Prof. Noam Chomsky on Economy & Politics of Pakistan, India & South Asia I PIDE Debate
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 25 июл 2022
- Prof. Noam Chomsky warns about South Asian future, at PIDE Debate with Dr. Abdul Jalil (Professor of Economics at PIDE)
For Pakistan, to start a new journey on the right track, first of all, it has get itself free from the clutches of colonial legacy and institutions, said Professor Noam Chomsky - an American linguist, philosopher, cognitive scientist, social critic, political activist and also known as "the father of modern linguistics". He authored more than 150 books on range of topics. Chomsky was in conversation with Dr. Abdul Jalil, PIDE
Dr. Jalil asked about the academic view of the reasons behind Pakistan’s sad state of affairs; on economic front in particular. Moreover, if Pakistan has to reset, with the current circumstance, then where is the starting point?
#Economy #NoamChomsky #Pakistan #Debate #Politics #India #SouthAsia #Linguistics #ProfNoamChomsky #noamchomsky
For Further Details Please Visit:
www.pide.org.pk
/ pideofficial
/ pidepk
/ pideislamabad
/ pidepk
/ pidepk
Thanks for having Noam on! You deep love and respect is appreciated. Thank you for your thoughtful questions.
MUST SEE . Search . ' Noam Chamsky : US Is World's Biggest Terrorist '
Thoughtful questions?? How about some hard questions!! Stop boot licking!! You’re embarrassing yourself!! He’s a faker!!
Keep it up Dr. Thank you for your work.
Very interesting information.
Thanks .
Dear Professor, after 93 years you have been using your mind to make sense of reality. Your work will live on. Thank you sir.
Chomsky is so open to being on so many shows of small to medium sizes, of any backgrounds, its inspiring considering his influence.
It doesn't matter who comes to power in Pakistan. This country has been steadily sinking since Jinnah died. Look at Bangladesh, Indonesia, Malaysia, etc are all Islamic, but have given priority to economics. Islam is not a problem, some extreme 'Pakistani Muslims' and corrupt Military + Politicians + Madarsas are the key problem.
Search , Noam Chomsky : US is World's Biggest Terrorist '
Search . Noam Chomsky : US is World's Biggest Terrorist '
what about brgrhamin quota people
@@rezakarampour6286 Doesn't matter what Chomsky says. You Pakistanis can't seem to solve your problem by yourself. We Indians need to intervene, and prevent you people from conducting another 26/11 type of attack on Indian soil. (You, means your establishment, and their source of corrupt income)
Thank God first time an India is saying that Islam is not Problem otherwise most Indians are brainwashed against Islam to the core. Totally out of their senses . Yani Bilkul hi aqal sey paidal hain.
It's incredible how much insight Chomsky has on so many issues. I always enjoy his interviews and lectures.
"Majority of Intellectuals, throughout history, have been flatterers of the court." ❤
2:00 What is the importance of the economy?
12:40
18:55
25:00 India and Pakistan must cooperate
41:10
very great honour for host to manage to persuade such a distinguished and busy person for the programme. It also speaks volumes of great humility for prof chomsky to accept this humble invitation. At his advanced age when most scholars are playing with grandchildren to pass time Prof Chomsky is very sharp and clear in his speech.
title is wrong this is not a debate! this video was educstive
Love the authenticity of this conversation....ty both for allowing us to be the proverbial fly on the wall!
Every rational South Asian knows this…the only way forward is for India and Pakistan to foster cooperation,otherwise it is a disastrous path that they are on.
Why should the economy of Pakistan depend on cooperation with India?? Pakistan should focus on getting preferential access to rich blocs and countries such as the European Union, USA, Canada, Australia etc for exports. Also some deal with Middle Eastern nations for oil in denominations other than dollars.
Search . Noam Chomsky " US is World's Biggest Terrorist '
@@MrLee-gj2jz too late
@@Q_QQ_Q never too late; Low-income countries should try and export to countries that are 20-30 times richer to grow economy. That is how East Asia and how more recently, South East Asia grew their economies.
@@MrLee-gj2jz cant now .
Super job PIDE. Will hear in detail but the idea is great.
I'm humbled by this opportunity to have listened to present-day Socrates. Thank you, Dr..
This guy literally denies the bosnian genocide. But ig some Muslims matter more than others....
@@syedmohammadaanasfarukh890 i had a hunch that he had skeletons in his closet
@@evanarroyo1384 “they” all do 😏
@@velocirshtr3756 who?
@@syedmohammadaanasfarukh890 He doesn’t deny the massacre. He just denies the applicability of the word “genocide” since he feels that the word has been utilised incorrectly. Stop spreading misinformation.
Simply loved it ❤️
Noam is a rockstar
This is a great achievement to have such a great guest for pide just for helping viewers ❤
Great achievement indeed. Dr Jalil is not coming slow. Keep shining sir
Hurrah! I think you hear all about. Wow you are not coming slow.
thanks for giving a gem sir
Great information thanks host
I think PIDE should get another moderator. While Dr. Jalil is a well-known and articulate economist in Pakistan in Urdu, his command of English and holding a deep discourse with heavy weights like Noam Chomsky (in English) was not good.
Also, his demeanour of “respect” (which comes from how we are told to respect our teachers in school in Pakistan) was on full display. This was not so much a debate, but a school lecture received like a schoolboy by Dr. Jalil. In the beginning and the end of the interview, I don’t know how many times Dr. Jalil thanked Dr. Chomsky and called him “Sir”…. the way I would shake my head from side to side at school when my teacher would say something. Why?
Why did’nt Dr. Jalil question Chomsky on why Chomsky thought that the United States did not follow their comparative advantage after the American Revolution? and as a result was set on a growth path. Explosively, why did’nt he question Chomsky on how education in Pakistan could change to follow his principles of “open mindedness”. Given that we are still an “Islamic” Republic, what Chomsky means by education and open mindedness, would not at all suit the likes of Dr. Jalil. Is Pakistani education ready to teach evolutionary biology to its children in grade school? Is it ready to keep the books of Salman Rushdie on it’s bookshelves? Is it ready to allow its children to question Islam (or any religion) and their faith through the books of Christopher Hitchins and Richard Dawkins? Are we prepared to teach our children that all citizens are equal, including Qadianis?
I think the problem is that “Development” has very little to do with “Economics”. It has everything to do with open mindedness, critical thinking, questioning everything without the fear of being persecuted (teachers, parents, army, God), equality of all citizens, rule of law, entrepreneurship, Justice, and respect for institutions.
The recent political turmoil in Pakistan has laid two things bare for all of us to see: First, that Pakistan’s elite are not there to serve the will of its people. Indeed, the Jagirdars, Waderas, and Sarmayadars - who are the current crop of law makers in Pakistan - are there to serve their own interests and hide their thievery. Second, that the future of Pakistan is ACTUALLY very bright. I mean, in which other country have people come out en masse to protest against these band of dacoits, and willing to fight for their rights in their millions?
I like most of the points you highlighted and the sense of hope you have for the bright future of your country. I like the way you summarized many many things like the question of education by Dr. Chomsky. Even though he is a great man and I honor him a lot, but still he and his likes always supported the state of Israel whose basis are purely religious/zionist. I feel religion is very personal to a people while the education doesn't mean to shun it off. We can be best Muslims and great intellectuals at the same time, provided we are taught how to think.
As Dr. Chomsky points out India and Pak can both benefit from action on water and climate change. That is a good starting point. That being said at this point it is impossible for South Asia to decouple from global economies. We are all energy dependent. An interesting dichotomy.
Nice work PIDE
Great Interview
Great interview. Amazing overview of problems of South Asia. Hope one day wisdom dawns.
Search , ' Noam Chomsky : US is World's Biggest Terrorist'
Gud one❤️
His vice-chancellor sounds like wife chancellor. 😀
The Debate with Noam Chomski was not a debate but an interview. I suggest that a grand debate be held with Noam Chomsky and this time include all major economist of Pakistan at PIDE platform along with Government and Opposition parties represented through their economist and business men and associated government institutions leaders. One thing Noam Chomsky mentioned clearly was that TIME is short before Pakistan and India becomes un live able....well done PIDE for getting this interview
Mashallah great discussion.
Nice
Why the hell was the title put as debate with Noam, when the host in the very beginning clearly says that he wants to learn from the professor
Try to right down his words in book in to pdf through which we read clearly. PDF put in discuruption
Fantastic observation at 13:00
Thank you very much for the superb interview. Isn't common acceptance of climate change a problem too? It helps certain types of high-tech companies but does nothing to alleviate the tremendous pollution in crowded cities of India-I don't know Pakistan.
You are very right, a valid question. We will definitely address it in our coming debates, stay tuned.
Thanks for your valuable feedback.
👍👍👍
great interview
🙏🙏
The answer to the last question he nailed it.
Yes, Lovely.
Dr. Abdul Jalil sahb. thank you azeem baloch Gwadar Port
why is this interview titled as a "debate" ?
MashAllah nice Bahi jan ❤️
One needs not seeking opinions from scholars abroad on the mess that we have made of Pakistan.
We just need to look in the mirror.
"Guzarta hai hur shaks chehra chupaye,
Koi raah mey ayi'na rakh giya hai."
PS / no disrespect to Dr. Noam Chomsky whom I greatly respect and who I have the honor to read and listen to.
Firstly, for a country to prosper, it has to be free to do so. While looking that way, we know how free Pakistan and even India is from the external influence, especially the West. They can't survive without the outsiders. To build a home, we have to own it first and we know how dire the Pakistan's economy is. They already have more than 10 billion in debt. and they always require foreign aid to be rescued. Their failed economy is the outcome of their corrupt and inept governments, which have always been puppets. So it is a cycle of events which doesn't allow it to grow. And as Dr. Chomsky made it clear that the nations have prospered by crushing others, that explains the development by the others, which is not possible for Pakistan at the moment and in fact is a victim of it.
So it is not just education, open-mindedness or shunning off the orthodoxy which will free Pakistan from its shackles. Rather in addition, the hard work, resilience, resoluteness, harmony with the neighbors, great statesmanship of its people and a will to go forward without the foreign interference (for which they have to strengthen their institutions) that will uplift it and make a role model in the era we are living in.
all to be honest, open minded ...........
you are true face of Pakistan. I love you Man
Thanks a lot
you shouldn't use "Debate" in title
14:20 which pakistani intellectual professor is referring to ?
Pakistani Physicist Professor Pervez Hoodbhoy
No water rise or temp increase where I live
He spoke the greatest sense and the rest stays with us to accept it or reject it but it was all about stark realities, like rising temperature, uncomfortable conditions for people, increasing number of population that too are not very enlightened. thid is all demanding our extreme attention before virtually we are over taken by such threats......what else can be said!!!!!!
Search . ' Noam Chomsky : US is World's Biggest Terrorist '
not accepting religious authoritarianism, not accepting economic policies of neo liberalism, better ties with india, imf recommendations and ofcourse a fucking brain.
My grandfather Chomsky ❤
Aoa.sir kindly give your session on climate change too.its the hot topic now a days causing serious damages internationally and in Pakistan too.
Thanks for suggestion Sadaf. Noted.
We will record an exclusive with experts. Stay tuned
Development of any nation depends on its culture. Islam is the culture of Pakistan but Islam as interpreted by Allama Iqbal is the only way out for kick starting the Pakistani economy: Allama says Inductive reasoning is the spirit of Islam. Islam , for about 400 years ,had golden age in which science and scientific research flourished. That should be the starting point for the Pakistani society.
Search . ' Noam Chomsky : US is World's Biggest Terrorist '
دنیا کی تمام بڑی زبانوں سے پاکستانی زبانوں میں جدید سائنسی علم کے بڑے پیمانے پر تراجم ہی پاکستان کے عوام کو تعلیم دینے کا واحد ذریعہ ہے۔ انگریزی کی غلامی ہمیں مار رہی ہے۔
40:00 The concession for operations at Haifa Port was won by a 70-30 % bid by India's APSEZ and Israel's Gadot Group. The concession lasts only till 2054. There is no Chinese company involved.
I don't know the facts here, but Chomsky is saying China owns the other parts of the port, not that they were involved in the current Indian deal
@@siddharthamishra1999 He needs to be specific here. The Chinese built a terminal in Haifa Port and they are managing another Israeli port. The US sixth fleet docks at Haifa. It is bowing down to American opposition on Chinese presence in Israel that the Israelis decided to go with APSEZ. This was inline with I2-U2 (India-Israel-UAE-US) collaboration. These are the facts.
Comparing Adani's wealth with Mumbai slum dwellers is in anycase a ridiculous comparison. Per capita income in Mumbai is 23000$ (PPP). Per capita income in Puerto Rico, USA is 12000$. Why doesn't Chomsky compare Jeff Bezos or Elon Musk's wealth with that of Puerto Ricans? The order of magnitude of difference in wealth in both cases is 10^8.
There are two ports in Haifa
@@contrarian322 yes, the other one is Ashdod.
In pakistan old people have knee problems so how come we keep ac? We live with our parents.
We need actual neighbourhood and friendship relationships with all of our neighbouring countries
13:00 this friend must be Dr Hoodbhoy. 😁😁
Yessss
Simply loved the response of Prof Chomsky about the personal question posed
What a subtle snubbing - now that is the manifestation of colonial mind set / subjugation confused as modesty
Modesty is never at the cost of self respect
The question is pathetic, deplorable & as rightly identified as "Wrong Question"
Search , ' Noam Chomsky : US Is World's Biggest Terrorist '
Time Stamp??
Sad. Unfortunate but there is no sense of manners or personal space in Desi cultures
It is good that the host was very respectful, but seemed very unconfident and lacked courage. He was sounding childish quite a few times, which is not good for a Professor of his caliber.
sadly Chomsky has not hi-lited the role of defense spending feeding desolate poverty. he made zero ref to the afgh famine, after nato failure. B- for a giant intellect. charming Dr Jalil, a modest teacher who represents a great civilization strained by western capiatlism imf-nato
Good discussion. We have hosted Noam too, among others. Kindly check out, and help us grow.
If India and Pakistan finds it hard to cooperate bilaterally they need to find new ways to at least start cooperate multilaterally thru new means, such as the Indian Ocean Association. Both can find neutral influential players like Indonesia or Thailand to push this to realization.
Debate? Does the uploader even know the definition of the word?
Beard wars. You've got some front, there's no denying it.
Philippines is a Christian country East Asian countries are not
SIR is an acronym for Slave I Remain
"this is not an interview" and then goes on to keep such a title :(
Chomsky is a role model intellectual for the world. His comments on Pakistan are so apt because of his genius, his diligence, his modesty, his honesty, and his respect and regard for his interlocutor. There was not a whiff of arrogance towards what seemed at times to be simple-minded questions. The interlocutor in fact was rather good - and Chomsky instinctively knew that he was engaging not with the intellectual "elite" of Pakistan but with a person far more representative of the common perceptions of Pakistanis - and as such far more interesting.
Pakistan should look Indonesia not india how Indonesia prosper learn there man thinking mentality they never pressure there women wife to leave her work business etc there maid use vispa.
SIGNS OF ALMIGHTY ALLAH
IN THE HOLY QUR'AN
We shall show them Our Signs in the Universe and within their own selves, Dunhill it becomes clear to them that He is the Truth
(Qur'an,41:53)
A man can't see Almighty Allah therefore He manifested Himself in His Signs in the horizons (universe).
If we study and research the verses of the Holy Qur'an we will find many signs that will guide us to the existence of Almighty Allah.
One of His Signs mentioned in this verse:
و جعلنا السماء سقفا محفوظا و ھم عن آياتها معرضون o
And We have made the sky a roof withheld (from them). Yet they turned away from its portents.
(Qur'an,21:32)
Our life on earth is secured from all kind of space attacks like atomic charged solar winds come from the Sun and space strikes.
Who can tell us 1500 years ago that our life on earth is protected by a protecting roof well guarded ?
What if there is no magnetic fields/shields?
Almighty Allah is the Originator of the universe and Creator of the Mankind. All such verses are mentioned in the Holy Qur'an guide us to the existence of Almighty
Allah.
DR.MOHAMMAD LAEEQUE NADVI
Ph.D. (Arabic Lit.)
Director
Amena Institute of Islamic Studies
& Analysis
A Global & Universal Research Institute,
Donate to promote this Institute
SBI A/C30029616117
Kolkata,Park Circus Branch
nadvilaeeque@gmail.com
Thanks
These are people I would like gamble with, maybe start a political party. Fry a steak, go to the movies, no kissing animals. Hello?
In order for the Pakistan military to abandon the deadly competition with India, Pakistani Muslims must acknowledge their ancestry, culture & history of having Vedic (Hindu) roots.
Second: Muslims in general must understand the basic concepts of sanatana dharma (Hinduism).
Concepts such as 'murti'.
To understand murti we have to ask:
can God have a form?
well, I have a form & you have a form.
How can God (being the source of everything) be missing a form?
God must have a form, yet the form of God is spiritual, not material.
God can be in all places at all times - we can't.
God can transform the spirit into the matter & vice versa.
What follows from these basic philosophical rules is that God can have an unlimited number of spiritual forms.
God being omnipotent (all powerful) can do that.
Murti is a form of God that is visible to individuals on a material level of consciousness.
Murti is not an idol.
How does murit appear on a temple altar is another topic.
There are thick volumes that describe the process.
Idol worship is very popular among many religionists:
many Christians, Hindus, Muslems. Jews & other religious people worship idols.
Adoring cricket stars, movie stars or having money & power as the goal of life is proper idol worship.
Seeing one's religion as the only way to God is another.
This idea comes from pride, arrogance & greed.
God is not Muslim, Hindu or Christian.
God is God!
Sanatana dharma has an extremely long history of respecting other religions & of helping them.
Simply ask the Parsis of India.
Or the Jews.
Yet when a minority culture like Islam or Christianity starts to compete with the native one, no wonder there have been problems.
The reason that the Muslims & Christians undermine & criticise sanatana dharma (Vedic tradition) comes from their desire to convert the Hindus.
This desire (again) comes form pride in thinking themselves better.
Why did Muslims come to Bharat?
The conquest was motivated by greed & pride.
The same with the Christians.
Are we willing to cooperate?
Are we willing to respect one another?
Is the welfare of all in our hearts?
There will be no improvement in the relations between Pakistan & India unless & until these ideas are tackled & understood by Muslims.
Salaam aleikum
sat sri akaal
hare krishna
namaskar.
Krishna-Dasa, Belgium
We already know that our ancestors were Hindus or Buddhist and we have no problem in acknowledging that but when Indian insists on so called ''Ghar Wapasi'' this becomes Problematic.
Half of your comment about concept of God is near to Islam like God has no material form but on Murti Problem Islam is categorically clear about any kind of Idol worship be it Murti, Animals or Movies stars.
Muslims just cannot stand the concept of Murti worship, this leads to so much superstition, unnecessary fears and exploitations at the hands of Gurus or holy men. In fact most Indians are superstitious and are exploited at hands of some kind of fake Babas and fake Gurus.
No doubt Muslims need to stop hating Hindus and equating them with Pagans of Makkah who first expelled and then imposed war on Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him.
I think debate in a scholarly environment between Islam and Hinduism is the only way forward because we cant afford war in atomic age.
@@TajamalGhumman Thanks for your reply.
I appreciate your honest writing
No doubt Muslims need to stop hating Hindus
Any honest devotee of God would never cause harm to another living being.
Any so-called Hindu causing harm to Muslims is not really a Hindu.
The same with all the looting, temple demolition & countless genocides of Hindus by so-called Muslims.
These are just greedy people using religion to steal, kill etc.
I'm glad we agree on this one.
A question from your text?
Muslims just cannot stand the concept of Murti worship.
As I have explained, murti is a form of God that is visible to those who can't see the spiritual realm.
Isn't it true that both matter & spirit is manifested by God?
If God is the source of matter why can't Hie appear in His own energy as Prophet Moses (Musa), pbuh, saw God in a form of a burning bush?
The Jews & Christians accept that God can appear on the material element fire.
Murti is not an idol.
Yes, God has also an impersonal aspect.
If you treat me badly I'll show you my impersonal side by avoiding you by not talking to you.
But my personal aspect is the primary one.
A relationship must be between persons.
A relationship with money or other objects never satisfies anyone.
In any case, we do respect your choice of understanding God as an impersonal energy, eternal light etc. God that cannot be understood by us.
Yet, as God is all-powerful, He can make us understand Him... If He so chooses.
But whatever is that our heart goes to (persona God or an impersonal Deity), let us find a way to live in peace, acceptance & cooperation.
I do not share your beliefs but I accept that those are your beliefs.
We as the same in the name of brotherhood & peaceful co-existence.
Please respect our choice.
What is your good name?
Salaam aleikum
sat sri akaal
hare krishna
namaskar.
Krishna-Dasa
I dont think religious understanding is needed, we need to coexist not become best of freinds, coexist means respecting each others belief without understanding it, not what you said, french secularist ideologies were very different to christian kingdom of britian, eventhough their beliefs were different and they didnt accept this, there is peace, you need this in south asia region, forget about your gods and your beliefs, make it point that violation of ones rights as it pertains to religious propagana be outlawed to maintain civility between to strong set of beliefs, this well help this region. i also think gandhi is good example of religious coexistence although we need a separation of state in both countries as religions will always clash this way them being outside will help internally
Even the person asking questions jalil is wearing his religion on his sleeve. Looking at him itself does not give any hope for any country !! Islam as its national goal will not take Pakistan anywhere. There is no hope for Pakistan that's for sure as long as the aasmani kitab is the driving force of that country.
Mr Swami only Jesus is salvation !! Har har Mahadev !! Inshaallah you will understand vaheguru Di Fateh !!
re brothers of brhamin quota people
Haribol !!! Hare Krishna !!! Hare Krishna !!! Aum Namah Shivaya !!
Very pathetic and iralevent questions from the jient of our time. Interviewer should be more literate about Chomskey, his work and his experties. Very disappointing dood.
Nice beard but mustache should not be there.
By why are you to shake? Strange! You should be confident enough to ‘tackle’ this talk. You seem to be soooo obedient; do you know what impression of Pakistan are you leaving on people! Didn’t they have anyone better who knew language and communication better? What is ‘Sir’; you should use the word ‘Professor’. Arent you even ashamed of what and how you do stuff? What a conservative behaviour!
sir it is okay, why do pakistani people talk like this, im from uk i hear this alot from indians and pakistanis, sir isnt being used anymore besides the people 😂😂😂
Nomsky the utter crank has lost every last marble. "Lock em all down, mask the children, force medical procedures on anyone unwilling to comply".
Lowland Joe can't disagree with you more. Happy now?
What?
Lol what
There are always right-wing trolls following Chomsky trying to denigrate him. Hasn't succeeded in 6 decades!
Even the characterization of Chomsky's remarks on dealing with Covid-19 is completely wrongly. Try reading what Chomsky actually said!
I'm humbled by this opportunity to have listened to present-day Socrates. Thank you, Dr..
Lol
Lol
Methuselah!
🤣🤣🤣
See to it that u dont get a heart attack from all this excitement 😂😂😂