We were taught that communism is evil but over the past few months, watching your vlogs has completely changed my perspective on communism, thanks for uploading, this study circle is extremely informative and insightful.
Our state institutions and agencies will never want a hint of socialism in Pakistan because our state itself is a new name for a feudal system, capitalism.
Great honest analysis Sir,very grateful to u sir,I have learnt a lot of things from u in the age of 16.And I have many debates with family members on socialism ❤❤
kash humare college mae bi esi open discussions hoti.... idr sirf faza e amal parha jata hai humare college mae break ke duran kuch demaghbandi students bait jate hain
They don't talk openly because our state our state needs mazhab to fool people because open debate raises questions and questioning is prohibited in any mazab 😊😊
That's very interesting. Country run by billionaires but country begging for money. kind it's run by lots of kings and queens . Then it's not democracy 😢😢
dear professors you explained very well, thank you. sir recently i am in china and i am doing phd in marxism. i am studing about it now there is one thing in my mind about which i am not clear if you can help me explain that. thank you why all karl marx follower end up as a kind of a dictator? and even during their struggles and after winning such a massive killings happened? and both in russia and china the Famine i mean just after the revolution? about cuba i know less but yes its true in china the health care is far better than we pakistani can imagine but at the same time its really expensive if you dont have medical insurance even its very hard to afford a very minor surgery like appendicitis etc which is even free in kp pakistan(a developing country facing a lot of problem) about other provinces i dont know. one last thing if karl marx followers reach to that level of classless moneyless stateless society who will lead? if nobody then there is always a space for the bad guys to rise and control. thank you sir i am just trying to learn if i wrote anything wrong please forgive me.
sir ye red room ka name change kardo plz , sound something like the dark wed red room, btw the content is really good, 1000x better than bongialogy of molvis and their front mens
kash app jese teacher college mae mile hote to ajj kafi agge hote, humain to katmulle tablighi teacher hi mille jo class mae 6 number batatae aur din rat communism aur bacha khan ki bashing karte
@@Taimur_Laal these parties must accept the "leading role" of the CCP as a condition of their continued existence. (as per source at Wikipedia, but I don't know much about the subject)
You people didn't mention kashmir.what is your perspective on this issue.a lot of resources go into this problem. What do the lefts think about it.?we need to be briefed and educated on this.its one of the causes breeding violence in the country.
@@messagevibes so ur a genocide denier like deobandis . deobandis never spoke for uighurs , look at taliban deobandis they dont give a shit about uighurs. uighurs and Tibetans is not a deobandi problem
@@messagevibes so ur a genocide denier like deobandis . deobandis never spoke for uighurs , look at taliban deobandis they dont give a shit about uighurs. uighurs and Tibetans is not a deobandi problem
@@messagevibes btw uighurs ke mazalim sun kar ..... its so deeply traumatized me for 2 years atleast and basically i get out of islam and muslim brotherhood to care less about them. so i dont believe anymore , coz if there is no one to help uighurs, bo one can help us in time of need
@@messagevibes demaghbandi are also genocide deniers, they never spoke for ui gurs , tali bans demaghbandi have good relations with china and hunt down seperatists there for china
Do you think China is still committed to its communist ideals? After the death of Mao, Deng Xiaoping gradually opened up the Chinese market and they haven't looked back ever since. Present day China is arguably more capitalist than the USA itself, you can say that it is state capitalism but ultimately it's capitalism, they've allowed billionaires to amass huge amounts of wealth at the cost of the working class. The Communist symbolism seems nothing more than life service and a way for the CCP to stay in power. I don't see them creating a Communist society any time in the near future. They've conveniently delayed the creation of a socialist state to 2050, much like what they've done with Hong Kong and Macao, defer the responsibility and burden to the next generation. I would like you to make a video on the Chinese government system, on why or why not it's still committed to communism.
Pakistan k students kitne bad naseeb hai, history k naam pe Unko yaha waha ki stories sunayi jati hai.. Marks or Lenin padhaya Jata kiyu ki inka apna toh koi hero hai nhi..
It is because of political stability, continuity of a system not the reasons you guys mentioned! Monarchy, capitalism and communism are a system. Dictatorship is no system!
@@Taimur_Laal India lifted more than 415 million in 15 years. That does not mean anything, how many people did Mao have to k!ll in order to get this regime?? 40-8-million isn't it. This is what the left does, if someone's still confused. I come from a family of refugees who support the left, but they never talk about the marichjhapi massacre and who it targeted. All of it is a sham!!
We were taught that communism is evil but over the past few months, watching your vlogs has completely changed my perspective on communism, thanks for uploading, this study circle is extremely informative and insightful.
Communism is evil
It's better to ask those who have lived in communist state
Our state institutions and agencies will never want a hint of socialism in Pakistan because our state itself is a new name for a feudal system, capitalism.
Great honest analysis Sir,very grateful to u sir,I have learnt a lot of things from u in the age of 16.And I have many debates with family members on socialism ❤❤
Great. What do u do?
It was really a great discussion to listen both of you Intellectuals. ❤
Useful discussion. Learned a lot .thank you, both of you.
Excellent lectures in common places with students giving them visions to look forward to become respectful nation in the world. Keep it up.
Of course, it's a great debate, you covered.
God Bless all ...we are comrades
Thank you sir.
Mashallah love from India bhai
Appreciate deliberations of the study circle.Such awareness is the need of the time to counter the fake propaganda by the reactionaries.
kash humare college mae bi esi open discussions hoti.... idr sirf faza e amal parha jata hai humare college mae break ke duran kuch demaghbandi students bait jate hain
They don't talk openly because our state our state needs mazhab to fool people because open debate raises questions and questioning is prohibited in any mazab 😊😊
Great discussion love you
आपका मार्क्स वाद की सेवा कर रहे हैं आपको इस समय में ऐसा आंदोलन बहुत मूल्य वान है आपको लाल सलाम
Pakistan cabinet has not a single poor person, all all billionaire.
That's very interesting. Country run by billionaires but country begging for money. kind it's run by lots of kings and queens . Then it's not democracy 😢😢
Then question is ? Is it a light democracy?
दुनिया के मेहनतकश को लाल सलाम
Do laal Bhai, dono tabahi
From now I am your party member
Comrade je MKP ko mazeed membership dilwaein Distt wise universities m jaein students ko mazed engage krein.
It is of no use because the state is always looking to thwart it with its political engineering.😊😊
dear professors you explained very well, thank you.
sir recently i am in china and i am doing phd in marxism. i am studing about it now there is one thing in my mind about which i am not clear if you can help me explain that. thank you
why all karl marx follower end up as a kind of a dictator?
and even during their struggles and after winning such a massive killings happened?
and both in russia and china the Famine i mean just after the revolution?
about cuba i know less but yes its true in china the health care is far better than we pakistani can imagine but at the same time its really expensive if you dont have medical insurance even its very hard to afford a very minor surgery like appendicitis etc which is even free in kp pakistan(a developing country facing a lot of problem) about other provinces i dont know.
one last thing if karl marx followers reach to that level of classless moneyless stateless society who will lead? if nobody then there is always a space for the bad guys to rise and control.
thank you sir i am just trying to learn if i wrote anything wrong please forgive me.
Ahh! I miss my university days....kash k ma join kar sakta....
sir please nexr tiime announce before such session we want to join...
Yes Sir Please Announce that sessions
He did that I guess on Instagram or something.
It was not red, it was green house
Sir G aik request ha
Left or Right ki politics ko detail sa explain krein, in mein difference clear kr dein or is ki history bhi explain kr dein 😊
Left are those against capitalism. And eight are those in favour of capitalism or religious state.
Love you 💕 sir both
Aab hoga tandav.
Napoleon Bonaparte vs Rothschild =Bank of England 😮?😊
sir ye red room ka name change kardo plz , sound something like the dark wed red room, btw the content is really good, 1000x better than bongialogy of molvis and their front mens
7 billion from IMF, celebration is going on. ❤️ inflation is going to sky rocket, proletariat is going to cry, noise will go to Mars.
❤❤❤❤❤❤
Blue shirt waly Ho Chi Minh hain?
Confucianist looking philosopher ammar k sath baitha hua 😂 is he important stuff?? 🤔
sir wese singapore , south korea aur taiwan ka capitalist system china se bi sucessful hai
kash app jese teacher college mae mile hote to ajj kafi agge hote, humain to katmulle tablighi teacher hi mille jo class mae 6 number batatae aur din rat communism aur bacha khan ki bashing karte
Now AI is here. The working class is already disappearing.
Capitalism will die if that happens.
@@Taimur_Laalno you are wrong
Common prosperity via Riyaz malik, jahanigir Tareen.
No. Via a state run by the working class.
45:00 if it means economic Development & Growth for us what's wrong with it? Let's become a US ally again and develop at a faster rate.
This time let's demand more from the US.
Sir, can't be socialist governance model without one party rule and authoritarian style of governance?
China has 8 parties.
@@Taimur_Laal these parties must accept the "leading role" of the CCP as a condition of their continued existence. (as per source at Wikipedia, but I don't know much about the subject)
You people didn't mention kashmir.what is your perspective on this issue.a lot of resources go into this problem. What do the lefts think about it.?we need to be briefed and educated on this.its one of the causes breeding violence in the country.
sir u should also condemn the concentration camps there and the genocide of Uighurs, Tibetans and Mongolians.
Oper ap ny damaghbandiyun pr tanqeed kiii or ic comment mai ap ny wohi dimaghbandi wali baat krdiii
@@messagevibes so ur a genocide denier like deobandis . deobandis never spoke for uighurs , look at taliban deobandis they dont give a shit about uighurs. uighurs and Tibetans is not a deobandi problem
@@messagevibes so ur a genocide denier like deobandis . deobandis never spoke for uighurs , look at taliban deobandis they dont give a shit about uighurs. uighurs and Tibetans is not a deobandi problem
@@messagevibes btw uighurs ke mazalim sun kar ..... its so deeply traumatized me for 2 years atleast and basically i get out of islam and muslim brotherhood to care less about them. so i dont believe anymore , coz if there is no one to help uighurs, bo one can help us in time of need
@@messagevibes demaghbandi are also genocide deniers, they never spoke for ui gurs , tali bans demaghbandi have good relations with china and hunt down seperatists there for china
Do you think China is still committed to its communist ideals? After the death of Mao, Deng Xiaoping gradually opened up the Chinese market and they haven't looked back ever since. Present day China is arguably more capitalist than the USA itself, you can say that it is state capitalism but ultimately it's capitalism, they've allowed billionaires to amass huge amounts of wealth at the cost of the working class. The Communist symbolism seems nothing more than life service and a way for the CCP to stay in power. I don't see them creating a Communist society any time in the near future. They've conveniently delayed the creation of a socialist state to 2050, much like what they've done with Hong Kong and Macao, defer the responsibility and burden to the next generation. I would like you to make a video on the Chinese government system, on why or why not it's still committed to communism.
@@WhyClaudius sure. Will make a video.
Imran Khan zindabad. Release 804.
Pakistan k students kitne bad naseeb hai, history k naam pe Unko yaha waha ki stories sunayi jati hai..
Marks or Lenin padhaya Jata kiyu ki inka apna toh koi hero hai nhi..
The system in china is ghatya system!
@@mfvohra101 they lifted 850 million people out of poverty in the last 40 years and made their country into a superpower.
It is because of political stability, continuity of a system not the reasons you guys mentioned!
Monarchy, capitalism and communism are a system. Dictatorship is no system!
@@Taimur_Laal India lifted more than 415 million in 15 years. That does not mean anything, how many people did Mao have to k!ll in order to get this regime?? 40-8-million isn't it. This is what the left does, if someone's still confused. I come from a family of refugees who support the left, but they never talk about the marichjhapi massacre and who it targeted. All of it is a sham!!
@@mfvohra101so monarchy is better than Dictatorship, loved your logic 😂
@@Taimur_Laalthat's because they shifted from communist economy to capitalist like economy
Dr. Ammar Jan saheb uighurs par sirf namaz ki azadi nehi balke ethnic cleansing ho rahi hai
Why did Biden only talk about Ughers? Why is he silent on Palestine? Yemen? Lebanon? Iraq, Afghanistan?
نام نہاد ماہر تعلیم
@@habibgilani_Official. do you have arguments or only insults?
❤❤❤❤
❤❤❤❤