already four years, and many other idol survival show, but this show left the best feeling... mentors, trainees, performance, interaction.. i love them all.
This performance was outstanding though... You can still tell they worked hard, no matter what. I can't believe the way some of them were scored even compared to others that made class a and b
Weng7788 not all the choreography copied only like 10 to 20 sec like the choreography same with the yugyeom hit the stage i think...n doesn’t mean that he copied right? why all the people being so salty n said the choreography is copied but like seriously only 10 to 20 sec like that😑 edit : btw how u know that jackson know that they copied the dance? ohh are u mind reader? i guess not😐 so guys stop being salty..im not being rude just want to explain🙂
Angelo Santos hey the intro from seventeen is just looking up and walking many idol do this choreo..n exo sitting down also not only exo can do this many idol do it also n wanna one also..
Oh please, Banana Culture's group deserves the lower rankings for sure. They may be talented but they plagiarized a choreography from Got7 Yugyeom's "Hit the Stage" performance and said they choreographed it. They not only stole credit for a dance they never made, but also lied right in front of the judge's face about. That included Jackson, as if he wouldn't know the choreography of his little brother. The beginning was also stolen from Seventeen's "Don't Wanna Cry" and one more was also put in there. Their dance was more like a compilation of choreographies, which is fine, but then they tried to pass it off as theirs, which is not.
Cheryl and some cats If the leader of banana culture said he used senior’s dance in his dance performance at the time, people wouldn’t be that mad. But the other trainees was innocent, there are still talented trainees inside them but because his words many people boycott the whole group. Besides, idol producer pick the top 9 trainees to debut, not the whole group from each company. Haih...
Lucky Starxoxo But somebody should've declined it instead of going along with the lie. If they didn't know, that's fine but that still means he deserves the rank.
Cheryl and some cats what if those trainees didn’t know where the actual performance comes from? I mean the one who choreographed the dance surely knows, but the others might just learn and follow the dance moves without noticing it. Besides, the one who answered the question is their leader, if one of the trainees reveal the truth infront of so many trainees and teachers. The leader might feel ashamed, and there will be fan wars happened between each bananas trainees. So, the person that should be responsible for this should be the one who answered the question. He really should answer it more carefully. I hope you give chances to the other trainees.
To the people still complaining about choreography- I’m a dancer. There is no such thing as original choreography anymore, or if there is it’s rare. People get inspiration from a number of dances and certain moves may be appealing to them. It’s not the moves themselves, but rather the combination of various moves that make a dance. Take the shoot dance. It’s everywhere. Are they all plagiarizing because their choreographers take credit for creating the dance? No. Certain moves may be recognizable but unless it’s move for move and beat for beat, then it’s not plagiarism, that’s just how choreography works. Thanks for coming to my TED Talk.
I guess originality is rare, but claiming that the choreography was by you IS plagiarism. There was A LOT of similar moves. He should have credited Yugyeom. Even Jackson whispered 'copied' to Lay after.
Tae Kookie i dont think they were able to credit yug out loud since this is a chinese broadcast. Claiming its theirs is... a grey area. Its theirs in the sense they did create certain combination of dance. Its just that they took a lot of yugyeoms dance. You never know maybe they said it but the show cut it out :/
mands ; sorry i wasn't informed of that until now, but i still think even "copying" some coreographies and arranging the whole performance to look that solid needs a lot of practice i don't mean to offend you but some team do covers too so i don't think it's bad considering they are still trainees besides, if some of the moves such as the clock hand thing is credited to others then dancers can't even move freely
the thing is he said he choreographed it himself, if he just said he did the cover dance it was all fine, people are angry or upset because he claimed it was his own work :/
Sydney Yuanita I'm agree with you...for me the words choreographed can also means rearranging things/move to solid new performance... and people nowadays always ignores the practice & effort dancers or artist put in their performance... citizens/people love to find wrongdoing others without consider the full story behind it.... TT
A OH hahaha...its not about dumb or young...Im just tired with this all about...tired with all this comment from "maybe" youngster who overreact and abviously only know dancing and etc from kpop or cpop...haha...bcz we dont know what really happened behind the editing...or maybe he too exhausted, young or too nervous so answer it wrongly....we dont know kid!...
Agreed and I just found the show with sub-titles. Amazing show that launched so many worthy entertainers. Lin Yanjun is my bias and those dimples need to be insured.
I watching idol producer until now because this group...love them.. .theyre so talented good voice, dance rap n visual too.most handsome Yanjun and foodie YZ... so good!.. .. please hater get lost.. dont spread hatred here... (⌒o⌒)
Ikr and his latest single Christmas has you already reached more than 6 million popularity points in qq music and is diamond certified.,. He mean business for banana entertainment..
This is the most beautiful and heart warming performance in the first performances of Idol Producer Goodluck to all of them especially to the vocalist and the choreograper guy I'm rooting for you guys you're already in my top 9
It's been 2 months yet i still see people commenting on this that they copied Kpop dances. Let me get this straight. Lin Chaoze clearly said that he choreographed MOST of the dance, not all. And I'm saying this as an ahgase, wannable, carat, and exo-l, just give them a break. Yes, I'm not denying that he should've given credits, but don't make such a big deal that he did not. As a dancer myself, it is hard to think of a choreography that is as amazing and powerful as that. And it's not like he copied the dance for his own song or anything like that, it is simply for a cover. And who knows, they may have said that they were inspired but some Kpop dances but China could've decided to edit it out, you never know. They only took 10s-15s of Yugyeom dance. For Wanna One's, many people do that now, and plus it could've been choreographed back in 1900s and Wanna One took that choreography, you never know ;) For the walking around in Seventeen's Don't Wanna Cry, c'mon, can't they even walk around? And for EXO's floor move thing, saying they copied that is simply outrageous, everyone does it nowadays. And they're amazing vocalists and dancers after all, so strop hating on them.
Linang Algo I agree but in the second evaluations gao maotong moves from c to d Lin Yanjun a lap moved from c to d and li Ruotian went from c to f and Jiang jing zuo, Lu Dinghao, qiu zhixie stayyed in c class and Bei Honglin upgraded from c class to b class while you Zhangjing upgraded from b to a class then Lin chaoze got a level in this performance and he remained in a level
@@mariannes6657 only you zhangjing and Lin yanjun successfully made into the debuting team...the remaining 7 of them already debuted in the group tangram under banana entertainment..it's also rumoured that zhangjing will release his solo album after the disbandment of nine percent. I am not sure about Lin Yan Jun though.
I know us ahgasaes are upset that yugyeom wasn't credited but this is a CHINESE show after all, even Lay and Jackson didn't talk bout their grps but talked about their personal careers I don't think he meant to not credit yugyeom I just don't think it was allowed or advisable but that's just my opinion. I hope everyone will discuss about this issue rationally and will not bash without looking at the context
IsaacIN2U_ Violet The original is by Yoga Lin, but I like this version more, the harmonies really get me 🙈 I love Yoga Lin, but because he's a soloist, the song lacks the beautiful harmonies this one has 🙈
Latest update on banana boys in nine percent...you zhangjing already successfully made his solo debut in June with his first ost song ao Hong chen which ranked first in China billboard chart for the month of July..he also voted as the best new artist in China region for the whole month if August on weibo and he successfully upgraded his category into Asia Pacific region which he topped the chart on the first 2 weeks of September....now he is busy preparing for nine percent upcoming album and also his solo activity.,..who would have thought that a low profile contestant like him would made so big eventhough he is from Malaysia a foreigner...
The question about the choreography could have been edited out, but to make the show a more authentic reality show it is best not to. Lin Chaotze may have thought the question is about the choreography on the first part. The performance on the second part is to showcase their dancing skill (as performers are also asked to) and in their case they showcase it as a group whereas Bei Honglin also showcase his rapping skill individually. They are not trying to deceive anyone intentionally as everyone say anyone with a trained eye (Lay, Jackson and the dance mentors) will be able to recognize the Hit The Stage choreography, and people who asked them to be kicked out of the show just so that their favorites will have a better chance of getting in are being ridiculous. I think Lay understood that the leader just gave an erroneous reply cos of the occasion (some have stage fright and other giving an erroneous reply and forgetting to give credit to whoever) Anyway just appreciate what was a good performance.
Even seasoned performers will need feedback from a team of choreographer. Just treat it as a dance medley or performance medley like people singing in song medleys...Will people mention that the song is a medley of which singers if the medley of songs are so obvious.
It is a medley of singing and dancing performance just as in in medley of songs. He had no intent of deceiving and gave an erroneous answer probably surprised by such a question. They are just idol contestant and not expert dance choreographer.
And I mean why would they "oh so obviously" copy Yugyeom's dance if Jackson who watched the actual performance himself would be there???? Even if they did copy the dance, the dance was still hard making them put their efforts into learning the dance
i love it how everyone pointed out the fact that they copied the dance and this wasn't creativ at all *but ignores how talented their are by singing and dancing even thought it was copied* _--_
LadyLisa01 _. I am not sure if they did or not but still it meant to be a good choreo and not a creative one. I was just mad cause I didn't understood why people wished that they would get eliminated soon. This made me pissed off
kkaep horat yes, I understand what you are saying. Just because they copied someone doesn't mean they are bad, especially not to the point of having to be eliminated. And I'm sure if the program speaks up about this, the guy will apologise. I'm not saying he did something good but it's not bad enough to the point of heving to be excluded from the program
This is a very beautiful song! The vocals are good, the harmonization is wonderful, Zhangjing hit the high notes too! Great job Banana Culture Ent. for giving a great performance for the song and dance too! For me, they have the best performance as a group!
for me I believe that Zhangjing should have gotten an A score for this audition piece, & other members should have higher scores. Anyway, he got in the final top 9 of Idol Producer so all is good.
i think it's possible that the leader was only referring to the choreography of the singing part and not the dance part... i know they did not give credit to yugyeom and others (or maybe the show did not show it), but i still want to appreciate how beautiful their singing is and how good they are as a team!
I believe he said Majority was choreographed by him and the other trainees give him ideas and stuff so he didn’t say the entire dance was choreographed by him
Majority by him, and opinions from other members. Bus didn’t say ANYTHING about “borrowing/inspired” by other artists. Hmmm...omission is a form of lying. There is no way around that fact.
A lost ELF - everlastingfriend , the BC trainee (Lin Chaoze) could have said: “the dance was inspired by other artists.” without using any words like “South Korea”. The political issue can’t be an excuse for taking credit for other artists’ work.
Maybe he just didn’t think of saying that or he did mention it but the editors cut it? It’s kinda sad for him though because he probably doesn’t know about this and can’t clarify himself.
Watching idol producer s3 now makes me realised how little of screen time jiang jing zuo gets..... he was outstanding in this performance and had quite alot of centre parts yet he’s graded C
A OH compared to u maybe? Choreographing and harmonizing isn't as easy as u think. Try choreographing for urself first and see how well u do. But do remember that he has to choreograph for 9 PEOPLE and even think of their positions and formations and how to make them stand out during their part.
A OH lol, I'm not from China. There is a reason why I speak decent English. You are the one being racist here. U claim that Chinese people are close minded, however u are so adamant about ur view and refuse to think of the other perspectives and also from the leader's shoes. And since you obviously don't understand chinese, let me tell you what he had atually said.He said that he choreographed MOST of the dance and not ALL of it and he said that he did it WITH the help of his members. Most choreographies have dance moves that are commonly in many choreographies.Did you know the starting move of got7 hard carry where they shrug their shoulders is what shinee does for their song replay? So are you going to say that got7 plagiarized Shinee? I absolutely love kpop, but if u look closely, the choreography isn't exactly the same. There were actually parts where they had edited the it. Check this out : ruclips.net/video/z-er_rVDlUk/видео.html
A OH and if u are so unhappy the show, stop watching it then. No one is forcing u to watch, so stop hating on them unless u can do better than them in terms of singing, rap and dance. Oh and make sure u are able to choreograph and compose songs as well as write lyrics speak multiple languages.
A OH lol, it isn't cause there are more to think about on where the need to stand how they should move to make the formation look better. He also has to decide how to make each part of the dance make a specific person stand out. And no it is NOT easier to choreograph for 9 ppl than it is for 3 ppl. I've created choreographies and I do dance as well as music. If u think that it is that easy to choreograph, why not choreograph for 9 people and get 8ppl to dance with u and post it online,n
Lovely performance, I was honestly amazed. And I'm so done with certain comments about plagiarism here. They never said that they made the ENTIRE thing by themselves and also, certain dance moves did not even originate from the kpop idols some of the people are mentioning here.
It's September 2018 and I came back for this! This performance would always have a special place in my heart! The best audition piece by a group at Idol Producer!
well this is was 'chinese survival show', and they would don't want to involve from outsider especially between China-Korea nowadays you know, they have a bit problem.maybe because of that Lin Chaoze (leader) banana culture, doesn't want to say it maybe, who know.also we don't know about their story so please stop ignoring or compared about anything since they are truly talent considering this was 'survival show' .^^
STOP BASHING THEM. This was one of the best performance for evaluation. They might have taken the dance of the got7 member but that doesn't mean there is no originality in their performance. And when that A trainee had said that he had made most of the choreography he had also mentioned that he got ideas from others too. He might have meant the vocal part's choreography but who knows. You all are going around writing huge ass paragraphs on how they didn't give credit but then just stand in their position and let's see if you remember what to speak. These boys did so much hardwork yet there are only a few who appreciate it. Great.
back here after 3 years, time has gone by so quickly. From this performance You Zhangjing became one of my picks and i remember crying when he got in :') i have watched most of the shows from both iqiyi and tencent, but this one just hits different.
I love this performance so much ❤. The vocals were beautifuk and the dance was amazing 💕. They could actually debut as a group. And im also very happy that Yanjun and Zhangjing got in the final Top 9 ❤!
For ppl who keep gg on about them copying kpop idols: the moves which u claimed are from wanna one which is most likely the stomping part is a very comman dance move and plus moves like looking upwards are common. there are many choreographies where the idol looks upwards, so do u want to say seventeen copied some other boy band? and plus the floor move which i am sure are referring to exo's is not something that is rare. there are many choreographies that include them dancing on the floor and such. and the leader said he choreographed MOST of it and not ALL of it. Yes he could have said that part was from Yugyeom performance, but that itself would stir up politcal issues as well. And he did say his members helped him. So what if it was his members' suggestion? As a leader, he has a greater responsibility compared to the rest. In addition, has it ever occur to you that he may have not know that yugyeom's choreography was done by jackson teammate? plus if u want to claim that it is plagerism, what about moves from BTS blood sweat tears? the one where the all move against the floor? that particular move is done by Uniq in EOEO first. so are u gg to accuse BTS of plagerism? Not to drag bts down cause i stan them hardcore. Just wanted to make a point here. And plus, dancing to choreographies are already hard enough, so what makes u think that choreographing for 9 PEOPLE is easy?Please look at their talents too cause it isnt easy to harmonise too. plus to remain stable while dancing isnt easy either. Plus if you people keep criticizing them as its making u unhappy, then just stop watching. Simple as that. No one is forcing u too watch now are they? And plus the mentors also said that they have great harmonies which u need to put in a lot of effort and practice to do well. And if u think harmonies are that easy to do, try doing it on ur own. Since I have music background, I know that it is not easy to harmonize unless u are born with it. And plus they have multiple talented singers like you changjing who was the one that hit the high notes. There were also some differences in choreographies. They didn't actually copy it exactly, they actually DID change some parts. Look up this link. ruclips.net/video/z-er_rVDlUk/видео.html
Lee Ann Chong Finally found someone who thinks like me. Making a choreography for a whole song with whole new steps is not possible. Just look at them they are so talented. No matter what others say I'm gonna support them.😍😍
![Banana Culture trainees first evaluation - Idol Producer 偶像练习生 [ENG SUB]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/RJSzbPKQY7o/mqdefault.jpg)
![Banana Culture trainees first evaluation - Idol Producer 偶像练习生 [ENG SUB]](/img/tr.png)
already four years, and many other idol survival show, but this show left the best feeling... mentors, trainees, performance, interaction.. i love them all.
Six years later and this comment holds true. I've seen many shows and Idol Producer still shines differently.
現在回來看這個舞台 覺得好好看 很厲害
看到後期的 林超澤 尤長靖 林彥俊 對團隊的貢獻
第一期有這樣的表現 似乎又不奇怪了
他们三人组织能力很强。特别是林超泽，天生的队长！尤长靖有团队精神，愿意也懂得怎样去教其他人。而林彦俊则有舞台魅力，光芒四射。
反复看了很多次，这次看到了姜京佐还不小心踩了小尤😂
@@eejoo1617 哪里😂
@@eejoo1617 他回去青你3
@@dialing1111 3:06
Support You Zhang Jing 🖤🖤🖤
Haesley_KLM 6 you should support the other members from this performance because they did their best
This performance was outstanding though... You can still tell they worked hard, no matter what. I can't believe the way some of them were scored even compared to others that made class a and b
It might look good as a show but the teachers looks at them individually. Some of them don't really shine as much as others
Weng7788 not all the choreography copied only like 10 to 20 sec like the choreography same with the yugyeom hit the stage i think...n doesn’t mean that he copied right? why all the people being so salty n said the choreography is copied but like seriously only 10 to 20 sec like that😑
edit : btw how u know that jackson know that they copied the dance? ohh are u mind reader? i guess not😐 so guys stop being salty..im not being rude just want to explain🙂
민 민 not only the chireo hit the stage
the intro is from seventeen dont wanna cry
is also take choreo from exo and wann one
Angelo Santos hey the intro from seventeen is just looking up and walking many idol do this choreo..n exo sitting down also not only exo can do this many idol do it also n wanna one also..
민 민 ruclips.net/video/SWxkOznzfQQ/видео.html
You! Zhang! Jing!
Please pick him~
And also Lin Yanjun
Yes. He is ranked 67 currently, very low rank for a main vocal
Oh please, Banana Culture's group deserves the lower rankings for sure. They may be talented but they plagiarized a choreography from Got7 Yugyeom's "Hit the Stage" performance and said they choreographed it. They not only stole credit for a dance they never made, but also lied right in front of the judge's face about. That included Jackson, as if he wouldn't know the choreography of his little brother. The beginning was also stolen from Seventeen's "Don't Wanna Cry" and one more was also put in there. Their dance was more like a compilation of choreographies, which is fine, but then they tried to pass it off as theirs, which is not.
Cheryl and some cats If the leader of banana culture said he used senior’s dance in his dance performance at the time, people wouldn’t be that mad. But the other trainees was innocent, there are still talented trainees inside them but because his words many people boycott the whole group. Besides, idol producer pick the top 9 trainees to debut, not the whole group from each company. Haih...
Lucky Starxoxo But somebody should've declined it instead of going along with the lie. If they didn't know, that's fine but that still means he deserves the rank.
Cheryl and some cats what if those trainees didn’t know where the actual performance comes from? I mean the one who choreographed the dance surely knows, but the others might just learn and follow the dance moves without noticing it. Besides, the one who answered the question is their leader, if one of the trainees reveal the truth infront of so many trainees and teachers. The leader might feel ashamed, and there will be fan wars happened between each bananas trainees. So, the person that should be responsible for this should be the one who answered the question. He really should answer it more carefully. I hope you give chances to the other trainees.
Fighthing You Zhang Jing ~~~ ❤❤❤
To the people still complaining about choreography- I’m a dancer. There is no such thing as original choreography anymore, or if there is it’s rare. People get inspiration from a number of dances and certain moves may be appealing to them. It’s not the moves themselves, but rather the combination of various moves that make a dance. Take the shoot dance. It’s everywhere. Are they all plagiarizing because their choreographers take credit for creating the dance? No. Certain moves may be recognizable but unless it’s move for move and beat for beat, then it’s not plagiarism, that’s just how choreography works. Thanks for coming to my TED Talk.
I guess originality is rare, but claiming that the choreography was by you IS plagiarism. There was A LOT of similar moves. He should have credited Yugyeom. Even Jackson whispered 'copied' to Lay after.
Tae Kookie i dont think they were able to credit yug out loud since this is a chinese broadcast. Claiming its theirs is... a grey area. Its theirs in the sense they did create certain combination of dance. Its just that they took a lot of yugyeoms dance. You never know maybe they said it but the show cut it out :/
@@fatin9769 he said he choreographed most of it though (atleast according to the subs)
Alexa Tamara yes. I assume he did choreograph this because he choreographs a lot of the dances through out the show and is a great dancer.
Morgan M you are so true they kept saying that Chaoze copied yugyeoms dance and im like “ There is no original in this fucking universe ‘
You zhang jing's vocal on point😍
Who's still here watching?? Thanks to these boys they made my quarantine fun
Fantanstic You Zhang Jing !
i love their performance the best because they look so prepared
like, they ain't here to play around and i'm here for it
mands ; sorry i wasn't informed of that until now, but i still think even "copying" some coreographies and arranging the whole performance to look that solid needs a lot of practice
i don't mean to offend you but some team do covers too so i don't think it's bad considering they are still trainees
besides, if some of the moves such as the clock hand thing is credited to others then dancers can't even move freely
the thing is he said he choreographed it himself, if he just said he did the cover dance it was all fine, people are angry or upset because he claimed it was his own work :/
Sydney Yuanita I'm agree with you...for me the words choreographed can also means rearranging things/move to solid new performance... and people nowadays always ignores the practice & effort dancers or artist put in their performance... citizens/people love to find wrongdoing others without consider the full story behind it.... TT
thank youuuuu omg some people are so ignorant
A OH hahaha...its not about dumb or young...Im just tired with this all about...tired with all this comment from "maybe" youngster who overreact and abviously only know dancing and etc from kpop or cpop...haha...bcz we dont know what really happened behind the editing...or maybe he too exhausted, young or too nervous so answer it wrongly....we dont know kid!...
有長進小小身體,可以有這麼爆發力,真的很厲害,also support 尤長靖💗
years later and i still come back to watch this again. deadass my favorite performance in Idol Producer history
Agreed and I just found the show with sub-titles. Amazing show that launched so many worthy entertainers. Lin Yanjun is my bias and those dimples need to be insured.
The vocals got me shook
In all seriousness this is so incredibly beautiful✨💖
especially you zhangjing's,lin yanjun's and bei honglin's voices
I watching idol producer until now because this group...love them.. .theyre so talented good voice, dance rap n visual too.most handsome Yanjun and foodie YZ... so good!.. ..
please hater get lost.. dont spread hatred here... (⌒o⌒)
Ahn _m Chinese version? Idol producer was always Chinese lol
You Zhangjing truly deserves to be in the Top 9. He got good vocals, can dance well, has skills in variety and a little cutie pie.. ^^
Ikr and his latest single Christmas has you already reached more than 6 million popularity points in qq music and is diamond certified.,. He mean business for banana entertainment..
长靖加油！
This is the most beautiful and heart warming performance in the first performances of Idol Producer Goodluck to all of them especially to the vocalist and the choreograper guy I'm rooting for you guys you're already in my top 9
Taipei Swaggy Rapper He copied/plagiarized almost the whole choreography
Crystal Cube ENTERTAINMENT really? From who?
Taipei Swaggy Rapper From GOT7's Yugyeom, From 17 & Wanna One
Crystal Cube ENTERTAINMENT I just find out about it. I agree to Yugyeom's choreo but not to Wannaone and Seventeen
seventeen is obvious because of the foot work and the beginning
there is also a small part of exo monster
i’m still here even in 2021 “)) i miss them so much! gonna rewatch guten guten banana right now “))
You zhangjing rejuvenates my old and tired soul with his beautiful voice and incredible high notes.
尤长靖不只唱歌好跳舞也很好看啊啊啊啊 请支持大马甜心尤长靖 送他出道好不好😘
Come here again..miss this show and all trainees..ninepercent members..love this song too..
香蕉家出道就弄这种风格的歌 很有团魂很炸
this was on of my favorite performances, they are all on sync, they harmonize amazingly and the have pizazz. i cant just pick one, tgey were one
是我最喜欢的初舞台，超爱唱跳的尤长靖 💕
我是覺得他們乾脆就這樣一個團也挺好……
他們本來就是要出道的團，只是被公司派去參加偶像練習生的，最後有兩個團員因投票票數高而也變成nine percent的團員。
其實應該當初應該讓他們在出道邊緣就好
我是說尤和橘
現在團隊也很少活動
(((別噴
@@蕭子涵-k4j 香蕉娛樂是故意先讓他們兵分二路進行演藝事業的啊 不然兩團同時並行宣傳不是就累死了嗎？
@@loisjan9057 說的好，當然會累死，不像樂華把人搞的累崩了
心疼他們
之後還會回歸的，放心吧
NPC 約期結束應該就回來了
那个原点高音好好听诶
Jia Jamie 尤长靖了解一下吧~~
It's been 2 months yet i still see people commenting on this that they copied Kpop dances. Let me get this straight.
Lin Chaoze clearly said that he choreographed MOST of the dance, not all. And I'm saying this as an ahgase, wannable, carat, and exo-l, just give them a break. Yes, I'm not denying that he should've given credits, but don't make such a big deal that he did not. As a dancer myself, it is hard to think of a choreography that is as amazing and powerful as that. And it's not like he copied the dance for his own song or anything like that, it is simply for a cover. And who knows, they may have said that they were inspired but some Kpop dances but China could've decided to edit it out, you never know.
They only took 10s-15s of Yugyeom dance. For Wanna One's, many people do that now, and plus it could've been choreographed back in 1900s and Wanna One took that choreography, you never know ;) For the walking around in Seventeen's Don't Wanna Cry, c'mon, can't they even walk around? And for EXO's floor move thing, saying they copied that is simply outrageous, everyone does it nowadays.
And they're amazing vocalists and dancers after all, so strop hating on them.
You Zhangjing and Lin Chaoze i support you guys 💪💪💪
It's May 2018 and i'm watching this again! I'll never grow tired of this performance
I come back to this everyday
I can’t get enough of this
This was pure perfection and better than most established artists ...facts
时间真快，还记得刚刚看这一期的时候，现在都决赛了
back after 5 years. remember when i literally had the audio downloaded because i loved it so much and still do🥲
快四個月了 回到這個表演 很有感觸
由九個人 變五個 變四個 再變三個 直到最後兩個能成功出道
雖然如此 香蕉團魂 九人永遠同在🍌💙
Wow they all can sing and dance... they're good
Linang Algo I agree but in the second evaluations gao maotong moves from c to d Lin Yanjun a lap moved from c to d and li Ruotian went from c to f and Jiang jing zuo, Lu Dinghao, qiu zhixie stayyed in c class and Bei Honglin upgraded from c class to b class while you Zhangjing upgraded from b to a class then Lin chaoze got a level in this performance and he remained in a level
@@mariannes6657 only you zhangjing and Lin yanjun successfully made into the debuting team...the remaining 7 of them already debuted in the group tangram under banana entertainment..it's also rumoured that zhangjing will release his solo album after the disbandment of nine percent. I am not sure about Lin Yan Jun though.
I know us ahgasaes are upset that yugyeom wasn't credited but this is a CHINESE show after all, even Lay and Jackson didn't talk bout their grps but talked about their personal careers I don't think he meant to not credit yugyeom I just don't think it was allowed or advisable but that's just my opinion. I hope everyone will discuss about this issue rationally and will not bash without looking at the context
Still the best performance they performed like a real group ! And the vocal, dance were in point ❤
LOL I want a studio version of this, I really like the harmonies and Let it die is just such a good songgggg
Grace Li yeah me too, i want full version of this song.. it's too good ^{^
IsaacIN2U_ Violet The original is by Yoga Lin, but I like this version more, the harmonies really get me 🙈 I love Yoga Lin, but because he's a soloist, the song lacks the beautiful harmonies this one has 🙈
Latest update on banana boys in nine percent...you zhangjing already successfully made his solo debut in June with his first ost song ao Hong chen which ranked first in China billboard chart for the month of July..he also voted as the best new artist in China region for the whole month if August on weibo and he successfully upgraded his category into Asia Pacific region which he topped the chart on the first 2 weeks of September....now he is busy preparing for nine percent upcoming album and also his solo activity.,..who would have thought that a low profile contestant like him would made so big eventhough he is from Malaysia a foreigner...
他们真的是太齐了！！团魂炸裂！
尤长靖 我爱你❤️
The question about the choreography could have been edited out, but to make the show a more authentic reality show it is best not to. Lin Chaotze may have thought the question is about the choreography on the first part. The performance on the second part is to showcase their dancing skill (as performers are also asked to) and in their case they showcase it as a group whereas Bei Honglin also showcase his rapping skill individually. They are not trying to deceive anyone intentionally as everyone say anyone with a trained eye (Lay, Jackson and the dance mentors) will be able to recognize the Hit The Stage choreography, and people who asked them to be kicked out of the show just so that their favorites will have a better chance of getting in are being ridiculous. I think Lay understood that the leader just gave an erroneous reply cos of the occasion (some have stage fright and other giving an erroneous reply and forgetting to give credit to whoever) Anyway just appreciate what was a good performance.
thats the thing the beginning also had parts copied just not as obvious
but they did great can tell they practices hard
Even seasoned performers will need feedback from a team of choreographer. Just treat it as a dance medley or performance medley like people singing in song medleys...Will people mention that the song is a medley of which singers if the medley of songs are so obvious.
You're so right. I really enjoy the stage, well put together, both the singing and the dancing. Not sure what's the big fuss about.
It is a medley of singing and dancing performance just as in in medley of songs. He had no intent of deceiving and gave an erroneous answer probably surprised by such a question. They are just idol contestant and not expert dance choreographer.
And I mean why would they "oh so obviously" copy Yugyeom's dance if Jackson who watched the actual performance himself would be there???? Even if they did copy the dance, the dance was still hard making them put their efforts into learning the dance
i love it how everyone pointed out the fact that they copied the dance and this wasn't creativ at all *but ignores how talented their are by singing and dancing even thought it was copied* _--_
kkaep horat and not all the dancing was copied, just a part. They are still very good, but they should've given Yugeom the credits for the choreo
LadyLisa01 _. I am not sure if they did or not but still it meant to be a good choreo and not a creative one. I was just mad cause I didn't understood why people wished that they would get eliminated soon. This made me pissed off
kkaep horat yes, I understand what you are saying. Just because they copied someone doesn't mean they are bad, especially not to the point of having to be eliminated. And I'm sure if the program speaks up about this, the guy will apologise. I'm not saying he did something good but it's not bad enough to the point of heving to be excluded from the program
LadyLisa01 _. Thank you 🔥😊
the problem is that when yixing ask them if it was their own choreo ,they sais yes
You zhang jing i never forget this ❤ u perfomance well!
You Zhang jing!!! Please vote for him! International fans can vote too! :)
This is one of the performance at idol producer that gives me goosebumpss
Our main vocal You zhanjing so powerful 😍❤️❤️❤️
I'm still confused as to why their company didn't debut them. So talented and they go so well together!
Outstanding performance really! Dancing to singing, and that Harmony! it’s just WOW! 😃
You Zhang Jing!! Proud of Malaysia 😍😍😍
they really did a great job. Missing those day with their performances
This is a very beautiful song!
The vocals are good, the harmonization is wonderful, Zhangjing hit the high notes too! Great job Banana Culture Ent. for giving a great performance for the song and dance too! For me, they have the best performance as a group!
for me I believe that Zhangjing should have gotten an A score for this audition piece, & other members should have higher scores. Anyway, he got in the final top 9 of Idol Producer so all is good.
One of the best idols program performance just amazing and amazing and amazing ❤️
amazing high notes you zhangjing~!!
尤长靖加油!❤永远pick你
我只认识5个😂
林彦俊
尤长靖
林超泽
陆定昊
贝泓磷
K J 最後面翻跟斗的認識一下~ 姜京佐！！👍 他是淘汰成員裡面覺得最可惜的了~
邱治諧，李若天。高茂桐，姜京佐
momo 我也蠻喜歡他的，因為前面人太多鏡頭太少有點可惜..
K J 我也是只認識5個
9個我都很喜歡
i think it's possible that the leader was only referring to the choreography of the singing part and not the dance part... i know they did not give credit to yugyeom and others (or maybe the show did not show it), but i still want to appreciate how beautiful their singing is and how good they are as a team!
I believe he said Majority was choreographed by him and the other trainees give him ideas and stuff so he didn’t say the entire dance was choreographed by him
Majority by him, and opinions from other members. Bus didn’t say ANYTHING about “borrowing/inspired” by other artists. Hmmm...omission is a form of lying. There is no way around that fact.
A lost ELF - everlastingfriend , the BC trainee (Lin Chaoze) could have said: “the dance was inspired by other artists.” without using any words like “South Korea”. The political issue can’t be an excuse for taking credit for other artists’ work.
Maybe he just didn’t think of saying that or he did mention it but the editors cut it? It’s kinda sad for him though because he probably doesn’t know about this and can’t clarify himself.
I SWEAR THIS WAS THE BEST AUDITION PIECE IN THE WHOLE SHOW!
Their vocals...wow....those high notes. I. Wow. I just. Oh goodness that was beautiful
Watching idol producer s3 now makes me realised how little of screen time jiang jing zuo gets..... he was outstanding in this performance and had quite alot of centre parts yet he’s graded C
This performance was really SUPERIOR and in another level
In love with zhangjing's voice..
My favorite performance ❤️
stop hating on them, they are so talented.
A OH compared to u maybe? Choreographing and harmonizing isn't as easy as u think. Try choreographing for urself first and see how well u do. But do remember that he has to choreograph for 9 PEOPLE and even think of their positions and formations and how to make them stand out during their part.
A OH Do you decide they are talented or not by comparing them to someone who already debuted like 3-4 years ago? lmao you are talking nonsense
A OH lol, I'm not from China. There is a reason why I speak decent English. You are the one being racist here. U claim that Chinese people are close minded, however u are so adamant about ur view and refuse to think of the other perspectives and also from the leader's shoes. And since you obviously don't understand chinese, let me tell you what he had atually said.He said that he choreographed MOST of the dance and not ALL of it and he said that he did it WITH the help of his members. Most choreographies have dance moves that are commonly in many choreographies.Did you know the starting move of got7 hard carry where they shrug their shoulders is what shinee does for their song replay? So are you going to say that got7 plagiarized Shinee? I absolutely love kpop, but if u look closely, the choreography isn't exactly the same. There were actually parts where they had edited the it. Check this out : ruclips.net/video/z-er_rVDlUk/видео.html
A OH and if u are so unhappy the show, stop watching it then. No one is forcing u to watch, so stop hating on them unless u can do better than them in terms of singing, rap and dance. Oh and make sure u are able to choreograph and compose songs as well as write lyrics speak multiple languages.
A OH lol, it isn't cause there are more to think about on where the need to stand how they should move to make the formation look better. He also has to decide how to make each part of the dance make a specific person stand out. And no it is NOT easier to choreograph for 9 ppl than it is for 3 ppl. I've created choreographies and I do dance as well as music. If u think that it is that easy to choreograph, why not choreograph for 9 people and get 8ppl to dance with u and post it online,n
其实我觉得姜京佐有A的实力啊 可惜了
I just love the harmonizing parts as well als the amazing high notes
Lovely performance, I was honestly amazed. And I'm so done with certain comments about plagiarism here. They never said that they made the ENTIRE thing by themselves and also, certain dance moves did not even originate from the kpop idols some of the people are mentioning here.
It's September 2018 and I came back for this! This performance would always have a special place in my heart! The best audition piece by a group at Idol Producer!
I miss Banana Culture!! I really love their vocals and harmonization of Yanjun and Dinghao :3 ofc Zhangjing vocals! uwu. I super love Trainee18💗
well this is was 'chinese survival show', and they would don't want to involve from outsider especially between China-Korea nowadays you know, they have a bit problem.maybe because of that Lin Chaoze (leader) banana culture, doesn't want to say it maybe, who know.also we don't know about their story so please stop ignoring or compared about anything since they are truly talent considering this was 'survival show' .^^
IsaacIN2U_ Violet i'll flood this one hahaha
Up
Up
Up
lol
As a group that has not debut at the time, their performance was very well thought of and shows much maturity.
STOP BASHING THEM. This was one of the best performance for evaluation. They might have taken the dance of the got7 member but that doesn't mean there is no originality in their performance. And when that A trainee had said that he had made most of the choreography he had also mentioned that he got ideas from others too. He might have meant the vocal part's choreography but who knows. You all are going around writing huge ass paragraphs on how they didn't give credit but then just stand in their position and let's see if you remember what to speak. These boys did so much hardwork yet there are only a few who appreciate it. Great.
可盐的林彦俊和可甜的尤长靖了解一下
很成熟的一个团队！真的很棒！让人印象很深刻❤️
Lin yanjun. You Zhangjing. Lu Dinghao.Lin Chaoze ❤️
Indeed fantastic and excellent.
VOTE FOR YOU ZHANGJING, HE NEEDS TO DEBUT! HE IS THE MAIN VOCAL WE NEED.
This is the best performance out of all. The first performance is just so touching
This is the best perfomance in ep 2 Idol producer
I cant control myself but to rewatch this over and over againnnn
2020...i m still watching tis😢...ip the best👍🏻👍🏻😍💘
back here after 3 years, time has gone by so quickly. From this performance You Zhangjing became one of my picks and i remember crying when he got in :') i have watched most of the shows from both iqiyi and tencent, but this one just hits different.
I love this performance so much ❤. The vocals were beautifuk and the dance was amazing 💕. They could actually debut as a group. And im also very happy that Yanjun and Zhangjing got in the final Top 9 ❤!
Omggggg They are so good 😭😭 OMG dancing and singing... And the high notes boy, Omggggg I can't
Second best performance in idol producer (group) they are amazing I'm in love
Yan Jun😍😍😍😍 Evan Lin🥰
For ppl who keep gg on about them copying kpop idols:
the moves which u claimed are from wanna one which is most likely the stomping part is a very comman dance move and plus moves like looking upwards are common. there are many choreographies where the idol looks upwards, so do u want to say seventeen copied some other boy band? and plus the floor move which i am sure are referring to exo's is not something that is rare. there are many choreographies that include them dancing on the floor and such. and the leader said he choreographed MOST of it and not ALL of it. Yes he could have said that part was from Yugyeom performance, but that itself would stir up politcal issues as well. And he did say his members helped him. So what if it was his members' suggestion? As a leader, he has a greater responsibility compared to the rest. In addition, has it ever occur to you that he may have not know that yugyeom's choreography was done by jackson teammate?
plus if u want to claim that it is plagerism, what about moves from BTS blood sweat tears? the one where the all move against the floor? that particular move is done by Uniq in EOEO first. so are u gg to accuse BTS of plagerism? Not to drag bts down cause i stan them hardcore. Just wanted to make a point here.
And plus, dancing to choreographies are already hard enough, so what makes u think that choreographing for 9 PEOPLE is easy?Please look at their talents too cause it isnt easy to harmonise too. plus to remain stable while dancing isnt easy either. Plus if you people keep criticizing them as its making u unhappy, then just stop watching. Simple as that. No one is forcing u too watch now are they?
And plus the mentors also said that they have great harmonies which u need to put in a lot of effort and practice to do well. And if u think harmonies are that easy to do, try doing it on ur own. Since I have music background, I know that it is not easy to harmonize unless u are born with it. And plus they have multiple talented singers like you changjing who was the one that hit the high notes.
There were also some differences in choreographies. They didn't actually copy it exactly, they actually DID change some parts. Look up this link. ruclips.net/video/z-er_rVDlUk/видео.html
Lee Ann Chong Finally found someone who thinks like me. Making a choreography for a whole song with whole new steps is not possible. Just look at them they are so talented. No matter what others say I'm gonna support them.😍😍
Chimchim Moktan yes do vote for them on Iqiyi. They have talented singers and dancers
Only people living in china can vote,isn't it??
Chimchim Moktan nope I have been voting ever since the start of the program and I'm not from china, but Singapore. So i still can understand chinese
Really?? Then I will try as well. Thank you for telling me😀😀
太棒了吧！！不簡單！！
this entire performance is still godly seriously
Oh my god, the harmony at 1:02! Love Lin Yanjun
看完莫名想哭！默契十足！
just one ep left before final AAHHHH PLEASEEE VOTE YOU ZHANGJING AND LIN YANJUN THEY BOTH DESERVE TO DEBUUTT
I cant wait for their debut. Really like You Zhang Jing, Lin Yan Jun and Bei Hong Lin
You Zhang Jing😭❤️👌🏽 Vocals of a god😍
Great vocal and dance 👍👍👍👍
Still amazing in 2022~
Omg best audition ever😍😍
Best group performance during auditions. From singing to dancing, just WOW!! 😊😊😊
This is the best performance for me😻
LIN YANJUN❤❤❤❤