must say that they do have great partnership where selling and interacting with fans;but one can feel,that it’s all business and none of the playfulness they had in their previous live selling (if u go and watch it again); something has changed with them - mayb they are now more “matured”; seriously focusing on their respective careers; both of them may have realized that they have gone through a whirlwind beginning 2 years back when they being shipped as “Englot” couple and honestly it could have taken a toil on their personal lives as well; every movement, every friendships other than them are also being scrutinized and criticized; their privacy is exposed and some fans take their “shipping” out of context; Engfa had said many times they cannot be more than “sisters” as if they are in a relationship and it did not work out - it be difficult to work together; Charlotte has been honest right from the beginning to say that she respect Engfa and treats her like an elder sister and love her for being there for her; I believe Engfa has been the “force” behind Charlotte guiding her; teaching her and supporting her; probably and likely she did “fall in love”with Charlotte and wanted more but Charlotte (let’s not forget she is a straight girl) and has never been with a girl; the feelings she has for Engfa is genuine in terms of “more than love” for a sister, friend, teacher, mentor etc but gf not in the beginning perhaps; mayb over the past year she may or did feel for Engfa in a romantic way but let’s face it - she might be scared as well - becoz it’s an unknown territory for her whereas Engfa has been in the LGBTfor many years, if both of them don’t work out - it could end badly for both of them especially Charlotte (if she does get marry to a man) etc charlotte has always said if she truly love a woman it’s only Engfa otherwise no - that truly speaks a lot ie she is not 100% LGBT- probably don’t think she is Bi either - only she knows herself what she wants or who she wants, the fact that since the beginning of the second half of 2023 - they both have a lot of dramas (as what it is being called) and again the negative publicity could have taken a toil on their relationship ( from being playful, fun loving,caring;) to this current state - colleagues in the same industry. Mind you I could see that Engfa still care for Charlotte in a subtle way throughout the 2 hrs live and Charlotte being Charlotte will take a lead from Engfa ( if Engfa is not playful - she won’t be too playful as well - not the clingy Charlotte we see in the past) this I believe they have both grown up to be more professional and mature in their interactions. They have to try and find their way back to each other to the beginning when they first met and really understand that they may not be couple in real life but they have a bond that is beyond any relationships and that they can support each other. Engfa is so the One and Only born in this era and fans are lucky to meet this beautiful talented lady but hope she does not get burnt out - otherwise it be fatal for her especially in her health. Charlotte is very sweet and talented and she has gown these past two years with confidence (although you can see she still have some insecurities that she is facing) but she is still young and I believe she will get better and better - she is unique in her own way and I am not surprised that she is much loved - u can see that she genuinely care for Engfa and all her friends, she is also one that stand up for her friends and support them. I believe that their upcoming USA TRIP will be different from the very first one - it’s more of a working partnership now unless they both had to let go of what is troubling them and talk to each other and ask themselves this “ do we truly want to walk in success together” and be there for each other other no matter what happens - do they want to let go of the special and unique relationship they had built over the past 2 years? We don’t know what is happening here - only they know themselves or those close to them - no matter what let’s respect- support- love them and give them space. If everyone loves them for who they are - leave the toxicity negative comments behind: just b there for them and don’t have too much expectations put on them. They are their own persons in their own rights and I believe both of them have a great future in their careers - their personal lives (whether is it together or not) - apologies for this long post 💕
I think their feelings right now is not genuine anymore, specifically engfa, she does englot things only like its the rules that she cant espcape cause they have big fan base,,, and their chemistry is not good anymore, i love engfa im a big fan of hers, but sometimes i feel pity for charlot… if you go through their insta story or anything you can clearly tell that…. Anyway forever englot❤
The live looks fun. Especially with the fans. Apparently, P’Fa has seen charlotte’s house but did not come in, because she does not invite P’Fa. Charlotte invite everyone to her house except for P’Fa wow. Wish I could invite P’Fa to my house haha😅
They are still cute but it is a time were all boxes needs to be checked on both of them. I have watched about ever clip , movie and videos of these lovely ladies. They have a lot of growning up to do you can use the word love any time to everybody that just a word beening thowed around , love cherish and obey with all your heart not only accept all there faults and short comings.😢😢 engfa first showed no respect when she ran off for 3 days with that older women and was trying to court charlotte then and repeatedly showed disrespect with all her flirting , drunkeness with over half of the miss grand girls. That alone would of had me running the other way and charlotte was still there putting up with all that mess even after they started sleeping together. Second that sister this and a that please i have 4 stster and we dont ack like that and i love them to death . Charlotte wanted love not a sister she truly love engfa to this day you can see it in her eyes but what one person can take , iam not making excuses for her but if you can't get love from the one you love anyone will go find it somewhere else, and thats just my opinion and i didnt say that what she did. Third and with the work they have and all the crazy jobs with so many different peoples coming and going you need to have someone to go home to. And iam not talking about no #### rabbit and dog someone to hear and talk back to hear how there day went and whats coming next . Fourth engfa got fame way to quick and cocky with it she knows she looks good so she can do whatever she wants to do , she's the KING as she put it and she can slay anyone of those girls as she may. That in itself is so disrespectful not only to those contestants but to herself as well , no women or man should ack or think like that . And the fans is the biggest problem cause they the one's got her thinking like that. Money and fame will change you in a good way or bad way , if you are not careful engfa in the next 5 to 10 years you might have money but the fame and that special someone will be gone. Charlotte you are very very very talented and you or getting better every day , please get a back bone and stop 🛑 running behind engfa she is not worth it and she have proving that over and over again. Reach for the stars you have a very good start the world is at your feet , You're young you're beautiful and very well raised and can get any women are man you want if they don't love you the way you want don't settle protect your heart we only got one.. 🎉🎉🎉HEARTS TO HEARTS ❤❤
Agreed, Charlotte is too kind which is also not good. When Charlotte's MV was released E didn't post or didn't even clicked on like in IG whereas yesterday when E's MV got released C posted on her IG appreciating her MV. E reposted everyone else's post of her MV except the post from C. People sometimes take advantage of C's kind heartedness and I think she should think of her self respect 1st. Fans will always support but most of the time they are with their costars or MGI members. If there is an ego, it's difficult for any true relationship to stay.
شكرا على الترجمة ولكن انجلوت انتهى 💔 كنت حقا اعشق قصتهم و تصرفاتهم العفوية و لكن الان اشعر ان كل شيئ مبتذل و مجرد تمثيل للوصول للشهرة اعشق انجفا رغم تكبرها و غرورها و اعشق تشار رغم تررده و خوفه سادعمكم و لكن بشكل منفصل 😢
وأخيرا حدا عربي بتابعهن فعلا انتهوا بالاصل ايمت ابتدؤا ولا مرة صرحوا انو مروا بمرحلة علاقة رغم الفانز من الاول معن انجفا من البداية صرحت رح تنطر شارلوت وقت اعترفت لها بالمشاعر ماعاد تريدها وفعلا كل شي تغير بسنة 2023 حتى اصدقائهم ماعاد صاروا يسمعوا حكي متل الاول انا برأي كل واحد يمشي بطريق لحال أحسن ورغم هيك اتمنى يكونوا لبعض😢
@@rosaliemelhem1789 ما قلت انهم كانو ع علاقة صريحة بس كان واضح الاعجاب و الحب بينهم في حلقة مفقودة ما بيحكو عنها شكلا موضوع بيخص العقد لانهم دايما بيتركو الموضوع للوقت رح اعمل متابعة ل قناتك ع اليوتيوب لنضل ع تواصل ❤️ في اكتر من شخص عربي عم يتابعهم
I am fans of cha.because she is humble..sincere and no arogant.
P'Fah's acapella vocals tho, oh i'd listen to it for hours. Engfa💅
thank you for the English sub. Hope for the next lives like tomorrow, glutanex you all translate also.
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤wait for this video... finally.. thank you admin... Englot ❤
Thanks admin..stay safe😘🤗👍😉
i will 🤗 stay safe too 😘
must say that they do have great partnership where selling and interacting with fans;but one can feel,that it’s all business and none of the playfulness they had in their previous live selling (if u go and watch it again); something has changed with them - mayb they are now more “matured”; seriously focusing on their respective careers; both of them may have realized that they have gone through a whirlwind beginning 2 years back when they being shipped as “Englot” couple and honestly it could have taken a toil on their personal lives as well; every movement, every friendships other than them are also being scrutinized and criticized; their privacy is exposed and some fans take their “shipping” out of context; Engfa had said many times they cannot be more than “sisters” as if they are in a relationship and it did not work out - it be difficult to work together; Charlotte has been honest right from the beginning to say that she respect Engfa and treats her like an elder sister and love her for being there for her; I believe Engfa has been the “force” behind Charlotte guiding her; teaching her and supporting her; probably and likely she did “fall in love”with Charlotte and wanted more but Charlotte (let’s not forget she is a straight girl) and has never been with a girl; the feelings she has for Engfa is genuine in terms of “more than love” for a sister, friend, teacher, mentor etc but gf not in the beginning perhaps; mayb over the past year she may or did feel for Engfa in a romantic way but let’s face it - she might be scared as well - becoz it’s an unknown territory for her whereas Engfa has been in the LGBTfor many years, if both of them don’t work out - it could end badly for both of them especially Charlotte (if she does get marry to a man) etc charlotte has always said if she truly love a woman it’s only Engfa otherwise no - that truly speaks a lot ie she is not 100% LGBT- probably don’t think she is Bi either - only she knows herself what she wants or who she wants, the fact that since the beginning of the second half of 2023 - they both have a lot of dramas (as what it is being called) and again the negative publicity could have taken a toil on their relationship ( from being playful, fun loving,caring;) to this current state - colleagues in the same industry. Mind you I could see that Engfa still care for Charlotte in a subtle way throughout the 2 hrs live and Charlotte being Charlotte will take a lead from Engfa ( if Engfa is not playful - she won’t be too playful as well - not the clingy Charlotte we see in the past) this I believe they have both grown up to be more professional and mature in their interactions. They have to try and find their way back to each other to the beginning when they first met and really understand that they may not be couple in real life but they have a bond that is beyond any relationships and that they can support each other. Engfa is so the One and Only born in this era and fans are lucky to meet this beautiful talented lady but hope she does not get burnt out - otherwise it be fatal for her especially in her health. Charlotte is very sweet and talented and she has gown these past two years with confidence (although you can see she still have some insecurities that she is facing) but she is still young and I believe she will get better and better - she is unique in her own way and I am not surprised that she is much loved - u can see that she genuinely care for Engfa and all her friends, she is also one that stand up for her friends and support them. I believe that their upcoming USA TRIP will be different from the very first one - it’s more of a working partnership now unless they both had to let go of what is troubling them and talk to each other and ask themselves this “ do we truly want to walk in success together” and be there for each other other no matter what happens - do they want to let go of the special and unique relationship they had built over the past 2 years? We don’t know what is happening here - only they know themselves or those close to them - no matter what let’s respect- support- love them and give them space. If everyone loves them for who they are - leave the toxicity negative comments behind: just b there for them and don’t have too much expectations put on them. They are their own persons in their own rights and I believe both of them have a great future in their careers - their personal lives (whether is it together or not) - apologies for this long post 💕
Beautiful post❤
@@JC-hg4oc than you 💕
ต้องบอกว่าพวกเขามีหุ้นส่วนที่ดีในการขายและโต้ตอบกับแฟนๆ แต่ใครๆ ก็รู้สึกว่ามันเป็นเรื่องธุรกิจ และไม่มีความสนุกเลยในการขายสดครั้งก่อน (ถ้าได้ไปดูอีก); มีบางอย่างเปลี่ยนไปกับพวกเขา - บางทีตอนนี้พวกเขาอาจ "เป็นผู้ใหญ่" มากขึ้นโดยให้ความสำคัญกับอาชีพการงานอย่างจริงจัง พวกเขาทั้งคู่อาจรู้ว่าพวกเขาต้องผ่านพายุหมุนเมื่อสองปีที่แล้วเมื่อพวกเขาถูกส่งมาเป็นคู่รัก “อิงลอต” และอาจทำให้ชีวิตส่วนตัวของพวกเขาลำบากเช่นกัน ทุกความเคลื่อนไหว ทุกมิตรภาพนอกจากนั้น ยังถูกวิพากษ์วิจารณ์อีกด้วย ความเป็นส่วนตัวของพวกเขาถูกเปิดเผย และแฟนๆ บางคนก็มองว่า "การจัดส่ง" โดยไม่มีบริบท อิงฟ้าบอกหลายครั้งว่าจะเป็นมากกว่า "พี่น้อง" ไม่ได้ เหมือนมีความสัมพันธ์กันไม่ได้ผล - การทำงานร่วมกันเป็นเรื่องยาก ชาร์ลอตต์พูดถูกตั้งแต่แรกว่าเธอเคารพอิงฟ้าและปฏิบัติต่อเธอเหมือนน้องสาวและรักเธอที่คอยอยู่เคียงข้างเธอ ฉันเชื่อว่าหญิงฟาคือ "พลัง" ที่อยู่เบื้องหลังชาร์ล็อตต์ที่นำทางเธอ สอนเธอและสนับสนุนเธอ อาจเป็นได้ว่าเธอ "ตกหลุมรัก" กับชาร์ลอตต์และต้องการมากกว่านี้ แต่ชาร์ลอตต์ (จำไว้ว่าเธอเป็นผู้หญิงตรง) และไม่เคยคบกับผู้หญิงเลย ความรู้สึกที่เธอมีต่ออิงฟ้าจริงใจในแง่ “มากกว่ารัก” ต่อพี่สาว เพื่อน ครู พี่เลี้ยง ฯลฯ แต่อาจจะไม่ใช่ในตอนแรก ปีที่แล้วเธออาจจะหรืออาจมีความรู้สึกกับอิงฟ้าแบบโรแมนติกก็ได้ แต่ขอยอมรับมัน เธออาจจะกลัวเหมือนกัน เพราะมันเป็นดินแดนที่ไม่รู้จักสำหรับคุณ แม้ว่าอิงฟ้าจะอยู่ในกลุ่ม LGBT มาหลายปีแล้ว แต่หากทั้งคู่ไม่ประสบผลสำเร็จก็อาจจบลงอย่างเลวร้ายสำหรับทั้งคู่ โดยเฉพาะชาร์ลอตต์ (ถ้าเธอแต่งงานกับผู้ชาย)
Thank you, I explained all my thinking on the subject
I think their feelings right now is not genuine anymore, specifically engfa, she does englot things only like its the rules that she cant espcape cause they have big fan base,,, and their chemistry is not good anymore, i love engfa im a big fan of hers, but sometimes i feel pity for charlot… if you go through their insta story or anything you can clearly tell that…. Anyway forever englot❤
Wow so fast in translating. Thank you!
Спасибо большое за перевод ❤❤❤❤
Thank you so much❤
Mereka terlihat santai.aku sangat menyukainya..tanpa terbebani harus ini dan itu.engfa terlihat santai juga.love englot
Thanks ❤ Englot
Always support them . They have always brought smiles on our faces
Thank you for the Eng subs💕
The live looks fun. Especially with the fans. Apparently, P’Fa has seen charlotte’s house but did not come in, because she does not invite P’Fa. Charlotte invite everyone to her house except for P’Fa wow. Wish I could invite P’Fa to my house haha😅
E la prima volta che leggo in italiano che bello grazieeee
1:22:13 Engfa, what are u thinking? swallowing so hard, huh? 😂
Danke
Thanks for you translate
真可愛的一對夫婦❤
Please post videos of USA concert also ADMIN
What is the name of the song that played?
❤❤❤❤❤
ขวัญใจมุสลิม
They are still cute but it is a time were all boxes needs to be checked on both of them. I have watched about ever clip , movie and videos of these lovely ladies. They have a lot of growning up to do you can use the word love any time to everybody that just a word beening thowed around , love cherish and obey with all your heart not only accept all there faults and short comings.😢😢 engfa first showed no respect when she ran off for 3 days with that older women and was trying to court charlotte then and repeatedly showed disrespect with all her flirting , drunkeness with over half of the miss grand girls. That alone would of had me running the other way and charlotte was still there putting up with all that mess even after they started sleeping together. Second that sister this and a that please i have 4 stster and we dont ack like that and i love them to death . Charlotte wanted love not a sister she truly love engfa to this day you can see it in her eyes but what one person can take , iam not making excuses for her but if you can't get love from the one you love anyone will go find it somewhere else, and thats just my opinion and i didnt say that what she did. Third and with the work they have and all the crazy jobs with so many different peoples coming and going you need to have someone to go home to. And iam not talking about no #### rabbit and dog someone to hear and talk back to hear how there day went and whats coming next . Fourth engfa got fame way to quick and cocky with it she knows she looks good so she can do whatever she wants to do , she's the KING as she put it and she can slay anyone of those girls as she may. That in itself is so disrespectful not only to those contestants but to herself as well , no women or man should ack or think like that . And the fans is the biggest problem cause they the one's got her thinking like that. Money and fame will change you in a good way or bad way , if you are not careful engfa in the next 5 to 10 years you might have money but the fame and that special someone will be gone. Charlotte you are very very very talented and you or getting better every day , please get a back bone and stop 🛑 running behind engfa she is not worth it and she have proving that over and over again. Reach for the stars you have a very good start the world is at your feet , You're young you're beautiful and very well raised and can get any women are man you want if they don't love you the way you want don't settle protect your heart we only got one.. 🎉🎉🎉HEARTS TO HEARTS ❤❤
Agreed, Charlotte is too kind which is also not good. When Charlotte's MV was released E didn't post or didn't even clicked on like in IG whereas yesterday when E's MV got released C posted on her IG appreciating her MV. E reposted everyone else's post of her MV except the post from C. People sometimes take advantage of C's kind heartedness and I think she should think of her self respect 1st. Fans will always support but most of the time they are with their costars or MGI members. If there is an ego, it's difficult for any true relationship to stay.
Столько ненависти к Энгфа. И совершенно зря.
شكرا على الترجمة
ولكن انجلوت انتهى 💔
كنت حقا اعشق قصتهم و تصرفاتهم العفوية و لكن الان اشعر ان كل شيئ مبتذل و مجرد تمثيل للوصول للشهرة
اعشق انجفا رغم تكبرها و غرورها
و اعشق تشار رغم تررده و خوفه
سادعمكم و لكن بشكل منفصل 😢
وأخيرا حدا عربي بتابعهن فعلا انتهوا بالاصل ايمت ابتدؤا ولا مرة صرحوا انو مروا بمرحلة علاقة رغم الفانز من الاول معن انجفا من البداية صرحت رح تنطر شارلوت وقت اعترفت لها بالمشاعر ماعاد تريدها وفعلا كل شي تغير بسنة 2023 حتى اصدقائهم ماعاد صاروا يسمعوا حكي متل الاول انا برأي كل واحد يمشي بطريق لحال أحسن ورغم هيك اتمنى يكونوا لبعض😢
@@rosaliemelhem1789
ما قلت انهم كانو ع علاقة صريحة بس كان واضح الاعجاب و الحب بينهم في حلقة مفقودة ما بيحكو عنها شكلا موضوع بيخص العقد لانهم دايما بيتركو الموضوع للوقت
رح اعمل متابعة ل قناتك ع اليوتيوب لنضل ع تواصل ❤️ في اكتر من شخص عربي عم يتابعهم
Tx sub indo