Beautifully explained. With a grasp on arabic and the educational depth thatbyou already have you could bring out gems from the Quran and benefit the audience so much
Wonderful doctor sahib to simply elobrate a signigant Islamic period with respect to financial resource management and mobilization for greater understanding of ordinary people ❤
Sir we are desperately waiting for a complete series on Muslim History. Sir, your lectures are of great importance for the students from weak educational background.
Great topic. The system of governance by Hazrat Umar , is the only Islamic system, which was successful, and دور اندیش with regard to protecting the rights of "muslims". What we usually call ریاست مدینہ ,people misunderstand that there were rules and mechanisms of governance during the time of Prophet pbuh, as it was just a small city state with a population of few thousands. Hazrat Abubakar r spent his time controling and unifying the revolting groups, and never had time to do "governance". Hazrat Umar was the one who had to deal with finance, police, military, tax collction and distribution (Hazrat Abubakar was establishing ذكوة tax as a necessary part, but its management was done at a scale applicable to our times was done by Hazrat Umar. It would be interesting if in the end, you can touch up changes brought in by Hazrat Usman r to the policies of Hazrat Umar, which eventually resulted in first fitna. Though I will be careful not to dig deep, and leave enough untold, for the apologetics to defend the policies of Hazrat Usman and feel good, rather than labeling you with toheen sahaba. Best wishes and kudos
Policies of Hazrat Usman RA were different from Hazrat Umar RA definitely because former was lenient and later was strict. These are traits found in general public either of these are not bad. Based kn the policies you can’t judge someone’s level of piety. If Hazrat Muhammad SAW chose him as one of his best companion then who we are to challenge that.
Sir mutah marriage was banned by Prophet himself on the day of Battlr of Khayber. Some sahaba had not heard of this hadith were practicing mutah at Hazrat Umar's time, thus Umar reiterated the Islamic Ruling and strictly emphasized it
Btw its sustainable financial system and conquest strategies were wholly different. It was how to maintain any new land of conquest and people. For the conquest point Arab Strategy was fast charging/ raiding cavalry and desert tactics to attract the counterpart in desert and then fight. These strategies of conquest were mainly developed by Hazrat Khalid Bin Walid, Hazrat Saad Bin Waqas and Kaka bin Al Amr. Moreover Arabs were so enthusiastic to see the first fight amongst Commanders of both sides. Meanwhile a great video. But requesting you to change the title.
By system, I don’t mean their mode of fighting. But how the financial and economic system created in order to promote conquest and as a result of conquest.
@@muhammadadeel8639 what shura are you talking about brother? Hazrat Abu Bakr RA became caliph due to a panic situation(his own words in Bukhari) Hazrat Umar RA was named caliph by hazrat Abu Bakr RA,there was a shura for the third caliph but if you read ahadis,it had a clear bias towards Umayyads,the fourth caliph Hazrat Ali RA came into power because no one else was willing to take that position including himself because of the chaos after the mob lynching and brutal murder of Hazrat Usman RA after starving him for days on charges of corruption and nepotism,which was followed immediately by two wars against well Muslims who rejected Hazrat Ali's caliphate,one against Amma Ayesha RA and the other against Muawiya..don't see much shura/consultation in that,safe to use the word monarchy which is not a haram or bad thing
@@AslamKhan-mk8yi الیکشن کا ادارہ بھی بن جاتا ۔۔ یہ جن حضرات یا جس قوم کی تاریخ بیان کی گئی ہے ، روم و فارس کے حکمران یا لوگ اس عرب علاقے کی طرف جانا تک پسند نہیں کرتے تھے۔ نبی محمد اپنے اصحاب کے لیے قدم قدم پر معجزات کے ساتھ مدد نہیں چھوڑ کر گئے تھے نہ ہی اپنے اصحاب کو فرشتہ بتا کر گئے تھے ۔۔۔ وہ انسان تھے اتنی جب ترقی کر لی تھی تو مزید ادارے بھی بن جاتے ، مگر سیدنا عمر کا قتل کر دیا گیا ۔۔۔۔ سیدنا عمر کا شوریٰ کی لسٹ دینا ہی یہ ثابت کرتا ہے کہ آپ الیکشن یا نمائندگان کا عوام کے ذریعے انتخاب کرنے کے بارے میں سوچ رہے تھے۔ یہ روم و ایران کی سلطنت کے نزدیک عرب بدو تھے جن کی کوئی اوقات نہ تھی ، تب ہی جنگ کے وقت روم و فارس کے کمانڈر ان سے کہتے کہ کچھ پیسے لو اور واپس چلے جاؤ۔۔ تم بھوکے ہو۔۔۔ ان عربوں نے پہلی مرتبہ سلطنت دیکھی تھی۔
@@AslamKhan-mk8yibro search about Hazart Abu Ubaidah RA and saeed RA then you will see how was the leader elected in islam. Was he a monarch or caliph
@@AslamKhan-mk8yiif the caliph was a monarch then we would have seen Hazrat Umar RA interest in Hazrat Abdullah bin Umar instead of Hazrat Abu Ubaidah RA
Muhammad was born in the slave society and he perpetuated all the rules of slave society ; feudal system also exploited the serfs and the socialist society of the 20 th century ended the exploitation. But you regard that period of history remarkable where women were made loondis and sold in the market places.
Where is contemporary history, all this history is based on Islamic sources. Being Muslim, i believe in it but it doest stand the scrutiny of modern history. There is another problem, zakat rate on income is @2.5% which has no historical basis. Plz ask Illyas saheb.
My point has never been that Muslims didn’t develop a political and economic system. My point is that this political and economic system continues to change with changed objective conditions and that we should remain open to this change in order to progress.
@@Taimur_Laal this view , when you put like this appears to be more clear and seems fair . however, to which extent a change could be acceptable in Islamic framework has not been discussed yet by you . That would be interesting.
Hazrat Umer Farooq Razi Allah u Anhu is the second Khalifa of islam. The one who does not give him respect by heart and try to count his achievements as "Mistakes" is not a Muslim.
Bhai Aapne kaha Ye System Islam Ke Hazaron Saal Pahle Se Chalta Aa Raha Tha, Aap Logo Ko Ye Baat Kyu Nahi Samajh Aati ke Islam Tab se Hai Jab Se Ye Dunia Bani Aadam Alaihissalam Pahle Paigamber hai Aur Muhammad Sallallahu Alaihi wa sallam Aakhri Paigamber hai
"islam se pehle raids ka maqsad maal lootna tha, jab k islam k aane k baad ye mamla change ho gaya" WHAT A JOKE! Agar aisa he tha islam ka sab se pehla large scale battle(Badr) 1 tejarti kafla lootna he Q tha??? Secondly, if 1/5th of the loot is for Allah and Prophet then where does 4/5th go??? What about the sex slaves that the prophet and companions used to keep, didn't they get it in fightings???
آپ ابھی بچے ہو سوال میں ہی جہالت ٹپک رہی ہے تب ہی جواب کا دل نہیں کیا۔۔۔ کیونکہ جاہل حق واضح ہونے کے بعد بھی گردن سے سریا نہیں نکالتے یہاں تک کہ مر کر گل سڑ کر ہی انکا غرور مٹتا ہے ۔۔
Khalifa is not a king Allah is the king of Khalifa is like viceroy and there is no particular way of choosing a Khalifa the Khalifa himself can choose the next Khalifa or they can choose five people the choose among themselves
🌟 First thing, arabs were mainly agriculutral based. Kindly have some basic idea on arab region. Secondly, Macca was NEVER trading centre You are completely mistaken !! Kindly read Quran before you attempt Islamic topic. Its lot of disinformation Regards,
The Bedouin, Beduin, or Bedu (/ˈbɛduɪn/; Arabic: بَدْو, romanized: badū, singular بَدَوِي badawī) are pastorally nomadic Arab tribes who have historically inhabited the desert regions in the Arabian Peninsula, North Africa, the Levant, and Mesopotamia (Iraq). The Bedouin originated in the Syrian Desert and Arabian Desert but spread across the rest of the Arab world in West Asia and North Africa after the spread of Islam. The English word bedouin comes from the Arabic badawī, which means "desert-dweller", and is traditionally contrasted with ḥāḍir, the term for sedentary people.
@@Taimur_Laal Kindly read Quran which elaborates agriculture being the main stream profession of arabs. Also read about Dadan, Yathreb, Tema, Al hegra(Pre Islamic) and the #dams constructed during umayad era in Yathreb and Taif. Regards,
Of course there has to be some agriculture. Otherwise people will starve to death. But it was extremely small scale in comparison to Iraq, Egypt and Syria. This is the Fertile Crescent. The birth place of the agricultural revolution.
زراعت تھی لیکن اس درجے کی نہ تھی کہ سب عرب کو زرعی علاقہ ہی کہا جائے۔۔ جب عرب ، فارس و روم کے کمانڈر آمنے سامنے ہوتے تھے تو روم و فارس کے کمانڈر عربوں کو یہی کہتے تھے کہ تم لوگ بھوکے ہو ننگے ہو، عرب کی گرمی اور بھوک نے تمھیں تنگ کیا ہے اور تم ہمارے علاقوں پر چڑھ دوڑے ہو، آؤ تمھیں کچھ کھانے پینے کو دیں اور مال دیں اور تم واپس جاؤ
I know one thing upon death of Hazrat Umar RA: Hazrat Ali RA invoked Allah's Mercy for 'Umar RA and said, "O 'Umar! You have not left behind you a person whose deeds I like to imitate and meet Allah with more than I like your deeds. By Allah!
Disagreement is a common thing which can happen even between them but that’s fine because they didn’t hold grudge with each other rather pray for each other. Also when you research something make it credible by verifying it from 3-4 independent sources otherwise it has no value.
@@farazahmed0 first of all your quoted fake quotation towards hazrat ali. Islamic history has solid proofs in the books which happened. I myself have verified it. Sunni shia divide were started from saqeefa. Which solidified after karbala.
شاید آپ بھی اب جواب نہ دے پائیں مگر خیر۔۔۔۔ دراصل یہ مجوسیوں کی لکھی کہانیاں ہیں۔۔۔ یہ بات سمجھنی چاہیے کہ نبی محمد کا خط جب شاہ فارس کے پاس پہنچا تو اس نے خط پھاڑا اور نبی پاک کو گرفتار کرنے بھیجا کہ عرب کا ایک بدو چرواہا مجھے اطاعت کا حکم دیتا ہے۔۔۔ فارس و روم کی سلطنتوں کے سامنے عربوں کی کچھ اوقات نہ تھی ۔ اس لیے جب روم و فارس فتح ہو گئے تو فارس کے مجوسیوں نے خوب اپنے سینے پیٹے، یہ جو آج بھی آپ سینے پیٹنے کی مشق دیکھتے ہیں جس جو اسلام سے جوڑا جاتا ہے یہ دراصل وہی فارس کی سلطنت کی جلن ہے۔۔۔ اس کے بعد مجوسیوں نے سیدنا علی کو کوفے میں خوب ستایا اور لعنت پائی پھر سیدنا حسن کو ستایا پھر سیدنا حسین کو کوفے بلا کر دھوکے سے قتل کروایا ۔۔۔ مجوسیوں نے اسلام کے ٹکرے ٹکرے کرنے میں کوئی کسر نہیں چھوڑی۔۔۔ ہر دشمن اسلام کا ساتھ دیا صرف اور صرف فارس کی جلن میں۔۔۔ ہر وہ صحابی جو فارس کو شکست دینے، فوجیں بھیجنے میں شامل ہے مجوسیوں نے اس کے خلاف تاریخ لکھی ہوئی ہے، ابوبکر، عمر، عثمان، سعد بن ابی وقاص ، مغیرہ ابن شعبہ، خالد بن ولید ، یہ سب سلطنت فارس کو نقصان پہنچانے میں شامل رہے۔۔۔۔ ان پر مجوسی آج تک اپنے بادشاہ کی طرح لعنت کر کے خود کو تسلی دے رہے ہیں۔۔۔ ورنہ سیدنا علی اور انکی فیملی کا مجوس کو کیا غم؟؟ یہ سب تو عرب تھے ۔۔۔۔ عربوں سے تو ایرانی ویسے بھی جلتے ہیں سلطنت کی یاد میں۔۔۔ پاکستان میں سید ہونے کے دعویدار سعودیہ کے مطابق مجوسی ہیں وہ کہتے ہیں کہ ان کی کالی شکلیں دیکھو اور ایران سے محبت دیکھو یہ پکے مجوس نسل ہیں اور سلطنت کی جلن میں عربوں کو گالیاں دیتے ہیں۔
agar hazrat umar ka dosre mulkon pr hamla kr k wahan k logon ka qatl e aam kr k un k mulk pr qabza krna theek he tu phir ye kaam koi bhi karay theek hona chahye dosre karay tu ghalat lekin Umar karay tu theek ye duhra meyaar q?
ان اصحاب نے نبی پاک کے فرمان کے مطابق حملے کیے تھے اور اللّٰہ کے قانون کے مطابق نبی کی اطاعت نہ کرنے والوں کو سزا ملی۔۔۔ ایک ہی کمانڈر خالد کافی ہوا۔۔۔ اور ہزار سال سے قائم روم و فارس کی سلطنتوں کی اینٹ سے اینٹ بجا دی۔۔۔ روم نے پھر مان لیا۔۔۔ مگر فارسی چونکہ مجوس تھے نسل پرست تھے اس لیے انہوں نے اپنے بادشاہ کی طرح آج تک لعنتوں کا سلسلہ جاری رکھا ہوا ہے اور سلطنت فارس کے غم میں جو ماتم ہوا تھا وہ آج ان کی نسل کی عبادت بنا ہوا ہے۔
@@wisedome3433 iran me jo islam phela he wo imam ali raza a.s ki badolat phela he. Baqi majosi umar k baray me kia khayal krte hen wo tmhe majosio se jakar pochna hoga.
@@Truth-qe6sf وہ اسلام علی رضا کا نہیں بلکہ مجوسیوں کے بنائے ہوئے فرقے کا ہے۔۔۔ دل سے اسلام قبول کر لیتے مجوسی، نہ اسلام کے خلاف سازشیں کرتے، نہ سیدنا عمر کو قتل کرواتے نہ سیدنا عثمان کو قتل کروا کر سیدنا علی و معاویہ میں جنگیں چھیڑتے، تو آج اصل اسلام ان تک بھی پہنچ چکا ہوتا۔ ۔
@@hasbideadman tu tumharay kehne ka matlab he k agar umar majosio pr hamla kr k unka qatl e aam kr k un k ghar pr qabza na krta tu aaj majosio ne islam ko nuqsan nhi puhunchaya hota. Ye sari umar ki ghalati he k us ne majosio pr hamla kr k unhe majbor kia k wo umar k kuilaf hon aur wo islam k khilaaf ho. Tu is me tu sara qusoor umar ka he k jis ki waja se islam ko nuqsan pohuncha. Zahir si baat he k tum kisi k auper hamla kr k unhe nuqsan pohunchaogay aur wo reaction me tum ko nuqsan pohunchaye tu qusor reaction dene walay ka nhi balkay tumhara he.
Bring more contributions from my Idon Umar e Farooque Aazam Radiallaho Taaala Anho in the service of islam. Love & respect for your teachings from Chandrapur, Maharashta, India
آپ نے فرمایا اسلام کے ابتدائی فالوور نے اپنی جدوجہد کا آغاز ریڈنگ سے کیا۔۔ کھلے الفاظ میں کیوں نہیں کہا کہ تجارت کے بجائے لوٹ مار سے کیا۔۔ آج کے وی لاگ میں پہلے والی دلیری نہیں دیکھی گئی۔۔۔
@@MuhammadAshraf-mh5dl it is not a question of courage but a question of historical facts. The great historian Montgomery Watt has explained the central role of trade between Yemen and Syria (through Mecca) played a key role in the social structure of Arabia.
So what is perfect? I think humans are perfect when they believe in one God and obey the holy book as it is. Otherwise there will be no chances of perfect. Because humans are born with mistakes.
Great Job To Bring Out So Many Topics Of Early Islamic Age
Never Heard As A Common Man
Very Interesting,Clearly Knowledgeable
Thanks
Beautifully explained. With a grasp on arabic and the educational depth thatbyou already have you could bring out gems from the Quran and benefit the audience so much
one of the best research ... Long live Dr Saib
Great work sir!. Really appreciate your knowledge and point of view.
Learning new things in each new episode. Interesting
Love your lectures regarding Islam
Taimur sir u r doing most best affert for doveloping our thoughts
Please release second part.we extremely waiting for this
Wonderful doctor sahib to simply elobrate a signigant Islamic period with respect to financial resource management and mobilization for greater understanding of ordinary people ❤
Sir we are desperately waiting for a complete series on Muslim History. Sir, your lectures are of great importance for the students from weak educational background.
Jazak Allah Sir,,,aap tu REVOLUTION le aaenge
Thank you, dr. Sb
Very nice about islamic history in urdu
Very well explained sir. A big fan of you dear sir. Stay blessed.
Mind blowing analysis.
Great work sir g...
Wao wonderful, great explanation
Great lecture.So very helpful.❤
Great topic. The system of governance by Hazrat Umar , is the only Islamic system, which was successful, and دور اندیش with regard to protecting the rights of "muslims".
What we usually call ریاست مدینہ ,people misunderstand that there were rules and mechanisms of governance during the time of Prophet pbuh, as it was just a small city state with a population of few thousands.
Hazrat Abubakar r spent his time controling and unifying the revolting groups, and never had time to do "governance".
Hazrat Umar was the one who had to deal with finance, police, military, tax collction and distribution (Hazrat Abubakar was establishing ذكوة tax as a necessary part, but its management was done at a scale applicable to our times was done by Hazrat Umar.
It would be interesting if in the end, you can touch up changes brought in by Hazrat Usman r to the policies of Hazrat Umar, which eventually resulted in first fitna. Though I will be careful not to dig deep, and leave enough untold, for the apologetics to defend the policies of Hazrat Usman and feel good, rather than labeling you with toheen sahaba.
Best wishes and kudos
Policies of Hazrat Usman RA were different from Hazrat Umar RA definitely because former was lenient and later was strict. These are traits found in general public either of these are not bad. Based kn the policies you can’t judge someone’s level of piety. If Hazrat Muhammad SAW chose him as one of his best companion then who we are to challenge that.
کمال کر دیا آج تو آپ نے.. ❤
Thanks Dr Sahib for starting here rather than Mauwiya ibn Abi Sufiyan . Thanks for mentioning Khums at 3:30 which many don’t know or never heard of .
🌹💚میری جان حضرت عــــــــــمـــــــــــــــــــرفاروق رضی اللہ تعالیٰ عنہ💚🌹
شاندار ولاگ۔
Can not wait for next episode
Please identify the follow up episode... Link
Very knowledgeable video Asgar Ali Engineer ki book " Islam ka Janam or itihas". me bahut detail me bataya gya hai .
Sir what is your thoughts on osho
Kia baat hai......zabardast takziya ❤❤❤❤❤
ماشاءاللہ ماشاءاللہ ماشاءاللہ سر جی
❤❤❤
Zinda baaaad Dr sahib
may ALLAH bless you sir AMEEN
reference?
Assalam alaikum
Sir mutazila complete kariye pehle
Bahut Zyada time le lia aapne
Where is next episode of this series???
So are you old with white hair or young with dark hair?
Make an explanatory video on Osho
Sir ,can you tell us that only Arab traders had made the part of administration or non Arabs are also participated ?
Very informative video sir.
Waiting for next episode
❤❤
سر سلام ھے آپ کو ھمیں مغالطہ اسلام بتانے پر۔
What do you mean ?
Dr shahib you have forgotten Sobho Giyanchandani on his 104 birthday
Dr Saab You are 💕💕
Sir mutah marriage was banned by Prophet himself on the day of Battlr of Khayber.
Some sahaba had not heard of this hadith were practicing mutah at Hazrat Umar's time, thus Umar reiterated the Islamic Ruling and strictly emphasized it
You are the best in Pakistan sir
Btw its sustainable financial system and conquest strategies were wholly different. It was how to maintain any new land of conquest and people.
For the conquest point Arab Strategy was fast charging/ raiding cavalry and desert tactics to attract the counterpart in desert and then fight. These strategies of conquest were mainly developed by Hazrat Khalid Bin Walid, Hazrat Saad Bin Waqas and Kaka bin Al Amr. Moreover Arabs were so enthusiastic to see the first fight amongst Commanders of both sides. Meanwhile a great video. But requesting you to change the title.
By system, I don’t mean their mode of fighting. But how the financial and economic system created in order to promote conquest and as a result of conquest.
@@Taimur_Laal yeah thats true and it was well consistent with your thoughts but I just said for suggestions.
♥️بَغیر عِشقِ ابوبکر ؓ عمر ؓ عثمان ؓ حیدر ؓ زِنْدَگیِ فَنا ھَستَم😍
Dr. sb mut'zilla ka next part kb upload karain gy?
This is part of the same series. You will see how it all connects.
Dr. saheb, معتزلہ par lecture karain, معترضہ par nahe.
Khatmal Majoosi Yazeedi tere pai lanaat
Waiting for second episode
Beautifully explained the transition from religious monarchy to Arab colonialism..once again we witness the magic of Dr. Sahab's sweet words
Religious monarchy is not the right word for Rashidun caliphate. As it was not hereditary, but Shura/consultation based election system.
@@muhammadadeel8639 what shura are you talking about brother?
Hazrat Abu Bakr RA became caliph due to a panic situation(his own words in Bukhari) Hazrat Umar RA was named caliph by hazrat Abu Bakr RA,there was a shura for the third caliph but if you read ahadis,it had a clear bias towards Umayyads,the fourth caliph Hazrat Ali RA came into power because no one else was willing to take that position including himself because of the chaos after the mob lynching and brutal murder of Hazrat Usman RA after starving him for days on charges of corruption and nepotism,which was followed immediately by two wars against well Muslims who rejected Hazrat Ali's caliphate,one against Amma Ayesha RA and the other against Muawiya..don't see much shura/consultation in that,safe to use the word monarchy which is not a haram or bad thing
@@AslamKhan-mk8yi
الیکشن کا ادارہ بھی بن جاتا ۔۔ یہ جن حضرات یا جس قوم کی تاریخ بیان کی گئی ہے ، روم و فارس کے حکمران یا لوگ اس عرب علاقے کی طرف جانا تک پسند نہیں کرتے تھے۔ نبی محمد اپنے اصحاب کے لیے قدم قدم پر معجزات کے ساتھ مدد نہیں چھوڑ کر گئے تھے نہ ہی اپنے اصحاب کو فرشتہ بتا کر گئے تھے ۔۔۔ وہ انسان تھے اتنی جب ترقی کر لی تھی تو مزید ادارے بھی بن جاتے ، مگر سیدنا عمر کا قتل کر دیا گیا ۔۔۔۔ سیدنا عمر کا شوریٰ کی لسٹ دینا ہی یہ ثابت کرتا ہے کہ آپ الیکشن یا نمائندگان کا عوام کے ذریعے انتخاب کرنے کے بارے میں سوچ رہے تھے۔
یہ روم و ایران کی سلطنت کے نزدیک عرب بدو تھے جن کی کوئی اوقات نہ تھی ، تب ہی جنگ کے وقت روم و فارس کے کمانڈر ان سے کہتے کہ کچھ پیسے لو اور واپس چلے جاؤ۔۔ تم بھوکے ہو۔۔۔
ان عربوں نے پہلی مرتبہ سلطنت دیکھی تھی۔
@@AslamKhan-mk8yibro search about Hazart Abu Ubaidah RA and saeed RA then you will see how was the leader elected in islam. Was he a monarch or caliph
@@AslamKhan-mk8yiif the caliph was a monarch then we would have seen Hazrat Umar RA interest in Hazrat Abdullah bin Umar instead of Hazrat Abu Ubaidah RA
*یعنی ڈی ایچ اے کا کونسیپٹ یہیں سے لیا گیا ڈاکٹر؟ معتزلہ کی ساتویں قسط کا انتظار کرنا چھوڑ دیا آپکی مجبُوریاں قابل فہم ہیں ڈاکٹر* 💔
10 years preaching didn't work then loot started that's successful.
❤❤❤❤❤
Qaiser Ahmad Raja Rebuttal comming soon
Starting from
"Ye Socialist Secular Terrorists........"😂I
Usko bhi Rozi Roti krni hai bechare ko
No one explained it better
Kiya karl maxx ne islamic system ko copy Kiya tha
👍👍👍
People should have the right to earn and have property. Otherwise it will pave way for dictatorship.
Muhammad was born in the slave society and he perpetuated all the rules of slave society ; feudal system also exploited the serfs and the socialist society of the 20 th century ended the exploitation. But you regard that period of history remarkable where women were made loondis and sold in the market places.
❤
Where is contemporary history, all this history is based on Islamic sources. Being Muslim, i believe in it but it doest stand the scrutiny of modern history. There is another problem, zakat rate on income is @2.5% which has no historical basis. Plz ask Illyas saheb.
Now this is against the notion that Islam lacks a comprehensive system or the concept of a state (3:50).
My point has never been that Muslims didn’t develop a political and economic system. My point is that this political and economic system continues to change with changed objective conditions and that we should remain open to this change in order to progress.
@@Taimur_Laal this view , when you put like this appears to be more clear and seems fair . however, to which extent a change could be acceptable in Islamic framework has not been discussed yet by you .
That would be interesting.
@@hammadhussain4422 this is what I have always said. My arguments have always been distorted by my opponents.
Hazrat Umer Farooq Razi Allah u Anhu is the second Khalifa of islam. The one who does not give him respect by heart and try to count his achievements as "Mistakes" is not a Muslim.
It was almost soviet model.
Bhai Aapne kaha Ye System Islam Ke Hazaron Saal Pahle Se Chalta Aa Raha Tha, Aap Logo Ko Ye Baat Kyu Nahi Samajh Aati ke Islam Tab se Hai Jab Se Ye Dunia Bani Aadam Alaihissalam Pahle Paigamber hai Aur Muhammad Sallallahu Alaihi wa sallam Aakhri Paigamber hai
"islam se pehle raids ka maqsad maal lootna tha, jab k islam k aane k baad ye mamla change ho gaya" WHAT A JOKE!
Agar aisa he tha islam ka sab se pehla large scale battle(Badr) 1 tejarti kafla lootna he Q tha???
Secondly, if 1/5th of the loot is for Allah and Prophet then where does 4/5th go??? What about the sex slaves that the prophet and companions used to keep, didn't they get it in fightings???
آپ ابھی بچے ہو سوال میں ہی جہالت ٹپک رہی ہے تب ہی جواب کا دل نہیں کیا۔۔۔ کیونکہ جاہل حق واضح ہونے کے بعد بھی گردن سے سریا نہیں نکالتے یہاں تک کہ مر کر گل سڑ کر ہی انکا غرور مٹتا ہے ۔۔
Mecca was not on trade route
Khalifa is not a king Allah is the king of Khalifa is like viceroy and there is no particular way of choosing a Khalifa the Khalifa himself can choose the next Khalifa or they can choose five people the choose among themselves
It's mean muttah was. Banned by Umar not the prophet.. reasons were administrative.
Yes. Sadly no muslims will accept that.
🌟 First thing, arabs were mainly agriculutral based. Kindly have some basic idea on arab region.
Secondly, Macca was NEVER trading centre
You are completely mistaken !!
Kindly read Quran before you attempt Islamic topic. Its lot of disinformation
Regards,
The Bedouin, Beduin, or Bedu (/ˈbɛduɪn/; Arabic: بَدْو, romanized: badū, singular بَدَوِي badawī) are pastorally nomadic Arab tribes who have historically inhabited the desert regions in the Arabian Peninsula, North Africa, the Levant, and Mesopotamia (Iraq). The Bedouin originated in the Syrian Desert and Arabian Desert but spread across the rest of the Arab world in West Asia and North Africa after the spread of Islam. The English word bedouin comes from the Arabic badawī, which means "desert-dweller", and is traditionally contrasted with ḥāḍir, the term for sedentary people.
@@Taimur_Laal Kindly read Quran which elaborates agriculture being the main stream profession of arabs.
Also read about Dadan, Yathreb, Tema, Al hegra(Pre Islamic) and the #dams constructed during umayad era in Yathreb and Taif.
Regards,
Of course there has to be some agriculture. Otherwise people will starve to death. But it was extremely small scale in comparison to Iraq, Egypt and Syria. This is the Fertile Crescent. The birth place of the agricultural revolution.
زراعت تھی لیکن اس درجے کی نہ تھی کہ سب عرب کو زرعی علاقہ ہی کہا جائے۔۔
جب عرب ، فارس و روم کے کمانڈر آمنے سامنے ہوتے تھے تو روم و فارس کے کمانڈر عربوں کو یہی کہتے تھے کہ تم لوگ بھوکے ہو ننگے ہو، عرب کی گرمی اور بھوک نے تمھیں تنگ کیا ہے اور تم ہمارے علاقوں پر چڑھ دوڑے ہو، آؤ تمھیں کچھ کھانے پینے کو دیں اور مال دیں اور تم واپس جاؤ
Hazrat Umar k wo karnamay bhi batayega k jo unho ne hazrat ali aur bibi fatima k sath kia jiski waja se muslim ummah shia sunni me taqseem hui.
I know one thing upon death of Hazrat Umar RA:
Hazrat Ali RA invoked Allah's Mercy for 'Umar RA and said, "O 'Umar! You have not left behind you a person whose deeds I like to imitate and meet Allah with more than I like your deeds. By Allah!
Disagreement is a common thing which can happen even between them but that’s fine because they didn’t hold grudge with each other rather pray for each other. Also when you research something make it credible by verifying it from 3-4 independent sources otherwise it has no value.
Shia Sunni division came after Karbala and Banu Ummayah.
@@farazahmed0 first of all your quoted fake quotation towards hazrat ali. Islamic history has solid proofs in the books which happened. I myself have verified it.
Sunni shia divide were started from saqeefa. Which solidified after karbala.
شاید آپ بھی اب جواب نہ دے پائیں مگر خیر۔۔۔۔
دراصل یہ مجوسیوں کی لکھی کہانیاں ہیں۔۔۔ یہ بات سمجھنی چاہیے کہ نبی محمد کا خط جب شاہ فارس کے پاس پہنچا تو اس نے خط پھاڑا اور نبی پاک کو گرفتار کرنے بھیجا کہ عرب کا ایک بدو چرواہا مجھے اطاعت کا حکم دیتا ہے۔۔۔
فارس و روم کی سلطنتوں کے سامنے عربوں کی کچھ اوقات نہ تھی ۔ اس لیے جب روم و فارس فتح ہو گئے تو فارس کے مجوسیوں نے خوب اپنے سینے پیٹے، یہ جو آج بھی آپ سینے پیٹنے کی مشق دیکھتے ہیں جس جو اسلام سے جوڑا جاتا ہے یہ دراصل وہی فارس کی سلطنت کی جلن ہے۔۔۔
اس کے بعد مجوسیوں نے سیدنا علی کو کوفے میں خوب ستایا اور لعنت پائی پھر سیدنا حسن کو ستایا پھر سیدنا حسین کو کوفے بلا کر دھوکے سے قتل کروایا ۔۔۔
مجوسیوں نے اسلام کے ٹکرے ٹکرے کرنے میں کوئی کسر نہیں چھوڑی۔۔۔
ہر دشمن اسلام کا ساتھ دیا صرف اور صرف فارس کی جلن میں۔۔۔
ہر وہ صحابی جو فارس کو شکست دینے، فوجیں بھیجنے میں شامل ہے مجوسیوں نے اس کے خلاف تاریخ لکھی ہوئی ہے، ابوبکر، عمر، عثمان، سعد بن ابی وقاص ، مغیرہ ابن شعبہ، خالد بن ولید ، یہ سب سلطنت فارس کو نقصان پہنچانے میں شامل رہے۔۔۔۔ ان پر مجوسی آج تک اپنے بادشاہ کی طرح لعنت کر کے خود کو تسلی دے رہے ہیں۔۔۔ ورنہ سیدنا علی اور انکی فیملی کا مجوس کو کیا غم؟؟ یہ سب تو عرب تھے ۔۔۔۔ عربوں سے تو ایرانی ویسے بھی جلتے ہیں سلطنت کی یاد میں۔۔۔
پاکستان میں سید ہونے کے دعویدار سعودیہ کے مطابق مجوسی ہیں وہ کہتے ہیں کہ ان کی کالی شکلیں دیکھو اور ایران سے محبت دیکھو یہ پکے مجوس نسل ہیں اور سلطنت کی جلن میں عربوں کو گالیاں دیتے ہیں۔
agar hazrat umar ka dosre mulkon pr hamla kr k wahan k logon ka qatl e aam kr k un k mulk pr qabza krna theek he tu phir ye kaam koi bhi karay theek hona chahye dosre karay tu ghalat lekin Umar karay tu theek ye duhra meyaar q?
ان اصحاب نے نبی پاک کے فرمان کے مطابق حملے کیے تھے اور اللّٰہ کے قانون کے مطابق نبی کی اطاعت نہ کرنے والوں کو سزا ملی۔۔۔ ایک ہی کمانڈر خالد کافی ہوا۔۔۔ اور ہزار سال سے قائم روم و فارس کی سلطنتوں کی اینٹ سے اینٹ بجا دی۔۔۔
روم نے پھر مان لیا۔۔۔ مگر فارسی چونکہ مجوس تھے نسل پرست تھے اس لیے انہوں نے اپنے بادشاہ کی طرح آج تک لعنتوں کا سلسلہ جاری رکھا ہوا ہے اور سلطنت فارس کے غم میں جو ماتم ہوا تھا وہ آج ان کی نسل کی عبادت بنا ہوا ہے۔
Hazrat Umar ne Iran ko bhi fatah kiya is liye Majoosi Rafzi hazrat Umar se bugzh rakhte hai. Jalte raho.
@@wisedome3433 iran me jo islam phela he wo imam ali raza a.s ki badolat phela he.
Baqi majosi umar k baray me kia khayal krte hen wo tmhe majosio se jakar pochna hoga.
@@Truth-qe6sf
وہ اسلام علی رضا کا نہیں بلکہ مجوسیوں کے بنائے ہوئے فرقے کا ہے۔۔۔ دل سے اسلام قبول کر لیتے مجوسی، نہ اسلام کے خلاف سازشیں کرتے، نہ سیدنا عمر کو قتل کرواتے نہ سیدنا عثمان کو قتل کروا کر سیدنا علی و معاویہ میں جنگیں چھیڑتے، تو آج اصل اسلام ان تک بھی پہنچ چکا ہوتا۔
۔
@@hasbideadman tu tumharay kehne ka matlab he k agar umar majosio pr hamla kr k unka qatl e aam kr k un k ghar pr qabza na krta tu aaj majosio ne islam ko nuqsan nhi puhunchaya hota. Ye sari umar ki ghalati he k us ne majosio pr hamla kr k unhe majbor kia k wo umar k kuilaf hon aur wo islam k khilaaf ho. Tu is me tu sara qusoor umar ka he k jis ki waja se islam ko nuqsan pohuncha. Zahir si baat he k tum kisi k auper hamla kr k unhe nuqsan pohunchaogay aur wo reaction me tum ko nuqsan pohunchaye tu qusor reaction dene walay ka nhi balkay tumhara he.
Bring more contributions from my Idon Umar e Farooque Aazam Radiallaho Taaala Anho in the service of islam.
Love & respect for your teachings from Chandrapur, Maharashta, India
SubhanALLAH
It has nothing to do with Islam Omer just conquered those countries and Omer is just ordinary Muslim and nothing else …
Sadly no muslims will accept what you said.
It doest not affect him and anyone else what u think...other than yourself.....
@@Onlymuslim-28724 bit what he commented is true though.
@@Onlymuslim-28724 but what he commented is true though.
آپ نے فرمایا اسلام کے ابتدائی فالوور نے اپنی جدوجہد کا آغاز ریڈنگ سے کیا۔۔
کھلے الفاظ میں کیوں نہیں کہا کہ تجارت کے بجائے لوٹ مار سے کیا۔۔
آج کے وی لاگ میں پہلے والی دلیری نہیں دیکھی گئی۔۔۔
@@MuhammadAshraf-mh5dl it is not a question of courage but a question of historical facts. The great historian Montgomery Watt has explained the central role of trade between Yemen and Syria (through Mecca) played a key role in the social structure of Arabia.
hazrat umar farooq is not perfect but still he is a genius...his ideas are practical
Tü putar jop rah
🌹💚میری جان حضرت عــــــــــمـــــــــــــــــــرفاروق رضی اللہ تعالیٰ عنہ💚🌹
i said again he is not perfect
So what is perfect?
I think humans are perfect when they believe in one God and obey the holy book as it is.
Otherwise there will be no chances of perfect.
Because humans are born with mistakes.
prophet make mistakes and they are not perfect. perfection is only for god
لیکن مولانا مودودی صاحب نے 'مسئلہ ء ملکیت زمین میں بالکل مختلف فتوی دیا ہے ۔
🖐🏻
Bekaar, maza nahin aya
شاید آپ مجوس ہو۔۔۔ یا پھر
👍👍👍