Andrew Roberts | Remarks on Winston Churchill

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 дек 2024

Комментарии • 14

  • @periphron
    @periphron 4 года назад +5

    I love Andrew Roberts, and the opportunity to hear his thoughts and to share his research is always a genuine delight and pleasure.

  • @robertj.5012
    @robertj.5012 4 года назад +2

    Is there anyone more interesting and genuine and thought provoking than Larry Arndt? Hillsdale is exactly the place for a man of his caliber.

  • @monocles.IcedPeaksOfFire
    @monocles.IcedPeaksOfFire 5 месяцев назад

    Just a champagne performance,
    a real pleasure

  • @melvincunningham5660
    @melvincunningham5660 4 года назад

    Happy Birthday!

  • @NorwayT
    @NorwayT 3 года назад

    ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

  • @lynnettespolitics9656
    @lynnettespolitics9656 5 лет назад +1

    Gracious, that comment to Von Ribbentrop about Italy HAD to have come from Churchill!

  • @carnivaltym
    @carnivaltym 3 месяца назад

    He misses the drinking. It worked with Stalin.

  • @willhovell9019
    @willhovell9019 Год назад +1

    Stick to Napoleon Roberts. Valueless 'insights' into Churchill. Not as bad as the Johnson biography. George VI preferred Atlee

  • @aon10003
    @aon10003 5 лет назад

    According to rumors. He was present on the MI6 dinner party whos official purpose was to introduce Trumps Manager Mike Flynn but whos real purpose was to set a honeytrap. That is what i want to hear about.

    • @voraciousreader3341
      @voraciousreader3341 Год назад +1

      How many books have you read? Or do you expect people to do that for you? I’ll be nice and give you a few facts, which you could have found yourself in about 20 seconds on the internet: Churchill died when Trump was 20 years old, and he had been suffering from senility for several years beforehand. So are you saying that Trump had a manager from the age of 15 or so?? And there is no way I will believe that the person you named could ever have been invited to such a dinner, unless he was a busboy, or something. See how silly you can appear when you don’t do your own fact checking?? It’s so easy now, too, so there’s absolutely no excuse for making such ridiculous mistakes.

  • @nmiipsych5238
    @nmiipsych5238 Год назад

    Stephen Fry has bipolar disorder and is brilliant.. As debilitating as the illness is, I wouldn't rule out the possibility that Churchill did meet the diagnostic criteria for the milder type of BD (type II)
    As for him leading meetings until very late, one of the characteristics of BD is a significant reduction in need for sleep and an increase in energy, so this is hardly a counter argument

    • @voraciousreader3341
      @voraciousreader3341 Год назад +1

      May I ask, are you a psychologist or psychiatrist?? No, I didn’t think so, because I happen to _be_ a psychologist who has also read at least 12 biographies of Churchill and several more about his parents, but even if I’d never read any, I know that doing historical psychological diagnoses is simply never done by reputable clinicians, unless there is a mountain of information available. Such is not the case for Churchill. The most important information-that derived from a personal evaluation, where the professional collects a great deal of information directly from the subject-cannot be obtained. If people believe that they can make *ANY PSYCHOLOGICAL DIAGNOSES* using a few documentaries, or even that and a few history books, *then I would bloody well love to know why all of us can spend up to 10 YEARS* working to obtain a clinical psychology PhDs, longer for psychiatrists, not to mention passing tests to obtain the necessary licenses. Please do us all a favor and stop making absolutely unfounded statements about bipolar disorder or any DSM 5 disorder for _anyone,_ because you most assuredly lack the credentials to do so.