to take G.E.M.. Why ? Because she is the most versatile one in terms of multi talents like singing slow as well as up-bit songs. She can dance, she can play piano with sophisticated skills while singing. She can sing Cantonese, Mandarin as well as English songs equally well, which let me take her anywhere to perform even in places like Les Vegas, London, and most cities in Asia. Her ability in arousing audience is amazing, which makes her the darling for concert shows. And her youth and beauty, my God, that is why within so little time she can develop a huge fan base out of no where in China. However, I have a hunch she may not be able to win it all in the " I Am A Singer" show at the end for some reason, top three may be. Then everyone will be happy. Right ?
Why GEM impresses other is not only because of her high-quality performance, but also because her performance is quite diversified at the same time. Although everybody has tried to that, but GEM balances the best.
Really proud that GEM was able to grab first place once again! I agree that Shila has a very powerful and skillful voice, however from all her performances so far I haven't felt WOW from her..there seems to be a lack of climax in her performances.
The result matches completely with my expectation. Below is my personal comment on the rank (again, I am not trying to deteriorate the voting result, but to show a bit analysis) 1. GEM: For those who commented on her high notes are annoying, I am in fact quite supportive to GEM. I believe in the past a few episodes, people raised doubt on her due to her high note breaking. GEM this time brought a completely technical performance, is really just to prove her singing skill is comparable to Shila, and her high notes are crystal clear. No matter you like her singing style or not, the doubt on her singing capability is clear gone. I think GEM only needed to demonstrate this before the final round, which she did it perfectly well.I don't expect she will preserve and bring this singing style to the final. One more comment, singing an English song, and as a 1st performer, she definitely deserved 1st place. 2.Han Lei: I do not need to comment any more on Han Lei's singing skill. As the last episode stated, he is not just a singer, but a musician. This song probably will not be understood by younger group. In addition, the song "Beijing Beijing", singing in another city Chang Sha...I personally do not think the audience can really feel it... Again, as Han Lei's statement, he does not really care about the ranking, he just wanted to achieve his unfinished musical dream; 3. Jason Zhang: Really needed to give him a thumb up. Very good attitude, he had upset stomach but he still finished it perfectly well. The B-box was creative, with his body movement. I think he is making a break through and I would say it is a success. Good job, good attitude Jason! The good attitude will add mark to your attraction. 4. Shila: I watched 3 times of her performance along with the entire interview. I really had to say, this performance was not quite impressive. There had no break through and no change in the singing style. Yes she is very skillful but she is too conservative on the stage. She needs to bring something new. But the 2nd and 3rd time I watched her performance, and think of her family, and to achieve her singing dream she came all the way to China as a single non-Chinese speaker, is bravo. She is bravo, the audience may not even vote for her because she is not local. I almost cried when i listened carefully with her song, it in fact has strong emotion. For those saying they can not feel her song, you need to listen by heart. Do not put too much stress on yourself Shila, I think you are already very successful in China. 5.Power Station: I do agree they made great progress, I personally even think their performance was better than Zhang Yu's. Their attitude is back and compared to last episode when they showed a little bit scared to compete. This time, they totally freed themselves. Power Station's failure is due to multiple reasons. One of it is the song chosen. Zhang Yu commented the song as everyone known, in fact I never felt familiar with this song. Only had a little bit memory of listening it somewhere. I believe is a Taiwanese local song, which the audience probably were not familiar at all. 6. Bibi: I gotta say I never liked her (more because of the personality). But her performance in episode 8 was really good "Shi Jian Dou Qu Naer Le". This time, she was quite impressive as well. She controlled the entire stage, everybody stood up. I had to say she did make a great job, especially the part she played the instrument, which showed how much effort she put into this performance. I think ranking 2nd is fair, if she ranks 1st I believe she may got attacked by too many people, so 2nd place is a good position.
See wht u wrote this comment u mst get many benefit from the winner. Everything in my expectations. .so funny. .like tht find out the lost plane from Malaysia. U totally like malaysia momoh.
bryan tan your comment doesn't sound too friendly. I hope that is not because I commented my own PERSONAL opinion toward Shila. It is a TV show, not a competition between 2 nations.
Agee with you. Though I love Shila to death, I do think that she needs to try new songs to break through her singing styles. I feel that she performed much better when she was competing at Asian Wave, way more relaxed. To me, she was underperformed singing "FOREVER LOVE" last Fri. She sang this song so beautifully and in a simpler version(which I preferred) at Shanghai's Asian Wave. She sang it so happily like she was falling in love(with Lee Hom, I did feel that way haha), that was the Best version(do search in youtube Shila Forever Asian Wave). Her emotion was too sad for this song last Fri. Gem is so versatile, she deserve to be No.1 last week, she did nail "Falling". I think she could win this competition.
technical singing means "yelling" high notes? so children below the age of 9 are all amazing technical singers...its an r&b song, constant high notes just ruined it for me. It felt like she was trying too hard and didn't fit the soulful groove.
GEM is amazingly good in this performance. Bibi's voice is not strong and I don't really enjoy her performance at all, but she's from China and was the last performer for the night (compared to Gem who sang first), so i'm very proud that Gem still managed to beat Bibi, and this is her fourth time getting #1 :)
G.E.M. sounded a lot like Alicia Keys. However, she added her own twist. Also, she was supposed to scream because the song contained a lot of screaming, and G.E.M. controlled it very well. Shila did pretty good, because she was worrying about her family.
這一期的確很棒，特別是紫棋和韓磊大哥，紫棋是香港人的驕傲，現今香港年輕歌手沒人能敵，加油！！！
因為這個舞台，認識到大陸原來有張杰這麼出色的一個歌手，以前在康熙看過，現在好多了，跟Gem不分上下，人品丶表現丶造型跟台風，整個態度真的很敬業，非常棒👍👍👍👍👍
突然覺得這不是來看名次的比賽,而是透過這比賽看出每位歌手私下的人品跟態度~幸好台灣的歌手態度都挺不錯的~排名已不是重點啦(由觀眾投票的比賽,因為各有自己支持的對象跟喜好的音樂風格,名次未必代表歌手實力阿~~ )
这次高手云集现场乐队现场观众气氛浓烈，歌手们都很棒，遇强则强碰撞出火花。
张杰挺棒的！
邓紫棋新一代歌后。。。话语乐坛终于迎来了新一代，可喜可贺。。。。哈哈哈
周笔畅与邓紫棋不在一个等量级上，她把邓紫棋视为对手完全是搞错了或说自视过高（她应知道茜拉才是邓紫棋的真正对手），视频中也似乎有零星但不少的佐证。但，因为她为茜拉喊“加油”就说她嫉妒邓紫棋太有那么点儿“贼的眼中都是贼”的味道！
Yuqi Gao 重要是周筆沒有茜拉和鄧的台型，很難沖出中國。
這世上有一種人, 是為了襯托別人的好而存在的, 這種人還必須有 "不知自己斤兩" "心胸狹窄"的特色, 很明顯在這節目裡 這樣的人是~~周筆暢
@Yiliang Yuan
說得太好了, 周筆暢把鄧紫棋視為對手, 實在是不自量力的最佳寫照, 另外【 補充說明】 : (我的觀察)周筆暢之所以沒有把席拉視為對手並為之加油, 主因是 席拉 曾經 答應和周互換出場席, (第幾期我忘了), ....(好像還有一期, 鄧因為經常抽到第一位出場, 所以後來好不容易不是第一位出場就不願意換??????) 從這裡更可以看出周筆暢的小鼻子小眼心思. 實在沒什麼大將風範
周筆暢真的只是湖南衛視的保障名額，在整個十場比賽下來，她實在是最不值得一提的歌手。
同感
我觉得G.E.M(邓紫棋)和茜拉素颜的时候,非常地漂亮~
Support GEM~~真的很棒，每次看GEM表演都快看傻眼了，每一首歌曲都用不同的方式演唱，全能歌手，会唱也会写，也会弹钢琴~~超爱你~~加油加油
张杰病了，虽然忘记歌词，可是B-Box那段真的很精彩，而且他一路以来的表现都很好~~希望突围赛能进前三强，加油~~
我喜欢她唱英文歌語音很好
邓紫棋好可爱！！！
我真的很喜欢你的演唱，你是很好👍👍👍
G.E.M 愛死你的聲音..
Gem 怎么不是香港的最佳女歌手，
唱得超正的歌，
呵呵, 生為香港人我都想知道.
她在香港的頒獎禮 連露個臉也沒有
結果讓容祖兒拿到連十年的"歌后"..
我都已經沒興趣看什麼頒獎禮了
香港的樂壇很畸型的，奨是頒給圍內人，就算唱得不好也照頒如宜。新城電台算是中肯，也願為樂壇出力，其他的就不用提，也不用睇或聽了！
yan yip +1
香港有很多很棒的歌手，她只是其中一个。容祖儿的歌唱也是属于one take的她拿可算是名副其实。
+Sam chiu 因为香港讲辈分
GEM's performance was awesome !
邓紫棋太棒了！
超崇拜張杰，因為他竟然不會因為身體的狀況而減低能量，太屌了，因為自己已經流淚了不舒服了，還是希望把最好的聲音獻給觀眾，太厲害了，讚讚讚，我永遠支持你，太棒啦！杰哥讚讚讚讚讚
+1
+1
+1
+1
+1
邓紫棋的这首《Falling》和钢琴自弹自唱真的达到出神入化的境界👍🏻👍🏻
周笔畅就是很明显的嫉妒邓紫棋又美又会唱，从来不说欣赏邓紫棋。只能说她还蛮诚实。
對，笔笔自己也説她是-個蛮拘謹的人，又她在第二場錄影前已对孫堅說: 紫棋是她的對手，而前輩要尊重。到第二場公佈結果時，她得第三時開心了-陣，當宣佈紫棋得第二時，她卽時黑面望著紫棋！大家可重温第二集，就知笔笔重頭至尾都視紫棋為對手，反而紫棋並無當任何人為對手，她高興與高手同台，這点同張杰-樣，我認為紫棋与張杰均有大將風範，都是華語乐壇超班的接班人！
Ophelia xu 看完第二季,才認識周筆暢,也才發現原來網路上說她有多令人討厭..無知,...等等..原來全部都是真的...看到她的畫面都直接快轉,跳過...
她對莤拉說加油 不和gem加油
一是莤拉是新来又是外国人 人缘很好 我觉得也是她真的很喜欢她的声音 但是我感觉重点应该是她觉得莤拉是可以跟邓紫棋抗衡 甚至打败的
Ophelia xu 周笔畅为什么经常和邓紫棋坐在一起，太蠢了，有心机却没心计啊。她难道不知道么，一个是('ω')，一个是( ー _ ー )。
張杰看別人表演和評價時的表情都很真誠XD
我覺得他是真心去欣賞其他人的表演然後去改善自己，很好的態度！
可惜！
張杰有大將之風，享受比賽，懂欣賞對方，不存毀滅扭曲心態。
逼鄧紫棋換歌可能是湖南台支持韓磊的一步棋，但誤把GEM預唱的imagine換走，反而令她換上更考現場功力Soul式唱腔的falling，第一個出場也勝出無礙.
+1 同意 👍👍👍👏👏👏
Kai Kaiwong 可能是吧。我朋友認識節目的製作人。他說韓磊的爸爸是幫忙做這個節目的高層。
@@alice910901 所以你觉得韩磊的实力不配拿冠军吗
@@alice910901 韩磊他爸不是一个退伍士兵吗，充其量算个士官
@@jinshibaij4319 有點實力不用做小動作, 做人做事光明磊落. 這更表現了這個年輕人的👱♀️實力更上一層樓. 所以現在她更勝從前. 要勝過自己這就精彩的人生.
其实第二季我最期待和最关注的始终只有三位就张杰，茜拉和邓紫棋。不过可惜茜拉和张杰进得有点晚不然他们三PK绝对太有看点了。因为实力相当而且人品都很好起码对音乐和对手或长辈态度都很好
同意,這三個我都不熟,但很欣賞他們的態度及面對壓力的處理方式..
明显邓紫棋高出一个级别
GEM就是来证明第一个唱也可以第一的！！
+Joy Jung 没错。第一第二虽然是一票之差，但是是第一个出场与最后一个出场的一票之差。这个前提让大家知道什么叫差距。
+Kaixuan Chen +1 説實話，兩人的差距真的頗大！
周筆暢次次靠搞怪拿高票，穿著難看死了，土氣十足，還竟然有服裝公司找她代言，她自不量力以鄧紫棋當假想邀，這一期居然穿睡衣出場，那些嘉賓評判真是不知所謂也。
Ken Ng 周年纪也不少了，仍要扮小女孩，真難頂！嘩眾取寵！
黄伟 別這樣講，她只是睡過頭穿著睡衣來唱罷了😂😂
邓紫棋先声夺人，开了个好场。韩磊老师接手毫不示弱，情深意动走心了啊！北京可以是任何一座让你梦牵魂绕的城市。很感动！这俩几乎可以驾驭任何一种曲风。张杰的表演其实也很不错。动力火车/酒干倘卖无很好，但是更希望听他们自己的歌曲。
鄧紫琪好可愛~
GEM 的聲音氣勢澎湃 , 濤如雷鳴的呵～
GEM is the best! She has the complete package! By far she has been the most consistent singer in this show in terms of ranking. She consistently delivered what she has planned and this is professionalism.
Totally agree with u!!!
张杰是最好! he is the best always support him!!
張杰, 要不是預先看見' 出情況' , 我感覚你' 抹痕' 高超. 真的幾乎無痕.可能太緊張了. 放鬆,亨受自己和其他同台的演出. 不知是因為' 同道' 還是因為普及.總感到音樂到處有知音, 人才輩出. 太好了.
"...這幾年不要再做女歌手了因為很難干得過她."
In my opinion, that was a huge compliment to 鄧紫琪.
評語雖然真實，但坦率程度令眾歌手不安。
茜拉的眼妝每次都好漂亮
GEM always enjoy all her opponent performance... i can see that she loves music so much.. vote for GEM n SHILA =)
Gem not only perform in high quality but also her dialog is so mature
張杰真的令人心疼
看到他流淚我都驚了
真的是從這節目才認識張杰的
另外GEM唱的超好的!!!!
张杰最棒！我爱死你了！加油！😍
張杰玩命表演，心疼張杰
我覺GEM一直唱都是熱門歌曲, 加上觀眾喜歡聽高音(我也喜歡),所以高分是一定的, 但我覺得韓跟張宇唱的大部份都是老歌或者冷門歌, 唱出他們的人生, 更有味道.
越来越喜欢邓紫棋！人美有实力也大气！韩磊唱得很轻松也很气派！这一期周笔畅的表演让人耳目一新，希望她能放松一下心情，就会更可爱了。不知道怎么，茜拉的歌一直都没引起我的共鸣
What a great show!!
邓紫棋做了一个超高难度的表演，坐着又彈还要唱又長又高的音，技巧、气量和琴藝少一点都不行，唱得很Blue，很有味道，她的歌声唱这種歌很有優勢；
韓磊这首唱到情感点上了，很抓人。外傳他唱破音，根本沒这回事，他用了比較滄桑的腔去唱，並不是什么破音，那些人到底懂不懂？
張杰本是不錯，但事實上出了大問題，反正有一段沒了詞，可惜一点也得現實，因為每一个都唱得很好；
張宇这一塲强差人意，有几个地方的音控制不好，而且这種唱法不太適合他；
茜拉一貫的穏，很难出問題，除非特別出色的才能超越她；
動力火車高音很準，兩个人很有墨契，是精采的表演，只有一点点節奏上的問題和唱漏一点点的詞，不太明顯；
周笔暢可以說是精采的表演，但唱得並不是很突出。
个人認為排名：邓紫棋－韓磊－茜拉－動力火車－周笔暢－張宇－張杰。
totally agree!!!!!!
you are right
i like 张杰. his actually very honest about his feeling towards every performance. he truly loves music and respect everyone. i don't think his treating this as a competition but more like a platform to meet other singers :) and i respect that. 张杰 go go go!
haha couldn't agree more :P
真心觉得周笔畅在这里完全就是浑水摸鱼，她能撑到现在只是因为她在娘家。是她主场而已。这样牺牲掉张宇好心疼啊。
Cheung Sunny 周筆畅很難走红香港，因外型不討好，相反茜拉可以，因相貌甜美，鄧紫棋可以走红内地，因聲，色，藝俱全。
我都贊成以上 講法 不過犧牲的是張傑 不是張宇 張傑唱得實在太好了 真替他可惜
Cheung Sunny 说得太对了！有调音师也显得唱功很一般。而且从细节也感受出她为人不怎么样，整容得再“好看”也无法把内心整善良。
不能再同意妳的看法，周筆暢的歌聲實在跟這十場歌手比起來不在一個水準上。
紫棋, you're always on my mind the absolutely best singer. You never give up since the beginning you attend this show until today. Great - I support you forever! Greatest love of Switzerland.
我挺喜欢韩磊的，虽然很多人说他是因为辈分和资历赢的，但是我喜欢的是他不停挑战，用不同的风格，毕竟前辈歌手风格很难多变，不像年轻歌手，他不能唱着唱着来段舞蹈，或者真的去唱rap，但他依然每场表演都做到极致，都挺不一样，而不仅仅就是靠着自己的声音好，而且他性格好温和，不争不抢，不会整天摆出个大哥大的样子，对后辈好好，邓紫棋啊张杰啊都很敬重他，不仅仅是看着前辈的身份
这一票我当然给 邓紫棋了💙
I must say that Jason is such a gentleman! He has what it takes to be a star. On stage and off stage. His personality will win over many hearts. This is a grate show...introduced to the world many talented young artists like GEM and Jason. Brought back the charm of older ones like Han Lei - classic! Helped showcase a young super talent from Malaysia. At the end of the day it is not the singing but the personality that will win BIG time!
I'm so glad that Zhang Yu was able to make it to the finals!!! Yeah!!!
And I'm so proud of GEM; it's her fourth #1 ranking on the show.
看這集特別歡樂。也特別喜歡張宇、梁翘柏、周笔畅(雖然我是因為聽到GEM的歌才來追的劇。汗。她的歌真的太好聽了!!)但特別提他們是因為他們給我一種「唱歌就是開心」的感覺。唱的人開心，聽的人感動。好難得有這種感覺。我不知道其他人覺得怎麼樣，但我覺得會讓我感動的歌是這樣子唱的。
鄧紫棋超讚！張杰雖然這場不舒服可是也很好啊
虽然张杰总招黑，总被说土，但讲真，他挺帅的，台风不错，唱歌不错，说话风度也不错。而且越来越嫩的迹象。加油！
+1 👍👏
杰哥的態度真的很討人喜歡💞
Yudie Du +90000000000000000000000
在年轻歌手里面，我超爱张杰，邓紫棋，莤拉的态度，是一种很开心的态度在这个台上比赛，虽然他们也很想赢，也有胜负欲，但是表现出来是他们尊重每一位歌手，每一位前辈，态度很乐观很向上，说话很有风度
周笔畅演唱永远都一个样，完全没有变化和突破，不知道凭啥撑到最后，更喜欢邓紫棋！
Shila is blessed with one of the most loving parents on earth. May God bless you in your musical journey, and your grandfather to be healthy and well~
真的很喜歡張杰，即使再怎樣不舒服也能堅持唱下去，無論是對人真誠還是對舞台和觀眾的認真
GEM好厲害。好喜歡GEM和Shila。但是這次為甚麼韓磊拿第5啊？韓磊唱得很好
i like 动力火车very much..他们的声音真的很棒!
还有他们乐观的态度真的值得学习
看得出曹格還有挺喜歡鄧紫棋的，沒當她是對手
張宇，張杰，韋唯也是，其他的就呵呵呵！
现在回来看 周笔畅真的很不错啊 每一场都在突破自己 也从来没有矫情过一次说些场面话 有些人的好是要经过时间 经过对比才慢慢发觉的
張杰不舒服也唱得很好听，很敬业。韩大叔唱北京北京超有feel的，在我心中是第一名。我不是笔笔我Fans ,我覺得在那麼多集中，這期唱得最好听，感覺很high!!我喜歡張宇大哥主持，好好笑。
宇哥每次的名次都这么让人担心呢...不过幸好还是进总决赛了...长舒一口气
好像各歌手若有暗示, 是我多心嗎?
歌手的對話中,
張傑堅持唱是對, 那幾集前GEM唱情人主動叫停了, 代表是什麼 ? 心理質素有問題嗎?
主持要堅持挑出來此問題，反覆問多個歌手又是什麼？
在我看來, 對GEM 是平常心的有張傑及張宇 , 及之後的茜拉
韓磊在前幾集說過 "我不在乎什麼排名, 我那還跟那些小孩爭什麼排名 ? "請大家留意之後他一直拿排名後的面部表情
筆可能是被坑了，ＧＥＭ給她太大壓力，她差不多跟ＧＥＭ那同一條件，筆還是超女第三，本身是唱功承可，樣子亦不錯，
我一直欣賞是GEM 在面對其他人及 整個場面的壓力, 想像她明白大家話中有話，仍要配合大家及保持平常心
她的面部表情一直很完美
我也一直这样认为的呢。紫琪很可爱善良。也觉得她当然都感觉到每个人对她的态度情绪。张宇张杰希拉都是善良同类。
笔笔是超女第二啊
张杰这是咽炎犯了，嗓子干痒了，这是职业病啊，强忍着结果刺激到泪腺了。临危不乱，挺棒的。
看到大家都在罵周筆暢，我就放心了。群眾的眼睛是雪亮的。穿個睡衣配著八線歌手的唱功，也撈能得個名次，只能說她經紀公司手段很厲害。
动力火车真的很棒，看到他们对音乐的真诚和执着。感动，希望他们能继续加油！
Han Lei is just incredible, I feel that he's the only one in competition who just does things his own way instead of trying too hard to please the audience. He has his own taste, and you can just see the difference age and experience can bring to a singer. simply amazing. I can feel every new thing he is trying is for himself. Besides his wife is soo freakkkiiin BeautifulLL!! Dayyyuum!!! you're the MAN Han LEi!!!
I like his other performance except this BeiJing BeiJing, a bit not suitable for his voice. His voice is too grande for this lonely song. However, I have to say that he is still the best singer technically in this competition. And, I predict, he or GEM will take no 1 spot this season.
Please, Power Station 动力火车 deserves so much more recognition. They are living proof that their singing talent and ability does not depreciate with age. I remember listening to their songs when I was a little kid. (I'm a 91' kid) and I still am listening and loving their music! I love how they always stay true to the genre of music they love. I hope more people can pay attention to their vocals and appreciate their music.
加油，动力火车！
So touched by the bond of Shila's family! Shila, dont put too much pressure on yourself!
Shila has so beautiful eyes! I hope she can always sing for audience.
每次上台前都戴美瞳，之前有某次花絮拍到了
BiBi has tried very hard to beat G.E.M. and this time she came so close. I am afraid she has exhausted all the tricks. Good try anyway.
Shila's voice is more like Camomile from Japan. She is kind of album singer than a concert artist. She doesn't have the high pitch as G.E.M. but she certainly can sing into your heart, so soft and smooth.
Zhang Jie is very talented and entertaining, and he does have a beautiful voice despite lacking certain virility. I like his attitude and effort though.
Han Lei is very good, skillful and always touching but I am afraid the younger ages may not share the same inmost feeling as the mature groups.
Chang Yu, the most entertaining and the funniest singer among all. Actually I like him a lot for his unique voice and interpretation of most songs. I am glad he made it to the final round.
Power Station, what can I say ? I can imagine how much I enjoy listening to their albums in my spare time, so harmonized and relaxing. Unfortunately they are a little less appealing as other front runners in terms of putting a good show in front of audience.
And finally, G.E.M.. If I have a chance to choose an artist among these seven to represent as a manager for show business, I wouldn't waste a second to take G.E.M.. Why ? Because she is the most versatile one in terms of multi talents like singing slow as well as up-bit songs. She can dance, she can play piano with sophisticated skills while singing. She can sing Cantonese, Mandarin as well as English songs equally well, which let me take her anywhere to perform even in places like Les Vegas, London, and most cities in Asia. Her ability in arousing audience is amazing, which makes her the darling for concert shows. And her youth and beauty, my God, that is why within so little time she can develop a huge fan base out of no where in China. However, I have a hunch she may not be able to win it all in the " I Am A Singer" show at the end for some reason, top three may be. Then everyone will be happy. Right ?
pee pee sucks
agree, but gem already won, she already open up the china market now
周笔畅要区别于邓紫棋只能走偏锋，比如前几唱唱深情慢歌，真刀真枪怎么都赢不了
Shila to me is a live singer. She is born with the voice to sing live.
I see bibi I feel like pee
Why GEM impresses other is not only because of her high-quality performance, but also because her performance is quite diversified at the same time. Although everybody has tried to that, but GEM balances the best.
Totally agreed
...
张杰。棒棒的
what a father!who can give up everything to make her daughters dream came true.shila加油!!!
So appropriate to sing Forever Love on White Valentines day.
2022還回來重看的🙋🏻♀️第二季實在是太精彩啦，放到現在也不會過時！
同意！2022重看，雖然８年了，但精彩不減！
我是為了G.E.M.再回來看的🥰同時其他人都很好👍
我已经反反复复看了无数遍了
太喜欢汪峰的《北京北京》，每次听都很感动。韩磊唱得太动情了！！！
同意，汪峰的口氣無法超越
最爱GEM
这一轮周笔畅不是以唱功拿到高分的。而我个人，仅仅是我个人，是听唱功。仅就唱功而言，周与邓，周与茜拉有很大的距离，并且这种距离是无法弥补的。
Yiliang Yuan 她只有主场的天時，地利，人和。的优勢！勉強和茜拉，鄧相比，只是国内歌迷一廂情願的想法！
邓紫棋赢在比周笔畅更有魅力！
SHILA, We will always support you~ You fans from MALAYSIA!
張杰好可惜啊！那段B-Box太棒啦！但因為身體方面>
动力火车唱得非常棒，一开口就把我给感动了。超赞的～
I was completely attracted by Shila's eyes!! So beautiful.
希望動力火車 能有軍司幫他們稍微把歌重編下 注入更多新派的元素，帶勁點。 筆筆太有膽了敢玩 勇敢學生 贊！ 韓磊老師 喜歡他每次的演繹， 專業不落俗套。 張宇 是自在的歌手。他有在玩跳框框，有趣好玩。GEM 基本就是優班生，厲害，好聽。張傑 看見他這次無比的執著，處理事故成熟性特強，流著淚都要把歌show完，倔強 我喜歡他的態度，聲音。 西拉 慣用的西方演繹 這次有些切合不錯。 我還是希望她 咬字能努力，音樂上的玩法在多元點。好了這期看見了 比較貼近現實我們生活的呈現。我敢說他們這次都變凡人了。我喜歡這感覺。當然一次就好了。畢竟這還是節目。大夥加油
Really proud that GEM was able to grab first place once again!
I agree that Shila has a very powerful and skillful voice, however from all her performances so far I haven't felt WOW from her..there seems to be a lack of climax in her performances.
个人比较喜欢茜拉的声音,很顺滑的感觉,听得舒服。。。紫棋的高音太尖了感觉是硬喊上去的,不过整体气氛能被带到最高潮。(在这期紫棋唱得那首是不错! 没有特别喜欢哪个歌手,只针对这期我心中前三是:茜拉,紫棋,韩磊)
Jy Summer 是有点，因为邓紫棋高音都是真音，茜拉善用混合音。
韓磊老師的排名應該是前三的，直搗心裡去的一個演繹。在我心中今天的前三是紫棋、韓磊、Shila。
agree!!!!!
The result matches completely with my expectation. Below is my personal comment on the rank (again, I am not trying to deteriorate the voting result, but to show a bit analysis)
1. GEM: For those who commented on her high notes are annoying, I am in fact quite supportive to GEM. I believe in the past a few episodes, people raised doubt on her due to her high note breaking. GEM this time brought a completely technical performance, is really just to prove her singing skill is comparable to Shila, and her high notes are crystal clear. No matter you like her singing style or not, the doubt on her singing capability is clear gone. I think GEM only needed to demonstrate this before the final round, which she did it perfectly well.I don't expect she will preserve and bring this singing style to the final. One more comment, singing an English song, and as a 1st performer, she definitely deserved 1st place.
2.Han Lei: I do not need to comment any more on Han Lei's singing skill. As the last episode stated, he is not just a singer, but a musician. This song probably will not be understood by younger group. In addition, the song "Beijing Beijing", singing in another city Chang Sha...I personally do not think the audience can really feel it... Again, as Han Lei's statement, he does not really care about the ranking, he just wanted to achieve his unfinished musical dream;
3. Jason Zhang: Really needed to give him a thumb up. Very good attitude, he had upset stomach but he still finished it perfectly well. The B-box was creative, with his body movement. I think he is making a break through and I would say it is a success. Good job, good attitude Jason! The good attitude will add mark to your attraction.
4. Shila: I watched 3 times of her performance along with the entire interview. I really had to say, this performance was not quite impressive. There had no break through and no change in the singing style. Yes she is very skillful but she is too conservative on the stage. She needs to bring something new. But the 2nd and 3rd time I watched her performance, and think of her family, and to achieve her singing dream she came all the way to China as a single non-Chinese speaker, is bravo. She is bravo, the audience may not even vote for her because she is not local. I almost cried when i listened carefully with her song, it in fact has strong emotion. For those saying they can not feel her song, you need to listen by heart. Do not put too much stress on yourself Shila, I think you are already very successful in China.
5.Power Station: I do agree they made great progress, I personally even think their performance was better than Zhang Yu's. Their attitude is back and compared to last episode when they showed a little bit scared to compete. This time, they totally freed themselves. Power Station's failure is due to multiple reasons. One of it is the song chosen. Zhang Yu commented the song as everyone known, in fact I never felt familiar with this song. Only had a little bit memory of listening it somewhere. I believe is a Taiwanese local song, which the audience probably were not familiar at all.
6. Bibi: I gotta say I never liked her (more because of the personality). But her performance in episode 8 was really good "Shi Jian Dou Qu Naer Le". This time, she was quite impressive as well. She controlled the entire stage, everybody stood up. I had to say she did make a great job, especially the part she played the instrument, which showed how much effort she put into this performance. I think ranking 2nd is fair, if she ranks 1st I believe she may got attacked by too many people, so 2nd place is a good position.
See wht u wrote this comment u mst get many benefit from the winner. Everything in my expectations. .so funny. .like tht find out the lost plane from Malaysia. U totally like malaysia momoh.
bryan tan your comment doesn't sound too friendly. I hope that is not because I commented my own PERSONAL opinion toward Shila. It is a TV show, not a competition between 2 nations.
Agee with you. Though I love Shila to death, I do think that she needs to try new songs to break through her singing styles. I feel that she performed much better when she was competing at Asian Wave, way more relaxed. To me, she was underperformed singing "FOREVER LOVE" last Fri. She sang this song so beautifully and in a simpler version(which I preferred) at Shanghai's Asian Wave. She sang it so happily like she was falling in love(with Lee Hom, I did feel that way haha), that was the Best version(do search in youtube Shila Forever Asian Wave). Her emotion was too sad for this song last Fri. Gem is so versatile, she deserve to be No.1 last week, she did nail "Falling". I think she could win this competition.
thumb up for your comments. =)
im malaysian, btw , mr bryan tan, what related with lost plane har?
technical singing means "yelling" high notes? so children below the age of 9 are all amazing technical singers...its an r&b song, constant high notes just ruined it for me. It felt like she was trying too hard and didn't fit the soulful groove.
Shila, I'm a Malaysian, I'm proud of you
支持棋,張杰,張宇,茜拉~太讚了,有實力及謙虛和幽默,加油
真的很喜歡張杰，謙虛禮貌又很真誠，超級有風度
i really like Gem！！！
Meijun Lu everybody like GEM
gem 真棒，天资，能力，对歌曲的驾驭和表现能力真的无话可说！说真的，我觉得韩磊可惜了拿到第四还是第五。
为动力火车不值。。。。你们是最赞的！
反而是在唱greatest of love 的時候被感動了！
SHILA YOU ARE NUM 1...WE PROUD WITH YOU..AND I WOULD LIKE TO SAY ..THANKS...I REALY3 LOVE YOU..XIE XIE NI..WO AI NI
動力火車，不要失望，你們其實沒輸，在這肯定你們的實力，棒👍
製作單位應可再請動力火車參加節目，一定可以增加節目精彩度，而動力火車也不要心存陰影而排斥參加，歌手的生命就在舞台上，還有好多動力火車的精彩拿手歌都還沒唱呢，像是梨山癡情花忠孝東路走九遍彩虹……等等，太多了
G.E.M love your performance
紫棋琴技唱功大爆發，盡顯歌后本色！14:26~14:28魔一般的迷人眼神，簡直令人窒息。難怪刘还良建議女歌手这几年都不要入行，根本干不过她，直接把話說到心坎里，同台競技的女歌手們可尷尬～哈～～
张杰要照顾好自己拉!!!!你唱得真的很棒!!
GEM is amazingly good in this performance. Bibi's voice is not strong and I don't really enjoy her performance at all, but she's from China and was the last performer for the night (compared to Gem who sang first), so i'm very proud that Gem still managed to beat Bibi, and this is her fourth time getting #1 :)
Love GEM's performance!!!
I love GEM!!😘😍😂
不管什么情况， 很少人喊暂停重来，毕竟这是live的限制，无论什么情况，演出必须进行
ps，变的很喜欢张宇， 很喜欢他这种开自己玩笑的方式。 这次的摇滚也很带自己的味道。 挺喜欢这个版本
看见那个制作人唱歌的水准了么，声情并茂， 而且还没有实现准备，开嗓啊，和伴奏配合啊 之类的全部都是现场第一次，比某些歌手不差。说实话，我觉得歌手光声音高又尖其实没有融入感情来的重要
永遠的偶像GEM，我愛你！！
G.E.M. sounded a lot like Alicia Keys. However, she added her own twist. Also, she was supposed to scream because the song contained a lot of screaming, and G.E.M. controlled it very well. Shila did pretty good, because she was worrying about her family.
christyk97 if G.E.M. saw your comment saying that she sounds like Alicia Keys , she would be very happy . It is because she is one of her idols.
shila touched my heart
我是歌手第二季，最令人討厭的就是周筆暢 ，沒有風度，沒有水準，又每一集老是覺得自己應該是第一名。其他的歌手都很好
Lisa Yuki Chen 對，超討厭
這角色，演得挺好。最近看倚天，看到周海媚演的滅絕，總想著像誰。回來一看，原來像筆筆。
@@yeunkong5580 本樓最中肯
太赞了 你说了我想说的话
你说了 我想说的话
‘有想过放弃，但是机会只有一次，放弃了我会瞧不起自己’
Shila... u are still the winner... keep going strong!! Your voice superb!!!!!!!