Men Without Work: Key Findings - Dr. Nicholas Eberstadt

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 23 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 21

  • @fallsgrave
    @fallsgrave 6 лет назад +2666

    There are a ton of jobs out there. Many more than there are people... It's that these jobs have no room for advancement, no promotion, no benefits or career path and low pay. Who wants to participate in a society that sees you as disposable? Not me.

  • @terrythompson7535
    @terrythompson7535 5 лет назад +1017

    You can ignore reality.. but you cannot ignore the consequences of ignoring reality..

  • @atonewiththedust
    @atonewiththedust 7 лет назад +617

    This is what the breakdown of the traditional family and the "liberation" of women gets you.

    • @happymgtow4133
      @happymgtow4133 6 лет назад +202

      yep and the outsourcing of everything overseas in search of more $.

    • @indviduation
      @indviduation 6 лет назад +172

      So your daughters you teaching them to be housewives, eh?

  • @wealldieanyway5374
    @wealldieanyway5374 6 лет назад +446

    This trend will continue. Life has become mundane and dull, so have we. Skill has been replaced by technology, so have we. Nothing left to do but let the fruits of our labor render us obsolete. Perhaps a war or economic collapse will give us purpose again? We will flourish when we are needed.

  • @Ulrna
    @Ulrna 7 лет назад +432

    The problem is Not uniquely American, We have the same kind of problem in Europe, its even worse, no work for anyone.

  • @johnow7
    @johnow7 7 лет назад +449

    I can't help watching this and thinking of discussions that I have been having with Trekkies and a friend who believe that it will be so wonderful when or if society reaches a point when everyone's basic needs will be taken care of and no one will have to work. They believe that most people will self improve academically, professionally, and spiritually by solely their own initiative. I believe that most people in such a world will be like the men that he is speaking of in this lecture. I can't believe that anyone would think that once everyone's basic needs were met and work would be unnecessary that most people wouldn't spend most of their time with leisure activities.

  • @bneedalm
    @bneedalm 7 лет назад +249

    I have two conjectures. First, the data sources show only those people who hold or desire "legitimate" jobs. It is highly likely that most "inactive" people are in fact engaged in under the table work and are not reporting that work. Second, as our economy becomes more productive, more people are able to lead a "non-consumer" lifestyle. Food, basic clothing, and out of big cities, housing has become relatively cheaper. For some, time is valued over money. Over time worker productivity increases and less income is necessary to provide the basics of life.

    • @ErickaWilliamsCC
      @ErickaWilliamsCC 6 лет назад +31

      Barry Needalman yes I meet many people working under the table in central Texas

  • @ohthankg-dforthebourgeoisi9800
    @ohthankg-dforthebourgeoisi9800 7 лет назад +176

    I wonder if there are social circles where everyone in the group are unemployed and discourage each other from participating in activities that would be productive. Or if these are individuals that are making independent decisions. This would be important to know if you want to change the situation.

  • @AramakiMakisan
    @AramakiMakisan 7 лет назад +185

    At 33:20 he mentions the rate of leaving men does not match up with the boom and bust cycles and yet he mentions why that may be the case earlier when he said that women started entering the workplace as a reason for why this wasn't noticed earlier.
    I get the feeling that his personal politics/ideology are preventing him from analysing his own data.

    • @Chillfacor666
      @Chillfacor666 7 лет назад +130

      Are you serious? So, its your contention that women in the workforce had zero effect on the economy? Do you even realize what your saying?

  • @THECHAOSEMPEROR
    @THECHAOSEMPEROR 7 лет назад +82

    The intro music reminds me of Saving private Ryan.

  • @paddy3002
    @paddy3002 6 лет назад +126

    this was painful to watch...the future looks bleak....

  • @bryanalmeida5342
    @bryanalmeida5342 7 лет назад +13

    Is this video in 60fps? It keeps stumbling in my chromecast.

    • @woooweee
      @woooweee 6 лет назад +13

      yes, its 720p60

  • @ezratay1
    @ezratay1 7 лет назад +40

    I can't believe there are no comments from this video. Anyway, how do we change the values of men in America? How can instill the values of immigrant in the souls of native born American men? I'm reading Dr Eberstadt book now and I find it freighting.

  • @davidfarley1555
    @davidfarley1555 6 лет назад +83

    Or could it be just pure laziness! In otherword's bottom feeders!!!!