Making a DIY CNC machine with limited tools

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 9 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 879

  • @benmakeseverything
    @benmakeseverything  Год назад +38

    Please see my follow up video for answers to questions and more info: ruclips.net/video/nlWXileUSbU/видео.html
    If you want the 3D files and wiring diagrams, check here: github.com/BenMakesEverything/Ben_CNC_v1

    • @dieSpinnt
      @dieSpinnt Год назад +1

      Thanks for sharing your experience and showing this project, Ben!:)
      Just a sidenode: Next time you plug in a mains-line power cord, don't move on, just wait for some seconds and think about it: What would happen, if the male contacts where swapped with the female jacks .......... Right! We would all be dead by now. Now look what you have designed/done with your motor power connectors (btw. connectors are a good idea). They literally invite disaster[1]:)
      [1] Here the danger is not so much for the well-being of us humans (although it is never a good idea to have current-providing and potentially live contacts fully out in the open, flapping in the breeze), but for the well-being of the machine. Sh.. can happen in this configuration and it WILL happen! Especially in a place with metal shavings and dirt all around like a workshop. Just swap it around, so that the female part of the connector is the "power-providing"-side.
      Good machining!:)

    • @DETHTWUKTAUR
      @DETHTWUKTAUR 7 месяцев назад

      Hey Ben - good stuff. I'm also thinking of making a Router CNC table like this (>'.')^

    • @uproarink
      @uproarink 6 месяцев назад

      @@dieSpinnt I don't fully understand your comment. Can you elaborate since I'm planning a similar build.

    • @slimel-gharbi8170
      @slimel-gharbi8170 2 месяца назад

      Oh yeah !!! Good and fantastic Job ! Thanks for sharing

    • @ertugrulemre2525
      @ertugrulemre2525 2 месяца назад

      Hello, I have a Makita RP2301FC milling machine. Can I use it on a workbench like this?

  • @richardskull5279
    @richardskull5279 Год назад +239

    I am a very well experienced machinist of 25 years.
    I am impressed.
    You took on a huge project and came out successful.
    Great job!

  • @blaschii
    @blaschii Год назад +181

    My jaw dropped when you showed what your machine is capable of (although the build process itself was already hella impressive). Kudos to you and your skills!

    • @TheBinklemNetwork
      @TheBinklemNetwork Год назад +4

      seriously. I've settled on a masuter pro from fox alien with the 300 w spindle and... it is not doing the job on 1mm thick aluminum :(

    • @yobekorb
      @yobekorb 6 месяцев назад

      😊

  • @LouisKleiman
    @LouisKleiman Год назад +959

    Not an engineer!?!? You may not be formally trained, but you are absolutely an engineer. Great job!

    • @amorton94
      @amorton94 Год назад +57

      Unfortunately for him and people like him (me), that's not how that works in the real world.

    • @6022
      @6022 Год назад +55

      @@amorton94 Honestly, I've known plenty of engineering jobs where they'd take a documented design and build of something like this as adequate proof of qualification. Lots of engineering jobs are very pragmatic. If you can make something work, and as a bonus, you have an understanding of the importance of keeping costs down, that is what you really need.

    • @DespaceMan
      @DespaceMan Год назад +30

      @@6022 Engineers today are usually a person who specialized in one particular field or section of engineering, I've come across many engineers some I know personally & yes 95% of them do know everything about how a combustion engines works but to fix or build one they can't do. If you doing stuff for yourself you got no one to prof to but if you want a land a job you require a white piece of paper to prove that you jumped through hoops & passed a test.

    • @6022
      @6022 Год назад +28

      @@DespaceMan I know successful engineers who never got a degree. It depends on the company. Some places are smart enough to know that degrees aren't everything.

    • @Randorandom232
      @Randorandom232 Год назад +21

      @@DespaceMan yeah fixing and maintaining stuff is what technicians and mechanics do. Engineering is more theoretical and design.

  • @oliverer3
    @oliverer3 Год назад +97

    It wasn't until you said that this was your first project with a CAD tool I truly realized just how much of an enormous task this must have been for you, truly impressed.

  • @haveagocommentator983
    @haveagocommentator983 11 месяцев назад +10

    "Far from perfect" you say. One of the fist things you learn as a machinist is nothing is "perfect". You did a great job , much respect.

  • @DIYerGuy
    @DIYerGuy 5 месяцев назад +21

    I am an engineer (electronics) and I would not attempt such a project as you have. I have to say, though you're not an "engineer", you are in fact what an engineer is. That you have been successful is a reflection of your careful and studied approach to such a monumental project, weighing the pros and cons and tradeoffs to each decision. That is to a great deal what real engineering involves. You mention in your video that it took you almost 1 year to complete your project. I can appreciate the time involved. Complex projects do take time and usually more than we initially realize. One thing I would have asked myself considering such a project as yours is whether it would be cost-effective for me to spend the time and money and do the entire job myself vs. purchasing a pre-built CNC. There are advantages and tradeoffs to both approaches of course. With your approach you learned things that someone purchasing a CNC would likely not learn. And of course, building it yourself gives you the unique feeling of satisfaction that one does not get from purchasing a similar CNC. That you built it yourself also gives you the ability to repair and/or modify your machine in ways that one ordinarily would not be able to do. On the other hand, purchasing a CNC allows you to get to the job(s) at hand almost immediately. Those are just some of the tradeoffs with building it yourself vs purchasing. In any case, your results are quite remarkable. You might consider offering your CNC as a kit; I'm sure it will sell. Of course, putting together a kit and making it into a money-making proposition is a completely different kind of challenge. But considering your excellent approach I think you'd be equally successful. Unless I missed it, one thing you don't mention in the video is the resolution in the X, Y, and Z axis - something that would be of interest to others. Best of luck with your future projects and congratulations on a very impressive result!

    • @Doingstuff.since76
      @Doingstuff.since76 16 дней назад

      The main point I would add to your excellent review of this guys project is he really wanted to build it heavy duty and made it so. I am no engineer either although I believe that I can do, build, repair, make anything I set my mind to. It was my father's unique view as a project manager for Australia's only telecommunications in the 60's till the mid 90's. Also his relentles and high expectations of me. I am of a very high I.q. but that's only according to some rules and interpretation. My father would be in his workshop where he would rig sailing boat masts, strip down old vessels and rebuild them. Make custom rigging systems which I am certain helped him win the National titles in the class he focused on. The Corsair. I'd hang around interested but wanting to be observing not really want to solve problems he already probably knew the answer to. But it was simply teaching me how to get my mind to simply and quickly see solutions by thinking "OUTSIDE THE BOX!" That box I guess is the box that constrains most others looking at the same issues. It really was drummed into me. Think wildly outside what you may already assume the right answer is. I remember him having a mast, a blank mast, tapered aluminium about 5 metres long which is extruded and included a c section track in profile if the mast was cut across. He said that these rectangular fittings needed to go into the mast. They were little blocks with little shelves in them for the use of fine lines or stainless wire cable to go up the outside and into the mast then Back down inside. I looked at it closely and was about 7 or 8 and always wanted to get it right... these little tests. I thought about it and decided I would drill a maybe 5mm hole inside each corner then a 3mm hole in a line inside the lines denoting the cut out. He looked pleased then said ok what next. Remembering his father's rule that a tool is used for its purpose only and not used as a stupid thing to get a job done in a poor fashion. I didn't care and said I'd get an old chisel and cut through the little joining bits between holes. He said excellent. He did not think of that. Then what? I'd file the rest of the holes flat till the rectangular cut out was exactly as it should be! He was so happy. I know because he would be overheard telling hos sailing mates about such stuff. Even though he never or rarely congratulated me on little brilliant mental achievements I overheard him telling people about me and it was then I realised he did it all to sharpen my mind. My brother also has this ability and can do anything at all as well. Dad said he regretted not becoming an engineer. I do also. But I am an e ginger in ability and trained in Surgical engineering. Small engineering shop building everything from raw materials. Bending ultra thin wall 7/8 and 3/4 inch .028" wall chrome molly tube using mandrels we made and all by hand. No motorised bending. We got it perfect often.a big thing to be proud of. Milling all stuff. Punching out parts. Bending flat steel.casting aluminium parts. Brazing chrome molly frames and mild steel. Tig welding alloy and stainless for racing wheelchairs and showering chairs. I did the full apprenticeship In upholstery, but never sent to college as the boss feared any employee leaving. With proof in paper it was easy. But I care not. I was skilled in many many amazing things I use daily. I learned immense skills at my high school which I chose as every module was recognised by the state and federal competency and teaching standards. I soaked up every tiny detail of ever single lesson and despite the other boys telling me to shut the fk up... we want to leave before the bell! I still picked the teachers brains and my results reflected this. I use these skills daily also. I made some great choices early on concerning my future. Out I took a break from making these and had a long period of being a fk up.

  • @beppe_c60
    @beppe_c60 Год назад +134

    This is what I mean for a REAL Tutorial. A design, main measures, components list. A great help to understand what to do. Really good job, Ben. Not for the object only, but for the excellent way You followed to present it.

    • @mattivirta
      @mattivirta Год назад

      but need be "tutorial" better, this not tell how softwares install, lot problem if use raspberry pi or linux computer install good shit GRBL or linuxcnc software, cam soft what can use linux, limit switch has many builder problem need tell how make, what size spindle and spindle speed controller problems, only good has use aluminium frame and big 60x60 profile, expensive lot, and ballscrews super expensive use, windows OS not must use because not have safety realtime OS, need use linuxcnc OS because have lot better and true realtime controll, and this safety lot more. cad program need if want build good frame all dimension come right before cutting parts. and drill holes right,accurate. need know all roeque powers how and were need frame strong etc,beam need lot more strong support not twist.z-rail need be supported rails not only worst rod, lot torque power go to z axis and not accurate and weak lot if not strong. this some little point for my vkill i has build hobby users and small factory many 100 cnc and know what need know.

  • @JPToto
    @JPToto Год назад +125

    Sir, this is EXCEPTIONALLY well done. Definitely the best and most practical DIY CNC build I've seen on RUclips. Just the right amount of detail too. 👏🏻

  • @shingabiss
    @shingabiss Год назад +15

    My compliments to your ingenuity and resourcefulness! I first built a pcb mini milling machine in 1995, pre maker explosion, wrote code in VB4 and wrote step bit patterns directly though FETS to motors via the pc parallel port. I know the task is multi faceted and can appreciate your efforts. Proffessional results!

  • @szymonszewcjr
    @szymonszewcjr Год назад +113

    Algorithm has spoken! Hello from Poland! 😃

    • @PiefacePete46
      @PiefacePete46 Год назад +5

      Algorithm is alive and well... Hello from New Zealand! 👍

    • @kevinldaniel
      @kevinldaniel Год назад +3

      Same lol

    • @robertkaminski1781
      @robertkaminski1781 Год назад +1

      Me to

    • @Артём-м4д4б
      @Артём-м4д4б Год назад

      Hello from 🇷🇺 Russia. F❤🎉ing poland

    • @robertkaminski1781
      @robertkaminski1781 Год назад

      @@Артём-м4д4б Russia should be cut off from internet. You have mental like KRLD. Brains washed from hundred years....

  • @tomsdreamshopworx
    @tomsdreamshopworx Год назад +62

    Just going down the rabbit hole of RUclips videos on building your own CNC. Nice job on your build!

    • @PiefacePete46
      @PiefacePete46 Год назад +4

      @
      @TomsDreamshop Worx : Ahhh, the wonders of "The University of RUclips"! How quickly we (Oldies!) have forgotten the hours spent wading through the shelves at our libraries, or eagerly waiting for next month's edition of our favourite magazine!
      Have fun!

    • @Bu5H84
      @Bu5H84 Год назад +1

      Hahahaha i too have been down this Rabbit hole, i miss my CNC machine

    • @Ding_Bat
      @Ding_Bat Год назад +2

      A word of advice: Get going on 3D design while doing your research (if you don’t have it nailed down already). This will go a long way is helping you design your CNC.
      If you cannot design, you cannot CNC. Garbage in = garbage out. 😉😉
      Good luck!!

    • @winulff7082
      @winulff7082 Год назад +2

      Have you hit the goldmine of New Yorkshire Workshop and his homemade 4x8 cnc? 5 hours worth of pure building videos. Super high precision.
      Sadly he doesnt speak a word, but its a nice look at what goes into building large scale cnc, and the steps (and mistakes) taken to achieve precision.
      highly recommend watching.

    • @Mr.Thermistor7228
      @Mr.Thermistor7228 Год назад +1

      ​@@PiefacePete46cant even imagine that. Us young generation take for granted all the information available to us in a split second. If everything I've learned online had to be re-learned through books and physical paper, I would probably be at like 2% total of everything I've learned with a computer

  • @willbe7442
    @willbe7442 Год назад +22

    I’ve never seen you channel before but this came up recommended. I already own an open builds workbee v3 kit. And to be honest, even though I have spent over $3000 and many, many man hours setting it up, I think yours is way better! Absolutely brilliant. Well done and congrats

  • @PlayNowWorkLater
    @PlayNowWorkLater Год назад +44

    Great project! Amazed you could put that together for around $1000. Can’t wait to see what you will build next. Make sure you show us your tool collection as it grows. I imagine you’ll have a shop with all kinds of stuff in there in no time. Good luck!

  • @RandomAudioGuys
    @RandomAudioGuys Год назад +8

    I watched your entire video and I am impressed, I started with a Buildyourcnc 4x8 kit, and is amazing how much you learn by putting one together and the ups and downs, I then purchased a Laguna IQ for our shop, 2x3 ft. And later a Industrial Artisan 408 to replace the Buildyourcnc ( Way over priced but they do work). And I was imaginging this taking you awhile to do and when you said 1 year, I was like, yes this stuff goes through so much that people will never understand in a 14 minute video.
    With all that said you did a very impressive video and kept it to the point, clean cut and full of the right knowledge that matters to someone wanting to build one. And remember this, you have to build the machine so it can build the machines, now you can mill all your parts on it and fine tune it, But you did an amazing job and I am very proud to become a new subscriber to your channel. I hope you find your place on the RUclips platform because you deserve it, pulling off a video that good so early on.
    PS, lasers are fun too :) Started with a cheap 400.00 Ebay laser and now have a Laguna EX-C 36x50. You should give one a try, they are far more amazing than a CNC when you learn how to use it to your advantage where a CNC cannot do tight corners.

    • @benmakeseverything
      @benmakeseverything  Год назад +1

      Thanks! Glad you enjoyed the video. I've actually been thinking of either adding a laser attachment, or just building a separate laser cutter as well.

    • @alwayscensored6871
      @alwayscensored6871 Год назад +2

      @@benmakeseverything Guys have been cutting 19mm ply with a 20W laser diode. Not fast but it does work with air assist.

    • @amorton94
      @amorton94 Год назад

      @Random Audio Guy Your laser is a CNC machine. A pet peeve of mine is when people only call routers/mills a CNC machine. Semantics really, I know, but still. A 3d printer is a CNC machine. Your laser is a CNC machine. The router/gantry mill in this video is a CNC machine. CNC simply refers to how the machine is controlled, by numbers/code sent to it by a computer.

  • @tomreijtenbach7154
    @tomreijtenbach7154 Год назад +14

    Great build, best practical tutorial I have seen so far! I like that you condensed everything in a 15 minute video while still remaining clear. One tip I have from building my CNC is that those loose wires going into your arduino might cause you problems in the future. I would suggest making a shield with screw terminals to effectively lock the wires in. If a step or direction wire vibrates loose during machining, one or more axis can fail, resulting in a crash.

    • @benmakeseverything
      @benmakeseverything  Год назад +1

      Good idea. I should probably do that, but I also might switch it do something other than an arduino as the controller at some point.

  • @jonaswinkelmann8203
    @jonaswinkelmann8203 Год назад +13

    Unbelievable that such a small youtuber makes so high quality videos. Keep going such a great vid!

  • @Elymyntal
    @Elymyntal Год назад +15

    Nice! You've given me the practical, not ridiculously expensive inspiration I've been looking for all week. Much appreciated.

  • @jackryan4313
    @jackryan4313 Год назад +9

    My friend, you now have a product. Don't keep this to yourself. You genuinely have an opportunity to give yourself the chance to never have to worry financially, as well as your kids
    You did amazing. I showed my dad, who is also a CNC machinist, and he too was both impressed and jealous. I'm truly amazed. Congrats

  • @jmotti23
    @jmotti23 10 месяцев назад +2

    I was not prepared for the product showcase 😳 this is bloody inspiring!

  • @FredrikSvensson1979
    @FredrikSvensson1979 Год назад +1

    "How hard can it be?" Having this mentality and being stubborn has helped me a lot in life. Pretty quickly, or at the latest half way through what ever it is I thought I could do, my naivity usually dawns on me, but then the stubborness kicks in and I see it through any way. I've learnt so much this way, and I am really thankful for my slightly stupid but positive naivity. The only real way you can fail at things is by never trying at all.

  • @treyvnl
    @treyvnl Год назад +9

    I’m currently going through my own CNC build and this gives me good inspiration and some ideas to implement on mine. Thanks for documenting the process so well.

    • @benmakeseverything
      @benmakeseverything  Год назад +2

      Glad to hear the video helped. Best of luck with your build!

    • @lUnderdogl
      @lUnderdogl Год назад

      Use linear guide ways, not linear bearings. It will be stiffer.

    • @benmakeseverything
      @benmakeseverything  Год назад +2

      @@lUnderdogl I agree with this, If I built another machine I'd use those.

    • @lUnderdogl
      @lUnderdogl Год назад

      @@benmakeseverything If you need any help you can write

  • @olasod1
    @olasod1 11 месяцев назад

    I know many engineers that cant do 20% of what you do. The difference between them and you, is that you are a born engineer and they just have an education. Good job👍🏼🙏

  • @mikeeddy1099
    @mikeeddy1099 Год назад +1

    Mate like wow. I really don't think I've ever seen someone do what you have done here. I work in fabrication and we use industrial branded machinery and I kid you not, I haven't met someone who can produce a detailed and accurate product on a million dollar machine than what you have produced here. Also, your knowledge on CNC programming and CAD drawing is up there. I commend you sir.

  • @FerociousPancake888
    @FerociousPancake888 Год назад +15

    Yes! Someone has actually used DIY in their title and actually did a DIY project without tools that cost six figures! This is awesome. I’d love to build one. Maybe sometime in the future you could attempt building a 4th axis mod!

    • @benmakeseverything
      @benmakeseverything  Год назад +5

      Thanks! I have been thinking about adding a 4th axis attachment.

    • @mil3k
      @mil3k Год назад

      This machine already has 4th axis. It is C axis, rotation around Z. It is done by interpolation in XY plane. You can see it in a segment where the hole grid is made. That helical/tornado milling is exactly that.
      5th axis is A or B, rotations around X and Y. In that case it can be done as indexing or continues rotation. First one allow to set the material on demanded angle and carry on an operation as usual. Second allows to simultaneous rotation in A or B and milling in XYZC.

  • @Ding_Bat
    @Ding_Bat Год назад +3

    Really great job!
    I followed a similar route, but I built a WAY smaller prototype (roughly 400 x 500 x 150mm) out of MDF first. Kind of a proof of concept designed in SketchUp. All the electronics for a larger machine were installed, though. It worked fantastically well - so much so that I used it as is for more than a year!
    During that time, I designed V2 of my CNC using Fusion 360. This one built out of aluminium extrusions and 16mm aluminium. The biggest change was to use 2 motors on the Y-Axis due to the size of the new machine.
    A lot of lessons were learnt from building the first machine, so all of those were incorporated into the new one. The new one was 1500mm x 1000mm x 450mm. The best part was that I used my MDF CNC to cut the parts for the new CNC. It was slow, but it worked, and it was accurate enough to enable me to assemble the new machine in less than a day!
    The only tools I used in constructing V1 were a jigsaw, handheld drill, screwdrivers, Allen keys, taps and glue. With V2 it was pretty much taps and Allen keys.
    I recently upgraded to a 1500W liquid cooled spindle, which made a MASSIVE difference.
    I have my eyes set on building me a similarly sized 100W laser CNC over the next couple of years…
    Happy CNC-ing!!

    • @benmakeseverything
      @benmakeseverything  Год назад

      Thanks! Sounds like you put a lot of thought into your designs. I like the idea of using the first machine to make parts for the next one!

  • @steveg2021
    @steveg2021 Год назад

    legitimately channels like this have inspired some of my favorite projects and i can't express my gratitude more.

  • @trisys2000
    @trisys2000 Год назад +13

    I went through the video for a 2nd time and I tried to make a parts list as well as shop for the parts online, and I think I was able to find everything for about $1500. You may be able to save some if you shop around more, but as of today, I would expect to spend about that much to make it. Great video and great design.

    • @CP-fz4sr
      @CP-fz4sr Год назад

      PLEASE. Can you put a parts list? Or even better, where u got them from?
      I got some of the parts, as I do wood working, but I never built a CNC, and I been wanting to do one for years.
      I would appreciate the info. Thanks.

    • @Mr.Thermistor7228
      @Mr.Thermistor7228 Год назад

      ​@@CP-fz4srive seen other commenters saying that parts are listed in the description, might be a good place to check

    • @dcurry7287
      @dcurry7287 Год назад

      @@CP-fz4sr At the $1500 price mark, you're pretty close to a PrintNC, and if you have the ability to make one of those, you'll have much more of a community to help you make it.

  • @SuperSadom
    @SuperSadom Год назад +89

    I just finished building the handrail on my deck ruclips.net/user/postUgkxfQ5_mgwq6PcudJvAH25t-I4D-3cTPz4z and used this great little router to clean up the top rail before the final sanding and stain. It was light weight but packed lots of power. Either size battery didn't seem to make it top heavy and I'm a 64 yr old women so I really appreciated how easy it was to use...................... CORDLESS only way to go !!

  • @q011519
    @q011519 Год назад +15

    This is amazing, I would love a cost break down and maybe a build guide. I know I'm asking a lot but I would love to build one on my own.

    • @joshuamahon260
      @joshuamahon260 Год назад +4

      If you look in the description, he did put the products he used. I would think he didn't put the price as the prices may fluctuate.
      I haven't done the math myself, but another commenter stated around $1000, which for what it is, which is a really good price point all things considered. Many comparable CNCs would be at least double that.
      If you're just wanting to get a cheap/inexpensive machine, I would say this isn't the project for you.

  • @Adanos_ger
    @Adanos_ger Год назад +1

    As others have already stated .. this randomly came up in my recommended videos.
    Great effort there, really like what you've created and the decisions you made.

  • @SalaziNazz
    @SalaziNazz 6 месяцев назад

    Wow, your DIY CNC machine build is seriously impressive! 🙌 Great job on tackling such a big project with limited tools!

  • @eddymack8568
    @eddymack8568 Год назад +2

    You are absolutely an engineer. Great job. What you made is incredible

  • @imanutnur7
    @imanutnur7 Год назад

    I was a field service engineer for Mazak several years ago and when I retired I made a CNC in my shop. It worked great. I had two separate versions, one had the axles running on precision rods and later I used aluminum 90-degree rods with bearings running on them which was very accurate. I get bored easily and since played with a lathe and lately do intarsia.

  • @到青蛙
    @到青蛙 Год назад +4

    Just about to embark on the same journey so your project was a must see and an inspiration. I love the way you housed the electronics, I'm stealing that idea.

    • @benmakeseverything
      @benmakeseverything  Год назад

      Glad to hear you found it helpful. Best of luck on your project!

  • @QAYWSXEDCCXYDSAEWQ
    @QAYWSXEDCCXYDSAEWQ 9 месяцев назад

    I love the wiring thing too! I beginning to think this machine is better than you would get commercially.

  • @johnprosser2142
    @johnprosser2142 11 дней назад

    I can’t believe how well you have done with that!

  • @hotchow8766
    @hotchow8766 Год назад

    I subscribed after I saw your finished projects. People can talk a good game but the proof is in the production. You did well, better than I thought it would turn out.

  • @michaelrechtin
    @michaelrechtin Год назад +3

    This is really well done! Looking forward to future projects!

  • @suntzu6122
    @suntzu6122 Год назад +1

    Nice. I love finding new channels like this!

  • @jkdm27
    @jkdm27 2 месяца назад

    You are incredibly talented !!! I can't believe you're not an engineer. I am an engineer, and I would not be able to combine and manufacture all the parts as you did. You really should be an electrical/mechanical engineer (mechatronics). You're young and can obviously learn and research things very quickly.

  • @vincentrodak9734
    @vincentrodak9734 Год назад +14

    "I'm not an engineer" (after engineering and fabricating a very capable and functional CNC router) ;) Great video by the way.

  • @carl7162
    @carl7162 Год назад +1

    Dude your a pretty sick artist way beyond your mechanical skills. A true craftsman. Nice work and beautiful art.

  • @jakubpetr4830
    @jakubpetr4830 Год назад +4

    Hi Ben, well done! Since I made few of DIY CNC machines, I would recomend 2 crews, one at each side for the Y axis. Because of twist under the higher load for one screw in the middle. (I had the same design at my first router and changed it to this configuration.) Also the USB connection could have issues, I end up using ESS (Ethernet Smooth Stepper with Mach 4 software) using ethernet cabel, that has more rigid comunication protocol, but there are other options like MASSO or PoKeys57. Offcourse these upgrades are for higher budget project. Last recomendation are hybrid servo stepper motors(idealy with error output to stop the machine). Wish you all the best! Have FUN with your machine.

    • @benmakeseverything
      @benmakeseverything  Год назад +1

      Good suggestions, I agree that 2 screws is a superior configuration. I was just trying to save money on the build using 1. If I built another machine I'd use 2, and also look into the servo motors as well.

    • @pepaw
      @pepaw Год назад

      How much of a difference do the servo motors make vs a stepper? I would thing magnitudes accuracy difference? Worth the money?

    • @doulos5322
      @doulos5322 10 месяцев назад

      ​​​@@pepawservers make zero difference in accuracy. In a closed loop system once You've actually missed a step. You've already ruined your work piece anyway. Most systems at least in hybrid closed loop systems. Once you have missed steps, it just sends an alarm to trigger to stop the motors

  • @josegarciacas
    @josegarciacas Год назад

    Hey man!! Great job!! Another engeneer here, just add pressure air supply and also an extractor, both in line. That will helps with the temperature and also will leave everything cleaner.
    Thank you for your job!

  • @olenfersoi8887
    @olenfersoi8887 7 месяцев назад

    Like others here, I am totally impressed by how good the projects are that you made...and the machine that made them!

  • @Astral_Knowledge
    @Astral_Knowledge Год назад +1

    Love the cnc! The only thing I would suggest is swapping to polycarb on your enclosure so if anything gets flung at it it won't shatter.

  • @grathado28
    @grathado28 Год назад

    Engineers are only really useful for making them cheap and not over engineering, The information's on the internet only self-doubt stops you from achieving what you want Good job sir very cool

  • @kylepayton1036
    @kylepayton1036 Год назад +5

    Such a great video. From the build to your explanations to your projects to editing it was all very well done. On the way to build my own now

  • @UrosRodic-qd8ve
    @UrosRodic-qd8ve Год назад +1

    That surely wasn't cheap as people would imagine it to be... Nice build... coming from an engineer-constructor, props for your first time... welcome to the club!

  • @alwayscensored6871
    @alwayscensored6871 Год назад +1

    Shielded motor cables, nice tip. Especially useful on bigger machines.

    • @Z3n1tHL0rD
      @Z3n1tHL0rD Год назад

      Indeed i will buy some of that for mine

  • @MikeMcAuliffe-g2f
    @MikeMcAuliffe-g2f 9 месяцев назад

    Thanks. Appreciate that you reported that it took a year. That is helpful.

  • @Sly_Wolf_1
    @Sly_Wolf_1 Год назад

    I'm just speechless 😶...... And totally envious!
    Magnificent machine and carvings.

  • @joemilich
    @joemilich Год назад

    Holy shit. You are dedicated, my dude. It turned out looking fantastic. And your projects look awesome.

  • @janiwirman
    @janiwirman 5 месяцев назад

    Hey! I just made a very similar CNC at home myself, although a bit smaller than yours and added a tiny 4th axis.
    You make it look easy my friend! ...I wish I'd seen your video before I started my project because you got some pretty cool ideas there.
    Kudos!
    A fellow "not an engineer"

  • @rccanuck4473
    @rccanuck4473 Год назад

    OMG that's art I made one out of plywood and threaded rod . You've inspired me to do it right. Great Job

  • @TwoToolDesign
    @TwoToolDesign Год назад +1

    I cant tell you how many iterations I went through I had a reliably built CNC.. Yours looks and works great on your first try!

  • @joefog964
    @joefog964 Год назад +2

    Very well done. In case you ever have to tap tons of holes in metal in the future, opt for threaded inserts/helicoils. That way if you ever damage threads you can reuse the hole and not have to retread a hole.

  • @carloshenriquecoutinho1199
    @carloshenriquecoutinho1199 Год назад +1

    Awesome, great results. One day I'll do mine too. Waiting for more videos!!
    Congratulations Ben.

  • @davidspisak1837
    @davidspisak1837 Год назад +1

    Great job Sir! You definitely have an Engineering mind. Don't ever let anything stop your imagination from spinning! I have close to 10 years of Machine Tool Wiring and finally getting the opportunity to get into programming. Started with a $20 screwdriver set and nothing else. Don't let a piece of paper hold you back!

  • @dh1569
    @dh1569 Месяц назад

    "...far from perfect"? I'd call that pretty much perfect. Outstanding video.

  • @roberthardy2013
    @roberthardy2013 Год назад

    As an engineer I am truly impressed AND it’s in Metric not freedom units!

  • @iankathurimakinyua1145
    @iankathurimakinyua1145 Год назад

    The algorithm has led me to you and i accept the challenge in a year I'll take your lead and work on this thank you

  • @isaacsmothers820
    @isaacsmothers820 Год назад +1

    I was mesmerized by your work!! Very impressive. You were extremely descriptive and informative. Thank you for sharing your wonderful build with us 😊

  • @wayne6318
    @wayne6318 Год назад +2

    WOW, you are one very clever man, to take on something so complex and achieve something so good. My hat goes off to you, and you've inspired me to see if I can achieve something similar. Hope to see more great videos from you in the future.

  • @rhebostatfibulator6124
    @rhebostatfibulator6124 Год назад +2

    Good Job, look forward to more from your channel. I went down the same rabbit hole over the last couple years and it's amazing how similar our results are. I went with large spindle/vfd and ESS to Gecko drives. Also had several large pcs of 1" T6 and access to lathe & mill but overall design turned out very similar. Keep em coming.

  • @bogopouk8551
    @bogopouk8551 Год назад

    Algorithm works.
    Thank u 4 sharing ur story.💜
    That's was one of my dreams to build things on my own.
    Cant afford a single linear rail!
    So keep watching those videos n dreaming😯!

  • @jules9923
    @jules9923 Год назад

    i am doing a similar project of my own. although, quite a bit smaller. more of a desktop cnc router. I'm a bit short on budget atm so project is on hold but i have most of the big hardwares. next purchase should be electronics. mine is belt driven. this vid gave me more motivation to finish it especially when i heard you say it took you a yr. thanks

  • @dawnmarie6480
    @dawnmarie6480 9 месяцев назад

    Omg I'm so glad I found your video bc I've been going on about the different tools and various uses of the same basic framework designs

  • @ebernabeo
    @ebernabeo Год назад

    Further proof that hard work and determination, make a successful outcome! Great job!

  • @Gaming_Biker
    @Gaming_Biker Год назад

    Didn't notice it in the video, but you could add a window opening or some perforation w/ a foam filter on one side of the enclosure, then put an opening for a vacuum/exhaust system on another panel - preferably opposite of the "intake" filter side. It would increase the noise by opening the box a little & adding the vacuum, but you would gain a more self-cleaning system & would keep your work material & tools cooler to boot. Currently going thru a Machinist Technician course & that's pretty much what metal CNC Mills or Lathes do w/ liquid coolant. Coolant keeps everything cool & washes chips out of the enclosure & is run thru a filter & recycled back into the machine.

    • @benmakeseverything
      @benmakeseverything  Год назад +1

      You are correct, I don't have a chip/dust evacuation system and that would be a good addition. I plan to re-do the enclosure and add one in the future. Thanks for watching!

  • @spacecraftbuildingservices
    @spacecraftbuildingservices Год назад

    Wow. You clearly are an engineer at heart! Great video. Very helpful and inspiring. Thanks

  • @paulroberts7315
    @paulroberts7315 9 месяцев назад

    As I am sure it has been mentioned a copious amount of times, that ,Ben, was absolutely brilliant, A huge Tick V.G. from me. To be quite honest I would love a parts list and construction manual

  • @Jptoutant
    @Jptoutant Год назад

    Very interesting build, i like the surface with the inserts and the way you did breakouts for the motors

  • @caretchara
    @caretchara 11 месяцев назад

    You are an engineer. You don't blink at all!

  • @Crus0e
    @Crus0e Год назад

    god damn brother you did everything without any experience in this field? and you "only" have 2.6k subs? that is crazy you are really amazing and underrated

  • @trados68
    @trados68 Год назад

    Bloody awesome video and commentary. Just like you, I have always wanted a CNC machine, however, I did not want to go with a China cheapie. You have inspired me now to build my own CNC router, and this video will make all the difference. Thank you so much! 😀

  • @BEdmonson85
    @BEdmonson85 Год назад

    You're doing something right, YT just recommended this video to me. Nice work.

  • @ArthLud
    @ArthLud 10 месяцев назад

    Oh man, you did a great job. I would like to make one too but I am not so skilled and what I need is an easy step-by-step guide.

  • @happygilmore2100
    @happygilmore2100 Год назад

    You did an amazing job, when there is a will, there is a way.

  • @adriansvideochannel
    @adriansvideochannel Год назад +1

    Great job, Ben! A lot of machine/dollar here :)
    I have had a project like this going for the last few years aswell and the surface finish I see on your aluminium parts tells me there might be some play in your Z-axis. Nothing critical of course, but you might want to check the tightness of the retaining nut at the fixed end of your Z ballscrew. Or it might be some play in the router itself of course.
    Again, great job on the project! First time I see someone using an old computer case for electronics housing. Great idea!
    Cheers

    • @benmakeseverything
      @benmakeseverything  Год назад

      Thanks! The Z-axis unit has unsupported rails so it might be the cause. I thought they would be OK because they were so short, but maybe not. Definitely something I would change in a future design.

  • @guipuinam370
    @guipuinam370 Год назад

    I do love the fantasy-themed end-products you created! thanks for sharing your year of work! XD

  • @JuanManuel123ify
    @JuanManuel123ify Год назад +2

    Impresionante compañero.....Toda una obra de arte.....Mil gracias por su aportación a la comunidad.....Ya me he dado de alta de inmediato en su canal......A la espera de que siga subiendo más contenido tan interesante.....Un gran abrazo desde Las Islas Canarias (España).............Bendiciones.................

  • @noahagnew6517
    @noahagnew6517 Год назад +1

    DVD control box is clever and clean looking.

  • @DM-me3gb
    @DM-me3gb Год назад

    Very good job you did there! Not only the video is top tier, but also youre CNC is looking good and works just fine.

  • @Martin-uj6zn
    @Martin-uj6zn Год назад

    Alright man, this is my next project. Thank your for making such an easy-to-follow guide!

  • @HunterNX_s
    @HunterNX_s Год назад

    Simple and rigid design, very cool. One point you should take care is to protect any exposed connections, such as the stepper wire connection block, from aluminum chips that could cause a short.

  • @jakemeyer8188
    @jakemeyer8188 Год назад

    Since a CNC machine is one of the only machines that is essentially capable of building itself, you should use this CNC machine to build an even better CNC machine, and then use THAT one to build an even BETTER better one until...viola! You have the best CNC machine EVAR.

  • @QuadMcFlyFlies
    @QuadMcFlyFlies Год назад

    I was interested in getting a CNC a few years ago, but I ended up going with an inexpensive Chinese 6040 that is very similar to what you ended up with here. All aluminum extrusion and plate construction, rails and 16mm acme lead screws. It's served me really well over the last few years.
    One thing I would recommend is looking into CNCjs as an alternative to gcodesender. It's a pretty slick package with some really nice features. It can actually run on a raspbery pi and be accessed over a network to control, monitor and upload gcode. It even supports a webcam so it can be remotely monitored, which is pretty awesome. I've been using it for a couple of years and I'm very happy with it. It supports GRBL out of the box, which is slick, and it's being pretty actively developed. Definitely worth checking out.

  • @roverdad
    @roverdad Год назад

    I thought about doing this myself but couldn’t find plans that I liked and don’t feel comfortable doing everything from scratch. This looks awesome though. Thanks for sharing!

  • @pguid
    @pguid 6 месяцев назад

    Awesome thanks. The version im building is using a rasberry pi 5 with a 20W Optical Power Laser Cutting Module and Dremmel.

  • @musicmakesmeloose
    @musicmakesmeloose Год назад +2

    Wow, looks amazing and really inspires me to try this out, though I am a bit hesitant regarding the electronics and programming aspects.
    Great project and great video!

  • @Renato_Paganini
    @Renato_Paganini Год назад

    Thanks for sharing your design and the assembling process. I have the same fascination with CNCs and manufacturing in general, that you have. Probably, I will make one in the near future here in Brazil.

  • @rRobertSmith
    @rRobertSmith Год назад

    As a seasoned electrician with extensive experience in wiring control boxes, you should have used cable penetration bushings (such as Part #S2212)
    instead of jacks to reduce the chance of additional failure points and lower costs and labor.
    The inside of the control box could also be organized with strategically placed cable ties to minimize the risk of short circuits.
    Despite the over-drilled appearance of the z-axis mounting plate, this project was well executed and could be packaged and sold as a kit with some modifications.

    • @benmakeseverything
      @benmakeseverything  Год назад

      Thank you, I'll consider those suggestions for any future upgrades or other machines.

  • @Omicron2280
    @Omicron2280 Год назад

    Fantastic work. I love your example pieces. You definitely made a quality machine. You should be very proud of yourself.

  • @daitedve1984
    @daitedve1984 Год назад

    It's really cool video! All interesting (and necessary/important) details are covered, making video practically useful for us, same "non-engineers" 😆 Thank you! My greatest like!
    What I doubt as a real engineer is Y axis: you move a WHOLE CONSTRUCTION on a single rod! (ball screw) It's weight of vertical supports, X axis, Z-mech assembly and a router (more it powerful, more it weights). Obviously you create load on the screw (actually on NUT on this screw). I would make TWO screws on each side of machine, join 'em w belt and put a whole X-Z-construction on a rollers (also frequent solution). Then all load comes on roll wheels and you simply move things with ONE st.motor, which rounds TWO cogs, which are joined to long screws. Hope you got my idea 😆

  • @alexanderokak5112
    @alexanderokak5112 4 месяца назад

    Absolutely incredible. This is incredible.

  • @PiefacePete46
    @PiefacePete46 Год назад

    I went to your channel to check for more "goodies"... this was the only video there. If this is what you offer as your first video, and this CNC router is your first construction offering, then I take my hat off to you! A really useful machine, with a carefully considered component list, and well thought out design. Your video was clear, well explained, and nicely paced. If you haven't "burned yourself out", I really look forward to your future projects!
    My thoughts for a next video:
    ** A quick walk-around of the finished machine, itemising good and bad points.
    ** How does it perform compared to your initial thoughts?
    ** Knowing what you know now, would you do it again?
    ** What you would do differently?
    ** Would you stick with a router, or consider a spindle? (Kevin Barnett on the Carbide 3D channel is pushing spindles as a better option.)
    ** Planned upgrades and add-on's?
    ** What basic design changes will you make on your next one? 😵‍💫
    Also, I am sure there are many viewers that would be interested in a video covering the steps involved in making a simple project, from design to finished item.
    Have I "Liked" and "Subscribed"... OF COURSE I HAVE! 😄 👍
    Thank you.

    • @benmakeseverything
      @benmakeseverything  Год назад +3

      Thanks for the input! Those are good suggestions. This was my first video, but I am definitely going to make more. If I built another machine I would 100% use a spindle (probably water-cooled) instead of a router.

  • @ThePytercoyote
    @ThePytercoyote Год назад

    This is awesome... I want to do the same thing for years!! Great job my friend. Now that I have a lot of time available could be the time to start. But I really need to watch the budget.

  • @roryodonovan3440
    @roryodonovan3440 Год назад

    An absolutely brilliant achievement. Well done !!!