supernatural means some thing that can be done ,which a normal human can not do. and as per my knowledge here is a supernatural case seen in NEPAL. In Nepal there is a small boy who is differently able and did something that a normal kid cant do. He just wrote and predicted the future about country PM years ago and also wrote different languages and now he is even worshipped as incarnation of god. if supernatural doesnt exit then what it is ? His name is Aaditya Dahal aka google boy of Nepal.
@@rohitgiri8692if supernatural means something that can be done and a normal human cannot do that does that mean formation of black holes or creation of a lifeform is supernatural? because as far as I know, not even extreme humans can produce black holes etc. and in your example, that's prediction or coincidence or (although can't agree on it fully)superhuman in someway, NOT supernatural cause all of his doings and he himself is within nature
@@nischay6932 I am not saying anything about the formation of blackholes or creation of a lifeforms as a supernatural thing, even i consider all life and this universe as a natural phenomenon. I am just telling, the things which can be done by human, that a normal human cannot do is something supernatural. it doesn't point towards all blackholes and stuff. My point is about that person Aaditya Dahal who is doing things that normal human can't do and how is it possible that a kid who is just a kid can do prediction and write languages.
In simple terms he is saying what would it take me to believe that god exist My answer is " if god come in front of me then only I will start believing god " simple 👍
What shit, if you don't know something with solid evidence, just say i don't know or i will tell you later if I came to know about it.. why to make up answers if you don't know, we are not giving an exam in which attempting all questions is compulsory@No-I-dont-want-that
The scientists, historians, and other scholars are doing their work, they are trying to know the unknown, what we can seek is their true researches and knowledge based on those researches, till now no evidence is for god or how universe was created, we know about big bang but not about what was before big bang, so only thing we can say is we don't know what was before big bang happened and what was before universe began to expand, scientists are doing their research and we should use the most recent and sensible research and we are doing that
@@lasyak6355 Satya Anveshi, Rama Pandita, Bairi Naresh are good Telugu atheism channels. Indian humanists is another channel that has good videos especially of babu gogineni.
There is a recent video by Bharadwaj brothers on why Annamalai is important for South India. That video was kinda problematic for me! Can you analyse it?
Vimoh should have more emphasized the fact in addition to Math there are observations as well, which is comprehensible rather than an abstract mystical entity called God. crux of the argument is, when asked to provide some kind of logical evidence of God which is flimsy. Instead of saying "I don't know" the theists eventually will fall back to belief and faith
एक आदमी शराबी दोस्त को पकडकर घर लेजारहा था, और देखने वालो को दोनों ही शराबी दिखरहा था। Forgive me for the comment 🙏 But the discussion is very soothing. Thank you!
This is the problem with learning Science from priests, maulvis and pandits etc. Science is way past "Just equations" about the big bang. Science never accepts anything that is "Just equations" (string theory being a great example). It always needs to be backed up by experiments and observations. It was Einstein who first got to the equation that indicated towards an expanding universe (and there by a Big bang). He put in a lot of thought and a balancing factor into the equations to stop the universe from expanding. Later, observations of the universe showed that is is actually expanding and it turned out that the only mistake Einstein made, was thinking that he made a mistake. Today, we can literally see galaxies moving away from each other at a faster and faster rate. It was initially a "common sense" speculation that they must have been all at same place at some point of time. Later, it was estimated (more like calculated) what would have been the effect of present day universe of it was all crammed into one point. All these estimations (One of them being the cosmic microwave background, that Vimoh alluded to) were also "Observed" to be true. There is hard proof for the occurrence of the big bang even if it was not observed directly. It is like saying, sure, all the streets are wet, buildings are wet, trees and cars are wet but you did not see it rain, how can you be sure that it rained? I on the other hand, firmly believed that a supernatural being (whatever that means) came in with an invisible, silent helicopter and sprayed everything with water or perhaps made everything start sweating. You should respect my beliefs and also join me in since both of us did not see it rain from the clouds ourselves.
Dear Sir, I thoroughly enjoy watching your videos. Despite being an atheist, my perspective changed after watching Acharya Prashant. Since then, it has become challenging for me to maintain my atheistic beliefs, and I find myself drawn towards Advaita Vedanta philosophy. I would appreciate it if you could share your thoughts or reactions to his videos on God and Advaita Vedanta. Thank you
It could be possible that there was few mans like Ram, krishna, etc in past who had said that i am every where but actually he means that God is everywhere. God means qualities of those persons (Rama, Krishna, etc). Am I right?
I am really confused about what actually works? I mean, the guy kind of transitioned from finding the truth to being ignorant and proving you wrong, or maybe he's just trying to make you understand that you don't understand something that he does, which for him is very clear without any confusion or doubt. It makes me confused about understanding their emotions and what they actually want...
supernatural means some thing that can be done ,which a normal human can not do. and as per my knowledge here is a supernatural case seen in NEPAL. In Nepal there is a small boy who is differently able and did something that a normal kid cant do. He just wrote and predicted the future about country PM years ago and also wrote different languages and now he is even worshipped as incarnation of god. if supernatural doesnt exit then what it is ? His name is Aaditya Dahal aka google boy of Nepal.
@skylight3857 “I can understand [...] with same arguments” =================== Actually, it is the same, refuted, debunked arguments. I would not be surprised if it turns out that dealing with such callers day in and day out for about 20 years, is one of the reasons for Matthew Dillahunty's heart-related problems.
My definition goes like schrodingër's cat and box. God is null and void box could be anything till you can think, unless you open the box. When you open the box and put your hand or look into it there you find nothing. Now as you are sure there's nothing you tell others but they don't believe because they don't want to give up their beliefs and resist showing.
lets say if there is no god. then what's let human being to believe in some super natural being. even a study carried out on new babies they also believed in some super natural being. what are your thoughts on that @vimoh
The caller wanted to say that like scientists have equations as proof , our priests have holy books as a proof; if u believe in scientific theory then why don't u believe in theological theory
Caller g mujhe nahi pata aapki mother language konsi hai north india mai hindi samjhte hain isliye likh raha hoon hindi mai, jitni baar aaapne like like like like like bola hai mai daawe se keh sakta hoon k aapki mother language english toh bilkul nahi ho sakti, aur agar mai galt nahi hoon south indian accent bhi nahi hai aapka , toh isme hamara ayr aapka faida ho jata agar aap hindi mai samjhane ki koshish karte shayad acche se point rakh paate , mujhe 2 baar rewind karni padi vedio called or coled samjhne k liye , aaaghe se dhyaan rakhna accent accent mai log samjte nahi hain agar aapki mother language hindi nahi hai aur agar aapko nahi aaati toh maafi chahta hoon mera maksad hurt karne ka nahi hai aur naale comunal way se keh raha hoon
Definition of God. God is one without the second. He is iternal. He has no mother and father nor children. He is unique. He doesn’t require food and sleep. He is all powerful. He is generous, kind and merciful. He is the creator of all things that exist.
God is someone who created everything. from soul to rock to sky to universe i.e. what is visible human being and beyond human visibility and imagination.
@noobplayer6388 God is someone [...] beyond human visibility and imagination.” ================== Nice claims that so far have no credible evidence, no irrefutable evidence to support them.
@@ex.hindu.now.atheist even you don't have evidence to deny it. that there is no god but we have at least a faith in religious scriptures that they provide guidance to mankind and how to live the life and its purpose ? can you tell me the purpose of life and why you live the life the way you are living.
@@noobplayer6388we don't have evidences against God but we have physics that denies god ..we have debunked fake people's fake claims on gods...we have have evidences for things that completely denies the evidence of God...but what bout you?..."faith"
vimoh why dont you have a discussion with muhammad hijab or mansoor from dawahwise or saboor ahmed? they are both very friendly and gentle people, it will be fun to see you discuss your perspectives and gain some understanding. bring in Islam into the discussion too.
Dear caller, defining a word doesn't make the word "REAL"!
Bro are you an agnostic or aethiest
Theists had only extraordinary claims from Centuries .
Its good you stay at solid base point god.
Your argument is sharp and logical
How, Why and what...these three words shatters their world away
Well, He should first decide the boundary between *"Natural"* and *"Supernatural"*
supernatural means some thing that can be done ,which a normal human can not do.
and
as per my knowledge
here is a supernatural case
seen in NEPAL.
In Nepal there is a small boy who is differently able and did something that a normal kid cant do. He just wrote and predicted the future about country PM years ago
and also wrote different languages and now he is even worshipped as incarnation of god.
if supernatural doesnt exit then what it is ?
His name is Aaditya Dahal aka google boy of Nepal.
@@rohitgiri8692if supernatural means something that can be done and a normal human cannot do that
does that mean formation of black holes or creation of a lifeform is supernatural? because as far as I know, not even extreme humans can produce black holes etc.
and in your example, that's prediction or coincidence or (although can't agree on it fully)superhuman in someway, NOT supernatural cause all of his doings and he himself is within nature
@@nischay6932 I am not saying anything about the formation of blackholes or creation of a lifeforms
as a supernatural thing, even i consider all life and this universe as a natural phenomenon.
I am just telling,
the things which can be done by human, that a normal human cannot do is something supernatural.
it doesn't point towards all blackholes and stuff.
My point is about that person Aaditya Dahal who is doing things that normal human can't do
and how is it possible that a kid who is just a kid can do prediction and write languages.
@@rohitgiri8692that's superhuman.
@@therealkendallroy
yes
i think he is also superhuman
and he goes beating around the bush
Such brilliant clarity of thoughts!
Its observational almost all the way to the big bang. We have literally seen it.
Bhai aapki video play krte he 1st ad astrotalk ka aaya 😂😂
use youtube vanced, no ads👍
@@jayeshchandawat4328 chl ni rha bro wo ab 🥲
In simple terms he is saying what would it take me to believe that god exist
My answer is " if god come in front of me then only I will start believing god " simple 👍
Very strong reasoning vimoh sir hats off
Vimoh, is it possible for you to make a video on Ontological argument and debunk it on your main channel? Would really appreciate it.
Alex oconnor, sam harris, stephen woodford, gms etc have already debunked it. Check em out if they interest you.
'Why there is something rather than nothing?'
This is a famous question, I would like to hear it from you. Your statements are unique.
He would simply say " I don't know"
@@mdnoman7032 agnostic shit yeah
What shit, if you don't know something with solid evidence, just say i don't know or i will tell you later if I came to know about it.. why to make up answers if you don't know, we are not giving an exam in which attempting all questions is compulsory@No-I-dont-want-that
@@VishalYadav00003 Always try to find out the reason/origin or assume the answer.
The scientists, historians, and other scholars are doing their work, they are trying to know the unknown, what we can seek is their true researches and knowledge based on those researches, till now no evidence is for god or how universe was created, we know about big bang but not about what was before big bang, so only thing we can say is we don't know what was before big bang happened and what was before universe began to expand, scientists are doing their research and we should use the most recent and sensible research and we are doing that
I dont understand why people believe on things Which doesn't make sense
That was a heck of a talk ❤🎉
He blabbered the same in telugu channel 'Talk Rationally'
Oh never knew that there was a Telugu Atheist channel, will check it out.
@@lasyak6355 don't u know any telugu channels
@@VIKRAMARKUDUFRONTJPG I know Telugu channels in general, but not those which revolve around Atheism and rationality.
@@lasyak6355 Satya Anveshi, Rama Pandita, Bairi Naresh are good Telugu atheism channels. Indian humanists is another channel that has good videos especially of babu gogineni.
@@harshithamuthyala2701 Thanks for the recommendations! Will check them out.
There is a recent video by Bharadwaj brothers on why Annamalai is important for South India. That video was kinda problematic for me! Can you analyse it?
#PROUDATHIEST ❤ thanks VIMOH
Actually. It is observational. Because we are seeing back in time. Billions of years. The farther the light we see
Vimoh should have more emphasized the fact in addition to Math there are observations as well, which is comprehensible rather than an abstract mystical entity called God.
crux of the argument is, when asked to provide some kind of logical evidence of God which is flimsy. Instead of saying "I don't know" the theists eventually will fall back to belief and faith
Kukdu kukdu is personal 👽
You are yourself confused😂
Pixie dust believer found ☝️
Kukdukuk 😂
I believe in unicorns, elves, pixies, leprechauns and ogres. Please dont ask me to prove their existence. I just know they exist.
एक आदमी शराबी दोस्त को पकडकर घर लेजारहा था, और देखने वालो को दोनों ही शराबी दिखरहा था। Forgive me for the comment 🙏 But the discussion is very soothing. Thank you!
This is the problem with learning Science from priests, maulvis and pandits etc.
Science is way past "Just equations" about the big bang. Science never accepts anything that is "Just equations" (string theory being a great example). It always needs to be backed up by experiments and observations.
It was Einstein who first got to the equation that indicated towards an expanding universe (and there by a Big bang). He put in a lot of thought and a balancing factor into the equations to stop the universe from expanding. Later, observations of the universe showed that is is actually expanding and it turned out that the only mistake Einstein made, was thinking that he made a mistake.
Today, we can literally see galaxies moving away from each other at a faster and faster rate. It was initially a "common sense" speculation that they must have been all at same place at some point of time. Later, it was estimated (more like calculated) what would have been the effect of present day universe of it was all crammed into one point. All these estimations (One of them being the cosmic microwave background, that Vimoh alluded to) were also "Observed" to be true. There is hard proof for the occurrence of the big bang even if it was not observed directly.
It is like saying, sure, all the streets are wet, buildings are wet, trees and cars are wet but you did not see it rain, how can you be sure that it rained? I on the other hand, firmly believed that a supernatural being (whatever that means) came in with an invisible, silent helicopter and sprayed everything with water or perhaps made everything start sweating. You should respect my beliefs and also join me in since both of us did not see it rain from the clouds ourselves.
Dear Sir, I thoroughly enjoy watching your videos. Despite being an atheist, my perspective changed after watching Acharya Prashant. Since then, it has become challenging for me to maintain my atheistic beliefs, and I find myself drawn towards Advaita Vedanta philosophy. I would appreciate it if you could share your thoughts or reactions to his videos on God and Advaita Vedanta. Thank you
Nice debate 👍
02:44 amazing random out of context timestamp
It could be possible that there was few mans like Ram, krishna, etc in past who had said that i am every where but actually he means that God is everywhere. God means qualities of those persons (Rama, Krishna, etc).
Am I right?
You're wrong
The biggest proof that God doesn't exist are the poor beggars sitting outside the temple.
2:44 haha haha. 🤣🤣
Hey, when they say God made it, can you ask them out of what?
Sir , aapka video aa66a lagta hai , or sunna bhi chahta hut , lekin hindi language thora jyada use karte to aa66a hota🙃❤️
2:44 😂
I am really confused about what actually works? I mean, the guy kind of transitioned from finding the truth to being ignorant and proving you wrong, or maybe he's just trying to make you understand that you don't understand something that he does, which for him is very clear without any confusion or doubt. It makes me confused about understanding their emotions and what they actually want...
supernatural means some thing that can be done ,which a normal human can not do.
and
as per my knowledge
here is a supernatural case
seen in NEPAL.
In Nepal there is a small boy who is differently able and did something that a normal kid cant do. He just wrote and predicted the future about country PM years ago
and also wrote different languages and now he is even worshipped as incarnation of god.
if supernatural doesnt exit then what it is ?
His name is Aaditya Dahal aka google boy of Nepal.
I can understand why vimoh stop taking callers cuz everytime they come up with same arguments
@skylight3857
“I can understand [...] with same arguments”
===================
Actually, it is the same, refuted, debunked arguments.
I would not be surprised if it turns out that dealing with such callers day in and day out for about 20 years, is one of the reasons for Matthew Dillahunty's heart-related problems.
debate with shudhanshu trivedi
Sir ap hindi me satrim is chanel konsi hay
Yehi channel hai. Jo jis bhasha mein poochhta hai usi bhasha mein jawab de deta hoon.
❤❤❤❤ amazing
My definition goes like schrodingër's cat and box. God is null and void box could be anything till you can think, unless you open the box. When you open the box and put your hand or look into it there you find nothing. Now as you are sure there's nothing you tell others but they don't believe because they don't want to give up their beliefs and resist showing.
how annoying the other person is, my guy is stuttering like hell
Theists basically fear from accepting the reality
Vimoh, I may be wrong but I think you may be an Igtheist as well. Have you given that position a thought?
Yes. I think you are right. But since an atheist is someone who lacks belief n god, I think an igtheist is an atheist as well.
Yes you are correct.
Love it
Science neither proves nor disproves the existence of God.. There is no such kind of experiment that proves the existence of God. 😄
lets say if there is no god. then what's let human being to believe in some super natural being. even a study carried out on new babies they also believed in some super natural being. what are your thoughts on that @vimoh
Great
Iskka to accent bhi nakli hai
Bro make video on black magic
❤
🌄🐔🐔🐔
The caller wanted to say that like scientists have equations as proof , our priests have holy books as a proof; if u believe in scientific theory then why don't u believe in theological theory
I mean we can apply those equations to the real world and they work.
While holy books are just words which just say stuff
@@Ashraf_Zholy books are just fictional novels and comics used for entertainment nothing else
Caller g mujhe nahi pata aapki mother language konsi hai north india mai hindi samjhte hain isliye likh raha hoon hindi mai, jitni baar aaapne like like like like like bola hai mai daawe se keh sakta hoon k aapki mother language english toh bilkul nahi ho sakti, aur agar mai galt nahi hoon south indian accent bhi nahi hai aapka , toh isme hamara ayr aapka faida ho jata agar aap hindi mai samjhane ki koshish karte shayad acche se point rakh paate , mujhe 2 baar rewind karni padi vedio called or coled samjhne k liye , aaaghe se dhyaan rakhna accent accent mai log samjte nahi hain agar aapki mother language hindi nahi hai aur agar aapko nahi aaati toh maafi chahta hoon mera maksad hurt karne ka nahi hai aur naale comunal way se keh raha hoon
Definition of God.
God is one without the second.
He is iternal.
He has no mother and father nor children. He is unique. He doesn’t require food and sleep. He is all powerful. He is generous, kind and merciful. He is the creator of all things that exist.
God is someone who created everything. from soul to rock to sky to universe i.e. what is visible human being and beyond human visibility and imagination.
@noobplayer6388
God is someone [...] beyond human visibility and imagination.”
==================
Nice claims that so far have no credible evidence, no irrefutable evidence to support them.
@@ex.hindu.now.atheist even you don't have evidence to deny it. that there is no god but we have at least a faith in religious scriptures that they provide guidance to mankind and how to live the life and its purpose ? can you tell me the purpose of life and why you live the life the way you are living.
@@noobplayer6388we don't have evidences against God but we have physics that denies god ..we have debunked fake people's fake claims on gods...we have have evidences for things that completely denies the evidence of God...but what bout you?..."faith"
vimoh why dont you have a discussion with muhammad hijab or mansoor from dawahwise or saboor ahmed? they are both very friendly and gentle people, it will be fun to see you discuss your perspectives and gain some understanding. bring in Islam into the discussion too.
This bit at @04:55 is funny.
bro stuck in loop about supernatural 🫡