This story is one of the rare cases where Sherlock Holmes makes a mistake! 🔍 Why do you think Holmes was wrong in this case? Did the complexity of human emotions outweigh logic? Share your thoughts in the comments! 💬📚
Holmes is used to dealing with crimes and logical puzzles, but this case was driven by human emotions and a mother's love. That’s something even he couldn't fully understand.
Great analysis! 🌟 This was indeed one of those rare cases where Holmes missed the emotional aspect of things. Thank you so much for your insightful comment and for being such a loyal supporter! 🙏😊 Stay tuned, there are more exciting stories coming your way soon! 📚🎙️
I enjoyed the narration and intonation. You have a great voice for this,breathing control,intonation and stress on the right parts.If this is a hobby for you,it suits you very well and it’s pleasing for listeners.
"Thank you so much for your kind words! I'm glad to hear that you enjoyed the narration and found it pleasing. I truly appreciate your feedback, and I'm excited to continue sharing more stories. If there are any specific tales you'd like to hear next, feel free to let me know!"
@@MagicalDreamPort I’m still binge watching the old ones cause your channel was recommended to me a few weeks back.I’m enjoying it very much,you’re very much welcome and talented too.
"It was a great story, I really enjoyed it! The way Sherlock Holmes solved this mystery was incredible. Effie Munro's secret really surprised me. It seems like there’s some confusion in the comments, but the most important part is how Holmes uncovered the secret. The narration was neither too fast nor too slow. I think it was just right. Please keep sharing such wonderful stories!"
"Thank you so much for your great feedback! I'm really glad you enjoyed the story and found the narration pace to be ideal. I’ve been working on this for a long time, and I’ve received quite a bit of feedback on this aspect in other stories as well. The way Sherlock Holmes solves mysteries is always fascinating, isn’t it? I’ll be making short videos that explain his methods of solving cases too. I’ll continue with new stories. Stay tuned!"
That sounds really exciting! Watching short videos about how Sherlock Holmes solves cases would be amazing. I also want to say I really enjoy your narration style, the stories flow so smoothly. Looking forward to your new videos!
Thank you! I'm really glad you enjoyed my narration style. I plan to make short videos explaining how Sherlock Holmes works. Thank you for your supportive comments. I’m doing my best to deliver the best content I can. Stay tuned!
Thank you! I'm glad you found 'The Yellow Face' to be a great story about America. The themes of struggle and identity are indeed profound. I appreciate your insight!
“Thank you so much for sharing your thoughts, @jclamay! 😊 I totally understand where you’re coming from. Ads can sometimes interrupt the experience, especially with sleep stories. I truly appreciate your feedback and will keep it in mind to improve the listening experience. I hope the stories still brought you some relaxation! 💛”
“Thank you so much for sharing your thoughts, @jclamay! 😊 I totally understand your point. Ads can sometimes interrupt the experience, especially with sleep stories. I'll definitely keep that in mind for the future. By the way, I'd love to hear what you thought about the story itself! Did it help you relax? 💛”
"Thank you for your comment! I understand that ads can sometimes be a bit disruptive, but they do help support the channel and allow me to keep creating content. I truly appreciate your support and hope you enjoyed the story! Please feel free to share any other thoughts or suggestions you have."
"Thank you for your comment! In the story, Effie Munro is indeed divorced before her current marriage. However, the plot primarily revolves around her relationship with her husband and a significant secret she is hiding. This mystery is one of the most exciting aspects of the story. If you have any more questions, feel free to ask!"
"In the story, Effie Munro has divorced her first husband in the past and later remarried. However, the main mystery that Holmes investigates concerns a significant secret that Effie is hiding in her second marriage. I want to emphasize that the issue of divorce is not at the forefront of the story."
@@elizabetharce5041 "Thank you! Actually, in the story, Effie Munro’s first husband didn’t die in a fire. She divorced him and later remarried, but kept some important secrets from her second husband. Holmes investigates those secrets to solve the mystery. I appreciate your comment and feedback!"
"Thank you for your comment! I understand that 'The Yellow Face' may not feel as strong as other Sherlock Holmes stories for some readers. However, this story highlights Holmes’ insights into human nature, which makes it unique in its own way. I value every comment, and I truly appreciate your feedback!"
'The Yellow Face' might feel a bit different from other Sherlock Holmes stories because, in this case, Holmes is actually wrong. This story is interesting as it highlights his human side and his ability to make mistakes. While Holmes is usually known for his perfect deductions, this time he misinterprets the situation and later admits his mistake. In this sense, the story reveals a rarer aspect of Sherlock. I appreciate you sharing your perspective!"
I disagree with this comment.This is my favorite story because it highlights Holmes’ repeated advice of not jumping to conclusions and to leave room in a theory to the truth to reveal itself by the developments that emerge.Being confident in probabilities often leads to rushed speculation,Norbury is the word to remind him that unless it’s confirmed by facts,it can still be just an assumption. Also I prefer the original strand magazine’s wording of the last words from her husband to Effie: (…)It was a long two minutes before Grant Munro broke the silence,and when his answer came it was one of which I love to think.He lifted the little child,kissed her,and then,still carrying her,he held his other hand out to his wife and turned towards the door.”We can talk it over more comfortably at home”,said he.”I am not a very good man,Effie,but I think that I am a better one than you have given me credit for being.” It shows that he had no prejudice even if all society did,and that little girl was to him,a daughter,not something to be ashamed or hidden away. So, this is one of my favorite stories cause it shows that even Sherlock Holmes could be led astray in his deductions when he let his mind be taken by over confidence.
"Thank you, you've provided a very valuable perspective! It’s true that 'The Yellow Face' can resonate differently with different readers. Seeing that even Sherlock Holmes can make mistakes and be led astray at times makes his character more human. As you rightly pointed out, Norbury serves as a reminder for Holmes to act on facts, not assumptions. Grant Munro’s final words are indeed powerful; they highlight his humanity and how he rises above societal prejudices. Thank you again for sharing your thoughts, I believe this perspective will be valuable for other viewers as well."
Thank you for your feedback! I kept the narration a bit slow to maintain the mystery of the story, but I’ll definitely take your comment into consideration. Please feel free to check out my other stories, and I’d appreciate it if you could subscribe!
This story is one of the rare cases where Sherlock Holmes makes a mistake! 🔍 Why do you think Holmes was wrong in this case? Did the complexity of human emotions outweigh logic? Share your thoughts in the comments! 💬📚
Holmes is used to dealing with crimes and logical puzzles, but this case was driven by human emotions and a mother's love. That’s something even he couldn't fully understand.
Great analysis! 🌟 This was indeed one of those rare cases where Holmes missed the emotional aspect of things. Thank you so much for your insightful comment and for being such a loyal supporter! 🙏😊 Stay tuned, there are more exciting stories coming your way soon! 📚🎙️
I enjoyed the narration and intonation. You have a great voice for this,breathing control,intonation and stress on the right parts.If this is a hobby for you,it suits you very well and it’s pleasing for listeners.
"Thank you so much for your kind words! I'm glad to hear that you enjoyed the narration and found it pleasing. I truly appreciate your feedback, and I'm excited to continue sharing more stories. If there are any specific tales you'd like to hear next, feel free to let me know!"
@@MagicalDreamPort I’m still binge watching the old ones cause your channel was recommended to me a few weeks back.I’m enjoying it very much,you’re very much welcome and talented too.
"It was a great story, I really enjoyed it! The way Sherlock Holmes solved this mystery was incredible. Effie Munro's secret really surprised me. It seems like there’s some confusion in the comments, but the most important part is how Holmes uncovered the secret. The narration was neither too fast nor too slow. I think it was just right. Please keep sharing such wonderful stories!"
"Thank you so much for your great feedback! I'm really glad you enjoyed the story and found the narration pace to be ideal. I’ve been working on this for a long time, and I’ve received quite a bit of feedback on this aspect in other stories as well. The way Sherlock Holmes solves mysteries is always fascinating, isn’t it? I’ll be making short videos that explain his methods of solving cases too. I’ll continue with new stories. Stay tuned!"
That sounds really exciting! Watching short videos about how Sherlock Holmes solves cases would be amazing. I also want to say I really enjoy your narration style, the stories flow so smoothly. Looking forward to your new videos!
Thank you! I'm really glad you enjoyed my narration style. I plan to make short videos explaining how Sherlock Holmes works. Thank you for your supportive comments. I’m doing my best to deliver the best content I can. Stay tuned!
great story about america, black and blue.
Thank you! I'm glad you found 'The Yellow Face' to be a great story about America. The themes of struggle and identity are indeed profound. I appreciate your insight!
Personally, I don't think sleep stories should not have ads 😢 😮
“Thank you so much for sharing your thoughts, @jclamay! 😊 I totally understand where you’re coming from. Ads can sometimes interrupt the experience, especially with sleep stories. I truly appreciate your feedback and will keep it in mind to improve the listening experience. I hope the stories still brought you some relaxation! 💛”
I like the pictures, love it
"Thank you so much! I'm really glad you liked the pictures. Your support means a lot!"
Well I'm tired but you know what I mean 😅
“Thank you so much for sharing your thoughts, @jclamay! 😊 I totally understand your point. Ads can sometimes interrupt the experience, especially with sleep stories. I'll definitely keep that in mind for the future. By the way, I'd love to hear what you thought about the story itself! Did it help you relax? 💛”
What a shame I discontinued too many ads
"Thank you for your comment! I understand that ads can sometimes be a bit disruptive, but they do help support the channel and allow me to keep creating content. I truly appreciate your support and hope you enjoyed the story! Please feel free to share any other thoughts or suggestions you have."
He encounters his husband?
And at the beginning she was divorced.
"Thank you for your comment! In the story, Effie Munro is indeed divorced before her current marriage. However, the plot primarily revolves around her relationship with her husband and a significant secret she is hiding. This mystery is one of the most exciting aspects of the story. If you have any more questions, feel free to ask!"
"In the story, Effie Munro has divorced her first husband in the past and later remarried. However, the main mystery that Holmes investigates concerns a significant secret that Effie is hiding in her second marriage. I want to emphasize that the issue of divorce is not at the forefront of the story."
I thought her first husband died in a fire in Atlanta? She divorced a dead man?
@@elizabetharce5041 "Thank you! Actually, in the story, Effie Munro’s first husband didn’t die in a fire. She divorced him and later remarried, but kept some important secrets from her second husband. Holmes investigates those secrets to solve the mystery. I appreciate your comment and feedback!"
Disappointing, not worthy of Sherlock Holmes’ effort; story is so very common place. Not up to ACD’s usual standard
"Thank you for your comment! I understand that 'The Yellow Face' may not feel as strong as other Sherlock Holmes stories for some readers. However, this story highlights Holmes’ insights into human nature, which makes it unique in its own way. I value every comment, and I truly appreciate your feedback!"
'The Yellow Face' might feel a bit different from other Sherlock Holmes stories because, in this case, Holmes is actually wrong. This story is interesting as it highlights his human side and his ability to make mistakes. While Holmes is usually known for his perfect deductions, this time he misinterprets the situation and later admits his mistake. In this sense, the story reveals a rarer aspect of Sherlock. I appreciate you sharing your perspective!"
I disagree with this comment.This is my favorite story because it highlights Holmes’ repeated advice of not jumping to conclusions and to leave room in a theory to the truth to reveal itself by the developments that emerge.Being confident in probabilities often leads to rushed speculation,Norbury is the word to remind him that unless it’s confirmed by facts,it can still be just an assumption.
Also I prefer the original strand magazine’s wording of the last words from her husband to Effie:
(…)It was a long two minutes before Grant Munro broke the silence,and when his answer came it was one of which I love to think.He lifted the little child,kissed her,and then,still carrying her,he held his other hand out to his wife and turned towards the door.”We can talk it over more comfortably at home”,said he.”I am not a very good man,Effie,but I think that I am a better one than you have given me credit for being.”
It shows that he had no prejudice even if all society did,and that little girl was to him,a daughter,not something to be ashamed or hidden away.
So, this is one of my favorite stories cause it shows that even Sherlock Holmes could be led astray in his deductions when he let his mind be taken by over confidence.
"Thank you, you've provided a very valuable perspective! It’s true that 'The Yellow Face' can resonate differently with different readers. Seeing that even Sherlock Holmes can make mistakes and be led astray at times makes his character more human. As you rightly pointed out, Norbury serves as a reminder for Holmes to act on facts, not assumptions. Grant Munro’s final words are indeed powerful; they highlight his humanity and how he rises above societal prejudices. Thank you again for sharing your thoughts, I believe this perspective will be valuable for other viewers as well."
I don’t agree with you. Look beyond the story. You will get the meaning of the story.
To slow to hold my interest
Thank you for your feedback! I kept the narration a bit slow to maintain the mystery of the story, but I’ll definitely take your comment into consideration. Please feel free to check out my other stories, and I’d appreciate it if you could subscribe!
Perfect for me
I adjusted to 1:25 speed -- easy enough -- and pace went along just right ...
** too **