@@beachfanatic2010 I most definitely agree. Her instrument is pretty big but also quite soft and warm, it doesn't quite have the piercing, explosive quality of a soprano drammatico.
@@freethinker8686 Let’s completely disregard that she is anything near or close to a dramatic soprano whom are extremely rare voice. If anything a Spinto but if Tebaldi and Leonie Rysanek were spinto soprano, Voigt is nowhere near them cause their voices are much bigger and much more metallic.
In my opinion, I believe she got real old school training... so many singers today think that opening their mouths as wide as possible is the key... Her jaw is comfortably relaxed and never overextended for power or range. Just truly brilliant, exciting singing...
I just adore when true dramatic soprano tackle spinto rep. Such a solid wall of sound up and down that register; I'd never heard her sing this, and was delighted with the post. Thanks a million!
Here's what she said in Nov. 2006: Q. What new pretty-girl roles do you want to tackle with your new body? A. I really want to do ``La Fanciulla del West.'' I want to do a lot more Salomes and Toscas. Also Manon Lescaut. Brunnhilde is coming down the pipeline, not that she's necessarily a pretty girl, but I'll be able to wield that spear a lot more easily.
Unfortunately none of that happened as the voice fell apart and deteriorated .Voight was an Artist I enjoyed and her sound was glorious. Her being a big Lady never bothered me as she commanded the stage and had star quality The surgery for weight loss was a grave mistake. She should have left her body and the voice within it alone. She was never the same Artist afterward.
This is the Deborah Voigt we all love - a truly wonderful singer. If only she had lost just a few kilos ( which she would have felt the benefit of) rather than so many which no doubt disturbed her vocal support. However her physical change is long complete now and even if her voice divides public and critics she still has admirable artistic qualities.
There is no point in speculating (i) Ms. Voigt would have "felt the benefit of" some lesser weight loss (we are not her physicians) or (ii) what effect some other weight loss would have had on her voice. In any event, all artists experience changes in their voices throughout their operatic careers. This clip is 17 years old. Who can possibly say what Ms. Voigt would sound like now without the weight loss? It's all speculation.
She sounds quite good here, and the voice sounds much richer and bigger than now. Has anyone here heard her pre and post surgery? I'd be curios to know if her voice has lost volume afterwards.
I've heard this solo done several times by students during Met Opera regional auditions. No one sent a chill down my spine like she does here. I'm trying to find more posts of her singing after surgery, to try to compare if there's a major difference in the voice.
I haven't heard her since the surgery - but I will later this year. I used to love to say that you knew the show was over when she sang. Has she really lost a lot of weight? I guess I won't be able to say that any more. Well, all the more power to her, especially if she can still sing like this. She sends chills down my spine.
I heard her at the Met a couple of years ago just as the news came out about her surgery. I don't know, time will tell. I felt she held back a bit that night. I do think the volume of sound has diminished a great deal, but she is still very, very good. You know; you damn if you do and damned if you don't. . .
I totally agree!!!! And I'm fed up with all this "skinny girl" nonsense. Singing like that she should be able to sing it staged or not staged or wherever the "f" she wants to. This singing is almost perfection and I'm just sick to death of all this weight obsession with opera singers!!!!!!
commandert5 that’s because he was a man and apparently that makes one exempt from overweight criticisms. Meanwhile, if a woman has an extra 10 pounds people harp about it like she’s manufacturing anthrax.
She's better... There's a 60 minutes episode of her after surgery on here that shows here singing the love duet from Tristan und Isolde with Ben Heppner that is out of this world!
Sola, perduta, abbandonata In landa desolata! Orror! Intorno a me S'oscura il ciel... Ahimè, son sola! E nel profondo deserto io cado, Strazio crudel Ah! Solo abbandonata Io, la deserta donna! Ah! Non voglio morir! No, non voglio morir! Tutto dunque è finito. Terra di pace me sembrava questa Terra di pace Me sembrava questa Ahi! Mia beltà funesta, Ire novelle accende Strappar da lui mi si volea Or tutto il mio passato Orribile risorge, E vivo innanzi al guardo mio si posa. Ah! di sangue s'è macchiato. Ah! Tutto è finito! Asil di pace Ora la tomba invoco No! Non voglio morir... Non voglio morir! No, no, non voglio morir Amore, aita!
Unbelievably beautiful. I don’t think anyone can sing this like she can. Dimitrova’ a high notes on this are so harsh it makes me cringe. Voigt’s technique here is flawless.
Lonely forsaken and abandoned All my hope then is over. And in the heart of this desert I'm dying. O wretched hapless woman! I sought this region as a peaceful haven. Ah! Through my fatal beauty Torments afresh surround me They would have severed me from him; Mow all my past does haunt me With fearful pangs of anguish, And rises straight before My eyes to rend me. New dangers come to threaten Only the tomb can release me from my burden. No! Let me not die dearest help me!
She had a marvelous and powerfull voice ! What a great disaster and she was very well interpreting...Now her voice is just ok for "musicals and operettas !!!
Why do the powers that be believe we would rather see a skinny, under-powered soprano with a wobble the size of a truck than a shimmering woman of size like Ms. Voigt?
Großartige dramatische Stimme. Ich verstehe nicht, dass man so ein Theater um ihr Übergewicht gemacht hat. Die Caballe war doch auch nicht schlank. Wahrscheinlich ist das der heutigen Medienpräsenz geschuldet. Jeder soll jung schlank und attraktiv sein.
She gave of herself extravagantly at her peak. No one could surpass this.
Perfect diction, thoroughly involved, right up there with the great interpreters of this role.
These were the days of Deborah Voigt! Such wild abandon and easy singing! It’s just such a joy to watch her!
This is one of the best renditions of this aria that I have heard.
Yes, yes, yes, yes, and YES! The Deborah Voigt that I simply adore. Shimmering focused flowing waves of true dramatic soprano sound.
Except she was never a dramatic soprano. Maybe a Spinto but on the light side. She is a true lyric soprano to me.
@@beachfanatic2010 I most definitely agree. Her instrument is pretty big but also quite soft and warm, it doesn't quite have the piercing, explosive quality of a soprano drammatico.
@@freethinker8686 Let’s completely disregard that she is anything near or close to a dramatic soprano whom are extremely rare voice. If anything a Spinto but if Tebaldi and Leonie Rysanek were spinto soprano, Voigt is nowhere near them cause their voices are much bigger and much more metallic.
Wow! She's got it all here. Beauty and drama and such a command of line. Brava!
In my opinion, I believe she got real old school training... so many singers today think that opening their mouths as wide as possible is the key... Her jaw is comfortably relaxed and never overextended for power or range. Just truly brilliant, exciting singing...
This is so beautiful its unbelievable!
Best version I have ever heard. Perfect vocal production and performed very passionately.
I just adore when true dramatic soprano tackle spinto rep. Such a solid wall of sound up and down that register; I'd never heard her sing this, and was delighted with the post. Thanks a million!
So true!
Agreed!!!!!
A true example of not losing the character even if one sings at a concert or event. Amazing voice... words cannot explain..
It's a very difficult aria and she sings it relly wonderful. davvero bravissima!!
Какой прекрасный голос! Какая прекрасная вокальная техника! Браво, Дебора! Браво, оркестр!
assoluta perfezione
simply amazing. the best
La plus belle voix du monde,❤
My fav aria because I feel like it describes. Fabulous Deborah Voight!
This is the best performance of this aria I've ever seen.
BRAVAAAAAAAAAAA she is the best, i love her interpretation wonderfullllll!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
This is stunning!!!!!
Brava!!!! When singing was singing!!!!!!
Stunningly beautiful! What a great singer. Brava!
So amazingly rich !!! The oboe solos are equally beautiful.
LOVE YOU!!!!! MARAVILLOSA, PERFECTA!!!
Perfect tone throughout. Even dipping into her chest voice on "son' sola" (at 1:40) is seamless and not the least bit coarse.
Bravo!!! She is breathtaking
So splendid🎶.....wow she spent her teen years in Orange County...my neck of the woods.
Here's what she said in Nov. 2006:
Q. What new pretty-girl roles do you want to tackle with your new body? A. I really want to do ``La Fanciulla del West.'' I want to do a lot more Salomes and Toscas. Also Manon Lescaut. Brunnhilde is coming down the pipeline, not that she's necessarily a pretty girl, but I'll be able to wield that spear a lot more easily.
Unfortunately none of that happened as the voice fell apart and deteriorated .Voight was an Artist I enjoyed and her sound was glorious. Her being a big Lady never bothered me as she commanded the stage and had star quality The surgery for weight loss was a grave mistake. She should have left her body and the voice within it alone. She was never the same Artist afterward.
Today's one of the best, and here is divine!
Glorious!!! ❤️
This is the Deborah Voigt we all love - a truly wonderful singer. If only she had lost just a few kilos ( which she would have felt the benefit of) rather than so many which no doubt disturbed her vocal support. However her physical change is long complete now and even if her voice divides public and critics she still has admirable artistic qualities.
There is no point in speculating (i) Ms. Voigt would have "felt the benefit of" some lesser weight loss (we are not her physicians) or (ii) what effect some other weight loss would have had on her voice. In any event, all artists experience changes in their voices throughout their operatic careers. This clip is 17 years old. Who can possibly say what Ms. Voigt would sound like now without the weight loss? It's all speculation.
Damn, this is a good voice!
Wow! Voigt was absolutely magnificent.
Wunderbar!!!!!!!!!!
Bravissima!
*****
Debbie ist eine der wundervollsten Sopranistinnen.
Celestial.
She sounds quite good here, and the voice sounds much richer and bigger than now. Has anyone here heard her pre and post surgery? I'd be curios to know if her voice has lost volume afterwards.
Brawississimo ! Wunderschon !
Oh mine, I love this.
I've heard this solo done several times by students during Met Opera regional auditions. No one sent a chill down my spine like she does here. I'm trying to find more posts of her singing after surgery, to try to compare if there's a major difference in the voice.
You'd have to be a stone not to be moved by this.
Great!
I haven't heard her since the surgery - but I will later this year. I used to love to say that you knew the show was over when she sang. Has she really lost a lot of weight? I guess I won't be able to say that any more. Well, all the more power to her, especially if she can still sing like this. She sends chills down my spine.
👏👏👏👏
I heard her at the Met a couple of years ago just as the news came out about her surgery. I don't know, time will tell. I felt she held back a bit that night. I do think the volume of sound has diminished a great deal, but she is still very, very good. You know; you damn if you do and damned if you don't. . .
Dang I can't wait to be like her, I have a dramatic soprano voice just like her (:
👆🏾👆🏾👆🏾👆🏾
brava bella interpretazione
I agree! Try listening the performance by Ghena Dimitrova as well for a comparison.
One of the best wagnerian sopranos of all times shining also as Manon
very nice. cant wait for her "frau" here in chicago.
btw, why are people still talking about the weight thing???
I totally agree!!!! And I'm fed up with all this "skinny girl" nonsense. Singing like that she should be able to sing it staged or not staged or wherever the "f" she wants to. This singing is almost perfection and I'm just sick to death of all this weight obsession with opera singers!!!!!!
No one complained about Pavarotti
commandert5 that’s because he was a man and apparently that makes one exempt from overweight criticisms. Meanwhile, if a woman has an extra 10 pounds people harp about it like she’s manufacturing anthrax.
Wonderful ! She never sacrifices the cleanness of her singing to fake dramatism.
She's better... There's a 60 minutes episode of her after surgery on here that shows here singing the love duet from Tristan und Isolde with Ben Heppner that is out of this world!
Sola, perduta, abbandonata
In landa desolata!
Orror!
Intorno a me
S'oscura il ciel...
Ahimè, son sola!
E nel profondo deserto io cado,
Strazio crudel
Ah! Solo abbandonata
Io, la deserta donna!
Ah! Non voglio morir!
No, non voglio morir!
Tutto dunque è finito.
Terra di pace me sembrava questa
Terra di pace
Me sembrava questa
Ahi! Mia beltà funesta,
Ire novelle accende
Strappar da lui mi si volea
Or tutto il mio passato
Orribile risorge,
E vivo innanzi al guardo mio si posa.
Ah! di sangue s'è macchiato.
Ah!
Tutto è finito!
Asil di pace
Ora la tomba invoco
No!
Non voglio morir...
Non voglio morir!
No, no, non voglio morir
Amore, aita!
Unbelievably beautiful. I don’t think anyone can sing this like she can. Dimitrova’ a high notes on this are so harsh it makes me cringe. Voigt’s technique here is flawless.
Lonely forsaken and abandoned
All my hope then is over.
And in the heart of this desert
I'm dying. O wretched hapless woman!
I sought this region as a peaceful haven.
Ah! Through my fatal beauty
Torments afresh surround me
They would have severed me from him;
Mow all my past does haunt me
With fearful pangs of anguish,
And rises straight before
My eyes to rend me.
New dangers come to threaten
Only the tomb can release me from my burden.
No! Let me not die dearest help me!
Listened to Freni's version, Tebaldi's version, Callas' version. Leontyne Price's version, Renata Scotto's version. Caballe, Jessye Norman didn't do this one. Couldn't find Teresa Stratas. Ghena Dimitrova's version, Renee Fleming's version.
Renata Scotto's version ranked #1 for me. Renee Fleming's version ranked #2 for me. Deborah Voigt's version ranked #3 for me.
All of this ridiculous ranking. This isn’t Formula One or whatever
Brava. Is the violoncellist Rostropovitch?
goood
PERFETTA. Puccini would have find this perfect!
i liked her better when she was heavier...the voice was nicer to listen to
Is it a semitone or so lower, or is it me?
She had a marvelous and powerfull voice ! What a great disaster and she was very well interpreting...Now her voice is just ok for "musicals and operettas !!!
Damn that bytch can sing!
Why do the powers that be believe we would rather see a skinny, under-powered soprano with a wobble the size of a truck than a shimmering woman of size like Ms. Voigt?
Großartige dramatische Stimme. Ich verstehe nicht, dass man so ein Theater um ihr Übergewicht gemacht hat. Die Caballe war doch auch nicht schlank. Wahrscheinlich ist das der heutigen Medienpräsenz geschuldet. Jeder soll jung schlank und attraktiv sein.
Dramatic soprano? The nerve. Voigt was a true lyric soprano.
No, it is not.