Can we take a minute and appreciate the fact that in here there is Voldemort singing with pain about the times before he became evil? Only Starkid can go there.
The irony comes when there was a time when Darren Criss was just Harry Potter and knew all the lines to the show, now he is also in Glee and not just Harry Potter being the star of the show
AVPS: Every son and daughter safe from You-Know-Who all because of you! AVPSY: There was a time before I was adored by every son and daughter Gets me every time 💔
the Starkids are the only people who can make people all over the world feel bad for Voldemort and love him more than Harry or is it just me that's like that... anyway MY COMPUTER IS TELLING ME VOLDEMORT IS A WORD THIS IS AMAZING!!!!
My heart is ripped into a million pieces when I listen to this. It's honestly the most emotional I've ever gotten over Starkid, and I've been a fan of them for 5 years. I think only the part in Starship where Joey says "just look up" is slightly comparable to the emotions I get listening to this song.
Favorite song of the soundtrack. I love the non darren version also, but this one is just incredible. You can tell darren and Joe are feeling the emotion of the song completely. Perfect.
Im playing both versions at the same times OMG THE WATER WORKS!! The main difference is the emotions ,darren has more history and eventhough clark has an amazing voice , darrens sounds better
HARRY: There was a time when life had meaning Not so long ago I knew the lines, it was easy being The star of the show There was a time when things were fine I could make wine from water There was a time when I was happy When I was Harry Potter (Ginny talks to the diary) TOM RIDDLE: There was a time when I was hopeful When I was good inside Everyone said that I was evil Maybe they were right I changed my name, I went insane I never felt so little I was a fool -to think they could love me When I was Thomas Riddle HARRY & TOM RIDDLE: Ive fallen From up high The world has said goodbye Im not an angel Not the answer I'm just going nowhere faster HARRY: There was a time I was a hero But that heros gone Looking back, I can hardly see him Everyones moved on HARRY & TOM RIDDLE: Cast me aside Throw me away Go on, forget Yesterday And I'll try forgetting too (But) I wish it was Just like it was before (Harry leaves Hogwarts) HARRY: Ive fallen From up high The world has said goodbye Im not an angel Not the answer How did life become a disaster? I'm just going nowhere faster There was a time before I was adored by every son and daughter There was a time when I was happy When I was Haaaarry Potter Read more: AVPSY - A Very Potter Senior Year - StarKid - When I Was Lyrics | MetroLyrics
I saw quite a few comments raving about Sidekick, but this song is the apex of Team Starkid. This very well may be the best song they I have ever written.
Always remember star kid made an evil character relatable and human whilst not exempting him from the punishment coming to him from all his evil deeds. Like. Can we get some more of that in media pls
This and the Everything Ends songs always makes me cry!!!! Damn you StarKid.... Soooooo many feellsssss.... Too much to handle... Sobbing like a baby...
All of my feels exploded the first time I heard this. Sucks that AVPSY is the last one, but by the magical powers of RUclips theres always a way back.... Back to witches and wizards and magical beasts, to goblins and ghosts and to magical feasts, it's that I love and it's all that I need at HOGWARTS, HOGWARTS, I know I'm going back -3
THIS is how this song is supposed to go. No offense to the guy who sings harry on the recording, but THIS is how AVPM is supposed to end. Just feels right. Darren and Joe. Yes sir.....um Im gonna go to a choir room now...
StarKidWannaBe it was Clark and I agree. Clark is an amazing singer but I prefer the Darren version of this song as well. It’s much more personal and emotional I think
Everyone is saying they started crying at a point in the song. I started the moment i heard Darren's voice. i missed him singing with his real friends :)
Y'all ever notice that "I've never felt so little" can have a double meaning? Firstly for not feeling anything, secondly for feeling powerless and small?
I'm from The Netherlands too (Yay, Dutch StarkidPower! :D), and I was able to download it... but I downloaded it from their Facebookpage. Maybe that works...? Good Luck!
I went to buy this on the Ann Arbor website and they told me it was out of stock! What does that even mean?! It downloads to my computer! I'm not asking for a material copy of it!... Oh Darren
I agree with everything you said... except that Felix Felicis is a good luck potion and Amortentia is the love potion...Sorry! I'm a giant potter head!
I'm seriously sobbing over here cause I still have not been able to download the script. Every time I check out at the Ann Arbor webshop it says: 'We're sorry, but something went wrong'. Maybe it does not work cause I come from The Netherlands though I can't imagine how that what be a problem since it is a digital download?
![[SFM] Risky Recital](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/RzNkY1_Nk3o/mqdefault.jpg)
Can we take a minute and appreciate the fact that in here there is Voldemort singing with pain about the times before he became evil?
Only Starkid can go there.
Darren will ALWAYS be Harry Potter, as long as those who remain are loyal to him.
I kinda want to see Darren Criss and Daniel Radcliffe meet and for them to just talk about being the chosen one and stuff
@@parryxxlivxx the met, i think it was at the darren premier of how to succeed
The irony comes when there was a time when Darren Criss was just Harry Potter and knew all the lines to the show, now he is also in Glee and not just Harry Potter being the star of the show
ignoremyinsanity That's not irony that's literally what the song is about: the history of star kid
ignoremyinsanity 4 year later but that song was written in mind of darren moving on from starkid and harry potter to do other things
Oh God it's like Darren singing about how he isn't as involved anymore like "when I was Harry Potter". Cry.
AVPS: Every son and daughter safe from You-Know-Who all because of you!
AVPSY: There was a time before I was adored by every son and daughter
Gets me every time 💔
Emily
AVPS: you’re Harry freaking Potter
AVPSY: I remember a time when I was Harry Potter
❤❤❤1
the Starkids are the only people who can make people all over the world feel bad for Voldemort and love him more than Harry or is it just me that's like that... anyway MY COMPUTER IS TELLING ME VOLDEMORT IS A WORD THIS IS AMAZING!!!!
They also made people (me included) love Jar Jar Binks… and cry when he died oops
It just started raining and I think it's not rain it's actually my tears that have disapperated to the clouds
Cast me aside
Throw me away
Go on forget
Yesterday
And Ill try
Forgetting too..
There onward i started sobbing.
My heart is ripped into a million pieces when I listen to this. It's honestly the most emotional I've ever gotten over Starkid, and I've been a fan of them for 5 years. I think only the part in Starship where Joey says "just look up" is slightly comparable to the emotions I get listening to this song.
Sameeeeeeeeee
HOW DID I NOT KNOW THERE WAS A DARREN VERSION UNTIL NOW
Favorite song of the soundtrack. I love the non darren version also, but this one is just incredible. You can tell darren and Joe are feeling the emotion of the song completely. Perfect.
this was ten years ago lol, but this isnt darren 😭
@@thatonestarkidfan3918yeah this is darren! clark sings the other version of i was but this is the bonus track version with darren
@@littlekawaiidragon really ?? wow that must be why i thought clark wasnt sounding like himself haha
1:37 best part :3
3:50 worst part :(
6
Now when I hear "There was a time..." I don't know whether to think of Les Misérables or AVPSY...
Why not both?
Thomas Fitch I like your thinking
“There was a time when men had meaning...”
@@randomperson1997 water came out of my nose 🤣
I love the album version, but Darren just makes my heart melt!!!
God damn it i know im like 6 years late but i miss Darren so much and this song makes me so emotional hh
*beginning notes* there onward my heart shattered into pieces and I cried uncontrollably. And that Darrens vibrato 3 I just love this so much
JOE!!! *sobs* It's okay, Voldy, it'll be okay, don't make me cry with your beautiful voice! 😍😭
YES
I feel this
I'm not an angel,
not the answer.
I'm just going nowhere faster.
I hear sobbing.... oh wait that's just me :'( Darren Criss you beautiful baby boy
Im playing both versions at the same times OMG THE WATER WORKS!! The main difference is the emotions ,darren has more history and eventhough clark has an amazing voice , darrens sounds better
Cathy colors Clark sounds cleaner, Darren sounds more in pain
@@val8869 Which sounds right, because he should sound in pain. Clark does an amazing job though.
HARRY:
There was a time when life had meaning
Not so long ago
I knew the lines, it was easy being
The star of the show
There was a time when things were fine
I could make wine from water
There was a time when I was happy
When I was Harry Potter
(Ginny talks to the diary)
TOM RIDDLE:
There was a time when I was hopeful
When I was good inside
Everyone said that I was evil
Maybe they were right
I changed my name, I went insane
I never felt so little
I was a fool -to think they could love me
When I was Thomas Riddle
HARRY & TOM RIDDLE:
Ive fallen
From up high
The world has said goodbye
Im not an angel
Not the answer
I'm just going nowhere faster
HARRY:
There was a time I was a hero
But that heros gone
Looking back, I can hardly see him
Everyones moved on
HARRY & TOM RIDDLE:
Cast me aside
Throw me away
Go on, forget
Yesterday
And I'll try forgetting too
(But) I wish it was
Just like it was before
(Harry leaves Hogwarts)
HARRY:
Ive fallen
From up high
The world has said goodbye
Im not an angel
Not the answer
How did life become a disaster?
I'm just going nowhere faster
There was a time before I was adored by every son and daughter
There was a time when I was happy
When I was Haaaarry Potter
Read more: AVPSY - A Very Potter Senior Year - StarKid - When I Was Lyrics | MetroLyrics
This needs to be pinned!
I love this song. Darren's voice just completes it!
No, I'm not crying. There's just AVPSY in my eye.
The harmony in this is amazing
2:53 ahhhhdbdkosksbf my hearttt
Their voices are so emotive! And they sound amazing together! How have they not done more duets? Their voices meld so beautifully!
I was just listening to wiggly jingle, and the switch from that to this gave me whiplash
I was just jamming and now I feel like crying
@@thebananaowenslippedon7095 Joe and Darren should do duets more often 😍🥰♥️
*sobbing* why @ your name
I wonder if this song hits a little close to home for Daniel Radcliffe
Or darren criss himself
@@Julia-oe9xl Yes but he's still very involved in starkid :)
I saw quite a few comments raving about Sidekick, but this song is the apex of Team Starkid. This very well may be the best song they I have ever written.
OMG HOW DID YOU GET YOUR HANDS ON THIS VERSION!?
magic
It seems someone is a hufflepuff
Danny Hull what the hell is a hufflepuff
@@joseffgronkowski2638 Hufflepuffs are particularly good finders
@@glennal3432 Find!
This song is so beautiful. I can't stop listening to it.
how can you not cry to this!
It's illegal to not cry to this.
Arrest me then lol
Always remember star kid made an evil character relatable and human whilst not exempting him from the punishment coming to him from all his evil deeds. Like. Can we get some more of that in media pls
THIS IS DARREN.
Joe and Darren singing an amazing song together. Okay, I'm ready to die.
My favorite song of the whole album, can't wait to watch Darren singing this!
Listening to both versions of this song at the same time is a real experience.
joe gave voldemort more than just good looks. He gave him a different side, especially in this. :)
WHY AM I LISTENING TO THIS ON CHRISTMAS EVE
IT HURTS
This and the Everything Ends songs always makes me cry!!!! Damn you StarKid.... Soooooo many feellsssss.... Too much to handle... Sobbing like a baby...
I’m crying. What’s happening. IM CRYING WHAT DID YOU DO TO ME?
They got their hopes up so high and then they got mugged and murdered in an alley way!
All of my feels exploded the first time I heard this. Sucks that AVPSY is the last one, but by the magical powers of RUclips theres always a way back.... Back to witches and wizards and magical beasts, to goblins and ghosts and to magical feasts, it's that I love and it's all that I need at HOGWARTS, HOGWARTS, I know I'm going back -3
THIS is how this song is supposed to go. No offense to the guy who sings harry on the recording, but THIS is how AVPM is supposed to end. Just feels right. Darren and Joe. Yes sir.....um Im gonna go to a choir room now...
StarKidWannaBe it was Clark and I agree. Clark is an amazing singer but I prefer the Darren version of this song as well. It’s much more personal and emotional I think
Joe made Voldemort hot...Is that even possible??
Giving him a love interest in Quirrell.
THIS SONG BREAKS MY SOUL
3:02 onwards gave me shivers! Thank you so much for uploading this!
Actually genuinely sobbing.
Joe's voice is AMAZING!
This song is emotional without even reading the script! I can't wait to get up to this part!
Eh, what did I need my heart for? It's okay, Starkid, rip it out and stop all over it with your feels. I don't mind. Honest!
Everyone is saying they started crying at a point in the song. I started the moment i heard Darren's voice. i missed him singing with his real friends :)
Not a good idea listening to this after Everything Ends
1:37 that’s what you’re after and you know it
who wrote this song? was it Darren or Clark?
Clark
I cried at this part in the script...
You just made my day!! (Or night actually it is already around 3 am here :') But it works. Thank you for the link!
I actually got really excited when I found this
Y'all ever notice that "I've never felt so little" can have a double meaning? Firstly for not feeling anything, secondly for feeling powerless and small?
OH MY WIZARD GOD-
Like if you get chills when Darren sings, when Joe sings, and when they both singing
Also Joe is remarkably good in this song.
Feels.
I swear this reminds me of another song, can’t think which one though
Idk about you but it reminds me of "when she loved me" from toy story 2
I'm from The Netherlands too (Yay, Dutch StarkidPower! :D), and I was able to download it... but I downloaded it from their Facebookpage. Maybe that works...? Good Luck!
Listening to this while reading it in the script oh my god
joe walker sings like a disney prince wtf
So many people went on it at once the site crashed :P I can send the script to you if you want!
I cried!
MY WIZARD GOD AND OH MY ROWLING... I NEED THIS ON ITUNES.
Joe Walker and Darren Criss SLAP
DARREN SINGS IT SO MUCH BETTER. ah the fan girl chills.
i'll say it again, this would have been amazing live if Darren's mic would have worked
It's still amazing even with the fucked up mic
I went to buy this on the Ann Arbor website and they told me it was out of stock! What does that even mean?! It downloads to my computer! I'm not asking for a material copy of it!... Oh Darren
It’s kinda cool that Tom is really just singing about his own humanity leaving him
Daniel Radcliffe? Don’t know her
omfg i cried
yeah, on the album Harry is sung by someone else :)
2:53!!!
I'M FALLING FROM A 🥧PIE!🥧
2:51
JOE FREAKIN WALKER🥺
Why isn’t Draco in the picture?
Dushdjtoe Dushdjtoe he’s just rolling on the floor behind everyone else
Also- when he says harry potter the last time for really Long does it remind anyone of moulin rouge??
I agree with everything you said... except that Felix Felicis is a good luck potion and Amortentia is the love potion...Sorry! I'm a giant potter head!
Where is this version available for purchase? I just bought the AVPSY soundtrack from StarKid and this version wasn’t on there!
DARREN IS MINE I LOVE HIM TOO MUCH
Angelica Nicole same tbh
both. both is good ;)
Also like if you made a playlist for the album cause people put it on youtube and forgot to put the other songs on the playlist
I'm seriously sobbing over here cause I still have not been able to download the script. Every time I check out at the Ann Arbor webshop it says: 'We're sorry, but something went wrong'. Maybe it does not work cause I come from The Netherlands though I can't imagine how that what be a problem since it is a digital download?
I'll post a link that might work in the description of this video if you want. :)
who is the second singer?
gabygogo505 Joe Walker
On the full soundtrack it's Clark not Darren.
NO ONE UNDERSTANDS THIS SONG LIKE I DO
There's a non Darren version of this?
Hahaha! whoops.. did I say "Felix Felicis"? Looks like I might have had too much butterbeer! :)
@gabygogo505 Joe Walker
pretty sure this is clark
lol no this is darren